Debunking The Two State Solution in 3 Minutes 

A better argument is that Palestinians themselves do not want a two state solution. Palestinian leadership will only accept a Palestinian state if it replaces Israel. Until Palestinians stop calling for the destruction of Israel, a two-state solution is 100% unworkable.

Bottom Line: You cannot compromise with those who do not even recognize your right to exist.

Two state solution was realized a long ago. Israel is situated on 23% of the historic Palestinian mandate and thre Kingdom of Jordasn occupies 77 % of the lands initially promised to the Jews! What else do Muslims need?

The Arabs have a state already it’s called Jordan 🇯🇴

I'm not pro isreal, nor am I pro palistine. But would I feel comfortable living in the middle of Muslim nations? Fuck no, and having one right next door shooting missles into my country? Again fuck no. If Nz or Indonesia was shooting missles into Australia, do you think Australia would put up with it? Of course not. And vice versa.

Love this guy, right on every point, weakness breeds destruction.

When people say, "The conflict in the Middle East, is a very complex issue," they know little or nothing about the Middle East. It is not that complex, it was clear from the very beginning. Jews wanted only one thing, to return to their indigenous homeland. They wanted their ancestral land back that foreigners had ejected them from, and been occupying for over a thousand years. Though they never completely left or abandoned the land of Israel and a remnant had always maintained a presence in Israel, they had never regained the sovereignty they once possessed. Multiple foreign armies had for over a millennia, overrun the land, occupied it, then in turn had their own homelands conquered, and eventually abandoned their occupation of Israel and left. For Jews, it is not a complex issue. They are no different than any nation that in the past was conquered and had their homeland occupied by foreigners. Their strongest wish is to return to their indigenous homeland and once again gain sovereignty. After over a millennia the Jewish people scattered abroad, returned to join the remnant that had managed to remain and accomplished their dream, regaining sovereignty over some of their indigenous land. To Arabs in the Middle East, it is also not complex. They have sovereignty over 22 nations, and also only want one thing. The one thing they want, is for the Jews not to have sovereignty over any of their historic indigenous land in the Middle East. The conflict in the Middle East is not a very complex issue.

Loved this! BTW, there already are two states. Jordon resides on more than half of former "Palestine". If anyone wants to actually look at an historical map, they will see what former "Palestine" was and what is it today. I can't quite understand why this is rarely, if ever mentioned in the media.

Never ever give up, never ever give in , never ever give way ! Stay strong , stay determined and stay put forever ! Am Yisrael Chai ❤

Point 3 is the best! And widely misunderstood - too bad the woke west will not understand until it is too late.

Land for peace is a failure. I was wrong. We need a 23 state solution. Arabs in greater Israel go to any of 22 Arab states and the indigenous jews get Israel which stays where it it. American former democrat voter (voted dem in every presidential election since carter and saw the 79 Sadat deal as proof that land for peace worked. Never again 10/7 was a seismic event

The root cause of the problem is NOT occupation, colonization etc. It is the inherent inability of Muslims to co-exist with any other religious groups. * Show me ONE country where Muslims have integrated well? * Show me ONE muslim country where non-muslims are treated well? Another good example of giving 2 states solution is Kashmir where Muslims enjoyed an almost fully autonomous state till 2 years ago since India's independence (that is more than 50+ years) and it became a breeding ground for all types of terror groups. Now Modi revoked the special status of Kashmir and it is getting back to normal.

Ding ding ding, we have a winner

plain and clear, the wife comparision got me.

Israel will always prevail, not because of our capacity or force, but because the Almighty said so. These demons may cause havoc with their brutal wickedness, but their god is a false god, a delusion. As in ancient times, whichever tribe prevailed meant that their god was stronger etc. But the God of Abraham, Isaac & Jacob is the one true God. When Israel suffers, it’s due to disobedience, rebellion, idolatry or social injustice, not because of God. This is all due to the covenant. The Almighty will also judge the nations against Israel, in His perfect timing. Blessed is He.

Great video 👏👏

In history there never was a independent state of palestine!

Very insightful. Thank you

With Islam. Your kindness is interpreted as "Kindness is weakness"

They had a defacto state …they failed the test

Why do you call it "Two State *Solution"* and not Two State Problem?

Yes the Palestinians should go live in Jordan. But then again they tried to overthrow the king 👑 of Jordon. Everywhere they go they cause problems. Peace is not in the vocabulary of Palestinians.

Exactly. "Peace at any cost" is the motto of cowards.

Excellent explanation!! Very clear..

Finally someone making sense! Thank you.

Yishai is spot on with his observations on "what the Arab ear hears" and it's something that the West is generally ignorant of.

PALESTINE already have a state called Jordan

it debunked itself good and proper on 10/7

There's a fifth reason he didn't mention: there are actually three states wherein two disagree with each other (West Bank and Gaza).

Ireland supports Israel

Love that Yishai was able to explain so clearly why a 2 state solution would never work. Only 1 point... the comparison of ceding land to the ´enemy´ is like giving them your wife... not sure that equates .... is there some other comparative perhaps ?

This issue is dead simple. There are 5 million Arabs in the West Bank and Gaza. They cannot vote for the Israeli government, even though the Israeli government controls their land. There are 2 million Arabs in Israel who can vote, leading to 7 million total Arabs in the land. There are around 7 million Jews in the land. If you reject the two-state solution, Israel can be majority-Jewish, or it can be democratic. It cannot be both. Which do you choose?

Take it all back.

This should be essential viewing for Blinken and Co. who continue to push the old worn out line that has guided their actions for decades ......and the outstanding results are obvious to all. In the meantime the Palestinians and friends are constantly encouraged to believe that in no time at all it will all be theirs...but dreams sometimes are shattered.

Well spoken ❤❤. I stand with Israel 🇮🇱

Free Judea. Annex Gaza. Build settlements. Permanent peace.

Israel is Israel because we are Jews and are supposed to follow the Torah and the Tanach which includes the books of the prophets, which is the word of G-d. Which prophet spoke of two nations existing, splitting the land of Israel? Answer: none

@Israel “An appeaser is one who feeds a crocodile, hoping it will eat him last.” Winston Churchill

The two state solution has been implemented for over fifty years: the Mandate of Palestine was split into Jordan an Israel. Even that has been fraught with problems, but it seems to have worked itself out at this point.

Sadly, too true!

History of the imaginary PALESTINIAN STATE: 1. Before Israel, there was a British mandate, not a Palestinian state 2. Before the British Mandate, there was the Ottoman Empire, not a Palestinian state. 3. Before the Ottoman Empire, there was the Islamic state of the Mamluks of Egypt, not a Palestinian state. 4. Before the Islamic state of the Mamluks of Egypt, there was the Ayubid Arab-Kurdish Empire, not a Palestinian state. 5. Before the Ayubid Empire, there was the Frankish and Christian Kingdom of Jerusalem, not a Palestinian state. 6. Before the Kingdom of Jerusalem, there was the Umayyad and Fatimid empires, not a Palestinian state. 7. Before the Umayyad and Fatimid empires, there was the Byzantine empire, not a Palestinian state. 8. Before the Byzantine Empire, there were the Sassanids, not a Palestinian state. 9. Before the Sassanid Empire, there was the Byzantine Empire, not a Palestinian state. 10. Before the Byzantine Empire, there was the Roman Empire, not a Palestinian state. 11. Before the Roman Empire, there was the Hasmonean state, not a Palestinian state. 12. Before the Hasmonean state, there was the Seleucid, not a Palestinian state. 13. Before the Seleucid empire, there was the empire of Alexander the Great, not a Palestinian state. 14. Before the empire of Alexander the Great, there was the Persian empire, not a Palestinian state. 15. Before the Persian Empire, there was the Babylonian Empire, not a Palestinian state. 16. Before the Babylonian Empire, there were the Kingdoms of Israel and Judah, not a Palestinian state. 17. Before the Kingdoms of Israel and Judah, there was the United Kingdom of Israel, not a Palestinian state. 18. Before the United Kingdom of Israel, there was the theocracy of the twelve tribes of Israel, not a Palestinian state. 19. Before the theocracy of the Twelve Tribes of Israel, there was an agglomeration of independent Canaanite city-kingdoms, not a Palestinian state. 20. Actually, in this piece of land there has been everything, EXCEPT A PALESTINIAN STATE.

Absolutely! There is no agreement when one part want to eliminate and eradicate the other.

"We walked out of Judea and Samaria". What about all the settlers and soldiers there? I don't know if or how a two state solution could work. But what is the solution? A one state, all Israel? If Israel wants to stay a democracy it would have to give equal rights to everybody, but then Jews would be a minority. Or you would ethnic cleanse the Palestinians. Where should they go? No neighbour state wants to take them (all).

Can someone explain point 2, i dont get it.

That guy makes a lot of sense. Unfortunately common sense is very un PC.

HAMAS's objective is to built a replica of the Islamic Republic of Iran under Shariah Law. I have seen a video asking Palestinians on the street what would happen to the Jews 'If Palestine was to retake Palestine.' The interesting thing is that some said they would be okay with the Jews who were there prior to 1948, they say they had no problems with them, even though the Arabs and Jews fought almost all the time in the 1920s. Everyone else, except for maybe direct descendants would have to 'go back to where they came from, not my problem. It's your mess to clean up.' The Palestinians see Israelis as Europeans, and they don't care where they would go. Thing is, though, that HAMAS and Fatah want to make sure all the Jews are dead, so they're not going to let the Jews leave if they have their way. So Israel must defend themselves, or no Jew is safe. And after the Jew will come the time for other non-Muslims. The West does not understand, HAMAS does not value anything the same. HAMAS is an agent of Iran, so they have the same values as the Ayatollah. And they don't bother to hide it.

The Balfour Declaration even states a Jewish homeland in Palestine.....

No problem: just give each Palestinian Israeli equal rights, freedom of movement, an Israeli passport, freedom of profession, and one vote, in your fabulous democracy of the Middle East. Problem solved.

GOD GAVE THAT LAND TO ISRAEL

Which is worse: 2 state? Or 3 state?

People in the West don't realize how much Judeo-Christian thought influenced their thinking and they just do away with God, so now they think that this is the way all humans everywhere think. No, it's not. Islam is very different.

Proud of you Refreshing to see

Israel ought NEVER to agreed to the Two State Solution- yes for the above reasons but the Bible clearly states that the Almighty God gave the land to them and the prophet Joel that that God will "enter into judgment against all nations ...concerning His inheritance, His people Israel for they scattered my people and divided up my land". Joel 3:1-3.

The shop keeper story sounds like a more extreme version of stores in Portland having to put up Black Lives Matter signs in their windows during the riots and fire bombings to avoid being burned down or assaulted.

The Two State Solution is a nice wishful thinking proposed by people who don't even live in the land. Period.

I agree with this man, a two state solution will never work. Israel must be in control or Hamas will continue to flourish. 🙏🇨🇦💝

✡️🇮🇱✝️🇨🇦🏴󠁧󠁢󠁥󠁮󠁧󠁿💪🙏👍⚔️😘

The 1,000 Years’ War, wow, and England/France though they had it tough with a 100 Years’ War… war without end.

Perfectly said. Bravo

Well put

So Mr Fleicher what do you suggest Mr. Netanyahu do??

IDF soldiers just recovered these tractors from Gaza which were stolen by Palestinians on 10/7 from Israeli farmers.

Israel ❤ ❤ ❤ ❤ ❤ 👍 👍 👍 👍 👍 I feel very sad when I think what will be the condition of the children of Europe, America, Canada and many other countries in 50 years when the country will be filled with people from such communities . Imagine what would happen if your children had to live in your own country according to Islamic rules

Moshe Dayan gave whole West Bank to the Arabs after the 1967 Six Day War for peace and it never worked. Egypt signed the Peace Treaty with Israel for return of Sinai Peninsula but their President was assassinated and the Peace Accord survived to this day. Jordan signed the Peace Treaty with Israel to wash their hands off the Palestine problem. Syria the third player in all the Arab/Israel wars never signed any Peace Treaty with Israel and is now one of the proxies for Iran sponsored terrorism hotspots. Israel gave all the Arab Land it conquered in all the wars except for Golan Heights for Peace, 75 years on it's still fighting it's right to live on its Ancestral Home land. Wests idea of compromise does not work for Middle East mentality, the Arabs will consider pushing for more until Israel the only Democratic State will have nothing more to give. Palestine people must accept the only land available to them, Gaza to set up their Statehood. The West Bank belongs to Israel, all Palestinians must move to Gaza and live as an Arab nation. Enough of compromise, Israel gave back all the land it conquered only two countries signed peace treaty and the landless Palestinians still giving problems to Israel. Move them to Gaza and leave to run their own affairs and if they still want to fight then it's their problem because Israel will not turn another cheek but to fight back. Long live Israel!

We should get the Sinai peninsula & Gaza back, period!!

A Palestinian state would give the Palestinians recognition as a Sovereign nation which in turn would mean they could have their own Army , Airforce , and Navy , Backed by Other Arab Nations and funded by Iran . Over time this would be disastrous for Israel .

I know they aren’t the same but they sure sound similar to them invading marauders, the philistines.

The Holy Peaceful Loving Qur'an The Koran (translated by Dawood in Penguin Classics series) says, "When the sacred months are over slay the idolaters wherever you find them" (Sura 9:5). "When you meet the unbelievers in the battlefield, strike off their heads" (Sura 47:4). "Prophet, make war on the unbelievers and the hypocrites and deal rigorously with them. Hell shall be their home: an evil fate" (Sura 9:73). "The true believers fight for the cause of God, but the infidels fight for the devil. Fight then against the friends of Satan" (Sura 4:76). Who are these idolaters and unbelievers and infidels? Those who are not strict Muslims. "Muhammad is God's Apostle. Those who follow him are ruthless to the unbelievers but merciful to one another" (Sura 48:29).

Why you still talking about this name Palestine? The name is the confusion !The land is called Israel !What did a Roman emperor ,was impertinent and wrong!

The two state solution was offered 5 times

It’s classic. Give me your wife and children and we’ll have peace.

Sinai did not turn into a cancer. Sinai worked. We haven’t had an armed conflict with Egypt in decades when they used to be Israel’s worst enemy. Gaza is a great example. Sinai is a lousy one.

I lived in a house for 30 years but was forcibly evicted. Do I have the same historical claim to that house as today's Israelis historical claim to Israel? What do you think the answer would be if you ask Palestinians whether they're willing to swap their wives for peace? Also, I'm dubious about anyone that claims something has been "proven to be the all time best" - especially in a non-scientific field like politics.

I've been for the 2 state solution, but this guy has a point!

I am not saying, I disagree. I would just like to know what the alternative is? The status quo is intolerable and a one state solution would be even worse, I imagine. So what is the alternative to a two state solution? Sincere question. Does anyone have an answer?

Palestinians are protesting the land that was bordered off from them, not the Jews themselves. Jews and Arabs/Palestinians have lived in that land for thousands of years. “Archaeologic and genetic data support that both Jews and Palestinians came from the ancient Canaanites, who extensively mixed with Egyptians, Mesopotamian, and Anatolian peoples in ancient times. Thus, Palestinian-Jewish rivalry is based in cultural and religious, but not in genetic, differences.” US Institutes of Health

Sinai was NEVER Jewish land! It's always belonged to the Egyptians. Also since you gave it back to the rightful owners, the Egyptians, you've had no issues with the Egyptians. This guy is talking nonsense.

Yasser Arafat said the Oslo Accords meant nothing more to him than the Treaty of Hudaybiyyah.

There are people who will understand you and there are people who will feel qhat you are saying. I feel you cz I am able to see my existence is on the line. These people are not civil and they don't find you equal enough to let live freely.

The trouble for Israel is that, on the spiritual level, they are still in disobedience to God, and they have been suffering the consequences of that for millennia. They rejected, and still reject Jesus Christ as Messiah. Jesus cried out, "O Jerusalem, Jerusalem, you that kill the prophets, and stone them which are sent unto you, how often would I have gathered your children together, even as a hen gathers her chickens under her wings, and you would not! Behold, your house is left to you desolate." Matthew 23:37-38.

if israel refuses to recognise palestine as a state then, by default, all the people living in palestine are israeli citizens and have the legal right to vote and all of the legal rights and protecitons that israelis have however the fact that they are being refused of those rights means that israel see them as second class citizens which is kind of the definition of apartheit

Shalom❤✡️

Another RU-vid debate about Middle East in the comments ……. I’ve got the popcorn ready !

Palestine has been through history and will continue to be Palestine 🇵🇸

Dopey dave cameroon needs to watch this

Yes! Two states in jewish Israel was totally wrong from the beginning!

Right on! Keep preaching the truth.

When i went through Gaza in 82 , to go over into the than recently handed back Sinai (camp David accord ) . I have no recollection of seeing any Arabs there . All i remember is just fields & fields of sunflowers !

In the Middle East you need to think like a Middle Eastern. For reasons of survival!

Who's here after the ICJ found a prima facie case of genocide against Israel.

Soooo True !!!!❤❤❤❤❤

There was sizable minority of Pakistani immigrants in my home town, but I never thought of myself growing up with middle eastern ears. Maybe the non-Western countries are more rational on SOME points? Maybe we can actually still learn from other cultures? Maybe that is what made the West so incredible powerful and dominating in the past?

I gotta admit, he's right. And I've often thought the Palestinians really don't want a 2 state solution. If they did, there would be one already. They have had many opportunities, many of them flawed, but they have balked on all of them. If they really wanted it, it would have happened. they want the right of free return

I'll agree the two-state solution isn't workable. The problem is, can Israel; absorb the West Bank and Gaza without also absorbing the people who live there? Can there be a single democratic state with the existing populations? What are the other options? Driving the existing people off their land, or absorbing the populations, but not allowing them a vote in the new singtle state. Which do you choose?

It's about that this is an area that is sacred to three religions. Why should all of it belong to members of one religion? Why should it all belong to jews only? Because it says so in your book? To everyone his own book is right, so this is no argument. The jews could have had a big area in today's west poland, what was once germany. Instead, they came to palestine and started oppressing people who hadn't harmed them. That jews did that is a shame, they should know best what discrimination means

Scary what can happen in a head of a relatively smart person.

Absolutely....Rosa Larsen

America 🇺🇸 has 50 states (that's more than Arab states). Give them Wyoming.

Absolutely! Jews must NOT give up their rightful ownership of Judea and Samaria.

2 srate was wrong knew this even as a kid!!! Thankful people know it better now