Тёмный

Does Sim Racing Have An Esports Problem? 

Jimmy Broadbent
Подписаться 948 тыс.
Просмотров 230 тыс.
50% 1

A lot of mad stuff has gone on since the start of the year, so I figured I should probably talk about it.
Stuff used in this video:
• Iracing Daytona 24h To...
www.dexerto.co...
Le...
15jacrya.wixsi...
Cr...
pr...
racinggames.gg...
Pr...
If you enjoy the video then please hit that like button!
Twitch - / jimmy_broadbent
Business Enquiries - jimmybroadbent@dotxtalent.com
Discord - / discord
Twitter - / jimmybroadbent
Facebook - / jimmerinobombino
Send me stuff! (if ya want)
Po Box 53
Unit 3
Burnt Barns Farm
Ninfield
TN339LZ

Опубликовано:

 

28 сен 2024

Поделиться:

Ссылка:

Скачать:

Готовим ссылку...

Добавить в:

Мой плейлист
Посмотреть позже
Комментарии : 956   
@roussin_
@roussin_ Год назад
Esports has an Esports problem and sim racing is just one form of expressing it
@Lungolord
@Lungolord Год назад
Exactly. Any game I can think of, Madden, Fifa, and even Call of Duty all have some major issues right now
@philipkalin1928
@philipkalin1928 Год назад
well, you right
@jericosha2842
@jericosha2842 Год назад
This is what I came to comment, but you did it perfectly.
@tonyyimbo
@tonyyimbo Год назад
This guy gets it .
@nickheisler2559
@nickheisler2559 Год назад
@@Lungolord Would you be willing to say what those issues are? Is it technical related, like connections dropping and notorious DDOS attacks? Or is it more of a META gaming problem? Just curious as I don't really follow eSports anymore, save watching Jimmer
@iRedTomato
@iRedTomato Год назад
I used to be a director in PSGL. Down in the 11th tier is where you have people just racing for fun, maybe some of the older guys who’ve been racing there for a decade and don’t really practice but like having a race once a week. Cheating at that level is embarrassing and pitiful.
@HypHipHop
@HypHipHop Год назад
Well Jimmer ...this is a good moment for you to start a proper Virtual Sim event ! I think you got a big amount of guys following you !
@sirmez9597
@sirmez9597 Год назад
UPVOTETHIS!!!
@Wall562
@Wall562 Год назад
This^
@lomdonsreets5350
@lomdonsreets5350 Год назад
all hail the JIMMULATOR
@CarlosGarcia-ze6rt
@CarlosGarcia-ze6rt Год назад
I said it in the video where he announced that he bought the praga. A broadbent "gt academy" would be awesome, a simracing championship where the winning prize is racing with the praga
@youtubesucks69420
@youtubesucks69420 Год назад
This!. Ive never raced in a sim event because I don't like how serious people take it. But if Jimmers made one I would try it for sure.
@buddhapest
@buddhapest Год назад
in real sports punishment is much more severe then a short ban. that's the real eSports problem.
@VinnyFonseca
@VinnyFonseca Год назад
Exactly, and with MANY more available participants, it's not a matter of scarcity. Bring the hammer down.
@RaindancerAU
@RaindancerAU Год назад
Nothing saps the fun out of a hobby quicker than competition of the highest levels. When you throw money into anything forget fun and sportsmanship, people don't just want to win, people want the money and will do what they can to get it.
@kami_narisama
@kami_narisama Год назад
There's definitely a point where competition is balanced with fun. Finding it however, is very difficult
@zeendrom
@zeendrom Год назад
Same with most hobbies. The moment it becomes a job, say goodbye to all the fun. Good to see you here, Rain.
@Skumtomten1
@Skumtomten1 Год назад
@@zeendrom My dad played a round with a pro golfer in my country (Niclas Fasth) and that is exactly what he said. Now that my hobby is my job, I have to find a new hobby.
@Couchtripper
@Couchtripper Год назад
put a bonus in for clean driving - voted for by the competitors.
@TheCynicalJedi
@TheCynicalJedi Год назад
Saw a video the other day about how quickly money ruins things, said person (Moistcritical/penguinz0) would get tonnes of emails or livestream chatters suggesting video ideas, he decided if he makes a video someone suggested he'd pay them however much money for the idea, as soon as he publicised that he was doing it his email became an un-readable hell hole of vague ideas, obvious ideas that never needed suggestions (I.e. telling a movie reviewer to review a brand new high profile movie..) and brevity purely because people think that'll get them paid. Almost instantly it became about the money not the ideas. Same with everything else, exactly as you say, entertainment turns into business and the fun goes away
@prattomatic
@prattomatic Год назад
Sure seems like I need to look up the sponsors of the Williams eSports team and let them know that I find it hard to buy products from companies that encourage the teams they sponsor to act in unsportsmanlike ways.
@WLS_Churchill
@WLS_Churchill Год назад
Chillblast, Razer, BenQ, Playseat, Fanatec, Heusinkveld (Svend and Niels took the matter seriously
@mattiesinclair7689
@mattiesinclair7689 Год назад
Motor racing has always been about cheating as hard as possible without getting caught, why should sim racing be any different?
@prattomatic
@prattomatic Год назад
@@mattiesinclair7689 because they are competing in a field consisting of amateurs as well. If the split was 100% professional, paid teams, go for it - but this was the equivalent of Rick Hendrick bringing a team to a local track for a publicity event and blowing everybody else away because they had 100 extra HP in their engine
@Svend1500
@Svend1500 Год назад
Hi David, Svend from Heusinkveld here. We sponsor/support simracing teams on all levels but never encourage unsportsmanlike behaviour. We are taking this matter serious and have been in contact with the team about this. Please allow those directly involved in this matter to do better in the future where needed. Thanks :)
@prattomatic
@prattomatic Год назад
@@Svend1500 thanks for the reply, and I absolutely know that Heuskinveld would not condone this, you guys are a great company. You might want to have a chat with them though, in that the (now deleted) tweet from the Williams driver basically said “We have to act this way to keep our sponsors happy” which, while not true (of course), isn’t a good message.
@sodaaccount
@sodaaccount Год назад
8:30 Some found out the hard way :D Im a marshal and was watching the pit exit line at an event. Drivers kept ignoring it and were reported. I got A LOT of "unfriendly gestures" after their drive throughs. Some were stupid enough to do it several times in different sessions (I guess they thought the marshals rotated?!)
@sodaaccount
@sodaaccount Год назад
@@ThaJay I gotta be honest, its literally "my pleasure"😅 Its just great to be less than a metre away from the action (at least on parts of the Nordschleife)
@mrxbas
@mrxbas Год назад
This will surely be an interesting topic in 2023, especially considering the growth of simracing esports and the ESL tournament with its large prize pool!
@carlzee3230
@carlzee3230 Год назад
I think asking EA to actually care about anything besides microtransactions is asking far too much (let’s remember who now owns Codemasters). They’re probably more concerned with finding a way to create F1 Ultimate Team
@dannyx2737
@dannyx2737 Год назад
Yeah that's the truth. Games just aren't what they use to be. Games are made with micro transactions in mind first before gameplay and game performance
@MysteriousFigure
@MysteriousFigure Год назад
It's not like Codemasters were achieving masterclasses with developing F1 anyways, so now that they are a part of a very lazy and cash hungry developer, I wouldn't expect muich if at all unless it makes money
@captaincookieee6586
@captaincookieee6586 Год назад
Indeed, and after F1 2020 (which I thoroughly enjoyed) the F1 games went rapidly downhill, and F1 22 just is a mess and after buying 3 games on launch, I couldn’t bother anymore
@jdevlin1910
@jdevlin1910 Год назад
Codemasters stopped caring long before EA arrrived
@kanojo1969
@kanojo1969 Год назад
This is the first time I realised there weren't live stewards in the top split. This blows my mind and explains everything. The solution to this specific problem - cheating by drivers on track - is simple, we already have the real-world racing examples right there to copy from. if there's pro teams involved, there has to be live stewards and human policing of race behavior. And before that, much better rules that are very specific about both violations and penalties. Basically, iRacing needs to put in the measures any reasonable fan would expect to exist. To put it another way, the worst part of this whole thing wasn't Williams cheating, it was that nobody stopped them or punished them for doign it. Absolutey pathetic from iRacing and others who run the event.
@gsheist
@gsheist Год назад
💯 agree with you. How can iRacing claim to be a serious platform for professional sim racing without life stewards. That’s a huge miss in my book
@Sushi227
@Sushi227 Год назад
People in my iRacing league have all been saying the same things for years now: top splits during special events need live stewards, and that the sporting code needs an overhaul along with enforcement to show unsportsmanlike behaviour will not be tolerated at any level.
@virtual_GaRy
@virtual_GaRy Год назад
iRacing should make offtack areas actually offtrack and delete your quali time, fix their countless physics exploits and live steward top split. Netcode also absolutely not esports ready and where is the rain?
@juni_2452
@juni_2452 Год назад
Yeah i think having live stewards on top would be very beneficial to iRacing, because incidents like this wouldn't have happened, and also i think that everyone involved in that top split would take it more seriously. I don't really think it would be favoring top split, if i ever got to top split i would expect iRacing to take measures like live stweards
@randomchannel323
@randomchannel323 Год назад
Agreed if this was a real race it would be noticed instantly and they'd be DQ'd
@periurban
@periurban Год назад
As someone who loves arcade racing games like Wreckfest and Wreckfest, the sim racing world looks completely mad.
@emlyndewar
@emlyndewar Год назад
Yeah, the fun seems to be being sucked out of it.
@Pobsworth
@Pobsworth Год назад
@@emlyndewar nah, sim racing is fun on a personal level. These big events just give it a bad image
@rickrolled7930
@rickrolled7930 Месяц назад
​@@Pobsworth aren't the aliens also sim racing for fun? Because if not, why are they doing this? For the money? There are better paying things out there.
@Einveldi
@Einveldi Год назад
I chaired a panel at the World Science Fiction Convention in 2019 that asked "is Esports the future of competition?" And I think we're now there. If it's going to be contested at that level, it has to be governed at that level.
@Samylton
@Samylton Год назад
Still waiting for a full vid on T-Rex Assetto Corasa mod, I think we all need a break from all this serious esports shenanigans
@seanberry1
@seanberry1 Год назад
I agree that top-split esports events need live stewards. I've been saying it for years. If they want to protect the integrity of their sport, they're going to have to pay more attention to the aspects of real motorsports that aren't covered by the programming.
@Torquematterz
@Torquematterz Год назад
My old auto teacher would warn us. When your passion becomes your job; you can't use it as an escape anymore.
@02bluehawk
@02bluehawk Год назад
Hit the nail on the head at the end there bud! People are forgetting how to have fun and taking it too seriously.
@mikehipperson
@mikehipperson Год назад
When money and kudos is involved anything goes in any sport, real or digital!
@joeogle7729
@joeogle7729 Год назад
@@mikehipperson ah money, the ruiner of all good things
@rickrolled7930
@rickrolled7930 Месяц назад
In average lobbies yeah, maybe. But when there is money to be won, people want it, no matter what it takes. Some poeple do decades of jail for robbery and drug trafficking and so on, all for money. Esports drivers are also people and want the big prices. Not to even mention the ego.
@billyrowlee7337
@billyrowlee7337 Год назад
No matter what, in any type of game, you're going to get competitive. And in a game where competition IS the game, its only going to get worse. iRacing was fantastic when i first got it, but after Covid, it's just gotten to the point where I'm not on very much. Not from being burned out, but it has so many glaring issues that aren't addressed that takes the fun out of it. I'm not willing to do wacky things with a setup, wall ride or do anything out of the norm that I'd do in a real car. No matter what happens, when money gets involved, things change, and generally for the worse. Is it good that sim racing is growing? Yes, but the consequence to that is this type of behavior that goes against the "spirit of the race".
@Formaldehydex
@Formaldehydex Год назад
Check out what happened at the very first corner of the very first lap of the last race to win the Skippy School scholarship. Diego Pinto’s teammate put the chrome horn to the second place driver when there was just a 5 point lead, so everything was up for grabs until he got punted off the track.
@tquiring212
@tquiring212 Год назад
I agree with your idea of live stewards for the top split on major events like the Daytona 24. It's the one that is broadcast, most likely has all the biggest names in the service, and is the one everyone will hear about. Live stewardship would have prevented that qualifying lap from occurring and may have altered the GTD shenanigans.
@griff_the_boxer
@griff_the_boxer Год назад
The worst thing about F1 esports is that for bad drivers it’s really obvious when they’re cheating…they miss apexes and make tons of mistakes but still do great lap times. The problem is that if the top drivers just give themselves like 1% more grip, it would be almost impossible to tell (unless you implement an anti cheat).
@DFT1929
@DFT1929 Год назад
'this breaks my balls' is such a classic hispanic phrase but it sounds so weird in english lmao
@staceybertran52
@staceybertran52 Год назад
Thats the best point made. Since it was top split and generally live broadcasts by someone like Race Spot, there should ALWAYS be live stewarding as part of the norm. As a benefit for making the top split. If its already getting live broadcast, not every split gets live broadcast. So live stewarding is mandatory in my mind. Because its like we have seen in the past with tire dipping etc. Drivers pushing the edges and no fear of getting caught unless protested. At the time of protesting. its too late.. too late to change the outcome. too late to get safety rating and irating back, too late in general and since iRacing is making a shyte ton of money off of us perhaps even have the top 5 splits with stewards to dissuade people from going one or two splits down on purpose to do the same stuff. Just my thoughts. Thanks for the update Jimmy.
@mrj3217
@mrj3217 Год назад
How does Iracing not have code for this to automatically flag these actions. Then after the race have the possible flagged infractions scrutinized before officially awarding a win. To easy.
@fourutubez7294
@fourutubez7294 Год назад
The Rennsport saga is going to be so entertaining.
@VinnyFonseca
@VinnyFonseca Год назад
I agree, but hoping to be happily disaapointed on that one. Another top notch sim on the market would be great right now.
@SpaceFoxAD
@SpaceFoxAD Год назад
Really appreciated that ridge racer towards the end
@theparkster1542
@theparkster1542 Год назад
7:20 one of the more irritating parts of this is that this is literally every online apology these days. It's just "sorry we got caught" rather than, genuinely being sorry for what you did. Fm
@Tomani02
@Tomani02 Год назад
This is pretty sad overall... If there is a competition that deserves to be called an "Esport" more than anything else since it is the closest thing to the real sport in video game form. Even with a Logitech G29, it enables people with modest income to have a similar experience to driving a real race car. It is the democratization of motor racing. So it is sad for me to see all this stuff that harms this hobby which I call my favorite.
@brunoboldt6336
@brunoboldt6336 Год назад
It´s human nature, specially on the higher levels of competition, team will use ANY breach on the rules to get a advantage over the others, and it happens every where on e-sports and "real"sports. Ethic is something that dies rather quickly when huge money / sponsorship gets involved sadly. Good thing is that there ARE good and honest people.
@marijn17s
@marijn17s Год назад
Spetz has gotten a year ban actually. His discord status also has the days remaining until his unban in it.
@Hellcat_UK
@Hellcat_UK Год назад
What he did probably wasn't worth the year ban. After all, pole in a 24hr race isn't as important as say a 15min sprint. But as that was his 3rd bannable offence it's justified. He's an amazingly fast driver but absolutely lacking in common sense, or a support network for preventing him from doing stupid stuff!
@marijn17s
@marijn17s Год назад
@@Hellcat_UK Yeah i agree. Also shows that the grass dipping one week bans were kind of a warning for them that they’re not going to get away with those things in the future. I hope this sends a message to all the esports teams that they should play fairly
@bundesautobahn7
@bundesautobahn7 Год назад
This is where EA can assist Codemasters with their expertise. The responsibility is with Codemasters, but they can ask their parent and publisher for assistance in finding an anticheat solution.
@DERP_Squad
@DERP_Squad Год назад
EA are more likely to identify the cheats and offer them as an in-game subscription.
@mrhatty0514
@mrhatty0514 Год назад
On the Williams debacle, the mechanical side or “game” aspect of the platform does allow what did. The sporting code, the thing every iRacing player has to abide by and agree to before turning a single lap, doesn’t. Willams Esport violated no less than 4 regulations in the sporting code with their shenanigans. The driver in questioned got suspended, not banned. A ban would indicate they are done for good and not allowed to return at all. And if iRacing had any teeth they would not only lifetime ban the driver, but tell Williams to hit the road and exclude them from every broadcasted and special event for the rest of the year given their response.
@whassupg89
@whassupg89 Год назад
Sim racing’s other esports problem is that too much focus in the building of these games is aimed at the top levels of esports competitors, meaning less effort goes into making these games just enjoyable to play for the rest of us who like racing but suck at it 😅
@si1208
@si1208 Год назад
Well expressed, Jimmy. It's a sad side of human nature that some will take advantage wherever they can get away with it. Adding prize money incentivises the bad behaviour. Add corporate sponsorship, and the bad behaviour takes over.
@boccs
@boccs Год назад
When the exploits are obvious to the point of people doing them by accident... Maybe there is an obvious solution to people misusing bugs, fixing them! I guess that would be a lot to ask for though :/
@JSmith73
@JSmith73 Год назад
Check the latest release notes for iRacing, re Daytona? ;)
@LaurentLaborde
@LaurentLaborde 3 месяца назад
Race Marshal here (at a national level, not international). There is 2 broad category and we can see them very clearly without a shadow of a doubt : - pilots that are just happy to finish the race. Taking moderate risk. My favorite kind. They even take the podium sometimes. - pilots aiming for the podiums, racing hard and taking all kind of risk. They keep us busy. And then there is the "lawyer pilot". At the "non-international' level it's not going to end well for them. Even if they are "technically right by the rule", they'll get a black flag anyway and the race/podium is over for them. Even if the race director is being ruled out (unlikely), it's over for them anyway. So in the case of the video here : - staying on the pit lane : orange disk flag, or black flag. - pushing someone out : black flag The legal technicality doesn't matter much, you're a safety concern, you're out. We'll sort it out later, for now just get out of the track. Once you get used to it, you'll see tons of "marshal moment" with mistakes made by the marshal or director. It's not a big fuss. It's a "racing incident" as you call it. It's only a problem at the international level with many tweet, fanboy, and 2 camera per square meter of track. Sim racing ESport need neutral human race marshal (as in real life) who doesn't give a F about who's who and why.
@oliveiradmdiogo
@oliveiradmdiogo Год назад
Is no one talking about how he took the theoretically slower way around the track and went FASTER?
@regibson23
@regibson23 Год назад
The qualy thing was so minor. It's a 24 Hour race. Big deal. It's better to be 2nd anyway to fuel save. The bigger problem I have is sending out cars that are laps down to block competitors.
@Crash88
@Crash88 Год назад
Famed NASCAR driver Kevin Harvick once said "if you're not cheatin you're not tryin" after getting caught qualifying with only half a gas tank of fuel.
@wag0NE
@wag0NE Год назад
As soon as I read words like robust in a statement everything seems to just mean nothing. Cheaters always seem to have one thing in common a narcissistic stupidity.
@marijn17s
@marijn17s Год назад
The F1 cheats have been around for a long time actually. Started to get serious around F1 2020. I've heard from a very reliable source that Longuet had them as well back in F1 2020, not sure if he still has them though. Edit: Codemasters have implemented an anticheat after about half a year into the F1 2021 game, but it has proven not to be very effective.
@jacekatalakis8316
@jacekatalakis8316 Год назад
FWIW I remember trainers for as far back as 2013, sites like Cheathappens were distributing them a decade ago and with some fiddling you could get them to work online without too much hassle
@marijn17s
@marijn17s Год назад
@@jacekatalakis8316 true but it really kicked off with fully working online cheats in 2020
@greg5095
@greg5095 Год назад
Yeah that ESL money is straight from the Saudi Public Investment fund. I wouldn't be happy for that
@alexda6789
@alexda6789 Год назад
rF2 seems to be heading in the esports direction too. as someone who does simracing as a way to pass the time, and rF2 re-doing their tyre model for Goodyear and the Virtual LM completely changed how you have to go about those cars, including what used to be my all-time favorite simracing car, the Oreca 07. I can no longer just hop into a race when I feel like it, I have to spend hours practicing because even with TCS and ABS assists turned all the way on, which I never had to do, it's impossible to drive as a casual player. Am I saying that I'm mad about a skill issue? Maybe. But the point is that I can no longer do what I want to do in rF2 because of too much attention to esports and I am not an esports driver. The casual feel of the LMP2s and GTEs is gone and it's just a bit frustrating, since rF2 perfectly suited my wants as a simracer before.
@VodkaRob
@VodkaRob Год назад
Sadly there will always be cheating where any computer /console game is concerned and as soon as something is out to combat it I would imagine the cheats will be working on a way around it. Unfortunately it's not like real life racing in a physical car. It's sad that people do it. For me I would rather finish last than win by cheating but not everyone is the same. I can remember playing a mobile game and the top 10 times were all ridiculous like 1 second for a full lap and that kind of thing is even more ridiculous. It's not even believable. We just have to hope the devs keep working on fixes. Great video as always, thanks ✌️ 😎
@jjfreer
@jjfreer Год назад
this problem has been around for years. we were league racing in MRL, when f1 was off for covid and the f1 drivers started streaming the game, and you would have people suddenly buying wheels and gaining 2/3 seconds a lap over the course of a couple of days, or just turning their cheats up over the course of a week and just saying they are practicing. It destroyed all the hard hours honest players put into getting good over the course of YEARS, then having people ruin the league clearly cheating, with all the moderators not being able to tell conclusively and just saying i guess its possible that they "just got good" lol
@erikr968
@erikr968 Год назад
The iRacing Daytona 24H is an amateur event. It is an amazing opportunity for anyone to take part in a 24H race, regardless of if you're a clueless beginner or one of the best of the best. The problems happen when drivers, teams, sponsors and broadcasters start treating the top split like it is a professional event, with all the hype that goes with it.
@Franconen
@Franconen Год назад
Hello Jimmy, when you introduce money problems comes, it's like that everywhere.
@saltbjorn
@saltbjorn Год назад
I caught one of the cheaters - CptForgie. Dude literally basically has ‘forgery’ in his name. Set a 26.1 at Silverstone while missing every apex.
@dirkvanechelpoel4577
@dirkvanechelpoel4577 Год назад
here's a solution for cutting corners; force-fields... cut detected? disintegrate the part of the car that touches it. would come in handy for dual-lane roundabouts too actually :P
@joelandjake
@joelandjake Год назад
I think the main problem of Simracing as an esports discipline is lack of organization. I've seen other competitive titles that have well-sorted and well-organized tournament structures. In order to qualify for a regional tournament, you have to win local and national competitions; then if you at least win podium in regionals, you're qualified to join an international tournament. I might be wrong about this, but Simracing just "drafts" its competitors from across the globe to be pitted against each other directly. There's little to no indication about their recent achievements that qualified them for the world stage in the first place. "You won a previous tournament years ago? Congratulations, you're qualified for this one!" "Oh, so you're new to the competitive scene? Welcome to the big time!" Nothing to gauge whether the players can still technically compete or are already considered "washed out" or "too green."
@jonclark25
@jonclark25 Год назад
Agreed. Doing something proffesionally and as a passion is very different. Programming was my passion 7 years ago and now I'm a programmer I still enjoy it but it doesn't get me outta bed in the morning but sim racing and driving on the limit at race tracks IRL too and adding performance parts to my car consumes 99% of my thoughts because it's a hobby. I bet pro drivers even get a moment here and there when they just don't want to think about racing even.
@electropneumatic
@electropneumatic Год назад
Jimmer you hit all the points I was thinking on the head. And I completely agree: if something is not set in stone driver can and will take advantage of it--and they should. But this was a blatant and they knew what they were doing was wrong.
@King_Ears
@King_Ears Год назад
What's disappointing is the amount of winnings on offer in sim racing compared to games like Rocket League & CS:GO etc etc. It's a pittance in comparison. I always found it silly that Gran Turismo offers no monetary rewards to its top players just 'stuff' whilst also banning drivers from wearing any team affiliated clothing or personal sponsor brands. GT could be a massive eSports brand for us less fortunate console racers but instead they do it half arsed
@Markusaur
@Markusaur Год назад
imagine that. split one and no official adjudication .. and this is the pinnacle of "Esports" what an absolute joke!
@0verfiend
@0verfiend Год назад
Gt7 daily race: “define problem.”
@shinebassist
@shinebassist Год назад
The solution to the car laps down is a) real stewards b) introduce F1 rules about having to let the faster car through before you pass 3 blue flags, at least for these major events and c) forced retirement of any car more than 20% of the completed race distance behind the leaders. This needs to be nipped in the bud now or everyone else is going to start doing it
@BenKuyt64
@BenKuyt64 Год назад
Yea, esports has always had issues whenever a genre is becoming more popular. Same thing happened in CoD, Smash, speed racing, Halo, etc.
@PixelisedPaul
@PixelisedPaul Год назад
There’s corruption and a lack of consistent authority. Sounds just like real life, high profile motorsport to me.
@SwigerQ86
@SwigerQ86 Год назад
The iRacing Rolex 24 was beautiful, it was an amazing experience, probably the best ive had in any sim.
@Shiraumere
@Shiraumere Год назад
Williams e-sport should be banned from the next daytona event for their behaviour. Button is just a bellend. Forcing e-sport generally tends to ruin everything if it's forced too much, look at Siege and Overwatch.
@KashouWannabe
@KashouWannabe Год назад
I think the most sickening thing was Jenson shoving his nose in. He really had no idea, did he? I mean, if in a race one of his competitors took their own line around about a third of a course, and sat on the end of the pit lane for two minutes to wait to play blocker for a team mate, I think Button would appeal to have them disqualified, right? So what if the Automated Marshall system did no catch these things, a real one would have. Williams knew that there was no human officiating at the event and took advantage of that, breaking both rules and regs by the race coordinators. Didn't he go on to say "Its just a game"? I mean, sure, its a game... that brings in actual race drivers and teams from around the world, with lots of real, actual money on the line. You have to treat these events with the same respect that you would a real world event when the stakes are that high, and both MSG with how they handled Le Mans, and Williams how they handled Daytona, simply do not respect the sport, or their peers.
@JanBruunAndersen
@JanBruunAndersen Год назад
Without racing stewards, teams might start "self-stewarding". If the leading car of team A does something dodgy without being punished, then team B can use their non-leading car to take out team A's car. It will become a demolition derby.
@Neil3D
@Neil3D Год назад
I've said for years that Codemasters need to have the F1 license revoked and moved to another dev. Even their in-game leaderboard is rampant with cheaters but they never monitored it nor did a damn thing about it. I'm a huge F1 fan and loved the competitive leaderboards, but I just stopped playing the game because of there was zero chance of your abilities being represented fairly on the leaderboard.
@stevebuscemi3622
@stevebuscemi3622 Год назад
Esports takes the fun out of casual gaming.
@layingblacklines
@layingblacklines Год назад
It's just competition at the end of the day. Like you said about drivers exploiting anything they can for a competitive advantage. We can ask for drivers to be good sportsmen, but really it's up to the games and organisers to enforce it. Like anti-cheat. Or proper track limits. Or not having weak physics (brake dragging etc). Rather than blaming the cheating eSports weasels, we should be considering is the problem that we don't have a sim that is fully eSports ready?
@Decebalus
@Decebalus Год назад
To be honest, despite having raced in iRacing for a few years now, this is the first time I realised the top split races for the big events like Daytona 24h don't have actual stewards. To me that's a no-brainer, and I don't think many people would be worried about the preferential treatment aspect because ultimately the top split is where you have people who like you say have actual sponsors, have probably spent hundreds of hours of their time practicing, there's prize money on the line, etc. etc.
@4_14_fan
@4_14_fan Год назад
Funny enough iracing added a slow down penalty for going on the apron on the Daytona road course the day of this video
@GregoryPrzybyl
@GregoryPrzybyl Год назад
As someone who plays f122. I’ve been accused for cheating because of my age and my surge in form. It’s a shame how the game is going downhill
@marshallpeters1437
@marshallpeters1437 Год назад
And Jimmy there's quite a bit of cheating in f1 esports especially at the highest level. Several were accused this year including the champion this year
@scotthecarnerd1995
@scotthecarnerd1995 Год назад
This will be talked about for the rest of the year you can guarantee it, whatever happens it needs change like you said because its tainting something that a lot of people find really enjoyable and rewarding.
@SRV
@SRV Год назад
What a juicy start to the year for sim racing.
@hollowkatt4821
@hollowkatt4821 Год назад
While I loathe 99% of the GT7 Penalty System I do like how "if you cut the track it's a penalty". With regards to the statement "if the game allows it it's legal" the "simple fix" is for the game not to allow it. It should be theoretically possible to have some kind of marker on the double yellow at Daytona that would negate or nullify or otherwise impede the lap time of someone who spends time down there with all 4 tires across the yellow lines. Nobody "Has" to cheat in esports/sim racing and if your sponsors will drop you because you didn't cheat to get pole then they're shit sponsors and not worth having. Integrity should mean something.
@JaysMackie
@JaysMackie Год назад
I missed the follow up to that. I did not realise Jenson had sold Williams both his experience and integrity
@XPLOSIVization
@XPLOSIVization Год назад
This is why i always stick to single player A.I races, and will always fight for better A.I in Sims
@hamleyn
@hamleyn Год назад
Great video Jimmer and completely agree. I understand there's serious money in eSports now but it doesn't excuse behaviour like that shown by Williams. I don't really care that there are no limitations embedded within the sim to stop cheating, there's the spirit of competition, which is to compete fairly and whoever is best will win. As Josh Revell would say "don't be a manus" - you're just ruining the experience for the rest of us and people are going to stop watching eSports if things like this continue to happen. The devs for the sims could do more to stop it, like AC does, which I think is the most practical route to nip this behaviour in the bud.
@rickswanracing3139
@rickswanracing3139 Год назад
Once money gets involved... there will be attempts to have the upper hand...when talent alone cant gain the advantage.. teams will look to any and all means possible.
@Laurens_en_Daire
@Laurens_en_Daire Год назад
Not really the topic of the video, but i personally feel of two minds about simracing esports, huge respect for the dedication, but at the same time, I feel like the fact that technically anyone could become an esports driver/youtube famous or both is adding elitism and unnecessary tryharding into simracing in all levels which in turn can become a turnoff, because you feel less welcome in an environment where you have to feel sorry if you're off the pace by certain amount or worried that you might ruin someone else's race because you haven't practiced every corner to perfection. On a personal level, this has stopped me from being able to enjoy simracing, which I would love to do, because I do enjoy fine car control and physics, clean racing, more realistic events, etc, but at the same time, I've never been able to cross the competitive barrier. (Literally can't get past C-class in Iracing since my safety keep yo-yoing for random incidents, some of them my fault, some of them probably from others being overly competitive, in ACC i can't even complete all the track medals or get within the pace requirements of leagues like LFM) Of course, simracing on average more competitive and perfection-driven because it requires finer car control to even stay on the track and the physics and rules of motorsports should not part should not be dumbed down, but people's attitudes need to change, rather.
@Tara-B-Jackson
@Tara-B-Jackson Год назад
I thought you still had to verify your game files when you try to drive online and it removes any mods or files that aren't supposed to be there? I had a few time that when I used to play the F1 game it wouldn't let me play online until I verified my game. If it doesn't now then it should to stop people using cheats and mods online and in leagues.
@Alnilam1973
@Alnilam1973 Год назад
I've been mostly playing AC offline so far this year and really trying to improve but not for esports, for fun. I didn't know about the f1 22 problem but the rest is history, apart from Rennsport and they seem to be following a game plan, I'm willing to give them the benefit of drought for now, they've made themselves a very hard deadline with the competition aspect but can anyone really say it's not gained a lot of free publicity for them. I think they're gonna go hard and that event will be a sink or swim for them, who's gonna invest time in it if it fails spectacularly? On the flip side if it's as good as the hype and delivers first time out, I'd be very surprised if there wasn't a big change in the hobby next year either way. It would be nasty to see a split between esports and the hobby, I kinda feel they need each other more than ever atm.
@TehBrownie
@TehBrownie Год назад
1000% I have been saying this for years. that they need to have live admins in the Top split as they are showcasing the Sim. No idea why iracing does this crap
@knowlestoo
@knowlestoo Год назад
It's the same solution as in every other competitive endeavor. Don't make rules you can't enforce. Poker has this issue with people using databases of solutions to guide, or even automate, their decisions when playing online. If the rule is 'don't go below the apron', then have a mechanism to enforce it, the same as already exists for track limits. If the rule is 'stream driver's perspective of the race and the driver' then invalidate any laps where this isn't the case. It's a failing on the game to allow cheats. It's a failing on the organisers to add rules they can't / won't enforce. The very minimum is a professional behaviours rule that allows for retrospective lap invalidation or penalty or DQ for the rules you want that the game can't enforce for you. That alone gets the Williams team DQ'd because after the fact we can see that they acted as a team with the intent that driver 2 would impede \ crash other drivers for driver 1's gain. It's so obvious that the Williams team principals must be giggling to themselves that they got away with keeping the win. Losing a driver is likely only a minor inconvenience.
@testpilotian3188
@testpilotian3188 Год назад
We had a team in our “don’t win anything other than a pat on the back” NR2k3 league doing stuff outside of the spirit of the rules including driving on the apron and playing silly buggers at superspeedways with blocking while multiple lap down etc. We eventually got so fed up we kicked the entire team out, so it’s not just pro team esports teams that cheat.
@beastehful
@beastehful Год назад
Cheating is a huge problem in so many online games. Any measures implemented by game devs to block one method of cheating seem to be quickly circumvented by the cheat makers. I would ask why these game companies, which are worth hundreds of millions, and in some cases billions of dollars, seem to be losing the battle against small teams of cheat makers. Is it really an impossible problem to solve? Or are they simply unwilling to pay enough people to take the problem seriously?
@Nails077
@Nails077 Год назад
This happens with everything when people start taking things too seriously.
@pox87
@pox87 Год назад
My two cents: There are two main problems, licensing and the online aspect of the thing. The licensing problem arises when lots of money is paid by developers to secure real world sport branding to simulators which are not adequate for proper competition (rfactor2 and f1 22). A serious sporting association would professionally test multiple simulators, choose the best performing one, and pay the developer to make the appropriate cars/tracks content, not the other way around. The online thing is simple, online servers will always have problems, and cheating online will always be easier. If you plan to have "the biggest simracing event of the year", with an enormous budget, celebrities and such, just get them all physically in the same location, racing on gear provided by the organizer, on servers which are completely offline, possibly with a live audience too. It would be a much better event, and cheating/technical problems would be minimized.
@Andymh5
@Andymh5 Год назад
Reg the 24hr Daytona - IMO, they should have live stewards, limit car speeds on the apron, and apply the same blue flag rules as in F1. Also, they should have the penalties to breaking the rules issued to the teams and available publicly online to reduce any confusion when a team/driver does cheat. I agree with everything you've said regarding sim racing esports in this vid.
@dustindarland4373
@dustindarland4373 Год назад
Any game with a public leaderboards especially if money or a chance for money is going to attract cheaters and hackers.
@dotkomist
@dotkomist Год назад
As a filthy e-sports casual looking in from the outside, it seems like sim-racing gets much closer to the 'real thing' than other e-sports (Rocket League, LoL etc). Yet for some reason doesn't get any of the same preventative measures that real sports get like proper stewards or harsh(er) punishments. There seems to be a mindset of "eh, it's only e-sports, it's only a video game, sportsmanlike conduct doesn't matter that much", and when it spreads to team cultures like the Williams thing seemingly did, it endangers the sport as a whole.
@vin2676
@vin2676 Год назад
It’s classic game theory jimmy. If someone does thing that’s maybe morally ambiguous but not illegal. Everyone will do it because if you’re the only one who doesn’t you’re at a disadvantage And not just morally ambiguity but also something that’s against the spirit of it but again not illegally. Everyone will do it because if you don’t you’re at a disadvantage This is not just a thing in racing or sim racing but every single part of life
@Dethmeister
@Dethmeister Год назад
How come there isn't a track limits set below the line down to the apron on the banking? There's track limits everywhere else. Also, it couldn't be that hard to have it auto disqualify a car that's sitting at pit exit or on the side of the track.
@dddsss376
@dddsss376 Год назад
My thoughts on simracing are simply that I think it's a piece to feel like your racing idols for a few minutes seconds or hours. Without risking your live in a Group b car.^^ The problem with Esport starts I think is simply the money. There are still a lot of unknown Leagues, which did not know how to help themselves, starting to buy Bots for Twitch or hired agency to buy klicks. Simply search a little while on youtube. Racing in the real world is nothing more than a money-burning machine. The part that can make profits is so tiny. The same can be said for Esports.
@ThaJay
@ThaJay Год назад
This is completely on the game developers end event organizers. The event organizers should take their participants seriously, have crew onsite like irl and the developers should take what is learned and make an update asap to mitigate the effects for future events. Not having any anticheat in a competitive environment is just unforgivable so the only correct course of action is to boycott F1 games until they are fixed. These games should be called unviable and maybe even malware until the developer steps in and regains the player trust.
@dystopia_lp
@dystopia_lp Год назад
I am pretty sure these sponsors dont want to be connected to such behaviour.
@oneohfive6584
@oneohfive6584 Год назад
Odd that it’s a bigger bone of contention when Williams Esport do it than when Red Bull/Alpha Tarui/Alonso does this to Lewis Hamilton
@JoshuaC923
@JoshuaC923 Год назад
Wow i cannot imagine how Williams can defend dishonesty
@ChrisbyFlanker
@ChrisbyFlanker Год назад
It's up to us to drag the people who cheat and act unsportsmanlike. Sponsors don't care, they just want results and can happily shrug off forgettable incidents from teams. One of the big things would be for the event organisers to take a stand and ban the team from operating and strike their results. They must do it for thier integrity as a competition. Otherwise it'll have more cheaters next time and less legitimate participants.
@trautsj
@trautsj Год назад
Gaming has a fucking Esports problem in general. Next to the outright vile amount of monetization every game is built for nowadays; Esports has done some of the most harm to gaming as we WANT it to be IMHO.
@Wanted797
@Wanted797 Год назад
Sim racing just doesn’t have the rules like real motorsports. People always push the boundaries all the time. We need better rules.
@gutbuster84
@gutbuster84 Год назад
I agree with some of the other comments here. It's a wider sports problem. If there is a sherry of money and fame being dangled in front of you. You're going to do EVERYTHING possible to try and succeed. The reason it isn't a torrential problem in high skilled physical sports, is becuace over the last 100 years or so we have made advancements to prevent doping and cheating. Secondly, real, harsh, punishment. These aspiring esports drivers will just buy a new account if their old one gets banned. Or buy a new game system. We haven't found it yet, but we have to have real punishment for people ruining the integrity of the games they are cheating on.
@Picks_Productions
@Picks_Productions Год назад
My theory is, not everyone can win, there’s no need to turn into a ‘beep’ for driving so aggressive or whatever it may be. I do it for the fun factor. If it’s not fun, I turn it off.
@brandonmansell
@brandonmansell Год назад
Williams is disgusting and I will no longer support their real life team until actions are taken. Deplorable, when winning matters more than integrity in a gentleman's game
@vpreggie
@vpreggie Год назад
I said this on another streamer's site, but I learned a long time ago that some people will sacrifice EVERYTHING for a win. They will sacrifice their dignity and basically insult the intelligence of everyone in the community for the win. These people play a game based on reality, only so they can twist and exploit EVERY little advantage they can? At what point do the exploits they take advantage of result in them not playing the same game everyone else is? I learned this while playing Wolfenstein: Enemy Territory - which ia an old-school, first-person shooter loosely based on the WWII era. It was hardly realistic, but the game had the premise of being a WWII soldier, using WWII weapons in WWI environments. The problem was that the game allowed you to tweak the graphics in such a way that rendered the surrounding environment all but invisible to the player. So nobody could use the surrounding bushes, trees, hills to hide or take cover. These tweakers would twist the game's graphics so much that it looked like they were playing the game using X-Ray vision in high-contrast mode. These players would argue "But the game let's you do this!", but the majority of other players would complain +(rightfully so) that they simply were not playing the same game we all were playing. They would sacrifice how the game looked and played to gain an unfair advantage, and then expect everyone else to accept their choices. There was no convincing these people otherwise. The game "allowed" it, so they did it. There was no "level playing field", and someone like me who wanted good graphics and good frame rate would be at a huge disadvantage to those who chose to play the game like they were wearing Night-vision goggles. This, in my mind, is cheating, and bringing the community down by forcing everyone to play the same way or get slaughtered. Some people have zero dignity or respect. How do you compete with that?
Далее
My TOP 5 FAVOURITE Racing Sims In 2022
19:51
Просмотров 406 тыс.
11 ming dollarlik uzum
00:43
Просмотров 391 тыс.
ПОЮ ВЖИВУЮ🎙
3:19:12
Просмотров 872 тыс.
How Max Verstappen is a Sim Racing GENIUS
10:59
Просмотров 3,2 млн
I raced against a cheater...
15:28
Просмотров 69 тыс.
My Driving Got Shamed On Reddit
13:52
Просмотров 333 тыс.
Racing Esports is Failing. Here's Why
18:19
Просмотров 34 тыс.
The WORST Advice You Could Ever Get About Simracing
8:45
My Twitter Asked Me To Roast Their Sim Rigs!
14:33
Просмотров 332 тыс.
This NASCAR Race Took NEARLY 5 HOURS To Complete
28:51
Просмотров 402 тыс.
I Got To Race Against An ENTIRE LOBBY Of Racing Drivers
20:28
Racing Esports has a MAJOR problem…
16:32
Просмотров 65 тыс.