CGI 3D Animated Short "Rubato" - by ESMA | TheCGBros 

Any video that treats a dog well gets my thumbs up.

Whoever fathered the idea of linking a metronome and a waging tail of a dog has to be a meaningful and enchanting human being. Love from Spain!!!

I lost my dog last month ,, and feeling like my heart is cuts to half 💔, he was so cute and funny ,miss u so much honey ❤️🇪🇬

There are many animation maker but only a few has the quality to touch our hearts.. I must say this man is one of those few people 👍

Впервые вижу этот мультфильм.Очень интересный,с глубоким смыслом.Спасибо за предоставленное удовольствие.

Everything about this video - story, visuals, animation and audio were absolutely world class... bravo.

Rhythm is life, and life is rhythm. A good mechanical metronome is a little work of musical art, and so is a good little dog. Love this little film.

Изумительное анимэ, не устаю удивляться искусству мультипликации. Это не детство в нас, это чувство прекрасного в нас.

I actually had tears in my eyes at the indescribable beauty of this short. The background is breathtaking . . . can't find the right words . . .

If I catch anyone dissing an old man and abusing a animal, well it well hurt 😞! I’m an old man...and ppl diss me all the time. What a wonderful film! Kudos to All involved in the production and amazing creativity...thank u... grazie!

Absolutely marvellous ! Such minute details, cobbled stones, frosty air, even the scratches on the old wooden stool look real. Wow ! 👏🏽👏🏽👏🏽👌🏽👍🏽

Beautiful...the hands, the roof tops, faces all of it..great attention to detail in the making of.

I've only just discovered these delightful shorts !! My, my, how entertaining.

This is one of my favorite cartoons. Today, I paused it because I couldn't recall the musical definition of "rubato." Wow! The title was so well chosen with the musical settings and character pacing offering both aural and visual echoes of the title!

This is the most beautiful flawless artwork. This video is better than anything Disney has recently produced

A Masterpiece! Storytelling, that’s what it’s all about! Marvelous! Thanks for sharing!

He's been doing this for a long time..judging by the four worn away patches on the stool that match up with the four corners of his metronome,lovely little detail..plus,the darker wood in the centre where the metronome has protected it from the Suns rays.❣

Beautifully rendered story. The background is a work of art. Nice story too, dogs will almost always bring out the best in people.

Who needs a metronome when a cute dog will do....... lovely animation accompanied with sublime music.

Que animación tan extraordinaria, hermosa,, muchas felicitaciones, historias ideales para los niños, desarrollan la imaginación, el arte, estimulan la atención, la percepción, el lenguaje y a mi en especial me encantan!

Loved it! Especially the depiction of Paris' streets and alleyways. Thanks so much.

4:24, that dog's face, so cute with the puppy eyes :D

Every dog has its day! Superb video.... Amazing talent of the makers.

How sophisticated and detailed this wonderful video is created. I imagine it takes a lot of time and work, plus patience, to design that city-view from above. Well done!

Bravo! What a delight to watch; the street scenes and buildings wonderfully created with such realism and the story heartfelt, inspiring..........Compliments to all involved.

C est magnifique , plein de finesse et de poésie.💝 Un tout grand bravo !

Gran animación, refleja el arte de sus creadores. Es lo que necesitan los niños de hoy, para que sepan visualizar cosas positivas en su mente. Me encantan éstos cortometrajes animados. Saludos desde México.

The scene with the three kids is incredible!

Haven't historically liked CG films, had to do all practical work on projects in college. This was a simple story and well done, nicely paced, I'm sure it was a lot of work and everyone did a great job!

Beautiful lighting, particularly off the musician's hands.

I love dogs so... I love this short film it’s amazing!💐

Excelente animación. Las atmósferas y texturas son increíbles. Mucho éxito!!!

thank you you tube!!i love this short animated so much!

Для того чтобы исполнить рубато, надо отключить метроном. Рубато это свобода! Что и происходит в этом сюжете, к тому же жизнь дарит главному герою нового верного друга ❤️

The most beautiful 3D video I ever see.

Magnifique court métrage, j'adore !

The 'tempo rubato' is well illustrated in this short animation film... at the beginning, the old man is reliant on his metronome to keep the beat, simply because he is down and out of loving feelings in his heart, and his music is clearly lifeless. After his encounter with the stray dog, his heart opens up and his music becomes inspired by loving feelings and free. He is thrilled when he realizes that he does not actually need the metronome anymore! There is a great sense of freedom for a musician once he/she gets to that stage in his/her musical journey! The old man is now playing with 'rubato', a musical indication from the composer asking the musician to play slightly loosely with tempo so as to allow more feelings to show. That is the subtle but important distinction between a robot precision playing (=lifeless) and a more inspired and expressive playing that stirs the listener's soul. If you look further, you notice that at the end, before starting to play, he looks up the dog wagging tail to give him the beat, just like a metronome would! Then starts playing and the two of them are totally in-sync.. so lovely and free!

Love the gentle animation. Keep up the great work..... A strong compact story really drags you in.

Très beau film d'animation, émouvant, merci 😊

Даже пигментные пятна на руках музыканта есть....это потрясающе!!!! Характерные движения лап 🐕, супер!!! Браво создателям!!!!

It takes time to accept new things and changes. The dog is too cute

Não atoa a união entre cães e homens existe à milênios. Simples e emocionante, parabéns!

When there’s a dog, I click like. Life’s simple.

Wonderful !!! Much needed this day and age.

Wonderful, loved the animation and city backgrounds. And you nailed the irrepressible nature of dogs.

¡Que hermosa animación! ¡Que calidad de imagen, y bonita historia!

Beautiful work! It is nice not to have a depressing piece of work that makes me cry.

I love the design and artwork on this and the expressions of your characters. Marvelous!

Absolutely beautiful short film.

Excellent work on the modelling and texturing of that city, it looked very detailed and natural,

Tiere sind und bleiben das ehrlichste und treuedte was es gibt! LIEBT SIE!! SIE geben einem soviel mehr, als jeder Mensch!!!!

My good, this is sooooo BEAUTIFULLY done! Thank you. Amazing

True friendships are far more important than material possessions.

Quanta sensibilidade, muita qualidade no sentimento que quis passar, encantador!!!👏👏👏 abraço aqui do Brasil 🇧🇷

Schitterend! Wat een prestatie , om de figuren van de man,de hond,de straatjongetjes en het prachtige decor van de stad te creëren ,voor dit geestige verhaal . Heel mooi, dank!

Nicely captured the emotions of both dog and his owner.

Потрясающе интересный мультфильм. Благодарю!

Haha, that man looks just like my Uncle. ...He's just as mean too. XD Beautiful animation. Its a fantastic quality and the ending made me smile. Thank you.

Hermoso cortometraje 🥰🤗🐶🐕 Me encantó 👏👏👏

Gratitude, amazing energy to you. Upping vibration to happy. Love.

cudownie zrobione 🤗 brawo !

One of the better things I seen on RU-vid but I'm glad the dog didn't sing too long.

If only real life was full of this kind of love.

Thank you a lot for such kind history 🤗

Incredible animation. Inspired story. Bee you tea full!

Just wonderful. Thank you. 😀😍👋👋👋👋👋👋

Délicat et lumineux.... Merci !

when ever I see a dog wiggling its tail, this is what I'm gonna think about.

Love the video, and the music was awesome as I love Violine and Cello music.

I'm a musician...and a dog lover....I LOVED THIS FILM!!

Deux mots pour ce magnifique court métrage : Wouaf ! Wouaf !

Que legal isso. Precisava encontrar alguém que realizasse o meu projeto com essa qualidade. Mas é muito difícil encontrar! Parabéns ao artista pela animação.

+++ j'adore ces petits films d'animation. les gars, vous dessinez extraordinairement bien...je vous envie...chapeau, bravo....

Adoro esses tipos de filmes! América do Sul , Brasil, nordeste, Bahia, Salvador.

Adoro este tipo de animação ,a história e cativante .

La historia muy emotiva . Y ambientar la historia en el París de esa época muy lindo enhorabuena gracias desde Elche Alicante

This short movie is amazing though. Background music caught my attention. Every thing is explained simply and beautiful. Specially the ball comes back to him.

Absolutely charming, thank you.

Strike the bass that beat the clock, Sound would shine that can't be stop, Except of course, a lonely dog, That lead the hope of epilogue. From down and out, to quit the day, But here a friend has come to stay. Though not by gain the old believe, A different stand to feel relieve.

Well done. Storywas good, music great. Guy looked lil evil but it worked. Nothing beats a good dog!

Veramente bellissimo! Bravo!!!

Rubato was excellent. It made me feel what the characters were feeling and I Loved the dogs tail imitating the Metronome. Wonderfully Artistic !

I am surprised that there are dislikes as well. This is a nice story. That dog 🐶 is so adorable.

Such awesome details

Créativité, écriture, scénario, arts graphiques, réalisation, montage : un grand bravo sur tous ces points (et ceux que j'oublie).

Merveilleux travail empli d'une belle philosophie!!!!

Спасибо за Ваших персонажей, за простую и замечательную историю.

You’r doing great makeing this films!

Beautiful thanks for sharing moments of joy

Πόσο όμορφο και παραδειγματικό!!!

I just love these stories.

I love this film 😍 💚💛😻💙 !!!

Just beautiful! thank you!

I 💞 your animation of Rubato. We need our children to return to the 'simplicity' that teaches the heart. Grazie.

Мультик чудесный. Настоящий шедевр!

I can watch animated short movies for hours🤩😍🥰

Vraiment beau!!!!....Bravo!!!

Brilliantly done. Clever play on words with the title.

😊que lindo, coisas simples nos faz feliz

Who are you guys? Modelling, texture and mapping, rendering and animation are superb. I wish I can improved my 3D skill with you guys