Carpio: Roque warning PH to lose Ayungin Shoal with hardline stance 'laughable' | ANC 

Big mistake of the Philippines to elect Duterte as President.

Traitors must be put behind bars

We rather lose Roque, instead of ayungin shoal.

Karen and Justice Carpio thank you very much for the information. Well said and we must defend our country against invaders like china. Justice carpio salamat po.

Please continue to counter China narratives and propaganda hurled against our stand in West Phil Sea. Filipinos do not yield ❤❤❤❤

Pwede bang tanggalan ng Filipino citizenship si Harry Roque at ialay na lang sa China.

Stand Philippines! Hindi tayo mag pa alipin nang china habang buhay!! Ang atin ay atin hindi tayo papayag na kunin sa china ang suberanya natin,,

Ex SC Associate Justice Antonio Carpio is a true Filipino patriot.

Roque should leave the country and go to china.. right now, right away.. we don't need a traitor here...

Mga kababayan gising na tayo! We won the UNCLOS na tayo ang mayroong sovereign rights in the WPS.

I‘m Pilipino and Ayungin shoal is ours !

Mabuhay ka Justice Carpio. You are indeed a rare breed of Filipino that loved our country

The Phil. government must follow the steps done by Indonesia and Malaysia against China on their EEZs. Let us not be intimidated with China's modern day colonization strategy.

Ngayun pa lang dapat nating malaman kung cnong mga local leaders ang kasama ng mga duterte’s para wag nang iboto. Dapat walang matitinong Filipino ang maging maka China

I respect Mr. Carpio when it comes to his knowledge about WPS salute you sir! you nailed it!

We need more leaders like Justice Carpio who could articulate our rights. He makes us proud that as a country, we can stand for our rights. His articulation gives us inspiration to continue to fight for our rights.

The more the Philippines procrastinate their plan to assert its claim the more we lose another sovereignty, we should not be fearful of being get wet by water cannon.

nakakadismaya ung mga pilipinong mas napanig pa sa china d nyo naiisip ung mga mangingisda na d nakakapunta sabteritoryo natin dahil inaangkin nga tapos kayo naman parang ok lang sa inyo anung klaseng pag iisip yan

I think there’s no more discussion we have already won in the arbitral ruling Sir Carpio is right to start drillings in the WPS Roque is a Chinese representative the word came out to his mouth shows and we must not believed.

Yes they destroy the corals and rampantly disturb the echo system

That’s understatement Mr. Carpio, Mr Roque is so brave enough to take the side of China, and insinuating we should request china to allow us to repair our own ship in our own territory. Traitors or taksil sa bayan must be punished.

Former SC Associate Justice Antonio Carpip is quite right. Let's not be intimidated by China the way other ASEAN countries did to their EEZ sovereign rights.

kailanga natin idig ang langis at gas habang maaga para magamit na ng bansa para makaalpas tayo sa kahirapan

Sana si Justice. Carpio na lang ang sunod na presidente. Matalino, matapang, matatag at makabayan.❤❤❤

Roque the Dolphin Boy Lunatic

Mr. Antonio Carpio must run as a candidate in next election, Filipino Citizens needs smart and Honorable Leader no need to argue he knew what he says. He explains clearly the solution rather sitting around and doing drama in media.

Former Supreme Court Associate Justice Antonio Carpio makes it plainly clear that a sovereign country, like the Philippines, doesn't need the permission of a foreign country, like China, before the Philippines can conduct economic or defense activities within the Philippine EEZ. The rhetoric of the Duterte administration that repeats China's intimidation talking points betrays their complicity with Chinese naval intrusion and aggression within the Philippines' EEZ. Duterte's subservient posturing to China's provocative behavior towards the Philippines was remarkably controversial and probably requires an investigation. China's lawless behavior in the West Philippine Sea and the South China Sea is an affront not only to the Philippines but also to every country that uses the international waters of the South China Sea where major sea lanes are located and many countries around the world rely on for shipping and commerce. China must be made to comply with international laws and conventions like UNCLOS for it to preserve its good standing with the international community. Otherwise, China must be made to bear increasing pressure, like intensifying economic sanctions, from the international community until it convinces itself that complying with UNCLOS is the better alternative to defying the code of international law and reaping the unprofitable consequences that accompany such defiance of world order.

Thank you Justice Carpio for the enlightening discussion on the WPS subject. Thank you for standing up for the Filipinos . Wish you to be part of that maritime group that will be formed by the government that will guide PBBM navigate PH policy and strategy in all in our WPS .

Carpio and Gibo for senador kailangan kyo ng gobyerno ntin khit isang term lng sir malaki maitutulong nyo sa paggawa ng batas pra sa sovereign rights ng pilipinas Wag ng iboto ang mga pulitikong maka china

We support PBBM and all the people that are working with him to protect our country sovereignity and Eez

Walang hahadlang nating mga pilipino kong anong gagawin ng ating pamahalaan for. Improvement

This s critical moment to all pilipino people mybe we lost our teretory if hanggang baliwain lng natin ang advice ni carpyo

Atty. Roque is frequently flying to China. Envoy na yata sya China. Baka may position na sya Chinese Government.

Simply because FPRRD was intimidated by China.

Mabuhay ka Antonio Carpio isa ka Makabayan!

Long live AJ Antonio Carpio. You are rhe ligjt amudst the darkness. Gid bless you.

Well said Sir Carpio 😊

It's so SIMPLE and LOGICAL...All because of DUTERTE.

Justice Antonio Carpio for PRESIDENT!!!! 💪🦾 Lakas mo Idol!!

Filipinos should unite in this issue. Wag po tayong makinig sa mga katulad ni roque, duterte at mga dds supporters dahil kitang kita mga taksil sa bayan ang mga yan.

Mabuhay po kayo Justice Antonio Carpio! Please continue educating Filipinos of our sovereign rights in the West Philippine sea. Thank you po.

Roque is a traitor

Great respect for Justice Carpio for championing the sovereign right of the Philippines on our EEZ.

The Philippines should continue to construct a permanent structure in Ayungin shoal to strengthen the maritime defence to deter China's aggression.

harrietroques strikes again hahaha...let us support our government's policy on wps

I go with justice Carpio, a true filipino patriot and brilliant lawyer

direct and honest explanation

Sir you are absolutely right

Well said sir

Sabi ni roque nbubulok n raw ang barkong seira madre. Di nya inisip n ang pangalang "seira madre" ay tumatayong simbolo n tagasangga ng anumang banta s ating Bansa. "Seira madre" mountain pra di tyo hgupitin n mllkas n bgyo at "Seira madre" ship n kanlungan ng ating mga sundalo n nagbbntay s ating teretoryo.

If President win our EEZ please extend his presidency because every time we change our leadership it’s always getting worse. Atleast this administration will fight for our nation.

Best explanation Atty Carpio.

Since when did we see any fight in a soft stance? China should follow arbitral ruling.Follow international law.China should be out of the Philippine Eez.No to Island building.Former administration should explain to Filipino people this illegal gentleman deal.

💕 Ipaglaban nman po ntin yung sariling atin. Everybody needs gas or energy. But that is ours 😇✌️🙏 🇵🇭 💪💙

Sa akin hindi siya laughable. Nakakagalit siya. Niyeta! Kung ang mindset ba ng mga ninuno natin noon eh hayaan nalang nila pananakop ng Spain, US at Japan dahil wala naman sila panalo, nakalaya kaya tayo? Tinulungan tayo lumaban at makalaya ng mga ibang bansa kasi nakita nila na nagbuwis ng buhay ang ating mga kalolo-lolohan. 45 years old na ako at nakakaranas na ng rayuma at hingalin na. Pero kung kailanganin makipag-giyera sa China dahil hindi sila makuha sa pakiusapan, magpapa-enlist ako. Hindi porke’t wala chance manalo eh hindi ka na lalaban. Susmi!

Well said sir, you the honorable justice carpio are truly God given hero of our beloved country.we need your leadership sir .God speed sir.

Tama ka Justice Carpio Sir, with the help of the Joint Patrol of like minded nations forces, we can do the oil drilling of the Reed Bank....

China' s illegal claim is a clearly just a dream😂😂😂

Let us stood our ground against China and not to be intimidated. Justice Carpio warned us based on his expertise and legal prowess. I believed him. Bayan ko Gumising Kana sa katotohanan.

Why allowed intimidation to freely surrender the sea territory? Why they doubted U.S Mutual Defense Treaty? Do they think Philippines AFP is afraid to fight for the country that they just allowed the intruders to do what they want in the EEZ treating the UNCLOS decision is just a piece of paper? Going by jetski with Philippine Flag was a false hope, isn't it?

agree to this.....

Philippine has two oldest map. Original and authentic

thank u justice antonio carpio.

AMLAC should check Roque’s accounts for remmitances from China.

MV Sierra MAdre they reconstruct become like new and statue of a Symbol of WPS and the Filipino Peoples always right?!

I wish Justice Carpio will run for president the next presidential election.

Why PBBM is not supporting the objective of ICC to investigate Duterte? This is perhaps the very reason why Duterte's head is ballooning causing a big trouble to the Ph and the Filipino people. Why not let Duterte keep himself busy defending his party?

Whoever received money from China needs to return to them.Filipinos did not agree to such sell of the WPS. All filipino officials who knew about these deal should be investigated and if found guilty of treason, they should be punished according to the law. And please don't vote anymore additional traitors in your government.

Umpisahan nang mag-drill sa Reed Bank bago matuyo ang Malampaya Gas Field!!!! Dahil magkalitsilitsi na nyan ang ating power supply!!! UMPISAHAN NA YAN!!!

Tama si Carpio wag tyo mag pa intimidate..

We lost Panganiban Reef aka Mischief Reef when our government got into to a diplomatic agreement with China back in 1996. Roque sounds like China's spokeperson just like other Filipino bloggers.

Correct chief justice.

C rokwe butanding ipadala sa wps ipakain sa mga pating 😅😅

Tama po kayo sir. No nee d to ask permission from china . It is our territory. Thank you sir for the good ideas have shared to us. Kailangan na talaga natin yong mga allies natin nang makapag s8mula ng drilling dyan sa wps. Sino pabang hinihintay ng ating mga officers. Malapit ng maubus ang gas ng malampaya . Aantayin paba nating maglampara tayo ulit.

Obviously, Roque is a mouthpiece of the PRC.

Karen … make it simple.. don’t back down against China .. you need to fight like Vietnam and other Asian countries did .. they didn’t back down instead they stand tall.. that’s what the Filipinos need to do . Fight for your country and your rights… that’s it don’t get intimidated by this Chinese aggressors ….stay strong …

Watching from CBR, Australia. Roque's arguments are quite illogical!

Right you are sir carpio 👍

Napakaliwanag ng pagsasalita ni kagalang galang na justice Antonio Carpio sa pag angkin natin sa kalawakan ng west Philippine sea. Marahil kung siya ang naging pangulo ng Pilipinas ng nakaraang anim na taon at hindi mangmang at may malasakit sa Pilipinas hindi natin aabutin ang kalituhang ito. Tama ang sinabi niya, sa paglalagay ng pangulo ay dapat maging maingat tayo pag hindi, mauulit na naman at maaring lalong lumawak ang pananakup mg china sa west Philippine sea.

In that case never again allow the Dutertes' to deceive the Filipinos.

Roque is the spokesperson og China.. but he got a very big eyes!!!😁😂🤣🤣

nakakatawa nga sa isang pilipino ang sinabi ni roque. a shame.

Mabuhay si Justice Carpio. He fight for Philippines Rights aand freedom. God bless you po.😊😊

Very well said justice carpio! Very smart big salute to you sir 👏👏

Good JOB CHIEF JUSTICE CARPIO WE SUPPORT YOU

Carpio should run as president. Still strong in mind and spirit!

What the senate doing investigate digong what he done to phi.sea why😮he don't care to pilipino people he give away the philippine

What criminal case can be filed to those agent and atty of china under the Phil.law?

Close Binondo if China forcibly gets Ayungin

China say one thing and do another things! Why o why Filipinos are not waking up of slumber nightmare dreams against China. Trust is built! From several years they are slowly getting our Exclusive Economic Zone! K

Correct Carpio

Tama baka nga may connection na Yan sa china

a competent man , thanks Justice Carpio

The best thing for the Philippines to do is to get the oil in Ayungin Shoal. Let China sue us in the International Court if it thinks it has a better right. But we have to get the oil first. Let us get the oil.

China is not ready for a big war because of lack military bases. Indeed they have the most numbers in terms of military armies and equipments but strategic bases is their weakness. If they engage into war most of southeast asia countries, US, Taiwan, Japan and maybe India will join the war against China. I don't think Russia will help china because of Ukraine issue.

an tanong meron ba tayong ship na tulad ng ibang bansa

This is the first time that I watch Karen's

As PILIPINO CITIZENS hears more the wisdom behind the reasonings of the justice chairman mr Castro , in its analysis to the PHILIPPINE position against the intrusion of CHINA , it makes more sense than the arguments of the others .

im curious, sana mapanuod itong interview na ito at ung mga prev interview kay Justice Carpio ni PBBM then consider JC in his cabinet in particular for.d WPS matters kasi ito.ung taong may pagmamahal sa bansa at alam nia ang batas at alam.nia ang diskarte na ggwin.nalulungkot talaga ako sa gnawa ni Duterte sa issue ng WPS

Ikulong nyo na so Roque at Duterte while investigating these issues para di na makapagsalita ng kung ano ano. Gawin nyo ang ginawa nila kay De Lima.