Helen Joyce joins Julia Hartley-Brewer on TalkTV to discuss David Tennant's comments about Kemi Badenoch. Original video: • Julia Hartley-Brewer |... Support our work: sex-matters.or...
try to imagine how little he cares? He is living in a rarified, EXclusive environment and so no ill effects for him embracing this ideology. His understanding of the issues 9and by logical extension, those of his 'wonderful wife') are as wide as they are deep....
"As long as they are not hurting anyone else" ?Like females in safe spaces? Like females in sport? Like females in prisons? Like females seeking medical care? Like children being medicalized? Like children being manipulated? Like people being canceled, losing jobs, harrassed, attacked physically, for knowing there are two sexes? 😮 ❤Helen Joyce ❤ Let Helen speak
You hit the nail on the head Julia! It’s become a fashion and David Tenant wants to be part of the trend! His remarks were unacceptable, it was very noticeable that he tried so hard to back track!
My understanding is that Tennant's son is 10yrs old. He says he's non-binary and asks people to use "they/them" pronouns. What 10 yr old does that without adult input? He's a child who should be occupied with all the things a normal 10yr old enjoys, yet he's clearly not only knee-deep in gender issues with all the relevant terminolgy, but has parents who are entrenching him in this stuff by making it public - and all before the child is even out of primary school.
@@londo776Do you honestly believe a child would come out with that without having it put in their head. It's abuse, pure and simple and the parents should be treated as such.
@@londo776 Obviously? 😂I think you're trolling this thread but anyway..... I'm from a large family. I've had children, plus a gaggle of nephews and nieces. Also, my academic qualifications are in psycholgy, so I'm not entirely without an understanding of what might be considered fairly average behaviour for a 10yr old.
@@londo776Not sure what you mean….but telling lies - as an adult - ie the parents - or the child - isn’t wise and isn’t good for the mental and physical health of the child. So sad….that parents can’t see they are seriously damaging the health of their children. I come from a legal child protection/vulnerable adult work background so I know what damage can be done. So so sad. But that’s the nature of following a cult.
Really, checkout the figures for rape by cis males as opposed to trans females and the miniscule number of children with body dismorphia and don't let political extremism win over facts.
Check out the nurses taking their trust to ? Tribunal, for sex discrimination for expecting female nurses to change in and out of their uniform in the presence of a man. I wish them luck in their case
@@jesipohl6717. Yes, that would be fine. Women are different from men. Strange men, NO. that would be crazy. Get out of here as if it’s the same. This lunacy is what people are so upset over. Would it be ok for your mother to change in front of a strange man?
David and his wonderful family are the perfect example of what we should all strive to be! Being kind and accepting others for who they are should be common sense and decency, in a world where you can be anything, be kind!
@@londo776 but he isn’t kind - he’s trashed a female politician telling to ‘shut up’ wishing she was no longer there. He’s not interested in women’s rights nor how to help children- Kemi’s job!!! 🤷♀️
I feel sorry for his child - that's no way to be brought up. I actually never had problems with Gay marriage, or them bringing up children (most I knew seemed pretty together) but this is....horrific.
Surely parents who mess with an innocent child’s mind in this way should have social services involved for abuse? This poor child is going to have serious mental health issues later in life 😡
My experience as a father of two ‘female’ daughters and grandfather to 5 grandchildren and of someone who worked as a youth worker for several years is that all children are looking for attention and will hook onto any excuse that adults give them to receive that attention. When I was a child it was called ‘showing off’. Maybe the adults in the room that advocate for this are the show offs.
Oh dear so sad ,poor David Tennant and wife having to go along with this bull shit feel sorry for their child let's hope time will re adjust this as I do believe they are coming from this from a bases of love, but will cause huge problems in the future of their child. Respect David and will be sending my love to his family , but they are so wrong.
And why are they allowed to do this to their children? If you were the average Joe Social Services would visit you. Luvvies turning themselves inside out to gain publicity and attention.
I'm not even convinced that Tennant believes the stuff he's saying. J.K. Rowling, who owns one of the most lucrative intellectual properties in the world, speaks her mind despite the backlash she knows she'll get for it. Tennant, who is an actor who is beholden to entertainment industry bosses (who are themselves very woke and at the same time also rich and egotistical) throws his own son under the bus in order to curry favor, look fashionable, and extend his career. In both cases, the ones with the real money are having their points of view heard. Rowling directly, and she owns it, despite the backlash, Tennant as the sock puppet of the people he's trying to impress in order to get acting work.
Robert Sapolsky, a Stanford professor of biology who has done extensive neuroimaging research, suggested a possible neurobiological explanation for cross-gender identification in a 2013 Wall Street Journal article, “Caught Between Male and Female.” He asserted that recent neuroimaging studies of the brains of transgender adults suggest that they may have brain structures more similar to their gender identity than to their biological sex. David's attitude is part of effect, not cause. As with Atheism, which would be pointless were it not for the existence of Theism. Atheism being an effect of Theism. If a society doesn't want uber-woke backlash then just let people exist in the name of decency and no malice and hatred? The only reason for this woke noise is the anti-woke counter-noise. It is actually that simple to just take it all down to a reasoned simmer and without all the rabble-rousing and assertions and shaming. It might actually help. To paraphrase: The sleep of reason is the wellspring of monstrosity. To get rid of monstrosity, remove unreason. It is not reasonable to bully and target minority and divergent populations with hatred and furthermore not expect a countermovement. That's what the rainbow flags are for! To some, David's comments may be monstrosity, but it is effect of monstrosity. The cause needs to look at itself before criticizing. And moving right to the cause, the importance of consent between biological genders and the non-invasion of private spaces needs to be drummed in at school age!! That should be mandatory!
@@msto1987 Do you want to back up that silly statement with reasoned argument and facts or are you just another one of those sound byte trans iconoclasts??.
@fusionfan6883 back it up? Sure. Fact 1 The LAW states trans women are women. You don't like that FACT. Fact 2. Your own party didn't agree with this nonsense stance (except of course for the bigots like kemi or sewerella) and had 14 years to change the law but didn't Fact 3- this woman is in fact old (ie fossil) and irrelevant as whatever she said will change zero, but it will make the sheep fans of talktv and gbnews happy....they love slopping up propaganda(ok that last bit was opinion) Fact 4- SIR Kier doesn't subscribe to your nonsense, he knows women can have a penis "under the law" which he will NOT be changinging Fact 5- I'll be on these boards nearly everyday trolling the intellectually bankrupt, morally repugnent "facts don't care about feelings yet I cry becuase trans women make me feel less" fake Christian hypocrites And #5 you can take straight to the bank dearie
There would be uproar if those remarks had been made about Diane Abbott ( quite rightly) because she's left wing. Either way, his comments are deplorable
yes, there is a 2 their system like you whine and cry about, so yes the left will be defended, the right are trash that will be swept out on July 4th. where they and there voters belong. Maybe get on the left side of things and you will find that the "The Left is the right". or don't, I enjoy you bucking up against the left and come running to Julia to hear her cry, then you can cry with her in the comments. I gotta say, I LOVE IT
@@londo776an informed choice would be "Sweetheart you know youre a boy because everyone is either a boy or a girl, but that doesn't mean you can't wear dresses or play with dolls all that's totally fine by us" Sex is, by definition, binary and almost all animals and plants have sexual reproduction to make offspring. We're mammals that's how we reproduce. Apart from reproduction there's no reason why people can't behave as they wish within the Law.
No! No, let him speak. Let him and the rest of them show everyone how illiberal and intolerant and just plain old misogynistic they are, whilst pretending to be the opposite.
you don't really want an answer, you just want to make that point since it appears to suit your argument. I can see a bad actor from a mile (the real way to measure distance) away
oh, we have a clinical Psychologist in here. Husky can hear a 10 second clip and quickly diagnosed how to type something dumb in the comment section... Tennent is more of a DR then you, sir
@HANKHILLFORTXGOVERNOR my movement? I don't care one way or another how people live there lives.... but you do. You insist on telling others they don't deserve the same rights as you and a 5 year old can tell that that is a selfish cowards position. Own it
My 12 year old daughter told me she was bisexual (fine, fully supported her) 3 years on she said she's not and that she just wanted everyone to see her as special. Very sad that she thought that was a way to get attention. Again, thrilled either which way!
In my day if I had told my parents I was bi they would have thrown me bashed the hell out of me and thrown me in a children's home. They bullied and bashed me anyway for being queer anyway.
Yes, funny that! It was a bit of a fashion when my kids were at school. Loads of kids, mainly girls, going around broadcasting they were bi. Now my hairdresser tells me, that after her son declared last year that he was gay, he now says he’s trans. There’s classes where whole groups of friends are coming out as trans. Again, mainly girls. Pretty sure it’s the same kind of thing, only with far more serious consequences should they take hormones or have surgery. It’s a social contagion. There will be a lot of very messed up young adults in the not too distant future.
I can relate to that. When I was 14/15 I was convincing myself that I was bi but I realise it's because I didn't feel comfortable as a stereotypical girl + thought there must be a reason for it. I'm now happily married to a man with a daughter myself and terrified of this nonsense absorbing her as she gets older and the hormones start raging!
@@Kazberhaf not as bad as when the Dali Lama asked that little boy to suck his tongue. People never fail to disappoint. Best not to put anyone on a pedestal, I've come to realize.
2 people with the intellectual intelligence of a rock talking about their own bigoted stances on an issue that the law has already addressed. I know you right wingers hate trans rights but if anyone was going to change the law it was during the last 14 years of terrible conservative leadership. Labour aint gonna change it, and it is the law so be prepared for a decade of disappointment
Tennant's crass virtue signalling makes me nauseous. Him bringing his child up in a cult-like ideology where objective reality is demonised makes me very concerned for that child's long term mental health and physical wellbeing.
As long as they are not hurting anyone else David. You said it. Men in women's changing rooms is hurting women however those men identify as. There is an old saying David, it's called a wolf in sheep's clothes. It doesn't make the wolf a sheep and he still eats the sheep.
For Fucks sake what's it matter to you what somebody identifies as How's it affecting your everyday life we I'm not asking you to agree but just show some respect We are all human
@@londo776 Men can identify however they want, but as the stronger and more violent sex, can't expect women to give up their safe spaces and sports. They already have the male spaces and sports categories, if that is not good enough for them, they can campaign for third spaces/categories.
Julia is terrible for interrupting. Badinoch was wrong to bring Race into it, we expect that from the left. She was right in her other comments. Tennant is a commie.
But it is doing harm! Exposing children to sexuality and sexual things before their brains are able to comprehend it creates lasting damage. And the kids that are being trans way before the appropriate age, before puberty, those kids have lifelong damage, not just to their mind and their psyche, but to their bodies!
@@londo776Yes. Tennant has the right to say what he's said... and others have the right to criticise him for saying it. You can't invoke free speech only in the instances when it supports your narrative and ONLY your narrative.
David said he believes that anyone can live however they want as long as they don't hurt anyone else and i agree BUT this small minority demanding we must all agree with their delusion IS hurting women imo. Women's rights should be respected too
For Fucks sake what's it matter to you what somebody identifies as How's it affecting your everyday life we I'm not asking you to agree but just show some respect We are all human
@@londo776it's affecting the life of vulnerable disabled women and girls who can know longer legally request natal female carers. If a male carer says he's a woman, he gets access to, for example, learning disabled girls and disabled women who live alone. The choice is let the man in or go without essential care.
silly silly comment, bet you said the same thing about women voting, blacks voting gay marriage, all these taboo issues will just go away. good luck with that
@@msto1987 No , I said trans children will go the way of other medical practices that were common in recent memory. Practices like.... Electro Convulsive Therapy Castration of homosexual men Frontal Lobotomy for criminals Asylums for hysterical women Eugenics Sterilisation for learning disabilities Homes for Down Syndrome people All these medical practices were common, soon medical gender transition for children will also be on the list and people in 20 years will look back in horror and wonder how on earth it happened. There will be a lot of long prison sentences here in the UK, that's for sure.
@@msto1987All those things you mentioned were examples of people fighting actual oppression. They were denied rights and protection by the law because of their race, sex or orientation. They just wanted to be treated as equals. They didn't demand special treatment or try to take away the rights and safety of others. The trans movement is demanding privileges and threatening the rights and safety of women and children. You might as well compare oranges and hand grenades.
For Fucks sake what's it matter to you what somebody identifies as How's it affecting your everyday life we I'm not asking you to agree but just show some respect We are all human
David Tennant should’ve been a proper father and man and not pandered to this destructive ideology he should’ve helped his child rather than colluded with his fantasy, he’s a child, there is no way he understands the severity of this rubbish
@@londo776 nope - the rights of women and the rights of the vulnerable to be protected - ideology only ‘affirms’ beliefs - it doesn’t help you work things out for yourself - which is what we used to do. Pride is lost and Now it’s all a kink fest and helps no one
@@londo776Is anyone surprised londo disingenuously OP'ed asking why can't "any of you" have a rational discussion? After a trick like strawman too. Same every time.
@@londo776 Kind and accepting of others, except those dreadful women who want to protect their privacy, dignity and safety. Oh, and that of children. Which would include Tennant's children, if he thought about it for a minute.
its not scary how many trans people have done anything to you most women children are hurt by fathers and boyfriends or a member of their family now thats scary but that does not mean all fathers boyfriends family members will do that they have picked up on the two rapists that said after that they were women they raped first now all are thrown under the bus
how's the irony of that man talking about "human decency" in the same breath as wishing for the non-existence of someone he disagrees with, and telling her to just "shut up"? I'm done with him.
R checkout the figures for rape by cis males as opposed to trans females and the miniscule number of children with body dismorphia and don't let political extremism win over facts.
Changing pants is clearly hyper violence. Should lesbian women have a seperate changing room? Cis women commit violent crime more often than any group of trans people, so lesbian women would in theory be more dangerous, or?
Unfortunately, that never stops them. Actors politics are not worth listening to. Ricky Gervais told them so at the Golden Globes. “Most of you have had less schooling than Greta Tunberg”!😂
Ah yes ! As if we don't have enough political actors within UK politics. How about Actors stick to acting and politicians stick to their own drivel. Stop mixing roles or perhaps like politicians we the masses only support those who align with your personal political views and avoid their work altogether.
David is right that it does not merit an award. Very wrong in his reasoning. As a parent desperately fighting the transing of children, I loathe parents affirming the bs.
0:44: "Everyone has the right to be who they want to be and live their life how they want to live it as long as they're not hurting anyone else". You can’t disagree with that. The problem is that these radical TQ activists only care about themselves so they refuse to see and hear that they effing *ARE* hurting others big time. They’re not only hurting women and children they’re also hurting people who are LGB and actual Ts.
Some actors own certain roles; others are owned by them. Mr. Tennant seems to be unable to shake that reptilian role he created in the Harry Potter series.
Deliberately choosing not to watch the video clip of him saying that, because I want to watch more episodes of his incarnation of the Doctor when I have time for it, (as I hear they’re very, very good!), and I do NOT want the misogynistic, TRA Kool-Aid sipping idiocy of the REAL human actor to ruin it for me.. As I know it likely would. :/ Oh well… At least torrenting is still a thing, and ye shall get absolutely NO money from me, going forward, David Tennant!! You’re most welcome. :D
I know. I did watch it but braced myself knowing I still want to see his DrWho. Reminding myself I'm not them and can accept differences. Still difficult though. :(
Can I just add? 3hrs later. lol. I have a very difficult time now watching Sarah Paulson on AHS. Knowing as a lesbian myself she'd throw her sisters to Michael Langdon. Fans of Apocalypse will know what I"m saying. She's no Cordelia. I realize actors are not their characters, but she's ruined the ability to suspend disbelief. To watch Cordelia drive a dagger into her own heart on behalf of her sisters who "are LEGION, mfer!" and fall to her heroic death... only to serve us up in real life.... such a betrayal.
... it's also a sad reminder that wmn are almost nothing like the sisters of the coven in AHS who are undyingly loyal. We have among us at all times a segment who will always throw her sisters to the mn. Wmn who badmouth fmnism with the fellas are displaying that just as the ones who ally on the left.
Considering more crimes are committed by cis women than trans people, should it be considered to seperate straight and not straight women as well if someone feels uncomfortable?
Actually David Tennant and his wife should have their child taken away from them they are irresponsible absolutely bonkers . Also Kemi Badenoch has something David Tennant will never have and that is 'Class '.
that's why the legions of fans will always support him over the bigot badenock. Face reality, he is THE Doctor, not baker or baker or smith or Capaldi or whittiker. and he will always be more loved and repected, and probably doesn't give 2 spits about a right wing opinion
Andrew gunn... another proud product of the failure of UK education system. Maybe google the definition of "dead" or "Killed" assuming you can read. or perhaps see the good "Dr. who" about you hearing issue, maybe David can get you squared away with a hearing aide. point being, you are either Dumb or deaf
