Тёмный
No video :(

"Dehumanization of Undocumented Immigrants" | Brandon Moran | TEDxStLawrenceU 

TEDx Talks
Подписаться 41 млн
Просмотров 15 тыс.
50% 1

Since "Illegals" and "Aliens" are flooding our country, it is expected that our government will construct a border wall for security. However, these undocumented migrants are joining our economy and schools across the country. Why do we continue to hear about the potential instability and danger in accepting undocumented immigrants into our country? Brandon Moran, a first generation college student at St. Lawrence University, explains the process of dehumanizing undocumented immigrants through analyzing 4 American policies.
Brandon Moran is a senior at St. Lawrence University with a Government major, and a Chinese minor. He is a McNair and Presidential Diversity Scholar, and a member of the Pi Sigma Alpha National Political Science Honor's society. He has studied a semester abroad in Shanghai, China at East China Normal University ('17) and has performed several human rights and social justice poetry recitations. He enjoys running for the Cross Country and Track Teams, playing chess for the Chess Club and writing for the Hill News.
After graduation, he plans to pursue a career in foreign service. In light of recent immigration developments, he has vocalized the urgency in supporting undocumented immigrants in a variety of platforms. In his talk, Dehumanization of Undocumented Immigrants, he highlights policies which have perpetuated an anti-immigrant rhetoric from 1986-2010. His goal is to motivate citizens to challenge the current discourse and policies which dehumanize undocumented immigrants. Brandon Moran is a senior at St. Lawrence University with a Government major, and a Chinese minor. He is a McNair and Presidential Diversity Scholar, and a member of the Pi Sigma Alpha National Political Science Honor's society. He has studied a semester abroad in Shanghai, China at East China Normal University ('17) and has performed several human rights and social justice poetry recitations. He enjoys running for the Cross Country and Track Teams, playing chess for the Chess Club and writing for the Hill News. This talk was given at a TEDx event using the TED conference format but independently organized by a local community. Learn more at www.ted.com/tedx

Опубликовано:

 

22 авг 2024

Поделиться:

Ссылка:

Скачать:

Готовим ссылку...

Добавить в:

Мой плейлист
Посмотреть позже
Комментарии : 174   
@rabsaque
@rabsaque 3 года назад
To all the pople telling don't come here ilegally let me explain, do you. think people who come to United states illegally would not do it teh rigth way if they could? many are uneducated they don't know how to do it propperly, they don't have the resources, migrating legally to america can get up to 60k only on lawyer fees, what person in an freaking 3rd world country destroyed by war or Socialism can pay that? can you tell me how much your ancestors comming from Europe paid to gain their citizenship? would you tell an Polish WWII innmigrant "well just stay on your country and figth that nazy guys you know fix your country" would you? im a migrant i left my country as a last resort it was that or literally dying i fougth for my country we protests om the streest and were slaughter like we were nothing, i saw a 17 years old kid protesting alongside me being killed by a soldier of Venezuelan dictatorship and we achieved nothing no one would help us that day i took the most painful decision of my life, i have to leave, leave or die either of starvation or being shot by a criminal or by the dictator's forces, i hope from the bottom of my heart none of you have to experience that ever please have some emphaty every innmigrant that leaves their family do it cause they have no other option than lave or die leaving your loved ones is so painful you have no idea.
@vincetagliano9910
@vincetagliano9910 3 года назад
Sovereign nations (including Mexico, Honduras and Guatemala) are under NO OBLIGATION to admit foreign nationals.
@remysimoneaux709
@remysimoneaux709 2 года назад
U have a legit claim for asylum, everyone knows what’s going on in Venezuela right now, but most people are not coming here with life or death circumstances but economic reasons and if we let people in because the US pays more, then the whole world would be moving here and that would ruin us. Surely you can understand that we can’t absorb the amount of people that are sneaking in by the multi-millions right now. The next President will be under tremendous pressure from the people to end the insanity the current administration is allowing and begin working on finishing the wall and in all likelihood they will give Ice Billions of dollars in resources to hire enough agents to begin deporting the millions of people who were allowed in illegally.
@lt4376
@lt4376 Год назад
The reason European whites were admitted with probably less cost, was because the intellectual worth / racial & cultural similarities. That’s the truth.
@lt4376
@lt4376 Год назад
The reason European whites were admitted was probably because they cost less, and were intellectual more compatible / racial & cultural similarities. That’s the truth.
@avradio0b
@avradio0b 4 месяца назад
@@vincetagliano9910I suppose it's a difference of values on whether or not we owe our fellow humans a duty of care. If you see a stranger having a heart attack, are you really under any obligation to call 911 or perform CPR? Some people care about other humans and some don't.
@amud2546
@amud2546 2 года назад
Indian legal immigrant here. There’s a reason a lot of undocumented immigrants here. The legal immigration is broken system. Does it makes sense to wait 90-100 years for a green card?
@noskpain2792
@noskpain2792 Год назад
Thank you for doing it the right way. Legal immigrants success is down played because of law breakers.
@lt4376
@lt4376 Год назад
What if most Americans don’t want there to be a more efficient Legal Immigration System? Do you realize if whites flooded your home country then you’d probably not feel comfortable with that. Does that mean anything to you?
@margaretnorvell9555
@margaretnorvell9555 Год назад
The US takes in more immigrants, legal and illegal, than any other country in the world. Our immigration system is not broken. The Sending countries are broken and dysfunctional. The US should not be a safety valve for their dysfunction.
@2557carla
@2557carla Год назад
That's why we need Merit Base Immigration System is the most Comprehensive Immigration Reform if US follow that system.
@joecole7122
@joecole7122 8 месяцев назад
You realize that we can't take everyone who wants to come here. We don't have the space.
@einveruarts8933
@einveruarts8933 3 года назад
The comments do not pass the vibe check.
@vincetagliano9910
@vincetagliano9910 3 года назад
Nor do illegals.
@katherinehernandez90
@katherinehernandez90 2 года назад
Legit, just a lot of ignorance
@danielkim7841
@danielkim7841 2 года назад
Many many Americans upset with the illegal immigration problem. It is a huge political issue
@lt4376
@lt4376 Год назад
@@danielkim7841 Wont be long before the American People identify and remove all the amnesty-receivers, and anchor-babies/adults, refugees, asylum seekers, and of course illegally occupiers.
@danielkim7841
@danielkim7841 Год назад
@@lt4376 I hope so. People keep saying we are a nation of immigrants to say illegal immigrants should stay. Correction, we are a nation of LEGAL immigrants, people who came from Europe and had to pass a quarantine in Ellis Island before they came in. It's not right how open the southern border is!
@diamondcharmpr3123
@diamondcharmpr3123 Год назад
Immigrants often come to the United States out of necessity, fleeing poverty, violence, or persecution in their home countries. They may not have the privilege of waiting for legal entrance and may enter illegally. Wanting a better life is not a crime, and it's important to recognize the challenges faced by immigrants and work towards creating a more inclusive and welcoming society for all.
@joecole7122
@joecole7122 8 месяцев назад
So if a 100 million poor people in India want to migrate to the USA, we should just open our doors.
@gustavo042
@gustavo042 2 месяца назад
Leave my country
@Yeorl
@Yeorl 4 года назад
Trojan Horse the video
@lpnjan7246
@lpnjan7246 Год назад
There are too many trump republicans in this comment section.
4 года назад
You spelled illegal wrong and they can be as human or non human as they like as long as they do it in their own country.
@eles5074
@eles5074 10 месяцев назад
Thanks for doing this!! People will never understand why people migrate and are willing to come here undocumented. We are not our legal status, and people who have never been in those marginalized situations should not be saying something. Ilegales y que????
@higherpower7176
@higherpower7176 7 месяцев назад
Yeah we should, as Americans we owe nobody anything
@Dv087
@Dv087 2 года назад
There is no justification. If everyone leaves the country because they're unhappy, how is "their" country supposed to improve.
@cintheone
@cintheone Год назад
Definitely not by having the US systematically destabilize their economies.
@quabledistocficklepo3597
@quabledistocficklepo3597 2 года назад
Why aren't the parents of illegal immigrant children prosecuted for child endangerment/child abuse?
@haydensmith3778
@haydensmith3778 2 года назад
lmao because it's a better chance than being killed in their native country
@NIcholasparker88
@NIcholasparker88 2 года назад
@@haydensmith3778 They should defend themselves. Shooting invaders is a constitutional right
@NerdyCatCoffeeee
@NerdyCatCoffeeee 2 года назад
I don't get why he calls them "illegal" and not just illegal, cuz technically they were in US illegally. If they were legal and they were discriminated against based on their race or something else and just called Illegal despite being legal. I'd get the "illegal" thing. But since they were illegal, I don't see why he tries make it look like they weren't. Ok. he does have a point that illegal-immigrant labor benefits economy as a cheap labor part. Immigration should always be legal. Idk, but this guy didn't convince me that illegal immigrants should have just as much as legal immigrants, cuz what's the point then? I'm not saying that I'd beat up or discriminate against an illegal immigrant or anything, but they shouldn't be able to thrive in the country on the same level as legal immigrants do. Sure, refugees are an exception cuz they have no where to go, but they are a separate case. I'm talking about people who chose to get to US despite not being invited via green card. Everyone knows that one guy who will force his way into a party or a sleepover even when he's not invited, but you're too polite to tell him to go f himself? Yeah, illegal immigrants are that guy. Except US has the balls to actually throw him away. Sure, ok, immigrants come with a benefit of not knowing the language and being cheap labor, especially illegal ones, but do we really want uninvited people to stay? I mean, let's debate. I might be wrong on this but i don't see it yet. let's discuss: Illegal immigrants good or bad and how?
@RRP2
@RRP2 Год назад
,,not knowing the language,, got me 😂 laughing
@margaretnorvell9555
@margaretnorvell9555 Год назад
They have ruined their own countries. Their criminal culture will ruin ours
@GustavoMoradel
@GustavoMoradel Год назад
I wonder if you would use the same argument for the Europeans that came here. Were they legal? Your argument would only make sense if you were Native American. If you’re not, you ate exactly what you are critiquing.
@LetsGoBrandonFJB-TRUMP2024
@LetsGoBrandonFJB-TRUMP2024 4 месяца назад
Dehumanized? No, an illegal allien who's residing within a country criminally? Yes
@xn0gaming
@xn0gaming 3 года назад
Whenever someone makes the quotation gesture, I stop listening. It communicates a disingenious character and mind.
@remysimoneaux709
@remysimoneaux709 2 года назад
So true, I never realized that before.
@OnePartySystem
@OnePartySystem 2 месяца назад
Stop trying to humanize the illegal criminal trespassers
@ibraheemghani7321
@ibraheemghani7321 Год назад
I don't agree with dehumanizing rhetoric, but America, like any sovereign nation, is a nation of laws and borders and has a right to protect, defend, secure its own borders and enforce immigration laws. It's a crime to cross the border illegally, that's a fact under U.S. immigration law. Asylum is legal at any port of entry, but crossing illegally is still a crime (and for good reasons, from a national security perspective). If you are in the country illegally (with the exception of DACA/Dreamers), you should be prosecuted in some form because it's only fair to those who followed the law and immigrated legally. That's just common sense. Safety and security. Too many liberals lose perspective on immigration and go too far to the left to the point where they don't want laws to get properly enforced. Sorry, but it's the honest truth. I'm left-leaning, by the way, but I'm also a common sense individual who is willing to call people on my side of the political spectrum out. I'm pro-immigration, and want diversity and inclusion. What America needs is legal immigration, not illegal immigration.
@carterhall2653
@carterhall2653 4 года назад
Just some more activist bs by TED .
@basemalt
@basemalt 3 года назад
you're really threatened by activism? embarrassing.
@Feanor1169
@Feanor1169 3 года назад
@@basemalt Don't enter a country illegally. Every single immigration law must be obeyed or else they can leave. No one has a right to enter another country without permission.
@basemalt
@basemalt 3 года назад
@@Feanor1169 what does that have to do with my comment? Did you even watch the video?
@noskpain2792
@noskpain2792 Год назад
He came in legally with asylum and now he spews his rhetoric. A bad case of cognitive dissonance.
@lt4376
@lt4376 Год назад
Wont be long before the American People identify and remove all the amnesty-receivers, and anchor-babies/adults, refugees, asylum seekers, and of course illegally occupiers.
@margaretnorvell9555
@margaretnorvell9555 Год назад
Why do all these POC come here to live among such oppressive White people. Sick of the whining. They should not be here.
@MrQualifie
@MrQualifie 2 года назад
Immigration must be legal.❗
@margaretnorvell9555
@margaretnorvell9555 Год назад
But troops on the US border.
@leew7863
@leew7863 4 года назад
The Progressive Socialist Educators have done an excellent job in training this young man as an articulate poster boy for their cause. He has all the right emphasis, air-quotes for buzz-words, and key emotional terms to derail sound thinking. AOC must be proud of him.
@basemalt
@basemalt 3 года назад
you talk so much about buzz words yet that's all your comment literally is. what does any of this have to do with socialism or AOC lmao. you actually sound out of touch.
@JK_JK_JK
@JK_JK_JK 2 года назад
@@basemalt What is an "undocumented immigrant"? This term does not appear in any US law. Does this refer to the legally correct term "unlawfully present alien"?
@cintheone
@cintheone Год назад
@@JK_JK_JK Yes especially if they're from Mars which we haven't reached yet and we have yet to conquer.
@JK_JK_JK
@JK_JK_JK Год назад
@@cintheone Alien. Any person not a citizen or national of the United States as the term “alien” is defined in section 101(a)(3) of the Immigration and Nationality Act (8 U.S.C. 1101(a)(3)).
@margaretnorvell9555
@margaretnorvell9555 Год назад
He sounds like an ACLU graduate. If his El Salvadorian family needed to flee the war, why didn't they flee to Mexico or another Spanish speaking country. They came here for US taxpayer benefits.
@sams5377
@sams5377 4 года назад
He said his family reached the border, pleaded their case and were given amnesty. He next said "these illegal immigrants" which he signals with quotes. That is BS, HIS FAMILY WERE LEGAL IMMIGRANTS.
@danielkim7841
@danielkim7841 2 года назад
I'm shocked TED would have a speaker who is advocating for illegal immigration. So many Americans are upset with the huge number of illegals trying to come in through the Texas border, etc. It really isn't cool to have speakers try to say illegal immigration isn't a problem when so many people are upset by it
@lt4376
@lt4376 Год назад
Wont be long before the American People identify and remove all the amnesty-receivers, and anchor-babies/adults, refugees, asylum seekers, and of course illegally occupiers.
@margaretnorvell9555
@margaretnorvell9555 Год назад
Ted is liberal. Liberals love criminals. They should follow this segment with a speaker from the Angel family.
@JJLL195
@JJLL195 3 года назад
Well, if you broke the law... I don’t know how we’re going to be so nice to you.
@karinaparedes7933
@karinaparedes7933 3 года назад
What law ?
@nathangoodwin8733
@nathangoodwin8733 3 года назад
@@karinaparedes7933 passing into the US undocumented.
@angelabolin1730
@angelabolin1730 3 года назад
Illegal border crossing has been a crime since 1929. In 1965 it became a misdemeanor now; they want that law repealed because it won't carry a penalty of deportation, furthering the left anarchy agenda rules doesn't apply to lawbreaker illegal immigrants. 8, Section 1325 of the U.S. Code (U.S.C.) Avoiding an immigration officer not presenting you're self at the border would be the reason for charges. As far as separation, you did that by not going to the port of entry having zero proof, the child is related to you, and you are not a Smuggler. If you don't want to be separated from your kids, go to the Port of Entry don't illegally enter the country. Have any documentation the child belongs to you. We don't let parents out a hospital with just anyone kid either there verified.
@hiphipjorge5755
@hiphipjorge5755 Год назад
Technically yes people should be deported based on legal proceedings. That's not up for debate. But don't pretend that you're some sort of lover of the law and you're just trying to enforce it as a patriotic citizen. We know damn well you don't care that much about the law. Almost every damn person who screamed "no masks" or supported the assault on our Capitol also claims that we need to obey the law no matter what. Pure hypocrisy.
@MrSquinn84
@MrSquinn84 Год назад
People said the same thing when slaves ran away.
@Calikid331
@Calikid331 5 лет назад
Imagine if they put as much effort into fixing their own countries as they did reaching the United States. The sense of entitlement is astounding. If someone doesn't want to enter the US properly, they are illegal. End of story.
@raulastor3891
@raulastor3891 5 лет назад
Some of these countries and nations that these illegals and aliens come from are that there governments are not as strong the USA and are already struggling enough and some of these immigrants are just looking for salvation and hope for a better life but apparently if your not white you have got to go
@gncma
@gncma 5 лет назад
Imagine if Americans behave humanely and saw the human ( and economic ) potential of these human beings who migrate in dire circumstances to find work and build a better life. Imagine for an instance that reason and facts ruled over fear and lies. Imagine that those Americans struggleling to find farm workers to work on their farms were able to find a steady workforce of greatful hungry hard working migrant workers Just imagine
@robertmasina4610
@robertmasina4610 5 лет назад
I'm assuming over 90 percent of their population is powerless to fix their countries. The barrier they face is the elites that run that government which is known to be notoriously corrupt.
@1236612
@1236612 4 года назад
Gladys Palacio, I would say that after a blanket amnesty in 1986, followed by five limited amnesties; this, coupled with the fact that the USA takes in far more immigrants legally than any other nation, really voids your argument.
@sams5377
@sams5377 4 года назад
@@gncma Imagine if migrants did it legally, like his family did. They came to the border, pleaded their case and were given amnesty. I don't have to imagine "if Americans behave humanely and saw the human... reason and facts", because that is what happen. THEY WERE GIVEN AMNESTY. He called themselves illegal immigrants which is a lie.
@Seanyz
@Seanyz Год назад
Every human being with a heart understands a better life, but this dude, one day he’ll look back and realize he was used to do this speech
@dgblac0
@dgblac0 10 месяцев назад
His solution to the illegal immigration problem is to make life easier for illegal immigrants.
@srsfuf9633
@srsfuf9633 5 лет назад
Görüntüleme yok haha. Ayıp olmasın diye girdim. Çok iyi ehuehwuw
@briankelly8614
@briankelly8614 4 года назад
Also if they really loved their family they wouldn’t risk being separated
@mariaj6807
@mariaj6807 3 года назад
that's irrelevant because there shouldn't even be separation.
@briankelly8614
@briankelly8614 3 года назад
@@mariaj6807 elaborate please
@mariaj6807
@mariaj6807 3 года назад
@@briankelly8614 i mean that families should not be separated at the border for any reason whatsoever.
@xn0gaming
@xn0gaming 3 года назад
Well 3rd worlders never care about their children, their wives just pop out another one. (or three). Its a resource for them, not much else.
@nathangoodwin8733
@nathangoodwin8733 3 года назад
@@xn0gaming yea, if your in a 3rd world country suffering, why have 3 children.
@JK_JK_JK
@JK_JK_JK 2 года назад
What is an "undocumented immigrant"? This term does not appear in any US law. Does this refer to the legally correct term "unlawfully present alien"?
@JK_JK_JK
@JK_JK_JK 2 года назад
@Les Toussaint Where is this term found in US law?
@Makoonga
@Makoonga 2 месяца назад
Cry me a river.
@jimmyvalhalla1939
@jimmyvalhalla1939 2 года назад
Let’s use historic precedent as our guide. We can go back to medieval Europe and earlier for reference, but it’s easier to use more modern examples. In June 1941, Germany invaded the Soviet Union. The Soviet’s didn’t grant the Germans amnesty or bus them throughout the Soviet Union. They killed them. Recently Russia invaded the Ukraine. Ukraine also balked at free health care and welfare benefits for its invaders, they also have actively been killing them. If your you’re confused about how the United States should handle it’s invasion, look to history and let it be your guide.
@margaretnorvell9555
@margaretnorvell9555 Год назад
We would love to. Seriously
@wayneduvall7423
@wayneduvall7423 2 года назад
Get them ALL OUT NOW
@briankelly8614
@briankelly8614 4 года назад
They arent looking for safer life’s, they are looking for a life where they don’t pay taxes and a life with food stamps
@basemalt
@basemalt 3 года назад
did you even hear what he said about the violence and the gangs my dude
@nycbankers1427
@nycbankers1427 2 года назад
@@basemalt don’t even argue with this clowns they all watch Fox News
@CrowTR0bot
@CrowTR0bot 2 года назад
Ah yes, they came here to weasel out of paying taxes and get on government assistance, and are so good at it that they pay $12 billion in taxes and get no benefits from it whatsoever.
@remysimoneaux709
@remysimoneaux709 2 года назад
How many is enough? 10 million a year? That’s what they say will be coming here in 2022.
@margaretnorvell9555
@margaretnorvell9555 Год назад
@@nycbankers1427 Do you know how many Spanish- speaking countries are between EL Salvador and the US. Countries that are stable, have The same heritage and the same language. His family came here to reap the benefits paid for by US taxpayers. Take the invaders under your wing, my Dude.
@leegarforth4189
@leegarforth4189 Год назад
So this guy thinks there’s no negative aspects to illegal immigration?
@MiniBagel
@MiniBagel 5 лет назад
This is some powerful stuff. Great job with the talk!
@edgespace3777
@edgespace3777 2 года назад
Trump 2024!
@allenharris5391
@allenharris5391 2 года назад
lmao sure
@RRP2
@RRP2 Год назад
Biden 2024
@robertmasina4610
@robertmasina4610 5 лет назад
Dehumanization? Nobody is being tortured on US soil.
@CrowTR0bot
@CrowTR0bot 2 года назад
We literally have reports of doctors in ICE camps forcibly sterilizing immigrant women, not to mention thousands of accounts of police brutality. And it's all justified with Trump loudly proclaiming Mexicans are rapists.
@RRP2
@RRP2 Год назад
Sounds about right
Далее
КТО ЛЮБИТ ГРИБЫ?? #shorts
00:24
Просмотров 1,1 млн
What If You Were An Immigrant? | Ben Huh | TEDxPortland
16:50
КТО ЛЮБИТ ГРИБЫ?? #shorts
00:24
Просмотров 1,1 млн