I believe Boa is often considered a top vocalist in SM, I've seen many say she's better than Taeyeon and Wendy (although they're all so good there's no need to compare I just mean she would be considered in the same list here)
There's a reason why Ningning wasn't here in the first unit of GOT. Adding all main vocals might not be good since they might overlap with each other vocals. She will have her time in the 2nd rotation of GOT. Just wait her there. Karina and Winter literally fits the songs.
[Karina] You must step back eodel eodel bwa neo gamhi nugurago nal jekkyeo [BoA] ijjeumeseo mulleonago ip danneunge joeulgeol anim eodi hanbeon gieo ollawa bodeonga [Seulgi] neol jjaksarangeul haesseonni sokkupjangnancheoreom eoril ttae [Taeyeon] enganhi kkireul jom kkireul jom kkireul jom nega buryeotgenni sositjeok chueok pari geuri jaeminni [Wendy] nae namjan jigeum Another level neo ttawin kkumdo mot kkul Level [Winter] nal gajin geureon Next level bodasipi Another level [Hyoyeon] Don’t bring it to me kkeojyeojwo [All] nae geoeseo son tte neo [Karina] Step back Step back [All] dasi taeeonado andoelgeol [Karina] Step back Step back [BoA] chakan namjadeurege neoneun dokbae gateun geot masilsurok oerowo [All] He’s sick and tired everyday neomji mara Border line [Hyoyeon] Step back Step back [All] nega bibil gosi aniya [Hyoyeon] Step back Step back [Seulgi] jeouljillo garin geon chamji mothal gabyeoun ne maeumilgeol [All] He’s sick and tired everyday [Hyoyeon] geureondago nege doena deureobwa sangsangboda neo gateun aedeuri mankin mana [Karina] geureogeona malgeona sesangeun neoreul ppaego doraga doraga [Taeyeon / Winter] You gotta get a good mind [BoA] Are you looking for fun [Hyoyeon] jaemireul tto channi [BoA] houiro dagawa [Hyoyeon] imi gyesan kkeunna [Wendy] gonghaesangui bomulseoneul bogirado han deut [Karina] mak deuridae [Wendy] sijakae Transaction [Seulgi] neon jom gamdang mothal Level segyega mudaein Our Level [Taeyeon] nae gyeoteseoya ganeung Level bodasipi Another level [BoA] Don’t bring it to me kkeojyeojwo [All] nae geoeseo son tte neo [Seulgi] Step back Step back [All] dasi taeeonado andoelgeol [Seulgi] Step back Step back [Winter] chakan namjadeurege neoneun dokbae gateun geot masilsurok oerowo [All] He’s sick and tired everyday neomji mara Border line [Karina] Step back Step back [All] nega bibil gosi aniya [Karina] Step back Step back [Taeyeon] jeouljillo garin geon chamji mothal gabyeoun ne maeumilgeol [All] He’s sick and tired everyday [BoA] geuwa hamkkehaetdeon sumaneun naldeul ne jangnan gateun yuhoge heundeulliji ana [Winter] sarangiran gamjeongeul georaehaneun geon Too much [Wendy] ije geuman kkeojyeo doraga ne segye dasineun chakgageun malgo [Karina] namjadeul da ttokgata naega tteumyeon siseonjipjung yeogijeogi Flash teojyeo [Winter] jjigeora jjigeora jjigeora [Hyoyeon] sangsangeun neoui Freedom gajigaji hagi jeone sokbuteo Build up deo nagamyeon neon jom dachyeo [BoA] Girls Bring it on [All] Step back Step back Step back Silly girl! [Seulgi] The only girl who live in a dream [All] Step back Step back Step back Silly girl! [Taeyeon] nae apeseo jom bikyeojwo Yeah [Winter] Don’t bring it to me kkeojyeojwo [All] nae geoeseo son tte neo [Hyoyeon] Step back Step back [All] dasi taeeonado andoelgeol [Hyoyeon] Step back Step back [Wendy] chakan namjadeurege neoneun dokbae gateun geot masilsurok oerowo [All] He’s sick and tired everyday neomji mara Border line [Winter] Step back Step back nega bibil gosi aniya [Winter] Step back Step back [BoA] jeouljillo garin geon chamji mothal gabyeoun ne maeumilgeol [All] He’s sick and tired everyday
i must say 4th gen ace winter is now on top with the most powerful earlier gen vocals!!! BRUH 4TH GEN ACE WINTER SITTING THE SAME TABLE WITH THE LEGENDS OF ALL LEGENDS
Isn’t Ningning main vocal tho? I mean I guess they have no positions but I think on a technical level Ningning has better technique and control and Winter
could you guys just stop bringing her up it’s chosen to be winter and karina. The ones didnt join The production of this song, May have another chance to appear in the comeback.
there will be a time, and i think there will be a reason why SM prefers winter to Ningning because Ningning already had two projects at that time, imagine if Ningning was replaced by winter then she was the only one who didn't have a project at all and fans would hate, especially winter fans because they felt unfair. ...so I think SM is trying to promote their rookie idols in a way that is fair to them
Bruh y'all are hating on Aespa and compare them with Nmixx. All of this cause Aespa don't sing live, Giselle's scandal, Karina's surgery, and Ningning being called as 4th gen's vocalist (not an opinion but a fact). People are stupid these days like no one told to love them, just respect them and shut your mouth it isen't complicated. If you know how much people i fought today👩🦲👍
FROM BOA TO AESPA. SERVES THE TALENTS OF DIFFERENT IDOLS FROM DIFFERENT GENERATION. THAT COLLAB THAT WE DIDN'T EXPECT WE WILL GET. I HOPE SM WILL LET THEM PERFORM IT IN MUSIC AWARDS OR SHOW.
i always didn’t understand ppl who thought winter can be the main vocalist of aespa but thanks to this song i realised that she has that special pitch in her voice just like in 1:55 😩💕☁️
amazing how the mind forces me to think there are still beats, it's like my head is trying to put the beats because i listened to the beat version so much
If anything listening to this Acapella makes me appreciate the song alot more. SM knew exactly what they wanted when picking out this track - vocals, vocals, and vocals.