Тёмный

Causal Inference: A Simple Difference-in-Difference Model 

Mike Jonas Econometrics
Подписаться 15 тыс.
Просмотров 56 тыс.
50% 1

An explanation and data example of a simple Difference-in-Difference model, with an example in Stata.
Link to excellent new book - Causal Inference: The Mixtape by Scott Cunningham
(amzn.to/3fTxdvg)
Classic Article by Card and Kruger using a Diff-in-Diff approach to study impact of changing the minimum wage (www.nber.org/papers/w4509)

Опубликовано:

 

6 авг 2024

Поделиться:

Ссылка:

Скачать:

Готовим ссылку...

Добавить в:

Мой плейлист
Посмотреть позже
Комментарии : 49   
@crystalwang2006
@crystalwang2006 2 года назад
Thank you, professor. Your video is very straightforward and clear. Keep positing more lectures of DiD!
@mg24ification
@mg24ification 2 года назад
It is really impressive how you are able to explain those topics in a straight forward und understandable manner. Looking at your videos and the effort you put in makes me wonder how its justified that my professor is getting such a high pay for simply reading down some slides. Thanks a lot for your very appreciated help!
@bpatriquin123
@bpatriquin123 2 года назад
I appreciate how challenging giving a lecture can be without a visual audience, but you nailed this! It’s obvious that you know the model’s requirements / applications, and you explained the a fairly complicated model in such an easy to understand way. Very impressive lecture!
@mikejonaseconometrics1886
@mikejonaseconometrics1886 2 года назад
Thank you for the kind words - glad it was useful! There is a lot more to the DiD model and literature, of course, but hopefully this is a good introduction to the concept.
@menzibennett4808
@menzibennett4808 2 года назад
Thank you Mike, I have learnt a lot from this lecture. I thought DiD was complicated and you have not just simplified it for me alone but also gave me confidence for graduate school thesis.
@ryantimothy84
@ryantimothy84 9 месяцев назад
Thankyou so much for your explanation from the data it was so clear, I thought DiD method was complicated but you just simplified it easily. I really appreciate this video and the lecturer.
@drjabirrahman
@drjabirrahman 3 года назад
Thank you for this, makes it easier to understand the concept.
@levine1886
@levine1886 2 года назад
Great video! Very easy to understand! Please do another one on when we need to consider other control variables!
@farhanshazia5610
@farhanshazia5610 3 года назад
This is perhaps the best lecture on DiD. Thank you so much.
@bpatriquin123
@bpatriquin123 2 года назад
👆 This comment nailed it!
@faresbenyoussef5090
@faresbenyoussef5090 Месяц назад
Thank you so much. Great Video !!!
@alipaf2002
@alipaf2002 8 месяцев назад
Man what a great teacher, Fantastic.
@wsmedley4498
@wsmedley4498 2 года назад
Well done... very helpful explanation! Thank you.
@arpitak20
@arpitak20 3 месяца назад
Amazing video! Thanks for creating such valuable content
@kdanielevans
@kdanielevans 2 года назад
This has been so helpful!!! Thanks so much. I had struggled to understand the concept. But this lecture has made it so easy
@mikejonaseconometrics1886
@mikejonaseconometrics1886 2 года назад
Glad it helped!
@sanchitachakrovorty6991
@sanchitachakrovorty6991 2 года назад
Very informative lecture. It made did very easy to understand. Thank you!
@TheRealGrunzy
@TheRealGrunzy Год назад
Thats a great video Mike!
@jannoriko7465
@jannoriko7465 2 года назад
Your explanation is so clear! Thank you so much!
@mikejonaseconometrics1886
@mikejonaseconometrics1886 2 года назад
Glad it was helpful - thank you!
@muayadali8312
@muayadali8312 2 года назад
Thank you. It was very impressive lecture!
@Kenkoopa44
@Kenkoopa44 7 месяцев назад
THANK YOU SO MUCH FOR THIS!!
@elvisduru2042
@elvisduru2042 Год назад
This is a great video for a first-time exposure to D-I-D.
@phyuphyuzaw1964
@phyuphyuzaw1964 3 года назад
Thank you!
@omaramri6862
@omaramri6862 2 года назад
Can I just say, in the past 4 years I managed to finish my bachelors and masters in finance and economics all thanks to you, I feel like u deserve some % of my salary. XD!
@mikejonaseconometrics1886
@mikejonaseconometrics1886 2 года назад
Haha - thank you Omar! Very glad to be helpful.
@arieljiang8198
@arieljiang8198 2 года назад
very helpful! thank you
@shenyingzhang5280
@shenyingzhang5280 2 года назад
It’s very impressive to listen to your lectures! Would you please share more information about DDD(triple difference model)? Especially how shall we do the robustness test
@fm109
@fm109 3 года назад
This is really nice
@fatur36
@fatur36 3 года назад
Thank you.
@Justme1635438
@Justme1635438 Год назад
Thanks so much. You really take the time to explain it in detail. I wonder how to conduct this test on longitudinal data though. Do you have a video about that? And I wonder how to use the didregress or xtdidregress function in Stata and what the difference is between the two.
@ryskeldiazizbekuulu333
@ryskeldiazizbekuulu333 2 года назад
Thanks! helpful
@nirobkothopokothon
@nirobkothopokothon 2 года назад
Thank you very much for explaining the DID. I kindly request you to explain how to conduct a placebo experiment to support the parallel trend assumption of DID. Thank you very much.
@fadhilfp6
@fadhilfp6 Год назад
Thanks a lot for your lovely explanation. My questions 1- in real life experiment (quasi) comparison treatment group to control group is hardly feasible and in most situations is unethically leave second group without treatment, so can we make this quasi-experiment to compare between 2 treatment groups, meaning treatment 1 group versus treatment 2 group (comparison group) ? Taking in our consideration that pre-treatments level in both groups comparable (no difference in the starting point) as possible as other factors except in treatment allocation to eliminate bias selection. Question 2- Evaluating pre- and post-treatment in each group threatened the external validity as we did not compare it to control, meaning we can not figure out the effect of treatment A or treatment B, noting that the internal validity is not violated as we can compare the differences between both groups. Question 3- Regarding the statistics, if the normality is violated in some variables and the average can not be evaluated , using the median is it fine to figure out the significant differences or not
@ibrar2kt
@ibrar2kt Год назад
thanks
@snk2818
@snk2818 2 года назад
Thank you for the extremely easy to understand video.. i have a data in which the control and treatment are sequencial.. ie half hour for control, next half hour for treatment, next half hour for control and so on until there are 4 control and 4 treatment groups.. also the participants were not the same. Do you think the D in D can be applied to it? Your guidance will be much appreciated.
@santiagoleon5110
@santiagoleon5110 Год назад
Thanks for sharing the information, it was very useful. I have a question, how relevant is the R2 value in this impact evaluation method?
@thechannelname81
@thechannelname81 2 года назад
Dear Mike thank you for posting such a useful and beatifully explained video. one question, why did you put all data into Stata? was it an alternative way of estimating a treatment effect?
@thechannelname81
@thechannelname81 2 года назад
Hello Sir, thank you very much for such a great lecture. what if to consider two or more T periods before the treatment. let's assume that they are t0 , t1, t2 etc from left to right. In this case, which t-value should be included in the formulat? the last one or t0? I hope I could explain my question. thank you in advance
@rezanorouzian8198
@rezanorouzian8198 6 месяцев назад
Thanks! My understanding is that if there are more than two time points, then, DID has to be done separately for each pair of pre-test and a subsequent post-test, right?
@prof.samtajain7001
@prof.samtajain7001 2 года назад
can we have more than two pre-treatment and post-treatment periods
@findingtruth6301
@findingtruth6301 7 месяцев назад
can you attach the sample workbook you use please
@asheeshnasa
@asheeshnasa 3 года назад
Really liked the video. Can you please share the referencees as mentioned by you?
@mikejonaseconometrics1886
@mikejonaseconometrics1886 3 года назад
Yes, thanks for the reminder! I've linked to a great new book, and an old article worth reading.
@jamesleleji9470
@jamesleleji9470 2 года назад
Thanks for the video. Can you do another video using SPSS or R
@mikejonaseconometrics1886
@mikejonaseconometrics1886 2 года назад
Yes, I will work on an example in R soon. Thanks!
@jamesleleji9470
@jamesleleji9470 2 года назад
@@mikejonaseconometrics1886 Ok thanks, looking forward to it!
@maximusg88
@maximusg88 Год назад
Shouldn't the slope change starting from the point of treatment? (13:26)
@maximusg88
@maximusg88 Год назад
I see - this is for two time points only - fair enough
Далее
Introduction to difference in differences in Stata 17
59:06
9 - Difference-in-Differences
33:01
Просмотров 9 тыс.
Это iPhone 16
00:52
Просмотров 924 тыс.
ПОМОГЛА НАЗЫВАЕТСЯ😂
00:20
Просмотров 2 млн
Tobit and Heckman models in Stata
36:26
Просмотров 32 тыс.
Causal Inference - EXPLAINED!
15:32
Просмотров 62 тыс.
Difference-in-differences methods
16:18
Просмотров 43 тыс.
Lecture 14   Difference in Differences
1:20:35
Просмотров 21 тыс.
Quasi-experiments: difference-in-differences
11:34
Просмотров 15 тыс.
An intuitive introduction to Difference-in-Differences
12:49