Тёмный

Deception in Animal Documentaries 

ABC News
Подписаться 18 млн
Просмотров 37 тыс.
50% 1

An industry whistleblower tells of artificial caves and trained animal stand-ins.

Опубликовано:

 

6 окт 2024

Поделиться:

Ссылка:

Скачать:

Готовим ссылку...

Добавить в:

Мой плейлист
Посмотреть позже
Комментарии : 72   
@pforce9
@pforce9 4 года назад
Everyone is talking about whales and wolves and no one is mentioning the Lemmings that were tossed off the cliffs to drown in the ocean.
@pforce9
@pforce9 4 года назад
@Natturner And probably thrown off cliffs too.
@revatherealestateagentandr8964
@revatherealestateagentandr8964 4 года назад
Trying to normalize mass suicide with a lie about the animal kingdom.
@SamirNaganaworkhere
@SamirNaganaworkhere 2 года назад
Reminded me of Madagascar where they pushed the penguins off the ice cliff
@bigmoneyc9395
@bigmoneyc9395 4 года назад
“How did they know the names?” “We made them up.”....Duh! 🤣
@Peleski
@Peleski 3 года назад
The big reveal. Ace reportage
@cherrytoasterpastry
@cherrytoasterpastry 11 лет назад
David Attenborough has stated they've used captive animals in the documentaries he's done. A notable example is in the film the Frozen Planet, where the entire polar bear cub birth scene is shot in a zoo using fake snow.
@Urhoboman5
@Urhoboman5 11 лет назад
Lol. "Reality TV" is older than we think it is.
@boldcounsel9406
@boldcounsel9406 3 года назад
As long as it's not fictitious on the educational aspect.... I just watched a docu that said a gator balanced a stick on its nose to lure a bird. A few edited clips, and they show a gator eating a bird. "This has never been filmed before" says the narrator. And I agree.
@Edw-Sc9wt
@Edw-Sc9wt 2 года назад
I watched that documentary too. It was about mangroves, right? I don't know if they thrown the bird on purpose.
@Kiezkollege
@Kiezkollege 4 года назад
I heard of these practices before and they ruined documentaries for me. But I'm still glad I know about this.
@jdu98a
@jdu98a 12 лет назад
They made up the names of the whales?!?!! WHAT?!??!??! You mean they didn't even try to learn the whale's real names? The illusion has been shattered!
@Flashlax19
@Flashlax19 12 лет назад
doesn't make sense to praise something that isn't real.
@Rainkit
@Rainkit 11 лет назад
It's even more heartbreaking when you know that the wolves are from a game farm...
@emiliobello2538
@emiliobello2538 2 года назад
The Penguins Of Madagascar made fun of this when Werner Herzog asks his crew to give the baby penguins a shove. And in White Wilderness
@Illbegoodinthefuture
@Illbegoodinthefuture 5 лет назад
No wild Eminems have been hurt during the filming...:D
@BrothaJeff
@BrothaJeff 5 лет назад
I wonder if they do similar things with the planet earth series and blue planet series.
@jheevanesh
@jheevanesh 3 года назад
Somewhat like this but more ethical
@BrothaJeff
@BrothaJeff 3 года назад
@@jheevanesh yeah.. I found out the Netflix show our planet lied about the walrus’ falling off the cliffs. It was because of polar bears and not because of climate change melting all the ice...
@Orcinus-s4z
@Orcinus-s4z Год назад
​@@BrothaJeff and frozen planet polar bear is from a zoo
@gmg9010
@gmg9010 4 года назад
I remember watching this and being heartbroken and wondering if Steve Irwin did this as well
@Rainkit
@Rainkit 11 лет назад
I have to say, sometimes it's painfully obvious they're captive.
@jvslyke4025
@jvslyke4025 3 года назад
shoutout to when disney threw a bunch of lemmings off a cliff to make a film about an animal behavior that doesnt exist.
@FarradMuseumofTruth
@FarradMuseumofTruth 12 лет назад
That's actually very sad.... damn :/
@dongeonmaster8547
@dongeonmaster8547 2 года назад
So, less documentary and more docudrama. A common trope using a narrative about a specific animal or group of animals to inspire more compassion for the whole species. News about people often employees the same tactics. Constructing narratives about individuals in a larger struggle so viewers might identify with those individuals and not disconnect due to the deluge of information and statistics in the big picture. Perhaps some disclaimers for recreations should be used. Maybe even a prologue to explain that real nature shots have been mixed with manufactured shots to tell a story and why.
@LetheMaghia
@LetheMaghia 3 года назад
Heck that hurling of the cliff. I now will keep doubts open in every animal documentary. This brings sense now too for my questions when I was young for example of a snake filmed as it moves, the camera was on its body. As long as it's in the credits, however, at least it can help for a better cause when people have their hearts captured by the acting animals also as stated in the end, without having to disrupt actual wild animals.
@robertwhitten265
@robertwhitten265 3 года назад
"How do you know their names? We made them up" Really? I thought you asked the whales?
@Peleski
@Peleski 3 года назад
"We put M&Ms in the animal". Can you feed chocolate to wolves? Aren't they the same as dogs, which are poisoned by chocolate?
@LetheMaghia
@LetheMaghia 3 года назад
Maybe they were referring to bears only with the chocolates? Since it would take high doses for it to be toxic. Trainers would probably be well-aware not to kill the animals they spent a lot on. But still pretty cruel to think of
@robertmotion
@robertmotion Год назад
watching a nature show today in 2023, and i had the same question 🤔 always wondered...and now i know why. still a nature fan for life tho. /bklyn👑
@yeshazion4098
@yeshazion4098 3 года назад
What's REALLY SAD IS IF AND WHEN someone does find anything new..we won't believe them.!!!
@karmarinnature
@karmarinnature 12 лет назад
i actually kind of agree with what the guy is saying, yes the whole thing was fake, but the animals weren't, so does it matter if theyr are captive actors or wild beats? they are still beautiful creatures and we are fortunate to be able to witness they're fantastic and funny behavior- if we interfere with them in the wild too much it could have disastrous consequences for the animals themselves not to mention other humans they come into contact with are potentially in harms way- sad but true...
@vonlee485
@vonlee485 2 года назад
and the lemmings they threw off the cliff?
@GianMaaark00
@GianMaaark00 4 года назад
Even this interview is fake.
@istinapravda7956
@istinapravda7956 3 года назад
good call
@trentfoyer8125
@trentfoyer8125 11 лет назад
this is totally not about animals
@SC0891
@SC0891 5 лет назад
OMG...are you saying...movies aren’t real??? I’m shocked. What’s next? Politicians lying?!! Oh, the unexpected horror.
@Alteori
@Alteori Год назад
1:58 Isn't chocolate bad for canines?
@Orcinus-s4z
@Orcinus-s4z Год назад
Yes
@MegaRicheyRich
@MegaRicheyRich 13 лет назад
i, of course, could see the re-enactments, and sets. what's funny is a show from the news which hasn't done a good job faking it for years
@slugfly
@slugfly 11 лет назад
Thank you for pointing that out. Apparently I can't thumb-up a comment so a reply-kudos will have to do. :P
@karmarinnature
@karmarinnature 12 лет назад
by the way, he doesn't mean all nature documentaries- he mean's feature lengths disney animal films. obviously david attenborough wouldn't pull this crap.
@saulgoodman9278
@saulgoodman9278 4 года назад
LOL
@germanicusfink2350
@germanicusfink2350 5 лет назад
"Non-Fiction" "Documentaries"
@eternalnut
@eternalnut 2 года назад
And as White Wilderness called it's self, "True-Life"
@okuya7783
@okuya7783 4 года назад
Pls dont be heartbreaking judt listen to the ending and understand why they try to do it besides money. Do u really want random people fliming u at ur everyday life? Or actors
@thekimward
@thekimward 10 лет назад
Wait... They made the names up too!
@phonotical
@phonotical 3 года назад
So he faked it all and then told on himself, nobody else
@DrSolonHUN
@DrSolonHUN 3 года назад
4:39 Rage Against the Machine fan spotted
@franzhaas5597
@franzhaas5597 4 года назад
THE CAKE IS A LIE.
@severketorskeleton3759
@severketorskeleton3759 5 лет назад
I hate and love you at the same time
@shanedivix9306
@shanedivix9306 2 года назад
The wolves are cgi and this guy is lying about it Edit: all animals are cgi
@Trouble_Bubble36
@Trouble_Bubble36 Год назад
Wow you are so stupid
@shanedivix9306
@shanedivix9306 Год назад
@@Trouble_Bubble36 amazing, well thought out and articulate reply. Thanks
@imagoodemployee
@imagoodemployee 13 лет назад
This knowledge does not bother me at all. I don't feel cheated or fooled that these action shots weren't candid. I thought it was common sense...
@jewishparasite100
@jewishparasite100 5 лет назад
That's good. You're probably the useful type who eats all the fake shit you're given. Open wide.
@2022irons
@2022irons 3 года назад
Propaganda
@dutchceezweh8069
@dutchceezweh8069 2 года назад
Yah neh!Whyt Pepo...
@hhhhh-kj8dw
@hhhhh-kj8dw 3 года назад
5:16
@Miguel_Mats
@Miguel_Mats 7 лет назад
LOLL
@andrewkesson
@andrewkesson 11 лет назад
when you see a movie,,,,,did you know they are just acting,,,,captain jack sparrow is not real! the part is played by a guy called Johny dep....whooooo caaaares!
@Rikon01
@Rikon01 5 лет назад
andrewkesson thanks for the info :)
@jewishparasite100
@jewishparasite100 5 лет назад
+andrewkesson What an idiotic comparison lol
Далее
True Facts: Deception in the Rainforest
10:29
Просмотров 3,7 млн
БЫСТРАЯ сборка ПК - от А до Я!
00:22
Nature Planet | Narrated by Adam Sandler
5:22
Просмотров 1,8 млн
If Ordinary People Filmed Nature Documentaries
4:23
Просмотров 1,1 млн
Sir David Attenborough being iconic for 25 minutes
25:45
The Life of Animal Hoarders
6:52
Просмотров 469 тыс.
Orphaned Animal Cuteness Overload
9:10
Просмотров 91 тыс.
How Animals Survive the Winter (Wildlife Documentary)
52:14