Remembering of course all those, including those Israeli families with members that were kidnapped, were never for the treatment of Palestinians. There’s always been a pro-Palestinian movement in Israel. Generalizing that what a government does is the fault of the people makes all North American and European countries funding the war, as guilty as anyone, and not just this war but Everywhere!
I don’t think that’s what he tried to do. You see, Netanyahu would’ve been taken down by his own society a long time ago if he wasn’t actually popular. You’ll see people protesting him every now and then but it’s all a show. Without him, they wouldn’t have been able to maintain and expand their settler colonial project to this extent. He’s the perfect frontman. He fully understands the American political system. All this noise about him being unpopular is just nonsense. The average civilian anywhere has no clue how things work behind the scenes, but those who actually matter understand that he’s their best man. He’s their champion.
@@adiidahl have you asked yourself where the states of Syria, Lebanon and Jordan came from? Or why Jordan and Syria were slaughtering thousands of Palestinians?? The world is very quiet when it comes to that because it didn’t involve the Jews.
@@lilypad999-i9v I hate to burst your bubble, but most of the world does not like what Israel is doing. The only explanation for Israel getting away with what it is, and has been, getting away with breaking international law is a political one.
David Hearst is probably one of the best on West Asian matters. A long career in journalism and real journalism for that matter. And with MEE he has been giving us the undercurrents of the West Asian and global geopolitics at play.
Unfortunately he is parroting the horrible narrative. As if the problem started on Oct last year. This is a chronic disease, a cancer. It will wear down the patient while removing it but it is the only way to survive. As long as this cancer exists, we cannot recover, ever again. A radical & permanent solution is the only way out. It will leave the region in state of destruction but ut is for the good of new generations, including the Jews.
without background music. you will hear a buzzing sound similar to a bee or background noises. that is because of background noises like lets say there is a fan to keep people cool will be picked up by that persons mic. So music is like noise cancellation.
@@lilypad999-i9vno Canaanites are natives, go study history properly. The world didn’t start with Judea, you see friend, you belong in Egypt building pyramids
HAMAS should reject any peace deal if it doesn't include the Israelis getting out of all the land they have taken illegally from the Palestians and getting out of Gaza and dismantling their open prison. If HAMAS just surrenders the Palestians will be back to where they were in 1980 no rights and back to the aparthied system with no self determination and a justice system that doesn't recognise them as humanbeings.
Hamas will never have a chance to sign a peace deal while netanyahu and Ben-Gvir are in power. The goal post will always move and any peace deal will be pulled before it can be agreed to. Biden had proposed a peace deal and Hamas agreed to it but of course Netanyahu refused at the last second. it's all a charade
Deeply informative, eye-opening, interesting and comprehensive. Thank you so much, Mr Hearst, and well done for these analyses. Presented in an easily understood manner and trotted out in a fashion easy to follow. Not dense or lugubrious. This is why I follow MEE. Well done, all.
This is utter nonsense that the person 'Netanjansky' is the one obstacle regarding a ceasefire and other things because if this one person would be the (only) troublemaker then the military and other organisations and the citizens of Israel would have easily couped him out of the way. The reality is that Israel is an atrocious monolith and has to be dealt with as a whole.
The freakshow Meilokowsky But case yahoo us the representation of that society. They've been doing this for the last 75 years out of sight and out of mind
It's true, as a Jordanian we are mad at our government for not doing anything significant, but at the same time we know it has no power to do much. It's a shi*ty hopeless situation that we're in, and it was designed to be that way by Israel and Western powers.
What do you suggest?, he does something to lose his country and sentences his people to have the same faith of the Iraqis, Syrians, Libyans and Yemenis?, or worse, the Palestinians? If this war has a hope for arab win believe me they would have won decades ago
@@4549uef you should address this question to the country that for the last 76 years that been causing chaos in the region 8000 miles away from their shores, involved in violently displacing people, supporting coups, fighting proxy wars, supporting dictators, invading countries, supplying weapons including chemical weapons, starvation sanctions, divide and rule and all manner of barbarism. Leave people alone and go back to your violent country and take all your bases and weapons with you. Then peace, prosperity and calm will return to the whole Middle East.
@@4549uefdirect your question to the country and its super ally that has been causing absolute chaos in the region for the past 76 years. Once this big ally stops its nefarious activities and returns 8000 miles back to its own violent shores, peace and prosperity will return to the Middle East. I can elaborate but then the comment will be deleted.
If the king is wise he would oppose Israel to secure his position in Jordan following popular sentiment, but it's too much to say no to the bribe ehm... Aid isn't it?
The PLO tried to overthrow the king of Jordon after he gave refugees citizenship. You can keep your pro-terrorist support. Protecting his people from war is the King's humble dream.
Well, he does oppose Israel publicly.. so? Do you want him to declare a war against Israel/America to be on the right side of History? In that case then, I really hope you don't get into politics.
What do you suggest?, he does something to lose his country and sentences his people to have the same faith of the Iraqis, Syrians, Libyans and Yemenis?, or worse, the Palestinians? If this war has a hope for arab win believe me they would have won decades ago
@MiddleEastEye Thank you for this very informative post. But please in future don’t have a loud background music. It was very difficult to follow the reporter.
With my deep and unrestricted respect: please don't say America.....it takes Brazilians, Mexicans, Argentinians, Chileans, Canadians hostage..... It's the US /administration ..... Great analysis...as always!
Listening to this discourse I perceive that the west , the leaders, the billionairs accept millions of deads in Gaza and Jordania or even look at it as colateral damage.
Unbelievable! Just ONE psychopath out of millions can actually destroy everything?! It's infuriating how easily evil could win just because of one lunatic with their finger on the button.
Why do you call the West Bank border with Jordan, Israeli-Jordanian border when Israel is occipying West Bank. More than 80/130 countries recognize Palestine within the 1967 borders as an independent state .
I accept your analysis but I would like to state that the insistence of US policy on making Israel défit Hamas may end up loosing Israel as a country . US should care about Israel as a state and society not only as an extended military of its army. Only fair peace with the Palestinians can keep Israel in peace.
Israel is a foreign occupying colony. The dream of Israel is like the British dream of India, or the French dream of French Algeria. Jews may be able to survive within an Arab or Muslim state as Jews have done in the past, but the colonial occupation must end
All those clear and well informed (if one choses to be informed and aware) were aware of this "Netanyahu status" to he be "free" (as sought by Israeli court( as kong as Israel remains in state of war...
Yes, my dear brothers, my beloved Palestine is the cradle of Christianity and Judaism, and it contains Al-Aqsa, the third holiest place for us Muslims in Palestine. Bethlehem, the cradle of Christ, is a blessed land, and it is the holy land, and it has been our land for tens of thousands of years, and it is the land of the Canaanite Arabs, the original Palestinian people, and they have lived in it since the Islamic conquest in the era. The Umayyad, Abbasid and Ottoman Arabs, Muslims, Christians and Jews are like brothers and neighbors under Palestinian rule to the owners of the land, but the Zionists came and the British occupation brought them to our land as compensation to the Jews for what they did to them Hitler. The question here is that who did the Holocaust, the Germans, why do I, the Palestinian Arab, pay the price? Why not Germany? Why do I, the Muslim, pay the price for crimes? Committed by the Germans and Nazi Europe, fascism is the root of all evil in the world. Our problem is the occupation🙏Palestine is an area of more than 27 thousand square kilometers and is on the borders of Egypt and Jordan, which historically is part of Palestine and the people of Jordan, more than 70 percent of whom are of Palestinian origin, but Britain made them a state and brought agents to the Jordanian ruling dynasty in order to rule Jordan and protect the occupation from the Jordanian-Palestinian people Palestine Its capital, Jerusalem, is the land of the Palestinian people for tens of thousands of years. It is the cradle of Christianity and Judaism, and it is the third holiest place for us Muslims. It is a land where most of God’s prophets lived, were born, and died. It is the holy and blessed land and the land of the Palestinian and Arab people. Muslims, Jews, and Christians lived there for thousands of years as neighbors and brothers before the Zionists occupied our land. Britain brought them in the Balfour Declaration to occupy our land. Those who committed the Holocaust against the Jews were the Germans and the West, not me.🙏🙏🙏
I agreed with most of your words Canaanite Arabs lmao? That's some historical revision on a epic proportion You're seriously suggesting that was the same population as the modern Arabs? Possibly some but even Jesus spoke Aramaic not Arabic There isn't a Aramaic population The Lebanese Phoenician isn't the same as Arab
And as for the wrongdoers, they will be the fuel of Hell.’ (الْجِنّ - Al-Jinn [72 : 15]) And this (Revelation has also come to me) that if they had remained firm on the right path (the path of truth, the path of the remembrance of Allah), then We would have provided them with abundant water, (الْجِنّ - Al-Jinn [72 : 16]) So that We put them to trial by this blessing. And whoever turns away from the remembrance of his Lord, He will cause him to enter a severe torment. (الْجِنّ - Al-Jinn [72 : 17]) And that mosques are (specified) for Allah alone. So never worship anyone else besides Allah. (الْجِنّ - Al-Jinn [72 : 18]) And that when the servant of Allah (Muhammad [blessings and peace be upon him]) stood up to worship Him, they thronged around him (to listen to his recitation). (الْجِنّ - Al-Jinn [72 : 19]) Say: ‘I worship only my Lord and do not associate any partner with Him.’ (الْجِنّ - Al-Jinn [72 : 20]) Say: ‘I do not possess any power to do you harm (i.e., make you disbelieve) or to do you good (i.e., make you believe. So Allah is the real Lord. I am a mediator and means).’ (الْجِنّ - Al-Jinn [72 : 21]) Say: ‘Neither can anyone shelter me from a torment (against the command) of Allah, nor can I ever find refuge apart from Him. (الْجِنّ - Al-Jinn [72 : 22]) But (my responsibility is) to communicate from Allah His commands and messages. And whoever disobeys Allah and His Messenger (blessings and peace be upon him), surely there is for him the Fire of Hell in which they will live forever.’ (الْجِنّ - Al-Jinn [72 : 23]) Until, when they will see that torment which is being promised to them, (then) they will come to know who is weaker in helpers and fewer in numbers. (الْجِنّ - Al-Jinn [72 : 24]) Say: ‘I do not know whether that (Day of Rising) which is being promised to you is near, or my Lord has appointed a longer term for that.’ (الْجِنّ - Al-Jinn [72 : 25]) (He is) the Knower of the unseen. So He does not inform any (common man) of His unseen, (الْجِنّ - Al-Jinn [72 : 26]) Except for His Messengers with whom He is well-pleased (and reveals to them alone the unseen because that is an exclusive trait of Prophethood and a Messenger’s miracle as well). So indeed He appoints protectors at both front and rear of him (the Messenger, for the security of the knowledge of the unseen), (الْجِنّ - Al-Jinn [72 : 27]) So that Allah may bring to light that surely they (the Messengers) have communicated the messages of their Lord, and Allah has (already) encompassed what they have (of Allah’s injunctions and the knowledge of the unseen) and He has kept count of everything. (الْجِنّ - Al-Jinn [72 : 28]) The Glorious Quran App Minhaj Publications
Thank you very informative. Big brother taking revenge on small brother (as a toy) from father's violence. That's a classic. Free Palestine forever AMEN
Palestinians (referring geographically to the people that lived there including Canaanites and Philistines) continuously lived in that land longer than the Children of Israel and Jews including when the Children of Israel were in Egypt and the wilderness and when Jews were exiled by the Assyrians, Babylonions and Romans. Historically Jews found refuge with Palestinians and Muslims. Judaism is not the same religion that the Children of Israel followed. After the death of Prophet Solomon (Peace be Upon Him) His kingdom split into 2, the people named the southern part Kingdom of Judah and they invented Judaism and called themselves Jews. Over a century ago, Zionists moved into Palestine in the thousands and started persecuting, oppressing and murdering Palestinians including women and kids and stealing their land, which they continue to do to this day. God is just, His timing is perfect and He commands mankind to do what is good and to not do what is evil. Persecuting, oppressing and murdering Palestinians (including women and kids) and stealing their land for over a century, is evil.
David Vs Goliath you heard of that? Goliath was a philistine invader from crete or other greek islands They are not older than the Jews. Jews were Canaanite also, Abraham was an Iraqi Jew Sumerian in origin
