@@Prdfls69 this is not possible and in future also it's not. But cyberpunk has improve itself a lot .. if you sees comparison between earlier cyberpunk and now then it's completely different...
The developers have really improved Cyberpunk, but rdr2 is still the most detailed and realistic game ever made. It would probably stay like that until 2024-2025
The first thing i noticed about rdr2 was how insane the graphics were. Literally the first mission had me amazed at the detail in the snow and distances, on top of the horses, buildings, characters all looking like a movie
In terms of physics, Cyberpunk might have improved a lot from what it was initially but still it is no where close to RDR2. RDR2 is the most realistic game built till date, developers have really thought and worked in and out on each and every detail of this game.
@@Ayush-sn8gd they've been like that before rdr2 released, so whats your points?? And the remaster wasnt done by them, hence is why they used Unreal Engine instead of RAGE... Secondly, why would you preorder a game without seeing its gameplay etc, that was dumb of you
@@f9oeks965 wtf you mean? Im supposed to be homeless?? Ya know, you can go outside all day, and then play rdr2 all night. Also, its been out for like 5 years. Your comment is stupid and makes no sense
The problem is that we all thought that Cyberpunk was going to be the chosen one for being better than RDR2,but because all the bugs and problems,that didn’t happen,but in my opinion,after the patch 1,5 Cyberpunk 2077 is a really good and enjoyable game.
@@sillybear7605 POV:You haven't play the game,but because when the game came out it had a lot of bugs and they made memes I will think that the game sucks
Rdr2 remains the most detailed game until now, but I'm very happy they're working on fixing Cyberpunk because it has potential and it's a fun game overall
Although rdr2 is better, It must be recognized that Cyberpunk has improved a lot in what was wrong, and it looks very good (sorry if I wrote it wrong, I don't speak English)
Still a bad game with boring story and garbage protagonist and characters. The Bug and Details weren't the main problem of the game. Even if they were great from start, Its a still boring and forgotten game.
Cyberpunk may have improved from when it was initially released but it’s still really the bare minimum of what was expected. I don’t think it deserves any praise for finally being able to achieve what most games have been able to do for over ten years now. Besides, RDR2 still looks far better.
Most of the issues in game were either coding ,physics or half assed promises but other than that, the visuals story and overall experience post 1.5 makes the game a very solid 8 without highballing
@@BBeowulf I just want to say the game is definitely a better RPG than Witcher3 in terms of combat and gameplay ..I see a lot of hate thrown around this game and I am kinda fed up of it truth to be told I played the game after 1.5 didn't touch it but after playing it I was pleasantly surprised how good the game is... and besides I played RDR2 as well it has one of the most immersive open world and brilliant top tier story but has the worst GamePlay loop ever and it's a decade old it gets real boring on second run.. while Cyberpunk may have repeated questlines they refined gigs in the patch to be more layered and gameplay is much better than Rdr2 . gameplay variety can be described as a bit of witcher3 and a slice of Deus ex and watchdogs a bit of farcry and a bit of mirrors edge( I really like the Parkour in cp2077 it's wierdly fun). and a bit of COD. let me look into Rdr2s gameplay loop and variety- stealth only in specific story beats and itsn't even viable most of the time because once you hit a guy everyone goes crazy and mostly it's just guns blazing.. and gameplay loop oh let me start describe how unfun it is in the second run start mission->long ass trailing-->reach destination->something goes wrong->guns blazing rinse and repeat this is basically entire R* games in a nutshell I think Rdr2 is my favorite game of all time but tbh it has some really serious flaws in its game design
I’m sad about the bad rep that cyberpunk now has as people nowadays don’t even give it a chance. Im not trying to sweep the train reck of a launch under the rug but the sheer amount of bugs and features that they have added over the last year and a bit is truly breath taking i I recommend you give it another chance for the story.
@@whitewolf2679 el problema no es el juego en sí, la culpa es del marketing, que nos vendia un juego que no "existia" ni existirá, problemas, mentiras, decepcion, etc. Si ciberpunk no hubiese tenido el marketing el paradigma seria distinto y el juego tendria mejor aceptacion, sin embargo no fue asi, tengo que decirlo friamente, cyberpunk es una basura (respecto a lo que nos prometieron)
I'm still confused why people had such high hopes and expectations for Cyberpunk 2077. What made The Witcher 3 great was its worldbuilding, writing, storytelling, characters. It all blended perfectly and the obviously passionate dev team matched very well with creating that fantasy world that draws heavily from the themes of historical Europe. But it's a completely different skillset to create tech that simulates a living open world set in modern times like Rockstar's been doing. TW3 did not have that kind of technology. It had preset and named NPCs with routines, and it looked alright, but nothing like Rockstar's background NPCs driving, walking, idling. That shit isn't easy to do, and Ubisoft had to pour a lot of resources over a long time to make similar open worlds at least look respectable compared to Rockstar. CDPR was just way out of their depth stepping into this field.
The problem was, as far as the PC and current gen (PS5/xbseriesx/s) versions are concerned, people over-hyped themselves. Like really over hyped themselves, cyberpunk, even in it's earliest form is exactly what I expected it to be coming from the Witcher 3. Great characters/story lines, alright gameplay and respectable but limited open world. I'm pleased to see cyberpunk tackle rdr 2 in the very latest patch. The overwhelming hate came from the newer crowd who had no clue what cdpr games are like. Though I'll admit the last gen fiasco did leave a very sour taste in my mouth, even I can't defend that, cdpr instead of going full corpo (ha ha) should've just scrapped the last gen releases. But yeah, that's about it. See ya.
@@johnlouie5088 They didn't promise. Marketing speak is not a promise. We've had games for 40+ years now, you should be able to distinguish actual promises from gameplay demos compared to CGI trailers and lists of what the marketing team says there will be.
@@blinkachu5275 marketing is literally promising, tf are u smoking? Why market the game as the next gen of open world gaming when it dosent even have the core physics and AI of a last gen game.
Yea, No way Cyberpunk defeats RDR2 😂😂 Cool vid and very cool to see devs are still trying to make the game perfect as it should have been when it launched
Of course not. Cyberpunk was made by inexperienced amateurs. Its trash. RDR 2 was made by experienced talented developers and its a masterpiece. Also the developers of Cyberpunk will go bankrupt soon because almost everyone refunded Cyberjunk.
but the thing is, is that its to late now, it has a permanent reputation of being a bad game. they shouldve done this stuff before the game actually came out.
Cyberpunk came out 3 years later so it should be better graphically although red dead did have a huge budget. I still think rdr2 is a million miles better than Cyberpunk and I like Cyberpunk but rdr2 is in the top 5 greatest games ever made
I think comparing these two games supposed to be an April Joke! Otherwise Rdr2 is an alive openworld game with its individual features completely Realistic which made me never tired of playing that since I repeat some actions 1574774684674645853 times and I was curious for doing it again for 1574774684674645854 time.
@@exysa2798 st that really amazed me was this fact that some of game supervisors and game designing engineers had not noticed some crucial failurs in the game until the game was released! That was shocking I mean how on earth could happen such thing in this level? Do they have any game testers? They have made some great products like witcher3 and this one was out of that line of work. as you said CP is mostly look Cyberjunk totally.
@@MehranHayati8803 All The Witcher 3 developers left CDPR after The Witcher 3 because of crunch, bad workplace culture, etc. Cyberpunk was made by new inexperienced amateurs. Thats why its so trash. It was Not made by The Witcher 3 talent. They had testers but they were trash too. Everyone was inexperienced trash.
I'm a huge fan of Cyberpunk but RDR2 is in another league entirely. Cyberpunk definitely has some gorgeous lighting and textures but what rockstar was able to do without rtx back then was incredible and it still looks amazing today compared to other newer games.
Agree, Valhalla on Ultra comes pretty close to RDR2 in all areas. Bigger too, although of course RDR2 is rooted in reality while Valhalla isn't. But still, they are two of my favorite games ever. I can't even play an hour in Cyberpunk before the lack of polish gets to me and I have to quit.
I knew red Dead 2 was super detailed but this vid is pointing out things I don't really focus on while playing it. They really wrote a love letter to gaming with it. The time and effort they must have put into every detail.
Yes. Everyone hates Cyberpunk and CDPR now. No one will ever buy their next game. And CDPR will go bankrupt soon anyways because almost everyone refunded Cyberjunk.
The fact that Red Dead Redemption is not even a first person game and can still compete with Cyberpunk is *a testament to just how much time was put into attention and detail, eh?* 😳🤯
@@Herbertis123 I’ve seen those mods on RU-vid. Can you do it on PlayStation 4 like as an in game feature? Sidenote, would you recommend it? I’m currently playing my way through Ghosts of Tsushima (amazing! I highly recommend if you haven’t picked it up) and I need something to play when I finish, so would you recommend Red Dead Redemption?
@@djvelocity its already implemented in the game you can just press a button and it will be first person and yes anybody that has played the game would reccomend it because of its truly amazing story and realism
@@djvelocity Like the other guy said, there is a dedicated setting to enter first person mode and I would recommend Red Dead Redemption if you are into games driven by satisfying combat and amazing storytelling, also not to forget about the incredible graphics!
Shooting water: tie Grenades in water: RDR2 Shooting NPC’s: RDR2 Shooting vehicles: RDR2 Fire: tie (I think fire itself looks better in CP, but the spread is better in RDR2) Swimming: RDR2 Glass: RDR2 Jumping from high: RDR2 NPC swimming: RDR2 Ladder: RDR2 (I had hands not touching ladder once in my CP play through) Shooting lights: tie (hard to compare lanterns and street lights) Bombing vehicles: tie (hard to compare horse and buggy to automobile)
@*smirk* By now, both very good games. RDR2 is a masterpiece, CP got released way too early but is really good by now and will keep improving. I enjoyed both games a lot, and they are very different.
One strong point of Rockstar games is that they never overhype their game and underdeliver ,infact their games are even better than shown in trailers (well that was true up until recent GTA trilogy definitive edition) This is why they have such good reputation. Cyberpunk 2077 itself isn't a bad game but the overhype and marketting it as the greatest open world game before release made people wrong impression about the game and left disappointment. They should have just shown some gameplay footage and not overhype it in the trailers people would have still praised Cyberpunk despite flaws because CDPR had built a great reputation after The Witcher 3 Wild Hunt.
It's really sad to see how little effort they decided to put on Cyberpunk 2077's details... I'm glad players shitstormed the game because it clearly deserves it.
No little effort. They just can't do it better. Cyberpunk was made by 500 inexperienced amateurs. Thats why its so trash. RDR 2 was made by 1500 experienced talented. developers.
I mean the NPC's are glitching through the ground in Cyberpunk. Cars are flying through everything. In Rdr2 its just sometimes a horse spawning randomly or weather changes instant
@@dqvmig3901 It's known that weather changes instantly sometimes, when you enter some places or a "scene". Also the one with the horses was like: The horse with the rider spawned in the air and fell down xD
@@dqvmig3901 Nah I mean: It's not wanted from the developers that the weather doesn't change fluently. And also the horse spawning in the air. But I don't care because it's rare. Also it's funny sometimes. In the end, the mistakes of the development of Cyberpunk has more game ruining consequences than the one of Rdr2
U see that dynamite thing, if u keep the dynamite in ur hand without throwing, Arthur will automatically cut the fuse before it's over. U see this kinda stuff 😃 that level detailing😳🤯
Cyberpunk is getting better the more and more they fix it and it has a lot of potential especially when they start implementing online multiplayer stuff I like futuristic Fifth Element type stuff is awesome. But Red Dead 2 is the most detailed meticulous game I've ever played the amount of detail in that game is breathtaking there is no game that can even come close to what Red Dead 2 World experience and detail. But they do need to add a lot more stuff to have a really good experience. But I've had a very good time with just going around exploring and doing the roll stuff. There is a lot of stuff they could add into it that would make it a lot more fun and overall better experience online. The fact that they don't have Indian territories is crazy to me. They missed out on a lot of stuff with that just like San Andreas with the gang territories if they just Implement Indian territories that would be crazy. Also needs train Heist any type of heist would be amazing.
CyberPunk improved A Lot. But If We See The Details Of Red Dead It Ahead Of It time. Also Say That Red Dead Have A Master piece Graphics In Terms Of Graphics And Gameplay And Main Part Is Story. Arthur Morgan Best Protagonist Ever Made ..
Cyberpunk destroys RDR2? Cyberpunk: released December 2020 - almost 2 years later > became decent RDR2: released October 2018 - almost 4 years later > still owning every game I have both, in cyberpunk NPCs are dumb NPCs, in RDR2 NPCs. are people.
Red Dead redemption 2 base game runs perfectly on PS4 fat and xbox one fat, RDR2 day 1 master piece. Cyberpunk 2077 needs a lots of patches to run stable in next gen consoles and Run decently on old gen consoles (dont forget the bunch of Bugs), Cyberpunk 2077 after almost two years a decent game. There's Is not comparision RDR2 have better World, graphics, and mechanics and a loot better development.
Cyberpunk may be in a better state then previous but it is in my opinion in NO WAY better then RDR2 in realism and overall quality. Great video though. 👍✌️
@@arindammishra2329 I hope not. :D Cyberpunk 2077 is in a right state from the point of view of realism. The Cyberpunk and RPG genre don't need as much realism as RDR2 needs. The cybernetic extensions and the RPG system makes the game unreal and maybe they could add some details, like more destruction and similar elements, but it is not a requirement for a good game.
Rdr2 is what started every company to pay attention to detail. Well rockstar, but rdr2 took it to a new level of its own, nothing will and can touch rdr2 thats why is the best game on top of story and graphics.
Cyberpunk still lacks depth though. Detail is cool, but RDR2 has complex ecosystems and NPC systems. Glass shatter effects may be nice, but seeing animals dynamically interact with one another is more impressive
bro cyberpunk 2077 is does not even deserve to stand near RDR2 just today i found a new mystery in RDR2 and saw on youtube that nobody had made a video about it . All i want say is howeever old RDR2 is (2018 four years) you can still find hidden stuff in it and it is the most detailed game in gaming history and the story telling so on point its litrely perfect
RDR2 came out 3 years ago and worked just fine. While it’s going to take 3 years for Cyberpunk to just work how it’s supposed to work. So my friend you can miss me with this bs.
RDR2 is still better as an open world game. I admire that CDPR hasn't given up on Cyberpunk but CDPR doesn't have Rockstar's experience at making open worlds, they overestimated themselves with Cyberpunk. Even Witcher 3 didn't have that much attention to detail, we liked Witcher 3 because of it's story and quests.
Bought cyber punk the day it came out…tried to like it for like two weeks before asking for my money back (which I got) I don’t care how much work they have put into it…it was pure shit when it came out…just because they polished it doesn’t make it stink any less….this is a terrible comparison, RDR2 blows this game out of the water
6:46 - Why did you decide to test this particular lamp? There are lamps on the road that, after the first shot, stop shining, and after the second shot, they simply break and fall on the road.
Rdr2 is all about interactions, little details, and answer for all the questions gamers throw at it. Amazing AI, lots of little things. While cyberpunk improved it is still bunch of plastic dolls while RDR2 world is a living place. I wish CP77 be detailed like RDR2 but it simply isn't.
