I’m very surprised that someone would want to compare them. They are so different stylistically but Miley’s lows are my favorites but I love Christina’s heads voice
I think Miley is underrated and her focus is to perform not only sing. Her voice is so different and low. Her latest performance (Miley Cyrus - Plastic Hearts (Backyard Sessions)) is just, wow.
Tbh comparing Miley and Cristina is not wrong cause Miley and Cristina have raspy voices have similar range and have very good lows. Miley’s lows are like ASMR to my ears tho 🙌🏼😍
@@rolascovers3378 excuse me it is a common sense notion that Christina is an A+++++++ singer, suffice it to say Christina could eat her alive in a riff off
Nothing to compare to this video.. ONLY XTINA.. HER VOICE IS OUT OF THIS WORLD.. What you saying / what you Showing with your face and your reaction are 2 different things.. Really?? You told that you prefer Miley but your face honey when Christina sing is speechless.. 😄😄😄
I had to put personal preferences aside and focus on objective critique. Everybody knows I prefer an darker, thicker voice and Christina's does it for me despite strain and larynx pulling.
@@elliegk225 on earth, y'all don't wanna admits it but xTina is especially famous for her tone and her emotion, like Adele, but she's screaming her lungs of, like keep it real. Miley is superior technically, that is a fact take it as u want. His reaction was perfect and unbiased deal with it
@@atolm1 Tone has nothing to do with vocals and you basically just toneshame singers or people with "hoarse smokers" voices by saying one tone is more legendary than the others when it even objectively does not make any sense.
These clips were biased ash, everybody knows Christina be spittin out D5s with ease😂 put back to basics Christina vs Miley then let really debate😂‼️ And why was head voice left out? Yeah we know why...
@@brandonpowell2060 I got all clips from Christina vocal channels here on RU-vid other than the B2 and Stormy Weather that I knew of hers. If I make another video with Christina I’ll try to use the perfomance you’re saying 🤗
I could have picked better clips for both of them, but especially Miley. For example, I know that she has far better D5s, Eb5s, E5s, F#5s, and so forth. We even heard better examples of some of those from her in other parts of the video. Also, she was inconsistent because starting in around late 2014, she began singing around a condition called Reinke's Edema which started making her voice noticeably deeper, raspier, and more hoarse. She could have definitely benefited from professional vocal training which she is now getting.
I love both!!! But Christina's lower register is stronger especially all the lows in I loves you porgy, beautiful CNN performance, You lost me and twice performance in New York...But these ladies are talented
Christina used to be a powerhouse and she'll always be a queen but Miley Cyrus doesn't get enough recognition. Especially with some of her new stuff. I love her!
Biased af, though Mileys clips werent all of her best either , more of Christinas better moments were skipped out, and we all know Miley has one of the better lower registers among most female pop singers , which was included in the video, but headvoice and falsetto were excluded where Christina out performs most pop singers .
@@lydob2471 yeah her controversial past made ppl overlook her actual talent. I love her tone she got that unique raspy country voice that I just love. And yeah her lows are UNMATCHED
Finally you are reviewing more Christina! She put out so much during Christmas and those would be great reviews. Comparing them both is so different, but I would much prefer reviews of all her live videos the end of this past year. 😐
I love them both, they have a different style, but thanks so much for your analysis 😊 Could you please react to Demi's new song - Dancing With The Devil 🙏
Miley 's lows are eargasm to be honest, she has a naturally deep voice, Christina just lowers her larynx and I don't know why she does that. Christina should have won with the mids but again with the forced larynx. They both strain and that's why technique is important.
Well if we only hear both in that notes they are in the same level but the complete voice from xtina her head voice, falsetto, growls, agility and her style of singing she is great
They are not in the same level tbh, the clips presented here were not Christina’s best and the reactor knows it as well, nor was it Miley’s, it was more of a comparison of their most popular performances which don’t always include the best vocals, and yes you are right Christina outperforms Miley in everything else other than lows.
@@EliteKaki well not only low notes,Miley is better in midbelts and overall she has better support than Christina because really often she pushes her voice to the edge where she sounds strained,Miley sometimes pushes her voice to but overall she uses more healthier tecnhique so its sounds more clean tha Christina.
@@EliteKakiYour statement proves that you wrong. Prime Miley is better in mid belts, upper belts and lower register while Christina will outshine her in head voice/falsetto and agility. Basically both are almost in the same level. Have you ever seen Miley’s covers? Like a prayer, heart of glass, maybe, Zombie and Nothing else matters are actually amazing. However, current Miley is very different. She isn’t capable of belting in the fifth octave like the past which is not different from Christina 😂
Please react to the performance of "Communication" by Miley Cyrus! It really showcases her amazing warm and dark tone as well as her great performing/emoting skills. She is in such a comfort zone when it comes to her voice in that performance and it's just a pleasure to listen to.
@@andresn695 eh? Que tiene que ver estar sordo? 😂 aquí la cosa es que si miley será buena tb? Si! Pero las comparaciones son odias y más compara a xtina con miley, nada que ver
I love me some Miley, but there were much more better clips of Christina doing those exact notes, and way better. Should’ve included her lower notes from these past years.
I like them both, but those were not the best clips of Christina. It was a biased comparison. Christina is the THE vocal savage and the voice of a generation. Haters are gonna hate, but you can’t throw shade on Christina.
Both of these beautiful women have very deep, grungy, and sexy voices. Absolutely love them both. But I have to say couldn't the uploader have found much better clips to showcase both of these women's voices in a much better quality? Great video Ash!!!!! 😁👍
They both have better note choices than these, but it was done fairly when an audio quality wakes into the place. I think them two are as fair of a comparison as you'd get when it comes to them two. Both are lower voices, raspy, with strained high notes, growling, and decent to great depth. In the end, I got 8 points for Miley and 5 for Christina.
Never understood these kinds of comparisons. To my ears, one of these singers has a stunning tone I find pleasurable to listen to, and the other does not. I’ll take a beautiful voice over a good singer any day.
I am sorry did you see 15 years old hannah montana has better lows than 30 years old christina christina better at headvoice mileys lows are asmr different styles both good singers
If we take out xtina's best notes from back to basic tour,stripped tour,Liberation tour and her debut reflection tour,and her performance from some awards plus include head voice and falsetto,Miley will be annihilated from dusk till dawn😂😂,Miley lows are great and she has great range like 4octaves,but Christina Aguilera has 4 octaves + few semi tones more than Miley...
I hate when fans of a particular artist do these type of comparison videos because their favorite singer will always turn out superior solely due to the clip choices. In this case the video was made by a Miley fan. Even though the fan did his best choosing Xtina clips (you can really tell, so props to the creator) it's still no where near a fair comparison on a technical standpoint for Christina. Some of these clip choices were straight up ridiculous. I wish people would make collabs. Like clips collected by Xtina fans and clips collected by Miley fans who are on the same page. It would prevent (unintentional) bias.
I’m sorry Christina will blow Miley out the water vocally. Whoever made this video strategically used certain clips to make Miley appear on Christina’s level.
If you have time and if you wanna see vocal battle between real vocalists, there's a vocal battle between Lara Fabian and Celine Dion, you already mentioned how close they sounds concerning the range, now if you wanna see their difference on the technical point, here's the perfect video : ru-vid.com/video/%D0%B2%D0%B8%D0%B4%D0%B5%D0%BE-I-1vClw8PyE.html . Great reaction as usual, really my fav reaction channel by miles
By these clips, Miley was definitely better sounding and stylistically better. But Cristina and Miley definitely have better clips than these but it is what it is 🤷♂️😂
Thanks for uploading! If you have a second, I tried my hand at a cover of Billie Eilish. As a fellow music fan, I'd love if you would take a listen. It's on my channel. Hope you enjoy!
This is not on you but the video you reacting to is literally created by a Miley fans, these clips are literally some of Christina worst clips. The creator could of used way better notes especially in the mid range section
The last Miley clip is from around the time the song was released. After her recent vocal troubles, and the surgery too, her voice changed and her range is much lower
