Democracy is simply majoritarianism in countries (internally divided into communities) like India. Democracy, according to me only works in countries with no clashing ideologies or communities and when the majority of people are rational and unbiased which will never happen any sooner in our country.
Democracy is necessary for a country like India where different ideology exist and everyone hopes to come in power either at local or central level and federalism again enhances it , a single man can rule china by destroying the differences and making a homogeneous country but dictatorship will break a country like india
bruh.... what do you mean by this? according to you? let's talk fact, Stalin killed 700,000 of his own people, Hitler killed 16,315,000, Mao killed 80 million of his own stfu if you don't know anything , democracy works and America and Europe is your shining example while Soviet Union died a not so graceful death, North Korea is no less then hell, Middle East is worst
@@g.cchaudhary22 hindu votebank bhi mention kr dete ? kafi log to isi basis pr dete h vote aur dalit hi nhi kuch aur caste wale bhi apni caste ke hisab se dete h vote
I believe constitutional monarchy is better for India - it avoids problems of democracy of short-sightedness, and avoids problem of dictatorship by avoiding rule and desires of dictatorship by having a constitutional values. Then there should be democratic rule inside conditional monarchy, where people can select representative of there own castes which will be part of the raj-sabha ( court of king ). This is in accordance to government mentioned in Mahabharata, which includes a monarch, and brahmins, kshytria, vaishya, shudra and suta for various departments and stuff.
Problem with your approach is sooner or later there will be a king who wants more power and wants to grab more land . Which resulted in invasion of India. The Invader promised kings certain things so they sided with Brits ( for examples , well there are many examples) . And when I say wee need kings like Shivaji then Muslims will be offended but when I say Aurangzeb is good Hindus will be offended. The base line is to rule a country with stability and progress there should not be a clash of communities . And when there are multiple communities the fall of nation is inevitable sooner or later. India will also fall because of some communities for examples fall of multiple states such as ( Bengal, Kerala ,Punjab) . You know the solution what needs to happen to make system work .
In this 2024 Lokshabha Election, maximum number people of West Bengal did the same thing by inundating Mamata Banerjee with votes. Right after Election , Mamata has started unleashing draconian law.
I want an ethical dictatorship in India. It's difficult to manage extreme diversity in a democracy. We have sick people who get on the road to protest for everything.
Dictatorship is never ethical and proper such ideologies does not exist....there is 10× more corruption in dictatorship than in democracy at least you can make comments on govt if they do such activities but in the latter you directly die 😂take example of history there had been very few examples of good and ethical dictatorship
I think dictotarship is good in some cases which is very exceptional.if the person indivudialy good and rational minded then dictatorship can help the country to grow . But the countries like india where we can find different ideologies ,democracy is far better option than dictatorship .
for a country like India which has been ruled for eternity by monarchs , whose period were considered as golden periods of India which is bhaarat now they are saying democracy this democracy that.... monarchy & dictatorship is bad system....it's fkin natural it's not on emotional basis but on rational ground that bhaarat is growing n a growing economy is always under attack....abhi ke liye toh i demand bjp dictatorship for @least 50 years uske baad ham democracy ke baare main soch sakte hain.... democracy leader ke haath se powers hi cheen leti hai....a distributed power makes a power less state shareer main bhi sabse jyada authority dimaag ko h.... vahan democracy nhin chalti....😂...#indialetstrydictatorship
dictatorship good hai sirf tab jab religious chutiyas or liberal chutiyas etc govt me na ho.. Rationalist experts agar rule kare to ve kabhi bhi north Korea/isis jaisi dictatorship nahi banayenge. Kyunki ve rationalists hai.
This video was as unbiased as it could be no left/right just points laid out in favor and against but still i find that democracy is better as even if dictatorship may help a country economically and provide stability and order. We may never know when the dictator might change as when someone have too much power there is a high chance it may be misused, while in case of democracy there is still a room for opposing govt. decision in dictatorship it's not. In all ways democracy might not be the sharpest tool in the shed but it's the best that we could have. But still the video was great and u earned a subscribe
It's simple someone who is actually visionary and wants India to grow will come in power and will challenge the Constitution . That person will establish dictatorship as him being the dictator but as i said he really wants to develop the nation so he will do so. But that dictator should sign an temporary dictatorship act of around 2 decades. In 2 decade India develop and grow with maximum potential then move back to democracy again as the temporary dictatorship agreement will end. I want this to happen in my nation .
@@hippospoop1871 but how could u say that they will not abuse their authority because no matter how much a person is willing to make a country developed when given power can change his / hers goal. It may not be always as u said but if we go by probabilities the what u said could be right but it's just a probability and even quite low at that so that's why I said that
@@ragexebec2410 that's what I am saying na we need an kalki avatar miracle person who is so intellectual that he must know that democracy is better for long term while dictatorship is only good for short term development, "Dictatorship fails when it continues after the end of the initial dictator"- Hippo's poop..... What I mean is that dictator should sign an agreement in the first place that his reign will end after 2 decades and democracy will be reestablished no matter what. It can happen if our Constitution itself accept dictatorship and that dictatorship works within the Constitution. Many empires become so developed and powerful because of a particular king(which is a dictator) but then that empire falls due to weak successors of dictators, it's simple democracy is ultimately the only way for long term . If those empires don't following dictatorship and followed a democratic system then those empires would have survived much longer due to them not being ruled under weak Kings (dictators).
@@Ram_ram_bhaiyo1 uska channel dekh bhai wo koi political strategist ya expert nhi h philosophy ka channel h usne dictatorship pe philosophical views diye hn philosophy kya bolti h that's it tum log use politics se jod rhe
@@vinit755 har sikke ke do pehalu hote hai par rathee har bar 1 pehlu dikha kar gumrah karne ka kam karta hai Or abhi bhi power sambhale esa option koi nahi, or comedy karne wale power de kar 1 desh bhugat raha hai. 7 puste bhugtegi hamare desh ne sadiyon se bhugta hai ab galti nahi karege.
Not possible, it should've happened in starting 20-30 years of our independence just like it happened in Singapore, South Korea, Malaysia, China, etc, we were equal to these countries at the time of our independence (you can check it), but we never had a visionary leader and that created the difference
@@Mr.manthan88 mere modi par 😂😂 modi mera kya lagta hai 😂 Mai democracy ki baat kar raha hun. Arab countries mein democracy nhi hai phir bhi unki quality of life aur apni quality of life dekhle 😂😂
zaroori Nehi hai dictators aur monarchs janta ke support se hi upar pahuncte hain...india jese value system main pala dictator kabhi Hitler jesa nhin hoga ...
Indian value system is based on Vedic mimansa & other shashtra we are tolerant people....n a cruel leader is demand of land ...a cruel leader against enemies of motherland who will make us great , n again morality sirf kitaab ke pannon par acchi lagti h reality is cruel...n kingdoms are based on cruelty....n Indians should be ready to pay such small price for such heavenly gains #indialetstrydictatorship
Why Plato hated democracy! Democracy me bhi ye dekhna padta hai ki kahi ye elitist to nahi ? Kahi ye oligarchy to nahi ban rha ya plutocracy ki or to nahi jaa rha hai, prejudices, cognitive biases, favouritism ye sab alag plagues hai hiding in the plain sight ...mujhe apne arguments strong banane hai, to realise a robust point , regardless of its colours and traits, without rose coloured glasses ke dekhna hai,
Hitler ke bare sare lok itna dictatorship bolta hai What did Churchill in India,, 2.5 cr people ka death due to loot of goods only in 3 years Desh bhag ke liye Bharat me 4-5 cr people ka death *And aaj tak khud ke political fayde ke liye pura Africa and Asian many countries mein dange krwa raha hai USA Russia and France,, these are more cruel DICTATORship*
Imagine the choices that our leaders had when India became independent? They could use colonialism and say, we need to secure the country and cannot give power to the people Yet, they chose to give power back to the people. This did not happen in Pakistan, Myanmar, Nepal etc. The only other country this happened in was the United States
android kam kar rha hai aj k samey zyada.. iphone bas camera chipka k kya model launch kar rha hai..ab muje nhi pta tera kya matlab tha is bekar k comparison se
Sir you applied all the thought of western Philosopher. do you know about thought of indian thinkers about how a state should run(eg-Vishma , Bidur, Chanakya, Krishna, Vikramaditya, and vaidik thoughts nasadiya sutra) as no matter who is the king india is always a welcoming country
video to sahi hai, Control to le rahi hai government , individual ki freedom ko bhi tak per rakha hai. Aur Sabse badi problem yh jo action ho rahe hai vh development ke liye hote to seh lete pr yh to nfrt Failane ke liye hai
Kya aap kashmir ki situation ko smjhte ho? Bengal ko samjhte ho? Desh me ander hi ander deshdrohi ho rahhe h . Samjhte ho? To ise nafrat failana nahi. Apni sanskriti ko bachana kehte h. Lekin dusra paksh satta k liye ise nafrat failane ka roopble raha h. Lekin ander hi ander desh ko khaya ja raha h.
Vimoh has said on his YT channel that People who support dictatorship, states that "Oh, the one leader would do so much benefit, quick decision making, law & order would improve" Just ask them, what if a leader who can do all of that but is from opposite ideology you believe in, would you still support such dictator?
Bro iam from kashmir Iam caught in a loop i.e iam obsessed with east direction I love east and i hate west Whenever i look at eastern direction i feel happy And whenever i walk towards east and that east becomes west and i dont want to come back just want travell east more and more . I MENTALLY OK AND NORMAL ITS THAT THERE IS SOMETHING IN EASTERN DIRECTION THAT CALLS ME . I'VE WROTE SOME PAGES ABOUT THAT AND GAVE IT A NAME : PHILOSOPHY OF EASTERN VIBES . WHAT DO YOU THINK WHAT IT IS IAM 18 YRS OLD AND I'VE BEEN WACTHING YOU FROM SOO LONG ❤❤
😅😅sir ji Hitler.. Christianity ko hi parmote krta tha...sch ni btaya public ko..news 📰 papper h history mey.. Hitler k tim pe..esaaaiiiee..pop father pastors brother nun sister sare chup the 😅😅ye ji asli history..ku k bibblee mey lekha hua h..yahudioo k nh jnme bche tk mrdo do ye unke khuda ka hukam h
If you ask me about Nepal, then I am ok with it but not satisfied. Indian democracy for me looks like a pure authoritarian circus for me. Sorry. But I know they'll choose the same kind of democracy again.
jo bhi ho loktantra hi ek society ko sustainable way mei grow kr skti hai.... ek autocratic society no matter kitna bhi tej grow kre... but it is destined to collapse... anr when it collapse.... cry is so loud... whole civilization become extinct..
@@manurazgoit middle East ki tabahi ka karan loktantra hain loktantra wahi falta hain jaha ekroop samaj ho jaise west Europe aajkal usa ki society bhayankar divided hain aane waale saalo mein bharat me bhi Aisa hoga 😊
loktantra hi hai kisi vajah se 75 years mein Indians mein itni nafrat bhar gayi hai, aur aajkal toh social media hai ab socho 2050 tak kitni hate hogi dusri communities ke liye logo mein. Hindu Muslim caste language har hate ki wajah loktantra hi hai, aur mai aapse sahmat hu.
Nope..singapore benevolent dictatorship ka example hai..not every dictator follows totalitarian ideology..kuan yew ne desh ka socha with civil liberties
Bro but all the dictators who did some positive reforms were much educated. And I think thats why the made the exact right decision for their country without choosing the path of violence. Btw naic info👍🏼
Aap sahi kahe rahe hu jilebi wale hi ko vot dete hai loog zhote gondo ko hi vot dete hai loog dimagi bimaro ko vot dete hai jitna bada zhota usko vot dete hai loog thnks sir ❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤🎉🎉🎉🎉🎉🎉🎉🎉🎉🎉🎉🎉🎉🎉🎉aapki bate bahut acchi aur sahi hai ❤❤❤❤🎉🎉🎉🎉🎉
Bro I am watching you since you used to teach philosophy on a white board and used to have like 100 views, its good to see you are gaining some audience.
As my solution , In our country India , Rajya Sabha is almost useless, so instead of a having a rajya sabha we must a have some specific numbers of intellectual from every state who have proven their wisdom in written and practical exams and they must have a say in the making of law of the nation . It's would be better to have a house of intellectual than the Rajya Sabha . It's only my own solution, if you have better solutions than this please tell me about that , I want to know more ideas🙏
@@Neelinmact The intellects should be selected by giving a specific type of exam conducted by an independent body of Phd holders in Political affairs which must have a minimum number of people from all states and UTs
@@Atheist_Indian what questions will you ask in political affairs and how ill anyone gauge the answers because the answers for a politcal phillosophy will not be consistent and it will change with people's political phillosophy ,, then it can lead to concentrations of intellectuals who lean towards one particular political phillosophy ,,
This man is contradicting his own statements after just 10 statements... All types of logical fallacy😂😂 Just for the sake of druv rathee and to prove himself this one is trying hard.
for a country like India which has been ruled for eternity by monarchs , whose period were considered as golden periods of India which is bhaarat now they are saying democracy this democracy that.... monarchy & dictatorship is bad system....it's fkin natural it's not on emotional basis but on rational ground that bhaarat is growing n a growing economy is always under attack....abhi ke liye toh i demand bjp dictatorship for @least 50 years uske baad ham democracy ke baare main soch sakte hain.... democracy leader ke haath se powers hi cheen leti hai....a distributed power makes a power less state shareer main bhi sabse jyada authority dimaag ko h.... vahan democracy nhin chalti....😂...#indialetstrydictatorship
how do you know they were considered as golden periods??? did you live in those times to actually know the ground reality?? you were literally murdered whenever you spoke against the monarchy. There was also the caste system(don't give that fking thing about varna system both are the same). There was slavery and also war was frequent in those times. Even the healthcare was horrible, there is reason why people in those times had 7-8 kids, because 3-4 would just die during the birth, various diseases were rampant during those times. You wouldn't think about this because you imagine yourself that if I were in those olden times then I would be a badass king and bring glory Bla Bla Bla. You just want to satisfy your fantasy of India being a dictatorship.
@@aryabartarout5697 nhi hoga bete ideologies different hai..hamare yahan sharia varia or sar tan se juda ka concept nhi hai hmari ideology or culture or un jihadiyon k culture mai zamin asman ka farak hai dictatorship kahin.. pakistan mai tum koi bhi system le ao fail hi hoga kyu ki janta or leaders dono jahil hai
@@Skyo.o India unhi logo ki baje se develop hua hai jinke pas science temperament, critical thinking, hardworking and real deshbhakti hai like apj abdul kalam, shubhash chandra bosh and niraj chopra. agar ye nahi hota to india bhikhario ka desh hota
@@aryabartarout5697 in sab k piche bhi insan ki ideologies hi hoti hai..or ideology surroundings or culture or religion se hi influence hoti hai..age ye sab madrase mai padhe hote kisi pakistan se fir dekhte kya karte. jahan tumhe kuda pe question karne se hi tumhari critical thinking to choro tumhari basic thinking ko hi khatam kar diya jata
Brother i have been viewing your channel since your white board days. I hope you do good. Your video quality has improved so much, yet your content was always brilliant. Kudos to you. I want more on indian philosophies, because i can get my hands on western philosophies easily. I want one with dvait and advait vedanta. I loved your carvak video. Take care of yourself. You are brilliant.
Dictatorship is a risk which every weak democratic country should take in case of disorder and choas in the system. Similarly every dictator country should take risk to bring back democracy in the country. Maybe it's inevitable thing we can't do anything about it. Because sometimes people crave for freedom and sometimes people want to full fill their imaginary desires. Such as what's happening in India right now is an classic example of "people seeking pride in things which is lost in the past, they want to bring back their dreams" it's bullshit but anyways I don't think it's that much easy jaisa log soch rahe hain Modi aaya toh simply dictatorship hi Aa jayega jaise dictatorship koi halwa hain aur Modi aake turant bna hi lega. Dhruv kuchh jyada hi hyper bta raha mujhe toh uske pichhe bhi left ka propaganda hi lagta hain left ab itna weak ho gya ki usko power regain karne ke liye logo ko dictator bolne ki jarurat pad rahi hain. Chill guys dictatorship is not halwa and India is not pak or north Korea jo aasani se dictatorship Aa jaye. Indian people are some how still rational and logical and it's not happening anyway. Logo ko panic karke unke fear ki vajah se insecurity create Ki Jaa rahi hain bas jo ki mass choas me badal sakti hain kabhi bhi... Sab narrative Ki Baat hoti hain bici is information ke duar me itna manipulation hain ki logo ko kabhi bhi kuchh bhi mehsus karaya Jaa sakta hain.
Constitutional monarchy with multi-party Democracy is better where the Prime Minister is directly elected by the people. In which the Executive Prime Minister runs the country, but if the Prime Minister doesn't listen to the voice of the people and oppresses the people, then the constitutional king can remove him from power and elect a new Prime Minister who the people want.
Is dictatorship good or bad? I will say it's depend on the dictator. If the dictator is good then the dictatorship will be good and if the dictator is bad then the dictatorship will be bad.
हमारे संविधन मे सब कुछ है situation and time ke according democracy aristocracy like autonomous body and dictatorship in emergency but the present government want to uproot the constitution and wanna bring dictatorship
