As small youtuber that also does history videos, and a lot of them has to do with the middle east, I am glad that you make these sorts of videos 👍 Keep spreading knowledge.
his channel become bias against islam n muslim...he called to himself muslim wahabhi bt actually pleasing christian fr views ..plz report this channel n unsubscribe n I tolerated his biasness fr long time bt he is continuously spread wrng message of Islam n covering crusader bad act to get support from Christian n nonmuslim n he think Christian islamophobic source more important than muslim source
America has 33000 museums and you go on about the British museums and it only has 2500 and that's between 4 countries 🤔🤔 even Canada 7500 or South America is same 7500.even Germany and France have over 7000 each 🤔🤔 to me its got more chance of ending in one of these museums??🤔 quite interesting all the countries or even any empire in history used the same tactics prize money or spoils of war 👍 if you had a war with anyone and you lost you got looted and the prizes would be sold to be split between the combatants was very Common. military equipment would be taken.ships would be seized. Camps and forts.palaces would all be looted for prize money 💰 then what would happen is the government's would put the stuff up for public auction.thats actually when these museums get involved and all stuff ended up in museums or in antique galleries👍 the practice only got stopped in 1920s by law I was actually surprised when I found out about it myself 🤔👍
It also seems possible that Reynald originally intended an attack upon the holy cities but those he sent to the task got distracted by more lucrative targets and blown off course.
@@Lucifer-do5ed whats up with your name kid?Did you molded your name into it?i dont remember anyone saying in the bible to name their children as devils.if you're a satan worshipper your existence is to mold truth into fake,so be gone.
According to Ibn Jubayr, it was stated that Reynald attempted to steal the body of the Prophet (PBUH) (Wa Allahu Allam). However, Ibn al-Athir and al-Dhahabi concentrated on Reynald's attack on Hijaz without mentioning this particular incident. Reynald's assault on Medina led Saladin to vow that he would kill him if he ever captured him, and this oath was reinforced when Reynald attacked the caravan. Nevertheless, the Muslim chroniclers of that era were united in their view that Reynald was the most despicable among the Crusaders. Quite ironically, if you don't mind us saying, we have just released a video on Reynald intended as a two part series: ru-vid.com/video/%D0%B2%D0%B8%D0%B4%D0%B5%D0%BE-4ZjyYMu4Nqg.html
his channel become bias against islam n muslim...he called to himself muslim wahabhi bt actually pleasing christian fr views ..plz report this channel n unsubscribe n I tolerated his biasness fr long time bt he is continuously spread wrng message of Islam n covering crusader bad act to get support from Christian n nonmuslim n he think Christian islamophobic source more important than muslim source
AbuTahir Al-Jannabi destroyed kabba and took black stone which he used it in his toilet for 21 years to pee & poo on it to challenge allah and he succeed.
I’m a Scottish Christian and I love your channel so interesting and well put together keep up the good work my friend look forward to watching many more 🏴
Before this amazing video starts I'm guessing you'll probably mention Raynaud de Chatillon as he tried to destroy the kabaah but was brutally defeated by the ayubbid navy.
I'm only a teenager, but Arabic, Islamic, and especially Medieval Islam and Islamic jurisprudence fascinates me especially. But, since my age, and also lack of money therefrom, I cannot buy or acquire many resources on such topics ... would you have any recommendations on books, essays, or other forms of media to get started in any of such topics? Which would be best to start with? I do not know much Arabic, either, should I begin with a basic study of Arabic? Would the Hans-Wehr dictionary be useful for someone with no prior knowledge to the language, or should such a buy be reserved for later in study? I do not shy away from books or resources with academic and or pompous language either.
If you want to learn jurisprudence then it's better if you learn it under a scholar of islam or in madarasa, there you would have proper guidance because the books of jurisprudence aren't easy read and need a teacher.
"A European force hadn't entered the sea since 24 BCE" seems wrong considering there's a Roman inscription dating to 144 CE on the Farasan Islands which attests to a military garrison there.
@@masazis923 Google keeps deleting it when I try to tell you because of the no links rule I guess. Anyway you should be able to find reference to it under the title “Ausserhalb des Reiches? Zu neuen römischen Inschriften aus Saudi Arabien und zur Ausdehnung der römischen Herrschaft am Roten Meer” The oldest source I am aware of that mentions it is the *Proceedings of the Seminar of Arabian Studies* (2004). It seems to have been widely reported in around 2017 after a blog post mentioned the German article.
@@masazis923 In the 1st century AD, the islands were known as Portus Ferresanus. A Latin inscription dating from 144 AD has been found on the island which attests to the construction of a Roman garrison. It is believed that the islands may have been attached to the province of Arabia Felix, before being transferred to Aegyptus some time before 144 AD.[3] If this is correct, it would make the Farasan Islands the farthest Roman outpost, being nearly 4000 km from Rome itself. en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Farasan_Islands
m.ru-vid.com/video/%D0%B2%D0%B8%D0%B4%D0%B5%D0%BE-Ry8K4sK3uDc.html&pp=ygUbbXVzbGltIGNvbnZlcnQgdG8gY2hyaXN0aWFu Unfortunately you venerate a liar who didn’t even know what he was worshipping. May the Lord have mercy on you
I remember reading about Raynaud and his ability to plan long term was limited, to put it mildly, so the idea that he planned a raid but hadn't thought out the potential consequences seems in character.
A guy name Raynald of Châtillon had some sort of same intentions when salahudin ayyubi ( saladin) took the oath to kill him with his own hand. When Muslims defeated the crusaders in the battle of hattin and the king of Jerusalem and Reynold were taken as prisoners of war saladin offered a glass of water with ice to the king and the blow of his blade onto Reynolds neck. He was true to his word.
@AlMuqaddimahYT Just a reminder to say "peace be upon him" every time you mention the prophet in this video or any others. Assuming you are a muslim, I thought you would be aware of it but anyways. Peace!
@@chendaforestwhy? how would that change the content in any way, shape, or form? as well as this, this isn’t an academic paper, but a youtube video; he’s not bound by any institution
@@unhingedconnoisseur164 he's seeking to make an academic video, and one should firewall as far as possible between ones personal beliefs and the academic study of religion. Markers of belief would in my view distract from that objective.
doesn't that make all the more sense that civilization started somewhere in the middle east? Could Adam have died somewhere near Mecca? He could have played a part in the building of the Kaaba
@@xunqianbaidu6917 That doesn't mean we popped out of the earth like plants... It's more rational to believe we as a species started from a single community and branched out from the earliest settlement, somewhere in the middle east. Maybe it was egypt, maybe it was Babylon(Iraq) who knows?
@@xunqianbaidu6917 eh, that's quite a huge leap from where we started, Babylon and the pyramids in Egypt are much older than that, and it is pretty important from a religious context.
@@xunqianbaidu6917 no, slightly older than Egypt and the other settlements you mentioned. The Qur'an mentioned about humanity being a single community, I thought the verse might have been talking about Babylons or the Sumerians. Maybe an even older unrecorded civilization
Fantastic video keep it up you're doing amazing things also I was talking about this with my mum early today and you made a video about it may Allah guide all of us to the right path ameen 🙏
Subhan 'Allah Alhumdulilah Wa li ilahaillilah Wa Allah O Akbar ☝️♥️ Peace and blessings of Allah Swt be upon all the prophets messengers and the companions RA and the Muslim Ummah Ameen yah rabbil Aalameen ♥️☝️
Awesome video! The shenanigans of Reynald sound rageful, cartoonish and tragic, all at once. I must point out that there were was a permanent Western presence on the Red Sea during the Roman Empire, mostly for trading purposes. The outpost of Portus Ferranus served as the furthest point of the Empire's reach, in the Farasan island (name derived from Roman times), in front of the Arabian city of Jazan. Recent archaeological evidence suggests that it was occupied during the times of Antoninus Pius (138-161 AD). Also, the Egyptian seaport of Berenice (250 kms east of Aswan) was founded in the 3rd century BC, later controlled by the Romans until the 4th century AD and abandoned on the 6th century AD. Thanks for your insightful videos!
We are familiar with another version of trying to steel the body. It talks about two Christians claiming to be Moroccans dug a tunnel from their accomidation in Madinah near the mosque toward the prophet tomb during Zinky time.
Salah-ud-deen finally gave this raynald guy what he deserved . The only regret I have is why he didn't he gave him excruciating pain for creating corruption in the land of the prophets between Muslims and Christians .
Reynald totally deserved it after everything he did. Speaking of Egypt and Syria, why didn't the Abbasid Caliphs seize authority back from the Mamluk Sultans and ruled Egypt and Syria themselves? I even heard that there was even one time that the Abbasid Caliph has to step up and govern Egypt and Syria himself. But then, he handed the authority back to the Mamluks. The point is that if the Abbasid Caliphate is restored in Egypt and Syria, will Sultan Selim I dared to annex Egypt and Syria?
The Mameluke were of Turkic origin, and therefore their martial skills were superior to the Arabs, just like the Germanic people are superior to the Latins. It’s not an accident the Christian West was ruled by Germanic peoples, Franks, Anglo-Saxons, Visigoths, Normans and Vikings while Islam was taken over by Turks like Seljuks, Ottomans, Safavids and Mughals.
For the same reason the imperial family of Japan didn't reassert their power in the time of the shogunates. They didn't have any military forces to call on and that position of semi useless spiritual leadership isnt that bad. You get all the lifestyle of a ruler with none of the actual responsibility.
Amazing video bro, love your content. But just as an FYI, it's pronounced 'Al Ayoubi' not just 'Ayoubi', and it's not 'loo loo' but 'Lu' Lu' ' there is a very crucial Hamza (ء) on the Waw (و).
Well you certainly don't take history lessons from religious scholars because they focus on religious studies, creed and theology, not history. That doesn't mean some scholars aren't good in history but yeah. It doesn't take much to make emotional people drink the koolaid. Take a random photo of some ancient footstep, attach a Prophet's or a saint's name to it and see how people start to swim in the koolaid lol.
I think of the whole period of crusades as a delicate period. The Kingdom of Jerusalem was always walking a tight rope in its neighborhood. A character like Raynald really added a lot of flavor to the stories. An interesting villain to the calm and collected Saladin.
AbuTahir Al-Jannabi destroyed kabba and took black stone which he used it in his toilet for 21 years to pee & poo on it to challenge allah and he succeed.
It was a fascinating period. And even tho quite bloody it was fairly tame compared ro a lot of Major wars and conquests of the time period. Reynald was definitly a bad guy, with poor strategy even if he was a good tactical commander and brave/daring. A perfect villain, competant and dangerous but ultimatly undone by his lack of perspective and self asurance.
Hey, I noticed a mistake. You said that European ships weren’t in the Red Sea after the failed annexation of Yemen by Aelius Gallus until the 16th century. The Romans were most present in the Red Sea after they brought the Nabateans under their rule. They built a garrison on Farasan Island in the mid 2nd century. Obviously you were going for a bit of a rhetorical flourish to emphasize the state of exception of the video topic. By my (limited) understanding, the decline of Petra is directly related to the Romans establishing this sea route, so this seems like a relevant enough oversight to actually point out. Love your videos.
The actual question ought to be, what body? When the Ummaiyad graves were desecrated by the Abbasids the older graves produced nothing but dust or few bone fragments.
There's an ayat in the Holy Qur'an.. "We made it and We shall protect it"... simple they can try whatever they want.. ALLAH says clearly he'll protect it...
10:59, That is exactly why we call them Munafiquun. a Bunch of Armed Crusaders requesting the help of a guide to the holy cities of Makkah and Madinah, it's so obvious.
Bro, u are wrong. Saladin is very diplomatic and intelligent. He does not make traps when he is in a war. He does it before going to war. He made an agreement with Frank's and others so that he could buy time to prepare to conjure Jerusalem. To do that first he shall unite Muslims worlds. So he always jump in to agreements and let the crusaders belive he is losing. What ever that I came across this is the story. I suggest u to review your view and news sources. This video is incorrect
Renault may have been belligerent as hell, but to try and steal the prophets body is just silly. It is far to hard to believe that this is true. Now to raid something or really anything, sure. The prophets corpse though? Man that's a tough sell without a doubt.
Reynald de Chatillion/Brins Arnat wasn't just a loose cannon. He was a dick. He basically ruined Cyprus, slaughtered the Orthodox priesthood, all for gold. That's against fellow Christians.
whenever you speak about Arabic sources you say it might not be true which is fine, but whenever you tell the story from the crusaders percpective you tell it as if it was a fact ! are you that concerned about western audiances? this is my 3rd time watching your videos.
As evil as Reynald was (May Allah Curse Him) he likely did not intend to take the Prophet's (PBUH) body. Ibn al-Athir or ad-Dhabi would have mentioned otherwise. Ibn Jubayr was the one who suggested that he did however he is not as reliable. Wa Allahu Allam.
I'm sorry you got that feeling. I didn't mention any crusader sources in this video because there are none. However, in some regards, Crusader sources would have been more accurate than Arabic ones. For example, there's no way an Arab writer would know what the intention of the raid was but a Christian writer would probably know. If we get both sides on a story, we're more likely to get a better idea of what happened.
That is its actual pronunciation. Makkah instead of Mecca. The complete name is Makkah Al- Mukarramah (The honoured city) while Medina is Arabic word for city. So when they said city of Medina it means "city of city" which kind of akward. The complete name at the time of the Prophet is "Madinatan Nabi" or sometimes they call it "Madinat Al-Nabi" which means City of The Prophet (City of Nabi). Present day Saudi renamed it to Madinah Al-Munawarah (The radiant City)
You should have done your research On Nur Al-Din Al-Zanki and the dream that he had about the two blonde boys Who managed to dig around the prophet's grave until they were almost there.
@@berdigylychrejepbayev7503 Exactly, cool is the problem, arabs could not deal with it. So, seriously, how would islamic forces cross to europe at this date? Try once more to take Constantinople? You need to wait for the turks, who can deal with cold weather.
@@nunolip well they many nations between defeated Tang Empire and Visigoth kingdoms. They occupied many islands in Mediterranean sea. And Destroying Holy cities will trigger all Muslims to unite which includes Turks Persians Arabs Berbers Kurds Pashtuns Punjabis and many more.
@@berdigylychrejepbayev7503 Please, do not blind yourself with fanaticism. in 1180 most Mediterranean islands had been recovered by the European states. The Almohad Caliphate was fast retreating in the Iberian Peninsula and would soon collapse. The Byzantines had recovered considerably. The Abbasid Caliphate was reduced to Iraq. And do not dream of help from the Seljuks in Iran or from India, there is no way logistics would work. At this time there was one strong muslim leader, Saladin, and he defeated the crusaders in Jerusalem. But even Saladin was not able to fully expel the crusaders. If he had 10 times the army, he would just be unable to find food, and he would still be unable to defeat the Bizantine ships armed with Greek fire. At this time, a large muslim invasion of Europe would be nothing more than a Zerg rush ending in a lot of drowning and starving muslim soldiers. What really opened the way for Europe was the 4th crusade, that destroyed the Byzantine empire, and the rise of the Ottomans, who build heavy armies, with infantry, cavalry AND artillery, able to face the European heavy armies on their own turf.
Mecca is the birth place of only Muhammad (pbh), not the Islam. Islam was very very much before Muhammad pbh. And I think nobody knows exactly,that where it started. Thanks
AbuTahir Al-Jannabi destroyed kabba and took black stone which he used it in his toilet for 21 years to pee & poo on it to challenge allah and he succeed.
@@noorjahan1333Abu Tahrir died with a gangrenous worm all over his body and the messiah he planted got brutally murdered, so an apt divine punishment.
@@Avicerox this is fabricated story by muzlims who were so embarrassed that AbuTahir Al-Jannabi pissed and poo on the black stone that allah sent from jannah. Long live AbuTahir Al-Jannabi.
We all saw the legacy of Mohammad and the impact of Islam in Uganda today. Several children were hacked to death with machetes in a school by the Allied Democratic Forces (ADF) just another Islamic scumbag terror group just like ISIS. Yet the entire Ummah is quiet.
they tried to steal his body? Muslims always told me that he stood at the dome of the rock and his body was taken up to heaven like how it was with Jesus? i've been lied to?
You should read more before making this video. There was another attempt to steal Prophet body during Sultan Nuruddin Zenki reign. 2 Christians digging hole and almost can grab the prophet's hair. The sultan at night got a vivid dream of Prophet telling him that the Christians want to steal his body and the sultan check all around Madinah and caught them. You should read more. The even not just during Salahudin era
So, a dream is what you consider historical? Watch this video, if you understand Urdu/Hindi: ru-vid.com/video/%D0%B2%D0%B8%D0%B4%D0%B5%D0%BE-D4CKoZzEpgQ.html
@@AlMuqaddimahYT thank you Al Muqaddimah, you're right, the story have no basis. I checked from Malaysian mufti website about authenticity this story. It'sI knew this story during my school time
A lot of assumptions that Reynold was very smart and reasonable person. If he was that smart you think he would have killed the sister of Salahudin knowing the consequences of doing that ?
I’ve never heard any native Arab pronounce Mecca and Medina like you do. No need to fill your mouth with the words. The two names should smooth out effortlessly. What you do might impress on non Arabs that you know because you can pronounce these alien names, others will simply see it as a cover for ignorance on the material.
The way that I pronounce those city names comes from my mother language, Urdu. If you think that not pronouncing those Arab names as Arabs do (but rather with an accent) is a sign of "ignorance on the material" then I must that that's exactly what Arab supremacy looks like. That supremacy is, in turn, exactly what caused the downfall of Arabs and rise of non-Arabs in the Caliphates.
It is ignorance of Arabic. That’s the point. Urdu or any other imposition would not do for a performance of Shakespeare for example. Then again, no Urdu pronounces arabic as you do. Sorry. As for Arab supremacy, that’s a nonstarter since the point is Arabic, into which the Koran was dictated. That is, I guess, God’s choice. Talk to him about it. So if your mother speaks this way, try to correct her. A holy endeavor I should think. As for caliphate, it seems Arabs lost caliphate of Islam and gained a caliphate of oil. Now that is power!
@@bentalal2879your contention is silly imo, it’s just the way he pronounces it. it’d be different if someone was pronouncing the Quran wrong, but these are just the names of our holy city in fact, show me any proof that Islam says that we are meant to pronounce “Makkah” or “Madinah” in the way that Arabs do?
@@unhingedconnoisseur164 the Koran says the book is Arabic. أنا أنزلناه قران عربيا. So it is not Hindu. That means it should be in Arabic, at least in public. If you read Shakespeare with Hindu accent then every V will be pronounced wee. As in wee pee instead of VP.
@@unhingedconnoisseur164 proof in the Arabic when it says the book is Arabic not Hindu. أنا أنزلناه قران عربيا. It is not the testament where it is Greek and not Aramaic.
THE AJUURAAN/ADAL/SOOMAALI ISLAMIC EMIRATE HELPED SALAXUDEEN BY FIGHTING THE PORTUGUESE IN THE RED SEA (SOOMAALI/ARAB SEA) AND INDIAN OCEAN (SOOMAALI/ARAB OCEAN) AND BY FIGHTING THEM I EAST AFRICA REGION IN THE ISLAMIC SOOMAALI PENINSULA (LAND OF THE ISLAMIC MUSLIMS SOOMAALI PEOPLE) IN EAST AFRICA WHICH CONSISTED AT THAT TIME OF THE WHOLE OF ETHIOPIA, KENYA, ERITREA, DJIBOUTI, SOOMAALIYA IT IS CALLED GREATER SOOMAALIYA TODAY WHICH INCLUDES BURUNDI, UGANDA AND TANZANIA AS IT WAS AN ISLAMIC EMIRATE
As a Muslim, I cannot fully trust all written history about Salah al-Din, he was is a great murderer and a seeker of self-promotion. Much of his history appears to be a fabrication, and even this particular story does not seem plausible enough to be accepted.
I love how none of the Muslim sources are taken seriously and is replaced with feelings and speculation, what a way to show us Muslims that you are at your core insincere or just ignorant and brainwashed, may Allah guide you and us to his straight path
