Duke Cannon VS Dr.Squatch 

I like Dr. Squatch pine tar, but even when I scrub the hell out of myself with it, it doesn’t have a lingering smell like the Duke cannon soap does after scrubbing with the tactical scrubber. It’s very pleasing and I also enjoy that the Duke Cannon soap is massive and provides a better price for what you get. I feel Dr.Squatch has a strong smell in the package but it unfortunately doesn’t transfer to your skin well. Oh and the Dr.Squatch crumbles to bits when it gets remotely ‘thin’.

So I had this debate with someone already. The comparable ingredients between the bars are the same. It's just that Duke uses the chemical names for the ingredients vs. the "normal words". They're both organic not that that makes any difference rubbing crap on your skin.... i.e. Sodium Chloride === Sea Salt etc....

*"Always bet on Duke"* Got the Bay Rum bar, smells really good and got the tactical scrubber. Love it. Also have a jar of the Bloody Knuckles hand repair balm and holy shit it works so much better than any advance therapy lotion.

FYI- natural ingredients can hurt you and non-natural chemical compounds can be good for you as well. It’s not a good generalization to make that “natural means better for you”.

I've switched from liquid soap to Duke Cannon about a year ago, and I love Duke Cannon. Their beer and whiskey scents have actual beer and whiskey in them, which is great. They also sell a soap on a rope which is great for camping or just every day use. I tell everyone how amazing they are!

Use Duke Cannon and we will win the war by land, air and sea!😁

PSA: I've seen this complaint across many various soap company reviews "the scent smells good in the shower, but I can't smell it later in the day" ......you're NOT supposed to. That's not what soap is designed for. If you can still smell your soap on you at the end of the full day, you probably didn't rinse off well and you're going to have skin as dry as the Sahara Desert if you keep doing that. Advice? This is what we have cologne for gentlemen. I've used some of the Duke Cannon colognes, they're cheap, smell good, and aren't obnoxiously overpowering. (Sometimes do have to reapply the solid cologne midday depending on what you do for work) Also, if you're not a cologne guy, find a body lotion that gives off a nice scent. Outlaw Soaps has some great masculine smelling lotion, albeit a little pricey

Different between the two. Squatch smells better and actually sticks to your body. Dukes will last you about a month depending on how often you shower and

I like the smell of Dr. Squatch's Pine Tar, but it's too rough for me, personally. Fresh Falls, though, is one of the newer scents, and I highly recommend giving that one a try. 🙂

Duke all day!!

The Dr. Squatch smells great, stronger than the Duke Cannon. Not a fan of the oatmeal, salt, or any other rocks and pebbles found in soap. But the new Pine Tar scent from Duke Cannon is a litter stronger than the Fresh Cut Pine and is the new favorite, still not the punch in the face scent when you open the Amazon lock box. Tried a lot of the Duke Cannon soaps and they really deliver the suds, and proceeds from their sales go to support military veterans' organizations.

I used Squatch for a while. Now I use Duke Cannon Here's why. More soap for your dollar I subscribed and those smaller bars of squatch soap wouldn't last all that long Duke Cannon is called "Big Ass Brick of Soap" for a reason One big bar of soap lasts you a long time. And I shower some times twice a day depending on if I've been exercising, working in the yard, etc.

I have many of both currently and Love both brands! They're very similar, Duke's bigger which is good but could be bad if you have small hands. Both smell really good. Dr.Squatch leaves my skin feeling better but not by a huge difference. I'll probably use both...

You and I must have had wildly different experiences with squatch It’s fragrant, but barely out of the tiny cut away. And you got one of the high exfoliant soaps, that’s why your skin is softer…you should exfoliate more. Also in no way did the fragrance last all day.

I like Dr. Squatch quite a bit, but switched over to Bearsville soaps because they have more sales and a bigger variety for that type of soap. I recently ordered a bunch of Duke Cannon soaps and they all smell great. I'm looking forward to giving them a try.

Been using Duke Cannon for a few years now w the tactical scrubber. I’m making a 10oz bar of their soap last almost a month and a half. 👍🏼

I love Duke over the Dr and you can get it at tractor supply for 6.99 a bar when on sale I like the victory bar best also a portion of the sale goes to support veterans

I found Duke Cannon stuff at an outdoor store and got a nice musky cologne and a citrus mint lip balm, I only checked out Dr Squatch after reading the Duke body wash ingredients full of sulfate. Guess I can keep my duke routine by doing the switch to bar now

I like Duke Cannon's Naval Diplomacy body wash. I tried one of the Squatch products and didn't feel like I got ultimately clean and it was too small.

I use the duke cannon I haven’t tied the other one. I was thinking of giving it a shot. But idk I’m happy with what I get. Duke is double the size for the same price sometimes cheaper.

Ay bro what background beat is this? Also im in love with Dr. Squatch and ima be honest the soap you goat is the only scratchy one they have. It was the same for me. And I'm contemplating about buying the duke cannon soaps

I used to use Dr. Squatch, but it runs out so fast and the price is so steep. Duel and cannon lasts so much longer and is so much more bang for your buck

So I've been considering some Duke, and I absolutely love the Dr Squatch pine tar. I know you said Duke isn't as strong-smelling, but would you say it is close scent-wise?

Most, if not all of Dr. Squatch soaps are just The Soap Guy’s soaps packaged differently. He’s based out of Indiana, you can buy it for a much much cheaper price straight from The Soap Guy wholesale.

I bought Dr. because of all the ads too. Went back to Head and Shoulders because the bar didn’t last long but man the squatch bros were right. I noticed headaches and a weight on my scalp after using head and shoulders again. Gonna try Duke. I got their pomade, my woman got it for me. Love it. Smell isn’t overpowering and I got feel it stuck in my hands like other pomades even after washing my hands two or three times.

Does Duke Cannon have the DHT Blocker element to their soaps like Squatch has?

I like them both, but I do like the Dr. Squatch pine tar more than Duke Cannon, I like how much grit is in the bar, but Duke Cannon lasts longer, I love the powerful scent of Dr. Squatch. I use them both, I just switch up during the week.

I've used Squatch for over a year and have never even come close to the smell issue you had. Yes, it smells pretty strong just sitting there, but after the shower is done, the smell doesn't stick around at all. Also the point of the oatmeal is the grit. If you don't like grit, get their soaps without it. I, myself, prefer the ones with various grits for exfoliation. Yours really had a strange wear pattern, too. Mine always stays rectangular. I love what the soap has done for my skin and the price isn't so bad if you get a bundle. I paid about half what you said you did.

I love the duke cannon buffalo trace body wash, finally a body wash that actually makes me smell like a man and sticks with me throughout the day.

Why do I have the compulsion to bite a chunk out of the brick of soap

Hey guys im really new to the mens grooming world, and honestly im inlove with the pine scent from squatch soaps, trying to find a good budget calogne that matches the soap, anyone know any good stuff to buy?

If the bars were the same size how would you have rated them?Any different or still the same?

I usually switch in between dove,axe bergamot sage,Irish spring moisture blast but I'm order a box of Duke cannon bar and bodywash

I liked the Duke cannon soap. Lathers up like crazy. Great smell...and bars last months...Bay rums a good scent too...

Got some Duke Cannon body wash arriving today, I like Dr Squatch a lot. Haven't had the pine tar yet. It is a heavy grit soap they have which some people like, and others don't. They also have zero, and medium grit. They do smell good, yet strong, so you aren't wrong there. I'm slightly bummed that the Duke Cannon soap isn't all natural. I'd pay $20 for an all natural 10 ounce bar of soap honestly. Solid review, and I'm still likely gonna try some of Duke Cannons Bar Soaps.

Duke Cannon Soap is a Dr. Squatch killer! Though my tub is a lot more grungier because I'm using real soap, my skin feels so much better!!!

What is that instrumental? It's fire!

Ive used both of these and its honestly kind of a bad choice of scent for the comparison. They both have much better scents than these two. I also thouth the Squatch pine tar was too much. But the Duke cannon pine is nowhere near as good as their beer soaps or Leaf and Leather, or Buffalo Trace.

i find that the smell isn't really there after i shower with Dr. Squatch... i've tried several different bars, and they almost all seem to melt away quickly... especially when you like really hot showers

I like the oils in DS soaps for dry skin!

The dr squash one was a 10/10 for me

Tried both and I prefer the Duke Canon. My favorite scent is the leaf and leather

I’ve been using Dr. Squatch but the bars are gone after a couple showers. Ordered some Duke.

The Duke Cannon Gun Smoke is my favorite but a close second is the Dr. Squatch Pine Tar. I wish Duke made more products in the gun smoke scent.

I suggest you do something from Dr. Squatch with less grit. Bay Rum is my favorite scent. Freedom Fresh was a limited-time but is still available on eBay and sometimes rack stores. Freedom Fresh has zero grit and smells like a normal soap like Dove or whatever.

I've tried both. Squatch is good but Duke is way better and the bar itself lasts a long time. Plus you can throw it at someone and it won't break.

Im a first buyers with dr squatch & i like that it has that salt added since i work with chemicals i feel they help me remove reduce from my body not all bars have it but i grabbed a lil of everything but so far those that carry that have been my main favorite now down side soaps runs out pretty quick less than a week but guilty it might be my 30-40min showers since i shower 1st a day since our oils of our body are good so yeah but that bar runs pretty dawm quick for 8dollars now i been viewing videos here an there i found this other guy that was weighting the soap bars the packaged would say 5onz but they would be almost 4.2 around there thats crazy i need healthy products but for that price i would like my bar bigger.

Salt and oatmeal is for exfoliation. Duke cannon also makes a pine tar soap.

I would argue that doctor squatch is hands down a better quality soap, but I just can't justify the price when I'm satisfied with Duke.

I love them all! GIMME ALL OF THE COOL YUM SMELL BARS!

All of the dr squatch soaps I've tried, the smell goes away after I rinse. I haven't tried Duke yet. I see they have a rum version. Bar is huge though..

Duke is the way to go! Hands down

That's so weird. i found dr.sqautch to be really weak, but it could be to me not having such a strong sense of smell.i just ordered a Duke cannon bar of soap, and i can't wait to use it.

i love the dr squatch pine tar.

Just bought my first bar of duke. Love the smell.

I tried Dr Squatch I had like a Cool water it was gone in a week. I recently ordered Duke cannon Midnight Swim and I love it just ordered Bay Rum, Bourbon and Frothy the beer men I love it! Duke Cannon for the win

You should throw RIDGE THICK into the mix for conversation.

For both brands, use a kitchen knife and cut off a small piece at a time. This allows you to sample multiple "flavors" in a single month.

Get Duke Cannon. Its basically natural and cleans your body just as good. Dr squatch is overrated. The soap will last you like 3 or 4 showers. Get yourself a big ass brig of soap not a dissolving square

Pine tar smells good but doesn't last at all. I've switched to Duke Cannon Bay Rum. I prefer DC

My experience with dr squatch is ok but not the best. My first bar was pine tar which smells great but god forbid it stained my shower. Plus they don’t last long about a month and a half with showers once a day or every few days, now on my last bar. Today I bought like 7 bars from dukes and they last for months

The pine tar is has the oatmeal for exfoliation.

Just got my 1st order of Duke Cannon today. Tried Dr. Squatch and wasnt thrilled. Smelled great in the package but in the shower I smelled NOTHING. Perhaps its the water in my town but Idk. Got high hopes for Duke Cannon though.

I'm a Dr Squatch fan big time, I just got bar of Duke for Christmas, I don't like soap that has harsh chemicals in it, and having brown skin some soap makes your skin to dry, and The Dr. Keeps feeling clean all day even after working with horses all day and working out I don't get funky junk or pitts from sweating with Dr believe or not with the Dr I don't wear deodorant anymore and no I don't stink my wife would kill me for funky, I will let you know how the Duke stands up from good days works or how it feel on darker skin tones and if I get funky with my bad self I not going to use the Duke except to wash my hands and not on my nurts & babies arm holding an apple

Duke Cannon is a little heavy on the scent, but damn if their marketing isn't genius. I thought Dr. Squatch was genius, but Duke Cannon has that "most interesting man" packaging.

I have been trying out some of these men's soap and shower companies, trying to find out which ones I like over others. Regarding Dr squatch, the pine tar is the only soap fragrance of theirs that I actually do like, precisely because it is so strong. I don't want some whisper or pretense of fragrance in the bar, I want a powerful, muscular scent that threatens to knock me on my ass. However strong that s*** might be in the shower, it definitely does not last long on my skin. All the other squats fragrances, in my humble opinion, or mediocre at best. But I just recently tried out Duke Cannon I got the sawtooth body wash and two in one stuff for my hair, end up the Three soap companies I've tried so far, bearsville is the third one, Duke Cannon is the worst by far.. at least when it comes to fragrance, Duke Cannon sucks balls. Strictly in terms of fragrance, baresville is the winner from what I have tried out so far. But I do like the scotch hair care stuff, though it's quite expensive. But a strong pine tar fragrance from squash? No, that's an asset

Duke KILLED EM

They both make men smell better. So they’re both great

$6.99 plus $2 off in HEB this week for Duke Cannon 11/2021

It does seems like when dr.squach soup being all natural it's like I'm sure women would like to have something like that. I do remember the dr.squach comicals saying that men's body wash from other companies is like washing your body with dish soap but I am starting to wonder if it goes the same way with womans body wash if that is the same way to

anyone try dr. jekyll soap?

The fact that Dr. Squatch apparently blocked Duke Cannon on Twitter makes the comparison so much funnier

Can't go wrong with The Duke.

Duke cannon camp fire is the sh!t ,smells great ,only thing I wish Duke would do is put some grit in a few bars besides that I got a huge stack of Duke ,an Duke cannon make s there soap like they did back in day .

Dr Squatch is more expensive , has a slightly stronger scent up front , but the bars melt faster in shower or bath use, and will crumble quickly( best to use one of those shower scrub or definitely a towel) and with switch you need to wash it down from your skin Duke lasts longer per bar ( scent comes on strong under hot water and lathers up good) definitely pair it with a solid cologne Duke also has better sales - a 4 pack of Duke is $26-29 vs Dr Squatch 4 pack at $32- 36 Choose Dr Squatch on dirty days ( digging up backyard or working on car) but Duke Cannon as a bar can literally last a month of before and after work showers Salute the Duke!

after being a Irish Springs man for a very long time I broke down and got Dr squatch pine tar soap and deodorant. absolutely love the smell now if only they can come out with a ceder scent I would be all over that!!

Those ingredients in Duke Cannon are not chemicals, but derived from natural products.

Must have been background noise (on my side) but when you mentioned Oatmeal in the Dr Squatch soap, I thought you said Opium. That would make for a different bathing experience (and scent) but since many employers require random drug testing, also maybe not the best idea. Oh well...

As far as I can tell (no expert) the list of chemicals on the DC isn't that bad, chemicals don't necessarily mean bad for you. It's a small list too and the ones on the list just tell me it's decent soap with not too much added

The shipping is like 6 dollars how do I get it for $9.99

Love both of these soaps but I can’t believe you only gave it a 6 out of 10 , dr squatch is better hands down ,me and my kids both use it and it is expensive but there is no doubt it’s much better and better for you , no bad chemicals , smells awesome and it’s all natural leaving your skin feelng amazing, I only get Duke cannon when I run out and I brake out from any other soap including Duke cannon but not as bad , hands down dr squatch is a 10 out of 10 and much better

I like the dr squatch but it makes a mess out of your shower. You have to clean the shower before it dries

I think outlaw Soaps have some of the best smells. But for the price I'll take duke any day. You get way more soap for your money

Now the taste test

My Duke Cannon bar lasted so much longer than Dr Squatch. With the price of each compared to the difference in longevity Duke Cannon wins for me.

I disagree. My pine tar bar wasn’t strong at all. Hardly had a smell

Despite the fact that duke is a better value for money and the smell lasts after wards if you pay more for you soap you need to use a soap saver and take it out of your bathroom to dry after. Don’t expose any nice soap with more water than you need to and it WILL last longer….i don’t think duke has as many “bad” chemicals as people are claiming…also for the love of god guys use a loofah or a wash rag. The grit just worsens your skin by tearing it. Unless you have a huge patch of dry skin that needs to go why even use the bar directly on your body? That’s gonna waste a lot of the soap anyways and the rag/loofah will lightly exfoliate you as long as you don’t have the dove branded one 😂

So I have a white shower and tub, the dr squatch pine tar rinses black and stained my tub, their soaps don’t last me long and never have a strong enough scent, duke cannon on the other hand, doesn’t rinse black and doesn’t stain my shower, plus its bigger, last me longer and has a stronger smell. Duke cannon all day!

Duke canonn is Twice the size for basically the same price, and is a far far far better product. Also they support the troops so it’s a win win. Duke Cannon wins by a mile.

Gun Smoke by duke cannon is amazing

Dr. Squat has if your a blue collar worker like me that need something strong. Duke for the white collar worker like my brother that seats on a desk all day .

I got a bar of duke at buccees gas station. $6.99.

Oatmeal is great for the skin. Loaded with beta-glucans. Thanks showing the ingredient labels and thanks for the warning about the strength of the Dr. S. Scent.

Squatch smells good, 5oz bar, doesn’t last long at all because they are single milled. Duke some smells good, 10oz bar, lasts forever because they’re triple milled. No brainer. At Military PX/BX duke goes for 6$. I picked up two Frothy The Beer Man couple days ago for 4$ a piece. Squatch at Walmart goes for 10-12$ here in Alaska

Try bay rum

Duke cannon is the greatest soap especially the pine

Duke all day

Duke Cannon tastes better and lasts longer on pizza and pancakes. Dr Squatch does go down smoother with coffee but does terrible in the winter on car alternators.

Duke Cannon was great until they added Tetrasodium Glutamate Diacetate

I prefer the natural ingredients of Dr Squatch but the briccs arent big so of course Duke Cannon would last longer