Тёмный

[CLEAN MR Removed] 211231 aespa (에스파) Dreams Come True | 2021 MBC Song Festival MR제거 

BHK MR Removed
Подписаться 68 тыс.
Просмотров 414 тыс.
50% 1

Опубликовано:

 

31 окт 2024

Поделиться:

Ссылка:

Скачать:

Готовим ссылку...

Добавить в:

Мой плейлист
Посмотреть позже
Комментарии : 1,3 тыс.   
@BHKMRRemoved
@BHKMRRemoved 2 года назад
Happy New Year!! May all our dreams come true!✨ If you are new in this channel, subscribe, like and turn on your bell of notifications for you not lose any MR Removed like aespa's that I post! Thanks for watching!!
@xyzran
@xyzran 2 года назад
This live?
@karylleonce
@karylleonce 2 года назад
@@xyzran nope
@cynthiafransisca3531
@cynthiafransisca3531 2 года назад
@@xyzran this is live at the end of the song winter’s mic didnt work well so she didnt sing the last part
@restwell7261
@restwell7261 2 года назад
This is live or no?
@bruno_malta13
@bruno_malta13 2 года назад
praying for blackpink's comeback
@kangyoungk
@kangyoungk 2 года назад
보아님이 왜 닝닝이한테 성대에 확성기 달렸냐고 했던 이유를 알 것 같다.. 성량이나 전체적인 밸런스가 닝닝이가 진짜 안정적이네.. 꿀보이스
@mintykookieee
@mintykookieee 2 года назад
👍✨
@네에-t2l
@네에-t2l 2 года назад
이거 라이브 ar임
@voxiomfighter
@voxiomfighter 2 года назад
@@네에-t2l 당연히 ar 이지
@voxiomfighter
@voxiomfighter 2 года назад
얘네는 욕 먹는거 감수해서라도 성대 보호할 필요가 있음
@네에-t2l
@네에-t2l 2 года назад
@@voxiomfighter ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ 개웃기네 실력파 가수들이 얼마나 많은데…ㅠ 그 사람들 올 립싱크 하는 거 봄?
@amazing-cd9bf
@amazing-cd9bf 2 года назад
그러니까 윈터라는 친구는 댄스 페스티벌을 통해 캐스팅했다구요? 뽑아놓고 보니 유영진이 성대로 낳은 딸이라는 평가를 받는다니...캐스팅 디렉터 당신은 대체....
@구-t1i
@구-t1i 2 года назад
아니 스엠은 왜 라이브를 안 시키지 실력은 충분할 텐데
@오아-p9r
@오아-p9r 2 года назад
본방 봤으면 알겠지만 이거 라이브아님. 라이브처럼 녹음한거임. 엔시티가 무대마다 녹음하는거랑 똑같음. 숨소리 들어갔다고 라이븐가..; 저렇게 목소리가 일정하게 나온다는것 자체가 라이브 아니라는거임
@행복-p7n
@행복-p7n 2 года назад
ㅇㅈ 이거 라이브 아님... 라이브처럼 들리게 사전녹음한거임. 춤 추면서 라이브 잘하는 보아도 여자친구도 아이유도 라이브하면 이렇게 소리가 완전하게 일정하지는 않아요 ㅠㅠ
@ledayng3345
@ledayng3345 2 года назад
카리나음색너무좋다
@ineedsomemoneyyy
@ineedsomemoneyyy 2 года назад
Can't deny Giselle's voice too. She also slayed the rap part
@Mimi-hw5pm
@Mimi-hw5pm 2 года назад
her vocals are sooo underrated
@gabbbsworld
@gabbbsworld 2 года назад
@sloth tbh,i feel like karina should be the sub vocal,since she has shown more powerfull notes and middle/high notes than gisselle,or maybe SM just does'nt wanna give gisselle powerful notes idk
@jihan8367
@jihan8367 2 года назад
@@gabbbsworld that's okay since they mentioned before that they don't have any official positions except for the leader position so anyone can switch roles i think ^^
@gabbbsworld
@gabbbsworld 2 года назад
@@jihan8367 they have offical positions iirc ,they just dont like being categorized sjnce they are alk all rounders i think, iirc their positions are Karian: main dancer,lead rapper,leader,face of the group(if not , i think it was winter) winter: lead vocalist,visual ningning: main vocalist, maknae giselle: main rapper,vocalist/sub vocal
@melisacaceres8740
@melisacaceres8740 2 года назад
It looks like BoA loved her voice because she highlighted it so much on this remake
@yeolii2680
@yeolii2680 2 года назад
Sebagai yang ngikutin aespa dari awal, aespa prerecord ataupun tidak sangat sulit membedakan, karena suara mereka khususnya winter ningning seperti full mic menggema gitu, liat aja saat dia nyanyi di radio atau knowing brother, mmtg, recording dct kemarin² ambil nafas aja baik artikulasi nya, dan jika kamu the real smstan kamu pasti tau boa dan Sunbae lainya dilatih nyanyi sambil lari demi stabil pernafasan. Mau prerecord atau tidak suara mereka bagus banget, karena ya gimana ya masa mau ragu sama anaknya Bada sama Yoo young jin. Kuharap kedepannya aespa bisa membungkam telak para yang bilang aespa selalu lipsing. Next cb comeback ke yuhiyeol book mantap tuh
@cuapcuapahoy1373
@cuapcuapahoy1373 2 года назад
Emang Risiko si debut terlalu sempurna
@bettyzoe7506
@bettyzoe7506 2 года назад
Bernyanyilah kamu sampe kaya aespa selalu dikira lipsync 😂😂 Saking bagusnya
@fullofstars3721
@fullofstars3721 2 года назад
s7 nih, sampe skrg gbs bedain mana aespa live sing sm ga
@dora2378
@dora2378 2 года назад
Iya nih
@yeolii2680
@yeolii2680 2 года назад
Iya ber 4, sm milih gak main2 meskipun cuma ber4. Yang bener2 yakin high note live liat deh yang all i want for Christmas kemarin di sbs, winter Ningning dg mudah nya ambil highnote sambil senyum ke kamera. Sama winter spoiler nyanyi bait dreams come true di acara sama heechul itu suaranya jelas bgt ru-vid.comv44GWhI34F8?feature=share
@공주-d3f
@공주-d3f 2 года назад
엠알제거하니까 카리나 목소리 진짜 잘들린다.. 카리나 음색 진짜 미쳤음.. 라이브 하나도 빠짐없이 잘하는 걸그룹 흔치 않은데..
@honeyfunny1150
@honeyfunny1150 2 года назад
이건 누가봐도 ar인데용.. 에스파 실력은 좋아도 라이브는 잘 안 하던데..
@꼬밍쓰-m1r
@꼬밍쓰-m1r 2 года назад
@@honeyfunny1150 AR같긴한데 중간중간 하압! 소리가 조금씩 들리는것 같아요오..!! 개인적인 생각입니닷!!
@usersql
@usersql 2 года назад
@@꼬밍쓰-m1r 그니까 라이브ar이에요 라이브처럼들리게 따로 녹음하는거예요 원래실력이되니까 녹음도저렇게되는거겟져
@꼬밍쓰-m1r
@꼬밍쓰-m1r 2 года назад
@@usersql 옹 감사합니다
@갸악-j5f
@갸악-j5f 2 года назад
ar이든말든... 라이브실력 좋은건 이미 다 알지않나
@user-wv7yg7oo6n
@user-wv7yg7oo6n 2 года назад
어느 멤버하나 못하는 사람이 없네 다들 너무 잘한다
@spotakerjeo5364
@spotakerjeo5364 2 года назад
Yes its true 😭
@mikrocosmos7759
@mikrocosmos7759 2 года назад
Ar 이니까 당연히 잘하는것처럼 들리겠지ㅋㅋㅋㅋ
@마다-e6t
@마다-e6t 2 года назад
그래도 잘 하는 건 사실임... 다 잘 하던데
@user-mo2bb8ip2d
@user-mo2bb8ip2d 2 года назад
@@mikrocosmos7759 방탄 인장 달고 그러지마 ㅠ
@잠만-c8r
@잠만-c8r 2 года назад
사녹이라며,, 이렇게 올리면 진짜 춤추면서 부른 줄 알았네
@ssageva
@ssageva 2 года назад
NINGNING DESERVE THE WORLD LIKEE HEARRRRRR HER VOCALS !!!!!!!!!!!!!!
@케이시-q4o
@케이시-q4o 2 года назад
whether this is prerecorded or not, we can't deny the fact that aespa has the best vocals in 4th gen girl groups. i love their voices so much!!!
@lilnai9859
@lilnai9859 2 года назад
@Skrtskrt Ncity well its mean shes really good at lipsing
@balakajan151
@balakajan151 2 года назад
@@lilnai9859 LIPSYNCH, LIPSYNCH okay? not lipsing. Before you come crying here make sure you know it right.
@elyn1217
@elyn1217 2 года назад
@@lilnai9859 lol she's not
@noorhussain9033
@noorhussain9033 2 года назад
@@lilnai9859 u can hear them breathe its not pre recorded
@eunham599
@eunham599 2 года назад
@@noorhussain9033 so um, if they don't breathe while pre-recordings, how can they sing 😭 or even live at all 😭
@Kiki-ce6zk
@Kiki-ce6zk 2 года назад
i’m totally shook of their vocals like i’ve never seen a gg having all these angels voice like omg it’s just incredible
@gold_stone_S2
@gold_stone_S2 2 года назад
라이브든 사녹이든 넷 다 노래 잘하는건 인정해야함,,, 난 가만히 서있어도 저렇게 못 부르니,,,
@user-pp2qi1hb5p
@user-pp2qi1hb5p 2 года назад
와 고음부분에서 소름이 진짜ㅋㅋㅋ 에스파는 꼭 성공한다 이장도 실력에 지금 올라온 자리가 너무 낮다생각함
@푸들-h9s
@푸들-h9s 2 года назад
낮지는않은것같은데.. 데뷔한지 얼마되지도않았는데
@차녁이-s8o
@차녁이-s8o 2 года назад
얼마나 더 성공해야돼...
@user-p1dmdisiw
@user-p1dmdisiw 2 года назад
신인상 다 쓸어가는 거 보면 4세대 중에서는 탑인 거 같음
@user-vk7kx8cq6r
@user-vk7kx8cq6r 2 года назад
솔직히 누가봐도 라이브 아니잖아
@뭐하지닉-v9b
@뭐하지닉-v9b 2 года назад
에스파팬이지만 이건 라이브아니고 사전녹음인듯 합니다. 다들 귀 수준높아서 다 구분 하실듯.. 라디오같은데서 라이브하는거 보시면 라이브실력 알수있어요
@Nam_Aeri
@Nam_Aeri 2 года назад
근데 충격적이게도 구분못하는 사람들 많더라고요 무지성 팬채널 몇군데보면 거의 종교수준임...
@째니-i8k
@째니-i8k 2 года назад
와 진짜 실력파그룹이다 소름끼쳐
@happ1_ddu
@happ1_ddu 2 года назад
크... 음원이 이 정도면 라이브 진짜 잘 할 텐데 춤추면서 하니까 힘든 거 알고 쉬엄쉬엄하는 거라도 듣고 싶당
@읗-l1i
@읗-l1i 2 года назад
지젤 음색 너무 좋다 …
@y2._xi
@y2._xi 2 года назад
헐 카리나 목소리 진짜 좋다 잘때 옆에서 조곤조곤 동화책 읽어주면 잠이 솔솔 올 것 같은느낌…😴💤물론 다른 멤버들도 목소리 좋아서 죽을뻔..힘내라 짱스파!!!
@tory6143
@tory6143 2 года назад
이게 라이브가 기든 아니든 목소리만 들을수 있어서 난 좋다 핡..귀지가 알아서 걸어나오는기분
@bruno_malta13
@bruno_malta13 2 года назад
Winter next queen of vocals. It's the powerhouse woman voice that Taeyeon and Wendy have too.
@moonlightespt3818
@moonlightespt3818 2 года назад
Ningning comes way closer but Winter is good too
@moalalisa3201
@moalalisa3201 2 года назад
But even all of them never sing live They only live singing at the encore So we cant stan if they can sing while dancing or not
@innerslothamonggus9070
@innerslothamonggus9070 2 года назад
Ning ning be having her own league, like Bada. Nevertheless, I agree.
@zif4557
@zif4557 2 года назад
@@moalalisa3201 We choose to stan who we want 💀
@user-yf1qt1ui4s
@user-yf1qt1ui4s 2 года назад
@@moalalisa3201 this live, MBC banned playback
@cpaintransit86
@cpaintransit86 2 года назад
Karina's voice is full
@yunhosparrot
@yunhosparrot 2 года назад
whether its pre-recorded or not, aespa still has really good vocals!!
@milkyuhnom5925
@milkyuhnom5925 2 года назад
pre recorded doesn’t mean they’re not using their vocals btw, idk why people flipped the og meaning of pre recorded lol
@zahrazarib8947
@zahrazarib8947 2 года назад
i agree, but it's a shame they can't show people that they have a good voice
@popogirljuju
@popogirljuju 2 года назад
와...........엠알 제거 왜 이렇게 잘하냐고ㅠㅠ대박이네....에스파에 빠지겠다
@량여우
@량여우 2 года назад
@@뽀잉뽀잉뽀잉 저건 사녹이에요
@triciapatclemor3838
@triciapatclemor3838 2 года назад
Wow, I don't even care if this is pre-recorded or not. Their voices are just so beautiful.
@katexo-lsong8796
@katexo-lsong8796 2 года назад
exactly.. they have nice voices and they can sing we’ve seen it from their radio and other. guestings. just Knowing Brothers gave us Aespa talent show lol
@nazifaprameswari
@nazifaprameswari 2 года назад
i love karina & ningning voice!!😻😻
@deaintananggraini1205
@deaintananggraini1205 2 года назад
Ningning is the best vocalist
@sheirumi1317
@sheirumi1317 2 года назад
Winter's high notes 🛐💘💘💘
@오공뽄드-u9p
@오공뽄드-u9p 2 года назад
기가막히네... 진짜 아이돌이아니라 가수네...
@taeyeonspa
@taeyeonspa 2 года назад
Ningning 💜
@cpaintransit86
@cpaintransit86 2 года назад
Upon seeing this fancam, Ningning and Karina dance hard. Ningning, the main vocal with amazing dance skills and stability.
@mksalvador4655
@mksalvador4655 2 года назад
i love aespa but they entered the world of performing, and given that they are singers, it's been a year since they debuted and i think it's time to unleash their true voice while performing, i know they can do this but it's just the management's decision, to limit their abilities
@-_--jq9zj
@-_--jq9zj 2 года назад
와 윈터 고음 진짜 미쳤다
@ly_yurae
@ly_yurae 2 года назад
Vokal dari sm jangan diragukan lagi pasti stabil dan bagus
@imabarbiegirlinthebarbiewo8943
@imabarbiegirlinthebarbiewo8943 2 года назад
NINGNING THO OMG HOW I WISH SHE CAN DO THE HIGHNOTES
@링이-p9g
@링이-p9g 2 года назад
에셈은 엔시티도 그렇고 걍 무대용 라이브 엠알 녹음한 거 틀고 라이브 안 시킴 .. 언제부터인지는 모르겠지만 20년도쯤? 그 전 무대들 엠알 제거만 봐도 숨소리 다 들리고 라이브 하는 거 다 티났는데 왜 바꿨는지 모르겠음 .. 잘하는 거 아는데 애매하게 하지말고 걍 예전처럼 해줬으면 좋겠다 너무 답답함 ㅜ
@임창균1895번째머리카
@임창균1895번째머리카 2 года назад
가요대전은 보통 다 립싱크 해요
@링이-p9g
@링이-p9g 2 года назад
@@임창균1895번째머리카 음방에서도 립싱크 하는 걸로 알고있어요..ㅜㅜ
@minjeongutted
@minjeongutted 2 года назад
Queens rocking as always, those who say they only use playback will see them in the music recordings. They were born with an autotune in their throat. TREAD ON MOMMIES
@deidarasenpai.4396
@deidarasenpai.4396 2 года назад
Winter's voice is so clear and strong
@user-4264L
@user-4264L 2 года назад
karina voice is magnetic
@Vvitaktori
@Vvitaktori 2 года назад
이제 라이브 ar 이런거 말고 진짜 라이브 해줄때도 되지 않았나... 실력 좋은거 아는데 도대체 왜 라이브를 안하는지 ㅠ
@지힝-n1g
@지힝-n1g 2 года назад
춤추면서 잘하지 못하겠지
@youtubeisntallowingmetocom9062
@youtubeisntallowingmetocom9062 2 года назад
If people are still saying they can't sing live, I hope they watch the behind the scenes recording video
@blinkifyouareablink8785
@blinkifyouareablink8785 2 года назад
They are queen in 4th gen when it comes to vocals
@youtubeisntallowingmetocom9062
@youtubeisntallowingmetocom9062 2 года назад
@@blinkifyouareablink8785 YES
@ekaass1735
@ekaass1735 2 года назад
Where can I watch the video? Can you give me the link?
@AB-yk2pq
@AB-yk2pq 2 года назад
@@ekaass1735 ru-vid.com/video/%D0%B2%D0%B8%D0%B4%D0%B5%D0%BE-85i3GC9AVfU.html Here they shared recording process
@juno1765
@juno1765 2 года назад
BUT WE WANT TO HEAR THEM SING WHILE DANCING, THAT'S THE PROBLEM.
@김도희-n6g
@김도희-n6g 2 года назад
윈터 미쳤다
@catbear7534
@catbear7534 2 года назад
I love winter's voice. So beautiful
@najwaekafifi2019
@najwaekafifi2019 2 года назад
Hai
@단나루리
@단나루리 2 года назад
이거 사전녹음이에요 이거 춤추면서 라이브로 부른거 아니고 립.싱.크 라고요!
@채아-s7q
@채아-s7q 2 года назад
그래서 어쩌라구요ㅋ
@marinmarin2022
@marinmarin2022 Год назад
어쩐지 ㅋㅋㅋ
@myluv3912
@myluv3912 2 года назад
내가 에스파 팬이지만 라이브 아님..ㅇㅇ 음방 ㅇmr제거가 이렇게 깨끗할수가 없음 애초에 아무리 잘해도
@Podojamong
@Podojamong 2 года назад
어쩐지 음원이랑 너무 똑같드라. 애드립까지 똑같아서 이상하다 했음
@뉴뉴-s2m
@뉴뉴-s2m 2 года назад
이거 라이브라고 믿는 분들은 스테이씨랑 있지 엠알제거 보고 오세요 춤추면서 부르는데 숨소리 흔들림 하나도 없는게 말이 안됨ㅋㅋ
@오상혁-y2y
@오상혁-y2y 2 года назад
뭐래 이건 찐이야
@Nam_Aeri
@Nam_Aeri 2 года назад
ㄹㅇ 천상계인 비욘세도 저렇게는 못부르는데 무지성 빠들은 라이브라고 굳게믿고있누
@larasdeaziska248
@larasdeaziska248 2 года назад
I adore Ningning and Winter soo much in term of vocal. Actually, all of Aespa member has such a great vocal, but who can deny that Ningning and Winter is amaaaazinggg!
@nice9251
@nice9251 2 года назад
야 진짜 개 잘부르네 음정이 진짜 너무 좋다~~~~
@user-eb6sq7gv7p
@user-eb6sq7gv7p 2 года назад
사녹이지만..진짜 마이로서 너무 자랑스러워ㅜㅜ 데뷔한지 1년밖에 안 됐는데 이렇게 잘하면 2~3년 뒤에는 얼마나 잘 할지 기대됨
@shellakrisnaayuningtyas1259
@shellakrisnaayuningtyas1259 2 года назад
Winter voice cute ,fresh and strong
@quynhphan4282
@quynhphan4282 2 года назад
Ningning vocal 😍😍😍
@sweetcheezyyy824
@sweetcheezyyy824 2 года назад
Suara mereka sangat bagus!!
@World0fme_
@World0fme_ 2 года назад
iya
@joenathanz7474
@joenathanz7474 2 года назад
Iya wong pre record
@ody5305
@ody5305 2 года назад
@@joenathanz7474 gak pre record pun suara mereka bagus banget, btw ini live, karina bilang sendiri di interview
@joenathanz7474
@joenathanz7474 2 года назад
@@ody5305 masa iya live ga ada ambil nafas samsek? Mulus kayak jalan tol. Sekelas SES aja masih engap loh.
@amboybanget4666
@amboybanget4666 2 года назад
@@joenathanz7474 itu kedengeran anjir ambil napas
@pthsm_
@pthsm_ 2 года назад
So clean 🤩 Happy New Year 🎊
@setanainterneteverdade7352
@setanainterneteverdade7352 2 года назад
I like to read the comments on Aespa's videos because almost 100% of them are questioning whether it's a live or pre-recorded, and regardless of what the person thinks they all agree they have the best 4th Generation locations kkklkkk
@suckmyD-c8f
@suckmyD-c8f 2 года назад
저게 라이브야..? 에이알인줄 진짜 대단하다
@user-yf1qt1ui4s
@user-yf1qt1ui4s 2 года назад
Yes, this live
@jkim4729
@jkim4729 2 года назад
누가봐도 사전 녹음한거 튼건데.. 진짜 모르고 말하는건가? 김나박이가 앉아서 노래불러도 엠알이 이것보다 깔끔하진않을겁니다
@yeho_0220
@yeho_0220 2 года назад
@@jkim4729 그럼 마지막 윈터파트에선 왜 안들렸죠?
@user-yf1qt1ui4s
@user-yf1qt1ui4s 2 года назад
@@jkim4729 this live
@jkim4729
@jkim4729 2 года назад
@@yeho_0220 사전 녹음 과정에서 잘못된게 있었나보죠 .. 아니 진짜 이게 라이브로 들리십니까..? 진지하게..? 김범수, 나얼, 박효신, 이수가 앉아서 노래 불러도 이것보다 안깔끔하다구요 ㅋㅋㅋㅋ 심지어 춤추며 부르는데, 숨소리가 단 한번 안들리네요
@BlueBird-pc2gd
@BlueBird-pc2gd 2 года назад
Ningning is my bias and Karina is my bias wrecker cz her runs r very pretty but after hearing this, i can say Giselle's vocal is very strong and beautiful too..she can be a lead vocalist in any other groups ❤️
@Cerezxmel
@Cerezxmel 2 года назад
0:19 Esta parte es simplemente preciosa🛐✨
@happydays2215
@happydays2215 2 года назад
아니 뭔 무대마다 ar이야ㅠㅠ 너네 노래잘하는거 알아 그니까 무대 라이브좀 보여주면 안되냐??
@putriaqilah7736
@putriaqilah7736 2 года назад
Aespa the best
@littlepear6728
@littlepear6728 2 года назад
WINTER'S HIGHNOTE JUST SCREAMMMMMSSS POWEERRRR, SHE DEFINITELY 4TH GEN ACE
@diamonda3253
@diamonda3253 2 года назад
It’s not even live though
@crazyinnie
@crazyinnie 2 года назад
Pre recorded thi
@atleti_jun
@atleti_jun 2 года назад
넘좋다
@Candaceflynnn25
@Candaceflynnn25 2 года назад
Winter your honey voice 💕😩
@돈갚아칠덕아
@돈갚아칠덕아 2 года назад
닝닝 미쳤네ㅠㅠㅠ 너무 잘해
@ae-kimey9094
@ae-kimey9094 2 года назад
3:13 we can't hear the voice of winter, but in the mv we can see that it's winter part. So, I'm hoping this is a live
@Yo-pg1lu
@Yo-pg1lu 2 года назад
Yes, its live
@user-yf1qt1ui4s
@user-yf1qt1ui4s 2 года назад
Yass, this live
@王心淋醬油
@王心淋醬油 2 года назад
This isn’t live but they still good at vocals
@user-yf1qt1ui4s
@user-yf1qt1ui4s 2 года назад
@@Yo-pg1lu this live
@multistan_kpop270
@multistan_kpop270 2 года назад
Ig it's pre recorded but these girls can sing live
@wheeinthepooh3906
@wheeinthepooh3906 2 года назад
Pre recorded or not, idc. I watched how they recorded this song, it just shows that their vocals are really on another level. I won't doubt them, they are very talented and they already proved it
@diannss7980
@diannss7980 2 года назад
This is live performance
@aranyamamaniolimpia7104
@aranyamamaniolimpia7104 2 года назад
Sm debe dejarlas cantar en vivo😩
@hyeonist
@hyeonist 2 года назад
@@diannss7980 no, there's no breath or amy error, when idols are singing live they have a heavy breath on the microphone because of the dance and they sometimes make mistakes like the lyrics or when to sing the lines
@sarahrubico6606
@sarahrubico6606 2 года назад
@@hyeonist this is my thought too. Not hating.
@NARIEZ
@NARIEZ 2 года назад
Winter & Ningning 😍
@만사종윤서
@만사종윤서 2 года назад
이게 에스파지
@rexmawara6228
@rexmawara6228 2 года назад
Winter vocal is so clear😍
@uknowwho03
@uknowwho03 2 года назад
yeaaah
@alyalathifah3374
@alyalathifah3374 2 года назад
@ㅇㅇ Yes!
@diamonda3253
@diamonda3253 2 года назад
Because it’s not live
@crazyinnie
@crazyinnie 2 года назад
Because it's not live HAHAHAHAHA
@rexmawara6228
@rexmawara6228 2 года назад
keep on jealous
@dareeeeeeee6989
@dareeeeeeee6989 2 года назад
Karina's vocals tho😍
@agunggumelar6806
@agunggumelar6806 2 года назад
Winter vocal ❤️ best
@nennieeiee4911
@nennieeiee4911 2 года назад
Their voice are gorgeous
@ntsya2958
@ntsya2958 2 года назад
2:14 KARINAAAAA
@nawanglsk1723
@nawanglsk1723 2 года назад
Aespa is the best
@비누-q4l
@비누-q4l 2 года назад
I agree
@nennieeiee4911
@nennieeiee4911 2 года назад
My girls I'm literally so proud
@정유진-x3v1f
@정유진-x3v1f 2 года назад
아니왤케잘해;카리나음색너무좋아ㅠㅠㅠ
@삼냥이집사-b8s
@삼냥이집사-b8s Год назад
ses 고정팬으로써.. 와... 이 노래 리메이크 되서 좋았는데 라이브 심지어 ,mr제거 실화입니까 ㅋㅋ 역시 실력파! 멋있네요!
@행복하자-n9p
@행복하자-n9p 2 года назад
진짜 잘하네~~
@yuki-vz2zz
@yuki-vz2zz 2 года назад
저젤 발음 진짜 쫀독 하다..
@littlest..
@littlest.. 2 года назад
karina’s deep voice 💔💔
@이경민-o7l
@이경민-o7l 2 года назад
그냥 다른말 필요없이 ,, 춤을추면서 저렇게 부른다는 자체가 너무 대단하다고 생각함 ...
@ghjkasdf476
@ghjkasdf476 2 года назад
​@@선예-h5f 춤만 추는건 저쪽 아이돌 장원영이 그러지 않나 ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ
@네에-t2l
@네에-t2l 2 года назад
@@ghjkasdf476얜 뭔 헛소리임 지가 다짜고짜 장원영 끌어와놓고선 ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ 그래서 선예가 에스파나 장원영이나 똑같다고 했는데 본인이 이해를 못했으면서 딴소리하네 멍청함에 박수를 아 그리고 너 글 ㅈㄴ 못 씀
@ghjkasdf476
@ghjkasdf476 2 года назад
@@네에-t2l 그래~ 실력도 없는 아이돌 실컷 옹호하고다녀라~ ru-vid.com/video/%D0%B2%D0%B8%D0%B4%D0%B5%D0%BE-XrI_7r3dkXM.html ru-vid.com/video/%D0%B2%D0%B8%D0%B4%D0%B5%D0%BE-97_nGaJxrsw.html 이걸보고도 와~ 잘한다~ 하면서 옹호하면 답없는놈이지 ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ
@네에-t2l
@네에-t2l 2 года назад
@@ghjkasdf476 도대체 누가 옹호함…? 이해력 진짜 후달리는구나… 이렇게 멍청한 놈은 또 오랜만에 만나네 ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ 장원영이나 에스파나 립싱크돌인 건 똑같다는 말이 이해가 안돼…?
@ghjkasdf476
@ghjkasdf476 2 года назад
@@네에-t2l 립싱크만 주구장창 하는 장원영을 잘한다식으로 쉴드쳐주는게 옹호지 그럼ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ 프사는 일본놈이고 똑같은 립싱크여도 에스파가 더 실력있는데 누가 누굴비교하노 억까충 장원영팬 주제에 ㅋㅋㅋㅋ
@emilymiao5365
@emilymiao5365 2 года назад
I love Ningning soooooo much
@nj5150
@nj5150 2 года назад
Winter's voice 🥺🥰
@thewh0rejumpedout504
@thewh0rejumpedout504 2 года назад
Yes, startin' off my new year with these heavenly vocals 😩👌
@katiemckenzie4972
@katiemckenzie4972 2 года назад
Ningning my girl. That's my girl
@whatyoulookinat2962
@whatyoulookinat2962 2 года назад
giselle vocal😻
@SnowPinkof7Springs
@SnowPinkof7Springs 2 года назад
They are just too perfect 😭
@mintyseouls2496
@mintyseouls2496 2 года назад
Karina's voice is so powerful
@lilac7910
@lilac7910 2 года назад
Ningning so amazing 🤩
@chizukei
@chizukei 2 года назад
aespa nyanyi sanking bagusnya, selalu diragukan live apa nggak haha😂 mau live apa kaga, suaranya bagus bangetttttt. heran sama yg blg "iyalah bgs kan pre record" ya kalo suara dari sananya udh bagus ya bagus aja sihhh wkwkwk🤪
@lilac7910
@lilac7910 2 года назад
Giselle I’m in Twilight zone is iconic
@nennieeiee4911
@nennieeiee4911 2 года назад
Aespa are the queens of 4th generation
@rafiezalpotera2909
@rafiezalpotera2909 2 года назад
I think it's pre record but still they voice such a angelic🦋✨
@user-yf1qt1ui4s
@user-yf1qt1ui4s 2 года назад
This live
@valentinmartinez9632
@valentinmartinez9632 2 года назад
@@user-yf1qt1ui4s I really doubt that
@eunoiavalley2567
@eunoiavalley2567 2 года назад
@@user-yf1qt1ui4s how do u know?
@nadlee9327
@nadlee9327 2 года назад
@@eunoiavalley2567 if you go to their original video of this performance- before the last part winter voice don't come out clearly (maybe the staff lower the mic volume) only hear backtrack so it's live. If you still not believe it, so it's up to you.
@Goldigga5
@Goldigga5 2 года назад
@@nadlee9327 Having a prerecorded backing track doesn’t mean their mics are off completely. The point of prerecorded audio is to give the illusion of a live performance rather than lip syncing to the CD version. It allows them to focus on a good performance for viewers. The girls are relying on the backing audio for this performance, it’s pretty obvious and there’s nothing wrong with that.
@gonexgirl9372
@gonexgirl9372 2 года назад
This is literally pre-recorded they are jumping and moving around like crazy and their voices are all stable like they are singing while standing still. Aespa do have incredible vocals, I know they could easily hit these notes, but they’re not doing that here. I think even if Ariana Grande was to jump and dance around like this her voice wouldn’t be as clear and smooth like a studio recording, it’s called being human
@heavensent1540
@heavensent1540 2 года назад
ican not believe that people actually think its live😭😭😭
@에옹-p8r
@에옹-p8r 2 года назад
ㄷㄷ ㄹㅇ좋다
@alifiahputrisahara
@alifiahputrisahara 2 года назад
Keren banget aespa ❤
@meo.cam.ngo.nghinh
@meo.cam.ngo.nghinh 2 года назад
Their vocal is more stable than I expect. I am so proud of them
@athena_53
@athena_53 2 года назад
It's not live
@iii.n3sss
@iii.n3sss 2 года назад
@@athena_53 even if it’s not live some people cant sing the right notes etc so
@lenanoldor6789
@lenanoldor6789 2 года назад
@@iii.n3sss but those people are not singers, it's not their duty to sing live
@lenanoldor6789
@lenanoldor6789 2 года назад
@@iii.n3sss it's not the girl's fault, they can't chose to sing live or not it's all up to sm
@iii.n3sss
@iii.n3sss 2 года назад
@@lenanoldor6789 yea
@힘힘-n9d
@힘힘-n9d 2 года назад
생 라이브 한 번이라도 대체 언제 해줄건지..... 궁금하네요 무대
Далее
Самое большое защитное стекло
00:43
Re:MASTERPIECE | YouTube Originals
41:36
Просмотров 3,2 млн
[STATION] aespa 에스파 'Dreams Come True' MV
3:41