I was looking for this video everywhere, I couldn't remember the name of the show. I used to watch it when I was really really young. I always remember this song. I still sing THIS version of the song every time.
1:29 Dan Futterman was my definite crush during my teenage years. He looks similar with that late Stepehen Gately which makes it even cuter. He was in Enough with Jennifer Lopez as her confidante.
I hope you found it long before now...but it was from the episode "Caroline and the Cold Sesame Noodles" - Season 3 Ep 8. Sadly...the entire number was cut out on the DVD. Why??? I'll never know. But that's what brought me here to see it.