I'm burning this candle for the first time right now and it's a "no" for me because the smell of men's cologne, which you noticed, is too pronounced. I prefer "Juniper and Laurel" for a woodsy scent. This has a #7 throw at my house.
Winter Wonder in the Daylight is a bit too powdery to my nose. Kringle’s Snow-Capper Fraser is a favorite. I have a backup. I picked up Winter Wonderland from last Winter that I’ll be enjoying this Winter. Warm Winter Wishes❄️