Тёмный

Did Jinnah Really Reject India's Offer of a Plebiscite in Kashmir in November 1947? 

Shakil Chaudhary
Подписаться 59 тыс.
Просмотров 7 тыс.
50% 1

Mr. Alok Gupta, 53, is a New Delhi-based businessman. He has been dealing in high-end manufacturing and robotic machines for the last 22 years. Previously, he had served as the country manager of Philips India (EMT Division).
He has earned a BE (electronics and communications), an MBA (FMS, Delhi University), and an LLB.
****************************************************
Dr. Farooq Adil (pronounced Aadil) is a renowned figure in literature, journalism, and research, known for his efforts to advance Urdu as Pakistan's national language. Born on September 15, 1962, in Liaqatpur Tehsil of Rahim Yar Khan, he earned his PhD in mass communication from the University of Karachi. His work as a pro-democracy intellectual and journalist has gained recognition both in Pakistan and internationally.
Dr. Adil’s groundbreaking research focused on how democratic politics can give way to autocratic rule, amending the Media Malaise Theory of public opinion. His findings have been internationally acknowledged, with particular relevance to third-world democracies like Pakistan.
He also played a pivotal role in promoting literary and cultural diplomacy, founding and editing the journal "Adbiyat International" under the Pakistan Academy of Letters, which brought together writers from diverse backgrounds.
With a 37-year career in investigative journalism and teaching, Dr. Adil designed the course "Practical TV Journalism" and trained journalists for the emerging electronic media. He also spearheaded efforts to enforce Urdu as the official language at the presidency under President Mamnoon Hussain.
Dr. Adil is a prolific author, with notable works such as "Hum Ne Jo Bhula Diya," "Eik Ankh Mein Amreeka," and "Jo Surat Nazar Ayi." His columns and articles continue to be highly regarded.
In recognition of his contributions to democracy, literature, and research, Dr. Adil was awarded the Pride of Performance by the President of Pakistan. He began his journalism career with "Takbeer" and has written for "Express" and BBC Urdu. He also served as advisor and press secretary to President Mamnoon Hussain.
You can follow him on Facebook: / faruqadil
I have interviewed him several times. One interview was conducted on November 15, 2021.
He was full of praise for Subhash Goyal, who runs an ayurvedic center in Chandigarh.
**************************************************
Shakil Chaudhary is an alumnus of Government College, Lahore. Subsequently, he studied international relations at Quaid-i-Azam University Islamabad and media at the London School of Economics. He has worked for several English-language newspapers.
He has written a critically acclaimed bilingual book, Handbook of Functional English (Ferozsons), to help those who wish to improve their English skills. Prof. Tariq Rahman, one of the finest linguistic scholars in South Asia, has praised it in these words: "This book is an excellent guide for the South Asian user of the English language. It gives examples of both the British and American varieties of English and provides guidelines to avoid the common errors of most Pakistanis when they write and speak English. It is also a comprehensive guide for pronunciation, vocabulary, editing and all other aspects of English usage. It has been written with great care and attention. I recommend it to students, editors, writers, and other users of English in Pakistan."
Shakil has conducted many workshops on communication, writing, and critical thinking skills. He is a former president of the Progressive Writers Association, Islamabad (2021-2022).
If you want to see his most popular videos, here are the links to them.
• Why didn't Jinnah impl...
• Prof. Hoodbhoy: Pakist...
• Shahid Siddiqui: The p...
• Muslims started the 19...
You are welcome to follow him on Facebook and Twitter.
/ shakil.chaudary
/ shakchaudhary

Опубликовано:

 

30 сен 2024

Поделиться:

Ссылка:

Скачать:

Готовим ссылку...

Добавить в:

Мой плейлист
Посмотреть позже
Комментарии : 76   
@karolbagh3793
@karolbagh3793 День назад
Where are Gupta's of Afghanistan, Pakistan. Where have they Vanished.
@vs9324
@vs9324 День назад
Dr Farooq should be asked " What about Balochistan and what the people want there?"
@Kabir00784
@Kabir00784 День назад
Juthi aur fareb ke subject pr PhD ki hai binod 🤣🤣
@AnujKumar-wj3ju
@AnujKumar-wj3ju День назад
Dr Farooq is graduated from Labbaik ya rasool Allah university.
@azeem_lahori-punjabi
@azeem_lahori-punjabi 21 час назад
😂
@Malik-lh4jh
@Malik-lh4jh 4 часа назад
Your from WhatsApp university
@rajpandit6630
@rajpandit6630 День назад
Mr Gupta is absolutely right that Plebiscite was the seed sown by Mountbatten not Nehru.
@Vishu.M123
@Vishu.M123 23 часа назад
The arms which used for World War II from army and police was transferred over to rider with the knowledge of Mr.Jinna . The letter written by Indian govt under secretary to Pakistan to Mr. John Rights. On 28th Aug. 1947
@MohinderSingh-lw6bk
@MohinderSingh-lw6bk 8 часов назад
The tribal invasion happened on 22nd Oct.,1947 but Dr. Adil says that it happened after 1st year of independence.
@raghupavan
@raghupavan 16 часов назад
Wow, I can't believe we have people like Mr.Gupta who doesn't understand the point of view of Pakistan. If one has to be blunt, it's very simple if one understands Islamic philosophy and how they work. They just want everyone to be Muslim and the entire world is ruled by them. Since J&K had Muslim dominated population at the time of our independence they belive it has to be part of Pakistan. No need of any jalebis to explain this. I believe Indians (Hindus) must read, understand Islam (Quran and Hadits) to understand them clearly. The entire Islamic countries, issues their wars will all be clear with that.
@Malik-lh4jh
@Malik-lh4jh 4 часа назад
Hindutva hatemonger troll.
@dramjad1712
@dramjad1712 22 часа назад
Sir, please do a detailed video on Jammu genocide in November1947 to further explanation of events as we do understand unfortunate killings in Kahuta and Haripur in March 1947 started the unfortunate events 🙏🌹🇵🇰
@_45sm-
@_45sm- 23 часа назад
Dr Shabbir Chaudhry is very apt person for chain of events from Sept. 47 to 1950 as regards J&K and Balochistan.
@prof.bhogalps9965
@prof.bhogalps9965 12 часов назад
There are many facts about Kashmir but the problem is that most Indians and Pakistanis select from amongst these facts as per their conveniences or biased and weave their narratives accordingly.
@bharatschouhan5197
@bharatschouhan5197 22 часа назад
@22:00 Dr. Farooq Quote that tribals always have weapon, in Rajput community we also have weapons but rarely any one have bullets to wage a war, and how tribals with different type of inferior gun without maps , trucks, fuel, food, can fight a war with regular army with logistical support
@Redm.Dealer
@Redm.Dealer 18 часов назад
*Plumber Farooq Sahab* *Please Yaha(Bharat) Me Na Aaye, Humne Already 25Crores Pakistanis Pale Huve He, Hum Hinduo Ko Shanti Se Rehne Do Humare Mulq Me, Pakistan Chale Jaye Aap* *No VISA No Trade, thank youuuu*
@avtarwasson4875
@avtarwasson4875 17 часов назад
Farooq Sahib, in NWFP people and the Bacha Khan did not want to join Pakistan, neither did Balochistan.
@chhindasinghaulakh6815
@chhindasinghaulakh6815 День назад
Shakil Choudhary Sahab Moti Moti Baat Ke Kashmir ko Lekar Dono Hi Country,s Ke Muh Me Pani Aaya Huya Tha, Lekin Kashmiri Or Raja Hari Singh Apni Azad Riyasat Banaye Rakhna Chahate They.Jo Baat Na India Ko pasand Aayi Thi Or Na Hi Pakistan Ko.Jaha Par India Ne Dhairya Se kaam Liya Or Kashmir ko Kuch Time Azadi Me Apna kaam kar Ke Dekh Lene Diya Jaye,ka Faisla Kiya.Ab Aage Aate Pakistan wali Side Kaya Ho Raha Tha, Pakistan Hamesha ki Tarah utabala Tha Kashmir Ko Pakistan Me Merge Karne Ke Liye, Isliye usne Kashmir Me Apni Army Bhejne ka Faisla Kar Liya, Pakistan Ne Attack Kiya Kashmir par lut paat, Rape Je Sab Karna Shuru Kiya, Jisko Dekh kar Raja Hari Singh Bharat ke pass Gaya Ke Hamari Help Karo India, India Ne Kaha ke Agar Kashmir Hamara Hisa Ban Jata Hai Tab Hi Hum Indian Army Ko Aap Ki Help Ke Liye Bhej Sakte Hai, Is Tarah phir Kashmir ka Palamusite instrument sign hua
@asangha182
@asangha182 2 часа назад
Chhinde veer, ik dum sahi farmaya tussin. The sequence of events, as narrated by you is also correct. However, ik gall ni samajh aayi, ehe 'Palamusite' ki hai? Tuhadda matlab 'plebiscite' ta nahin kitay?. Khair, plebiscite ta hoya hi nahi. Jo Maharaja Hari Singh nay sign keeta si, oho Instrument of Accession si, under the Independence of India Act 1947. It was the same document that 560 plus other princely states signed to join the Union of India. Ik hor gall lokan nu nahin pata aam taur tay, khaas kar Pakistanis nu. It is the principle of Partition that people tend to confuse. Pakistan waale samajh de nay ki Muslim majority areas of India will become Pakistan, and vice-versa,depending on contiguity of borders. The fact is a little different. It was the Muslim majority areas of 'British India' that were to become Pakistan, like Punjab and Bengal. J&K was NOT a part of British India, it was a princely state. In fact, Hari Singh headed the Chamber of Princes. Hence, this Muslim majority principle did not apply to J&K. The rulers of princely states had the right to choose between India or Pakistan, and that was the right exercised by Hari Singh in joining India. This right too was stressed on by Jinnah, because he had his eye on Bhopal, Hyderabad, Junagadh, etc.,which were states with Muslim rulers but a Hindu majority.
@SanjayGupta-jk7hl
@SanjayGupta-jk7hl День назад
Shakil sir🎉 Thanks a lot🙏 for a best program.......
@ShakilChaudhary
@ShakilChaudhary 23 часа назад
Thanks.
@BharatmatakiJai-kj4ip
@BharatmatakiJai-kj4ip 21 час назад
Sir, mein Pakistanis ko kafi salo se sun raha hu..magar yahi Samajh aayi hai ki. 90% Pakistani na tarkshil hai,, apne hi propaganda ko sach mante hai.. Badh bole hai,, mazhabi bimar hai.. Sach suna or manna nahi chahte..dimagi roop se bimar hai... Isiliye Pakistan barbad ho raha hai..?
@anupmabajpai6773
@anupmabajpai6773 23 часа назад
He is giving lame excuse
@dilipdesai8678
@dilipdesai8678 19 часов назад
Dr Farooq not telling truth about kabaili it was army in plain cloth
@asangha182
@asangha182 Час назад
It was a mix of tribals and army, wasn't just army in plain clothes. The army armed the tribals and provided logistics and arms.
@dilipdesai8678
@dilipdesai8678 19 часов назад
he is diverting real subject i mean Dr Farooq
@ramsharma3704
@ramsharma3704 14 часов назад
After atrocities in Baramullah, very few people to be found. Dr Adil, says it wasn’t brutality, but it was islamiyat, according to Koran, take what ever you can , what ever your right hand possesses. Battle of Badar, battle of Quraish, where all Jews were robbed/killed.All Jewish women were raped/ kidnapped/ enslaved londiyas
@SubhashYadav-tf5sh
@SubhashYadav-tf5sh День назад
I FOLLOW DR AFZAL A U TUBER FROM PAKISTAN VERY GOOD DOCTOR
@Kabir00784
@Kabir00784 День назад
Shakil sir I want interact with you
@ShakilChaudhary
@ShakilChaudhary 23 часа назад
Please send me your message at shakil.chaudhary@gmail.com at your convenience.
@SomnathDe-h7d
@SomnathDe-h7d 21 час назад
Watching from India।
@asangha182
@asangha182 Час назад
The principle of Partition was that Muslim majority areas of 'British India' would become Pakistan, and vice-versa, depending on factors like contiguity of borders etc.,for example Punjab and Bengal. Riyaasat J&K was NOT part of British India, but a princely state, whose rulers had the right to choose between Ind or Pak. Maharaja Hari Singh was Chairman of the Chamber of Princes at one time. Pakistanis claim J&K on the simple basis that it is Muslim majority area. The principle did not apply to J&K as it was a princely state. Pakistan themselves, particularly Jinnah, stressed on the right of the rulers of princely states to choose, because they had an eye on states like Bhopal, Junagadh, Hyderabad, etc, states with Muslim rulers and Hindu majority. Farooq sahib wants to have the cake and eat it too. If the rulers of princely states had the right to choose, as was Pakistan's stated position, then why should the 'people' of J&K be any different and be given the right. Apni convenience ke hisaab se position le lete hain Farooq sahib. He's denying the presence of army regulars in the October 1947 invasion, when Maj Gen Akbar Khan has written a book (which he very conveniently hasn't read in spite of having it). He attributes the arming of the tribals to the area having arms, rather than the army facilitating them. The Rawalpindi armoury was opened to them. Please read Akbar Khan's book first, then make statements denying the participation of the Pak Army.
@teamxgstarboy7432
@teamxgstarboy7432 День назад
🔥
@sanjaysingh1997
@sanjaysingh1997 День назад
I have never seen as good as you correspondence. You are great man of pak
@ShakilChaudhary
@ShakilChaudhary 23 часа назад
Thanks.
@arya.bharat
@arya.bharat 5 часов назад
Informative & Valuable show ❤️ Thank you Shakil sir 🙏
@gyaneshwershukla6207
@gyaneshwershukla6207 21 час назад
Raja Narendra Singh of Sarila, then ADC of Lord Mountbatten had written a book and given his account as witness of the happenings. He later became a diplomat. Information given about Ch. Khaliquzzaman is incorrect. He and his brother Dr. Saiduzzaman, born and belong to Meerzapur. Khaliquzzaman, initially was ADC of Mahmudabad. 😮😮
@azeem_lahori-punjabi
@azeem_lahori-punjabi 6 часов назад
"Selective history is not history, it's an ideology."!
@sushilhandu4425
@sushilhandu4425 20 часов назад
Plz tell me how 5lac people were killed by whom perhaps Mahraja army(people killed were Kashmiri) then your leads are false.
@gopalh9455
@gopalh9455 22 часа назад
When Mr Nehru accepted for the plebiscite, then why did not go for it ? You were sure of your wish materialising as it was Muslim majority
@ratnakamal1
@ratnakamal1 12 часов назад
Chaudhry Saab, what’s the point of rehashing history in which there is nothing to learn for the present or future?
@Harishkryadav1
@Harishkryadav1 22 часа назад
namaste assalamualaikum shakil sir 🙏
@attorneyumarghazalli
@attorneyumarghazalli 21 час назад
Undercover agents do not enjoy ordinary rights. It's absolutely fine to be rude to them.
@RaviYadav-bu2pg
@RaviYadav-bu2pg 23 часа назад
Yes Sir, this is what I was asking. We should have people from different viewpoints so that we hear both sides.
@mahajanratnakar1809
@mahajanratnakar1809 День назад
Shakil sahab kya wohi ghise pite subjects le ke aate ho??.. There are more happenings in the world specially in Islamic world... Aapne hame bahut kuch sikha diya bata diya.... Wohi munir ke sher and all that....pls come out all that....
@ShakilChaudhary
@ShakilChaudhary 23 часа назад
They say in English that good things bear repeating. I think nobody recited Munir Niazi's couplet in this show. Please make some suggestions. What issue should be discussed in this show?
@mahajanratnakar1809
@mahajanratnakar1809 23 часа назад
@@ShakilChaudhary how long?? It's 78 already goan !!!
@pradyumnanayak9844
@pradyumnanayak9844 12 часов назад
🙏
@dilipdesai8678
@dilipdesai8678 19 часов назад
he is trying make you fool Shakil saheb you know truth
@teamxgstarboy7432
@teamxgstarboy7432 День назад
@RHRHVL
@RHRHVL День назад
This is a reasonable discussion not shrill propaganda interlocutors. While the POV & some of the detailed facts by both sides seem fuzzy it was put in on the table without rancor. Dr. Chaudhary while you gracefully describe Mr.Noorani credibility many dissenters in Pakistan will not agree with your opinion - because subjective opinion in more valid than facts.
@ShakilChaudhary
@ShakilChaudhary 23 часа назад
It is perfectly all right if many Pakistani dissenters don't agree with me. They are entitled to their opinions.
@devendrasinghdalal2900
@devendrasinghdalal2900 18 часов назад
Itani gappain aaj tak nahin suni ya padhi thee. Please read General Akbar Khan's book, 'The Raiers of Kashmir'. Wastage of time.
@rls9292
@rls9292 7 часов назад
Shakeel sahib namaskar plz current topics per bhi baat karain. Llove
@dilipdesai8678
@dilipdesai8678 19 часов назад
i think Dr Farooq not read UN resolution
@VenuGopal-hk8fe
@VenuGopal-hk8fe 2 часа назад
Shakil Saab, could you please request Dr Farooq to mention the kitchen medicines names in English which I hope would be helpful to many of the viewers, me particularly. Thank you.
@asangha182
@asangha182 Час назад
Venu Sir, the methi seeds are known as fenugreek seeds (trigonella foenum-graecum), kalonji is nigella seeds. Kaala chana is Bengali gram or brown chickpeas. I have tried this combination for a couple of months after watching Dr Goel's video clip, but for some reason it didn't work for me. Good for Farooq sahib that it did.
@ramsharma3704
@ramsharma3704 14 часов назад
Hazrat Bibi Khatija /40years old/was very smart big business woman. Bibi Khatija used to to travel for long distances for trading, while prophet was not able to support himself/25years old.
@chaubeyashok9261
@chaubeyashok9261 16 часов назад
Totally fact se hat kar bat kar rahe hai Pakistanis Bakwas
Далее
Is Pakistan Giving Gwadar to China?
26:16
Просмотров 65 тыс.
Шоколадная девочка
00:23
Просмотров 360 тыс.
ТАРАКАН
00:38
Просмотров 1,3 млн
Why Did Iqbal Condemn Arabian Imperialism?
32:30