COUPLE REACTS TO 마마무(MAMAMOO) Wind flower + Where Are We Now MVs 

We all agree that Wind Flower is one of everyone's favorite songs, right? is beautiful.

The very last line of "Where Are We Now", the Hwasa/Wheein duet, "On this beautiful star / the two of us shared the same dream / where are we now" is especially meaningful because Hwasa and Wheein grew up together, went to the same school, dreamed of becoming idols together, and landed in Mamamoo together. And this beautifully highlights their connection.

"Where are we now" is NEXT LEVEL,.... so STUNNINGLY emotional. They treated it like a single when it dropped. And people were in shock. like OH YEAH!!! they're the best singers EVER. Did anyone actually forget that? It also came at a time when we didn't think they were staying together. And it sounded like a last song or a break up song. No one really knew. But it definitely added to the emotion.

Where Are We Now is actually a song talking not only about the disorientation of their life as a singer but also the confusion of their future as Mamamoo. 2021 is the seventh year of Mamamoo, they had been walking together for a long time, but everything just became so different from the time when they debuted. They all had different dreams, careers, and life. Time just ran so fast in these seven years that they could not realize the changes between them, between their relationship, and everything around them. Things became so much more complicated now. I think this song actually brought these four girls back together again to their starting point. They were able to stop and ask themselves, " we've came so far, but where are we now and where are we going?" I truly believe that this song is another starting point of Mamamoo. This songs was made by their tears, laughter, and their memories of the seven years. Although the future might be uncertain and they might sometimes feel lost, but they have each others. They are the strongest when they are Mamamoo. I am always teary whenever I listen to this song, because we all know how many difficulties they had been through to become this famous, successful and iconic legend in Kpop industry. I just wanna say that they always did a good job. I feel so lucky to meet these four gorgeous girls. I will always cheer for them as long as they are standing on the stage.

"On this beautiful star, the two of us shared the same dream" Hwasa and Wheein harmonizing together at the end NEVER fails to make me emotional

The bond these 4 wonderful women have with each other is so special🥲💖

Where Are We Now was done for the group's Seven Year Anniversary last year (so it has been more than eight years since their debut as of now and obviously they have known each other from before that, so somewhere over a decade...). This song really hit WAY harder for people who were fans and stans from the very beginning or while the group was still trying to find their footing than the way it hit for newer fans. I am a newer fan (just a few years, nothing like the OGs who knew about the ladies from pre-debut) and this song hurt me, so I KNOW that longer-time fans were crying. It's really a soulful piece and it will be one of those legendary timeless masterpieces. It's about the members' collective friendship with each other (especially Wheein and Hwasa because they have known each other since middle school) and the rather rocky road they have had together (including arguing and even fighting with each other). But it's also about their perseverance; how they are still together, how they made it to the seven years together when so many other groups don't make it that long, how they beat a bunch of others in so many shows together (they proved so many people and companies wrong and are still standing). They got disrespected not only individually but also as a group but they are still here because they stayed together. It's BEAUTIFUL, and I cried the first couple of times seeing the MV. It's just as emotionally charged as Hwasa's solo song LMM. These ladies are Awesome, Amazing and just deserve all of the superlatives. Hwasa has one of the most flexible voices, I swear. Maybe she doesn't hit all of THE HIGHEST notes like some others (those would be Wheein and Solar's forte') but you can't argue with her low notes, as you have mentioned. Maybe she doesn't belt quite so BIG as others have (obviously Solar's specialty), but she has real RANGE to her voice, she can go big and harsh or she can go light and delicate, she knows how to be subtle. AND she can rap. Out of the entire group, she's my pick as the Vocal Swiss Army Knife (with Moon Byul right behind her). I am hopelessly OT4. I love every one of these ladies to pieces. I straight up cannot pick just one as a bias because they ALL are, they HAVE to be, because QUEENS. Luv ya both!

Where Are We Now never failed to tear my heart up everytime i hear it. Knowing the meaning behind this song that makes it more emotional. It hits different. This song is special to Mamamoo.

Wind Flower was shot in Hong Kong and one of the things it's doing is an homage to a famous noir director. The color palette many of the locations and scenes are taken from his films. It's my favorite MV of theirs. Where are We Now came out in early June. It's them singing about their experience over the previous 7 years. 6/19 was their contract expiration and Wheein had not signed. When I heard it I was really afraid they were disbanding and was an emotional wreck for over a week. Final gut punch was Wheein and Hwasa the two middle school friends harmonizing one the "We shared the same dream, where are we now?" The ice cream scene gave me some hope. Funny you have the videos ending in ice cream in this reaction. Mumumumuch finally healed me.

The ice cream scene from Where Are We Now is indeed a homage to Wind Flower. Actually, moomoos could find a lot of things/scenes from Where Are We Now as homages to their older hit songs since Where Are We Now is a song of their 7th years as Mamamoo, the end of their previous contract which gave them roads to go as a group or individuals. Btw, the cinematography & scenes in Wind Flower is based on Wong Kar Wai's films, a famous film director from Hong Kong, where they filmed this.

Like what a lot of the comments have said here, Where Are We Now is a song for their 7th year as a group. Idk if you guys are aware, but idol group contracts lasts for 7 years before the renewal period. This is why there's a thing called "7 year jinx" in kpop. Meaning a lot of groups don't really renew their contracts after, or maybe only some of the members only, causing for the group to continue on but w/o those who didn't renew. Some groups don't even reach the 7th year mark before they disband. This is why the 7th year is a very important for both groups and fans. Just like the title of the song, Mamamoo questions "where are we now?" at the point of their career as a group and as individuals. Personally, the last part hits very hard because the lyrics were "On this beautiful star, the two of us shared the same dream. Where are we now?" and it was sung by Hwasa and Wheein, who are childhood friends since middle school and dreamed of the same dream, and miraculously debuted in the same group.

No matter how many times I listen to "Where are we now" the last part where Wheein and Hwasa sing together always hit me

wind flower is one of my fave mamamoo songs because of the lyrics, but the mv is also so cinematic. where are we now is a whole other level of emotion because it came out on their 7th anniversary, the cursed year when most groups disband and we didn’t know if hwasa and wheein will stay… then they put this song out with these lyrics…i was a mess hahaha

Where are we now i think talks about their time together as a group

Wind flower is that song!!! this is everyone's favorite, even for mamamoo they LOVE this song so much.

I absolutely love Mamamoo! Where are we now gives me the feels because it was their 7th year and them staying as a group was uncertain. However the behind the scenes of them making the MV is so funny because they are literally beagles but the finished MV literally tears. Wind Flower is a BOP!

Got to say good choice on the MV's for this one , the ice cream scene at the end means so much seeing them back to back

WAW is a song that came in MAMAMOO’s 7th Anniversary after Wheein decided to part with RBW as a soloist but to stay as a part of MAMAMOO, and this song brought so much relief to me - MAMAMOO is OT4, they’re 4 as always. I was crying when I watched this video for the first time, it has so deep meaning to moomoos. HwaSa and Wheein are best friends since middle school and they decided to sing together no matter of what, and all the MMM girls had about 50 auditions but nobody wanted to take them in a debut group (what a crime!). And only CEO of RBW risked and created this gorgeous vocal group. As MMM didn’t suit Korean beauty standarts CeO said that girls need to perform like nobody could so they did! And money for girls’ trainings were brought back 4 months after their debut. MAMAMOO has one of the best career in kpop imho. And they are THE ONLY KOREAN GROUP every member of which was on first places in the World ITunes Chart as a soloist. My Queens now and forever❤ Many letters but Inlove these Artist sooo much since 2016 omg

I love how no matter the mood of the song they always find time for ice cream.

Every one, absolutely ALL of us have cried with Where Are We Know, it is part of the many songs that Mamamoo has that even without knowing the lyrics can make you feel the feeling of longing 😭💕

As always with these ladies, "Where are we now" is even better live.

I hope they will include "where are we now" in the next concert list 🥺

Windflower... The more you listen to it, the more you like it... And then it becomes your best Mamamoo's song...

Windflower MV is inspired by Wong Kar Wai films. The parallels are amazing. There are Twitter threads that explains the connections well.

The Wind (Whee In) and Flower (Hwa sa) are truly beautiful

Mamamoo is amazing, Wind Flower and Where are we now are work of art!

Trivia: Windflower is one of Mamamoo's fave song, andn there's a scene in the mv that is inspired in a movie. Where Are We Now is just a very heart warming and wholesome song And these fits will always holds a special place in our hearts

Beautifulls songs both of them, but I love where are we now the most.

You guys I recommend watching the video of mamamoo after the manager falls asleep, it's very funny ❤

The way they dropped WAW when their contracts we’re about to expire and no one knew what would happen next was pure torture. Beautiful, gorgeous, heart wrenching torture ;___; There we’re tears when I saw the MV the first time and I still get close to crying when I watch it now…

If Where Are We Now doesn't get you at least a little emotional, you have no feelings.

I love that you guys are complete MOOMOOs now. Please react to some of the live performances of their single tracks. I also recommend that you guys subscribe to MINTBOX RU-vid channel because she literally is our MooMoos Hwasa Fancam Channel😊. She also has most of Mamamoo behind the scene performances going back years.

So glad you played Where are we now. I’m always requesting this one and no one ever plays it. I just adore this mv and song. Mamamoo is the best and only female group I watch.🫶🏻

Only mamamoo can make me cry with a song

Wind flower is my mood when I’m like OK, this is it, we all gonna be fine, just chill with the vibe

windflower is mamamoo members fav too and fandom

thank u for reaction! I knew I could trust moomoos in explaining the back story of both of these songs also it's a cool coincidence that in both mvs in the end they are eating ice creams🥺

Wind flower was a track that grew on me, Moonbyul’s rap is spot on as usual. Where are we now.. that damn song almost made or did make MooMoo’s cry. I just wish it had more Moonbyul.. thought I think all Mamamoo songs need more Moonbyul to equal out the distribution. Where are We Now is the title of an album that was just ballads and that is something I don’t think any other female KPop group has done. Be is promote a ballad or make an album of just ballads. The where are we now video had so many little Easter eggs in the camper trailer.I believe Solar was originally suppose to wear the dress Byul wears and vice versa, but instead Solar ended up in the sexy dress and Byul in the ruffle dress…

The interesting thing about wind flower MV is that its based on Wong Kar Wai's movies and is filmed in Hong Kong (the director is from there and the city itself is kind of a character in the movies) and he's one of the best and most well-known asian directors

Windflower is a fan favorite. Where are we now is about Mamamoo as a group. It's about their journey being together for 7 years as well as the time when I was announced that Wheein left RBW while the rest renewed. She's still part of the group but not at the label anymore.

Did you guys know that on their current tour, they decided to cover each others solos? The moos were screaming their heads off when they realized what was going on

FYI, Wind Flower was filmed in Hong Kong.. happy to say I've possibly walked on the same ground as the girls (I was there probably 5 months after they filmed this)

thanks, you have reacting to 2 of my most favorite songs. yes, mamamoo's group dynamic is no joking, they are close to like family, they have been together for almost 10 years, fighting against inside and outside the music industry, they work real hard from the bottom to the top. They live together in a small roof top house full of Cockroach before debut, it is only big enough for them to sleep side by side on the floor at night. Where are we now has a lot of behind the scene, teasers, documentary etc. you can check in their official yt channel: 1) [마마무] 'Where Are We Now' Special Interview 2) (MMMTV7) EP 10,11,12,14,16 (behind the scene) Enjoy

You should take a look at "Paint Me" because it's such a great song and often overlooked by newer fans in my opinion.

Don't worry just continue going deeper and you would no longer have two or three favourite songs u would definitely fall for all their songs. Both those with mvs and those without. Trust me I am talking from experience. Before I had only title tracks now I have their full OT4 albums and osts, solos albums and osts too. I will always stand for them and support them no matter what happens. They are so talented and lively, there's never a dull moment with them. MAMAMOO IS THE BEST AND WILL ALWAYS REMAIN THE BEST FOR ME whether SOLO or OT4🥰🥰. ✌on your journey into the world of Mamamoo.

ONE OF MY FAVE MMM SONG

i can't watch where are we now without ugly crying tbh 🥲

Idk if y'all noticed but here's another reason to cry: with the song being about their journey as mamamoo and asking themselves what their next step is, notice how at the end of 'Where Are We Now' the final lines "on this beautiful star, the two of us shared the same dream, where are we now?" was sung only by Hwasa and Wheein, alluding to them achieving their childhood dream together 🥺

im waiting for mamamoo

Kard at the end of wind flower omgg .. you guys should check them out!! I feel like you’d love them!

Finally wind flower! Moomoos fave!!!

Fun Fact: "Wind Flower" is not a random name. Mamamoo is referenced as Star (Moonbyul) Wind (Wheein) Flower (Hwasa) Sun (Solar) in their Four Albums series.

in the song where we are now talks about their 8 year career, they're wondering where they are now. Wheein did not renew the contract with the company but will continue to work with MAMAMOO

You should definitely check out the live performance of ‘Where Are We Now’

'On this beautiful star, the two of us shared the same dream' Wheein and Hwasa is friend since school, and they both want to be a singer....

This are the best songs they have among others in b-sides , as a 4 Girl group Mamamoo is my top number 1, next to AEspa and Blackpink, they shine with songs like this

Others have talked in these comments about Where are We Now and it's meaning as it relates to the group themselves. At the time the song and MV were released, we were still speculating on if they were going to break up. I will say I kinda grimaced when you guys said that you felt like they were the closest group... It's not that they're not close, but brace yourselves if you plan on watching the recent 2021 Netflix Mamamoo documentary that is available on RU-vid. It goes deep into the dysfunction of the group and their communication problems. Not trying to be a downer, but for me anyway the knowledge of the sometimes uncomfortable reality of their group dynamic just makes Where Are We Now hit that much harder.

Sorry for spamming. The last phrase in Where Are We Now, sung together by Wheein and Hwasa is emotionally deep considering that they have been friends since middle school.

Moonbyul hair and make up in wind flower era is 👌🏻

MAMAMOO ♥️🤗❤❤❤

Wooohooo more mamamoo content

Where are we now really punches me in the gut every time I sit down and listen to it 😭 I don't see people mentioning this a lot, but Wheein actually didn't renew her contract with the company in 2021 and 2023 will be her last year as a part of Mamamoo 😢 WAWN dropped at about the same time as I heard this, and while I'm happy for her going her own way solo I can't listen to that song without thinking about how they will sound without her voice and it hurts a bit.

Mumumuch. And their cf songs too. Also their ost songs.

Me encantan sus reacciones

Wind flower is one of mamamoo members favorite song too Oh did you ever react to HIP by them?

This is fucking with my depression . Where are we now hits me so hardddddd😢😢😢😢😢😢😢

I’m so early wow 😅

Windflower is i think, without a doubt, moomoo's consensus favorite title track. While HIP is their most popular, i think windflower is the most beloved by fans, so I'm glad you experienced it. Where are we now has a very special meaning to moomoos (as many comments said) and extra to me because it was on my birthday :3 and i think in that time, it's hard to describe how emotional it was during the unsure future of mamamoo. I'm so glad you both enjoyed them!!

The only other look that can compete with Ash Blond Bob Wheein is is Long Blue Hair Wheein.

Me acuerdo cuando salió Where are we now, parecía una canción de despedida por lo de sus contratos, más la letra y la carga emocional, no solté la canción por más de medio año

Star Wind Flower Sun > Solar wrote this to say thank you ; I love too > Solar wrote for all moomoo

Love your reaction 🥰can u guys react to Mamamoo questionable behavior when drunks part 1 ☺️☺️

At that point, I highly recomend you to start their solos music videos. - Hwasa - LMM - Hwasa - I’m a B - Hwasa - Maria - Hwasa - Twit - Moonbyul - Eclipse - Wheein - Watercolor - Wheein - Make me happy - Solar - Spit it out - Solar - Honey You could do a video for Hwasa’s solos. All of them highly recommended

I wonder if you guys would ever react to Moonsun content 🤭

the hints at homosexuality are great. if you didn't know, this whole MV was inspired by some of, Hong Kong's director, Wong Kar-Wai movies, the most known is Fallen Angels (1995) BUT ALSO Happy Together (1997), especifically referenced in the taxi scene. the movie is about a gay man who travels around argentina with his boyfriend but they break up and he can't leave the country. anyway, in this movie the couple does exactly as Solar and Moonbyul in the taxi, leaning her head on her shoulder. they have great taste in movies!! heavely recommend :)

Moonstar ❤️

You have to the emotional part of MAMAMOO - Now I recommend you react to the fun song like TALLER THAN THAT and AZE GAG

Hey, would like to suggest the both of you to react to Moonbyul’s Refuge cover^^

they have realy beautyfull song - Paint Me, try it, i think, u`ll like it

If you like Where Are We Now, you should definetily check out Paint Me. Possibly my most favorite balad from them! (Altough one warning: You'll like Moonbyul even more propably lol)

Should watch i miss you queendom

Really enjoy your reactions, especially to MAMA MAMA MAMAMOO!!!! Please react on YT, to their mv PAINT ME.

I cried when wheein left the company and heard this

Mamamoo is mamamoo. Can you try to react on their queendom stages and individuals performance on their concert? 😍😍

Please react to ‘Paint Me’ by MAMAMOO 💕💕💕

Matching today? That's cute.

AGAIN!!! WITH A CAT SHIRT!!!! Luv it❤❤❤

Please try to react Mamamoo - I Love Too. They wrote that beautiful song for Moomoos and you might cry harder than Where Are We Now ❤️

8:38 ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ 악 ㅋㅋㅋ 너무 웃겨ㅋㅋㅋ

Recommend to react mamamoo queendom performances 😍😍🔥🔥😭😭👑️👑️

Guys react to their consert

Pls also react to their solos :)

Have you been informed of the super hilarious series of vids called "WHEESA exposing MOONSUN". They are crazy fun! MoonSun -- the OG Ship that Sailed Itself. www.youtube.com/@moomoocorners8563/videos

If you liked windflower mv, you should definitely check this out in your own time ru-vid.com/video/%D0%B2%D0%B8%D0%B4%D0%B5%D0%BE-si2s1envgkE.html. This video has lots of references to Hong Kong filmmaker Wong Kar-wai's movies. It's beautiful!

Please react to MAMAMOO tipsy live!!!

마마무 my con 콘서트 리에셩 부탁드립니다

Please reaction where are we now vocals only version in 1theK channel.

Plz do Star Wind Flower Sun!!!

Where Are We Now hits even harder with that final harmony between Wheein and Hwasa when they sing "on this beautiful star the two of us shared the same dream, where are we now?" especially when you know the duo's history. Wheein and Hwasa literally went to grade school and high school together, they're from the same hometown, and have been best friends since they were very young. They both auditioned together for RBW, got in together, trained together, and their dynamic is what inspired RBW's CEO to find members that matched their energy and create Mamamoo. When Hwasa was dealing with internet trolls about her looks, Wheein was there for her. When Wheein was under fire for some stuff her father did (who isn't even in the picture), Hwasa was there for her. They've been through thick and thin with one another. When Hwasa was dealing with anxiety, Wheein was there. Wheein working to cope with her depression, Hwasa was there. They've been with one another through thick and thin. This song was released at a time when their contracts were starting to end; and while Hwasa decided to continue both Mamamoo and solo promotions with RBW; Wheein decided to switch to another company for her solo work with only her Mamamoo promotions being done with RBW. So when they sing "on this beautiful star the two of us shared the same dream, where are we now?" they fully shared the same dream, lived it together, and their journeys are starting to move them away from each other. And so they ask themselves and each other, is our bond still deep? Are we still together? Will our journey end as we walk away? Or is our bond even stronger because no matter what ways our paths go, they will always converge at one point? Is our love for one another enough to conquer the different bridges we are both crossing? It's honestly so heart-wrenching and I love that harmony will all my being.

Great reaction! Wind Flower is my fave Mamamoo songs though all of their songs are my favorite it's just that wind flower hit differently. And same as you guys I did tear up a bit the first time Where Are We Now was release. It was a special song as it was from the album before their contract with RBW expires and we all know the 3 (Solar, Monnbyul, and Hwasa) renew their contract and Wheein decided to move to another label agency, but she had a special contract wherein if there are group promotions she will be readily available for Mamamoo that's how much committed she is to the group.