If you are new in this channel, subscribe, like and turn on your bell of notifications for you not lose any MR Removed like aespa's that I post! Thanks for watching!!
tbh this comeback seems like they started to sing live, but with the use of prerecorded vocals that are much muchhh louder. i mean, kmys that attended their prerecording talked about them live singing +on fancams when the music ends you can hear breathing. anyways, i hope that means they'll keep increasing the volume of their mics each comeback
@@myouimina6385 maybe the back track or pre-recorded is much louder idk for sure but if they lip sync again SM really lose the value of these girls they're so talented
For those keep saying they don't sing live, theey are KMys and even K-netizens say they are singing live. They do a mic test before they performed and their mic was on, and after they performed they thank the audience with the same mic. Dure there is a backup voice in the track but all groups have that about 30-40% is a backup voice but that's normal in a kop groups.
@@anandafathiyyahutami8962 I don't have extreme feelings around this though? Why should I be so bothered about these idols when I dont even know them in real life? 😂 just commenting what seems common sense but not so common to the ignorant fans 🤦♀️
The studio audiences said the girls' mic are on and they can hear them singing during recording.. maybe SM changes their vocals with LAR (Live All Recorded) vocals for the live broadcasting... but regardless Live or LAR (Live All Recorded) vocals.. it is still their voice. but of course we still want to hear them singing live while dancing..
Yes. SM always make LAR for broadcast version. In next level performance we can see they sing live ( in next level performance behind ) but SM put LAR vocal for upload in youtube
@@hoanganhtraninh7831 nope its was pre recorded befor the performance because the shoe sound didnt come from the mic it comed from the simple sound that you hear, cuz the fancam records every sound not just the mic. The mic's weren't on sadly
@@kimmkimmy3006 gosh drama queen entered the comment section 🙄. They sing live. The studio audiences said the girls' mic are on and they can hear them singing during recording.. SM changes their vocals with LAR (Live All Recorded) vocals for the live broadcasting... but regardless Live or LAR (Live All Recorded) vocals.. it is still their voice, but of course we still want to hear them singing live while dancing.. and The fancam ver had sounds of shoes in it so their mic was on
At this point I don't care if they sing live or not I mean we know they can sing so what's the point in always pointing out when they don't sing live am still Loving their music and sound so whatever
I mean, for me personally a big part of fun in stanning an artist is seeing them perform their songs in different ways and hearing live performances with actual vocals. Also I simply think even the girls would enjoy being musicians more if they could actually show it that they are? In the end it's kPOP, it's about music, so if they don't write their songs let them at least sing them
I can’t believe some of y’all think this is live? There’s zero breaths in between? There’s no small mistakes or changes from the original. There’s nothing wrong with idols lip syncing at times imo but denying it is another on another level.
cuz their not singing live lmao, if it was live, u would actually hear some breathing, that also happens to the most stable kpop idols, u just cant accept that they lip sync lmao
I think they are singing live, but the prerecorded sound is still a little off. If you compare their live sound with concerts in America you will also notice that here they are still using pre-recorded in some part, although not as loud as in the previous stage. good job, I know SM artists have amazing voices🥂👍
Do you even know what prerecorded means? Because this comment suggests you don’t. Prerecorded doesn’t mean backing vocals or supporting vocals. It means they recorded themselves singing the song again in the studio, and then lip synced it on stage. There is no live vocals involved.
@@StanChunghaOrGoHome but isn't there an incident where a singer uses a prerecord+Live voice? because I've seen comments like that before, prerecorded but also live. *btw thanks for telling me(人*´∀｀)｡*ﾟ+
Prerecordings are made to sound different. They record the song again in the studio and sing differently to sell the illusion that they are singing live. And it works, delulus like you fall for it every time.
Choosing not to be delusional doesn’t mean we are hating. A lot of people who criticise Aespa for never singing live are stans that believe they can do it. They are more than capable of singing live and constructive criticism is valid.
Idk why sm didn't let them sing live...they are so talented and very easy to sing live..sm so stupid...but..ae don't care cause we know that aeapa live vocal are the best in 4th gen also nmix
I'm sorry but if people keep getting fooled by SM and think this is their live singing they will never make the girls sing. [watch me being called a hater lol], they can sing and it's sad sm won't let them at least live some stages.
Only Aespa get a lot of DEFENSE when they LIPSYNC. It's very different if the one doing the lipsyncing is another artist like IVE, StayC, Weekly or another girl group.They don't get a DEFENSE like Aespa did LIPSYNC. Very pathetic.
What's the point of this mr removed when SM would never let aespa truly sing live. I mean check out Stayc mr removed, that's what called live singing. Their voices must NOT be perfect, cause they DANCE and BREATHE heavily. You can hear them taking breath while singing and sometimes can't really hit those high notes perfectly. That's live singing. Not this. This is pre-recorded mr removed. SM must stop doing this to their idols, damn it.
for mys who are delusional please watch videos from imma stan that on youtube, they post how to tell the difference between live vocals or pre recorded vocals.
@@shiyingteng8723 i dont know if you are a professional in this singing industry but this performance actually live if you compare to other performance anyway stay pressed
@@psnrs yeah me too but i kinda think sm wants her to sound like that that’s why they give these parts to her so that it sounds more powerful or whatever… that’s not good at all for her :/
@@crow3969 frr, i totally agree with you. same with momo from twice, her fake voice does not at all sound cute it sounds bad and its not good for her voice at all. which is so funny with jyp let jeongyeon take hiatus and let her gain weight when usually kpop idols are supposed to be skinny. companies need to learn to take care of idols voice, as singing uses the entire voice, they are the instrument.
@@silverdrew6104 yeah i honestly have no issues with her first eb5 at 3:11 i think it suits the vibe of the song but the sustained one (3:26) is just too much
Some people aren't aware that pre-recorded vocals are mixed in with the instrumental so MR removed actually removes most of the pre-recorded vocals, too. This is live.
It's the first week at music bank, since they didn't perform last week there, so to me, it's "comeback stage prerecorded". I expect full live tomorrow at Music Core, since it's their 2nd week there.
People that think this is actually live 😭😭😭 EDIT: yall in the comments need to chill I ain't hating on the girls but these clearly aren't live vocals 😭😭 you guys really can't tell pre-recorded audio/studio version and live vocals apart can you?
I don't even why this op didn't put live on the other two performances where it was confirmed live and their are literally two videos showing that their mics were on 🤦 and their haters are coming at them again cause their bases if it's live if the op will put a live on the title 😂 but she didn't put it on the other two where their are proofs that they sang live
why people try so hard to push everyone to believe it was live? it’s obviously prerecorded because one time when they “tested” mics it sounded completely different like you could hear raw vocals, in this case they always sound the same despite of choreography while they’re jumping etc you can’t even hear them breathing….
@@LaBringsLoe enak yah jadi Aespa pas lipsync banyak yang bela coba klo itu terjadi pada STAYC, Weeekly, IVE, Everglow atau Itzy mungkin mereka nggak dapat PEMBELAAN SPESIAL kyk Aespa bahkan dihujat habis-habisan Wkwkwkwkk.... Standar ganda banget yah 🤣🤣
![[CLEAN MR Removed] 220722 aespa (에스파) Girls | Music Bank MR제거](/img/logo.svg){kind=logo}
