Thank you so much for showing us the undertones of all these colors! The swatches on Charlotte's website seem way off for some of these. Rose to fame looks gorgeous ❤
I’ve watched five reviews of these in an effort to narrow down my wishlist. Everyone is talking about the glitter in Icon Baby. Some people are bothered by it and some don’t seem to mind it. It would drive me bonkers because of the gritty feeling and the fact that glitter stays on the lips after the color wears off. Great review and comparisons! The Icon Baby liner looks like something I would love. Love your enthusiasm for Charlotte!❤
I got the Icon baby. Grittiness for the first application but after that it seems to go away and is very moisturizing. The others don't have the glitter at all but in Icon baby I actually really like it.
I am so excited for these Charlotte Tilbury is also my favorite lipstick formula!!! I also think that Ms. Tilbury is going to take my money! These are gorgeous!!!
Really pretty pink/red lip colors! I loved all of them on you, that red looks gorgeous with your neutral eye look. The Queen lip liner is a bright pink I can use in my collection. I like Rose to Fame and Hollywood Vixen! Nice review.
No Morgan I was not interested in buying that collection and now I do feel like I have to 😅 Very very good job reviewing products, I honestly think you are one of the bests at this !
GIRL! You look SO HOT wearing ANY vibrant color lip!!! Idk if it’s your skin tone or hair color, but I feel like you can definitely pull off any vibrant lip color!
If I'm not mistaken, I have been hearing people say that the first pink that feels gritty is a frosty metallic or similar to PMG BlitzTrane, but not as smooth? To my eye, it makes me think of those pink 80's frosted lipsticks that I went through multiple tubes of. Not my best lipstick moments...🤦🏻♀️ For my coloring (medium neutral olive skintone, dark hair, and blue-green eyes), I'm loving 90's Pink and Cinematic Red!
I was so close to buy the icon baby lipstick, but I saw a video where it said that there is glitter/pearl in it and I don't like that! I'm so glad I didn't buy it. But I ordered the icon baby lipliner 😂
I watched another review of these too, it's so painful, they are gorgeous but I just get so frustrated with anything that isn't budge/transfer-proof!! Great review as always.
Red Carpet Pink looks exactly like a lipstick I wore in middle school back in the 80s…lol. So, I will pass on that one. Rebecca from Not Fit For Print noticed the glitter from Icon Baby, too. She took the swatches out in the sunlight-yup glitter city.
I think her KISSING formula recently has changed loads too, especially with adding lots of glitter. Such a shame None of these shades appeal to me sadly, although they look lovely on Morgan
Im s glad you talked about Icon Baby, because nobody else ive seen has spoken about how gritty it is. Mine is the same, sadly. Im in England too, so im guessing thats just the formula for it. I'll still wear it as its so pretty, but I'm disappointed its so gritty.
Your reaction to the lipstick Icon Baby was exactly like mine! I literally thought something was wrong with the one that I purchased like maybe it had gone bad or something! Lol it was rough and gritty and I could feel the pieces on my lips, and when I looked in the mirror I could see glitter and I was just so confused because I had no idea that this was different than the other Kissing formula lipsticks. I can honestly say that I really like the color but I do not like the feel or the glitter or the grittiness and wish that she would reformulate this lipstick with the exact same color but in the regular kissing formula finish.
Thank you for this video Morgan! I can't wear a lot of powder cosmetics, so seeing an entire video dedicated to lips made my day, watching again now 😄 the packaging of CT doesn't do it for me, but I might try it for the formula, looks lovely!
I ordered Icon Baby specifically because it has shimmer in it! 😂. Everyone loves different things. I’m glad Charlotte Tilbury switched it up a little. I heard Rocket Girl limited edition also has the shimmer.
Thanks for going through all the colors! The side by side comparison of the pinks was super helpful. I was also looking at cinematic red and you sold me. That color look amazing on you.
90’s pink looks gorgeous and cinematic red is my kind of red. the lip liners look super pretty. 90’s baby and the first red one you swatched are my favorites. i would LOVE to get the 90’s baby, but it’s a mess, and i hope you reached out to customer service!!! 💗♥️💗♥️
From other reviews I have seen, the first pink is a shimmer. It probably should have been labeled as such and not as the regular kissing formula. I picked up 90’s PInk b/c i am a mauve girl. I passed on the liners as I have lots of mauve liners. I didn’t pick up a red, but I really do like that Cinematic Red on you! I’d love to see it compared to the new Natasha Denona Berry lipstick! Great review as always.
These colours looks gorgeous, I really want the darker pinks like Rose to fame or as I love the kissing formula, it's my favourite lipstick formula of all time. I like the way it lasts long but is still super hydrating and juicy looking
I was hoping you’d do a video on these! Bought Icon Baby today, I absolutely ADORE the colour on me but it did feel grainy also?? I’m still going to wear it cause I love it but yeah the graininess is 🤨
I picked up two and Icon baby is full of glittery gritty glitter ✨ it’s a bummer! I loved Red Carpet Pink.. I agree and just try to remove it! It’s more glitter not shimmer.. can’t wipe off..
Making my list of favs !! 90’s baby , mark of the kiss, oh the queen is nice too !! Now for lipsticks , red carpet pink , and a couple others ❤ umm yes I would be contacting customer service on that lipstick as I hope something didn’t get in the formula .. yikes !! Lots are upset so far I have seen ..
CT x Elton John released a KISSING lipstick with shimmers at Christmas. The shimmers dragged a hint on the lips but I forgot about them once applied. The shade looked stunning, especially when the light caught the multi-coloured flecks. Didn't leave any shimmers behind when the lipstick wore off. I'm interested to try Baby Icon to see of it is similar or different to the holiday lipstick. The pinks and reds looked beautiful on you! CT pinks have pulled orange on me (except for the original Stoned Rose), so I'm looking forward to trying a few shades and a red for sure. Thanks for your review!
GREAT VIDEO AS ALWAYS ❤️😍😍😍🖤LOVE THAT THUMBNAIL THO DROP DEAD BEAUTIFUL YOU ARE UR MAKEUP ALWAYS LOOK PRETTY SUPER CUTE LIPSTICK ON U ENJOY YOUR NIGHT AS WELL HAPPY FABULOUS WEEKEND AHEAD 😇😇STAY BLESS N BE SAFE ALWAYS
It's not faulty. That glitter looks exactly like MAC Viva Glam IV from the 90s. It's a mauvey pink with kind of a gold glitter. It's still sold and I still love it! So this is good news to me.
My icon baby has the same texture urs has,I think it's deliberate ,it's supposed 2 b that way,at 1st I can feel the particles,but after a few minutes it seems 2 melt away so it doesn't bother me,the only disappointment 4 me is icon baby is much darker in person,I was hoping it would b a lighter pink shade,but the color is still pretty
Nooo what a shame the Icon Baby shade has a bunch of glitter in there. It's such a gorgeous shade whyyyy! I think I'll just pick up the liner. Great to see your review before making decisions
I'm loving my Ready for Lust Elton John lipstick, the deep berry one eith the glitter, but it's not for every day wear. Remember frosted lipstick? Revlon still does these. I think for nudes and pinks frost would be better than glitter. Btw, I'm liking the Rose to Fame. It kinda looks like the new Guerlain Cherry Blossom. What do you think? And is that Guerlain formula a good one?
LOVED the review Morg, and yeah I bought a lipstick from the Elton John collection she did with him, and it was all grainy and disgusting, and I was REALLY wanting to love it, and it was REALLY sad, and sooo I CANNOT WAIT to get some of these lipsticks
Hey beautiful 😍 you look stunning. Question do you know if they’ll be restocking on the lip gloss jewels on the pinkgasm sunset those lip glosses were so beautiful. Thanks
Honestly I think Charlotte should have consulted you before the release LOL! I mean who do they use in their focus groups? I like her products but not so much her lipsticks, but I really like her lip liners.
Icon Baby lipstick is grainy because of the glitter. Which is not good. Every review has mentioned the grittiness of that lipstick. LA Colors/LA Girl make lip products with glitter and you can’t even feel it. And they’re super cheap/affordable brands. So for CT to make a gritty glitter lipstick is off-putting. 😬 And I already had Candy Chic. She launched it before and I’m glad she brought it back !!!!
I am so on the fence. I was Al in for those pinks. But swatches next to her previous shades I worry these will turn orange on me like every other lipstick Charlotte makes.
I love Charlotte Tilbury's lipstick formula! I only have the matte revolution & hot lips, so i ordered 3 of the pinks of the kissing formula 2 try..idk.. hopefully il like it as much of the others,does she not offer every color in every formula or do u have2 order a certain formula if u want a certain color
It’s just that shade. She did the same with the Elton John that was a deep berry shade. That was my fav shade. I wish she didn’t do that or name it different formula.
i love icon baby, candy chic and red carpet pink on me but i am really pale with blonde hair and blue eyes and a cool undertone haha. icon baby to me didnt have a gritty texture but it did have glitter so not sure what happened with that shade. it sounds mixed depending on the batch lol
I have realized I don’t love creamy lipliners. I love nyx suede and rimmel lip liners because they’re pigmented and easy to use but not too creamy. I like a little less emphasis with my lip liner and just the ability to clean up the edges, and the texture of those is perfect.