I dont have the CT one because its waaaay too expensive. So when the Elf one launched i rushed out and got it. I still like it but the shade i have is just tiny bit too dark. It can also look dry on me. But the coverage is nice 🤗 For me Catrice is the winner. Its cheaper, easier to get than Elf, better shades, natural finish and feels moisturizing on the skin.
It seems like Catrice would be best solo or as a topper highlighter, while Elf would be best for under a matte foundation to make it more satin finish instead of matte.
You have the same skin color that I do- yellow undertone (is that right?). The Elf color would scare me away, it is too peachy. Thank you for the video.