Jagdish aadat hone ka time hai Tum jaisa Anubhav rahata Na to Aaj tum log gulami rahe the kabhi Azad nahin ban paate mein jo mahapurush jitne bhi tha na sabke shoj alag the tum jaise nahin karna Modi ke Chintu asali ho to Modi ka beta Yogi to aapka Dada pada sab lag jaenge koi bada baat nahin hai Lekin jitne din rahoge utane dinank bhakti rahoge agar ISI tarah agar Muslim chahe na tum log to ekadam barbad hokar jaaoge 80 guda ho aur 15 18 karod se dar lag raha hai kitna bada Hindu Ho bada pata chal gaya
पहले भगवान की प्रकृति की रक्षा करें और बाद में अपनी मस्जिद और मंदिर की रक्षा करें। जलवायु परिवर्तन और भयानक बीमारियों के कारण होने वाले विनाश से खुद को बचाएं
Etihaskar mahashy sarkari paise se mandir nahi banana chahiye aap batala rahe hai. Lekin mandiro ka paisa sarkari khajana me jana chahiye. Mandir usi paisa se bab raha hai. Aap Galat bata rahe hai.
@@drmajidkhanpharmacy3683 Aurangjeb demolished Temple in era of Islamic rule, but these two are demolishing civilization in secular rules. Thats why these two are great & the greatest.
@@suniil-Shukla But mandir ka dhan Hindus bachcho ki education or greebo k liye kharch Karna chahiye sarkar q leti hai bhagwan k naam ka paisa bhagwan k bhakto k bhale k liye use hona chahiye ayse greebi door hogi or bachche educated hokar kuch achche post p jay ge
मुकेश कुमार जी आप ने कितने खूबसूरत ढंग से इंटरव्यू लिया है तारीफ के काबिल है इस बात को सभी को विचार करना चाहिए और उन लंमपटो को समझना चाहिए जो कि हमारे भाई चारे को समाप्त करने की कोशिश कर रहे हैं जै भारत *****?
इतिहासकारोंने सच्चा इतिहास बताना चाहिये। वर्तमान राजकिय बात नहि करनि चाहिये। क्या आगे चलके ऐसे इतिहासकार अफगाणीस्थान मे तालिबानी सोचवालोंने बुद्ध मुर्ती को तोडा नहि गया,बल्कि एक बार जोरका जलजला आया इसमे बुद्ध मुर्ती टुट गयी! नहि तो गलती से तोफका गोला मुर्तीको लगा....!ऐसा भि कह सकते है।
राम पुनियानी सर (इतिहासकार) बहुत सुंदर तरह से भारत वासियों को आप ने इतिहास का हवाला दे कर औरंगजेब बादशाह के बारे में हम सभी को अवगत कराया, बहुत बहुत धन्यवाद आप को। इंसानिताय सबसे बड़ा धर्म होता है...
Mai na to RSS/BJP ka support hu na Muslim ka dwesh karata hu, lekin ye Puniyani bohat bar itihas ki shallow narration (tippani ) karata hai, aise logo ki vajah se jo sachmuch neutral ( nispaksha) itihaskar hote hai vo badnam hote hai. Rahi bat Aurangzeb ki to aap ithihas ka adhyan karo, aurangzeb ka ek pahlu ye bhi hai ki vo kabhi broad minded nahi tha, fundamentalist tha, aur apne dusre sardar bhi dharm ka kattar palan kare ye nasihat deta tha, khud ko unche chugtai vansha ka manta tha, yaha jiziya lagana chahta tha.
@@MM-ue4ol There is nothing wrong in being fundamentalist, unless you don't harm anyone. You must know that India in the era of Aurangzeb was geographically bigger than any of the medieval kings, so his intention was just to expand n expand the India. yeah he asked for Jaziya tax which was 1.8% of someone's income (except Brahmins, Widows & Poor) where as muslims had to pay 2.5% of their income. However if you see our current government is taking how much of our income, if you compare with Aurangzeb rule, the tax was still lesser than what we are paying now.
ज्ञानवापी मस्जिद पर आए अरकेलॉजिकल 27 जनवरी 2024 के सर्वे रिपोर्ट ने तुम दोनों के ज्ञान की लंका लगा दी जो तुम रात दिन मुगलों को महिमा मंडन करते हो,, शर्म आनी चाहिए तुम्हें कुछ नही पता
ना रोजगार पूछो ना महंगाई पूछो ना गरीबी पूछा ना स्वास्थ्य पूछो ना विकास पूछो ना शिक्षा पूछो ना भ्रष्टाचार पूछो ना अपराध पूछो बस गुणगान करो वर्ना हिन्दुत्व खतरे में आ जायेगा आज भारत के शिक्षित लोगो की मानसिकता कितनी गिर चुकी है 🇮🇳
पुनयानी और ये दूसरा मुकेश शर्म नहीं इन दोनों कमीनो को जो खाते भारत देश का हैं और बुराई भी कठमुललों की तरह इसी देश की करते हैं इनके घर में भी कोई गैरत मंद इंसान नहीं जो इनहे समझाए कया घर में भी सारे चूतिए रहते हैं कौन सी नस्ल हैं ये संकर नसल के हैं शायद
Lekin dharm ka angle bhi chalaya Gaya hain muslim kings ki taraf se jaise gilgit mein conversion,pakistan mein conversion,sindh mein conversion,kashmir mein toh direct eviction,no conversion,bhai hindus only suffered a proper conversion mission.
@@kmustafa2967 bhai Mustafa dekh koi nahi karta tha discriminate kashmir mein kaha hain zikr discrimination ka woh tho talent ka respect karte the they never supported it,but look how u are presenting it ur kings had total machinary in place to convert they used,mullah,masjid,soldiers,bounties to convert atleast some will submit and convert when u create such branding and agency.even Brahmins converted and ur are telling that discrimnation lead to conversion,bhai kya muslims mein discrimination nahi hain kya women face till today,Shia Sunni,Sufism,wahabis killing ahmadis,whatvnot u have done and trying to create discrimination notion foolish community ur.
@@dheerajgoswamy7939 Mughals were brand agency for Hindus 🕉 and Hinduism. If Aurangzeb was hardcore Islamic and aggressive enough in the level of BJP/RSS today India 🇮🇳 would be a Muslim ☪️ Majority. Aurangzeb fought wars against Marathas and the British but never turn against the local Hindus population after they submit his rule and dominance.
There are written proof in Kolkata museum of Auranzebs order to demolish Kashi temple.why false history is being spread? why Indian govt is not taking action on this so called pundit Ram Puniya & Mukesh for spreading wrong history & confusion.
Jai Bheem kei chakkar mein Meem ki kitni chatoge bandhu??? Thora padh bhi lete yaar ki Baba Saheb ka kya kehna tha is kaum aur uski loyalty kei baare mein 🙏
Ye bkl n historian hai, n hi archaeologist aur n hi koi Islamic scholar, par Satya Hindi kei paas yhi ek expert hai Mughalon ko discuss karne kei liye 😅 Ekdum eco-chamber hai dallon ka
आप कितना सच बोलते हैं मैं नहीं जानता मगर औरंगजेब ने गुरु गोबिंद सिंह के साथ सारी जिंदगी लडता रहा और आनंद पुर साहिब गुरू तेगबहादुर् जी ने जमीन खरीद कर खुद शहिर बसाया धा लेकिन गुरू गोबिंद सिंह को वहा बसने नहीं दिया और ऊन के
Sir ji, Jab Loghon Ku PAR DADA Ka Naam Patha Nahin Hai, 700, SAAL Ka Purana Kissah Kaise Patha Chalega, Ye Sab Ak Siasath Ka Khel Hai. 2024, Mein "MP" Elaction Aane Wala Hai, Ye Sab Hotha Hi Rehagha.. DESH' Mein Kiya Ho Raha Hai Ye Sab JANTA" Samajh Na Chahiye.
Every Indians should think deeply in history thenshould take steps . A great historian , great description . Our honourable PM and honourable CM of UP should dig deep in History rather than distort it .
Very dispassionate and balanced view of Dr. Ram Puniani regarding the historiography of communalism in India. I suggest that a committee of learned men like Dr. Puniani and others be created to resolve the issues arising from temple mosque disputes in the country. The attention of government to win elections by fanning hindu Muslim communalism is regressing the nation into the past and misdirecting the people's focus into useless things.
Where the future of the country is heading or proceeding by digging the soils of the earth or selling the public sector national properties?? Couldn't understand.
Allah aur insaan ka rishta sirf bande ka hai, chahe oh koi bhi majhab se taluk rakhe ek maa jitni muhabbat karti hai apne aulad se usse 70 Guna jyada Muhabbat Allah karta hai apne hur bande se chahe oh uski ibadat kare ya na kare Allah ki banai Hui cheez asman jameen Suraj Chand insaan janwar ki ibadat kare in sab ka creator ek hi hai ek insaan ki madad karna khana Pani Dena halal hai haram nhi oh koi bhi majhab ka ho insan ka darja natural things se upper hai aur farishto se bhi jyada h
New age people are much well read than these people. These people are opportunists. They have neither the brain to study hard, nor intention. They are there because they are hyped & patronized by a section of very cunning people
@@kathanak2290 BHAIYA AAPKE JO VICHAAR SATYA ITHAAS KARONKE BARE ME BAHOOT ASTYA HAI IS KA JO SATYA HAI AAP KE VIGHNATA KO CHODNA HI SATYA HAI LEKIN SATYA AAJ KA AAJ HUM FARJI ITIHAAS SE GNYNI HUVE NAFRATI GNYAAN SE AGNYANI HUVE BHAGWAAN NA KARE KE BHAKT BHI ANDHE HONGE VISHWA KE SAB JATI OUR DHARM APNE HI HONGE GNYANI ANDH VISHWAS SE AGNYANI HONA AGNYAAN HAI DHANYAVAAD
SC did not say that there was no mandir under the masjid! SC said it is not clear whether the mandir was destroyed and masjid built. It was proven by archeologists that there was a mandir there.
Murthi Rakho -Kabza Karo . Sabi masjid , gurudwara , church meh murthi rakho -kabza karo. Ploice Army , Govt. Court aap kay saath hai . Thum bas Murthi rakho :Kabza Bajrang Dal kay Gunday kar layangay .
People belives that god knows everything even from anybody's mind and thoughts but he couldn't recognise his own son Ganesha standing in front of him People belives that god will protect them from every problem who couldn't protect their own temples churches and mosques
You fool I bet you haven't studied Shiv puran . Lord Shiva knew Lord Ganesha was his son but he did it so he could find a way to kill Asur . Asur could be only killed by a person who is born two times and who has 2 different people in one body . Lord Shiva even knew about Ramayan crore years before . Fool read scriptures before .
*ARTICLE-1:* JAMMU AND KASHMIR The ancient Jamia Mosque in Srinagar was built by King Sikander Shah Kashmiri in 1394 AD. It has a pond with a fountain in the middle which is used for ablution purpose. UTTAR PRADESH In the 100-year-old Asifi mosque in Lucknow, water for ablution used to come from a well, India Today's reporter found. According to Maulana Amil Shamshi, there were fountains in the past and they exist even today, but the pressure of the water has reduced. At Tehsin ki Masjid in Lucknow, there used to be two big ponds which are now covered with a net. Now, water from a tank is used for ablution. Chota Imambara in Lucknow, meanwhile, used to have a fountain for the purpose of wazu (ablution). At Jama Masjid Eidgah in Lucknow, a tank is used for wazu. Earlier, water was brought from a well. Maulana Sufiyan Nizami said, "Earlier, we used to arrange water for ablution, but not anymore." MADHYA PRADESH At Tajul masjid in Bhopal, the wazukhana is a huge open square tank with a flower-shaped fountain in the centre. On all four sides of the tank, taps are connected. The water from the taps is drained out after wazu. The construction of the mosque began in 1871. At Gwalior's 100-year-old Moti Masjid, water from taps is used for wazu. DELHI At Fatehpuri Masjid in Delhi's Chandni Chowk, there is a wazukhana in the front yard. There is a fountain in the middle of the wazukhana. Nowadays, water from taps is used for ablution in the wazukhana. The mosque was built in 1650. Meanwhile, Husaini Masjid in old Delhi has a wazukhana with a fountain at its centre. Mohammad Sadiq, who has been looking after the mosque for the last 30 years, said the mosque has changed over time. Source: India Today *ARTICLE-2:* Almost all mosques of the 16th and 17th centuries have a fountain in their or ablution area. Others have removed it only recently to replace the creaky old structure with a new one. Among them is the historic Masjid Abdun Nabi located next to the erstwhile police headquarters in central Delhi. The mosque which serves as the nodal point for Jameat Ulama-e-Hind, has had a large pond for ablution. At the centre of it has been a fountain. Named after Mughal emperor Akbar’s registrar, the mosque is under renovation and the fountain too is being given a facelift with the faithful meanwhile asked to use the tap for washing their hands and feet.wuzukhana The story is repeated at the historic Madrasa Husain Bux in Old Delhi. Built in 1852, the madrasa played host to freedom fighters in the early 20th century. The madrasa has had a hauz or a pond with a fountain at the centre. Now under renovation, the fountain was replaced with a pillar at the centre with provision for birds to quench their thirst in summers. The story is repeated at the good old Patna Wali Masjid in Bara Hindu Rao and Masjid Fakhruddin in Azad Market, etc. Each of them has a cylindrical fountain at the centre of the water body. Noted American historian explains the reason behind the presence of fountains in Islamic architecture. “You’ve got to circulate water. Otherwise, it will be gross and mosquito haven. Pleasantness of surroundings and cleanliness are pretty strong concerns in Islamicate culture,” she explains. Source: The Hindu
मैं पंजाब का रहने वाला हूँ।बड़ी बारीक़ी से सिख इतिहास को जनता हूँ। औरंगजेब अगर इतना दयालु था तो गुरु गोबिंद सिंह जी के बच्चों को नींव में चुनवाने को किस तरह से देखते हैं आप ।ऐसे क्रूर आदमी को मह्मामंडित कर रहे हैं आप जिसने अपने सगे भाई नही छोड़े उनको भी क़त्ल किया ।हद है जनाब शर्म आती है आप पर।
tu Bhai fake history RU-vid p dhek ta h gurugovindji ko phadi Hindu aur muglo ne Mara tha phadi raza Dosi Te marvane k liye aur ye ye jo tu bol rha wo sab glt bolta h real history dhek pata chale GA gurugovindji ka sat dono jati ne diya ta Hindu n b muslim n b isliye unhone kisi dharam ko glt nhi bola ta itna to mujhe pata h m Quran Sharif bina dheke phad deta hoon ko Sikh Bhai k bare m kafi Jan ta hoon
@@soaeb83 सुन, तू अपनी सोच मेरी छोड़। कोई तर्क ना हो तो ज्ञान नहीं देते। तरस आती है तुम्हारे सोच पे, जो तू औरंगजेब जैसे आक्रांताओ की वकालत करता है। जिसने लाखो लोगों को मरवाआ, गुरु तेग बहादुर, छत्रपति संभाजी महाराज , दारा शिकोह को इतनी क्रूरता से मरवाआ। वो अगर तुझे अच्छा शासक लगता है तो तुझे पढ़ने लिखने की जरूरत है। जाके इतिहास की किताब खोल तब सद्बुद्धि आएगी तुझे।
सोम नाथ मंदिर के बारे में गांधीजी को नही सरदार पटेल जी से लोगों ने बात की थी क्योंकि उस समय सरदार पटेल गृहमंत्री थे,और उन्होंने साफ शब्दो मे इन्कार कर दिया था|
Dharm ke Nam par Kisi ek dharma Ka Mandir ya masjid Janata ke paise ya kahiye sarakaro paise se banavana sambodhan Ka durpayog hai agar Janata me donation Diya hai to usaka bhi hisab Janata ke samane rakhana Hoga tabhi sarakar ya Mandir ki sanstha ko dena Hoga nahee to use bhee bhrashtachar me dala Ka sakata hai .sarakar ko pahale pardarsita par dhyan dena Chahiye taki Janata mein vishwas ho ki sarakar sahee kam Kar rahee hai bipaksh kya kah Raha hai usako bhi sarakar ko safai deni paregi aur ap kya Kar rahe ho agar sahee Kar rahe ho to kyon alochana ho rahee hsi.
Punwani sir has an excellent knowledge & study on history. He always share a relevant knowledge. Always found him very loud in his expression of reality based on his study & research. Thank you for sharing this. My request is to construct a place of worship without demolition of existing one. We should create harmonious & peaceful environment.
Ye bkl n historian hai, n hi archaeologist aur n hi koi Islamic scholar, par Satya Hindi kei paas yhi ek expert hai Mughalon ko discuss karne kei liye 😅 Ekdum eco-chamber hai dallon ka
This is truth that aurangjeb destroyed baba vishwanath temple.aurangjeb passed a order of destruction of baba vishwanath. So still murti of Nandi is facing towards gyan vapi masjid.
I am sorry for your disappointed views on Mughals. Aurangzeb was very soft with Hindus that he didn't turn India into Islamic Akhund Rashtra 😅. If he did this at the first place India will be saved from VHP fanatics.
Kyu itihash main apne matlab ki koi cheez nahi mili toh one side story kehne laga wah re andhbhaqti facts and historian ki books ko bhi one side story keh rha hai 😂
All Muslims know about the history, we don't know the exact facts, all are theories. 1. it was built 700/800 years ago, if you are supposed to fight, you need to be born at that time, not now. Why didn't the Hindu brave people fight at times? It is completely illogical. You already have hindu warriors like Shivajee, Todarmal, Rana Pratap, Jhansi Laxmi bai ...many more etc. 2. Moreover, as per constitution it is already declared/agreed that after 1947 no one touches the religious places, you are not supporting your own written document. 3. Based on the history if you judge muslims and start humiliating them - this will cause wars again. On this planet you find only temples and your idols, no humans. 4. Whatever you do now it will pay back to you in the future 100%, maybe after 100/200 later, the same cycle will run again.
Mughal Musalman They Jo Karnama Dikhaya Woh Musalmano Ka Kaam Nahi Jo Asli Musalman Islam Lay Unka Koi Naam Zikar He Nahi Ashtagfirullah 25 Sahaba Karam 42 Tabai 18 Tabe Tabai 85 Loog Khairunkuroon Ke Loog Islam Lay Kar Hind Men Aye Shirf Qur'an Hadith , Islam Qur'an Hadith Men Hai , Mughal Aur Firka Firka Men Nahi
Mathura temple was demolished ......numerous temples of rajputana were demolished......somnath temple was also demolished...... Stop spreading falsehood
So it's very clear that the rulers demolished temples for their political mileage and not for religious cause. And so the present political parties are doing. And as per your assessment it's not WRONG.
बाबर, हुमायूं, अकबर, जहांगीर, शाहजहां तथा औरंगजेब ने करीब 30 हजार मंदिरों को तोड़ा है और उसपर मस्जिद बना लिया था । लेकिन इस बात पर कोई गंभीर रुप से बातचीत क्यों नही करता है ?
Ibrahim Gardi was with Peshwas, who died in 1761, in the third battle of Panipat fighting against Abdali. He was not with Shivaji Maharaj. It is also absurd logic to say that Aurangjeb did not fight war with Shivaji Maharaj because it is not Aurangjeb but his General, Mirza Raja Jaysing faught it. Ram Puniyani always twists history according to his convenience
*Dhimmi means - non muslim citizens of a Muslim ruler* . As per the dhimmi covenant,ordered by Allah in holy Quran that an islamic emperor could not destroyed the religious structure of non muslim citizens of his sultanate. Quran says *whoever kills a dhimmi, will burn in hell* Prophet says *whoever harms a dhimmi, I shall be his foe on the day of judgement* Hadith says *do not damage the places of worship of the dhimmi's , if damage is done, it is your responsibility to repair it* Aurangzeb was a hard core muslim , therefore it's hard to believe in that he had violated the orders of the holy Quran and the prophet and hadith .
@@adityabanerjee7145 now it's your turn,if you can, do it. break it,move it. If aurangzeb did it, he was wrong. Is your religion says do it ? Jai hind🇮🇳
@@usmansharif3882 If kya hota hai bhai jaan... Aurangzeb ordered in his Farman and declared the same with pride in his authorised biography of the time that he broke the but-khana of kafirs... Ye "if" kitne din istemal karoge???
@@navintiwari112 तिवारी जी ❤️ कोई ऐसी गाली दीजिए जो मुझे लगे / मां मेरी अब स्वर्गीय हैं 🙏 आज एक शादी में व्यस्त हूं , कल आपको सोर्स बता दूंगा👍 जय हिन्द🇮🇳
इब्राहिम खान गारदी पेशवा के समय आर्टिलरी के प्रमुख थे aur पानिपत के तिसरे युद्ध मराठा vs अब्दाली , नजीब खान के साथ उनकी लढाई हुई थी। छत्रपति शिवाजी महाराज के समय इब्राहिम खान गार्डी नही थे यह पहली बात। दूसरी बात यह है की औरंगजेब के समय पर ही शिवाजी महाराज ने अपने स्वराज्य का विस्तार किया था और वो प्रसिद्ध वाकया है जब जय सिंह के साथ महाराज आगरा गए थे। इसका मतलब ही यही है की शिवाजी महाराज सीधा औरंगजेब के विरुद्ध खड़े थे। Punyani को इतिहास को तोड़ मरोड़कर पेश करना क्या मजबूरी है पता नही । लेकिन मुस्लिम शासक की बर्बरता को बार बार जस्टिफाई करने की उनकी कोशिश आदत में शामिल है।
You can give the logic that the islamic polity was dominant at that time.....that's a prudent logic.....but whatever you guys are discussing are just rubbish......
Agar aurangjeb ne 1000 temple tode aur wo hindu virodhi tha to tum kaise Bach gye aur bhart main itne hindu kaise hain, meri baat samjho man gadan baatein mat kiya karo sir ji.
