Because as sweet and perfect as Antonia was, they were never meant to be endgame. This story was an exit for Dylan to reunite with his first true love, and according to Kelly and many of us, the great love of his life - Brenda Walsh!
Well, I’m sure Brenda would’ve been able to get the name if Jim didn’t keep sticking his nose in their business! Dylan McKay - “I just got too close to all of you! I WON’T make that mistake again!” Also, Dylan McKay - “It’s not that I don’t love you.”