Daniel Schueftan, Israel's security advisor - Jung & Naiv in Israel: Episode 184 

As expected from security advisors

Seriously? You need to expand your knowledge before you can call him eye opening! He’s totally distorting facts to fit his views!!! Despicable!!!! He’s laughable as a Middle East expert🤯

@@Who.is.kidding.who. He is spot on. You seem to be the fool.

@@SG-zv2uc My knowledge is expanded enough and I need no advice from a supporter of a cr!m!nal-tyr@nn!cal-g€n0c!d@l st@te. You nor him are hardly good sources to seek any knowledge, wisdom or common sense from! Since you offered your opinion I thought I’d trade you with a question to reflect upon…who’s more foolish, those you think are fools or the one who converses with fools? 🤔😉🫣🤭😑

*Every word coming out of that guy's mouth is an outrageous lie.* Every word, supremacist Zionist propaganda.

@@ChristineQ-wr6iv like what ?

@@ChristineQ-wr6iv thats right bitch ,none !

@@martalevin4829 He is full of prejudiced Zionist propaganda.

@@martalevin4829 He has fabricated an imagined Jewish history.

Wish I could find that recording.

Nice comment!)

From 19 min up to 21:15 min !!! Great explanation of jewish society in Europe! Be Human. And because of that the most jewish people from east Europe do not want to go to Israel. The will become over there normal people :-) But on the other hand who wants to let his carrier as an musician or big boss ;-)

Haha "optimism" terminal disease^^

Useless explanation, World knows Israel greedy occupation. these kind of videos can not hide your sins.

killing childs have not good reason at all

I think they are not trying to keep their sins away, because the israelis justify the attack or bombing of GAZA in the way that arabian liga trying to destroy them. So as result they are making so strong and merciless policy against palestine or groups who wants the same for israel! They have no other option. They are surrounded of muslim countries and have no way to do it other way. Try to live on continent surrounded of christian countries like in balkans.

I mean, nothing has changed. He's still right. You just can't say it anymore without getting bullshit from clowns who don't know anything about the conflict

Nothing has changed.

Nope nothing has changed. Only pseudo religious psychopaths have the right "to return".

Kohtason muss am neuen Mikro liegen. war glaub ich nur einmal der Fall, sorry.

Danke für die Antwort Tilo Jung (: Wirkte so geschnitten.. Da musste eine naive Nachfrage einfach mal sein ;) Wie immer eine super spannende Folge!

darum geht's doch! so ist Tilo in jedem Interview ---> jung & NAIV

*Why PEACE TALKS ARE GOOD for Apartheid Adventures - Part One* ru-vid.com/video/%D0%B2%D0%B8%D0%B4%D0%B5%D0%BE-FEOpL7CerIs.html *PEACE TALKS, Part Two: How Apartheid Adventures Always Wins* ru-vid.com/video/%D0%B2%D0%B8%D0%B4%D0%B5%D0%BE-8-XbmPJNQGo.html *ENJOY*

Google partition plan

What is to explain? Israel offered to Palestinians a state within 1967 borders with East Jerusalem as a capital! What more can they ask?

@@460mas Bullshit. You get either a tourist Visa upon arrival, at least for many countries, e.g. Germany among others, i have done it. Or being a Journalist invited to interview the Foreign Secretary you would get a press visa.

Well name the cases, and we will see. Most of them were either iranian nationals or they were working while they just applied for a tourist visa. Pretty dumb.

+Der Dudelino da wird mit absicht alles in chaos gehalten... die araber waren lange vor dem westen zivilisiert... schon mal die geschichten aus tausend und einer nacht gelesen.... diese märchen erzählen nicht von barbaren...

In arabischen Ländern werden noch immer Frauen gesteinigt. Wer noch nach der Scharia lebt, dem fällt es schwer eine Zivilisation mit Werten aufrecht zu erhalten. Auch in Sachen Gleichberechtigung sind wir in Europa ein paar Jahrzehnte voraus.

Der Dudelino diese werte werden von den westlichen ländern gefördert ---- siehe saudi arabien..... in irak wie auch in den anderen arabischen ländern wurde regimes abgeschafft und mit der neuen ordnung chaos bewusst provoziert. man kann seine interessen besser durchsetzen wenn ein land zerstritten ist als wenn sich alle einig sind.... und manche bevorzugen eine politik der spannung.....

Damit hast du sicherlich Recht. Gerade die USA haben den Nahen Osten wissend oder unwissend massiv destabilisiert. Oft hat man ja das Gefühl, die CIA weiß nicht wirklich was sie tut und dient als schlechter Berater für das Weiße Haus.

He is referring to the Egyptian Air Force, then the Iraqi, Syrian and Jordanian Air Force. Everything was destroyed by Israel at the beginning of the war. You're wrong about armaments too. The U.S. did not supply weapons to Israel at the time.

@@1610dim ok, that's the question now which information is more correct ... I am referring to Jehan Sadat's autobiography - and you?

@@frauleinanni1528And you think that the former First Lady of Egypt knows better where Israel got its weapons from than the Israeli academic and chairman of the National Security Studies Center at the University of Haifa. The main supplier was France, but there were also secret deliveries from Germany using American helicopters, the forwarding of which had not been approved by the Washington Office of Munitions Control. The USA had already refused to supply weapons to Israel during the Sinai campaign in 1956. My source is a scientific paper from the University of Göttingen in Germany.

Inwiefern?

​@@simonl.6338inwiefern was von beidem?

@@frauleinanni1528 inwiefern passt es nicht in seine Argumentation? Oder was hat es überhaupt mit dem Punkt zutun den er hier bespricht

@@simonl.6338 er stellt es so dar, als hätten die Juden aus Osteuropa nir Chaos gebracht. Das möchte ich zumindest für Breslau/Wrocław zurückweisen. Daß es osteuropäische/sowjetische Juden waren, die während der Mandatszeit Großbritanniens Terrorakte verübt haben, wußte ich vor drei Monaten noch nicht. Insgesamt ist seine Redeweise ziemlich hitzig.

Er spricht von der Mehrheit der Juden in Palästina, die nur den Zarismus und Kommunismus zur Zeit der britischen Besatzung Palästinas kannten. Breslau gehörte nie dem Zarenreich an und wurde erst nach 1945 Teil eines sozialistischen Staates. Er meint also ausdrücklich nicht die Juden aus Breslau, die nur eine kleine Minderheit ausmachten. Die Mehrheit der Juden zur Zeit des brittischen Mandats stammt aus Russland, in den 50ern stammt die Mehrheit der jüdischen Einwanderer aus islamischen Regionen, die bis heute trotz Öffnung der Grenzen nach dem Zusammenfall der sozialistischen Staaten und einer erneuten Fluchtbewegung nach Palästina eine knappe Mehrheit der jüdischen Bevölkerung in Israel bilden. Vielleicht solltest du etwas aufmerksamer und aufgeschlossener zuhören, statt hier eine Unterstellung nach der anderen abzulassen.

hamas uses the palistinian's as human shields !!!!Dante Brown

You should really be embarrassed to take on yourself the blame for the state of the Arab world! You should stop relieving the Arabs of responsibility for their own lives. They are responsible for their live, not the West! Stop already with this useless guilt!

Märchenstunde ala Kolonialismus

Then Usa and Australia are in big trouble because yall are coming but both cultures are more similar to Europe than Arabic culture

Stop with this permanent guilt already!

Wojtek Bernhard I can say that you are a brainwashed individual with Europeans elite obsolete ideas. The Prof. Is talking about facts not wishful thinking.

TeslaStellar two states? This is a European dream that would not materialize. Palestine will decide its fate. Israel need to separate. That’s it.

If, instead of Palestinians, Swiss or Belgians lived next to Israel, Netanyahu would agree to a two-state solution easily! The problem is not Netanyahu, but the Palestinians! Israel has offered them peace and its country several times - the Palestinians have always refused.

Ich denke schon, daß er es könnte, aber nicht will.

yes

He was there

Sonst würdest du alle hassen? 😂 Alter, lies dir deine Sätze nochmal durch.. was für ein vergiftetes Gewäsch. Ich hoffe auch, du hast ein paar "ganz andere" Schwarze kennengelernt, nicht dass die dir noch Anlass geben, alle zu hassen...

Ich hab nichts gegen Juden, aber .....

@@Daniel-yl8y Von "hassen" habe ich nichts geschrieben, und auch nichts von "Schwarzen" - spare dir und uns deine Phantasien.

@@timkaradas3255 Ich habe genau das Gegenteil geschrieben! Mein Name ist übrigens jüdisch - ich habe ihn bei der Hochzeit angenommen weil der Vater meiner Frau der einzige mit diesem Namen gewesen ist der den Holocaust überlebt hat.

@@thomasszejnmann3917 Wenn man schlecht über Juden spricht, ist man entweder Rassist oder selber einer. Das ist so ähnlich als würde ein Schwarzer sagen, dass Afrikaner super faul sind und nur Ärger machen wollen😂

Escriba DeBalaguer ich glaube israel verübt über einen langen zeitraum völlig unverhältnismäßige und unnötige gewalt und schikane an einer großen bevölkerungsgruppe, insbesondere zivilisten.

Hä, habe ich nicht geschrieben dass ich Angst hatte Fehlinformationen zu unterliegen? Dann habe ich mir ein 90-minütiges Interview mit einem israelischen Funktionär angeschaut, und ein paar weitere Videos dieser Reihe, und nun würde ich behaupten beide Seiten zur Genüge gehört zu haben. Und mein Schluss ist: Israel verübt über einen langen zeitraum völlig unverhältnismäßige und unnötige gewalt und schikane an einer großen bevölkerungsgruppe, insbesondere zivilisten. Ich meine: mit jedem Satz den der Kerl im Video sagt versucht er Krieg und Terror zu rechtfertigen und hat offensichtlich keinerlei Interesse an einer friedlichen Lösung. Es gibt auch weltweit kein Militär, dass eine solche große Zahl von Zivilisten in einem Freiluftgefängnis hält, ihnen den Zugang zu Nahrung und Wasser erschwert und willkürlich gegen die Grenzbewohner vorgeht. Flugblätter schön und gut, Haus und Hof sind danach trotzdem zerstört, und wenn man nirgends hinkann ist das eigene Leben trotzdem nicht sicher. Ich verteidige auch gar nicht die Hamas, aber Frieden kann nur vom Unterdrücker ausgehen.

ich werd mir das ding nicht nochmal angucken, nur um ein paar passende zitate zu finden, aber wenn israel ruhe will ist es nicht die cleverste option seine nachbarn zu unterdrücken und willkür walten zu lassen. die palestinenser haben keine rechte, sie können nur as dem untergrnd heraus agieren. und mir ist natürlich bewusst dass israel in weiten teilen verhasst ist, aber das wird durch so eine politik nicht besser werden. wann kam das letzte friedensangebot von netanyahu?

@M Seit die Muslimbrüder nun auch in Indonesien die Fäden in der Hand haben, ist auch dort der gesellschaftliche Zusammenhalt gefährdet.

I am glad that you bought everything. I hope your English improved.

He was very mean with europeans.

+David Cano Wie recht er hat. Das können wir demnächst live erleben & verifizieren.

David Cano … LaLa-Land, not Legoland. Legoland has far better management than the godamn EU.

quote unquote … nun haben wir 2019 und man sieht leider, wie richtig er lag.

@@earlyivermectincancelscovi2522 es ist 2020 und ich sehe hier gar nix. Welche Werte sollen denn aufgegeben werden? Ihr leidet wohl an Paranoia.

He was right about everything. And he is even more sure about everything those days!

It's absolutely TRUE. I found this out when I went there and interviewed elderly people from that era. I couldn't believe I had been fed political LIES all my life. Crap is what people are being told by those who have power and evil.

I can easily guess what he'd say to the war crimes. Something along the lines of: You have to try everything to prevent war crimes, but you are naive if you think you can win a war without getting your hands dirty. Especially if the opponents strategy is to use civilians as a human shield for better publicity. In my opinion, the much more interesting question is what the security adviser would have had to say to the illegal settlements and if or how they threaten Israel's security. To be honest, I'm to afraid to go to Israel in order to ask him myself, I prefer my good old safe European Disney Land.

Yes, I prefer EU-Disneyland too. Also the "I know many Arabs who are nice but the collective is evil." sounds pretty much like the white racist telling me that he has black friend....

I didn't catch that. I understood him the way that although he is in favor of pluralistic Arabs, they will not be the majority anytime soon. I fear he might be right. He seems a bit like one of these stereotypical movie-soldiers. The one who is fighting for the "right thing" but has seen to much shit to allow himself to be hopeful about the future. A man who doesn't allow himself to hope, because it could kill him. Guess this is the kind of mindset you get, if you live constantly in a warlike situation.

Tulipau Should go without saying that he is a total racist. Even for Israeli standards. Look at what colleagues and students say about him. bit.ly/1AYE2Qp

No, it is not a war crime to shell hospitals and refugee camps when they are used militarily. en.wikisource.org/wiki/Geneva_Convention/Fourth_Geneva_Convention "Article 19 The protection to which civilian hospitals are entitled shall not cease unless they are used to commit, outside their humanitarian duties, acts harmful to the enemy."

Yes, of course. They are not to blame for anything, these are all circumstances. It's all the West with its colonialism. Hh

Zionism only expresses the desire to have a self-determined life in a state that offers Jews protection from pogroms, persecution, dispossession, expulsion and discrimination after 2000 years of exile. What this has to do with globalization is beyond me. And he explained your other questions with many examples. Maybe you didn't listen properly. "what is a barbarian" For example, someone or a society that strives for violence and war more than to provide a good life for its family/citizens. "Can barbarians become civilised?" Yes, of course. "Is it the obligation of civilised people to rule over or dominate the barbarians?" No, of course not. Civilized societies should strive for the well-being of their people and protect them from barbaric attacks. In other videos he always emphasizes that he is in favour of a unilateral withdrawal from most (96%) of the Palestinian territories in the West Bank. In 2005 he supported Ariel Sharon's withdrawal from Gaza and parts of the West Bank. "What is the qualification to be recognized as civilised?" For example, not threatening his neighbors with extermination, as Hamas does. To build a pluralistic and democratic society so that its citizens can lead a self-determined and good life that is life-affirming, instead of raising its children to martyrdom and paying terrorists who blow up civilians in buses, restaurants and bars with high monetary rewards. "Are all Jews civilised?" No, of course not. In other interviews, he advocates the shooting or arrest of Jews in terrorist attacks on Palestinians, just as Palestinians are shot or arrested in terrorist attacks. Every society, whether democratic or not, also has "uncivilized" people who are criminal and violent or want to impose their way of life on other people, such as fascists or religious fanatics, but in democratic countries these people are currently a minority. "Are all arabs barbarians?" No, of course not. He said that he knows many good, decent Arabs and that there are probably millions of good Arabs, but they form a minority in their societies. In his remarks, he distinguishes between individuals and societies with group dynamics. In Germany there were also good people during the Nazi era, but the society and its leadership was barbaric. "Is there a reliable test for determining a person is civilised?" He is not concerned with individuals, but with societies and leaderships. He considers Iranian society, for example, to be very progressive and open-minded, but its leadership is not. In other countries, such as Jordan, he considers the leadership to be trustworthy, but not the society. "Is it possible for civilised people to regress to barbarianism?" Yes, he cited Germany as an example, where a parliamentary democracy existed for the first time before Adolf Hitler came to power from 1918 to 1933. Or Turkey, which took a positive direction with Atatürk and is now moving backwards under Erdoğan. "The more clarifications we have about what exactly Zionism is, the better for everyone." Zionism means striving for an independent Jewish state. But Zionists are not a homogeneous group. There are left-wing, right-wing, secular and religious Zionists, but they all have one thing in common. The desire for a place of refuge where Jews can live in self-determination and freedom. Zionism is the emancipation of the Jews after thousands of years of oppression and persecution. "It seems to me that Zionism and globalism are closely related, perhaps even identical." No, globalization means worldwide interdependence in the fields of economics, politics, culture, science and others. Zionism means striving for an independent Jewish state. Two words with completely different definitions and nothing in common. There is no international financial Jewry, such constructs only exist in the brains of anti-Semites like Adolf Hitler and other people who believe in "The Protocols of the Elders of Zion", such as Hamas, which refers to them in its founding charter.

A state called Palestine never existed, he is right in this...

Facts matters. Read a history book.

Deutsch ist ok abzulehnen wenn man in Israel ist und besonders dann wenn kleine Tobi keine andere Fremdsprachen kann.

ichabe dichlieb Bist halt dumm

Der Verwirrte alte Onkel ist mit Sichefheit viel gebildeter als du. Und er lebt da. Da darf man ihm schon eine Expertise zugestehen. Besonders Da er als Berater für die Regierung fungierte.

Your comment is so infantile ! 🤦🏻‍♂️ Do you know any person, not country, a person who can survive alone? Without any help? Answer me when you'll grow up. PS. USA is your (German) best friend father mother and rich uncle. At 1945 instead of crushing the German nation after what you made to the world, they made the greatest thing, they helper you to become a normal society, ‏from people ‏what live in order to ‏dominant others to that live and build better future. You would never succeed without USA!

gur ruh you just showed your enormous ignorance in public. Sadly you are not alone.

@@charlieclown9913 Stop clowning around..... thicko.

They are still struggle with it... 80 years after it was gone 🤦🏻‍♂️