Тёмный

D&D Monks are GOOD, Actually 

Pointy Hat
Подписаться 338 тыс.
Просмотров 594 тыс.
50% 1

Monks in D&D sure do get a bad rap, but I'm here to talk about why they're good, or rather, they are fine.
Go check out the Petero's Tome of Adventure! bit.ly/3p9WoB9
This book contains basically anything you could ever need to eliminate prep from your D&D game, with 12+ Adventures (more to unlock in stretch goals), 20+ Monsters, 48+ NPCs, 50+ Magic Items, 12+ Battle Maps and much, much more. The kickstarter is live right now, so go see all the goodies for yourself!
Check out the Monk Way of the Flesh HERE!
docs.google.com/document/d/e/...
Video Editing by the amazing Bia: / bnazf
Writing, Illustration, and Narration by me: / antodemico
Additional sketches by the amazing Fey: / feymilde

Развлечения

Опубликовано:

 

14 май 2024

Поделиться:

Ссылка:

Скачать:

Готовим ссылку...

Добавить в:

Мой плейлист
Посмотреть позже
Комментарии : 3,3 тыс.   
@pointyhatstudios
@pointyhatstudios 11 месяцев назад
I'm sure this comment section will be very peaceful and serene 😊 no fighting 😇 no arguments 🥰 good vibes only 😘
@crustmass9
@crustmass9 11 месяцев назад
Ofc mr Pointy Hat
@valentinbayer1108
@valentinbayer1108 11 месяцев назад
We would never!
@dominicadorno5917
@dominicadorno5917 11 месяцев назад
I think there is something wrong the Google Doc link, it takes me to Oath of Love Paladin that you did.
@Skimmer951
@Skimmer951 11 месяцев назад
Nu uh they started it!
@realhuman4879
@realhuman4879 11 месяцев назад
I don’t want peace, I want problems always
@Ashen-Crow
@Ashen-Crow 11 месяцев назад
It's so weird to me that monks don't get like a shit ton of free stats. They are all over the place so they benefit greatly from spreaded stats AND their fantasy is all about self-improvement, body and mind.
@saparapatepete
@saparapatepete 11 месяцев назад
Yeah, i think the fantasy of monk could be achieved better by replacing some of the most situational monk abilities with an increase in stats more frequently, maybe some levels give a bonus on dexterity, wisdom or even constitution in exchange of....as the video says "being naked".
@jettlucashayes8508
@jettlucashayes8508 11 месяцев назад
They used to get 20 in every stat in the beta of dnd 5e
@JoeKeyes
@JoeKeyes 11 месяцев назад
Yeah, it's strange that rogues get an additional asi but monks do not.
@Cas-Se78.97
@Cas-Se78.97 11 месяцев назад
@@saparapatepete Maybe extra hp each level instead of a flat con buff (I mean they should also have a d10 hit die but that's a whole other issue)? It might fit the fantasy of these honed martial artists just wailing on each other and getting back up.
@sidecharacter7165
@sidecharacter7165 11 месяцев назад
@@jettlucashayes8508 That should be the capstone. Perfect Self = Perfect stats.
@The_Zxirius
@The_Zxirius 11 месяцев назад
"Kamehameha or whatever ungodly name your local translator gave the ball of energy Goku and pals shoot at people" master Pointy that sentence had such vitality to it
@Lilith_Harbinger
@Lilith_Harbinger 11 месяцев назад
Agreed, but frankly if you understand Japanese it's not much better. Kamehameha is roughly turtle destruction wave. Turtle because master Roshi was from the turtle clan.
@juliamavroidi8601
@juliamavroidi8601 11 месяцев назад
We don't accept Schockwelle der alten Ahnen slander in this house!
@Southgate1868
@Southgate1868 11 месяцев назад
@@Lilith_Harbingerthere was a Hawaiian Royal Family named Kamehameha after it’s founder, Kamehameha
@IsaSaien
@IsaSaien 9 месяцев назад
"Monks are good, actually" proceeds to explain in detail why monks are not good Loved the video btw
@cattiston374
@cattiston374 8 месяцев назад
Loved the “If the Monks sucks ass why doesn’t the Warlock suck too 😎?” Spells, they have spells, and let me tell you that 1 Hypnotic Pattern per every encounter is much better than 2-3 stun attempts lmao. Nevermind that Warlocks have good features that USUALLY don’t feed off their spells, and those that do suck ass anyways lol.
@crystallxix1493
@crystallxix1493 6 месяцев назад
@@cattiston374they also have actually good features that dont over-rely on finite resources
@mr.zendar885
@mr.zendar885 4 месяца назад
I mean... Fly + eldritch blast = Win With all the ways you can increase the range of E.B, you can be outside the range of actually Ballista. Example; You can fly directly towards any encounter and always have both the range and high ground advantage.
@dudejoe24
@dudejoe24 3 месяца назад
@@crystallxix1493 i hear this argument alot even tho most of the argument is still the damage output even tho i feel people just don't know how to manage points because people think they always need to stun strike even tho no you don't and some of the subclasses who do use ki don't use much but people treat it like its the end of the world
@crystallxix1493
@crystallxix1493 3 месяца назад
@@dudejoe24 I’m not sure I understand what you’re saying, there’s no commas or a clear line of thought xD. Could you rewrite that?
@darthmaul8278
@darthmaul8278 9 месяцев назад
I love the idea of a Monk with maybe 2 Barbarian levels that uses unarmed strikes and is kind of flavoured like Godfrey phase 2 from Elden Ring
@theeye8276
@theeye8276 9 месяцев назад
You can skip monk and take the unarmed fighting style
@Bandopede
@Bandopede 8 месяцев назад
Made a character exactly like that and it was rough... Unarmed fighting style dropped like a month after the campaign started 😒
@redmilk2861
@redmilk2861 8 месяцев назад
Or The Hulk, you know with rage and everything
@Cthulhu357
@Cthulhu357 5 месяцев назад
Thts how i made karlach in bg3!!!She is super fun being played that way
@swordpvnk
@swordpvnk 5 месяцев назад
rage monk with tavern brawler punch hard
@zibbitybibbitybop
@zibbitybibbitybop 11 месяцев назад
Monks are particularly fun with a permissive DM that lets the player lean way into the whole "you can just run up walls and generally be a ninja" shtick. The monk player in my current Strahd campaign gets into all kinds of shit because she plays the character like an incredibly nimble, kleptomaniac Leeroy Jenkins, it's really funny.
@thomascook3336
@thomascook3336 11 месяцев назад
This is what I have noticed a lot. The monks are great in campaigns that have dynamic combat or exploration.
@Dunybrook
@Dunybrook 11 месяцев назад
That's not so much permissive as just letting the class do what it should be able to do.
@TheRawrnstuff
@TheRawrnstuff 11 месяцев назад
And that's what the class is kinda built for. It irks me when some people adamantly claim a monk is a frontline class, but then go on listing all the reasons why it isn't, and get upset about it. Like, pick a lane, people. The monk is at their weakest when forced to stay locked in melee. A huge chunk of their suite is dedicated to getting out of melee, or to do things you wouldn't do in melee, like reducing damage from ranged weapons. What the monk player should do, tactically speaking, is run around the edges of the battle map, taking advantage of things like elevation, take out enemy ranged support, and generally get to places where an unspent action is needed - all of which monks can do even without magic or equipment.
@zibbitybibbitybop
@zibbitybibbitybop 11 месяцев назад
​@@Dunybrook I meant more that it's always possible for the DM to nitpick the exact wording of the monk's movement rules in order to limit them, but my current DM is smart enough not to do that. He actually lets the monk get away with some stuff that she's technically not even supposed to be able to do going by RAW, but no one cares because the results are too much fun.
@alexanderthegreat6682
@alexanderthegreat6682 11 месяцев назад
Ooooo I can see how a monk would be really useful in Curse of Strahd
@minaly22
@minaly22 11 месяцев назад
There's just something so fun about watching a pointy hat emote with a single eye and get placed on top of the heads of countless meme-able people.
@clusterfox6143
@clusterfox6143 8 месяцев назад
The Bene Gesserit sisterhood is kinda monk like too, with all their abilities coming from a mastery of their minds and bodies. They can use the voice to influence people, store diseases within their own bodies they can infect others with at will (which is why duke Harkonnen is like that), slow thier own aging although it is forbidden, access genetic memories, move at almost superhuman speed, predict enemy movements based on barely perceptible muscle twitches. Monks don't have to be wushu coded. They can be a network of manipulative witch nuns too.
@loukaspaquette2544
@loukaspaquette2544 9 месяцев назад
I agree but the Way of The Shadow incorporates the Ninja theme for monks and I’m kinda disappointed you didn’t mention them. But I’m happy you reminded us of their niche abilities and gave monks a good shine. ✨
@TheDapperSaint
@TheDapperSaint 8 месяцев назад
Kensei monks remind me a lot of samurais tbh
@ryanweible9090
@ryanweible9090 8 месяцев назад
@@TheDapperSaint honestly, both feel like they are trying to bring over some of the old eastern setting with the less than well aged name that abbreviats to OA, which had samurai, ninja and martial arts. which makes sense as there was kind of the forgotten realms version with kara-tur and the 3rd edition OA, but now its kind of baked in.
@Peavey311
@Peavey311 7 месяцев назад
This, absolutely.
@TheEnder515
@TheEnder515 4 месяца назад
I used Way of Shadow monk/Assassin rogue multiclass as an NPC assassin against my players years ago. Oh, she was so powerful. In the end, they wound up letting her kill them before letting a contingency spell they'd set up revive them. They just couldn't pass the perception checks against her stealth abilities.
@johnlannet3370
@johnlannet3370 2 месяца назад
​@TheEnder515 I did too. And she is a Tabaxi. She is great at either sneak killing them or annoying them to no end. Or both.
@mark-eq7xg
@mark-eq7xg 11 месяцев назад
Just wanted to say I've added like half your Google docs to my bookmarks bar. I use this stuff RELIGIOUSLY for some of my campaigns. Amestris has never been weirder or more terrifying, and I'm very happy about it! My players, maybe not, but they're still around, so good enough!
@carythacker8049
@carythacker8049 11 месяцев назад
Amestris???? 😳
@mark-eq7xg
@mark-eq7xg 11 месяцев назад
@@carythacker8049 The world that I built for the players. Its got everything from an entire nation of Death worshipping necromancers who use the dead as militia, steampunk enthusiasts with a love for explosions and politics to the Dread Myre filled with eldritch aberrations and the pirate adventures of the Thousand Illes.
@JaredClaunch
@JaredClaunch 11 месяцев назад
a campaign set in Amestris, full of Pointy Hat’s shenanigans sounds like an incredibly fun time!
@DerrickBarrows
@DerrickBarrows 11 месяцев назад
Since you have play tested many of pointy hat's creations, can I ask how they feel on balance? I am pretty new to dnd. One of his class ideas I read sounded pretty overpowered but I imagine I wouldn't know unless I tried them. What do you think?
@mark-eq7xg
@mark-eq7xg 11 месяцев назад
@@DerrickBarrows So, for reference, I've only gone through a few in session. In no particular order, one of my players uses the Phantasm Race (and no one knows yet, somehow, which we both find hilarious). The Sorceror Lich (Hierarch) is one of the BBEGs (there are several), the Blight is set up as a fallen nation on the border that no one wants to admit to, government secret style, the Restless is hunting one of the party members, and Hellish Adepts are working for the one of the BBEGs. On average, it all works, at least overall. Remember, I use lots of Homebrew to balance out the crazy, so take that with a dump truck of salt. In detail, the Hellish Adepts can be awkward if the party isn't RP savvy enough to unravel the weaknesses and strengths of the Adept they're fighting. The Phantasm is a little awkward RP-wise since it's hard to firmly say, 'This is against my goal,' so my player using it has to hash stuff out with me on that. The Blight run isn't for a while yet, but the Restless is GREAT for building tension and is currently driving our sorcerer up the wall trying to figure out why his exhaustion levels won't stop rising. The Hierarch can require some in-game tweaking to ensure they aren't too broken, like if the number of family members under him/her doesn't just steamroll the party. Overall though, this stuff is awesome.
@Windwolf001
@Windwolf001 11 месяцев назад
For every shonen, you can find a new monk subclass. This should be the lesson we take home after this video.
@eunicezayas3216
@eunicezayas3216 3 месяца назад
Freaking... Hunter x Hunter Zoldyck subclass 😂
@l3gend576
@l3gend576 10 месяцев назад
The quivering palm thing has so much potential for a sick ass scene where you spend 15 ki points over 5 rounds and then just snap and all 5 of the opponents you we’re fighting just collapse but since that’s a 17th level feature odds are your party has cleaned up by then since they’re also level 17
@sonyabeam292
@sonyabeam292 23 дня назад
If I remember right can only be used one one opponent at a time
@T1nyRaccoon
@T1nyRaccoon 6 месяцев назад
Monk: walks up to BBEG and uses quivering palm. BBEG: dies
@TieberiusVoidWalker
@TieberiusVoidWalker 3 месяца назад
They saved and take 55 damage than kill the monk next round since they have bad armor and health.
@sidneyrobinson18
@sidneyrobinson18 2 месяца назад
​@@TieberiusVoidWalkerI rolled high so my monk has a 19 ac lol
@TieberiusVoidWalker
@TieberiusVoidWalker 2 месяца назад
@@sidneyrobinson18 Thats an anecdote, rolling for stats doesn't prove anything but luck. If you used point buy your AC would suffer a lot more. Doesn't really change the fact that monks have bad AC.
@sidneyrobinson18
@sidneyrobinson18 2 месяца назад
@@TieberiusVoidWalker even with point buy you can get ~16 ac at the start
@TieberiusVoidWalker
@TieberiusVoidWalker 2 месяца назад
@@sidneyrobinson18 16 AC is pretty bad. I would never enter melee with 16 AC. At about level 3 you're just gonna suffer unless the DM is being nice. Second of all your AC isn't going to improve all that much because even if you use all your ASIs into Wis and Dex (which isn't even worth it) you're ac will grow so slowly and monster's to hit will be so high that youre incredibly squishy
@valentingigena6058
@valentingigena6058 11 месяцев назад
I love how every character has parents with high expectations
@choking1668
@choking1668 11 месяцев назад
Asian culture is drilled into the monk class 💀
@valentingigena6058
@valentingigena6058 11 месяцев назад
@@choking1668 i mean every character created by pointy hat
@BanditNation602
@BanditNation602 11 месяцев назад
He must be writing from experience
@whisperingsage89
@whisperingsage89 10 месяцев назад
They wouldn't have been adventurers otherwise.
@korvincarry3268
@korvincarry3268 10 месяцев назад
Sometimes we write what we know. Pointy hat... i understand
@not_nob0dy
@not_nob0dy 11 месяцев назад
Link to the build goes to the love paladin as a heads up
@patrikheijus4242
@patrikheijus4242 11 месяцев назад
Have you found way of the flesh anywhere else?
@BramLastname
@BramLastname 11 месяцев назад
I refreshed the page and it's fixed now.
@thehonestcompany867
@thehonestcompany867 11 месяцев назад
Talk about way of the "flesh" lol
@crispee_bills
@crispee_bills 11 месяцев назад
Is the link to the fear monster still broken?
@icarue993
@icarue993 11 месяцев назад
@@thehonestcompany867 way of (re)fresh :P
@literaltrash3351
@literaltrash3351 10 месяцев назад
one niche benefit of monks that i kind of appreciate is the viability of low damage weapons like whips and darts because the monk weapon damage can be replaced with your martial arts die
@momqabt
@momqabt 6 месяцев назад
You forget: whips are martial weapons. Before the optional features (which, to remind, are STILL OPTIONAL) you couldn't get it without sacrificing an ASI or multiclassing. Also, monks martial arts die and low damage weapons: any archer build with sharpshooter, do the math. 2 unoptimized fighter archers with sharpshooter if they roll high on ini can kill Vecna before he acts. Give me the math for 2 monks (straight class unoptimized) and cry me a river.
@literaltrash3351
@literaltrash3351 6 месяцев назад
@@momqabt that must have been one optimized sharpshooter archer build to manage to get that stick so far up your ass.
@gojicandle8188
@gojicandle8188 5 месяцев назад
@@momqabt Local man misses point of comment and also entire point of video. More at 9
@themoleznezz
@themoleznezz 5 месяцев назад
@@momqabt "unoptimized" "sharpshooter" Lol. That translates to your problem with monks is "can't use Sharpshooter." That barely has anything to do with the class.
@dudejoe24
@dudejoe24 3 месяца назад
@@momqabt *laughs in variant human and elven* but real talk bro the dude was just trying to be positive and you just came in like a piss baby for no reason and then talk about an unrelated topic
@matthewstanley1521
@matthewstanley1521 10 месяцев назад
I actually leaned into the supposed "monks being weak in combat" thing and homebrewed a subclass focusing solely on supporting allies. I called it the Way of the Guru. It gives players the aesthetic of a wizened teacher guiding others on the path to greatness. Mechanics-wise, it mostly involves use of the Help action at earlier levels, and at higher levels gaining the ability to grant other creatures additional buffs through consistent training sessions.
@1.red.panda.1
@1.red.panda.1 11 месяцев назад
A home rule you can implement is people can exchange health points for ki. People pushing their bodies so far that it *hurts* . They *need* to help their friends. They *need* to win. So much so that they are willing to give all that they *are* to this cause.
@Drekromancer
@Drekromancer 10 месяцев назад
That definitely seems to help with the whole sustain vs. burst dichotomy between monks and rogues. I'd give the monks d10 Hit Die for that, too.
@thecactusman17
@thecactusman17 10 месяцев назад
Lol, a melee monk with HP to spare? That's a good one!
@d4n737
@d4n737 10 месяцев назад
as if the class needed to be more anime, Nande bayo
@mrosskne
@mrosskne 10 месяцев назад
I just made all of their abilities free and removed ki points. They still don't even come close to the power of a mediocre full caster.
@1.red.panda.1
@1.red.panda.1 10 месяцев назад
@@mrosskne valid
@call911pls8
@call911pls8 11 месяцев назад
As a big wuxia fan, this is honestly amazing. There’re so many messed up clans and cults that focus on mutilating themselves in some way to gain power and this shines a great light on this part of wuxia. Great video! Edit: the link is wrong 😢
@stormy_does_stuff
@stormy_does_stuff 11 месяцев назад
What link?
@RollingCalf
@RollingCalf 11 месяцев назад
Monks are weird because their goal is to achieve immortality by absorbing qi from the environment..certain paths were extreme and involved stuff like eating poop
@juicyjuustar121
@juicyjuustar121 8 месяцев назад
I'm gonna be honest, this video is entirely what made me realize my swordswoman character could totally have been a rogue/monks rather than a rogue/fighter I honestly just assumed "monk weapons" implied you're either using your fists or a staff or something
@PhilosophicallyAmerican
@PhilosophicallyAmerican 6 месяцев назад
Yeah. The PHB is not clear enough on that. I had to use an external site to find out that any simple weapon qualified.
@presetregret184
@presetregret184 6 месяцев назад
The biggest flex I ever did was telling everyone I was going to play a monk, but instead of a Naruto running weeb, I made a monk from a European medieval monastery. Bookish, religious, very preachy, and adverse to fighting.
@SusCalvin
@SusCalvin 23 дня назад
I always think of monks as jesuits. That or the bloke who has brawled in half the pubs of Manchester.
@DarthRayj
@DarthRayj 21 день назад
Some of my friends play at renaissance fairs and similar events and have a song about exactly this juxtaposition XD
@NoAIStudios
@NoAIStudios 10 дней назад
The funny thing is, classic European monks during the dark ages actually *weren't bad at fighting*. That's actually what the "big walking stick" was for. They were traditionally staff fighters. Granted, it was only for self-defense, but the implication in Robin Hood when Robin Hood fights little John when they meet was that Friar Tuck taught Robin staff fighting.
@SusCalvin
@SusCalvin 10 дней назад
@@NoAIStudios When you need to walk long distances and walking is normal, you need a staff. A lot of people have a small blade as a common tool. I read the bartitsu manuals, written much later on, where they suggest using things you got handy when out for a stroll in victorian London. An umbrella. A bicycle. A cloak.
@carsonrush3352
@carsonrush3352 11 месяцев назад
There's a few more monk subclasses, like you said: - Way of the Long Death (for people who wanted the Quivering Palm feature to be an entire subclass) - Way of Mercy (for the plague doctors and spiritual healers) - Way of the Kensei (for the guys who want to use better weapons) - Way of the Drunken Fist (for the Jackie Chan fans)
@crowbar_the_rogue
@crowbar_the_rogue 11 месяцев назад
Also way of Shadow. The "please multiclass me to Rogue" subclass.
@juanjorodriguez1895
@juanjorodriguez1895 11 месяцев назад
@@crowbar_the_rogue Ah, yes, Batman
@Jordan-kq3qw
@Jordan-kq3qw 11 месяцев назад
@MMPJ Cari You mean, Take two levels of Warlock so you can see jn your own darkness.
@Jfk2Mr
@Jfk2Mr 11 месяцев назад
Way of the Long Death - a One Punch Man subclass?
@chancecomic1595
@chancecomic1595 11 месяцев назад
I cannot believe you would call me with that Drunken Fist take! It's completely true and accurate, but still
@williamjusino3640
@williamjusino3640 11 месяцев назад
minor note on the damage die: your monk weapon can start at d8 in any subclass. spear and quarterstaff qualify as monk weapons, and nothing about using them with two hands prevents you from also using unarmed strikes like kicks, headbutts, etc
@camillecutler6868
@camillecutler6868 11 месяцев назад
My favorite way to use this is to dual weild a quarterstaff and be a lizardfolk- the unarmored defence thing is good if you get bad stat rolls, and you get excellent damage at low levels- when using Flurry of Blows at lvl 2, for example, assuming 16 dexterity, you would be able to do 2d6+1d8+9 dmg in a turn.
@ARC--5973
@ARC--5973 6 месяцев назад
4:15 Slight correction, the highest damage die you can get is a d8 by two-handing a quarterstaff. Its honestly surprising how often this gets overlooked, given its very on theme for monks.
@user-ubludok
@user-ubludok 3 месяца назад
If you take an elf, you will gain proficiency with a long sword, which is can deal d10 damage. But yes, everything is bad at the monk’s base.
@ARC--5973
@ARC--5973 3 месяца назад
@@user-ubludok That's an optional class feature, so I decided to not go by that cuz there may be stingy DM's out there. But I disagree that the monk at base is bad. In the early levels the monk is fine, but it drops off the farther you go
@mihajloselmic476
@mihajloselmic476 2 месяца назад
Not just that, a greatclub is a monk weapon, and it has a base of a d8. It's just silly how a lil ghostwise halfling can swing a greatclub with dexterity
@ARC--5973
@ARC--5973 2 месяца назад
@@mihajloselmic476 Uhhh....a greatclub is not a monk weapon sir. It has the two-handed property, disqualifying it
@mihajloselmic476
@mihajloselmic476 2 месяца назад
@@ARC--5973 That's completely wrong. A weapon being two-handed does not in any way, shape or form disqualify it from being a monk weapon. Same goes for the Light Crossbow and Shortbow. I'm not sure where you got your info, but it's utterly incorrect
@mikealgiers7852
@mikealgiers7852 8 месяцев назад
It’s crazy how Larian made monk (specifically Way of the Open Hand) a really powerful class by reworking the Tavern Brawler feat to add your strength modifier TWICE to your attacks making you do insane damage with either an elixir of hill giant strength or cloud giant strength.
@tatsumiuchiha5559
@tatsumiuchiha5559 8 месяцев назад
I play open hand without that and still do a shit ton of damage because of some really cool magic items you can get in the *admittedly later* game. Like the one you get for saving Hope, which allows you to add 1d6 force damage to unarmed strikes and either heal or do attacks at advantage. This works best because flurry of blows doubles this with 1 measly ki point. My monk currently does comparable damage to Karlach, both of whom are using the best weapon/equipment for them that I could find (not done with my playthrough). And is more effective DPS wise than my other teammates (although then again I'm using Wyll and Shadowheart, tho I did try Gale and other stuff at some point, like Jaheira. But in terms of steady DPS, Karlach and my monk are better)
@mikealgiers7852
@mikealgiers7852 8 месяцев назад
@@tatsumiuchiha5559 yeahh you can typically find the ingredients for the elixir or the elixir itself by level 4 instead of needing to wait hours in. i made karlach my monk and she does the highest damage in my party turn after turn.
@cherechesalexdaniel811
@cherechesalexdaniel811 11 месяцев назад
Is it literally impossible for Antonio to not make the most compelling, interesting and fun characters in his D&D with a twist videos? I literally want to see an entire series just about Uriel.
@CadanL
@CadanL 11 месяцев назад
A whole party made from his twist characters would be really cool Though a lot of them seem to be running from their family XD
@cherechesalexdaniel811
@cherechesalexdaniel811 11 месяцев назад
@@CadanL yeah its kind of a theme isn’t it?
@noahlovato7331
@noahlovato7331 11 месяцев назад
@@cherechesalexdaniel811makes me wonder if there’s something Pointy doesn’t want to talk about?
@cherechesalexdaniel811
@cherechesalexdaniel811 11 месяцев назад
@@noahlovato7331 its not our place to tell. It could as well just be that he consumed a lot of media with this idea in it as it is a pretty prevelant trope. Things like this (even if they are true) are between him and anyone he personally wants to tell.
@AverageEldritchEntity
@AverageEldritchEntity 11 месяцев назад
Oh god I adore this.
@ezekielkade1823
@ezekielkade1823 11 месяцев назад
I never played him, but crafted a character who was basically The Modern Prometheus (Frankenstein's Monster) and he was an Ascendant Dragon monk but reflavoured to have all his abilities because of the process of being rebuilt. Like acid breath being stomach acid, lightning punches from his mechanical heart, wings as a grotesque add-on by his creator, etc. He was a fun concept
@Lilith_Harbinger
@Lilith_Harbinger 11 месяцев назад
This and the subclass in the video feel a lot like things that Simic Hybrid should have.
@Pinkblood_art
@Pinkblood_art 9 месяцев назад
I loved the idea of the way of the flesh monk, and I was thinking- "Oh maybe I could flavor one as double from skullgirls..." And you proceed to show her on screen!! 10/10 would totally make a monk like that now ;3
@ZpEB2741
@ZpEB2741 8 месяцев назад
Absolutely love Uriel. Seriously, who can hate the pure soul who can retain their wholesomeness in the face of unadulterated body horror?
@Fuck_whoever_took_my_name
@Fuck_whoever_took_my_name 11 месяцев назад
SPOILERS!! Marci in the DOTA anime on Netflix is one of the best ideas I've seen for the use of a monk in a non traditional setting. If you're not familiar with her character she is the mute handmaiden of a princess and since she is a small woman who carries no weapons she's never seen as a threat. One episode they are taken prisoner suddenly and you get to see the hidden secret that she's been carrying with her, just the fact that she's a trained monk. A fantastic reveal and a great way to incorporate the class into a different existence in your world something akin to a secret service bodyguard. Super cool.
@stJules
@stJules 11 месяцев назад
So a ninja.
@Emma-Maze
@Emma-Maze 11 месяцев назад
The double negation tripped me up, she carries only weapons she *has* seen as a threat?
@MumboJ
@MumboJ 11 месяцев назад
@@Emma-Maze I don't think it's a double negation, but it could do with an extra comma for clarity: "since she is a small woman who carries no weapons, she's never seen as a threat."
@Fuck_whoever_took_my_name
@Fuck_whoever_took_my_name 11 месяцев назад
@@stJules no, ninjas carry weapons
@slimetank394
@slimetank394 3 дня назад
​@@stJules the whole deal of fantasy ninja is they carry way more weapons than you can ever expect, not the opposite
@krinkrin5982
@krinkrin5982 11 месяцев назад
I would really like to see a monk subclass actually utilizing grappling to its full potential. Also other inspirations for a monk: Sumo fighter Luchador Capoira
@sidecharacter7165
@sidecharacter7165 11 месяцев назад
Grappling generally requires Strength unfortunately. Fun DM’s let you use Acrobatics or Dex-Athletics though.
@Zasek2112
@Zasek2112 11 месяцев назад
Matador?
@godsamongmen8003
@godsamongmen8003 11 месяцев назад
So basically you want to make different fighters from Street Fighter. Maybe the DM would let you use str/con or str/wis for your AC.
@VisonsofFalseTruths
@VisonsofFalseTruths 11 месяцев назад
​@@sidecharacter7165 astral self lets you grapple with wisdom.
@krinkrin5982
@krinkrin5982 11 месяцев назад
@@godsamongmen8003 Wasn't even thinking of Street Fighter, but that is a great idea. Maybe give the monk some fun combos they can do with unique weapons, like the meteor hammer (works as chain), so you can grab an enemy and drag them to you Scorpion style.
@whatevermatewhatevermate6638
@whatevermatewhatevermate6638 7 месяцев назад
Thank you for the body horror inspiration! I wanted to create an Aarakocra monk whose wings are clipped for the sake of "grounding oneself in humility" or something like that. In any case he can't fly anymore, and he's on a sort of pilgrimage. I've never actually played dnd before, but I hope to one of these days. I tend to stick very closely to the handbook and forget that you're supposed to use your imagination for this game...not sure I want my precious bird to break his hollow bones every fight, but I’ll take ideas like this into consideration 😁
@Drekromancer
@Drekromancer 10 месяцев назад
I love to see the cross-pollination between you, CR, and Matt Colvillen. The online D&D community continues to grow, and it warms my heart. 🙂
@fearjunkie
@fearjunkie 11 месяцев назад
I actually used Quivering Palm as a plot point during a samurai-themed campaign. There was this minor villain who'd learned the technique before his mentor would've given him permission, proceded to kill his master and then started hitting EVERYONE in the town with it, effectively holding them all hostage and giving him free reign over the town.
@Drekromancer
@Drekromancer 11 месяцев назад
Fuck, I love this. It even adds to the fantasy of a "forbidden technique" in a way that the level-gated default doesn't.
@miguelangelus959
@miguelangelus959 10 месяцев назад
But quivering palm can only affect one creature at a time. If you use it on somebody else, the effect ends on the first creature
@King_of_Clovers
@King_of_Clovers 10 месяцев назад
@@miguelangelus959 Maybe this villain learned a diffent version of Quivering Palm or perhaps perfected the technique. As a NPC he can get away with doing stuff the players can't and there are many ways to explain it.
@kylas1902
@kylas1902 10 месяцев назад
This is such a good idea for a villain. Maybe even an assassin guild master. Thank you master. I'm stealing this now. 🙏🫳🫴🖐️
@adolfodef
@adolfodef 10 месяцев назад
The ability learned by the villan was actually the ancient, forbidden, "superprototype" version WITHOUT the "safety valve" that automatically releases the previous "cursed" target [so, it allows unlimited simultaneous "hostages"]. -> On the Endgame, he has managed to "curse" about half of the population of [country party cares about]; hence big Thanos Snap.
@gustavogarcia8783
@gustavogarcia8783 11 месяцев назад
I remember my first and only monk character, a Lizardfolk that fights by biting people! Bite as unarmed strike, longdeath to gain hpt after each prey, speed to hunt fleeing foes... It was not a very hard campaign, so my power level was actually on par with the party, and it was great fun!
@Nomadic-Flea
@Nomadic-Flea 11 месяцев назад
Reminds me of a character I played who was a lizard folk kensai monk/ranger having hunters mark really helped bring the damage up to where I was in tow with the fighter while delivering stunning strikes
@EPgamez
@EPgamez 3 месяца назад
3:53 i wonder if Pointy Hat realizes how cool he sounds saying that
@flopus7
@flopus7 8 месяцев назад
The biggest problem with monks is that fighters are better at unarmed
@Yipper64
@Yipper64 11 месяцев назад
21:17 body horror has always terrified me, but I also love the concept. Jojo's has those vampire people who like use their bodies in weird ways, like the guy who has extremely hot blood and such. That type of thing I imagine this class would do, right?
@mikebougiamas3418
@mikebougiamas3418 11 месяцев назад
The Pillar Men
@arthurmarcelino9838
@arthurmarcelino9838 11 месяцев назад
The pillar man YES! I’d love to play as one in D&D
@coolgreenbug7551
@coolgreenbug7551 11 месяцев назад
@@arthurmarcelino9838 How do you want to do this? I want to climb into his body, puppet him for a bit, then explode out. ...Okay,
@kalebb1226
@kalebb1226 11 месяцев назад
AAAAYYAAAAYYAAAAYYAAAA!!!
@combativeThinker
@combativeThinker 9 месяцев назад
MEZAMATAMAE! WAGA ARUJITACHI YO!
@neebogreebo2052
@neebogreebo2052 11 месяцев назад
Hey Antonio! I just wanted to let you know that I DM'd the Pleasentries one shot for a group of my friends and we all had an amazing time! They actually managed to get a 3rd secret ending where they negotiated for just Sofia and left all the other sleepers behind. Very cool solution to that scenario I feel. We had a blast with it and I'll certainly be running any more modules you decide to make in the future.
@sarahferraro4641
@sarahferraro4641 11 месяцев назад
I just DMed it today as well. We played it at level 11 so I scaled it up a lot. They still thwarted everything in like 2 seconds (high level characters are really good at avoiding sleep and fear). At the end, they took half of the sleepers so that the pleasentries could survive, and struck a deal with them that they would bring new sleepers periodically. Then they went and established themselves mayor of Alacarn and turned the town into a sort of "country getaway retreat" for people from the big city who were stressed about their lives to "get away and clear your mind of the traumas of the everyday" (become sleepers). In return, the Pleasantry Queen granted the town a sort of calming aura, as well as a few other neato sleep boons to one of the players who was particularly antagonistic to her. I ran it as a one shot for my group who can't play Strahd whilst a player is on holiday but now they want to revisit it as an ongoing series of oneshots.
@MycoArsenic39
@MycoArsenic39 10 месяцев назад
27:04 Antonio: "Gnarly descriptions of your gross, gross, little guy." Me: "Um, phrasing?"
@Fenrisson
@Fenrisson 2 месяца назад
15:27 - Thank you *SO MUCH* for this! I have forgotten about this absolute *GEM* of a video. Went back to watch it and cried tears of joy.
@bluepearl4624
@bluepearl4624 11 месяцев назад
I love monks, I’m gonna be honest. Way of the Four Elements lets me live my ATLA dreams
@Marpaws
@Marpaws 11 месяцев назад
same
@TougherLoki
@TougherLoki 11 месяцев назад
My first character may have been an air genasi monk named Gnaa... 😬
@LothianNerd
@LothianNerd 11 месяцев назад
Naw gotta stick to my drunken monk style, hilarious for RP sessions
@zach415
@zach415 11 месяцев назад
It’s honestly better to just go Storm Sorcerer because they learn every spell there and for less of a cost. Four Elements Monk is just a suboptimal choice
@kaawan3201
@kaawan3201 11 месяцев назад
@@zach415 shhhhh, monk are fun
@ODDnanref
@ODDnanref 11 месяцев назад
The reason why warlocks are not considered weak due to the short rest thing, is that warlocks have spells, which are always comparatively more high impact than whatever a martial can do. The other reason is eldritch blast with the agonizing invocations keeps warlocks at such an okay damage level, people use it as a baseline. Not to mention eldritch blast is free and keeps up with a monk damage rating through Ki.
@ianaldridge7136
@ianaldridge7136 9 месяцев назад
"okay damage level" Without action surge, a Warlock's default Eldritch Blast is stronger then a ranged fighter while also getting its multi-attack faster
@ODDnanref
@ODDnanref 9 месяцев назад
@@ianaldridge7136 So, they do extremely good damage level. Strengthening my argument that it is a poor comparison to monks.
@ianaldridge7136
@ianaldridge7136 9 месяцев назад
@@ODDnanref Yeah, I'm in agreement with you
@VestedUTuber
@VestedUTuber 9 месяцев назад
Eh, I've seen people complain about Warlock being weak as well, but from a lot of the complaints I've seen it's more an issue with not giving a sufficient amount of short rests and/or giving too many long rests.
@andrewkandasamy
@andrewkandasamy 9 месяцев назад
@@VestedUTuber This is so true. A lot of campaigns revolve around the day by day with a long rest between each day and usually only one short rest during the day. That essentially means short rest reliant classes like Warlock and Sorcerer can feel like just nerfed wizards since their known spells are smaller due to being balanced around being able to use them more often using short rests.
@DungeonMagister
@DungeonMagister 8 месяцев назад
Made a kensai monk that was a musketeer. Swordsman that wears dandy clothes and a fancy hat. The unarmed attack is based on historical manuals. The magic damage for unamed is a blessing from his god. The god of luck, Tymora
@IAmWhoIAm2009
@IAmWhoIAm2009 3 месяца назад
Just about to finish up my first play through. Chose monk since my buddy told me it’s a beginner friendly class, and have been absolutely loving it. I recently found your videos and have been loving them. Keep up the great work!
@williansnobre
@williansnobre 11 месяцев назад
A Vampire Hunter Monk using the power of the Sun can be pretty cool, if possible you could mix western and eastern monks and make a pugilist padre that fights the undead with silver-knuckles
@lugusss
@lugusss 9 месяцев назад
Thats literaly JoJo part one and two
@williansnobre
@williansnobre 9 месяцев назад
@@lugusss Ah yeah, the Hamon. I forgot about that. Even better, the padre could be drawn in the JoJo style then.
@hadenharris78
@hadenharris78 10 месяцев назад
Honestly, the "Boxer" on DND wiki does a great job of exactly what you spoke about here. It makes the aesthetic more of a prize fighting champion who train tirelessly as the main point of the character. It also has some pretty decent abilities to back it up
@BigusGeekus
@BigusGeekus 5 месяцев назад
Voldo as an example of body horror made me laugh out loud. Nicely done.
@Shod_inSilence
@Shod_inSilence 6 месяцев назад
I like the subclasses you make for these videos, but THIS IS THE BEST ONE YET! I want to play it. I've already thought of several prospective stories, but my favorite is the idea of a performer who went too far and their wish, nay, their insane drive for superhuman ability warped every part of them. I love it, I love it, I love it.
@sinistertwister686
@sinistertwister686 11 месяцев назад
I've gotta say, while your free content is amazing, your storytelling abilities are underappreciated. I don't even want to play Way of the Flesh that much, but I would love to have a party member with character like Uriel! So much drama, so many opportunities for roleplay!
@thedogmaticdirector
@thedogmaticdirector 6 месяцев назад
I have a boss I'm designing for my campaign, and this subclass actually fills the gap I was missing for phase 1 of the fight. Awesome stuff.
@Fenrisson
@Fenrisson 2 месяца назад
26:12 - Yeah, that's amazing! You are very criative and come up with incredible ideas. I'm starting to like this channel so very much!
@morganbiddlecom
@morganbiddlecom 11 месяцев назад
As a DM married to a game designer I've been picking his brain to build my campaigns, dungeons, and homebrew subclasses for years. Very cool of Antonio to do it for everyone for free!
@umbralgaming3443
@umbralgaming3443 11 месяцев назад
I remember reading from a post that a dungeon master had the party fight a large dragon or something. When the wizard had cast meteor shower, the dungeon master had allowed the monk to use the meteors as platforms, jumping from meteor to meteor in order to reach the dragon and to personally deliver some whooping. I’m surprised that this isn’t allowed in base, cool things like this should happen more often
@firstnamelastname9237
@firstnamelastname9237 10 месяцев назад
This would actually be incredible. Also immediately made me think of Tai Lung from Kung Fu Panda.
@Greenweeper1387
@Greenweeper1387 10 месяцев назад
I mean I can see why it’s not in base. The way they’d have to write it all down in numbers and the specific situations it would have to be described as in order to be accessible would just be too difficult to not just leave it up to DM knowing when to “rule of cool” something.
@christopherfleetwood5252
@christopherfleetwood5252 10 месяцев назад
@@Greenweeper1387I would write it as ‘Getting Advantage on Rolls when on difficult terrain’ or something
@reubenthenerd1815
@reubenthenerd1815 10 месяцев назад
Cool idea
@douglasmorris8995
@douglasmorris8995 10 месяцев назад
As a DM, I allowed my Four Elments monk to create ice platforms and run across them between ships in a multiple ship combat. The rules would have said hard no, but what a great cinematic and bad ass idea.
@AlanTenore
@AlanTenore 5 дней назад
This sounds amazing! And a great fit for my war forged monk concept. After "the war," they were discharged, and over the centuries they found the rarest flowers and opened a flower shop in some town. All their powers were "forgotten" over the years (to start at level 1). This will make rediscovery horrifying for their party. So exciting! 😃
@gratuitouslurking8610
@gratuitouslurking8610 7 месяцев назад
Plot Twist: Way of Mercy is also basically an anime reference. I'm pretty sure it's partially inspired by one of the Fist of the North Star fake fighting styles from one of the support characters.
@starhalv2427
@starhalv2427 11 месяцев назад
I made a "Kiryu Kazuma" monk by taking the open hand subclass. Probably not what it was intended for, but the ability to attack 3 times and then finish it by attacking a 4th time and dropping their ass on the ground reminded me of hit combos from Yakuza. Also, that character made me realise what monks are supposed to do. They're supposed to use their increased speed, 3-4 attacks per turn and additional effects from each attack (Such as stun or drop prone) to go from one enemy to another and disrupt all of them. And out of combat, you're good at perception, stealth, survival etc
@Duhad8
@Duhad8 11 месяцев назад
I made Goro Majima using the Drunken Master subclass and it worked great! Knife for a monk weapon, using the whole 'making foes underestimate you by weaving around drunkenly' to represent his fluid fighting style and general personality and the stealth and perception options are perfect for doing a 'Majima Everywhere' thing! I kinda want to pair them with a barbarian 'Taiga Saejima' partner and have Majima draw agro and be all dodgy and annoying while Taiga smashes, I think that would be super fun and flavorful.
@condimentking3395
@condimentking3395 11 месяцев назад
Yep. The larger problem with Monks is that the stuff that they are supposed to be good at just wasn't thought out well in the system overall. Standing in one place is heavily encouraged during a fight as a melee fighter, and martial classes in general suffer from poor scaling, and specifically their martial arts die feels very similar to to piss poor barb rage scaling
@CJWproductions
@CJWproductions 11 месяцев назад
3-4 attacks if you don't use your Disengage tool. So you better hope you land those Stunning Strikes, otherwise your fragile ass is gonna be eating some attacks of opportunity that you really can't afford.
@starhalv2427
@starhalv2427 11 месяцев назад
​​​@@CJWproductionsnah, many monks have a ton of ways to deal with that. Astral Self has enought reach to stay out of Opportunity Attack range of most enemies, and Open Hand monk can straight up disable reactions on hit.
@condimentking3395
@condimentking3395 11 месяцев назад
@@starhalv2427 Most monks have to choose something like that over getting a different benefit though, which ends up punishing them regardless for it
@JuliaWoberts
@JuliaWoberts 11 месяцев назад
I would truly love to see more subclasses for monk that expand it beyond the eastern aesthetic and flip the script. Keep up the great work, Pointy.
@twanger6857
@twanger6857 11 месяцев назад
Building on what they said about the monk being able to have supernatural abilities from their own body. Imagine a subclass that sort of works like robocop, you are part machine and can use your robotic enhancements like a piston fist/or say you can create/attach to yourself any weapon that you then become proficient with (with the cost of having to make it attachable somehow/stuff for balance). Coming from that baseline of using your body to do incredible things gives a lot of potential ideas.
@saparapatepete
@saparapatepete 11 месяцев назад
There are some monk prestige classes in 3.5 that would be cool as subclasses, like the tatooed monk(monk with tatoos that grants them unique abilities), reaping mauler(grappling specialist), enlightened fist(monk with arcane casting with some touch attack synergies),sacred fist (monk with divine casting which gives lots of buffs)
@rango962
@rango962 11 месяцев назад
Give me a Boxer Monk, or something grappling focused. As much As IT does Not Look Like IT, 90 perfekt of Martial arts around the world are Wrestling focused, and even King of is a Lot of Wrestling, that got lost in Pop culture tho. So why dont expand on the Most Common Martial art that can BE found in almost any culture
@thosebloodybadgers8499
@thosebloodybadgers8499 11 месяцев назад
Yeah, there's a lot of potential there. Maybe you could have a different kind of drunken master subclass that utilizes different brews as a resource onto themselves in combat to gain special, almost supernatural, effects. Maybe you could have a worshiper of some deity, so devoted, they forsake everything aside from their own body and spirituality, in turn gaining incredible deific abilities, almost like an avatar of their will (maybe even literally). How about a researcher who augmented their body through technological enhancements, installing different upgrades with level progression and maybe also juggling some form of "overheating" resource instead. Perhaps some manner of spirit or other supernatual entity posessed a person and it lends them their power in combat through some manner of shifting and body enhancement, sorta Parasyte or Venom style. Tons of stuff to consider.
@nathanhepworth-smith9021
@nathanhepworth-smith9021 10 месяцев назад
Saying the problem people have with monk is just damage is very reductive. They have poor hit dice compared to other martials, poor ac, and poor utility and synergy with the party. I love monk and I want to see it buffed and it really doesn’t take a lot. I really like the way of the flesh because it proves that you can make a monk who’s priority isnt damage but please don’t act like people just say their issue is damage
@tiph3802
@tiph3802 10 месяцев назад
I was feeling really depressed today, Pointy. By the time you mentioned the subclass you made, I'd already nearly spit my water out about 5 times laughing. Your subclass literally made all the hair on my arms stand straight up! It's so cool! Thank you for making such amazing content and just being so funny and kind. I feel much better now. ❤❤
@TrixterTheFemboy
@TrixterTheFemboy 11 месяцев назад
The link in the description seems to go to a Paladin subclass rather than the Way Of Flesh? But also, this is awesome. I absolutely agree that monks have some of the best theming, and while I wasn't sure where you'd go with the twist aside from another Kensei, I instantly got ideas as soon as you mentioned the body-twisting. Props to you for coming up with it, it's so cool.
@scesher7777
@scesher7777 11 месяцев назад
yup, seems to be the wrong link
@Heroltz998
@Heroltz998 11 месяцев назад
It is going to the right document now.
@TrixterTheFemboy
@TrixterTheFemboy 11 месяцев назад
@@Heroltz998 Cool
@PaperSnakes
@PaperSnakes 11 месяцев назад
I came for the DnD content… I stayed for the killer edits
@jackmuaddib3745
@jackmuaddib3745 7 часов назад
Monk is my favorite class for the same reason, and I thought of a class for the Monk I called The Street fighter. Someone who learned to fight on the streets of whatever City or town they're from, and can learn things like improvised weaponry for free and something I called Dirty fighting where you get a bonus against enemies wearing armor and on horseback. My favorite one was Favored improvised Weapon, were the monk can pick one uncommon weapon as their favorite and gets to aid their strength and monk level to Atk @ Dmg. Sick class!
@McFatson
@McFatson 2 месяца назад
Amazingly helpful video for working on my own homebrew chapter. Thank you!
@RomLoneWolf23
@RomLoneWolf23 11 месяцев назад
"Perfect Self" was much more impressive in 3.5 and Pathfinder 1e, where it made you an Outsider, and gave you DR/10 (Chaotic). And unlike other Outsiders, you could still get resurrected if killed.
@llewelynshingler2173
@llewelynshingler2173 11 месяцев назад
DR/10 (Chaotic) means "Takes less damage unless it's from a Chaos Weapon"?
@Lord_necromancer
@Lord_necromancer 11 месяцев назад
​@@llewelynshingler2173exactly. All damage was reduced by a flat 10 damage unless the weapon was a chaotic weapon OR the natural weapon of an enemy who had the same type of resistance.
@WizoIstGott
@WizoIstGott 11 месяцев назад
1e Monk is so nice to play because the subclasses are actually good for once, who doesn´t wanna be a drunken master or a sensei?
@Lord_necromancer
@Lord_necromancer 11 месяцев назад
@@WizoIstGott 3.5 was excellent as well. Flurry of blows was an always on ability that gave up to 3 additional attacks at maximum BAB, you got spell resistance (which in 3e meant the caster had to beat your resistance DC with a check or spells just didn't work on you at all), your AC could get to ludicrous levels and you could deal up to like 40d12 damage per hit if built correctly. I had a monk in 3.5 that was SO good and could make theoretically infinite attacks per round with panther style feats.
@stevenmike1878
@stevenmike1878 11 месяцев назад
i remember when i first played dnd 5e a power gamer said monks really sucked. i just got done dming 3.5, pathfinder to where monks had a million punches. so i didn't believe him. then i built one and realized they really nerfed the poor class d8 class. even when multiclassing to maximixe a monk, 2 levels warlock cantrip will scale just as hard with no uber class planing. monks gotta spend a ki just to match match a free warlock cantrip. they should of given monk 3 attack actions and 3 furry of blows hits. at the higher levels. since it has less hp and ac then all the other front row martial classes. basically they can get extra hits but they absorb less damage before dropping. 3rd furry of blows strike at 11th and extra attack (2) around 17-20th level. so monks would always one punch/hit more then everyone else except for when fighter action surges.
@DM.Witted
@DM.Witted 11 месяцев назад
It feels like "way of the flesh" should get access to alter self somehow. Also, a quarterstaff in 2 hands is a d8, and still counts as a monk weapon, and allows for your extra unarmed strikes. It helps the damage a little, but makes your martial arts die feel even worse. On the other hand, a Way of the Kensai monk with a hand crossbow and a whip as monk weapons can feel pretty rootin' tootin'.
@wyattbailey1743
@wyattbailey1743 6 месяцев назад
Omg pointy thank you so much. I've been trying to make a fleshy-melee fighter character for so long now, and I've tried everything! But this... is GENIUS!
@jumpinghunter9152
@jumpinghunter9152 10 месяцев назад
One interesting idea for the monk subclass, since monk is all about "perfecting your body and using it as a weapon" would be something like a "fully-biological robot": a man who had suffered some sort of psychic or magical attack and as a result had his mind completely divided from the body, making him unable to feel anything without complete comprehension and conscious surveilance of his nerves' signals, unable to react to any thing instinctively at all, even unable to breathe without consciously commanding his body to perform a breathing cycle. But with help of some powerful magical mentors and through intense psychological training he was able to gain full and completely conscious control of his body, to the point that he controls it like a mech, a walking machine made of flesh and bones, and he doesn't feel any normal human feelings in a traditional way, pain is simply a damage indicator, love or friendship is a form of "friend-or-foe" identification for him, need of food or drink is a sign of low fuel level and so on. He didn't acquire any magical abilities, but mastered controls of his body to the point that if he calculated and thought out his next action perfectly, the execution will be at least of same quality, allowing him to perform actions inaccessible for normal people, even for some real traditional monks. I think this concept is rather neat, i never played DnD, but if anybody had any games with similar classes, please tell me how that felt, im really interested.
@DronesOverTheMoon
@DronesOverTheMoon 3 месяца назад
You mean a sociopath
@abcdefghij337
@abcdefghij337 Месяц назад
I think you mean Darth Vader without the swordsmanship?
@wertyw4353
@wertyw4353 11 месяцев назад
The entire premise of just punching things is just genius in multiple directions
@petre1758
@petre1758 11 месяцев назад
My personal main problem with monks is the same as my general problem with 5e martials: your only viable options in combat being "I make an attack". I think options like grappling, disarming, throwing, shoving, etc etc, should be more pronounced in fighting, and I think monks should be the ones to excel at it. (Also I always thought of monks not as a rogue counterpart, but as a Warlock equivalent for martials.)
@sidecharacter7165
@sidecharacter7165 11 месяцев назад
Look at all the shenanigans they get up to in manhwa with “cultivation” if you want good ideas. Some swordsman can part mountains and seas with single swings of their sword.
@ruga-ventoj
@ruga-ventoj 11 месяцев назад
​@@sidecharacter7165 yeah. If we take abit more from general Cultivation genre than just Martial films and some anime. All martial artists are basically Magicians(wizards) who learned magic with their bodies. Some use it enhance their physical bodies and others use it to basically cast spells. Monks if they wanted to embrace the Wuxia fantasy should be half casters or more access to magical abilities.
@drsnugglesfan
@drsnugglesfan 8 месяцев назад
My martial characters dont just attack, they grapple, drag, dodge, shove, search, take cover, interact with objects, and all kinds of other stuff. And I dont just do them for the heck of it, they are tactical choices that can really pay off. People say oh there is nothing to do but attack, i think that is more of a self imposed limitation than a true statement about the game. I also cant help but notice how many popular builds are based around spamming the same cantrip or spell over and over. If there really is a problem with repetitive action it is not apparently limited to martials
@YolkieYolk
@YolkieYolk 7 месяцев назад
@@drsnugglesfan Grapple and Shove are attacks. Realistically speaking, if you are doing anything but attacking unless there are specific scenarios in battle, you are misplaying it. People have done the math, besides, everything you just said can be done too with non martials. it's not the repetitiveness that hurts martial, is that they are only allowed to attack, nothing else, that's why things like battlemaster are so good. Yeah, Warlocks spam Eldritch Blast, but they have access to Hypnotic Pattern, Darkness, Invisibility, Command, Find Familiar etc. Even if they only had the spells I mentioned, they are instantly so much better than what any martial can do.
@drsnugglesfan
@drsnugglesfan 7 месяцев назад
@@YolkieYolk i gave examples of actions that aren't attacking which are valid. Everything in the game is made of "specific scenarios." So tell me what's the real criticism? You do have options beside attacking, but often the best move in a fight is an attack. So what? If you're a spellcaster the best move might usually be the same old "cast a spell."
@josephcompton5602
@josephcompton5602 9 месяцев назад
I really like the Way of the Flesh concept you got, I'm actually planning on using it for my next D&D character. The Concepts I'm going with, is the idea of a once powerful and well trained monk, but "Something" happened, while they where meditating, and where assumed dead. nearly 100 years later, through the slow and drain of the Monk's Chi pool, the Monk awakens in a mummified state, now as a "DARAKHUL" (Kobold Press's playable sentient undead lineage ). Their body now atrophied for so many years of unuse, as well has retaining no memory of their former life, other then the bare basics. What ever their training before, they are now a blank slate, and with their new body they are discovering new ways of fighting. So that what I'm going to go with, a undead Kung Fu Mummy. Sounds fun right.
@MikeyBeastPop
@MikeyBeastPop 2 месяца назад
I’m a big audio guy. Usually listening as i drive. This dude put’s so much into his video’s when i can watch. Nothing but respect for his entertainment
@tony_baloney6763
@tony_baloney6763 11 месяцев назад
Something’s I did for our monk player: -d10 hit die -unarmored AC = dex+wis -ki points = level + wis - give them higher unarmored strike die earlier -open hand flurry of blows stuff is just a part of the monk class Just a little bit of extra stuff to make them hit harder, have more options, and really helps early game play
@pistaalkohol
@pistaalkohol 11 месяцев назад
Isn't that how unarmored defense works by default?
@mineias9672
@mineias9672 11 месяцев назад
@@pistaalkohol No, its 10+dex+wis
@thomascook3336
@thomascook3336 11 месяцев назад
​@@pistaalkohol no, because what the mod does is allow the monks to wear armor on top of having extra defence. Which works in campaigns with no magical items because then the max AC would be 26
@swaws7810
@swaws7810 11 месяцев назад
​@@pistaalkohol yeah idk what OP thinks they're changing with dex+wis unless if the base number is higher than 10
@slightlyoffcenteravatar
@slightlyoffcenteravatar 11 месяцев назад
I slightly over-justified, but I went with: Allow Martial Arts features in light/medium armor; Martial Arts die is d6@3rd, d8@6th, d10@11th, and d12@17th level; Step of the Wind is a 0-ki bonus-action Dash and, only if you're not wearing armor, 1 ki to Disengage and double your jump dist; Slow Fall is only 4x monk level but works as long as you're not incapacitated; Stunning Strike costs 2 ki *but* shares a free usage pool, prof. bonus/any rest, along with Focused Aim; Timeless Body gets the previous Perfect Self feature; Perfect Self is just 2 +2 ASI's into any two ability scores you want. And some tiny tweaks not worth mentioning, but there's more QoL you can add
@crolithebard4964
@crolithebard4964 11 месяцев назад
This is awesome! My friends and I played in a zombie apocalypse campaign and one of the characters named Norman is literally THIS. He was a kid who woke up not realizing they were infected and they became a punk-inspired Kensei monk who uses gun-axes and undead fury to fuel their ki points. It’s awesome and his story was insanely well-crafted because we took it away from the stereotypical Asian-inspired monk to make something that fit the setting. Ignoring the monk stereotype is honestly the best way to play monk, and our group got an insanely memorable character thanks to this
@Ewafingmyth
@Ewafingmyth 11 месяцев назад
agreed, I saw someone make Gambit from X-Men a kensei monk using the cards as a monk weapon which I thought was pretty inspired
@christophermartin240
@christophermartin240 12 дней назад
Pointy Hat is single handedly my favorite dnd channel! keep it up!
@Mysteri0usChannel
@Mysteri0usChannel 10 месяцев назад
I have always been sad that there is no European style monk. So I'm currently home brewing one! A monk subclass where the monk gains access to the Cleric spells, casting them by use of Qi!
@Decaliyon
@Decaliyon 8 месяцев назад
A Europe style monk....?
@Mysteri0usChannel
@Mysteri0usChannel 8 месяцев назад
@@Decaliyon like, a Christian monk. You know... Praying, living in a monastery... Kinda like a male nun?
@Dyneamaeus
@Dyneamaeus 11 месяцев назад
Solid hit on this one! The concept of 'self-improvement through intense X' is such fertile ground for development. Monk could be such a hugely flavorful class once you step away from its roots. Body horror, Cybernetics, Divine Guidance, Genetic Tinkering, Mutations, Psychic Powers, Soul Devouring, almost anything could be the source of such power if presented the right way. I mean you can nab numerous 'enhanced' type character backstories wholesale.
@Drekromancer
@Drekromancer 10 месяцев назад
Holy shit. You're a genius. Now I need to make cybernetic monks!
@Drekromancer
@Drekromancer 10 месяцев назад
As a matter of fact, I'll try outlining a vague character idea for each premise you described. Body Horror: Person with an aberrant bloodline learns to find power by leaning into their inhuman nature. Cybernetics: Literally every cyborg ninja. Surpass human limitations by adding stronger hardware. The flesh is weak. Divine Guidance: This one is kinda tricky, but I imagine that rigidly sticking to a path of righteous observance could grant a person boons which make them far more capable and resilient than the average person. There's a Force User parallel here, maybe. Genetic Tinkering: See Cybernetics. But this gives a lot of rooms for unique flavor. (e.g., Quivering Palm becomes a sting of long-acting poison released from a talon on your pinky finger) Mutations: See Genetic Tinkering. You'd just have to make all the features feel less deliberate and more fucked up. (e.g., Quivering Palm is a touch of the character's blood, which is radioactive enough to kill when used appropriately) Psychic Powers: I think this has a lot of overlap with the Jedi/Force Users from Star Wars. Use your psychic powers to perfect your physical form and enhance your abilities beyond normal limits. Soul Devouring: Your once-feeble form has grown strong by feeding on a healthy stream of fresh souls. The souls impart their strength to you, and now you are stronger, lighter, faster, and tougher than you ever were in your past life. You could even learn new abilities by consuming the souls of powerful adversaries! (Like the Dragonborn in Skyrim.) But the hunger still grows...
@weedweeb9211
@weedweeb9211 10 месяцев назад
Exactly, kinda peeved that when I planned to make a Batman or Spider-Man in DnD, monk fits them aesthetically but mechanically other class can do them better. Monk concept should be loosened to "Using your body" instead of just ascetic martial artist
@combativeThinker
@combativeThinker 9 месяцев назад
That’s basically Street Fighter, lol.
@KneGros-nc1ss
@KneGros-nc1ss 5 месяцев назад
Cyber monks sounds like depriving yourself of earthly needs, like food or water, air.. and certainly no pp cause you're the opposite of Bard.
@plasmawolf7960
@plasmawolf7960 11 месяцев назад
Had an idea while listening to this: The way of Madness. Rasputin inspired monk, heavily emphasizing the damage tanking aspect of the monk, combined with the ability to cast healing abilities. I’m sure there’s more that should be there, but that’s all I could think of in the couple seconds the thought passed through my head.
@sweetyft
@sweetyft 11 месяцев назад
That sounds fantastic
@coolgreenbug7551
@coolgreenbug7551 11 месяцев назад
A catholic monk inspired monk!
@sweetyft
@sweetyft 11 месяцев назад
@@coolgreenbug7551 that’s a Paladin 😂
@plasmawolf7960
@plasmawolf7960 11 месяцев назад
@@coolgreenbug7551 I was thinking orthodox (cause Rasputin was orthodox), but that could be really cool too! I realize maybe a different t name for the way might be good... I was just thinking because they called him “The Mad Monk”
@coolgreenbug7551
@coolgreenbug7551 11 месяцев назад
@@plasmawolf7960 I'll be honest I'm not up to date on my monk history, I just like the idea of fury of blows coming from someone who looks like friar tuck
@gaelofariandel6747
@gaelofariandel6747 9 месяцев назад
I made a background faction for a home-brew campaign I was running. The faction had 4 branches & each sent an NPC as a representative/observer during the campaign. One of my favorites was a primarily fire Way of the Dragon Monk & I LOVE him.
@nebulastarz2197
@nebulastarz2197 Месяц назад
Ooooh man, I'm been binging all your videos and the idea of an Augmented Way of the Flesh Monk is just... SUCH A COOL IDEA TO ME!!
@Doctorfudge62
@Doctorfudge62 11 месяцев назад
Ive been playing a monk in a long running dnd campaign for the past 6 years. The amoUnt of shenanigans and absolutely badass shit ive done is INSANE. Having a cool DM that understand the badass kungfu power fantasy and allows you to do shit out of Kung Fu Hustle has been some of the most fun ive ever had.
@Staff7
@Staff7 10 месяцев назад
that doesn't mean they are not mechanically weaker.
@Falkenhorst2000
@Falkenhorst2000 10 месяцев назад
Holy shit, six years?! Not bad.
@louiesatterwhite3885
@louiesatterwhite3885 10 месяцев назад
Still mechanically the weakest class by far
@edwardlomeli5657
@edwardlomeli5657 10 месяцев назад
@@louiesatterwhite3885I mean really? Most campaigns end at early levels where they are still useful. Everyone I have played with or talked to has a lot of uses for their monks in and out of combat f
@mrosskne
@mrosskne 10 месяцев назад
Every cool thing you did was in spite of the rules, not because of them. D&D is a shit system.
@RockLucena
@RockLucena 11 месяцев назад
I think monks can be flavoured in many cool ways. I'm playing a Warforged way of the sunsoul monk that shoots energy blasts from an arm canon. And I'm planning on playing a second monk, but this time a dampyr way of the long death monk. Their unarmed strikes are scratches and bites, like a vampire. 😁
@stewartgames6697
@stewartgames6697 10 месяцев назад
Fun factoid Monks were added to the game by Gary Gygax because one of his early playtesters loved Bruce Lee movies and wanted to play a character like him. Clerics were also added for a similar reason - one playtest session somebody asked if they could play as a Vampire, and another player jokingly said if that player got to be a Vampire than he should be allowed to be a Vampire Hunter. Gary Gygax sat down after that session and hammered out the Cleric as a class with strong anti-Undead abilities. And Bards got put into the game because one of Gary's buddies like to play his guitar during sessions. A lot of the spells named after the character Tenser are also stuff that Gygax's son Ernest came up with, like "Tenser's Floating Disk". "Tenser" is an anagram of "Ernest", and along with his sister Elise's character (which nobody can remember the name of sadly), Tenser was the first character ever rolled in Dungeons and Dragons.
@liao2211
@liao2211 10 месяцев назад
I had this organization of spies and agents for an empire in one of my worlds, they took on the look of fantasy roman praetorian guards with the black armor *even tho they didn’t have any mechanically* the mask and purple tunics. And I had a fun idea where they wore special blade gauntlets that let their unarmed attacks deal 1d6+dex piercing damage. I then gave them monk-esque abilities. And often they were a on and off again antagonist but sometimes they will help the players mainly though one of their leaders which did actively aided the players with information, sabotage, and being a spy.
@anoriginalzero3107
@anoriginalzero3107 11 месяцев назад
Before you even mentioned the mad scientist flavour, I was already thinking how this could make for a good "Dr. Jekyll and Mr. Hyde" character. Looking forward to the 200K subscriber special when you inevitably get there (:
@aquartertwo
@aquartertwo 11 месяцев назад
Uriel is like a more innocent version of Killua from Hunter x Hunter, whose hands can turn into claws and has carved out a serial killer's heart in seconds and handed it back to him as he died on the floor :D
@axelgold5195
@axelgold5195 Месяц назад
You’re so incredible for going through all this effort | thanks dude 😎
@loselot6044
@loselot6044 3 месяца назад
I love the monk so much in terms of thematics and character identity, and all they need is just a slight damage increase on their martial die or a couple more attacks so they can keep up with Jimmy the unarmed fighting style fighter who is arguably just better statswise
@Subariel
@Subariel 11 месяцев назад
monk is my favorite class to play as, much like you said, its filled with tools to embody the fantasy i like of the cultivation trope. the numbers in combat however, those always remain low, but in hindsight, my monks proved to be rather durable.
@saparapatepete
@saparapatepete 11 месяцев назад
I just loved the idea of someone who beat things with their bare hands when everyone else relies on weapons and magic XD
@sidecharacter7165
@sidecharacter7165 11 месяцев назад
Monks are a tank and do the jon pretty well. Would be nice if there was a way to use Dex to Grapple or Shove like in the movies.
@j.m.r.7737
@j.m.r.7737 10 месяцев назад
I loved playing as a Monk in my last Dnd campaign. What I ended up doing, as a new player, was fighting as a Monk while being themed as a pirate, with it being worked into the character's backstory that he was trained by a former Monk as a child onwards. It was a blast to play as him!
@Restributordevill
@Restributordevill 7 месяцев назад
This is so good! That way of flesh is amazing. U gotta do something together with dungeon dudes, it fits soooo well into the Drakkenheim setting!
@rubenalvarez6830
@rubenalvarez6830 8 месяцев назад
The way of the Flesh sounds so awsome!! Thanks for your discretion, I will be working on a monk build in BG3!!
@jean-lucleblanc5825
@jean-lucleblanc5825 11 месяцев назад
The Way of the Flesh is the coolest and craziest twist you’ve come up with. You’re a genius man! 😊
@kudo5385
@kudo5385 11 месяцев назад
I don't care how disfigured Yuriel looks when he uses his abilities, I just want to give that boy a hug!
@acherem13
@acherem13 День назад
Dude I've been dying to play a monk in a 5E campaign since I finished making a BUSTED one in BG3. This is such a cool subclass and story you made for Uriel. It gives the DM so much to work with and the player so many opportunities. I'm totally gonna play him.
@ZzrzZ2012
@ZzrzZ2012 8 месяцев назад
Quivering palm used to come in at earlier levels in previous editions, it also did half of total HP damage on a failed saving throw. In 3rd ed we played two monks together in the party to kill all BBE.
@jgr7487
@jgr7487 11 месяцев назад
Pointy Hat: "[Monks] were designed as counterparts to the Rogue." WotC: "Monks have to spend Ki points to do everything Rogues get for free. oh, & unarmed Fighters ditch out more damage than Monks."
@Lilith_Harbinger
@Lilith_Harbinger 11 месяцев назад
Unarmed fighters do not do more damage than monks. That's straight up wrong (except maybe at level 1). They do have higher survivability though since they can wear heavy armor and invest in Con instead of Wis. The comparison to rogue is on point though. The monk abilities are a joke, rogue also get evasion and don't stop being useful in the middle of the encounter because they are out of ki points.
@user-uv6qu3wb5d
@user-uv6qu3wb5d 11 месяцев назад
@@Lilith_Harbingerunarmed fighting style let’s fighters have a d6 for unarmed strike from lvl1
@Lilith_Harbinger
@Lilith_Harbinger 11 месяцев назад
@@user-uv6qu3wb5d And monks get a bonus action unarmed attack at level 2, for 1d4+mod. Plus monks can also use this fighting style, if they are V.human or the DM gives feat, or just pick a race with natural weapons with d6. That's why i said unarmed fighters don't do more damage at any level other than maybe 1.
@jgr7487
@jgr7487 11 месяцев назад
@@Lilith_Harbinger *Fighting Style:* [...] *Unarmed Fighting.* Your unarmed strikes can deal bludgeoning damage equal to 1d6 + your Strength modifier on a hit. If you aren't wielding any weapons or a shield when you make the attack roll, the d6 becomes a d8. At the start of each of your turns, you can deal 1d4 bludgeoning damage to one creature grappled by you.
@jgr7487
@jgr7487 11 месяцев назад
@@Lilith_Harbinger *if* they are Variant Human of *if* the DM giver a feat. both of which give an extra feat for the Fighter, & both of which can give this Feat to anyone who fulfils the prerequisite: "Proficiency with a martial weapon".
@enriquehirshfeltikov2395
@enriquehirshfeltikov2395 11 месяцев назад
This has become like the only DnD channel I even still frequent. Best content.
@brandonhughes179
@brandonhughes179 3 месяца назад
The Way of Flesh is Baraka from the revamped "Mortal Kombat" short they did a few years ago: experimentation on the body, surgically implanting blades into his arms, etc
@alecelliott7506
@alecelliott7506 10 месяцев назад
Probably my favorite subclass yet. I also hate how constricting the monk class is in terms of what kind of character can be made. Maybe I'll give monk a try now. Love the character design you did for Urial
Далее
Are D&D Fighters Boring?
28:23
Просмотров 346 тыс.
How to make a GOOD D&D Villain
27:36
Просмотров 505 тыс.
The Problem with Druids in D&D
24:45
Просмотров 703 тыс.
D&D Halflings are Boring (and how to make them better)
19:53
Making D&D Online... ACTUALLY Good
23:56
Просмотров 205 тыс.
how to ACTUALLY use Mindflayers in D&D
24:28
Просмотров 711 тыс.
What D&D Can Learn From Baldur's Gate 3
26:24
Просмотров 400 тыс.
We need to talk about the new Monk
10:49
Просмотров 221 тыс.
What ALL Your Favorite D&D Races Say About You
17:21
Просмотров 880 тыс.
Giving your D&D players Rivals!
20:18
Просмотров 495 тыс.
The Problem with Warlocks in D&D
33:33
Просмотров 522 тыс.
капитан спас жизнь солдату
1:00
How? 😱   @fash
0:12
Просмотров 23 млн