Mr Shabir, regardless whether what you argue is right or wrong, I really respect you because you're a daring person, and acts very gentlemanly when you engage into debates with the Christian apologists. You don't curse, raise your voice or act like half baked self proclaimed thugs and imams/apologists like Hijab, Daawah or Zakir Naik. I'm not a Muslim but my hats off to you. I wish and pray that you continue to be blessed with more wisdom, sustenance and excellent health. Amen.
Mina Krupinski The Point Is comes or comes not from God ! We speak about God this is for all human and mankind from interesting 🧐 !!! But believing is a personal thing ! Nobody force you to believe in God, or in Islam ! The free will later comes the consequences for the free will !
It's a matter of intelligence, if you believe stars are missiles that are pointed to earth ready to shoot down in the presence of evil , and also believe in flying horses ,well you are the type of guillible person who will have an inclination to believe any Folklore .
Well that’s what the Quran says: Whoever wants to believe let him believe whoever wants let him not believe. But it also says not believing will send you to hell.
Peter Keller The book is the Proofs self ! Many prophecy’s that comes true ! Embryology ❗️ Expanding universe / that all was before one ❗️ The round Earth 🌍 ( the Bible say is flat ) ! The steel and metal comes from out of earth ❗️🗡🚗🚎🛵🚐🚚✈️🚊🚅🚄 Every time I read the Koran I become a Muslim 💯❗️
@@rabiadar8518 The Quran was written down from over 100 years (745) after Muhammed experienced (the stories) to about 923. Those who wrote this have never seen him or anyone that lived with him. Most was also written down far from where he lived. There is 0% chance that this in any way can be accurate words from Muhammad. There is no logic, scientific or historical reasoning to claim this. The writers of the final product where 9th century biographers. Where did they got their texts from? What are the sources and can they be trusted? The answer is obvious. This is the true controversy about Islam. Most muslims will not talk about this. Most muslims are not lectured in this at all.
It was not written down by his followers. Thats the main problem with Islam. There are more than enough proof that the written text was written from 745 to 923. And what they decide to write has been "carried" from mouth to mouth multiple times and over large distances. there is 0 logic in claiming that this is the word of Muhammad. The muslim Scholars are trying to ignore this or are directly trying to falsify it. The Christianity has a somewhat similar problem, but in a much lesser degree, I am thinking about the written texts made by Constatine and his clerks/priests who wrote the start of the bible as a final collection. There are historical proof that a lot got left out, wich means it is not really complete and may have fitted an agenda. You might claim his intentions where good, but if you change something that are supposed to be holy you also corrupt it. There is no way around that fact. That even more so goes for Quran and any Islam text. Also regarding Islam it is a interesting fun fact that the word Muslim did not exist in any Arab text before 691. There is not a single reference to Mecca before 741. We are not then talking about the text that make up Islam, but all Arab text. Problematic? Very much so! Muhammad is supposed to have his Meccan revelations from 610-622. so everything they base Islam on is a latter fabrication that started almost 200 years later and evolved over another hundred years.
First off, there aren't that many scientific errors, only a couple of hundred. Well there are historical and cultural errors too, but we will ignore them since you didn't bring them up. Besides, how can allah be expected to know everything? Certainly you can't expect him to be right all the time. It's amazing people hold deities to such a high standard.
He did not fabricate Qur'an/Islam for personal gain as he suffered and lost so much in the Meccan period of persecution, and he clearly didn't do it for "moral reform" since his preaching against the idols and call for their abolition was obviously way way more provocative and offensive to the pre-Islamic Arabs than just asking them to "reform".
Based on the comments , nice to see a lot of curious non Muslims checking this channel out . Now please actually watch and listen to the video before you place judgement . It’s obvious some of you have not actually viewed it and just jumped to the posts !! 😊
To believe that the Prophet died illiterate is to accuse him of ignoring the very first revelation.... Read! Also Ummi means a gentile in every context in the Quran.
I really dont know why people opposed to prophet Muhammad (SAW) continue to even waste our time arguing when there is a whole surah al Kafirun 109 which tells them clearly not to follow him "Say; O disbelievers, I do not worship what you worship. Nor will I be a worshiper of what you worship. Nor will you be worshippers of what I worship. For you is your religion, and for me is my religion."
1 This know also, that in the last days perilous times shall come. 2 For men shall be lovers of their own selves, covetous, boasters, proud, blasphemers, disobedient to parents, unthankful, unholy, 3 without natural affection, trucebreakers, false accusers, incontinent, fierce, despisers of those that are good, 4 traitors, heady, highminded, lovers of pleasures more than lovers of God; -BIBLE
then why did he himself make zero effort to have it written down? or even instruct anybody to preserve it? no it was a couple hundred years later that they decided to gather up whatever writings remained into a book and then that itself was re-written to be more cohesive. ....no effort to preserve the word of God?
What r u talking about. Judaism and Christianity all stemmed from the worship of Allah. Its not a new religion. We believe the jews have earned the hate of god for there pride and unjust corruption and the christians have gone astray from the worship of god. Islam was brought to establish the law again that was corrupted to a people we were closest to the jews so the covenant would be fulfilled, the brother of isaac ishmaels bloodline. Im not sure what pagan stories u r talking about.
Dr. Shabir Allay, is it not possible that Quran was written by Jewish writer with pseudonym "Allah" to confuse people about Jesus Christ with a new character of Muhammad and his Allah of love for Muhammad??
@@beefalot334 the Quran is fear-mongering. If you question it you die, if you leave you die, if you criticise it you die. Christianity is the religion of freedom and love. This is why Christ says the truth will set you free
In Yemen a copy of Quran written by Hazrat Ali (AS) was found during excavation of an old mosque and was compared by the experts with the existing Quran which was exactly the same. This report was published in many leading news papers in 1985. It should be noted that Hazrat Ali (AS) was sent to Yemen in 10 Hijra as a missionary in the life time of the Prophet (SW). Allah says in Quran: Surely We have revealed the Reminder and We will most surely be its guardian (Surah Hajir Verse-9).
@kaizen hkt Quran 31:34 "Indeed, Allah [alone] has knowledge of the Hour and sends down the rain and knows what is in the wombs.1 And no soul perceives what it will earn tomorrow, and no soul perceives in what land it will die. Indeed, Allah is Knowing and Aware. Saheeh International" Allah doesnt know what ultrasound is? XDDDDDD
he kept persisting because he wanted to wage jihad, and gain 20 percent of war booty. even when he was in mecca the quran mentions people fighting in the cause of allah… yet this was when he was a merchant of peace? makes no sense
Definitely you don't know H of History. Our beloved prophet Mohammed PBUH lived in a house 6/12 house, he slept hungry most of the times, he worn normal clothing though he can effort like a king, his wife's Peace be upon them had not lightened the kitchen for 4 days a week sometimes, he never had a fancy ride though he can effort in tons and when after he died their were handful of gold coins. He left no wealth, no palaces, no fancy things. He left Qur'an and his sunnah for us. Know the proper meaning of Jihad! I can give the answer rightaway but don't want to spoonfeed you cause Qur'an teaches Muslim to call the other religion for reasoning.
He stayed in mecca for 13 years. 13 YEARS! he was tortured mentally and physically. he bore all of this to get 20% of war booty? :/ wars that started after 13 years??? (there was no war held in meeca) Wars started after he migrated to madina (after 13 years approx)
In the first 13 and even 15 years of his prophet hood he did not know whether he or his companions would survive the next week and in many cases the next day so please read and educate yourself before writing comments.
I revealed Myself to those who did not ask for Me; I was found by those who did not seek Me. To a nation that did not call on My 'Shúam' (Name), I said, 'Here am I, here am I.' - YaoshuaYÁOHU (Isaiah) 65:1.
Were paul,mark,luke,john and matthew sinless? ;) The bible doesn't come from jesus,it comes from unknown authors(who according to christians are all supposed to be sinners).So go with your logic to someone else.Before you come with a verse from the Quran to say muhammad(pbuh) sinned,the verse about forgiveness is not for sins,but for shortcomings(which all prophets had).
Who exactly would describe the earth as spread out flat like a carpet and the sun sets into a pool of murky water? A god or an ignorant 7th century Arabian who thinks that the Earth is flat? Hm...
@Sufiyan Op enjoy. Pickthall: Till, when he reached the setting-place of the sun, he found it setting in a muddy spring, and found a people thereabout. We said: O Dhu'l-Qarneyn! Either punish or show them kindness. Yusuf Ali: Until, when he reached the setting of the sun, he found it set in a spring of murky water: Near it he found a People: We said: "O Zul-qarnain! (thou hast authority,) either to punish them, or to treat them with kindness." Shakir: Until when he reached the place where the sun set, he found it going down into a black sea, and found by it a people. We said: O Zulqarnain! either give them a chastisement or do them a benefit. Muhammad Sarwar: to the West where he found the sun setting into a warm source (spring) of water and a people living near by. We asked him, "Dhu 'l-Qarnayn, you may punish them or treat them with kindness?" Mohsin Khan: Until, when he reached the setting place of the sun, he found it setting in a spring of black muddy (or hot) water. And he found near it a people. We (Allah) said (by inspiration): "O Dhul-Qarnain! Either you punish them, or treat them with kindness." Arberry: until, when he reached the setting of the sun, he found it setting in a muddy spring, and he found nearby a people. We said, 'O Dhool Karnain, either thou shalt chastise them, or thou shalt take towards them a way of kindness.'
@@user-mh3ps4ld8k not according to your prophet. Narrated Abu Dharr: I was sitting behind the Messenger of Allah (ﷺ) who was riding a donkey while the sun was setting. He asked: Do you know where this sets ? I replied: Allah and his Apostle know best. He said: It sets in a spring of warm water (Hamiyah).
Muhamad is not the author of the holy quran this is a revealation from god through Jebrel author mean you research and provide books snd write the books but Quran is not s product of reseach it is revealation and memorise by Prophet Mohamad
Can someone explain to me why when praying we say may ALLAH bestow prays to Mohammed as you bestowed pray on Abraham and his people . As the CREATOR receives prays not bestows prays.
Kobina Jamieson That is true for all religions! We all seek the true and only way to God.But the holy books of the main religions-seem to set us against each other.
Kobina Jamieson That is true for all religions! We all seek the true and only way to God.But the holy books of the main religions-seem to set us against each other.
His answer would also suggest the Mormons and Jehovah witness are a true religion for they also claim to have been inspired by God, and also Joseph Smith the former prophet and founder of mormonism went through a great deal of trail and tribulations, but yet Joseph smith continued his work to establish the Mormon religion,. Also he created the Book of Mormon which is just as creative as the quran. Its also true to say there are many other religions who claim to have been inspired by God. Mormons also claim to have prophets today. Why shouldn't we believe in the Mormon former prophet Joseph Smith and their prophets of today.
It is not the word of God and was written by men other than muhammad. At one stage muhammad even forgot verses of the Quran, how could a prophet forget the word of God? There are various mistakes and verses in the Quran and Hadiths, some are removed or certain shieks or imams say are cancelled or untrustworthy, what's that all about? If Allah has the supreme intelligence to create this world and everything in it, how would he make errors or mistakes? Say one thing then take it back? Or even the men he gave these messages to, to be allowed to make such errors? I'm sorry no matter how we try to sugar coat things and make excuses for these things, if you are honest and apply logic , it just doesn't work!
@Sufiyan Op yes in His own words, “John 13:13 KJV [13] Ye call me Master and Lord: and ye say well; for so I am.” This is one of many verses that prove Jesus Christ is God Almighty! I challenge you to read the New Testament bible verses yourself, I dare you...you will see the Light!
The prophet, pbuh, was a persecuted one, he grew up poor and living under threats. Then god reveals the Quran to Him and all of a sudden he ended up having wives, slaves and being rich. What a wise man. !!!Started from the button now I am here!!!!!
Rayap 123 that’s not really a strong argument bro. Even Christians believe there were over 1500+ years between prophet Moses peace be upon him and Jesus peace be upon him.
The Quran was written down from over 100 years (745) after Muhammed experienced (the stories) to about 923. Those who wrote this have never seen him or anyone that lived with him. Most was also written down far from where he lived. There is 0% chance that this in any way can be accurate words from Muhammad. There is no logic, scientific or historical reasoning to claim this. This is the true controversy about Islam. Most muslims will not talk about this. Most muslims are not lectured in this at all.
If Jesus did not die, resurrect and then seen by His disciples why would then 11 of 12 disciples were executed, crucified, peter upside down preaching that Christ had risen, this man gave no answer, muslims claim Koran is word of God, they say men wrote the gospel, yet its clear men put pen to paper to write the Koran, cmon muslims, your prophet swore by the Torah that he believed all that was in there and who sent it, thereby believing in the Torah , and actually converting to Judaism technically, he wasnt aware he was doing this, OT prophets and Jesus performed miracles, Mohammed none, he was no true prophet, be objective with your belief, i hope all muslims come to truth, love you all
TheOnlyOneKing Elvis i have done it multiple times but i didn't find one.. the verses are presented in a such a twisting way to decieve people and to convince u that there is mistake in quran ... there is no mistakes in quran...!!!
And the proof is that the quran says so. You can't find any mistake, because your eyes and mind are closed and you don't want to question something you were made to believe was the only truth - that is how this lie spreads out. You, muslims, are all prisoners of islam, a prison of mind forbids you to see that it is the worst prison of all.
AGHA SAHIB ------------ HOLY PROPHET SAID I HAVE LEFT TWO THINGS AMONGST YOU ONE IS THE BOOK OF ALLAH AND OTHER IS THE MY AHLE BAIT----- SAHIH MUSLIM 6225/ WHAT DOES THE MEANINGS OF THE BOOK OF ALLAH?
And the Jewish people made the Christianity if the Jewish people doesn't made Cristus put him on cross doesn't make him guilty we don't have church on the world
Allah is the perfect creator. There can be no reason to circumcise your son since he has been created in the image of Allah. Do not let them cut your child's genitalia. Let them experience love as Allah intended. Peace out.
@@sultanahamed2484 Hair is dead tissue. So are fingernails and toe nails. When you cut them, they grow back. The foreskin is not just a flap of skin, it is a lip. It has an inner surface and outer surface. It is packed with blood vessels and nerve endings and once cut off, will never grow back. Why do I have to convince Muslims to trust in God's design? Don't you have faith in Allah?
I claim that Muhammad wrote the quran, for the gains of fame and fortune. For an example, he fabricated the story from the bible that claims of jesus' divinity and leaves one question unanswered. Who is the father of jesus if jesus is born male? Now the reason that question is still unanswered is that either that muhammad would accept the claim of jesus' divinity or he wouldnt be a prophet that he wanted to be in order to decieve many people. Muhammad wrote the quran so he could attain his status as a true prophet and not know the other prophets before him. And he claimed all of them were muslim. How can one believe this lie and not accept the truth of jesus' divinity? The answer is that muslims claim that it came from god and how is that possible. Well, you have one answer and one answer only muhammad wrote in allah as his alter ego. To be fair, allah is the pagan god of his mother's who he'd worshipped, if muhammad worshipped yahweh the biblical god, then muhammad would have been the true prophet. The debate for who wrote the quran is over. The bible had been written by jesus' followers and the quran was written by muhammad. Case closed!
IM A EX KATHOLIK KNOWING GOOD THE BIBLE AND MOHAMED GOT MANY SIMILARITIS WITH BIBLICAL PROFETS LIKKE SAMUEL 2 JEREMIA . .. DANIEL AND THE MEETING OF ARCHANGEL GABRIEL NR 10 CHAPTER I FORGOT ........ AND SOOOO ON ............
You may want to review your sources because the quran, the hadith, and prophet Muhammad himself have absolutely, without a doubt, given all praise and glory to Allah(arabic for God) and recognized Muhammad as his last and final messenger to mankind, nothing more. Muhammad is a very important figure in Islam and Muslims give respect to Muhammad and try to replicate his actions(known as sunnah) as he is recognized to be a mercy to mankind. However, every knowledgeable Muslim knows, when we pray and test to the truth, it is Allah, who we believe to be the ultimate ruler and creator.
@@mohamedhelalonline ...an observation not source but rather the human (persons) practising Islam as a collective, as for Allah being the same God as Yahweh seems a far fetched claim.
It is the same God. Allah is just arabic for God, like i said. It the same one God that Abraham, Moses, Jesus, and Muhammad called people to worship. And Allah is the center of Islam. The prophets and associates of the prophets are also very important as they are the people who received the revelation and passed it down to us. But still, all worship is to Allah.
I guarantee if God sent Prophets 1000 plus years ago they would be laughed at and nobody would believe them. If you think about it, if someone said Earth was round like a ball orbiting the sun which has 8 other planets orbiting it which 4 are bigger than Earth and 4 smaller and the Sun is one out of 100 billion sun's all with planets bigger and smaller than Earth each Trillions of miles away which is forms a Galsky that is just 1 out of 100 billion.
“You claim that the evidentiary miracle is present and available, namely, the Koran. You say: 'Whoever denies it, let him produce a similar one.' Indeed, we shall produce a thousand similar, from the works of rhetoricians, eloquent speakers and valiant poets, which are more appropriately phrased and state the issues more succinctly. They convey the meaning better and their rhymed prose is in better meter. … By God what you say astonishes us! You are talking about a work which recounts ancient myths, and which at the same time is full of contradictions and does not contain any useful information or explanation. Then you say: 'Produce something like it'” Muhammad ibn Zakariya al-Razi
Hai , You trying to make it seem koran is the word of good , the only thing u were trying to convince is that mohamed believed it i steh word of god .. but Mohammed believing its does not make it the word of the god . why dint u ask him that qstion
you cant explain what muslims learn and understand in 10 minutes! Allah gives us deep understanding and layered wisdom! we are extremely firm in our knowledge of this world and what it is about!
The time when the holy books were written embraced the idea that the past was always better. The Greeks looked up to the (imaginary) heroes of Troy, Jesus to the prophets, the Chinese to the anscestors. The holy books transplant this idea in our time, like a time capsule - a time when we value progress, innovation, the young and new. Why hold yourself back in a world made of and by science? By the time you convinced yourself that you understand the inconsistencies of this or that holy book, with the energy you needed to react to your critics, to disprove factual data and get yourself refuted back to square one... by that time you could have learned how to build a computer, cured a desease, achieved a great leap in human knowledge. I mean why bother, guys? Was it worth it??
There have always been and still are muslims contributing to science. It is actually one of the duties of a muslim to learn and innovate. But the thing is, while doing that, we also think about the life after death, so we do it in the first line for Allah, and in the second line for mankind, which indirectly leads to Allah again. :) The problems you see might be among some muslim person, but you should know that islam includes all of what you say. Read it :) have a nice day
@@UltimatePiccolo Then why does he need your prayers for?? Then how would your God know your feelings, your weakness?? Again which was written first?? Who wrote what?? Who is the explanation not the source??? Ask your self, why something needs so much translation and explanation when was supposed to be spread by recitation.??
I have questions to Christians 1. Why do you hate Pontius Pilate and Judas Iscariot? Did'nt they help Jesus to do what he meant to do? To sacrify himself for your sins? You owe them a gratitude 2. Why Jesus waited to Roman military and Judas Iscariot to do crucify. Didn't Jesus had 12 disciples that he could ask to build his own cross? 3. If Jesus was not crucified and not resurracted, will you worship him as God? 4. Why do you use the Cross as symbol of christianity? Was'nt the cross was used by Pontius Pilate to hang and tortured Jesus to death 5. Why do you potrays Jesus in his human state to worship him as God. A mortal human being. He is potrayed in many churches as bleeding corpse hang in cross looks weak and very dead. In other church is potrays only the cross without statue. In my imagine you should potrays Jesus in his divine state, instead. My best imagination is that: Jesus stand on the cross. His two feets step on the top of the cross. His body covers by blood having some scratches of tortured and a lot of wound. His clothes wet by his own blood, but he stands strong, his face is shiny, his eyes is open a little bit with sorrow but confident. Three or four feet behind him there is a pair of wing belong to unseen creature. The wing do not belong to Jesus because he is God, he doesn't need it to fly. It is belong to Gabriel. Gabriel was there because he was asked by God to accompany Jesus flying back to heaven where he belong to. The blood covering Jesus's body symbolizes that Jesus already complete his mission. He had died once for your sin. Then he is ready to coming back to his father. What do you say? Isn't the picture in my imagination more beautiful to worship?
Absolutely not!!!! His followers after his death along with about a hundred others all putting their own views and interpretations of what the believed; most definitely not inspired by God.
@Diane Winchester That's what you have been blindly taught, but Christianity is growing all over the world. And according to the Holy Scriptures many will be following false religions and false prophets, Islam being the most violent and deceptive of all of them. Muslims are eternally doomed without Jesus Christ as their Lord and Savior. Choose Jesus choose life.
There are a lot of proven evidences that the Quran is not the word of God and neither is a religion from God research yourself May Allah guide you to the truth inshalla
There are errors in the Koran. Try 18:86. That states that the Sun sets in a muddy pool or spring in the West. Clearly an error thus proving the Koran are not the word of God, but simply a man.
Cassandra Britannia , I know that Verse und there is explation for that too but what are saying is what David wood said but you don't want to hear both sides but only one side ,if you want to truth then you have to listen both sides.
I am listening to both sides. David Wood is not my source, although I know that he uses it. So does the Apostate Prophet,an ex-Muslim giving many reasons to show why the Koran is false. The Apostate Prophet is very good and worth looking at on RU-vid No, my source was the Prophet of Doom, by Craig Winn. It is available as a free download, both as a PDF or audio. He looked at the life of Mohammed historically, and the revelations. They generally made a good match. Events in his life miraculously becoming revelations. Therefore he simply made it up as he went along. So what is your explanation of the Sun setting in the muddy pool? Please don't say "it looked like it" because all the official translations don't imply that. The Sahih version has the translators personal insertion [as if] but the proves it was not there. Check in quran.com
Cassandra Britannia It seems for Dhul-qarnyn that sun is setting in murky pool. Allah is telling us a scene what dhul qarnain had saw.If a person among ourselves stands at the shore (sea-side) at sun set, he will see the sun as if it is falling into the sea, or setting into the sea. Therefore, what is meant by the verse “he found the sun setting in a muddy water” means when someone looks at it, that is what he/she would think and see.(he found ,means he saw and he was a human like us and I love to b at beach at evening because sunsets Scene ist a beautiful and when we say that sunsets Scene thats not mean that sun sets 🤔
