Colossal Color Showdown S2 Ep.5: Green Gold | Comparing 12 Watercolor Brands

Подписаться 63 тыс.

Просмотров 11 тыс.

50% 1

** Please support my Patreon **
/ otokano
Welcome back to the Colossal Color Showdown, in this episode, we take a close look at Green Gold, a bright intense yellow green, in terms of mass tone, alternative colors, prices, lift & glaze, and opacity
Watch all the Colossal Color Showdown episodes: • Comparing 12 brands! C...
** Colors tested in this episode **
+ Daniel Smith Green Gold
Jacksons: bit.ly/326wi3D Blick: bit.ly/3aJ3N0a
+ Holbein Greenish Yellow
Jacksons: bit.ly/3363xDr Blick: bit.ly/3unb11H
+ Schmincke Transparent Green Gold
Jacksons: bit.ly/3idiYju Blick: bit.ly/3spDm5T
+ Sennelier Brown Green
Jacksons: bit.ly/32aZTJs Blick: bit.ly/3skpbyN
+ Winsor & Newton Green Gold
Jacksons: bit.ly/35hNZzq Blick: bit.ly/3upV3Eg
+ QoR Green Gold
Jacksons: bit.ly/328O2vd Blick: bit.ly/2ZKKP37
+ M. Graham Azo Green
Jacksons: bit.ly/3jQmfFU Blick: bit.ly/3qOqC8i
+ Roman Szmal Green Gold
Jacksons: bit.ly/2ZhwgnO
+ Mission Gold Greenish Yellow
Jacksons: bit.ly/3ibotiC Blick: bit.ly/3bxiClJ
+ Da Vinci Green Gold
Jacksons: bit.ly/2R71Fok Blick: bit.ly/2No0hjd
+ Old Holland Golden Green
Jacksons: bit.ly/2FkGgFG Blick: bit.ly/3unh8mJ
+ MaimeriBlue Green Gold
Jacksons: bit.ly/2FkIdSw Blick: bit.ly/3aLxcaf
** Other Supplies I used **
+ Fabriano Academia bit.ly/3iYKgKc
+ Cadmium Yellow Light (Holbein) bit.ly/2FA8blz
+ Quinacridone Rose (Daniel Smith) bit.ly/2H8NJc2
+ Phthalo Blue Yellow Shade (Holbein) bit.ly/3j5nQaa
+ Pro Arte Prolene Plus size 10 round brush tinyurl.com/y2vqcejh
** Please support my Patreon **
/ otokano
** My Amazon Wishlist **
+ amzn.eu/fXKAv1n
** Connect with Me **
+ Twitter: / otokano_art
+ Instagram: / otokano_art
+ Facebook: / otokano
** My PO Box **
Oto Kano
PO Box 24120
Edinburgh
EH7 9FB
United Kingdom
Jackson's links are affiliate links in which a small percentage of the sale supports this channel without costing you any extra at all. Thank you so much for supporting this channel grow!

Хобби

Опубликовано:

13 дек 2020

Ссылка:

Скачать:

Готовим ссылку...

Добавить в:

Мой плейлист

Посмотреть позже

Комментарии : 70

@InLiquidColor 3 года назад

Daniel Smith's green gold was on my first professional palette and I came to love those brown mixes with the reds. It took me much longer to come around to PY129, but I have room in my heart for both now 😆

@Finkeldinken 3 года назад

I have W&N Green Gold and I really, really love it. I use it for all sorts of things, but mostly I think it's just a straight up star in skin tone mixes, where it brings amazing glow imo. Also, that DS Green Gold has been calling to me since the first time I saw it, it very much looks like it would be my jam. Thank you for the walkthrough, Oto, these are always so helpful!

@LowKey_izildura 3 года назад

White Nights calls their Py129 Irgazin Yellow

@spoopema 2 года назад

Thank you! Might order it soon

@miaRembetissa 2 года назад

Thank you! Roman Szmal has also Green Gold Deep with single pigment PY129.

@bruceosborne1892 3 года назад

Good to see you on here again. Thanks.

@kyratrimble8146 3 года назад

I missed your videos!!! I’m glad it came on my YT feed :)

@SarahBaileyArts 3 года назад

I believe the M Graham color is "Azo Green" not Azo Gold, at least on my tube it is. :) edit: nvm I see you caught it in the description!

@JaneSiet 3 года назад

I also believe it’s Azo Green by M Graham

@aoutsky 3 года назад

I love the Maimeriblu green gold. PG10 is my all time fave green gold. Unfortunately discontinued.

@everartokelli 3 года назад

I absolutely love these comparison and am happy every time a new one shows up and often go back to earlier showdowns when I'm setting up a new palette. I love using DS Green Gold (which by the way was originally made from PG10, an obsolete pigment that was also commonly called Green Gold), it mixes beautifully as you demonstrated, glows on its own and is pretty versatile for a green mix. However, while I understand the name rules that you stated, I'm not sure how Azo Green, Greenish Yellow, Golden Green and Brown Green (none of which are called Green Gold) are acceptable but then Rich Green Gold isn't included because it doesn't fit the rule. To be consistent with the rule, it seems that you'd have to invalidate those outlier color names considering that the color name is more important than the pigments in this comparison. It didn't stop me one bit from enjoying this episode as I'm looking at buying a PY129 green gold and even the other mixes are interesting, but it's confusing.

@franninchen 3 года назад

I totally have to agree your whole comment. Maybe it would have been better to include both DS paints, as they are both called green gold as rich green gold would have totally fit the name rule in that case. Now I am still not sure if I should buy rich green gold or green gold by another brand. The green gold by DS I already own and love it. 😅

@DahHar117 2 года назад

@@franninchen Oto has a separate video comparing DS green gold and rich green gold.

@franninchen 2 года назад

@@DahHar117 I know but it is much more efficient to see it next to all the others not just the ds one. In this video it would have been compared to all the similar paints.

@wb8695 3 года назад

I have the Mijello Mission Gold pure pigment Green Gold made of py150, it's bright and very comparable to Holbein or Schmincke according to your swatches here 👍🏻

@jaimeanderson9238 3 года назад

I love py150. It's a beautiful yellow and perfect mixer:)

@wb8695 3 года назад

@@jaimeanderson9238 yes, I really love it for landscape paintings

@boxapaint569 3 года назад

I still can't figure out how before, almost every single episode of both series, I start off by thinking "Yay, that's one of my favourites! Wait how many favourites are you allowed? 🤓" Thank you, and this is such a beautifully matched swatch card for the tail end of autumn.

@SathishKumar-pw9fu 3 года назад

Py129 in M.GRAHAM is Azo green.however they too have nickel azo yellow PY150

@KRCanetti 3 года назад

When a paint says: "I'm PY129" I'll go for it. My paint book keeping is a mess right now, but there are a few here and I love this colour. Beautiful Showdown again, thank you, Oto!

@salome.artist 3 года назад

Daniel Smith Green Gold is an absolute must have on my botanical/nature palette, it's perfect for light shining through leaves.

@McQuizzical 3 года назад

Thank you. Winsor & Newton Green Gold is absolutely beautiful, I've not noticed a rewet issue that I can think of. I would have been interested to see a pigment comparison with the Daniel Smith rich green gold, assuming that is a PY129 too?

@MissMagic 3 года назад

Re bubbles - the only time I ever get this with any paint is when rubbing at the dried paint to rewet it. Let a drop of water sit on top of the pan for a minute before digging in and the problem should disappear as you won't be rubbing and forcing air in.

@hannahthufvesson 3 года назад

I feel like I want to mention that that might not help. I've tried to do that a ton with a maimeri paint I have, and it's just hopeless. Cannot. Get. Rid. Of. The. Bubbles. 😭 Oh well, there are other brands out there..

@MissMagic 3 года назад

I have lots of Maimeri (tubes and pans) and just don't experience it at all. I have often wondered whether water hardness may also affect our painting experience though, do you know how your tap water is? Mine very soft.

@hannahthufvesson 3 года назад

@@MissMagic Same here, soft water in Stockholm. :) I have a few MaimeriBlu pans that don't bubble as terribly, but they are sort of "unfriendly" to rewet? As if they're hard and tacky at the same time. I've never experienced anything like that before. I want to love them, but I just can't. I've given up on them as a brand.

@MissMagic 3 года назад

I wonder what can cause such difference in experience then, how very odd. Maybe there is some manufacturing variation or like with M Graham they are affected by something environmental. M Graham paints set here no problem and stay that way btw.

@hannahthufvesson 3 года назад

@@MissMagic Me too, and possibly. I guess pigments are a bit of a wild card and batches will vary slightly, regardless of environmental factors? It's such a jungle! And I love M. Graham! They set here enough to stay put in a travel palette, but stay very soft and creamy, which I'm practicing getting used to. I love their color payoff and how matt they dry! 😍

@lightusphoenix 3 года назад

I use green-gold for the bright "sunset/sunrise" look behind a forest so I like my green-gold to be on the bright side. From the swatches, I looked at the colours that I would have liked and found I am already using W&N and M.Graham green gold but I probably will pick up Roman Szmal one to give it a shot too. Thank you very much for the comparison! :D

@sodabeentjes 3 года назад

I have Old Hollands Golden Green half pan. I have not experienced any bubbling or popping. I also have both Van Gogh's and Rembrandts Azomethine green yellow (PY129). Van Gogh's is very nice, and Rembrandts is more on the yellow side, quite similar to their PY150. Love those DS green gold mixes! 😍

@VeretenoVids 3 года назад

Thank you for sticking to your "color name" premise for this series. I for one really appreciate it and am finding it interesting that the art paint industry can sometimes be just as inconsistent as the house paint industry. Generally this green-gold color isn't one of my favorites, but that Schminke just jumped off the swatch card at me!

@SerenWen_art 3 года назад

I have the QoR green gold, as it’s part of the high chroma set, it’s lovely, as are the other colours in the set! Works great wet in wet, it has the typical QoR “whoosh” when you drop it onto wet paper.

@mangomontero 3 года назад

Wow, had been eyeing PY129 for weeks and I JUST got back with a new tube from my art supplies store and your video pops up!! I ended up buying Shinhan PWC's Greenish Yellow (PY129). It is sketchy that the label says lightfastness is only 2 out of 3 stars, seeing as every other manufacturer puts it at their top rank, but I've come to learn that with Shinhan, the ratings on the labels (and even the use of the word "permanent") don't mean much. Seeing the performance of the other options, I am still happy with it. It is a lovely hue, more greenish than yellow. If my monitor were perfect, I would say it's closer to the Mission Gold hue. Thank you for this episode, I am looking for ward for next week's!

@Dan.B.Artist 3 года назад

I really like a PY129 from Isaro, it's beautiful.

@anam00090 3 года назад

Love QOR's one. Their high chroma set has no duds, every hue is incredibly useful! Daniel Smith's Rich Green Gold feels very different, even though hue comes close - it feels heavier and muddier. QOR has amazing luminosity that sometimes substitutes a cool yellow in my mini palettes

@annettefournier9655 3 года назад

Thanks Oto. My M. Graham azo gold does set to a soft set. Maybe depends on the climate? It does take about a week though. I don't k non ow why I'm not getting notifications. I reset it so hopefully it will be back to normal. I hate it when that happens. Take care. Thank you so much your comparison series are the best!👍💜

@carolynderricks3226 2 года назад

Would you include Sennelier ‘s vert-Jaune in this group? Or would it go into another category? My favorite color! And so far I have not found a close equal in any other brand I’ve tried. Wonderful!

@sailorfan86 3 года назад

I can't see bubbling on my Maimeriblu swatch. Maybe it depends on the kind of paper one uses. Tried on a Sanders Waterford paper and Stillman&Birn Nova series book ( brown paper ) but no bubbles.

@jennifersjunkmail5935 3 года назад

Daniel Smith's PY129 is called "Rich Green Gold."

@jennifersjunkmail5935 3 года назад

Oops, you knew that (of course!). I commented before watching the video. My bad.

@jillkama7614 3 года назад

It would have been more helpful to see the daniel smith 129

@Josh_Freeman 3 года назад

The justification for using Green Gold rather than Rich Green Gold doesn't really make sense, in that she only wanted to use the colors called Green Gold to help beginners avoid mistakes, because half the colors she used are not named Green Gold. If you're only going to show the wrong DS Green Gold you won't help beginners find the right DS Rich Green Gold if you don't show it.

@Mackerachi 3 года назад

I have a small pan of the DS Green Gold and I love it, but I was super interested in seeing this sheet to see how the other green golds would compare, and was surprised that the shade was completely different than I had expected. I mean, by the title of the shade, the other color makes sense. What color name would be close in other brands to this shade that DS produces?

@DustyMusician 3 года назад

Sap green or olive green

@karenirving7088 2 месяца назад

Haven’t had any bubbling with Maimeri Blu

@CufflinksAndChuckles 3 года назад

I'm really just waiting for Mind of Watercolor's comment :) He seems to love it a lot! And so do I! Apparently, it comes close to making a Sap Green when mixed with certain cool blues.

@RoryP22 3 года назад

I have the Da Vinci Green Gold but it rewets very easily; although I do live on the coast so maybe it never gets bone dry.

@jenniefrench1338 3 года назад

I love mine and live in the Midwest. It is very smooth.

@minnalpavi 2 года назад

Could you please maybe post an image of the DS rich green gold next to the others? I'd love to see the side by side.

@Christine_R 3 года назад

I have Greenish Yellow by Mission Gold and I think it glazes better when it's a bit watered down. The Azomethine Green Yellow by Rembrandt is next on my list.

@marjoriejohnson6535 10 месяцев назад

Rich green gold is much more on the yellow spectrum much like the yellow shades here.

@jaimeanderson9238 3 года назад

I could never get into py129. I have Da Vinci and MGraham and I want to love them but it's just not there for me.

@spoonierv1543 3 года назад

This is one of the few colors where I have a very strong brand preference and it is QoR. It is the only QoR color that is on my main palette. This is also one of my favorite colors. I know some people think it looks like baby puke but I think it looks like a new leaf in the sun.

@theresarowe1656 3 года назад

I had considered DS Green Gold but I had a different concept of the color. Thanks for this update.

@kristiw.1823 3 года назад

Fascinating how different our color experiences can end up being. I only have the Da Vinci & QOR, but not had issues with re-wetting. I really love having this in any pallet because it is the perfect shade for making more natural, glowing greens.

@ap_po 3 года назад

one major factor is the paper someone uses which can contribute to different results.

@IridescentJen 3 года назад

wow! the only green gold i know is DS, so getting ready to order my first roman szmal paints i would have been very surprised not to receive a chartreusey yellowish green! thank you for doing this comparison. i had no idea the ds was actually the outlier and not the norm (at least in this situation). "green" should be the modifier of the subject "gold", as it is in the others. so DS would be best named gold green. ok now my brain is on track :)

@KatheeRN 3 года назад

I love the roman small paints. (Even though DS is my preferred brand). inexpensive yet lovely to work with. Hope U like them also.

@fufufuaru 2 года назад

romal szmal... why did they add in other pigments when they already use PY129? Based on DS' pricing, PY129 doesn't seem to be an expensive pigment so it can't be to make the paint cheaper...

@Cloudbreacker 3 года назад

Mijello (Mission Gold) actually offers a "Green Gold" (W600) made out of PY150 which looks very different to "Greenish Yellow" presented in the video. It looks similar to "Transp. Green Gold" by Schmincke but it's more yellow-ish.

@jkw9373 3 года назад

I'm so confused! I bought a dot card by Mijello Mission Gold. Are there two different companies called Mission Gold and Mijello Mission Gold?! Or two brands, of the same company, with inconsistent color names?

@Cloudbreacker 3 года назад

@@jkw9373 They are the same brand

@jkw9373 3 года назад

@@Cloudbreacker Aaahh, thx, I get it now m)

@StarskyGypsy 3 года назад

I don’t have my Sennelier pallet on me as reference ((CORRECT ME)), but isn’t Brown Gold in Sennelier is called Brown Pink?

@sigrunella1 3 года назад

Brown Pink is a similar hue but a mix of Py150, PG7 and PBr23. I bought it in an art store because of the interesting name, and I love to use the it in landscapesand florals. It mixes a bit muddier than the Sennelier Brown Green which is single pigment PY129.

@StarskyGypsy 3 года назад

@@sigrunella1 thanks for clearing it up

@kathrynegan4510 3 года назад

I highly recommend this utube channel pearfleur. She is a young artist who gets pigments that originates in Japan from a store in London.

@fusadiluna 3 года назад

I'm a little sad the maimeriblu is not doing great :( By the way, it's me or you are calling it maRimeri? Lol

@B1ackDahlia767 3 года назад

😘😘😘

@stalean0301 2 года назад

You have M. Graham's PY129 listed as "Azo Gold." It is actually called "Azo Green," hence you really didn't stick to color names instead of pigment numbers as many of your other choices didn't have the exact name either. Also, as you mention in your video Daniel Smith's "Rich Green Gold" is a PY129 and closer in hue (instead of DS Green Gold) to your other choices and the name isn't so different as Schmincke's Transparent Green Gold or Holbein's Yellowish Green. I love your videos and have watched them all, but sometimes your choices perplex me.