Do Shia Muslims Have the Same Quran & Hadith as Sunni Muslims? | Syed Ali Imran 

As an open minded Shia, I learn alot from shows like this. bring unity not division

I wish more people could have this open minded kind of discussion rather than trying to prove themselves over the other. May Allah bless you all.

I am Sunni Muslim, I always consider the Shia Muslims as like my brothers and sisters of my faith.

as a shia i obviously agree with Syed Ali Imran's views on this, and I am glad he didn't skip over the issues of the 17th century ulama, I was just thinking about that as I was watching this video

We have one Qur'an...so we are one.. that is all that matters...

I have come to know a lot of about shia Islam through this program. I don't want to watch debate between Shi'a and Sunni but eager to watch such type of conversation. May Allan bless you all

Thank you for enlightening us when there's so much false information out there

Prophet Muhammad (sws) never said I'm shia or sunni, just Muslim.

Very informative keep the conversation going 👍

Im glad, the channel is trying to bridge Shia Sunni differences. Hope to see more and may one day , both sides can accept each other. Its better to have a united strong muslim ummah instead of a huge muslim ummah that is fighting with each other.

No Shia ,Sunni , kadani Ahmadia No division in Islam we all are Muslims in Islam faith believing one God Allah , Prophets and Quran.

Excellent explanation of all the question by ali imran in a extremely polite and simple way. May Allah bless him

Hats off for this series. I am Sunni myself , i really don't get it why people especially of my sect always have problems with Shia sect and try to create conspiracies especially Moulvis ( So called scholars lol ) . I mean can't we live happily like bros and sisters. Yeah obviously , there are differences but we must always deal with each other with love and respect. Just look around in the world what this sectarianism has done. Thanks to so called scholars and political leaders for dividing , creating hatred. We are a ONE BIG family ❤️

Loved it again! Keep more like these coming our way

Beautiful conversation.. Thank you!

Great dialogue! It’s funny how some Muslims are extra keen on interfaith discussions and dialogue yet reluctant to engage in Intrafaith dialogue like this.🤔 Such discussions erase the falsehoods peddled by political “bidatologists” and “shirkalogists” and promote Islamic Unity !

Shia and sunni all are one we are one muslim 🦾

wow he said it without hesitation good👍

Informative interview.

We need more such talks to lower the gaps between the two sects.

Well said the Quran is absolutely preserved by Allah swt so any muslim with a sound mind cannot deny this fact.

lovely. This is how we should be as muslims. we are all muslims regardless of our different.

Alhamdolillah for this great effort.Justice of Allah swt prevails

Thank you so much, LTQS, for this series! I learned a lot! It would be great if Syed Ali could recommend some books of tafsir of shia tradition! And some books of shia philosophy. Especially because he mentioned a rational approach. I'm sure all sunni would benefit from educating themselves on shia tafsir tradition and philosophy.

while listening to both shia and sunni shcholors i finnaly raised above both sects to muslem.. i love my shia and suni brothres and sisters alike ..

_ **Please have more discussions with Shiites. Please! It is completely helpful.** - Lady Sufiyah is a very great Hostess. - **But if Doctor Shabbir Ally comes as the Host, then it shows the Unity of Islam more and more.**

This is educative!

You missed the most important question: "What is the view of Shia community on Abu Bakr Siddique, Umar ibn al-Khattab, Uthman ibn Affan (radiallahu anhuma) & Ummul Momineen Aa'isha (radiallahu anha)?"

I am a salafi. Still salafi. But I like sunni-shia unity. Not just in politics but in ideology. I had some misunderstandings about shias made by some Saudi salafi scholars. But it become ok.

Shahie al Buhari written 250 years after the demise of our Holy Prophet PBUH and his family.. Abu Bakr burned many many Hadeeses immediately when Our Prophet passed away. Pls remember GHADIR khoum. .....

The claim that parts of the Qur'an are missing is present as a fringe opinion within both Sunnis and Shia, and that claim is rejected by any Muslim with sound creed that has read the Qur'an and acknowledges that Allah has preserved his book. With regards to Hadith, do Isma'ili and Zaydi Shia (who have different Imams later on) have a different tradition and books on Hadith than the Twelvers? What do the Shia think of Sunni Hadith, do they reject it or take parts it?

Wowwww ما شاء الله can we please have more Shia sunni dialogue? 🙏🏼🌱

One of the problems is that there is also political motives of Saudi and Iranian governments pushing Sunni and Shia apart.

Real sunni scholars also accept that bukhari,muslim etc are not non questionable. Only quran is sacred divine revelation. Giving equal status to other literature as sources of divine legislation tantamounts to SHIRK,excommunication from Islam

I noticed brother Syed, that instead of saying salululahe alayhe wasalam, he’d instead say “salulsahu wali Ali”? Please correct my spelling if I’m wrong. I’ve never heard of this reference or way of referring to the prophet. Could someone kindly explain? Thank you.

We need bridges to build understanding and unity like this..

There is nothing missing in quran.

May Allah guide us ameen

Yeah we have the same Quran and same hadiths. It’s just Shias community, scholars and literature just don’t say certain words in verses of the Quran, pronounces words wrong, add or subtract words from the Quran. Shias only accept hadiths that favors their ideology.

Man. This kind of dialogue we need more often

Why dint you ask their position on sahaba r.t.a why do they insult Ammi Aisha r.t.

Ya allah bring unity amongst all Muslims Shia / Sunni leaders in their countries

There are errors in hadiths because its a human creation.

shia ppl having strong lanah about the sahaba. while literally sunni's are named after ali, hasan, husein, fatime. literally the host's last name is ali!

Wouldn’t it make more sense to take the Hadith from the direct companions of the prophet pubh who met and interacted with him then the descendants of the grandchildren of the prophet and their companions? I’m confused

We all are muslim innanillahi wainailahyraziun

I have a question , How did these 12 Imams come to have complete knowledge of Prophetic Sunnah? Was it something like divine knowledge or something they learned from Studying like other Scholars ?

I know you are trying to bring "unity" between sunni and Shia but this show is misleading. The Shia beliefs are furthest away from orthodox Islam. Their belief on Quran "distortions" is well documented especially among the ithna asharia sect that dominates Iran. I've lost respect for this show.

no dividation till death , One Ummah One Quran ☝

Excellent

Someone educate me as to how he was saying blessing after mentioning the prophets name pbuh.

wait wait i got a serious question. if you believe there isnt a single authentic book then why follow the teachings of your hadiths if its not %100 authentic

Quick q to all who all want unity between all. If everyone pretends there aren't fundamental differences in belief and practice, how do you then differentiate between the truth that the Prophet Salalahu alaihi wa salam came with and faksehood?

Shia and Sunni believe the same Allah and have the same book(Quran) but there are few extreme sects in both groups

May Allah grant you goodness

How can you say may "God" bless you instead of Allah(SWT) at the end of the video sister?

As long as you don't pray to Ali and use him as an intermediary or believe that some imams have knowledge of the unseen or Insult Aisha and the Sahaba

@3:38 minute mark he says all 12 Imams knew all direct Sunnah of the Prophet (pbuh). Some of Imams they recognize them before they reached baligh such as the individuals they label 9.10. 11 and 12.

Who's your favorite shia hafiz ?

Do shias take hadiths like Muslim,bukhari etc as part of Islam? Since Sunnis do and they way we practice ie pray, take ghusal and so on is derived from the those hadith.

I’m sorry but his statement at 0:40-0:45 “You will not find this opinion (among the scholars) ANYWHERE” is a lie. There are many Shia scholars in the past-well-known & respected ‘ulumā among Shi’a-who believed that the Qur’an underwent CORRUPTION (Tahrīf) at the hands of the close companions/disciples of the Prophet Muhammad (whom they also curse & reject as legitimate leaders), claiming that the “real” Qur’an contained up to THOUSANDS of verses that supposedly foretold the authority of Ali bin Abi Tālib as the rightful successor to the Prophet (which is obviously complete baloney). I’m afraid that his shocking denial of this clear fact of history, and his falsely attributing it to a mere “extreme fringe minority rejected by scholars” is totally false and misleading, and is either due to 1) Sheer ignorance (which seems unlikely, but I hope is the case) 2) Pure embarrassment of his own sources & tradition, or 3) He is being insincere & practicing ‘Taqiyya’, which in Sunni Islam is restricted “lying” ONLY allowed for fear of death or bodily harm, but in Shi’a theology is much wider and often allowed for ANY reason to protect or preserve the image of their faith, which even means lying to innocent people about what their books and scholars say in order to make it seem more palatable and help them swallow the faith. But there is absolutely no comparison between what we he mentioned about “problematic Sunni reports of Qur’an transmission” versus the HUMONGOUS & truly REPULSIVE claims made by great Shi’a scholars about the Quran’s alleged ‘tahrīf’ (corruption), which is a giant sin and anathema. P.S. For the record I don’t even consider myself a Sunni (but simply a “Muslim”) and I truly say all that I did with due respect, and don’t mean any offense or ill will towards our Shia friends, most of whom are themselves completely unaware of these teachings in their traditional books and scholars. I am only sharing my genuine thoughts. Salam.

CAN SOMEONE QUOTE AN AYAT THAT EXISTS IN THE QURAN OF ONE SECT AND NOT IN THE OTHER,PLEASE.

They don't have a book written by Jaffer Alsadiq .. 🙄❗

were the teachings of prophet muhammad, pbuh, not complete that people turn to other people?

Great discussion, refreshing to hear. The enemies of islam have fanned sectarian flames to weaken us so they could dominate our lands and people. The work you are engaging with here- the work of unity- is Godly work and insha’Allah will bring you all closer to Allah 🤲🏼

Vast majority? I don’t think so

This movie that has recently been released has caused negative energy between Sunni's and Shia's😒

God knows best.

Enlightening. But the Quran was compiled and transmitted by the sahabah using the same method for Hadith transmission. So how can you reject the sahabah’s Hadith, and instead use Hadith from other people??

Can a Shia answer my question please as I’m new to Islam? Considering no book can actually be authenticated how do we then decide which one to follow?

That's humble unlike sahih al Bukhari which claims to be 100 percent sahih.

Interesting, jzk! I wonder what he meant by shi'i companions.

Two Chapters are more in Shia quran. But what quran shiias are reading is also not what Imam Ali collected. Imam Ali' Quran is so so diffrent than Osman's quran that Shias are still afraid to reveal it to world. Because if Imam Ali' original Quran is uncovered then whole building of osmani islam will collapse.

The Zaidi Shia are acceptable and are definitely Muslim. Ismaili and 12ver Rafida shia are NOT within the parameters of Islam.

Wow! It's surprising to hear Syed Ali say that all Shiites accept today's Quran as authentic.

📢Ali bin Abi Talib, may Allah be pleased with him, mentioned Aisha, may Allah be pleased with her, Al-Siddiqa, the daughter of Al-Siddiq, and said: *✍️ “If a woman had been a caliph, Aisha would have been a caliph.”* {📒The origins of belief | By Al-Kaa’i, page 2762 ➖➖➖➖➖➖➖➖

They are too close to Christian theology. Also, very few think that Al -Bukhari's hadiths are 100% authentic. I've heard it is around 95% authentic if one was to put a number on it ( I forgot where and who said this but I'm sure with a little effort one can find this information). Regardless, they call and rely on human beings too much compared to the Sunnis.

I think it’s a bit deceitful to claim that the Quran is the same Quran all the Muslim ummah have but when you get the point of it, Shia will say their Quran is the true Quran. The is no Sunni literature that says that part of the Quran is missing and if there is Sunni literature that claims so, it is weak. Why even give this person a platform?

ماشاءاللہ بیٹا سلامت رہیں

The lack of consensus on hadith between Sunni and Shia is concerning. How do we know that the entire history of Muhammad and the sahaba is not fictional?

I have never doubted shai muslims have different quran.as long as you say lalilahi and have same quran.

Muslims should NEVER be deceived by falsehood attributed to Islam and our beloved Rasulullah by the evil Ummayad Dynasty founded by Muawiya. Moulana Mawdudi (ra) has adequately exposed the shenanigans of the Ummayads and the countless fabricated /absurd unQuranic narrations that have been arbitrarily declared "sahih" by these misguided elements. Read Moulana Mawdudis (ra) eye-opening work on the subject خلافت و ملوكيت

What in the Shia world is sallahu wali ali?? Asking all the Shias.

Ask him how the consider Abubaker umar usman.. ( r)?

What About These 12 Imams being raised to Higher level of having Unseen Knowledge. is there any Truth to this. Do shia Respect the 4 Caliphs and the Companions of the Prophet Mohammed PBUH. Are the Muharram Mourning True. Because that is very Un-Islamic if Shia do hit and bleed to Mourn

The shia don't have a chain of transmission for the Qur'an from amongst themselves.

why there's no questions about The prophet's wifes and the companions? it is the main issue about Sunni and Syiah. people claimed Syiah hates them and condemn them

Why only grandchildrens of Imam Hussain why not the grandchildrens of Imam Hasan *HYPOCRICY* isn't?? Selectively chosen imams probably because one of the wife of Hazrat Imam Hussain was queen of persia

Being a Sunni I really don’t find any differences with Shiaaet brothers… only don’t hurt our feelings as we don’t hurt ur practices!!!

can you explain brother what about the narrations that are taken from suhaba other than 12 imams according to you, and what about narrations taken from Aisha( mother if believers) or umar, usman (may Allah be pleased with them) etc 😊thankyou

This is great! How I wish to know why the offsprings of Hassan rabiyallahu anhu who was imam before Husseini Husseini rahimahullah, were excluded from the imamship? But Husseini"s children from a Persian mother were only considered Imams.

Both sunnis and shia are contradicting the Qur'an

Need more discussions on the Shites belief because we are fed with different information about them

Mashallah.

I lost respect to this channel how can you bring this Taqiyah here

Why do they not need witnesses to get married? Doesn't that mean if anyone gets caught commiting zina, they can just claim they got married to avoid punishment? Also, if he doesn't believe any book is authentic, why do they believe their hadith books?

Good video. Both sects have their good points and bad points, also they have both have their claims to islam. I lean the sunni way but do not regard the hadiths are completely provable, meaning no can be 100% it was said not unless you got tape recorder recording from the 6th century. So my view is that the hadiths i have come across ie bukhari etc and possiblely the shite hadith collections are the only ones whats we have left to suggest the prophet said this or that. So from an historical perspective they cannot be ignored and most likely true but that is not to say all is true. Of course to understand the hadith you need classical arabic training but also historical training. The problem with the sunni muslims view is they accept their hadiths are 100% but if you look at their collections they all contridict, that is fine you accept the prophet was a man and he made mistakes, but sunnis say he cannot make mistakes and to say so more likely get you killed. The shiah have a more pragamatic and sophisticate approach that hadith cannot be sure it was said, that is in line with current western historical methodology. The Shiahs are right on this point but by saying one cannot be sure if it was said 100% it does not mean a person cannot accept them. For example the fly hadith where it says one wing has a disease and other wing has a cure, put it in your tea then throw it out. paraphrasing here. That is extremely dangerous for your health if you follow that hadith, its a scientific fact flies transmite diseases. So if you do not beleive that hadith according to the sunni traditon it makes you a non muslims, and if you accept hadith but the prophet puh made a mistake it makes you anon muslim - one cannot win. It seems the sunnis are rather too quick to make people non muslim. I think the sunnis are right in general about what the hadiiths say, and that tradition cannot be ignored because it does not stand up to western historical methodlogy of the 21st century or science. That is not fair on sunni islam, because Bukhari only had the tools and and education of his age and with that he achieved a great thing with his collections. I have not deleved much into shiah hadiths yet but again i am not going to reject them out of hand just becasue they are shiah. www.orkin.com/pests/flies/house-flies/house-flies-and-disease. "Narrated Abu Huraira: The Prophet (ﷺ) said "If a house fly falls in the drink of anyone of you, he should dip it (in the drink) and take it out, for one of its wings has a disease and the other has the cure for the disease." sunnah.com/bukhari:3320 This article tries to argue flies are good in food, it is not true that flies were allowed to lay eggs on wounds, that would only increase inflectons, but it is true that maggots once cultivated were used to treat infected wounds. If the fly hadith is partly right but wrong on the other part. Putting flies in food can lead to illnesses and diesease, so he was right in that regard that flies can spread ilnesse etc. Hamaza Yusuf said that hadith is not authentic. The question is are you going to let a fly go near your food, i bet not. Remember flies feed on dead stuff, dung, defect when they land etc and then eat it up etc. Its not healthy to be near them and they should not be near any food. "In the two world wars the wounds of soldiers exposed to flies were observed to heal and scar faster than the wounds of unexposed soldiers. Even today, fly larvae, or maggots, are used medicinally to clean up festering wounds. They only eat dead tissue and leave healthy tissue alone." No they were not exposed to flies that would of made the wounds worse . seekersguidance.org/answers/general-counsel/does-modern-science-confirm-the-hadith-that-says-there-is-an-antidote-in-the-wing-of-a-fly/ "BioBag dressing: The maggots are sealed within a dressing which is a finely woven net pouch containing a small piece, or pieces of foam, which aid the growth of the maggot and manage exudate. The BioBag dressings come in varying sizes and are applied according to the nature and size of the wound being treated. The maggots remain sealed within the dressing throughout the treatment." www.chelwest.nhs.uk/your-visit/patient-leaflets/tissue-viability/maggot-therapy#:~:text=Maggot%20therapy%20involves%20the%20use,considered%20prone%20to%20re%2Dsloughing.

tahreef is a chapter title (not just one narration) in kitab al kafi. for imami shia today, kafi has the status bukhari does for orthodox muslims. khomeini wrote in so meof his poorly written books about the reality tahreef (among other zingers). this kid is peddling clumsy taqiyyah.

Lets cut the terms Sunni Shia etcetc in total, we are all Alhamdulilah Muslim one Islam because these dividing is from the devil in fact for all mankind a messenger was sent by same Allah wether people call it Yahweh Bhagwand God Boghov etcetc

DON'T DIFFRENCIATE BETWEEN SHIA AND SUNNI , STOP THIS NOW