Тёмный

Comprehensive Guide to Using Gas Canister Stoves in Cold Weather 

Mark Young
Подписаться 45 тыс.
Просмотров 7 тыс.
50% 1

Comprehensive Guide to Using Gas Canister Stoves in Cold Weather
About Pressurized Gas Canisters
To send fuel to the stove there has to be pressure within the canister
Pressure drops in the canister as the fuel is consumed
Pressure in a canister drops as the temperature goes down
Using the stove causes the temperature in the canister to drop
Canisters are available in butane, isobutane, propane-isobutane mix and propane cylinders
Butane stops vaporizing at 31F / -0.5 C (its boiling point) but pressure and performance will start decreasing well before that point
Isobutane, a chemical variation of butane, continues vaporizing down to 11F / -11.6 C
Propane continues vaporizing down to -43F / -42C
Propane alone is not practical as a stronger/heavier steel tank is needed to contain the higher pressure it requires to remain liquid
Use 20°F/-7°C as a guide for the limit when using a typical upright gas canister stove with isobutane or propane-isobutane mix
Regulated Stoves VS Stoves with a Pre-Heat Tube
Traditional Stoves
The jets in these stoves are small to help control the pressure being released
The small jets prevent sufficient fuel to leave the cylinder as the temperature/pressure drops
Regulated
Regulators have bigger jets then non-regulated stoves, allowing more fuel to flow through but have a regulator to prevent too great a flow
Benefits are fuel will flow easier at lower canister pressures and lower temperatures than a non-regulated stove but it still has limits to how much it can do
Stoves with regulators cannot be run in inverted mode, with exceptions
Pre-Heat Tubes (generator)
Remote canister stoves with a pre-heat tube can be inverted to allow liquid fuel to flow through
A remote canister stove with a pre-heat tube will save money as it uses all the fuel when inverted
An inverted canister stove can burn gas down to about 0F / -18C
Because the fuel remains liquid, it does not separate
If you are looking at adding a new gas canister stove to your kit and you plan to use the stove in cold weather then the best option is a stove with a pre-heat tube, followed by a pressure regulated stove
Tips and Tricks for Regular Gas Canister Stoves
Choose Propane-Isobutane (winter mix) over Isobutane over butane
Choose propane if weight is not an issue
Keep the canister warm or gently warm it up
Keep canister in sleeping bag or under jacket
Place on an insulated base or inside a cozy, etc
Place canister in water (warm is better)
Use a pocket heater to warm up
Caution should be used to not overheat the canister. This can create excessive pressure and cause a dangerous flareup.
Choose a stove with a pressure regulator or pre-heat tube
DIY a pre-heat device by using a strip of copper or aluminum held against the side of the canister and placed in the flame of the stove • Butane Canister Stove ...

Опубликовано:

 

4 авг 2024

Поделиться:

Ссылка:

Скачать:

Готовим ссылку...

Добавить в:

Мой плейлист
Посмотреть позже
Комментарии : 117   
@scottbutler1561
@scottbutler1561 Год назад
Thanks, Mark. This is the most accurate and comprehensive canister stove presentation relative to cold weather performance that I've ever seen.
@MarkYoungBushcraft
@MarkYoungBushcraft Год назад
Glad it was helpful! Thanks for commenting
@brashachilles9725
@brashachilles9725 22 дня назад
Such well structured, informative, expert videos.
@MarkYoungBushcraft
@MarkYoungBushcraft 22 дня назад
Thank you for your kind words
@maritimeblaster
@maritimeblaster Год назад
I had these issues the other day trying to make lunch. Thank you, I wasn’t sure what I would have to do besides using my gasifier stove which can be difficult with my dog around. The warm water in a dish I think is going to be my solution. Brilliant!
@MarkYoungBushcraft
@MarkYoungBushcraft Год назад
Glad it helped! Thanks for commenting
@Stoney_AKA_James
@Stoney_AKA_James Год назад
Great video Mark!
@MarkYoungBushcraft
@MarkYoungBushcraft Год назад
Glad you enjoyed it. Thanks for commenting
@connosaurus
@connosaurus Год назад
Good information Mark. Happy to see the hand-warmer test!
@MarkYoungBushcraft
@MarkYoungBushcraft Год назад
Glad you enjoyed it. Thanks for commenting
@956lizz
@956lizz Год назад
Thank you for sharing your knowledge with us! There’s always great videos on your channel
@MarkYoungBushcraft
@MarkYoungBushcraft Год назад
Thank you for your kind words
@brucematys8597
@brucematys8597 Год назад
Excellent video Mark and really appreciate the information shared. Cheers my friend.
@MarkYoungBushcraft
@MarkYoungBushcraft Год назад
Glad it was helpful. Thanks for commenting
@coreyschultz7018
@coreyschultz7018 Год назад
I never realized all the differences with fuel types as well as gaseous and liquid forms of dispensing. All great information. My choice is easy now! Thanks for your great info again!
@MarkYoungBushcraft
@MarkYoungBushcraft Год назад
Glad it was helpful! Thanks for commenting
@andrewinaustintx
@andrewinaustintx Год назад
Thank you for the excellent demonstration of the three work arounds for using an ISO-butane stove in colder temps. Since, I'm truck camping versus backpacking - I bring a trusty 45 year old SVEA 123 as part of my kit when headed to higher elevations, just in case.
@MarkYoungBushcraft
@MarkYoungBushcraft Год назад
I do love my SVEA 123 but they do require a bit more work than these type of stoves. Thanks for commenting
@theresamcpherson7352
@theresamcpherson7352 Год назад
Thank you Mark!
@MarkYoungBushcraft
@MarkYoungBushcraft Год назад
Most welcome. Thanks for commenting
@karenporter3156
@karenporter3156 Год назад
Thank you! Another great video full of information.
@MarkYoungBushcraft
@MarkYoungBushcraft Год назад
Glad it was helpful! Thanks for commenting
@spinner2000
@spinner2000 Год назад
Brilliant mark very comprehensive
@MarkYoungBushcraft
@MarkYoungBushcraft Год назад
Glad you found it helpful. Thanks for commenting
@stevensmith1911
@stevensmith1911 7 месяцев назад
Very informative. Thank you!
@MarkYoungBushcraft
@MarkYoungBushcraft 7 месяцев назад
Glad it was helpful! Thanks for commenting
@bcamping1
@bcamping1 5 месяцев назад
This is the best explanation of pressure regulator I ever heard. These two little stoves probably have very little jets. They are very efficient and slow. They probably show the difference of different fuels and temperatures the best.
@MarkYoungBushcraft
@MarkYoungBushcraft 5 месяцев назад
Agreed. Thanks for commenting
@nyleshintz69
@nyleshintz69 Год назад
As a gas fitter in B.C.,I outfit my cylinders with primarily propane in Winter or our colder climates in Autumn or Spring. Good to see you're still promoting something to the general public. I won't correct you here.
@MarkYoungBushcraft
@MarkYoungBushcraft Год назад
Thanks for commenting
@donnybryan6762
@donnybryan6762 Год назад
Great video. The amount of liquid in the tank does not affect the pressure. Only the temperature of the liquid affects the pressure. It takes energy to vaporize the liquid cooling the liquid. A smaller volume in the tank cools faster than a larger volume. Therefore, a smaller volume may appear to have lower pressure.
@MarkYoungBushcraft
@MarkYoungBushcraft Год назад
Thanks for the info!
@eramaidenkulkija
@eramaidenkulkija Год назад
I was about to post this same comment. The pressure depends only of the temerature of the liquid.
@wanttogo1958
@wanttogo1958 Месяц назад
The copper strip you saw demonstrated by Krizakoni (sp?) in a YT video is actually called a Moulder strip credited to Bob Moulder(still living to my knowledge) as the original, recent anyway, person who refined the technique and wrote about it at Backpacking Light. If you search for Moulder strip online you will see the thread come up at the BPL site where the details of making and using one are described. You don’t have to be a member to read those entries online.
@MarkYoungBushcraft
@MarkYoungBushcraft Месяц назад
Thanks for the information. I will take a look
@MichaelR58
@MichaelR58 Год назад
Good informational video , thanks for sharing , God bless !
@MarkYoungBushcraft
@MarkYoungBushcraft Год назад
Glad it was helpful! Thanks for commenting
@genelucky4002
@genelucky4002 Год назад
I find I can warm the canister using a remote canister stove by simply placing the canister somewhat near the burner. I use a wind screen and leave it open on the canister side. I monitor the canister temperature to make sure the metal stays low enough that I can touch the canister is not ouch response. In additon to touching the canister to monitor its tempurature, listen to the stove. If it starts to roar the canister is beginning to over heat. Turn it down or off immediately.
@MarkYoungBushcraft
@MarkYoungBushcraft Год назад
Yes, that would work. As you say, you would need to watch it closely. Thanks for commenting
@AtomicBleach
@AtomicBleach Год назад
Firemaple actually sells a insulated cowhide leather cover for your gas canister to help with performance in the cold.
@MarkYoungBushcraft
@MarkYoungBushcraft Год назад
Yes, and I will likely ask them to send me one to share. Thanks for commenting
@jacquelineatherstone9288
@jacquelineatherstone9288 7 месяцев назад
Thank you mark for this great information sincerely Jacqueline Wichita ks
@MarkYoungBushcraft
@MarkYoungBushcraft 7 месяцев назад
I am glad it was helpful. Thanks for commenting
@hypo345
@hypo345 Год назад
A lot of information succinctly delivered. Guess we all have our favourite stoves for cold weather, for me it’s the SOTO StormBreaker works with white gas or inverted gas, I also use an Optimus Vega remote stove that will work with a canister inverted and has a stand to facilitate this. I find it a bit annoying when a manufacturer makes a stove that can work with an inverted gas canister but doesn’t provide a suitable means to support the canister inverted. Liked your Bull Dog clip work around. In the Uk RidgeMonkey make a USB heated canister cover that warms the gas to keep it working in cold temperatures.
@MarkYoungBushcraft
@MarkYoungBushcraft Год назад
Fire Maple makes on as well that I will ask them to send so I can share it. Thanks for commenting
@clockworkvanhellsing372
@clockworkvanhellsing372 2 месяца назад
If you put some tablesalt on a stick and hold it into the flame, the flame would be much more visible in the video. Thank you for the demonstration. Some of the cheap chinese stoves conduct enough heat into their base, that they can run on an inverted canister without issues (at least mine can, and that one was realy cheap), so it might be worth it, to carefully try it out outside.
@MarkYoungBushcraft
@MarkYoungBushcraft 2 месяца назад
Interesting idea about using the salt. Thanks for commenting
@terryw.milburn8565
@terryw.milburn8565 Год назад
Great Demo Shared Mark ! I Use A Hand Warmer On The Bottom Of Mine When Needed. ATB T God Bless
@MarkYoungBushcraft
@MarkYoungBushcraft Год назад
I like the handwarmers as well. Thanks for commenting Terry
@margueritemitchell1829
@margueritemitchell1829 Год назад
Hello from British Columbia Canada 🇨🇦🖐🖐♥️🌲🌳🚍🚐🛣🚐🚍🌳🌲😎✊❄
@MarkYoungBushcraft
@MarkYoungBushcraft Год назад
Thanks for commenting
@Pedenzo
@Pedenzo Год назад
Mark, what about white gas stoves? (yeah, I'm always that guy....;-) I would love to see a comparison between W/G vs canister stoves. The amount of time to get the inverted canister stove going was longer that priming and lighting my beloved Svea. One thought, maybe you could try using some sort of priming pan with alcohol to warm up the inverted canister stove......great video, thank you!
@MarkYoungBushcraft
@MarkYoungBushcraft Год назад
I would love to make a video on white gas stoves. I am also thinking about one on alcohol stoves. Thanks for commenting
@josephtremblay6562
@josephtremblay6562 Год назад
Trangia gas burner has both preheat tube, and pressure regulator, and high quality. I use this with a trangia T27, as well as an optimus polaris for extreme cold and higher elevation. They all fit in a T27, so bonus windscreen
@MarkYoungBushcraft
@MarkYoungBushcraft Год назад
Yes, that is one of the pros for the Trangia burner. Thanks for commenting
@covenantking
@covenantking Год назад
I’ve been thinking about using my Optimus Polaris in a 25 or 27 Trangia windcreen. Can you tell me how stable is it, do you use any adapter? and if you have ever damaged the aluminum windcreen with the Polaris at full heat? Thanks.
@josephtremblay6562
@josephtremblay6562 Год назад
@covenantking I do not have the adapter, i use it in the closed position (as in I don't open the legs) and it is still stable that way. I do not crank the heat full either.
@charliemcdowell5231
@charliemcdowell5231 9 месяцев назад
It has a preheat tube but I believe it is not meant to use an inverted canister. Perhaps I’m mistaken?
@borissorkin8819
@borissorkin8819 Год назад
Mark, preheat tube on this stove would work much better with pot on the stove. The flame would spread wider and touch the tube. Without pot on top of the stove, the tube is not in the flame and less efficient. Thanks for the tips with paper clips and cooper strip. I will try them both.
@MarkYoungBushcraft
@MarkYoungBushcraft Год назад
I agree, I think I may have mentioned that at one point. I should have sown a pot being placed on all of them. Thanks for commenting
@eyeofthetiger4184
@eyeofthetiger4184 Год назад
Good on ya Boris, fair point mate. Cheers Duke.
@redsorgum
@redsorgum Год назад
I think the hand warmer was an easier way to warm it. I would recommend one of those gas can sleeves, I’ve seen people use them, and they seem to work pretty good. You should have lit up a Trangia as a bonus……✌️🇺🇸🇨🇦✌️
@MarkYoungBushcraft
@MarkYoungBushcraft Год назад
I may make a cold weather alcohol stove video. Thanks for commenting
@Fellmandave1
@Fellmandave1 Год назад
Really great video Mark. i have just bought a pressure regulator stove as was experiencing poor performance in the cold with my preheat tube type. I am still not convinced which is better, the pressure regulator stove or preheat tube type.
@MarkYoungBushcraft
@MarkYoungBushcraft Год назад
So far, in real cold weather I lean towards the pre-heat tube with the tank inverted. It does take a bit to warm up though. Thanks for commenting
@Fellmandave1
@Fellmandave1 Год назад
@@MarkYoungBushcraft would be great to see the pre heat vs the regulator though, kind of what I was expecting then went a bit unscientific. subscribed!
@MrLabradorwildman
@MrLabradorwildman Год назад
Hi Mark, Posted Comment on wrong Video lol, should have posted on this one on using the Ultra Flame Propane Torch Fuel Canister, 226-g, it has the same thread has all the stoves and yes i pushed the canaster down in the snow and tried my sole master on top, i do like the regulator stoves i like the look at the one you was using can you place a link to it please i may get one and try my propane canaster with it. Great video thanks again Dave from Lab City.
@MarkYoungBushcraft
@MarkYoungBushcraft Год назад
Here is a link to one from Fire Maple firemaplegear.com/collections/shop-all-accessaries/products/z1-lpg-propane-canister-adapter Thanks for commenting
@markmartello
@markmartello Год назад
Nice video Mark. Can straight propane be used with a stove with a preheat tube? Thanks.
@MarkYoungBushcraft
@MarkYoungBushcraft Год назад
Yes, it can but no need to invert the tank. Thanks for commenting
@colinsynstar
@colinsynstar Год назад
Great video, Thanks
@MarkYoungBushcraft
@MarkYoungBushcraft Год назад
Glad you liked it! Thanks for commenting
@Chris-hx7ub
@Chris-hx7ub 9 месяцев назад
Great video. Question for a canister stove with a pre heat tube i have msr windpro 2 in liquid mode what's the coldest you have been able to get then started? On the -25c day did you try to get that one stove started? I am trying to figure out limit of winter mix canister stove. Thanks.
@MarkYoungBushcraft
@MarkYoungBushcraft 9 месяцев назад
I don't have the MSR Windpro 2 but I have a few stoves of similar design. I was able to get them started and use them at -25C using the winter blend fuel. They sputter and flare a bit until they heat up. A trick I use is to carry the canister inside my coat to help pre-heat it. Hope this helps
@Chris-hx7ub
@Chris-hx7ub 9 месяцев назад
@MarkYoungBushcraft thank you. Will keep canister in pocket while getting camp set up.
@DrDennis
@DrDennis Год назад
Do all these gas stoves connect directly to 1 lb propane cans or do you need adapters? Great review.
@MarkYoungBushcraft
@MarkYoungBushcraft Год назад
They all require the adapter for use with the propane cylinder but the adapter is quite inexpensive. I got mine on Aliexpress but Fire Maple also has them. Thanks for commenting
@jimf1964
@jimf1964 Год назад
That was pretty comprehensive. I’m sure it’ll help some people, and THANK YOU for pointing out that you need a stove to get hot water, and you need hot water to run your stove. Some real keypad experts are out there. Personally I find it odd that the very people (bush crafters , hikers etc) who are supposed to be so environmental, drop it without a thought when it comes to personal convenience. Except for the maybe 1% of people who refill their cans, canisters are so so wasteful. Manufacturing the steel, the extra shipping of raw steel, shipping to be filled, then to the store when full, even printing the canisters, etc…make these the worst choice. I don’t mind if people choose these, it’s just when they’re being so hypocritical about it.
@MarkYoungBushcraft
@MarkYoungBushcraft Год назад
You make a good point about the environmental impact of the gas canisters. I heard Paul Kirtley argue that a few years ago and I resisted using the canisters at all. Now, I do refill my small canisters from the larger but even that, it is less impactful to use alcohol or wood. Thanks for commenting
@danielkutcher5704
@danielkutcher5704 Год назад
Another alcohol and wood stove user, I assume. 👍
@jimf1964
@jimf1964 Год назад
@@danielkutcher5704 Another person who doesn’t really read a post before commenting, I assume. If you actually read my comment, I said that I don’t blame anyone for using a gas canister, if that’s what they like, but don’t go around claiming you’re pro protecting the environment if you do. I can’t begin to tell you how sick I am of people who claim to be environmentalists, yet will do nothing of their own accord, if it causes them the most minuscule of inconveniences, and then expect the government to do it for them. Not that it’s relevant, since I’m only calling out hypocrites, but I adore my firebox stove, I use alcohol on occasion, and white gas. Though I’m planning on buying a universal fuel MSR stove soon.
@danielkutcher5704
@danielkutcher5704 Год назад
@@jimf1964 Apparently, you don't understand what 👍means. I agreed with your post. 🙄 I use alcohol and wood, and am environmentally responsible, and don't expect a pat on the back from anyone for driving tiny cars, recycling, etc. Your response startled me, but I will just assume that it was a simple misunderstanding on your part or a failure to communicate clearly on my part. ✌
@jimf1964
@jimf1964 Год назад
@@danielkutcher5704 Hey, I run into a lot of keyboard experts, so maybe I responded too quickly, or it was aimed at someone else. Sorry
@eyeofthetiger4184
@eyeofthetiger4184 Год назад
G'day Mark, probably around 0 C is the coldest I'd encounter and haven't had an issue with Colman branded iso-butane, butane, propane 28-45-26 mix. or iso-butane @ 80-20 mix, on the Blade 2 or Windmaster, though i do usually pocket the canister for a while as a matter of course, just a good habit to get into i reckon. I have heard, (second hand), of the odd dodgy canister valve, (have you ?), so depending on the trip I'll often take 2 X 220 g jobs rather than a single 220 or 450 g, ...... for our old mate Just-in Case. Btw; on the other end of the scale, I'm struggling to find upper temp specs, it can go 40+ C here in summer and I am particularly concerned with leaving these fuels in a hot car for any length of time. Any info would be appreciated. Cheers Duke.
@MarkYoungBushcraft
@MarkYoungBushcraft Год назад
Hey Duke. Good question about upper temperatures. We rarely get above 30C here so I have not thought about it. I think I will do some research on this. Thanks for commenting
@per-ake
@per-ake Год назад
Hi Mark, Will the FM polaris, being a regulated stove,will it run on propane with the appropriate tank adapter. I did try it with the MSR Reactor, which is regulated, but all I got was a very weak blue flame.
@MarkYoungBushcraft
@MarkYoungBushcraft Год назад
I wanted to conform before replying. I compared propane to isobutane on my FM Polaris and Campingmoon pressure regulated stove. I did not a small decrease in intensity between fuels. Interestingly, I noted a larger difference between the two stoves when using the same fuels. I cannot confirm but the difference may be due to the BTU difference between butane and propane. Isobutane would be my first choice but I would be happy with propane as well. Hope this helps
@turtlewolfpack6061
@turtlewolfpack6061 Год назад
Yea, in reality propane ceases to vaporize well before -40 Celsius. Seen it tons of times. As for the others altitude plays a huge part on any canister stove as well. Spouting stats is great, the real world shows otherwise very quickly.
@MarkYoungBushcraft
@MarkYoungBushcraft Год назад
Yes, I stated a number of times that the pressure and performance drop with temperature and that there is a point of diminishing returns.
@jarmosalonen2068
@jarmosalonen2068 Год назад
Farenheit? What happened to Celsius temperature measuring?
@MarkYoungBushcraft
@MarkYoungBushcraft Год назад
I kind of went back and forth. Should have done both right through. Thanks for commenting
@neemancallender9092
@neemancallender9092 Год назад
I still have an Optimus 88 or 99 (cant remember) that comes in an aluminum container where the lid is a pot I have the pressure pump to act as a pressure stove Called a white gas or coleman fuel, but i just always used unleaded gas/petrol lowest grade i have used that stove in -40 and it started perfectly A liter of fuel would last ten days in the winter snowshoeing in the woods and mountains of Vermont and the Adirondacks, or the Scottish Highlands in the winter , cooking lentils and rice as my main evening meal I have another heavy aluminum pot, that i simmered the lentils, and used haybox method and wrapped the pot in thin closed cell foam, to get a slow cook Used the lid to boil water for coffee and tea, with a thin aluminum mug, almost as light as titanium Still lights up like a treat I also had the first MSR remote multi fuel stove, it was a beast Did not use it much, as it was bulky. i don't even think it had a model number Fond Memories
@MarkYoungBushcraft
@MarkYoungBushcraft Год назад
A classic for sure. I have an old Svea and Colemen that work the same way. Bit more work to use but they work so much better in the cold. Thanks for commenting
@danielkutcher5704
@danielkutcher5704 Год назад
Was the early MSR an XGK? I had one, briefly, in the 1980s and replaced it with a Whisperlite when the model came out. I still have it.
@wanttogo1958
@wanttogo1958 Месяц назад
You have the 99. Good stove.
@user-hw6hb4rk9t
@user-hw6hb4rk9t 2 месяца назад
1:18 "And there's a winter mix of Isobutane, mixed with Cocaine." isn't hearing damage fun?
@MarkYoungBushcraft
@MarkYoungBushcraft 2 месяца назад
I hear you (pun intended) I wear hearing aids and still miss things
@godottt
@godottt Год назад
Generally love your videos, but this one was a bit annoying as you did it almost entirely in Fahrenheit -- especially since you are Canadian. Let the Americans Google translate while watching instead of the rest of the world.
@MarkYoungBushcraft
@MarkYoungBushcraft Год назад
Yes, my bad. I grew up learning Imperial until I was in my teens and the switch to Metric. Kind of think in both worlds. Thanks for commenting
@wanttogo1958
@wanttogo1958 Месяц назад
⁠@@MarkYoungBushcraftthe easiest method I’ve seen is just post the temperature not given on the screen for a few frames and keep talking. To my knowledge most schools in the U.S. are still teaching the metric system for length and volume measurements and Centigrade for temperatures.
Далее
Firebox "Wood Flame" Gas Burner  - Important Update
11:37
🔴Ютуб закрывают... Пока?
00:39
Просмотров 1,8 млн
Китайка Шрек всех Сожрал😂😆
00:20
Fire Maple FM119 VS Blade 2 Gas Canister Stoves
18:33
RV Propane for Cold Weather Camping
10:18
Просмотров 11 тыс.
Isobutane Canister Stove Fuel Test - Which is the best?
12:22
Camping Gas Adapter Plus Refill
10:59
Просмотров 11 тыс.