Creating the Overworld ! A Community-driven Project - Devlog 

I like the idea of RNG, but I'd toss an option in the options menu to make it static. Seems like almost everything becomes a speedrunning game any more and runners would love you for including that option.

Damn... Working on two projects at the same time and managing your time so efficiently... That definitely is something I want to develop as a dev. And I hope I could do it some time.

I realized that you forgot the first step, building your own game engine. Looking forward to that in the next devlog!

Finally i cannot wait you made amazing progress with this game you are one of the youtubers that i love to watch please continue with this game its got potential

One thing that could be used with or instead of RNG is adding a stat that increases the quantity/quality of the loot gained, similar to the looting enchantment in Minecraft. This would give the player a reason to revisit old dungeons while also encouraging them to progress in the game instead of getting caught up grinding to optimize one dungeon.

Another nicely done devlog! 💯 Super interesting, as always :)

vraiment tres chouette ce projet c'est magnifique, incroyable ta productivité !

Hey! I feel like RNG for the mob drops is a good idea. I don't think that it is necessarily a bad thing to be able to run a dungeon over and get better results. Almost like a mini high score system. I think it would make the aspect of assigning raiders to dungeons more interesting too.

Instead of complete drop RNG, you could implement a progression system that motivates the player to re-run the dungeon at certain points in the game to increase the loot. At first, the player only cares for clearing speed since the loot is always the same. The dungeons design could be done in a way where it is not immediately clear how to finish the dungeon as fast as possible, leading the player to take a few attempts in clearing as fast as possible. Then, after completing some progression in research or maybe obtaining an expensive item to upgrade a dungeon, the dungeon can be upgraded to be harder but also provide more loot. At this point the player will re-run previously cleared dungeons.

very well made video again

I think RNG in the way of quantity is good. However, I think items should be based on what enemy you're fighting, having each type drop a specific loot every time. Kind of a best of both worlds situation

Personaly I am against rng loot tables. In an automation game I want consistent in- and outputs

Nice!

I'm always so impressed by how much progress you make in a workday. I know this is full time for you, so you're getting a lot of hours in, but have you found anything useful when it comes to productivity? The game is shaping up great so far. And I love the Tao intro. 😹

nice devlog. you should also try to add some shadows to ui, cause to me it seems too flat

Such an efficient humain being!

Move to Godot!

What if the player could determine the loot and the speed of his dungeon helpers for each dungeon run by the players best time + loot? That would add a motivation to re-run the dungeons and optimize your runs as a player, because your helpers could get faster and/or get more loot per run.

If you go down rng drops then the automation should run the statistics on its output since the rng makes dungeons nondeterministic

timberborn est incroyable :o

I would just give the mobs loot tables similar to the way minecraft handles it. If you know exactly what you'll get every single time you kill something the game will start to feel same-y and lose that exciting "I wonder what's going to happen" factor. I like some of the suggestions I've seen so far as well, which is to add some sort of player stat that can improve the rates or quality of drops you receive. Since these dungeons are going to be automated and ran by the npcs after progressing into the game anyway I think it ultimately doesn't matter which way you land on this. But I think some variance is nice to have.

Wtf haha I literally had the exact idea of making an idle game where the core mechanic is running dungeons which gets recorded and replayed for loot. I opted to make something els instead, though

Add RNG, also love your vids!

A pour quand une suite sur Med Dyn ?

Another vote against RNG for the loot - - the optimization for time is already there, no need for a grind.

How long is the discount active for?

I like the RNG but maybe it's a good idea to increase the chance of getting loot when you didn't get it (when you earned that specific loot the percentages reset to the initial value). For me is kinda stressful when you need a resource and the RNG plays against you

I kinda like keeping the RNG as it "feels" right. To mitigate the urge to min-max, perhaps each dungeon could have a "run counter" and the automated dungeon raids take N*counter seconds longer to complete. So you could run again for better loot or a faster time, but each time you attempt it your end result is a little bit slower. Alternatively, a progressively increasing "retry tax". There are a variety of ways to discourage this sort of min-maxing and I think that's better than neutering the RNG. :)

I think the Loots shouldn't be rng as I would totaly farm a dungeon to get a better score, I think you should be able to get more drops from a dungeon but not from rng, more from something skill related like time or hidden rooms

The rng systeme will be a bad thing if it only encourage to redo the dungeon until the player get great rate. Rng is only here to give a feeling to the player, it should make him sad or joyful. So in that case, rng should be lock after the first run i think. So all dungeon will be different, evenif the mob quantity and type are the same

"putain" haha

YES YOU'RE A CAT PERSON

I’ve noticed something about your UIs that makes them look amateurish - scaling. Some of the smaller elements are simply scaled down versions of other elements, creating inconsistent levels of detail and visual weight. Additionally, even some elements of similar size have varying scales, further adding to the inconsistency. Beyond that, things are looking good.

i don't know why is this even a question, rng just feels better. people wouldn't go in the casinos or the arcades if a win was guaranteed. because it's boring and doesn't feel rewarding at all, because there's no dopamine rush idk the idea of making loot drop from enemies not rng seems... illogical to me, to put it nicely edit: i hope that's obvious that i don't mean rng like "oh you either get 1 or 37819101017 of [thing]" lol

don't put drag and drop panels at 2 ends of the screen. put them side to side to reduce the pointer's travel distance. it will be as annoying as the default unity editor layout