Diana DeGarmo-My Heart Will Go On 

Diana DeGarmo was the contestant on Idol that received the harshest criticism ever in the history of the show. I always enjoyed her performances.

Good fairly honest assessment from the judges!

Is it just me or did she sing this pretty fast?

In no way the hardest…. But they definitely believed in her and liked to offer feedback to improve her. She was amazing for her age!

I think only Celine can sing this. Its too bland for anyone else

Eric the midget brought me here 😂

Why is the arrangement so fast?? Sheesh...slow the thing down some

The speed of the song killed her performance. They should have stuck with the original tempo.

Beautifully magically god gift.

I understand where the judges comes from but poor girl, I think she got the harsher critic from a guest judge ever on the show.

Diana DeGarmo at her worst. This is her worst performance by far... but I think in a way, her bottom 3 trips were a good thing. Beginning next week she started consistently slaying!

Not all the time judges are right and they sing up to date. Forget about singing they can't even judge probably. Simon is zero not hero. Diana got talent.she has beautiful voice.compare to Celine Diana not bad.

Thats a hard song to sing.

Kimberly Locke performed this song better and so did Sylvia Yacoob. But of course only Celine should sing this lol

I love you diana

holy karaoke

This didn't do anything for her. Tarantino is right there were glass in front of him. I felt same way like it didn't come through didn't connect to the audience. Weak performance from her

Shes trying to hard i didnt like it awkward at times.

사이먼이 7점 주고 칭찬이에요 한 무대

Dang they absolutely roasted her?!? Haha and terentino?!?! Wow I do not remember him As a guest judge but he’s awesome

She needs to work on her breathing. She sounds out of breath. Imo

It wasn’t bad.

Terrible arrangement

😐 man that sucked but Tarantino was a little harsh.