No video :(

Classical Vocalists React: BTOB 'To My Love' @ Immortal Songs 2

Подписаться 834 тыс.

Просмотров 325 тыс.

50% 1

For the 7th video of this mini series, I showed classically trained vocal performance majors BTOB's To My Love performance at Immortal Songs 2.
Watch the original performance here: • BTOB - To My Love | 비투...
This series won't be updated as often as the 'Classical Musicians React to Kpop' series, but will hopefully cover some great live performances of KPOP groups/vocalists. I am only featuring KPOP vocalists on this series, hence why we haven't reacted to So Hyang yet. I may branch out in the future, but for now, I will only focus on featuring kpop vocalists.
I will be focusing on Immortal songs 2, Fantastic Duo, and Duet Song Festival idol performances that I personally am curious to see how my vocalist friends will react to & analyze vocal technique of.
To see what other performances the vocalists will be reacting to (scroll down past the cmr schedule): docs.google.co...
The vocalists to-react playlist: • Playlist
Social Media info:
~Channel instagram: @reacttothek_official
~ Channel twitter: @reacttothek
~ Channel tumblr: / reacttothek
~ Channel Facebook: / reacttothek
~Support us on Patreon and get extra access to videos you’ll never see on YT: / reacttothek
Umu (video editor and channel PD)
Instagram: @_emcha_
Tumblr: omg_horns
Nozomi (Thumbnail)
insta: @nonchanyuzuru
Jeremy:
Insta & twitter: @_jeremyl
Gwen
Instagram and Twitter: @gwenpakerr
Hugo:
Instagram & twitter: @hugohumbility
Rachel & Jonathan & James: N/A

Опубликовано:

21 авг 2024

Ссылка:

Скачать:

Готовим ссылку...

Добавить в:

Мой плейлист

Посмотреть позже

Комментарии : 906

@nyxie653 6 лет назад

"you can slice bread on that jawline" *_YES_*

@zelos138 6 лет назад

When they commented about Sungjae not being as strong, I think it's because Sungjae is a baritone, but generally sings in a tenor range, so he has to reach for his notes. Im Hyunsik is also baritone, but he got baritone lines in this arrangement.

@BurningFlame08 6 лет назад

The same as Freddie Mercury :)

@alleya9436 6 лет назад

hyunsik's vocal range is REAAAAALLLLLYyyy amazing so its not hard for him to sing tenor notes

@llllll1897 6 лет назад

Sungjae also got much better. Like in their 2nd IS2 performance you could hear a clear differnece!

@melatonin12 3 года назад

Sungjae was sing a lot in the E4-A4 range, which is pretty standard for a baritone belt.

@de-fume 3 года назад

Tbh Sungjae sounds lacking only because he's beside those 3. If it were anyone else he won't be.

@yourfriendlyneighbourhoodd3118 6 лет назад

"Need a wider 'u' vowel" Fun trivia fact: The American 'u' is actually wider than the Korean 'u'. They're not the same letter ✉

@dls4642 6 лет назад

BTOB has some of the best vocals in Kpop at all. They deserve a lot of praise 💖

@mybiases0688 6 лет назад

Seungjun's Bread indeed, all NtoB guys do. My melo, fave voice is dork Sungjae!

@Anonymous-ve7pi 6 лет назад

Seungjun's Bread Not really, individually Eunkwang does, but the others are average. Changsub above average but yeah

@niival 6 лет назад

if you guys wanna hear btob's live perfomance with less stuff happening on the background, I suggest you listen to this ru-vid.com/video/%D0%B2%D0%B8%D0%B4%D0%B5%D0%BE-f71MCbigBJc.html you're welcome

@nirudhami8123 4 года назад

@@Anonymous-ve7pi maybe you haven't watched their live version or their solo songs....these four can hit high note and have different tone

@Anonymous-ve7pi 4 года назад

Elsaa Xetrri I have. It doesn't matter whether or not they hit high notes, and tone isn't an indicator of vocal ability.

@vespa2223 6 лет назад

How can these people pay any attention when they are yacking through the whole thing. As to the vowel sounds, this is Korean, they shape their vowels differently than in English, and they have some sounds we do not even make at all. I do agree that on Immortal Songs, the style tends to be over produced.

@mimipanda2483 4 года назад

When he said “None of them look thrilled be there” and “I wish they would get more into the song” I was thinking to myself that they actually were really into the song and that they people watching should read the lyrics, which are on the screen, and he would understand that they are feeling the song and the meaning.

@hutalee0608 11 месяцев назад

indeed, right?

@JodiWong 6 лет назад

"the guy second to the left i heart you so much he's beautiful" same 😂

@hwi0kyun 5 лет назад

구독자로써 이 채널 진짜 좋아하는데 이 영상만큼은 볼 때마다 기분이 나쁨. 다른 영상들이랑 다르게 클래식뮤지션들 중에서도 성악가들만 나온거니까 리액션하는 사람들이 달라서 그런진 모르겠는데 계속 음식먹고 제대로 집중도 안하는 태도 굉장히 불쾌. 그리고 당연히 긍정적인 의견만을 듣기를 바라는 건 아니지만 혹평이 심하네. 일단 이노래 부르는 비투비는 국내 아이돌 중 보컬만으로는 탑이고. 그걸 제쳐두고라도 이게 노래로 승부하는 프로그램에서 우승까지 한 무대라면 객관적으로 남들한테 인정받은 무대인 셈인데.. 다른 보컬리스트들이 리액션한 영상도 많이 봤는데 반응이 너무 다르다. 얘네 다 실용음악 전공했고 가수면 똑같이 전문가인데 이런 무시를 받아야하나. 성악가들이 대중가수를 보는 시선이 이런건지..참..

@user-uv1td9qp6w 5 лет назад

클래식하는 사람들 중에 이런 말도안되는 우월의식을 갖는 분들도 계시기는 하죠. 근데 그걸 대중가요의 리액션 영상으로까지 찍어서 남기며 표현하는 저급함!!!!!은 대체 뭔지 모르겠네요. (설마 본인의 그런 생각이 티가 안날거라 생각했을까요????)

@user-mr5yw7mx4g 5 лет назад

Eugene Kim 이사람들은 그냥 우월의식이 깔린 국가시스템에서 교육받은.. 문화적 수용력이 낮은 사람들일 뿐이예요. 기본적으로 타문화를 존중하는 소양도 부족해 보이네요. kpop은 무시하면서 kpop이용해서 돈은 벌고싶은거죠. 자기들이 볼때 좋은?음악하는 가수들(이진아, 악동뮤지션..) 리액션하면서..kpop은 왜 이런음악을 못만드냐고 말합니다. Kpop을 공장식 아이돌음악이라 정형화 시키고 무시하죠. kpop 아이돌 무시하면서 왜 kpop 아이돌 영상만 리액션하는지.. 외국인들이 아이돌만 좋아하니까..제작사들이 돈되는 아이돌만 투자해서 한국 음악생태계 망가지고있다고 말해주고 싶네요.

@melody_caecilia4706 5 лет назад

폭풍 공감 ㅂㄷㅂㄷ

@never-ending8478 4 года назад

이 댓글보고 그냥 시간낭비 안하고 나가렵니다

@user-sq6cd1sh2v 3 года назад

저도 보는데 너무 속샹..ㅠㅠ

@faevynn2889 6 лет назад

One of the most annoying thing in world is hearing someone try to talk while eating...

@sheh8845 4 года назад

YES!

@redcherry471 2 года назад

YES

@luiz4z368 Год назад

That girl was irritating during the whole video

@starrybook4386 6 лет назад

2:32 "that guy's voice is so high I'm convinced he never reached puberty" makes me wonder how Hugo would react to Sunyoul or Jeup's voices lol (but seriously, it would amazing if you could react to them!) and thanks for this reaction! I hope we'll be seeing more vocalists reacting to BTOB in the future!! ^^

@berry1897 6 лет назад

starrybook Sunyoul!!!!

@gisels.5769 6 лет назад

Sunyoul up10tion! 😂❤❤❤

@acesmother4120 6 лет назад

LMAO I WONDER TOO

@huangcjz 6 лет назад

Sunyoul and Eunkwang singing So Chan Whee's Tears...

@zelos138 6 лет назад

Jeup’s performance of Wildflower on ICSYV is the best cover of that song I’ve ever heard

@blesselgraceandales2900 6 лет назад

I think what most musicians don't give a lot of attention to is that countries too have different perspectives on music. Korea specifically likes a lot of minors abruptly changes to a major with their songs, you'll know if you'll listen to their songs. Immortal Songs is a great show where you'll see a little bit of old and moedern korean music mixed altogether.

@JynxTheClown666 6 лет назад

Explanation was a little wrong again, its not all idols, its bands, singer-songwriters, soloists ect, idols rarely get invited because you have to be GOOD to be on the show since its 100% live and they arrange it themselves. I'd love to see them see a better performance from Btob since they really didnt get to hear the TALENT that is btob ya know. Also maybe Jeup's performance of Wildflower on I Can See Your Voice?

@norabeckwith446 6 лет назад

DarkAngelRin ikr and btob are already famous and i would love for them to train 12 hours day doing dancing and singing i bet they cant compete with that and their opinions about btob dont matter

@suzu444 6 лет назад

btob has the best vocal line among boy groups even their rappers can belt notes

@melatonin12 3 года назад

It’s really just Minhyuk

@btobhappy9thanniversary597 3 года назад

@@melatonin12 ilhoon can actually

@iamvoldy4583 3 года назад

@@melatonin12 dude before start talking know the facts! have you ever heard him sing! for your info he can sing she's gone without difficulties. we melodies heard him sing and that is why we comment here. so if you dont know just keep quite. please!

@melatonin12 3 года назад

@@iamvoldy4583 who

@iamvoldy4583 3 года назад

@@melatonin12 ilhoon:)

@plumplumi 6 лет назад

That was great ! I can't remember his name, but I'm totally in tune with the guy in red falling in love with Eunkwang's voice XD I'm hoping now he'll be on the video reaction of BTOB's I'll be your man and Movie coming up in june. I hope he'll react too on Eunkwang and his mom's duet since I saw you added it to the list /o/

@fzf7253 6 лет назад

i was about to recommend that duet to react to so thanks for your comment. saved me from embarrassing myself. :p

@jaelix329 6 лет назад

I was thinking the same hahaha I ❤️ Eunkwang is basically the statement of my life 😂😂😂 and I have asked for them to react to that video and the one with Eunkwang and his mother since the day they were released hahaha i hope they do it someday. Also "I'll be your man" would be great haha

@zalddowed6912 3 года назад

I just can't finish watching this reaction video..I regret clicking it.

@claritale_ 6 лет назад

5:34 HAHA, that's funny, because they did the Banana thing in one or two videos, BTOB is funny af xD My heart was racing when I saw the notification to this video, I love them and I want to hear all the praise they can get, it's good for my health and soul

@tnahpele0321 5 лет назад

애초에 클래식 발성으로 보는 게 잘못되는 거 아닌가 저건 가요고 많은 사람들이 칭찬한 무대인데 힘있는 고음을 소리침으로 보고 어이가 없다 진짜 전문가 납셨다. 보컬라인 다 실용음악과 나와서 기본적인 발성법 그런 거 다 배우고 지금까지 연구하는데 솔직히 아예 처음 볼 때부터 삐딱한 시선으로 보는 게 예의가 없는 것 같네요

@user-zu1cg4jj2y 5 лет назад

포렐시에 아 ㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠ 한국분 너무 반갑네요 시리얼이나 처먹으면서 전문가랍시고 앉아서 평가질하는게 너무 무례하다못해 끔찍하네요 ㅎㅋㅎㅋㄹㅋㅎㅋㄹㄹㅋㄹㅋㄹㅋ

@bluestar9795 4 года назад

지적질보다 칭찬이 더많은 영상인데 다들 너무 에민하게 받아들이시는거 아닌가요?

@user-ih7dd2sq5g 4 года назад

@@bluestar9795 기분 나빠하시는 분들이 많은걸 보면 그런것만은 아닌것 같네요..ㅎㅎ

@mookook-yy4nd 6 лет назад

Finally!!! Btob!! Actually all of the members are majoring music in korea. Two of them passed the best practical musical university in korea before their debut(that year, the school only passed two guys and three girls as their student, more than 3000 students applied and 'changsub'-at that time he didnt want to become an idol for awhile - and 'hyensik' got the ticket. Also one rapper was from musical major and so on.. Ah also almost all of them make their songs and write the lyrics. I love their effort and talent!

@anaghalekhu 6 лет назад

JiYoun Yoo thanks so much for these info..

@zelos138 6 лет назад

Also if you could let the vocalists react to Up10tion's Sunyoul "Tears" performance on King of Mask Singer + the reveal, it would be awesome! I wanna see if they can tell if he's a guy or girl lol

@jamiesilver7401 6 лет назад

Yes!!!!

@mia-pn2jx 6 лет назад

YESSSSSSSS

@bayanjumah5826 6 лет назад

yes yes yes!!! This I wanna see so bad!

@gisels.5769 6 лет назад

Omg yesssss

@gaby1102 6 лет назад

PLEEEEASE

@Yooteacher 6 лет назад

개인적인 의견이니까 싫어하는거 인정하는데 못한다뇨.. 못한다고 하지말고 안좋아한다고 해주시지... 그리고 이게 한국정서를 현대적으로 풀어냈다는걸 알아주셨으면.. 악기를 욕하는게 많으시니까...(횡설수설)

@sittinur-ginaboone7055 5 лет назад

sorry i cant continue watching this reaction. some comment are really bad. like the one who comment about puberty. this video really hurts me. BTOB is one of the best vocal group in kpop. I want Kevin!!!!! let them watch missing you live performance not the MV one. thank you

@user-xf5fo5fq9v 6 лет назад

I don't feel well. They are one of the best Idols in Korea..... 팬으로써 기분이 별로네요. 정말로요. 남자니까 당연히 고음 지르는데 힘들고, 저정도면 잘하는 거 아닌가요? 성재오빠는 한국에서 인정받고 있는데 클래식하는 분들이 계속 비판하니까 좀 짜증나요.

@rebeccaestrella 5 лет назад

ㅇ ㅈ!! 저두 기분이 나빠요😪

@manimagica 6 лет назад

Eunkwang has one of the best voices in kpop. It’s from another world.

@chrissycxc4909 6 лет назад

Please show them Sohyang's performances on King of Masked Singer 🙏

@tessbarnhart8988 6 лет назад

Chrissy Senpai YES !!!!

@charitypeter2396 6 лет назад

YES YES YESSS

@ck6082 6 лет назад

OMG her cover of breathe was amazing!!!

@blooberchik1 6 лет назад

i wish they would react to Dream i feel like musically its more interesting and there's a lot of songs that they could choose from her Masked Singer run i cant pick a fave :)

@greyyyroses 6 лет назад

Her songs on IS2 (Arirang, Bridge Over Troubled Water) are quite amazing too.

@user-mb2mk4mf7d 5 лет назад

I really want you guys to know this. BTOB is one of the top class kpop idol. Majority of the other idols even agreed that they are amazing vocalists, so I don't what to see anybody thinking about BTOB badly. If yiu think that way, it's cuz they, the reactioning guys did the bad job... that was really not nice at all

@julieannmaeyong3458 6 лет назад

BTOB's Missing You, Its Okay, I'll Be Your Man, Movie, etc.. PLEASE PLEASE PLEASE! PLEASE react to LIVE VERSION of BTOB's songs. pretty PLEASE!

@1_736 5 лет назад

마음에 안 드실 수도 있죠. 그렇죠. 비투비의 목소리에 반한 입장으로서는 조금 속상하긴 하겠지만, 어디까지 취향이나 개인적인 생각이 있으니까 괜찮다고 해도... 적어도 영상을 보실 때는 집중이란 걸 해주시면 안 될까요. 악기가 별로든 보컬이 별로든 간에 끝까지 제대로 감상하시는 태도를 보여주세요. 딴 멜로디분들은 어떠실지 몰라도 전 이 부분이 제일 눈에 띄었어요ㅠㅠ

@user-uv1td9qp6w 5 лет назад

The woman who ate the snack all the time watching their performance is so ..so!!! Rude and Arrogant... 클래식 보컬리스트, 성악가들이라 하셨는데, 감상하는 태도부터가 감상이 아니라...그냥 우스갯거리를 보는 듯한 태도시네요. 마치 옛날 귀족들이 성악가 불러놓고 나는 뭐 먹는동안 어디 한번 무대해봐라, 내가 돈은 줄게...그런 무대를 보는 듯한 태도처럼 느껴져서 매우 불쾌합니다.. 오케스트라때문에 목소리가 묻히니 안들린다고 싫을 수 있죠. 근데, 애초에 스낵씹으면서 그 소리가 들리긴 어렵죠. 그리고 성악발성을 싫어하는 사람들도 많고, 클래식만의 감성과 대중가요는 차이가 많다는 걸 모르진 않을텐데... 이 영상은 몇몇 분들의 성악가의 오만함과, 클래식하는 사람들 중 일부가 갖고 있는 개똥우월의식을 보여주는 영상이 되어버렸네요...

@King_Jonghyun 6 лет назад

Show them better live performances from BTOB :(( They are such amazing vocalists!!!!

@llllll1897 6 лет назад

Kιng Jongнyυn Ikr! Like. I would have used their 2nd IS2 performance (Under the Sky). That one was so much better mixing wise and vocal wise.

@bobbo922 5 лет назад

This is a good BtoB performance they are just being snobs tbh, check out Sam Johnon he reacts to the same video and is much more detailed and accurate in his analysis

@dreamwave5199 5 лет назад

Bobbo i don’t think they’re being snobs at all... please try to not disrespect them with your condescending attitude. i do understand where they are coming from. plus most of the stuff they talked about (mixing, instrumentation, etc.) was not actually something that btob could control it was just the sound engineer at the time. btob definitely has some of the best vocals out there but i think it is true that this video did not serve them justice about how absolutely amazing they could be. i think the reactors felt how good the vocalists could be they were just disappointed that under these circumstances btob did not perform their most amazing show. not saying that btob is bad... just saying that there are plenty of other videos out there that show the strengths of btob much more than this video

@dreamwave5199 5 лет назад

Bobbo also while Sam Johnson is a vocal coach these are students and some are still teenagers so don’t be too harsh... let’s spread love, light, and knowledge not hate

@tingtang93 6 лет назад

too much unimportant judgement. especially the puberty comment, kinda disrespectful (coming from a guy who doesnt sound all that manly either)

@kurayamiify 5 лет назад

dont eat during the reactions. not here for a mukbang please and thank youuuuuu

@aroobalt 3 года назад

I can’t stand people who think that they’re the best and they need to criticize everything so they don’t admit that there’s people who can actually sing other than them. If you were a professional you’d know what they can do with their voices even if they didn’t show everything. You need to choose the perfect technique for the damn song not to show off your voice and everyone have the right to choose how they wanna sing as long as they do it perfectly. Ugh

@aroobalt 3 года назад

Also before criticizing something how about trying to fucking listen first? They keep talking it’s so annoying and who tf talks when they’re eating… it’s fucking gross

@jellymelodywithbtob 6 лет назад

8:12 "I heart you" THAT'S OUR MAIN VOCAL OUT THERE WOOHOOO

@laylastecker2867 6 лет назад

They won this episode, they were great. I don’t really know how others think but I do think they’re amazing. They should check the feeling not the way they sing like they keep saying “they should...” and “I don’t really like...”. And what they don’t know is this song is sang by one person and they managed to make it into 4 person perfectly.

@cindih78 4 года назад

The one you say is not as good as the others is Yook Sungjae. All of the others singers are 3-5 years older than he is. He is the youngest member of the group and admits that his singing is not as good as his hyungs (elder brothers). However, his vocals have improved a great deal; he is also a natural baritone so singing upper register was his weakness but he has been training consistently to improve. He has now released a solo album with the title track “Come with the Wind” which you might check out. One other thing, this was live without ear pieces (which they normally wear when singing live) so the loud music is for them to hear.

@user-yo4if7fl8d 6 лет назад

아이돌 탑클한테 못부른다니ㅋㅋ 그것도 불후의명곡에서 1위한 무대인데ㅎㅎ 한국 아이돌 전체 다까버리네 ㅋㅋㅋ 지네들은 얼마나 잘부르려나

@user-ys8jq7ge7b 5 лет назад

좀 뒷북이긴한데 개시끄러워;; 여자들

@JoanneKim0420 5 лет назад

못 부른다는 표현보단 각각 어떤 특징을 갖고 부르는지 얘기하고 있고 뒤에 악기 소리가 너무 많이나서 가수들 화음이나 목소리가 잘 안 들리다는게 주 내용이었음.

@susiegotyonumber 3 года назад

umm nope. it's my first time watching a video from this channel and also the last, thank youuuu

@intotheshadows6232 6 лет назад

react to btob missing you pls

@syasol 6 лет назад

intotheshadows it’s on their won’t react list

@lostinbtobscharm 6 лет назад

aisyah #그리워하다 I wonder what the reason is.. 😕

@lostinbtobscharm 6 лет назад

eltk I see... thanks for the info ☺

@melatonin12 3 года назад

@@lostinbtobscharm anything on the list is because it’s not musically challenging enough.

@user-yb6fn3rf5s 5 лет назад

클래식 발성으로 보는것도 성악가만 모았으니 그렇다 치고, 노래를 못 부른다는것도 자기 생각이고 자기 취향이니 이해는 못하겠지만 넘어간다고 해도 음악 듣고 리엑션 찍는 영상에서 음식 먹으면서 듣는건 뭔가요? 적어도 기본적인 예의는 지켜야지; 악기소리에 보이스가 안들리는게 아니라 당신들이 음식 처먹는 소리때문에 안들린건 아닌가요? 당신들은 노래부르는 법만 배우고 음악 감상할 때의 매너는 안배웠나요? 장르는 다르지만 어쨌든 같은 음악을 하는 사람들인데 어떻게 그렇게 무례할수가 있죠; 아오 빡쳐

@user-bp8ei8br1m 5 лет назад

떠드느라 노래에 집중이 되나? 음악 평가 자격 미달이네...

@theelementofj 3 года назад

I don't understand how this ain't "flattering" to them since they won this round. :D The stylistic choices like airy singing were lauded by Korean audiences. I guess their comments were super technical because they're classical vocalists but maybe an overview of the show's concept could help shed light on these reactors? :D I guess you have to let 'em hear the original song, followed by this one for better judgement I guess? They themselves made the harmonies as it was originally sung by only one person.

@IIgoru1 2 года назад

it was their opinion, just like opinions were also what made btob win the round... you need to chill out and not take this so personal, weirdo

@theelementofj 2 года назад

@@IIgoru1 o please there was no harm in my comment from 7 months ago, weirdo.

@figulapt3784 Год назад

@@theelementofj you are the werido

@theelementofj Год назад

@@figulapt3784 YOU ARE.

@AA-pq4jo 6 лет назад

don't eat when you do reaction

@minmgurl 5 лет назад

agreed

@azmarajab8506 5 лет назад

Agreed, its kind of rude

@lil_sugi4633 5 лет назад

@@azmarajab8506 kind of? It is rude, sorry but to me thats really rude

@cupoftea_7373 4 года назад

Dude these are college students, and some of them even have double majors. They're doing this on their free/break time. Honestly this comment thread is rude lol.

@_11_58 4 года назад

@@cupoftea_7373 that is their problem. if they have no time, then just eat it without reactioning this. or just reaction. I have no idea why should we indure that ruuuuuude things for just reason that she is busy.

@hannasplit 6 лет назад

Also, please react to Eunkwang's cover of 'Letter that was sent blank'. He also sang that song on the same show and it really shows his vocal abilities. It is also such a sadly beautiful song ❤💓❤💓 I feel like the dude in the red would really appreciate it lol

@someonestophimwiththatdamn6150 6 лет назад

I just checked this out - so thank you so much for this comment. I think I'm in love. Man, it's so beautiful... I know what I'm gonna listen to nonstop for the next week

@hannasplit 6 лет назад

SOMEONE STOP HIM WITH THAT DAMN GLITTER THO Ahhhhhhh, I am so happy! I am so happy that someone else gets to find out about this talented man. ❤💓❤💓❤

@minhyukheota7553 5 лет назад

so after I watched this video there's a suggestion vid of a voice teacher reacts to this. and the difference in reaction is really different.

@hannasplit 6 лет назад

Ahhhhhh, thank you so much for reacting to Btob!!!!!! ❤💓❤💓❤💓 I love and appreciate it whenever you guys react to Btob ❤💓❤💓 Please react to Btob's Missing You!

@user-wz3xq2ww6c 4 года назад

이 채널 개인적으로 너무 좋아했는데 너무 자기중심적으로 지적만하는것 아닌가요.. 가요는 클래식이랑은 아예 다른 장르인데 그걸 생각 안하고 클래식 기준으로만 평가하는것 같아요. 그래도 이 무대 우승할 정도로 좋은 평가 받았던 곡이에요.. 너무 비판하는건 기분 나쁩니다. 다 실용음악이랑 뮤지컬 배운 애들이고 같은 가수니 전문가라고 할수 있는데 막 까내리고 싶어하는게 보이네요. 저도 음악을 오래한 사람인데 성악 창법을 조금 선보인 은광이 말고는 호평은 거의 없었고 음악 전공한 제가 봐도 혹평할 부분은 거의 없었던 것 같은데 좀 너무하네요.

@jenniferkoo4035 3 года назад

저도 동의해요.. 몇 안 되는 비투비 리액션이라서 들뜬 상태로 들어왔었는데 실망했어요. 기분도 상하고 ㅜ... 제가 모든 영상을 본건 아니지만 다른 그룹들이랑 너무 비교되게 하는것 같기도 했고요. 이 영상뒤로 이 채널을 거의 안 봤는데 갑자기 생각나서 왔다가 님 댓글을 봐서 남겨요.. (제가 한국말이 서툰점 양해 부탁드려요)

@snputri 6 лет назад

I do agree with the guy who said changsub has a beautiful falsetto, he has such amazing voice

@rahulnakarmi5183 5 лет назад

BTOB is far way better than these guys

@June_aeri Год назад

True

@cosmos920 5 лет назад

리액션영상인지 먹방영상인지 헷갈리기시작했다

@woori8089 4 года назад

Overall, I cant feel "RESPECT" in this reaction video

@animetell785 6 лет назад

coming back here after watching that Voice teacher reaction, he really said that their singing techniques are so nice, & their voices are so clean and their high notes are healthy & he praised the technique which eunkwang used in singing high note even hyunsik one, he really praised everyth' abt the performance, i felt someth' is strange with this reaction, any way the voice teacher explained every technique so simply even someone who doesn't know anything can understund easly what they are doing, he even said that sungjae voice is nice, compared to others we all know he lack a litlle bit but he's so good, he's not bad at all, his explantions were really good... any way i really like some reactors on this channel

@softlan_melo4906 6 лет назад

Yes its really true. But why the reaction here is truly different? 🤔 Then, eating while do reaction is really new to me. 😁

@animetell785 6 лет назад

MR BigBox haha same, she's always eating on other reactions too but here she was like "who are these guys! Whatever.. i don't give a shit" maybe it's only me but i found it a little bit annoying idk... at least give them some attention

@sanshirada1119 3 года назад

My mom's a former music teacher and she gave a high score when she first saw this performance. And she's too hard to please nowadays too.

@user-mp9kg5ec8j 4 года назад

나 이 채널 재밌게 봤고 좋아했는데 이 영상 보고 정 떨어졌다;;; 저 프로그램에서 우승도 하고 많은 사람들이 인정해준 무대인데 이걸 이렇게 비판한다고? 클래식 전공이면 차라리 음악만 판단하든가 이제 노래부르는 것까지 평가하네ㅋㅋㅋ? 남자가 저 정도로 고음 지르면 잘하는거 아니야? 잘 부르는 외국 가수들도 저런 식으로 고음 부르는 것 같던데? 밑에 분이 말한대로 k-pop 싫어하는데 조회수 잘 나오니깐 돈 벌려는 수작으로 밖에 안 보인다. 이 채널 손절한다.

@maddistrine6141 6 лет назад

Please react to one of nam woohyuns immortal song 2 performances, he's scored the highest that an idol has ever scored on the show. You won't regret giving either of his songs a listen, you may even feel blessed.

@steepedteadoubledouble 6 лет назад

omg yees they shouuuuuld

@a_lost_staysider 6 лет назад

ASDFGHJKL REAAAALLY HE DID OMG PROUD.

@pyuru 6 лет назад

Yes yes yes PLEASE!!!!!!

@rol969 6 лет назад

Omg yesss

@jazh2491 6 лет назад

*STAN TALENT STAN BTOB*

@cynza.8335 3 года назад

The two girls,How can they listen properly while they are eating and talking a lot at the same time..this is supposed to be a REACTION vid..😰😰please watch sam johnson on this reaction,he did better..

@jbee1999 3 года назад

God this commentary pissed me off

@johns80schick 2 года назад

Do they realize BTOB won that episode of Immortal Songs 2. I think one thing that might be throwing them off is the Korean language has like zero intonation, so it might sound flat or less emotive to them because of that. I think they sounded wonderful. Hyunsik is my favorite of the group, but I think Eunkwang has the best technique. Hyunsik's solo stuff is really awesome.

@redcherry471 2 года назад

MAYBE IF YALL LISTENING THE WHOLE SONG FIRST INSTEAD OF TALKING AND EATING........

@momiji7871 3 года назад

I am distracted with that lady who's eating. She also talks a lot and eat again, which I think she missed some important details of the performance. This performance is up to the mark.

@sf7113 3 года назад

there are two people here who aren't here to try and listen. they aren't even commenting objectively they are just here to say " oh we better than these guys" lol

@LupinKing 6 лет назад

As usual, and as expected, “Silver Light” and the others killed it.

@user-zv8vj4pr9j 5 лет назад

듣다보니까 웃기네 ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ어디서 평가질이야ㅋㅋㅋㅋ누가 무조건 좋아해달래? 그리고 남자가 왜 무조건 저음이어야댐ㅋㅋㅋㅋ사람마다 목소리톤은 다른거지 그리고 고음이 도데체 어떻게 걍 소리치는거임? 꼭 클래식첨 롸아아아~~일케해야 고음인거냐 은근 외국인들이 편견도 심하고 색안경끼고 본다니까 ㅋ

@keykth4040 2 года назад

besides the two guys with the red shirt, the rest of them should not be reacting. The two girls were chatting and eating away the whole time and the orange shirt glasses dude pair just don't seem to show that they know what's going on at all.

@abdulraisthamrin2574 3 года назад

I dont understand the way they react the video, it is a bit disturb me when they are eating watching and talking all at the same times.

@hannnah_u 5 лет назад

Be thankful for the low views of this video. If it were higher, all the normal viewers would be very angry on you guys' rude, stupid reactions.

@nrlwny6197 3 года назад

I come to this again bcs before i reacted once and i thought i just have a bad day by hurting with your judgement. But here i am again. Totally understand every sentence u said. Please, while reacting dont do something else like eating. Its annoying to watch. Please, do not disrespectful to grown man voice by saying he just like not reach puberty. Attitude guys, so not professional. The reactor season now is way more better.

@hachiya42 5 лет назад

다 실음 전공자에 전문가고 가수인데 이사람들이 "평가"할 자격이나 갖추고 있나 싶네 그리고 무시하는듯한 태도를 깔고 말하는거같아 불쾌함.

@lolapennyburg2966 6 лет назад

they NEED to react to Voisper perform “Forgotten seasons” on Immortal song... it’s absolutely draw dropping!

@Suny807 6 лет назад

Lola Pennyburg Oooh, really hope Umu sees this!! Well, this and my comment about Jaehwan 😅

@lnu_ortega_troy5067 3 года назад

How could they hear the singers' voice when they keep talking all throughout the performance yikes. those 2 girls were just so annoying, complaining about the volume of the orchestra yet they keep on drinking and talking at the same time.

@WellDressedGypsy 6 лет назад

Eunkwang is definitely one of the idol singers that has really good technique. For immortal songs 2 Jung Dongha and Son Seugon (i know I am spelling that wrong), would be really good to reactions for. Since there known for being amazing technique when singing. And Ailee and Sohyang of course.

@songsong2061 5 лет назад

아무리 자기 취향이 아니더라도 다른 나라 문화나 가수 존중좀.... I get that these people don't like this song or this song doesn't suit their style but they shouldn't disrespect other culture and the artists. Just saying..

@MARCIBEAUCOUP 2 года назад

I NORMALLY/USUALLY/ALWAYS leave thumbs-up on every video that I watch here on YT. But just want to let you know that I am one of those who DISLIKED this reaction content. I've watched some of your vids before, BUT THIS ONE JUST HIT THE ROOF WITH THE ARROGANCE OF YOUR "REACTORS"

@fullsunsqtpinky9926 6 лет назад

i haven't clicked so fast than now

@lycoris7285 6 лет назад

WOah im early also yES Btob

@user-zn9ns8ip6b 3 года назад

Idk man, i can never finish this channel's reaction videos to the end.

@btobhappy9thanniversary597 3 года назад

There are just times these reactors are so disrespectful to the artists they react to. They sound so condescending most of the time.

@lalolah2013 3 года назад

I would like to hear these reactors sing 😉

@catcatcat14 5 лет назад

I wonder why she eats while doing reaction video. Girl are you making mukbang video or reaction video? Or asmr video? Im hella confused

@dandansgi 4 года назад

다른 리액션들 다 좋아하고 잘 봤는데요. 이번 영상은 정말 볼때마다 기분이 안좋네요... 안좋아하면 그렇다고하면 되잖아요 왜 못한다고하세요? 그리고 리액션하면서 시리얼 먹는분은 처음봤네요 간식이던 밥이던 다 드시고 리엑션하세요 가수폄하 좀 하지마시고요

@shella.belarmino 6 лет назад

But BTOB has the one of the best vocals in kpop, though. Hehe.

@slowbluemoon 6 лет назад

appreciated how that guy was so quick to identify sungjae as the weakest vocalist of the four. the Korean public seemed to love his voice a lot after his performance on Masked Singer (i mean i do too), but he got to the 3rd round which was further than the other BTOB members who appeared, and it made people think he was a better singer than the other members. When frankly, thats just not the case. there's a reason why he's dubbed the sub-sub-sub vocal. also love how eunkwang got that stamp of approval from everyone. excited to see them react to his performance with his mom. kinda wish there was a full version of his performance of "Tears" from Masked Singer that they could react to. his short aria was beautiful, but im curious to hear about how it sounds to classically trained vocalists.

@kyaejeoung 6 лет назад

I don't want to sound petty but... there's a "sub" too much...

@taeilrights 6 лет назад

I personally don't agree that he's the weakest out of the three. Eunkwang is obviously just on another level, and Changsub too, but when it comes to Hyunsik and Sungjae it's a bit murky to me. Sure, Hyunsik has a wider range but like the guy in the video said, when he tries to go for the higher notes it tends to be shouty and just full of strain. And Sungjae puts himself down way too often because of the fact that he can't go as high as the others, but when he stays in his comfortable range his voice is something else. It wouldn't hurt to get proper vocal coaches for the both of them though.

@trangdo2612 6 лет назад

Actually Eunkwang also got into round 3 😅

@jessica1480 6 лет назад

drive.google.com/file/d/0B2dVo58fGmZAeGY0M1hpZW5vNDQ/view At 10:20. There is the full performance of Tears. :)

@slowbluemoon 6 лет назад

Gepi Kimy no its right lol thats the joke that started when he starred on king of masked singer. when he told the judges there were three singers in btob that were better than him, someone on the panel said “you’re the sub-sub-sub vocal?” its been a fandom joke ever since

@user-qd6gr1pi8e 6 лет назад

한국어 자막이 없어서 슬프네요ㅠㅠ 아무래도 악기 연주에 대한 얘기보다 멤버들 노래 스타일 평가가 많네요. 그와중에 창섭이는 마치 변성기 안 겪은 것 같다고, 아예 팔세토라고 부르고. ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ 은광이가 제일 테크닉적으로 완벽하다고하니. 역시 외국인도 비슷하게 들리는가봅니당. 우리 뎨뎨에게 혹평을ㅠㅜ 괜찮아요. 비투비가 제일 노래 잘 하는 날은 "내일"이니깐!

@augu8t139 6 лет назад

정확히 어느 부분을 혹평했는 지 알 수 있을까요ㅠㅠ

@user-qd6gr1pi8e 6 лет назад

glottal attack(?)이 과장됐다고 하네요. 그리고 자꾸 나머지 셋만큼 강하지 않다고도 하구요. ㅠㅠ(답변하기 위해 다시 귀기울여서 들었습니다. 여자분들 처음부터 끝까지 표정이 안 좋은게 마음에 걸렸는데, 덕분에 다시 들어보니, 밴드 연주가 과해서 때문에 노래 감상하기 어려워서란걸 알게 됐습니다.)

@augu8t139 6 лет назад

아휴 그렇군요...ㅠㅠ 저는 보컬 부분에서 너무 목소리가 세다는 식으로 이야기하는 것 같길래 왜이렇게 성재에게 안 좋은 말만 하나ㅠㅠ 걱정했는 데 그래도 생각보다 심하게 말하지는 않았...그래도 상처는 상처네요. 우리 애기 실력 많이 늘었는데....답변 감사합니다.^^

@user-ro7xl1vn8h 4 года назад

@@augu8t139 아니요. 처음부터 끝까지 삐딱한 자세로 비난했습니다. 성재뿐만 아니라 다요. 음악감상 하는데 과자같은거 씹으면서 악기소리에 목소리가 안들린다고 하고, 창섭이한텐 변성기 안 온 애 같다고 하고, 현식이한텐 지르는 거 듣기 싫다고 하고. 적당한 비판이라고 생각할 수 있는데 말하는 톤 보면 상당히 비꼬아가면서 까내리려는 의도밖에 안보입니다

@aqilabadr6187 6 лет назад

I really want you guys to react to BtoB reserved and quiet idol 😂😂

@adfdasfdas 3 года назад

진짜 짜증나는 리뷰다... 할많하않 하

@rongxuantan5406 6 лет назад

Eunkwang's 3rd round performance on king of masked singer! *if you do react to that performance though just take note that the video on mbc's channel is not actually the full version*

@MrAmmaralirocks1 6 лет назад

DBSK - Love in the ice, Bolero, Tonight, all live.

@user-mi6yg6md4t 4 года назад

기본적으로 리액션할 자세자체가 안되어 있습니다. 어느 누가 뭘 쩝쩝대면서 먹는 동시에 말하는 걸 보고 싶겠습니까? 모르면 가만히 있으면 중간이라도 간다는 말이 바로 생각나는 영상입니다. 가요라는 장르나 곡 자체에 대한 이해도 하나도 없는 상태에서 그저 자기 잘났다고 다른 가수 까내리는 것도 못봐주겠고, 솔직히 비투비가 보기전에 영상내렸으면 좋겠을 정도입니다. 초면에 반말하는 거 상당히 안좋아해서 저도 존댓말로 쓰고 있지만 그조차도 기분 더러운 영상이네요^^

@kol9947 6 лет назад

자기들이 뭔데 저렇게 호되게 까대시는지ㅋㅋㅋㅋ성재는 이미 목소리만으로 바르고 들어가는데 '이'를 왜저렇게 내냐부터해서 음이 어떻다 너무 과장한다 너무 떤다 각 보컬마다 개성이있는거지 자기들 입맛에 안맞는다고 까는 클라스보소 세상 노래의 신 납셨네 그리고 목소리가 안들린다 곡이 어떻네 이런 소리하는데 와 저걸 1위로 뽑은 방청객들은 그럼 귀가 어떻게 됐냐? 진심 극혐영상이네

@user-jw5xn5ss5e 3 года назад

4:37 ~ 5:28 아니 영어를 모르는데 그냥 기분 나쁘네 집중안하고 비아냥거리는거같고 무시하는거 같음 저 부분 다른사람 영상없나? 차라리 다른분들로 넣지 저부분이 하이라이트인데;; 먹으면서 집중 안하고 수다나 떨다가 높은음 나오면 그때 한번 듣는거같거같네

@user-jw5xn5ss5e 3 года назад

그리고 이럴거면 왜 케이팝 영상을 찍는거임 이럴거면 지들 나라꺼 찍으셈 기분 나쁘니까

@luna-ox7tu 6 лет назад

Please react to another stage of this group in the same show. The title of the song is "under the sky". That stage was really good, too.

@nanhic95 6 лет назад

I kinda wish they would watch an entire episode. They don't have to react to it but just watching an episode they could understand the concept of the show as well as be introduced to the other kind of singers Korea has, because it's not all the time that the idol singers are the best of the episode. They would also hear a small clip of the song they're remaking so they can hear the different arrangements the singer has done.

@cynkdf6241 6 лет назад

+Debanhi Cespedes Good suggestion. Actually while Immortal Songs 2 started with idol singers in the line-up, the line-ups on IS2 nowadays often have at most only one or two idol groups/soloists. As for an entire episode of IS2, I'd recommend something along the lines of the Seven Legends Special - ru-vid.com/video/%D0%B2%D0%B8%D0%B4%D0%B5%D0%BE-nL4OHELLMkg.html&list=PLub1fgILdp6MZZKouEuxJ2ax7N0idaZFk&index=2

@soyoungkim9536 6 лет назад

btob is the best . they have best vocals . 😇 and every single member. can sing really very well.

@tinajee4534 5 лет назад

"I dont like that scream" seriously?? Okay then plz let us know why and how did you think that was s.c.r.e.a.m??huh

@caythieo5832 6 лет назад

When it comes to BtoB's vocaline, the sync high note of I'll be your man is all I can think of.... Sadly the besr live version I found so far (on kiss the radio) doesn't contain all 4 high note singer. Still soooooo amazing?

@godot4105 6 лет назад

Watching this reaction, it gives me a contented feeling that, even though BTOB has been regarded by many as great singers, they still have more room to grow/improve. It somehow make me more excited that BtoB as a group can still be greater than their current condition. :)

@olivyutza 6 лет назад

You know... you shouldn't treat people in this channel like gods... It doesn't mean they are always right just because they study music...

@jakajan3187 4 года назад

Clyo VII true. their preferences have obviously clouded their judgement.

@joselinnquintero118 2 года назад

How can you appreciate this masterpiece if you keep talking all the time? So rude.

@n5909 3 года назад

I don’t think they deserved this kind of negative reactions when the majority of the professional reactors in youtube praises their voices... where are all this comments coming from?

@Dolunaylar6 3 года назад

Omg that girl eating gave me nerve :// I mean what’s wrong with the guy who said I don’t like the guy on the left! Seriously!!! I’ve just knew that there are actually people who doesn’t like sungjae :))!! Our precious cute maknae xx

@xiruochen971 5 лет назад

This video makes me realize that I will probably stan BTOB forever. Because usually when people don't like the group I like that much, I'm like ok fine it's your choice. But this time I literally want to say WHAT THE HELL YOU ARE DEAF OR WHAT??? lol no offense just want to say its funny seeing myself finally being emotional for a KPOP group. Thanks guys

@wheenona 6 лет назад

YES MORE LOVE FOR EUNKWANG. I wish this performance shows off Changsub's vocals more because I think he has one of the most unique vocal tones in K-Pop. But all of BTOB is talented so pls stan them

@King_Jonghyun 6 лет назад

MAKE THEM REACT TO EUNKWANG LIVE!!