Тёмный

Canadian Army in Normandy Campaign 

Grant Cree
Подписаться 897
Просмотров 78 тыс.
50% 1

What happened after D-Day? Guest speaker Thomas Bradley showcases Canadian Army participation during the Normandy Campaign in France, June 1944. His presentation includes dozens of soldiers’ stories, vivid maps, and rare photos that seem to leap off the screen at you.
Mr. Bradley opens his talk with historical accounts of Canadians fighting SS troops on June 7, 1944 and concludes with the war crimes trial of Nazi SS General Kurt Meyer. This presentation took place on April 22, 2017 at the Brigadier Jefferson Armoury in Edmonton, Alberta.
This presentation was to a non-profit group for educational purposes only. There is no expectation of commercial remuneration as a result of this video appearing on various social media sites. © 2017 Grant Cree Event Media

Опубликовано:

 

12 июл 2024

Поделиться:

Ссылка:

Скачать:

Готовим ссылку...

Добавить в:

Мой плейлист
Посмотреть позже
Комментарии : 210   
@robertneven7563
@robertneven7563 3 года назад
thanks to the good brave Canadians thye liberate my home town in Belguim in september 1944, this what my grandparent told me
@wezzagustus4868
@wezzagustus4868 3 года назад
This man clearly knows what he is talking about and is doing a great service to Canada
@joanfox6530
@joanfox6530 2 года назад
Excellent! Thankyou. My Grandfather Pownall volunteered 1939-44. Left my mom was 5. Came home she was 10. This is his route. 2cnd Field Company Royal Canadian Engineers. Always wondered what he did for that long. Had he got to Holland for liberation.He said could not stand to see people starving. Would give away their rations. Or they would build bridges just too blow them up again. Landed on Juno Beach. One of the very few to come home. Went in A1 shape in Mid 30s. Came home D8. Had PTSD for sure. Hard of hearing. Lived to 90. Best man ever ,my mentor, missed deaply George Pownall. Was so blessed to have had him in my life.
@rikmoyle3610
@rikmoyle3610 6 лет назад
Normandy was my Father's battle, 12th ss was usually in front of them...When Caen was plastered, he was on the point in a slit-trench; said many bombs came awfully close and didn't think anything could have survived...
@tommaynard8509
@tommaynard8509 5 лет назад
Outstanding ... My father fought with the Canadians in the guards armour division driving a tank and nothing but the highest regard for your bravery. First rate explanation, well presented and excellent detail. More please. Ten out of ten.
@cody_d3628
@cody_d3628 4 года назад
We thank him for his bravery and service
@guywerry6614
@guywerry6614 3 года назад
I had a buddy whose father drove a tank in Normandy. On one occasion he had to (ordered to) drag the dead body of his best buddy out of the driver's seat of his tank and then get in and drive that tank. We have NO freaking idea of the sacrifices.
@websterlee7708
@websterlee7708 2 года назад
My father too.👍
@MegaBloggs1
@MegaBloggs1 Год назад
Guards armoured division was british 2nd army-the two canadian armoured divisions were the 4th and 5th
@rorythomson149
@rorythomson149 Год назад
@@MegaBloggs1 Late reply but Guards Armoured Division was attached to the 1st Canadian Army as part of XXX British Corps in January to March 1945 and had fought along with them in Normandy. Lots of British and other countries soldiers served with the Canadian Army.
@nigeh5326
@nigeh5326 6 лет назад
Thanks for posting very interesting. Thanks to all Canadians who served and gave invaluable added strength in the fight against evil. Both on land, in the air and at sea 🇬🇧✌️
@Jimatuscc
@Jimatuscc 4 года назад
Bravo!
@michellejean11
@michellejean11 3 года назад
What you say is true but part of the problem was Monty's hubris and overestimation of what his troops could do. In each of the three main battles Montgomery expected victory, not factoring in German resistance and the material they had committed to Caan. Monty may also have made the same mistake the British made in WW I thinking artillery and the addition of mass bombings would break the Germans. I'm not Canadian and am impartial. But it seems the Canadian divisions did take the lions share of the fighting.
@joepalooka2145
@joepalooka2145 3 года назад
Great video, always interested as a Canadian to know more. When I was a kid back in the '60s, I had a friend whose Dad was a Canadian veteran of Normandy. He committed suicide when my friend was about 10 years old. It was extremely traumatic and my first experience with such a terrible tragedy. I have this memory of him as a very dark and brooding man. Little did I know this was called "PTSD" which they didn't treat in those days because "Real men" were expected to suck it up and not complain. Later on in my life, I learned how this guy had told stories of killing German prisoners after DDAy and experiencing heavy combat. Now I know he was a hero, but it's just so sad that he had to leave his wife and children by his own hand.
@Veritas975
@Veritas975 3 года назад
Thanks for watching and sharing the story of the veteran.
@peterlyons8793
@peterlyons8793 2 года назад
Can you can add any more information to your story? Just fascinating.
@treadheadpete4770
@treadheadpete4770 2 года назад
Thank you Grant for posting this video of Mr.Bradley's presentation, it was absolutely riveting!
@chelamcguire
@chelamcguire 4 года назад
The Canadian army earned so much respect from the Scots. They were a tremendously brave bunch of disciplined young lads. My late grand father kept up with two Canadians up until his passing in 1982. So many young souls never came home. Tonight I will remember them in my prayers. This presentation has been eye opening. Very informative. Thank you.
@Veritas975
@Veritas975 4 года назад
Chela McGuire - Thanks for your comment, it’s great to see the sacrifices of our soldiers continue to be honoured.
@twilly4655
@twilly4655 3 года назад
My uncle came home with a Scottish wife
@chelamcguire
@chelamcguire 3 года назад
@@twilly4655 Oh dear.....us Scot's can be a bit of a handle!
@twilly4655
@twilly4655 3 года назад
@@chelamcguire My aunt Elizabeth came to Canada during the war to a french Canadian family where she lived had 5 kids and passed away in her mid 80's
@chelamcguire
@chelamcguire 3 года назад
@@twilly4655 Bless her wee heart.. Scotland is so tiny, Canada must have truly taken her breath away. I recall visiting Texas years ago and absorbing my 'new found info.' that the UK could easily fit TWICE into Texas! Made me feel small. So, Aunt Elizabeth had a lot to learn including learning French as a second language, no doubt. And raising 5 children at the tail end of the war.......gosh, not too easy! I was one of 5 children and it was a case of, 'first up, best dressed' !!! Enjoy the rest of your day. x
@glen6945
@glen6945 4 года назад
thks dad for making it back to-canada
@vincentzack
@vincentzack 2 года назад
My Great Uncle served. He survived the Dieppe Raid as a member of the RHLI. He made it as far as Operation Spring. The only Unit to complete their objective during Operation Spring. I believe he was injured and getting help to move back for medical help stepped on a land mine July 26, 1944. Gerald Thomas Belleau from Garden River First Nation. RIP my Great Uncle. I found his place of rest "Bretteville-Sur-Laize Canadian War Cemetery" July 26, 1944.
@kartwood
@kartwood 6 лет назад
Thank you for this. My Father landed at Juno, late morning of the 6th (or so I recall) S, D. & G.Highlanders. Many stories.
@richardgreville6855
@richardgreville6855 2 года назад
My Dad, was in theSD&G, they have a marvelous museum in Cornwall, ON. In the armory. Call first and ask for Leon Chameau, the creator.
@SomeTechGuy666
@SomeTechGuy666 3 года назад
I knew Walter Wehage who served in the Royal Winnipeg Rifles. He was injured on July 7th capturing Carpiquet airport. He returned to service later in the fall to fight again in Holland and ultimately survived the war. His group was knicknamed the Dirty Red Devils. There is a book about their exploits. Walter didn't talk much about the war, but every now and then he would want to talk. He didn't give many details, he mainly spoke in generalities. He was, however, very angry when he spoke of the atrocity at Ardenne Abbey. He was very proud that his group got the furthest inland on D Day. These were incredibly brave men. Excellent presentation. Thank you for sharing it.
@nicflatterie7772
@nicflatterie7772 5 лет назад
Great presentation, good information, I have the deepest respect for that generation of Canadians, which I am proud to be a descendant of. Only shadow for me was when he mentioned that Meyer was made an honorary member of the PPCLI mess. I would have walked out of the mess in protest. There are limits to what I tolerate and pardon and that is over my limit. He did not fight with honour, did not properly respected the POWs. Had I been a PPCLI officer, I would have asked for a transfer, or turned my commission in. Unacceptable. IMHO obviously.
@peterlyons8793
@peterlyons8793 3 года назад
What's a PPCLI mess mean?
@BarnDoorProductions
@BarnDoorProductions 2 года назад
@@peterlyons8793 The officer's mess is a sort of social organization of the officers of a regiment. PPCLI is the Princess Patricia's Canadian Light Infantry. The Princess Pat's are one of the most honoured regiments in Canada.
@justjoking5841
@justjoking5841 2 года назад
princess pat's screaming pussies. lol
@terrynolan5831
@terrynolan5831 6 лет назад
Its very simple Canadian losses were high because they were in the thick of it , and a heroic bunch of guys , their leaders were good the asks almost impossible...bless them !!
@mhodgson4574
@mhodgson4574 6 лет назад
this an excellent account of our soldiers, thank you thomas bradley for setting the record straight. its frustrating that our contribution to WW2 is so often under-stated.
@Veritas975
@Veritas975 6 лет назад
Maxine Hodgson Thanks Maxine, I have forwarded your comment to Mr. Bradley.
@dulls8475
@dulls8475 2 года назад
By who?
@robertroy1435
@robertroy1435 3 года назад
What can I say but this is one reason I am so proud to be Canadian
@susanhampson446
@susanhampson446 3 года назад
My Father fought for Canada in Holland on the Scheldt Estuary where the retreating Germans blew up the Dams and flooded the Countryside. The Dutch were starved and the advancing Canadian Army shared food while defeating the Germans. The Dutch Princess was protected in Canada and every year Holland sends 100,000 🌷 Tulips in thanks to the Canadian Liberators.
@BrodyNelson
@BrodyNelson 2 года назад
cool, canada were the bad guys though
@MoosefromCanada
@MoosefromCanada Год назад
@@BrodyNelson 🤣🤣ok clown
@jerradtough5113
@jerradtough5113 6 лет назад
Very well done! I recommend Terry Copps book Fields of Fire the Canadian Army in Normandy.
@roymcewen8203
@roymcewen8203 Год назад
Thank You For Your Thorough Overview of the Important Contribution of the Canadian Army during the Normandy Campaign in WW II 🇨🇦🇨🇦🇨🇦 👍🏻👍🏻👍🏻
@ErynQuentery
@ErynQuentery 3 года назад
My Grandfather, Cpt. Robert Bayly Rowed (Medical Officer) was with the Canadians on D-DAY, through Caen and the rest of the war, without a day off. During one of the 18 major battles he was involved in he had to amputate limbs of over 100 men to save lives in their makeshift field hospital. He and my grandmother were family physicians in Oliver BC until he passed away in 1988. They in the UK during the war; she was from Edinburgh.
@theguy6873
@theguy6873 4 года назад
I was quite intrigued by this video to start. I am born Canadian thank you to my grandparents and Mom and Dad I am Canadian born and there is a reason Polish and Dutch made me. Any Canadian would never think the Canadians fought poorly. I’m alive today because of them.
@Veritas975
@Veritas975 4 года назад
Greg S - Thanks your kind comments, we’re very fortunate to be Canadians! Cheers, Grant
@joannehines7954
@joannehines7954 5 лет назад
the Canadians done fantastic,god bless Canada amen! my mum and dad were in wwii,mum a war worker,dad in british forces with AEC MATADORS.COULDNT PRAISE CANADA HIGHLY ENOUGH! AND QUITE RIGHT TOO.CANADA WE LOVE YOU
@MrD-et9dp
@MrD-et9dp 6 лет назад
Very thorough and well-presented presentation, as a grandson of a trooper who parachuted in with the 1st Canadian Parachute Battalion, a bit more information on the important role they played in the battle of Normandy would have been noteworthy.
@peterharrison2440
@peterharrison2440 3 года назад
My father also landed with the 1st Canadian Parachute, the were attached to the British 6th Airborne. Like you, I would love to see a video on the accomplishments.
@derekbaker3279
@derekbaker3279 3 года назад
@@peterharrison2440 Also, there were Canadians who jumped with the famous U.S. 101st Airborne. Canadians were very much part of the "Band of Brothers".
@stephenmason5773
@stephenmason5773 5 лет назад
This information is so amazing! Well done!!
@lucym5163
@lucym5163 Месяц назад
A fascinating talk. Thank you for sharing. What an immense sacrifice these brave men made for us.
@erickvilland5337
@erickvilland5337 2 года назад
Thanks for this vidéo, We ,the French people, use to say that we where save by the American guy ,in 06/44, we always forgot the young boy from your country who have paid with their life to deliver France from the Nazi . Triple salute from Paris.
@shaneprendergast1889
@shaneprendergast1889 3 года назад
There needs to be a good series like band of brothers made about some Canadian accomplishments in ww2.
@MrLandega
@MrLandega 2 года назад
That's just it though, we Canucks can/will shoulder the burden if we have to, in combat. The fewer people reminded of our tenacity, the more likely we'd be underestimated...sneaky tricks.
@roba4295
@roba4295 4 года назад
Awesome and a pleasure to hear. One thing that the military is very adept at doing is to use a "lessons learned" approach in reflection of past military action. The humble nature of the Canadian, combined with this concentrated approach to learning from experience, can result in a tendency to be hyper-critical in order to take as much advantage of hindsight as possible. Historians are going to focus on these reflections and we are left wondering if too many mistakes were made when, in reality, the opinions do not bear the weight of the facts. All history books are written with the benefit of hindsight and it is common for opinion to seep into some of these writings even when not directly intended. Battle maps containing dispositions of German forces and written accounts of their moment to moment observations when combined with Canadian regimental histories prove the truth of the matter to be self evident. The Canadians will likely never get the credit and recognition that British and American forces have been given for what was, at times, far less extraordinary. A nation fighting under the umbrella of the British commonwealth in WW1 and often seen as the same in WW2, combined with a massive nation on its southern border are further reasons for Canada not receiving due credit. It was simply a case of national and world history creating a juxtaposition between Canadian self identity and the way the rest of the world thought of Canada, if, at all. It is to the credit of the affable and humble nature of the ferocious Canadian warrior that to come home and get on with the peaceful life he fought so hard for, takes precedent over accolades, awards and medals.
@Veritas975
@Veritas975 4 года назад
Rob Ayres Thanks for your thoughtful comments!
@mauricen9688
@mauricen9688 6 лет назад
Meier should have been handed over to the Russians for conducting reprisals against civilians on the eastern front. Ironically Vokes himself ordered a reprisal in April 45. In Italy Vokes earned the nickname "Butcher" for willingness to sacrifice his own troops. This might have something to do with high Canadian casualty rates in Normandy.
@philharvey6589
@philharvey6589 3 года назад
WOW. Watched this documentary Thank You for making the world as it is today
@Waldvogel45
@Waldvogel45 3 месяца назад
I am proud to have started my career in Toronto, to live 15 minutes from a memorial to Canadians in this battle area, to have participated in a ceremony at Putot in the presence of the Governor 20 years ago. Proud , and thankful to be free and still alive, not far from Reviers.
@Mrkaycee7
@Mrkaycee7 6 лет назад
Thank you Thomas Bradley for your outstanding presentation on the Canadian Army and their never say die fierceness. The ultimate compliment comes from your adversary, in this case, leader of the battle hardened SS. It pisses me off that some armchair quarterbacks would question and or criticize the incredible feats of the Normandy campaign by our brilliant overworked troops. They should be ashamed. Thank you for putting their criticisms exactly where they belong, where the sun don’t shine!
@Veritas975
@Veritas975 6 лет назад
Kaycee 777 Hello and thanks for taking the time to comment. Much appreciated. I have forwarded your comments to Mr. Bradley.
@joangratzer2101
@joangratzer2101 2 года назад
ALWAYS OVERWORKED? 26 NATIONS AGAINST GERMANY.
@richardgriffn
@richardgriffn 2 месяца назад
My Dad was there at the Falaise Gap with the SARS South Alberta Regiment his name was Douglas Alexander Griffin. I only wish i could find some pictures of him while he was there.
@kegan51
@kegan51 7 лет назад
excellent presentation.
@jamesfraser4173
@jamesfraser4173 3 года назад
My dad was wounded during the battle for Normandy, having survived the carnage that was Juno Beach. He said he was wounded at th Gap, but, I finally discovered that he was actually wounded at Verrieres Ridge. He was a stretcher bearer with the Rileys.
@milesjohnson8927
@milesjohnson8927 Год назад
Grant old Buddy. Good to c this Miles
@adventure002006
@adventure002006 6 лет назад
Very well presented. Very Educational. Thanks for posting. Sad to hear of executions. SS standard procedure at Russian front from the sound of it. SS were paid back in spades.
@JAG312
@JAG312 5 лет назад
I have seen photographs of the Royal Canadian Commandos. What part did they play in D-Day?
@user-xt9kl1vm3z
@user-xt9kl1vm3z 13 дней назад
?Never heard of them?
@kirbygrant1718
@kirbygrant1718 4 года назад
North Nova Scotia Highlanders fought at Authie and Buron on June 7th, and it was a lot more than two hours. I expect that they would not worry about what the SS thought of their fighting ability. They took a lot of pows which is not indicated in the stats presented and the 25th had a lot killed and wounded. It was a tank battle and an infantry battle as well which ended only when the communication got through to bring naval bombardment down on the position that night. Kurt Meyer was convicted of war crimes ....he knew and approved of what his men were doing as they executed North Novies. There are a lot of silly reactions to this guy and a lot of silly stories. He was thwarted on the 7th and the next 2 days and failed to meet his objective and to live up to his braggadocio....he retaliated. He left his men to fight while he retreated many times as he was pushed back across NW Europe. He was a criminal during the war and likely before it. Nothing to celebrate there. The men of the 9th Brigade,and on the 7th, the men of the 3 companies of NNSH who fought to the end in the orchards and fields against much larger numbers, are the men who should be remembered . A couple hundred of them didn’t get to have that beer.
@emmville
@emmville Год назад
Do you have any content on Canadian merchant marines
@bryanbufton4358
@bryanbufton4358 2 года назад
Thank you to all the Canadian commonwealth and Americans that helped defeat a very evil enemy
@wombatwilly1002
@wombatwilly1002 2 года назад
Excellent production.Juno beach was initially to be called "Jelly" but Winston Churchill had it changed.I read a quote from Uncle Adolf about the Canadian soldiers.."Those damn indians"..!! Rommel was in Germany for his wife's birthday and only Uncle Adolf could order reinforcements to Normandy but he was sleeping on June 6th to at least noon.
@user-qs7gx7rp7m
@user-qs7gx7rp7m 7 месяцев назад
Good to hear. My uncle was with the same engineers
@wezzagustus4868
@wezzagustus4868 3 года назад
Absolute brilliance of the highest order. Canadian war rememberance history presented in accurate and unbias detail with a stroke of statistical genius. I'm sick of the over dramatized, hollywood propaganda I been fed my whole life finally my own country men laying the precious foundations of sacrifice at Juno and forward on
@kimberlymulhall2757
@kimberlymulhall2757 5 лет назад
I’ve had it pointed out to me that because of the disastrous dieppe raid, the Canadians rehearsed the beach assault too much (which was very successful ) and the breakout not enough.
@kimberlymulhall2757
@kimberlymulhall2757 5 лет назад
Well done on your project
@legacyproject2421
@legacyproject2421 5 лет назад
Great Presentation! Grant, tell me how do I find Thomas Bradley to invite him to do a presentation at our event?
@Veritas975
@Veritas975 5 лет назад
Legacy Project Hello and thanks for your note. Kindly provide your contact info and I’ll be happy to forward it to Mr. Bradley for his consideration. Regards, Grant
@legacyproject2421
@legacyproject2421 5 лет назад
lbrand@ingeniumcanada.org Thanks Grant!
@Veritas975
@Veritas975 5 лет назад
Legacy Project - Ok, I’ve forwarded your e-address to him. Cheers!
@legacyproject2421
@legacyproject2421 5 лет назад
@@Veritas975 Can you please give him my official email lbrand@ingeniumcanada.org Thanks!
@Veritas975
@Veritas975 5 лет назад
Legacy Project Yes, I forwarded your e-address to Mr. Bradley last week.
@nickdanger3802
@nickdanger3802 4 года назад
7.20 "Nearly 150,000 Allied troops landed or parachuted into the invasion area on D-Day, including 14,000 Canadians at Juno Beach. Total Allied casualties on D-Day reached more than 10,000, including 1,074 Canadians, of whom 359 were killed. By the end of the Battle of Normandy, the Allies had suffered 209,000 casualties, including more than 18,700 Canadians. Over 5,000 Canadian soldiers died." D-Day and the Battle of Normandy www.thecanadianencyclopedia.ca/en/article/normandy-invasion
@canadianbakin1304
@canadianbakin1304 Год назад
so there was something that was called the CanLease program where Canadian jr officers went to lead in British regiments so we did have an experience problem in our jr officer corp but our troops seemed to adapt and overcome it rather quickly
@kerrydennison7947
@kerrydennison7947 6 месяцев назад
Historically speaking the Canadian army performed much better when they were under direct Canadian leadership and Canadian military planning. Just look at the record of Canadian general G Simmons, many times general Montgomery called upon him to formulate a plan to break a dead lock. Especially the battle of leading up to the Rhine River crossing. Sadly general Montgomery use the Canadians and any Commonwealth soldiers as shock troops mainly because he did not have to account for Commonwealth deaths to the English government. Same as with the Australian troops in the Southwest Pacific there is absolutely no reason the Australians could not have fought independently under their own leadership, you have to remember the Australian government had the guts to pull their 7th division out from under Montgomery's command and bring them back to Australia. And the ultimate kick in the teeth for the Canadian soldiers were that general Montgomery made sure that Canada did not get an area of occupation in Germany. It is ironic that the Canadian people and military contributed so much and got so little out of the war, the country of France who had a marginal contribution militarily wound up getting their own area of occupation. Are firmly believe Canada would have performed very well under direct Canadian leadership and planning,.
@nickdanger3802
@nickdanger3802 4 года назад
16.00 Imperial War Museum: "In February 1944 the USAAF launched Operation ‘Argument’, or as it became known, ‘Big Week’. This was a series of systematic attacks on aircraft assembly plants. The factories proved more resilient than expected and production was only partially affected, but results in the air were better. The Luftwaffe, already pulled back from France and other fronts to defend Reich airspace, was now being decimated by free-ranging US fighters." www.iwm.org.uk/history/d-day-and-the-aerial-battle-for-normandy
@nickdanger3802
@nickdanger3802 4 года назад
4.20 Canada didn't have the luxury of being able to pull a division out of the line because no Canadians were required to serve overseas unless they volunteered until November 1944 and only a few thousand were in Europe before the war ended. Newfoundland was not part of Canada at that time and was considered "overseas" service. Conscription in Canada www.thecanadianencyclopedia.ca/en/article/conscription
@agalant13
@agalant13 4 года назад
I'm curious to know, how many were in the 12th SS on D-Day+1?
@Veritas975
@Veritas975 4 года назад
Alexander Galant Thanks for watching my video! According to Military Wikipedia and other online sources, the 12th SS division had approximately 16,000 to 20,000 troops by June 1944.
@agalant13
@agalant13 4 года назад
@@Veritas975 Thanks for the response. I've been doing some research to what happened at the Abby and have had trouble finding numbers on the enemy side. Even how many were directly under Kurt Meyer.
@deadhourgaming
@deadhourgaming 5 лет назад
Very good video, but doesn't really mention anything about the North Nova Scotia Highlanders except the images on the video. 12 of the pow's were NNS Highlanders and 6 were sherbrooke fuiliers that were executed in the gardens at the Ardenne abby.
@jordankashuba3467
@jordankashuba3467 2 года назад
This dude for Prime Minister
@richardheath7346
@richardheath7346 3 года назад
For those commenting please research 245 Battery Royal Artillery, A and B troop anti tank, M10 tank destroyers with 17 pounder's!!
@yeneracay2368
@yeneracay2368 10 месяцев назад
Canadian Newfoundland 1915 Gallipoli war campaign 19 september suvla bay extraction they withdrew peninsula coribou hill 🇨🇦
@Sid-gu5qk
@Sid-gu5qk Месяц назад
My grandfather and my great-uncle were two of the many native Canadian volunteers. They were overseas for five years but I have no idea what battles they were involved with or what divisions they were part of etc. All I know is they did their duty and did kill Nazis.
@keving9777
@keving9777 4 года назад
thank you sir well done. I knew about the war crimes but I did not know about him becoming a member of the ppcli mess. how the hell did that happen please tell me they didn't know about his history
@majmikecalnan
@majmikecalnan 3 года назад
The cover photo is Lt Garth Web of the RCA.
@Jimatuscc
@Jimatuscc 4 года назад
I'll bet those German Staff cars really enjoyed seeing those Canadian Tanks running up their lines.
@OldWolflad
@OldWolflad Месяц назад
God bless the Canadians............excellent troops undoubtedly - but I would say a few things here that need some sort of balance as inadvertently it gives a false impression of the British at Normandy He fails to mention: - 1) The Canadians at Normandy were probably expected to make quicker progress as they had less German strongpoints to overcome - the speaker is incorrect in saying Juno was the 2nd most defended after Omaha. British Gold sector had 28 German strongpoints, British Sword sector had 27 German strongpoints including 2 'Stutzpunkten' which were a sort of extra-strong defensive position including 'Strongpoint Hillman', the Canadian sector had just 7 strongpoints. Hillman strongpoint included steel cupola defensive lids, mines and extensive wire, and at least 10 machine gun posts, and it was finally taken after a ferocious battle by the 1st Suffolks by 8.30pm. They were faced by the bulk of 21st SS Panzer Division yet they moved on to Levisey Wood by midnight, some 5-6 miles inland, almost level with the Canadians. 2) No credit is given to British at Juno - their were 14,000 Canadians, and 7,000 British including 48 Commando who cleared the German defences immediately behind Juno Beach which made progress in this sector easier. 3) The Canadians had twice as much field artillery (anti-tank artillery) than the divisions in the adjoining British sectors, and were the largest division overall that landed, comprising 144 artillery guns and howitzers plus their own divisional artillery. 4) The attack by the 12th SS Panzer Division Hitlerjugend (Hitler Youth) was supposed to have been supported by the elite 21st Panzer Division but they could not disengage from fighting the British 3rd Infantry Division and were still at Couvre, as a result the right flank was open and being probed by Canadian tanks. Some Canadians came across little opposition on D-Day after the battle at the beach, and were able to move inland with the bulk of the Canadian force by-passing Buron and moved on Authie. So the greatest distance inland claim is a bit deceptive, only 3 tanks reached Carpiquet Airfield after little opposition and had to retreat to stay with the remainder of the division. 5) The only division to achieve all their objectives on D-Day were in fact British 6th Airborne Division, though it seemed likely the Canadians would have if not ordered by Dempsey to stay in line with the other sectors. 6) There was a huge discrepancy in pay between British troops and American /Canadian troops who received almost twice as much as their British counterparts. Although this arguably would not affect performance, it was a cause of great bitterness amongst British troops, unable to buy local goods when French shop-owners realised American or Canadian troops were in the area. Other than that the Brits and Canadians got on very well, but it did create envy and a sense of being under-valued. 7) The speaker is incorrect when he states that Juno saw the 2nd highest Allied casualties after Omaha, though he would have been making that incorrect statement based on information previously available. Unfortunately the British failed to keep official death rates on D-Day, and only recently via grave count has this been clarified. In the first 24 hours following the invasion the Americans had 6,603 casualties at Omaha and Utah, the British 2,700 at Sword and Gold, and the Canadians 946 at Juno. Importantly, in terms of deaths, the latest 2024 estimates of deaths by the Commonwealth War Crimes Commission have recently revised death totals on D-Day (6th June) itself based on grave counts - 2,501 deaths in the US sector (nearly all Omaha,) 1,760 deaths on the two British beaches (mostly Sword around 1,400), and 370 deaths on Juno. The count on British beaches had previously been massively under-estimated. The Canadians suffered 18,444 casualties, the British 63,865, and the Americans 124,394 casualties. The fighting had been as bitter as anything experienced in WW1, with 2,354 casualties a day to the Allies. By the end of August 1944, all British infantry divisions had lost 75% of their initial fighting strength. But in fact Omaha and then Sword were by some way the most bloody sectors, then Juno and Gild similar, followed by relatively blood-free Utah. So simply trying to give some balance because each sector had its unique issues.
@davidsabillon5182
@davidsabillon5182 3 года назад
Like commented and subscribed 👍
@wocookie2277
@wocookie2277 6 месяцев назад
So Canadian. He ends up drinking moose milk with those little fish during the New Years levy. Excellent video, as a veteran I agree, Canadians do not appreciate our service.
@williamwells1862
@williamwells1862 Год назад
USS Barnett APA-5 DEPLOYMENTS - MAJOR EVENTS BARNETT Add a APA-5 Shellback Initiation Add a APA-5 Deployment - Major Event Month Year to Month Year Deployment / Event SEP 1940 - Commissioned: 25 SEP 1940 APR 1942 - Shellback Initiation - 23 APR 1942 - Atlantic Ocean APR 1944 - AUG 1944 Mediterranean JUN 1944 - Shellback Initiation - 6 JUN 1944 - Pacific Ocean APR 1946 - Decommissioned: 30 APR 1946 APA-5 GENERAL SPECIFICATIONS Class: McCawley-class attack transport Complement: 491 Officers and Enlisted Displacement: 9600 tons Length: 486 feet 6 inches First ship to land delivered General Teddy Roosevelt who commanded the landings when the troops reached the beaches with no concern for his safety. My Uncle Don Wells was an Ensign on the USS Barnett. He talked about dropping General Roosevelt off. They took on wounded. He never talked about the gore only saying it was "Hell." He turned 100 Saturday. He went around to schools as part of a Kiwanis program around Alexandria, Va. with veterans to discuss WWII with them. He went to Sicily after that for a landing, and then on to the Pacific never talking about it.
@tumbler9025
@tumbler9025 5 лет назад
Nice vid man good job , what bugs me is not just Canadians not knowing what our troops went through it's the rest of the world most think we had it easy that is soooo not true in truth Canadian troops had the hardest battles through out the war, I've seen vids where ppl would say Canada too too long to reach there objective during the Fa-lease pocket but what ppl don't understand is that they had to fight the 12ss which was at the time the Germans elite of the elite not an easy nut to crack and that's just 1 battle , and in most cases were out gunned and out numbered with no reserves .
@ColonialHistory
@ColonialHistory 5 лет назад
Spot on....While the Hitler Jugend were largely 'green' battle wise they had been trained since the age of 12 in all aspects of war and were the fittest. They had been trained not only to obey commands without question but also to take the initiative when needed. For that reason their officers were the most experienced. Hitler provided them with the best equipment and materials to prove his point that the Hitler Youth would be the elite of the elite in any battle since they were HIS young warriors. He also created a bunch of monsters without any empathy or mercy. My late father told me about their arrogant attitude even after capture. In Normandy they suffered 80% losses but went on to be a leading force in the Battle of the Ardenne (Battle of the Bulge)
@derekbaker3279
@derekbaker3279 5 лет назад
@@ColonialHistory Indeed. They were well-trained, well-equipped, cocky, and well-rested troops who had been brainwashed completely. Furthermore, they were led by very experienced & successful leadership, with Meyer at the top. Meyer had distinguished himself on the Eastern Front as a fearless & determined tactician in both offensive & defensive warfare, so the Canadians encountered a formidable foe, in terrain that favoured the Germans. I am sure that Meyer's time on the Eastern Front galvanized his psychopathic attitude, plus knowing that he was commanding a bunch of eager brainwashed soldiers who were not yet tired of fighting would have made it a lot easier to order all those executions. He knew that he would not get any arguments from his junior officers who were likely anxious to give their soldiers an opportunity to kill the enemy. IMHO, the fact that Meyer was released from prison after so little time served is appalling & insulting to the families of the 102 young men exectuted between June 7th & June 17, 1944. I can't help but wonder if that is why he was transferred to a British prison before being released...if he had been released from prison in New Brunswick & the local press & public had found out ahead of time, the local residents could have created an ugly scene to say the least! Well, given that soon after the war ended, the Allies hired German generals like Guderian, von Manstein, and Halder (*) to advise them re: creating a defense strategy for western Europe (in case the Soviets decided to attack), I guess the b.s. with Meyer shouldn't have been a surprise. (*) In fact, Halder, who was very much at the centre of the militarization of Germany & closely involved in facilitating the Nazi agenda (e.g. including drawing up the official plans for Barbarrossa), ended up having a lengthy career working for the Americans. In fact, near the end of Halder's second career, the Americans even presented Halder with some prestigious American medals for his service to the U.S.A.!
@michellearmstrong7903
@michellearmstrong7903 3 года назад
@@derekbaker3279 the French Canadians would have given him a medal
@johnheigis83
@johnheigis83 Год назад
Thank you, Canada. For guarding freedom, on my N flank. Hoping I - for one - can hold, just a little S of you.
@TheRealBatCave
@TheRealBatCave 2 года назад
Didn't the British have an officer exchange program where they took many officers and put them in British units, my grandfather said ther Germans would say if ther was an army with German officers and Canadian troops they would b almost unstoppable
@OTDMilitaryHistory
@OTDMilitaryHistory Год назад
Yes there was. It was called the Canloan program.
@michaeldenesyk3195
@michaeldenesyk3195 4 года назад
Attacking a BRIDGE is a Bridgehead. Attacking a BEACH is a Beachhead.
@malbrandow7382
@malbrandow7382 2 года назад
Kurt Muir, murdered so many, then cowarded out when he knew he was gonna lose. Then turning him into some type of a Hero!? Good thing he didn't me me if I captured him, justice would have been served in a flash!!! Many of my Uncles fought there, I'm so proud of them.
@whispjohn
@whispjohn 4 года назад
Mongomery kept the Canadiuans and British divisionss in the East flank because that is where the bulk of the German armour were saituated. He knew the Americans would not be as good at fighting those heavy divisions so he got them on the other end of the battle. The Canadians artillery were very good and so were the troops, tough as old boots too. I read an account of the Canadian artillery and tank men, they had a hard fight to get Caen and won it. Casualties in Normandy for all armies was compared to WW1 figures, frightening to the generals of the British because we had no more men to take up the slack. Normandy was a killing ground.
@CLEO99087
@CLEO99087 3 года назад
omg what a stupid fudging moron you are,
@CLEO99087
@CLEO99087 3 года назад
There is good reason why Americans ran the Allied forces. The Canadians had no leadership capabilities what so ever, The British were afraid to do anything without American support.
@derekbaker3279
@derekbaker3279 3 года назад
​@@CLEO99087 Leadership? British afraid to do anything? A tiny little reminder.. it took the U.S. more than two years before it got off its fat arse & joined the fight against Hitler....and that only happened because Hitler was stupid enough to declare war on the U.S.. If Hitler hadn't declared war on the U.S., we'd still be waiting for the U.S. to join the fight! And, who took on the Germans on land, in the air, and on the seas for those 2+ years? The Brits, Canadians, Aussies, Kiwis, South Africans, Indians, Polish pilots, the French/Dutch/Belgian Resistance, and the Soviets. Who was afraid to take military action from the Sept 1939 until the end of 1941? The U.S.A. !
@terrysmith9362
@terrysmith9362 2 года назад
I am afraid the moron is you with your Hollywood fiction
@terrysmith9362
@terrysmith9362 2 года назад
Thats for the clown BMG
@batshit_for_ACME
@batshit_for_ACME 4 года назад
In their first real engagements in Normandy, Canadians took on the 12th SS and effectively destroyed two regiments that were supported by armor. They took Carpiquet, Caen and eventually took out Wittmann and his SS panzer bros. It sounds like they did pretty well, so the myth of Canadian inferiority is perplexing. They get extra thumbs up for killing some fucking Nazis.
@bruckermusic
@bruckermusic 2 года назад
Canada would have never defeaded the Germans if they had to fight against them allone without the other alies.Canada has always been inferior to Germany. You do not even have own tanks.You have the German Leopard 2 tank.In first and second world war Canada fought as s part of the British Army with American and British eqipment.You did not even have own steal helmets.If it came to a war only between Canada and Germany ,Germany would steamroll Canada within a few days.
@bruckermusic
@bruckermusic 2 года назад
And as a country Canada hasn t much to offer.You don t produce Cars or other machines like Germany does.Actually you do not even have an on Country.You live in a land that ist not yours
@batshit_for_ACME
@batshit_for_ACME 2 года назад
@@bruckermusic I'm not Canadian, you Wehrboo fluffer.
@glacialmobbs7657
@glacialmobbs7657 2 года назад
@@bruckermusic , actually we had our own military and command. We also produced lots of weapons including tanks, aircraft , small arms and artillery. We also had the third largest navy with Canadian produced ships. Canada also fed Britain with our agricultural products. Not bad for a country with a population of eight million. We also accepted many German immigrants before and after the war. No hard feelings but your country did not have the natural resources to win.
@bruckermusic
@bruckermusic 2 года назад
That might be true but If it came to a war between only Germany and Canada,Germany would defeat Canada
@ElricWilliam
@ElricWilliam 4 года назад
We didnt hold the beach we broke it, are you daft. We gained the most ground that day
@michaeltagg492
@michaeltagg492 7 месяцев назад
Canadian army have proved time and time again the best allied soldiers in WW1 and WW2. Ask the Germans.
@michellepeoplelikeyoumurde8373
@michellepeoplelikeyoumurde8373 3 месяца назад
Canadians never mention the hostility of french canadians to participate
@normlor
@normlor Год назад
FROM WHAT I SAW THOSE BOMBINGS, AND SHELLINGS JUST BEFORE THE LANDINGS DID VERY LITTLE TO DESTROY GERMAN POSITIONS. I'M JUST WONDERING IF JUST BEFORE THOSE LANDINGS TONS OF SMOKE BOMBS WERE DROPPED TO MASK ALL TROOPS ON THOSE MANY BEACHES. FROM WHAT I SAW IN FILMS OF THOSE LANDINGS OUR TROOPS WERE AS EASILY SEEN AND PERFECT TARGETS. DID THIS NEVER OCCUR TO EISENHOWER??
@Veritas975
@Veritas975 Год назад
Thanks for watching the video and posting your comment. Although smoke bombs would have certainly masked Allied troops on the beaches, it’s worthwhile to remember the Germans already had locked in and repeatedly rehearsed 8-figure grid references for their 88mm cannons. That said, I’m sure smoke bombs would have saved the lives of Allied soldiers.
@normlor
@normlor Год назад
@@Veritas975 THANKS GRANT, I'M JUST AN IGNORANT RETIRED MUSICIAN WHO HAS HAD IDEAS TO IMPROVE OUR PLANET ALL OF MY LIFE. IT'S JUST A THEORY OF MINE THINKING AS I WATCHED CANADIANS STORM THOSE BEACHES AND GET KILLED AS THEY WERE PERFECT TARGETS. IF SMOKE HID THEM FROM SIGHT, THEY COULD NOT BE SEEN.
@bruckermusic
@bruckermusic 2 года назад
I am German and I hate war. The Canadians fought bravely but we also have to mention that would have never had chance to beat the Germans if they had to fight against the Germans without the British and Americans .
@BarnDoorProductions
@BarnDoorProductions 2 года назад
That's the point of having Allies. Canada was a very small nation at that time, but stepped forward to become a major part of the Allied effort to defeat fascism.
@bruckermusic
@bruckermusic 2 года назад
That mightt be true but Canada cant keep up with Germany when it comes to military power.
@bruckermusic
@bruckermusic 2 года назад
And the Germans had already lost a lot of their material and soldiers on the east front and had to fight on so many fronts.We had the best soldiers in the world .
@bruckermusic
@bruckermusic 9 месяцев назад
No I don t feel better .I only wrote this because this report shows only one site. Of course it was a crime what the Nazis did but we shouldn t forget ist that many Germans had no choice to avoid the war. They had to go to war. I didn t want to say something Bad against the alies. But look at your condinent what happend there. You took away the native peoples land Actually you live on soil that belongs to the native people . And what about slavery in North America for hundret of years? It s all a crime. Not only what the Germans did in second world war .
@joececcacci4879
@joececcacci4879 Год назад
If only the rest of the world was like Canda.
@alastairbarkley6572
@alastairbarkley6572 2 года назад
FLAG FAIL!!! In June 1944 fought under the Union Flag of the United Kingdom (of GB and NI). On August 1st 1944, Canadian forces adopted the RED ENSIGN of Canada and later the Blue Ensign. The Maple Leaf flag was not adopted until 1965.🇬🇧 Similar too but not identical with 🇫🇯
@evangiles17
@evangiles17 3 года назад
The brits and yanks have never given any credit to the allied unit's that fought beside them - The Germans how said that the sides they feared the most were Australians , Nepalese and the Canadians because they would actually fight them
@YorkyOne
@YorkyOne 3 года назад
I don't know about the Americans but the British have always held their Commonwealth allies in the highest regard. Your comment is nonsense.
@tomgreaves991
@tomgreaves991 3 года назад
And now you know why the Canadians had a reputation for not taking any SS soldiers prisoner...paid back in spades
@derekbaker3279
@derekbaker3279 3 года назад
Yes, the battle between the Canadians & the 12th SS Hitler Youth division took on a level of hate more in line with what went on during the Axis-Soviet War. In fact, the 'rules of engagement', the Geneva Convention, etc had absolutely no meaning on the Eastern Front, and IMHO Meyer & other experienced German officers in the 12th S.S. probably indoctrinated the inexperienced Hitler Youth soldiers, and created a mindset & atmosphere that made executions & other war crimes inevitable. Meyer certainly had a reputation for war crimes when he was fighting on the Eastern Front, and IMHO he should have rotted in prison until he took his last breath.
@joepalooka2145
@joepalooka2145 3 года назад
I got to the end of the video and I have to take issue with "Canadian justice". Yes, we don't operate like the Nazis did, then or now. But you have left out an important part of the story. After the SS murder of Canadians, many Canadians (and British and Americans as well) got revenge by killing many German prisoners. It was a savage and ruthless fight. It's not a story that Canadians like to remember, but it happened. I can understand why. The SS and the fanatic HItlerjugend was the worst of the worst. Kurt Meyer must have provided valuable intelligence to the Allied command and that's why his sentence was commuted, because he definitely should have been executed for ordering the execution of captured prisoners.
@Veritas975
@Veritas975 3 года назад
Indeed. As the videographer, I was honoured to produce this presentation but have no control over the content. Thanks again for watching, it’s always rewarding to get feedback.
@wezzagustus4868
@wezzagustus4868 3 года назад
Totenkopf was far worse than Hitler Jugend
@derekbaker3279
@derekbaker3279 3 года назад
@@wezzagustus4868 Did the Totenkopf division ever fight on the Western Front (not counting 1939/1940)? The reason I ask is because the Axis-Soviet War was not just a military conflict, it was a race war where one side had genocidal goals & both sides were literally fighting for the survival of their race/culture (not just their political boundaries). Consequently, the Eastern Front was a place where 'rules of engagement', the Geneva Convention, etc had absolutely no meaning. So the Totenkopf fought in an environment that was far more hate-filled & brutal, while the Hitler Youth division were involved in 'just' a military conflict. If the situation was reversed, and the 12th S.S. Division spent 4 years fighting the Soviets, they may have developed the same reputation. Just some food for thought....
@wezzagustus4868
@wezzagustus4868 3 года назад
@@derekbaker3279 I have no clue if they did
@jeffreywiseman9026
@jeffreywiseman9026 Год назад
My father was there: He told me that after word of the SS executions of Canadian POW's got around to Canadian forces the unofficial word was, among Canadian personnel, "no prisoners": any members of the SS that were captured alive, wounded or not, were killed on the spot. He told me "The only good SS was a dead SS."
@leaomartinofaria1667
@leaomartinofaria1667 3 года назад
Na verdade os Canadense... pegou o osso mais duro no desembarque da invasão da Normadia... usar capacete igual tijela!
@mikeohagan2206
@mikeohagan2206 3 года назад
kurt meyer got 9 years for the murder of canadian soldiers, that was disgusting. we were too nice. canadian soldiers kick ass forever and always. rip boys, and women of the canadian army that always is the first to come to the aid of the mother country.
@michellearmstrong7903
@michellearmstrong7903 3 года назад
Pity you have armed forces which are inadequate to defend your country properly
@mikeohagan2206
@mikeohagan2206 3 года назад
@@michellearmstrong7903 true but when war starts we always step up in a hurry. we were the first to step up in ww2, besides any war now will be done with big red buttons. size wont matter.
@shirleyquinn7001
@shirleyquinn7001 2 года назад
@@mikeohagan2206 Hi Mike, I find myself in the posts b/c of what the truckers have started. What do you think of the Canadian truckers?
@ElricWilliam
@ElricWilliam 4 года назад
Canadian armies at juno! Juno! I cant take your credibilty seriously if you cant name all the beaches our allies landed on!
@Idahoguy10157
@Idahoguy10157 5 лет назад
Montgomery criticized the Canadian Army to the point of scapegoating. Especially about the Germans escaping through the Falaise Gap.
@lyndoncmp5751
@lyndoncmp5751 4 года назад
They were too slow pushing towards Falaise. That's a fact.
@Idahoguy10157
@Idahoguy10157 4 года назад
John Cornell ... there was an opportunity for a larger envelopment by the Americans. Patton proposed and Bradley denied. Don’t know whether Montgomery was included in that discussion.
@lyndoncmp5751
@lyndoncmp5751 4 года назад
@@Idahoguy10157 The Canadians were still too slow moving to Falaise. The only reason why someof the commanders weren't sacked was because they were Canadian. Monty fired three British commanders (all of whom had been with him in North Africa) just the week before. It was Bradley who halted Patton at Argentan as he said "I much preferred a solid shoulder at Argentan to the possibility of a broken neck at Falaise". Nor did he consult Montgomery. Cheers.
@Idahoguy10157
@Idahoguy10157 4 года назад
John Cornell .... that’s what I’ve read. There’s an assumption that if the Canadians had a better commander they could have closed the gap faster and bagged the whole of a German army in Normandy. Whether it could have happened that way, we don’t know... fortunately there was a Polish force occupying the hills above the Germans calling in air strikes and artillery. They’re heroes!
@lyndoncmp5751
@lyndoncmp5751 4 года назад
@@Idahoguy10157 Although the Germans had a lot to do with it. They still had SS Tigers and Panthers around. For example on 9th August the Canadians lost 44 Shermans to the Tigers of SS 101 and Panthers of 12th SS at Estrees la Campagne so I won't be too hard on them. They had a tougher job than the Americans.
@meghan7547
@meghan7547 5 лет назад
With the greatest respect to all the Allied forces in WW2, he failed to mention, the Canadian landing at Juno was geographically the easiest. There were no cliffs or high sea walls, just a slope into farmlands. When one gives details of meeting objectives, one should maybe give all the details as to why others didn't make theirs. Should one wonder what the casualty rates may have been, if they had to fight through the bocage area? Again, I give the greatest respect to all that fought in the Allied forces.
@tumbler9025
@tumbler9025 5 лет назад
you make some good points and yes the Canadians did have it a bit easier on the landings than the others, but you have to look at the big picture here and that is if the Canadians had been held up on the beach like the others and had not gained the ground they did and set up a good defense the 12ss would of drove right to the beach and split the ailed forces in 2 witch would off been very bad , Again not knocking your comment it's just fortunate the Canadians held there defensive line and gave the other forces time to get off the beaches .
@ColonialHistory
@ColonialHistory 5 лет назад
All the beaches except Omaha were relatively easy in terms of terrain in fact Utah was the easiest. Gold and Sword were about the same. However Juno also was confronted with a number of re-enforced 'houses' and a sea wall which had to be overcome. As someone has already mentioned, Juno was the target for 12th SS (Hitler Jugend) in order to split the bridgehead and had to be held at all costs. In fact Omaha was almost abandoned but once the foothold was obtained it was somewhat easier until the units reached the Bocage country further inland. The areas around Caen were also similar hedgerows but fewer small fields. My late father fought with the Canadian 3rd as a 'corps' Anti-tank unit (62nd Anti-tank) British RA and always spoke highly of the Canadian boys who he fought alongside. The 12th SS Panzer(Kurt Meyer)were their main opponents and, although they were young men, they were also the best equipped with Tiger and Leopard Tanks and the best trained and total fanatics.
@meghan7547
@meghan7547 5 лет назад
@chris eldridge….. so over half of all the Normandy Invasions deaths came from a beach landing that "In fact Omaha was almost abandoned"?? How does that happen?? So an almost abandoned beach accounted for more deaths than the other 4 combined? Could you please explain that, maybe give links to the information you are basing your statements about how abandoned Omaha beach was??????
@ColonialHistory
@ColonialHistory 5 лет назад
I suggest you read history and your clearly find that the slaughter on Omaha was so bad that it was discussed abandoning Omaha and withdrawing the remaining troops. You either read my comment out of context or didnt read it at all. "Realization of the grim losses on Omaha Beach had, by mid-day on June 6, caused Gen. Omar Bradley, a competent and "unflappable" commander, to fear that his 29th and 1st Divisions had "suffered an irreversible catastrophe." He came within an inch of ordering withdrawal of the Omaha force -- representing the main bulk of the American D-Day effort."
@ColonialHistory
@ColonialHistory 5 лет назад
"Bradley did consider evacuating Omaha Beach, but most military historians agree that he could not have done so, and that given the intricate nature of the D-Day landings, the transfer of the 1st and 29th to Utah likely would have meant chaos, not salvation, for the 4th Division troops already ashore."
@freakyflow
@freakyflow 5 лет назад
From what i read and gathered Under the direction of Gen Montgomery As he knew of German strengths down to the areas of Gold Juno Sword from gathered intell on German movements He placed the Canadians in the the heaviest of the SS And armor The idea being Why use up British forces when you have Canadians. Let them do the hard work and if the lose By then we shall have the Left and right flanks covered And the other way around if we shall need reinforcement From the German side They planned two options renforce and fight on the left flank And push the Americans back and cut off the Canadians And sweep up over the britsh from behind and infront Or Defend and counter attack towards the Canadian and British forces and turn into the American side Again from notes of the Americans They had many issues getting on the Beaches and being where they needed to be Had the Germans dug in and reinforced Utah It might have not changed to winning the fight But I think it would of set the Americans to hold on sending more troops in And get the Canadians to help with the flanks Leaving the British to cover ground only Grandfather Served with the Lincoln and Welland regiment of the 10th Infantry Brigade, 4th Canadian Armoured Division Which seen action start in Tilly-la-Campagne Just after Caen Onward to the Netherlands
@chazmena
@chazmena 2 месяца назад
Pound for pound, the most victorious and accomplished of the Allied effort. Time and again. (And I'm a Yank, btw.).
@michellejean11
@michellejean11 3 года назад
Some might say Montgomery's planning used the Canadians badly.
@derekbaker3279
@derekbaker3279 3 года назад
Montgomery was in command of British, Canadian, and Polish forces that faced the bulk of the German armour & fanatical SS units. The terrain, large number of villages, and location of the German defences resulted in a battle of attrition....there was no opportunity for any war of movement, sudden decisive thrust, or outflanking the Germans. Montgomery understood better than any other Allied general what he was up against, and he knew that if he made foolhardy risks, the Germans were more than capable of making the Allies pay & even seriously disrupt the Allied plans for conquering Normandy. Finally, given the nature of the battle, the quality of German men & equipment, and the fact that both British & Canadian manpower was not inexhaustable, there was little choice for how the battle had to play out. That meant that the Canadians were in the thick of the heaviest fighting for some of the most strategically important ground, and that resulted in heavy casualties. And, FWIW, the Brits certainly paid a high price in men & equipment too.
@ElricWilliam
@ElricWilliam 4 года назад
In less then 3 minutes you angered a candian national
@Jimatuscc
@Jimatuscc 4 года назад
Two German bad words...Canadian and American.
@daveb6815
@daveb6815 3 года назад
almost a reverse of 1066,, is this guy talking a lot of bs or what
@miguelromero3156
@miguelromero3156 3 года назад
canadians against the baby division
@derekbaker3279
@derekbaker3279 3 года назад
The Hitler Jugend was primarily made up of older teenagers, led by older experienced officers. The same could be said about a lot of the units in the Allied armies. Besides, a 17 year-old Nazi is as capable of aiming his MG42 & cutting you in half as a 20 year-old Nazi.
@brustar5152
@brustar5152 Год назад
With your last name; how many times was your grandpa's rifle dropped before he dropped it again?
@finallyfriday.
@finallyfriday. Год назад
"Battle of Cah." Monty's first big failure in N France... hardly his last.
Далее
Battlefield Normandy - The battle of Authie D-DAY + 1
11:56
Good dad 🥰 #demariki
00:17
Просмотров 10 млн
D-Day from the Canadian Perspective | Bird's Eye View
10:38
JUNO BEACH The Deadliest On D Day? | Normandy WW2
17:55
Ansichten vom Ende - Einsatz an der Ostfront 1945 (2/2)
47:38
Hitler in Colour (4K WW2 Documentary)
1:10:44
Просмотров 8 млн
Battle for Carpiquet Airfield - Normandy 1944
3:53
Просмотров 115 тыс.