Defeat: New VS Old | IMPOSTOR V4 

If you look at both of them closely,you can how much this mod has changed within less than 1 year of work

I can see the differences between the two, the new version sounds like it's an actual fight for survival

man i remember thinking the v3 version of defeat was an absolute banger. hearing this comparison makes it sound so underwhelming now

Differences: Sprites: Black, V3 (and V4, technically) - Black holds his knife backward (the blade faces away from BF, not towards him), and he carries a regular microphone. Also, his knife is less bloody, and his visor is the typical one you'd see on every other crewmate. Black, V4 - His visor is now rectangular, and he now carries a red mic. In his down pose, you can see Gray's dead father. BF, V3 (and V4, I guess) - just regular boyfriend, nothing to see here BF, V4 - Starts off cautious (keeping at least one eye open in every pose), and then becomes scared when the drop hits. He's practically screaming in all of his poses by this point. Visuals: V3 (and V4, because of the flashback) - The Among Us defeat screen. Nothing too special. V4 - Starts off with the Among Us defeat screen, and when the drop hits, piles of dead bodies (mostly skeletons) appear (you can also see BF's dead body on the right side of the stage among the skeletons). The song itself: V3 - For a song made in 1 hour (apparently), it's not bad. Black's vocals are just the dead body pizzicato, but bitcrushed slightly. V4 - A huge revamp. Black now sounds a lot more distinct from the other opponents you face throughout Story Mode. Mechanics: V3 - One miss, and it's over. Instantly. V4 - Pick how many times you can miss before you die, with 5 maximum (in the V4 trailer, it said 8 maximum). Miscellaneous: V4 - Has a callback to V3 at around 1:28. Although they aren't shown here, I'm putting in the death screens anyway: V3 - Black stares at the screen briefly before stabbing BF in the head. There's also a small chance for *something else* to happen. Let's just say it hurts. *_A lot._* V4 - Black does the same thing but throws his mic on the ground and swings his knife at BF instead, also aiming for the head.

In terms of quality it has had a tremendous glow up but in terms of difficulty it got a bit downgraded. Though honestly it was a very needed change as it makes it actually enjoyable.

the old one sounds like its under water

Old vocals are the same as everyone else

New version sounds like a UTAU cover due to black’s vocals or bf’s at the beginning (or not), meanwhile the old/og sounds weird like as you’re fighting someone in a black void while you’re in first person.

I love how v4 goes back to v3

This really shows the amount of work they had done for this mod. 2 years of going crazy

When the audio changes I get tonal whiplash which is kinda funny

Even the v3 song is more nostalgic, the new one is very Better, but i like the old black design, it's kinda more like the original game, maybe, make a remake of the old design would be good

Its crazy how 2 years ago Old Defeat was my favourite song, now looking back at it it sounds weird.

I love how this mod brought both among us and fnf back from the dead.

Damn this song got the best glow up out of all of them

I mean the remake version of Defeat kinda gave me some that of Parasite vibe

Wait why is my v4 impostor chart way harder than the v4 used here

hearing the old black vocals are just too nostalgic

i love the two just turn into old black then switch back to v4 black before the songs ends

The only thing i Know is That this part 1:04 Is so nostalgic :')

I like the old one Because Of Black's Vibe Movement

Thé only thing i prefer in V4 Is the background And the art but for the rest i prefer the V3

I like how in v4 black doesn't just snap back to place but instead moves back to place

V4 BF:Oh no its Black. V3 BF: WHO CARES LETS RAAAP

New instrumental with old vocals!!!

Weird opinion, Old version sounds better for vocal and is also better for charting. But i will give brownie points to the newer version for visuals. But then again thats just my opinion PS: 1:29-1:49 almost made me shed a tear.

Just my opinion, but I think that V4 and V3 had its differences that made it a little better from the other, but v4 is better in the end.

Audio: V3 better Background: V4 better V3 rating: 8/10 V4 rating 10/10

In V3, Dont Miss Or DIE, In V4 You Pick Misses To DIE.

I think V3’s imposter is better than V4’s imposter (I just don’t like black imposter’s down pose, it just didn’t feel necessary in my opinion)

Lit!

YAAAA this vid is cool

Remember when people used to say that blacks smooth as heck

Defeat was my favourite song in v3 and I still is in v4

YALL OUT IT ON 0.75X IT SOUNDS SO GOOD AND ALSO PUT IN 2X THE BACK ROUND SOUND IS A BIT I DIFFERENT AND ALSO THE SONG IS AN INSTANT VIBE

If you put it at speed 0.75 it looks more epic

I like v3 more because black sprites look like he is more cold, with no feelings

I like the old one. New black's design sucks. And I don't like how he sounds.

Is it just me that kinda likes the first one more? V3 just sounds better in my opinion. However it does feel a little empty

compared with v4, v3 sounds like an echo

Wow

Good

V3 in his time was a full banger, but hearing V4 and then suddenly changes to V3 makes it sound a bit trash

V4 👍

I hate the square glass thing on the new one

i feel nostagic hearing v3

Well new blacks' sprites look atleast faster and not slow like the old ones

I like de old song I don't say I don't like de new de new it's good but I like more de V3

he now have rectangle visor and changes yay (sarcastic way)

New one is not challenging at all. Like, Old one is so much better in terms of difficulty. I wish they keep the V3 stairs 😔

Lm really miss it

New follower #Serkoid Next: Crossed Out but The Chosen One, The Second Coming and The Dark Lord

1:28 old vs old?

Question why is their visor are square in the new sprite

im sorry but how do people genuinely think the old one was better it’s just… guitar and chiptune

V3 and v4

I think v4 is better but there is one issue with blacks sprites; they look purple

Why v4 turns to v3 when it’s on 1:47?

Funny cartoon new vs old tom basement

V4

Me like the old versi

And pghlego said it was the same charting

V5 NOWWW OR ELSE

They should have kept old style but new music

V4. Vs. V3. Black. Impostop. Video. ... more.

Hello

I prefer the v3 more but it wouldn't work in the v4 because it's better with the mystery it had of just being a random impostor.

SUS

ee

Designs are about the same only difference is v4 knife has blood and other doesn’t

I hate the new Defeat Im sticking with the old one

I personally prefer the old defeat over the new defeat it has to come down to the voice of Black Imposter in v4, it's voice in v4 is so high pitched which makes it very disorienting and headache inducing and overpowers the instrumentals at times.

ff

V5 is better

Bro, v3 its so much better than v4

First

V4 better.

Og better

old is better