Тёмный

Emily Brontë - The Strange One? 

Professor Graeme Yorston
Подписаться 104 тыс.
Просмотров 44 тыс.
50% 1

Emily Brontë - The Strange One?
Watch the full video here: • Emily Brontë - The Str...
Emily Brontë is the least well known of the Brontë sisters. She died at the age of 30, having published one major work - Wuthering Heights - a strange, rambling gothic masterpiece that puzzled and dismayed critics at the time, who were troubled by its moral ambiguity.
Like her novel, Emily was also regarded as strange - solitary, uncompromising, uninterested in small talk or social conventions and either painfully shy or bluntly antisocial.
In this video I draw upon my 30 years' experience in psychiatry to explore the life and inner world of Emily Brontë trying to work out whether her strangeness was just the eccentricity of creative genius or something else - an autistic spectrum disorder perhaps.

Опубликовано:

 

31 янв 2023

Поделиться:

Ссылка:

Скачать:

Готовим ссылку...

Добавить в:

Мой плейлист
Посмотреть позже
Комментарии : 83   
@isabelalzateestrada
@isabelalzateestrada Год назад
Isn’t Anne Brönte the least well known of the Brönte Sisters? I’ve heard of Emily, and of Wurthering Heights but I have never heard of Anne or any of her books.
@professorgraemeyorston
@professorgraemeyorston Год назад
Fair point, Anne is less well known as a writer, but she left more writings and letters - making Emily the most elusive if we want to try to understand her personality.
@isabelalzateestrada
@isabelalzateestrada Год назад
@@professorgraemeyorston okay that makes sense, I thought that you meant from a general public point of view instead of a psychological one.
@susanmccormick6022
@susanmccormick6022 Год назад
Try Anne's books.They are awesome.
@youisastar3246
@youisastar3246 Год назад
​@@professorgraemeyorston but your fact is wrong in the first place. Anne is the least well-known although experts have said its because of being overshadowed by her sisters. Her work stands on its own. Charlotte lived a couple of years more and had some career. I believe she met the King/Queen or was honoured during this time. Yet, Wuthering Heights was enough to put Emily at an equal footing as Charlotte. It was published posthumously and had Charlotte not lived longer to promote herself and her work, Wuthering Heights would have easily overshadowed Jane Eyre. Even today, you can't compare the two. Charlotte was a good sister who lost Emily and Anne within a span of two years. Emily died at 30 and Anne, 29.
@__str
@__str Год назад
The whole Brontë family experienced unfortunate situations throughtout their whole lives. Diseases and death were so common. They all died very early.
@Alfakkin
@Alfakkin 9 месяцев назад
Very true ❤
@Lady_dromeda
@Lady_dromeda 4 месяца назад
None of them had children either did they?
@annettekellner6232
@annettekellner6232 11 месяцев назад
Autism was the first condition that came to mind as you started listing her problems. Many university professors are on the autistic spectrum.
@professorgraemeyorston
@professorgraemeyorston 11 месяцев назад
It is much more common than people realise.
@c.s.70
@c.s.70 10 месяцев назад
@@professorgraemeyorston Yes agree more common than ppl realize, many well known historical figures like Beethoven and Mozart were also clearly on autistic spectrum.
@artangel4172
@artangel4172 21 день назад
To diagnose ASD the person needs to be alive….
@lunarmoon423
@lunarmoon423 Год назад
Emilys love for the darkest of winter days, the cold lashings of the rain as she walked on the sodden moors with Keeper, brought more happiness to her than any Van Gough sun... she thrived on privacy independence.. her love for the wild open spaces brought the essence of her creation in the form of the wild unforgiven HEATHCLIFF,.. she knew him well... untamed, unmanageable, yet in an instance forgiving.. she knew him,.. she was him.....
@professorgraemeyorston
@professorgraemeyorston Год назад
Did she know him or did she imagine him?
@lunarmoon423
@lunarmoon423 Год назад
@@professorgraemeyorston She was the female him...
@ilovenature9077
@ilovenature9077 11 месяцев назад
No, Emily was a deeply empathic person! The protagonist of her book, on the other hand, had no mercy for anyone,!
@c.s.70
@c.s.70 10 месяцев назад
@@ilovenature9077 Emily WAS Heathcliff at her core, the deep impassioned true raw heart of Heathcliff, having the capacity to love & feel deeply + intensely to the extreme. A deeply passionate fiery soul she was. It was deep empathy that compelled her to channel her passions & their explorations in the form of fiction. It was empathy that kept Emily from acting out & potentially hurting others too feeble to understand her intensity & truth. She felt intensely yet would not hurt others in real life if she could help it.
@ilovenature9077
@ilovenature9077 10 месяцев назад
@@c.s.70 I disagree! Emily was kind, generous, selfless. The male protagonist was a psychopath, interested only in himself. He, of course, didn't even love Catherine!
@BillyBelle101
@BillyBelle101 Год назад
It's honestly an astounding novel for even today's time. The melancholy darkness of this novel is other worldy. She puts words together that don't seem to belong but the emotion behind them makes them fit perfectly. There's a sense of light within the overwhelming darkness which seems to be Emily's or (Katherine's) ultimate and overwhelming love for the land that she grew up in. Anytime Emily talked about the land, she made sure to bluntly state how intense the landscape actually is and how miserable it can be but that its become so familiar and somewhat peaceful in that sense for her. She can constantly spot something beautiful within it... Katherine had the yearning for change and greater things but constantly battled the overwhelming need for what's familiar and dear, which is possible that that is what Emily battled as well. That's probably what k*lled Katherine in the novel. She couldn't find inner peace with herself and that stumped a lot of people back then, and even today. The idea that someone can become so stressed and constantly at war with their contrasting feelings that it can literally k*ll them from the stress of it all, was and is, simply unbelievable to many people. I can definitely see that Emily could have been autistic. A brilliant mind all around though. Wuthering Heights and Jane Eyre have a similar vibe but Wuthering Heights is definitely more of an emotional and mental rollercoaster.. its a novel you really have to sit back and decipher the real and underlying meaning behind certain phrases or situations. And all of this is excluding the stresses that she fought with her incredible love for Heathcliff.
@professorgraemeyorston
@professorgraemeyorston Год назад
Thank you for that eloquent analysis.
@c.s.70
@c.s.70 10 месяцев назад
What an insightful comment! Completely agree.
@terencebennison6275
@terencebennison6275 8 месяцев назад
I just love Chloe Pirrie in the role of Emily Bronte in To walk invisible' , an excellent actress who deserves many high profile roles.
@professorgraemeyorston
@professorgraemeyorston 8 месяцев назад
It's a great movie.
@Literaturedoodle_64
@Literaturedoodle_64 26 дней назад
If you like Wuthering Heights, you should check out here poems too. They're re just stunning.
@CassyC253
@CassyC253 Месяц назад
Or she could have been an introvert, extremely shy & like most of us introverts, extremely disappointed in other people (judgement, prejudices, behaviours, social norms etc) food for thought.😊 🙂
@professorgraemeyorston
@professorgraemeyorston Месяц назад
Yes, but some of her behaviour was unusual even for shy introverts.
@DeadGuye1995
@DeadGuye1995 11 месяцев назад
One of the best and saddest books and movies ive seen(b/w laurence olivier film only)
@user-jv9yt8ms1u
@user-jv9yt8ms1u 3 месяца назад
The moral of the novel: there is no moral 💀 I think i might have nostalgia too ❤😂
@cherrylee1103
@cherrylee1103 10 месяцев назад
I agree that Emily was likely autistic.
@justonefyx
@justonefyx 10 месяцев назад
She was asocial, not antisocial.
@professorgraemeyorston
@professorgraemeyorston 10 месяцев назад
What if the story about the dog is true.
@justonefyx
@justonefyx 10 месяцев назад
@@professorgraemeyorston These terms define traits, not states. In other words things you always do vs a one off thing. Her beating the dog was a one off thing in a STATE of anger, not a trait. If one violent act defined someone as antisocial, then everyone would be antisocial. Her asocial behavior of not wanting to talk to others was a lifelong trait. So when you called Emily antisocial, were you referring to her beating the dog or not talking to others?
@tomasomaonaigh7659
@tomasomaonaigh7659 10 дней назад
Nostalgia, it's not what it used to be.
@kirkpetersjr
@kirkpetersjr 7 месяцев назад
Because people dont like being around other people most foul want to enjoy their moments surrounded in beauty should not imply a disorder. Psychiatry is always with the implicit assumption that there is a standard to compare against.
@birdyjireh6391
@birdyjireh6391 8 месяцев назад
As an extremely introverted person, I think Emily was just an introvert.
@innocentnemesis3519
@innocentnemesis3519 7 месяцев назад
And as an autistic person, Emily sounds autistic asf. Neither of us can know for certain. 😂
@theforgotten1213
@theforgotten1213 6 месяцев назад
I kinda relate to Emily. Is tha bad?
@professorgraemeyorston
@professorgraemeyorston 6 месяцев назад
We are what we are - trying to understand what makes us happy is an important part of life.
@dayzeereyes128
@dayzeereyes128 7 месяцев назад
Y’all call everyone autistic now. Its so trendy.
@professorgraemeyorston
@professorgraemeyorston 7 месяцев назад
It is "trendy" because it is becoming apparent that many of history's greatest artists, writers and scientists were autistic.
@sunkintree
@sunkintree 4 месяца назад
There's a valid point to be made about it being trendy to self-diagnose and project diagnose others, but this condition didn't just show up in the past however many decades it's been recognized. There were absolutely people who were autistic in the past, lol
@Stonebrick
@Stonebrick 9 месяцев назад
Don’t you think it might a little insensitive to feature autistic people on a show called “insane history”?
@professorgraemeyorston
@professorgraemeyorston 9 месяцев назад
I can see why some people might be troubled by this, but my intention with the channel is to highlight individuals who have had mental disorders in order to challenge some of the historical beliefs and current misconceptions around mental illness and this necessarily involves using terminology that is out of date today.
@Sandrine_Damfino
@Sandrine_Damfino 8 месяцев назад
​@@professorgraemeyorstonautism is not a mental illness.
@kiryuchan860
@kiryuchan860 7 месяцев назад
​@@professorgraemeyorstonit's still rather demeaning.
@phillipstroll7385
@phillipstroll7385 Год назад
Bs. She was an athiest but had to keep it silent and she hated hypocrisy. She wrote more than wh and anyone who had read her work knows she was perfectly normal. They'll also know she was a stoic, an athiest and she hated wilful ignorance and hypocrisy. She wrote an entire work speaking of against hypocrisy. That's why she shunned most of society because she couldn't stand weakness of character.
@professorgraemeyorston
@professorgraemeyorston Год назад
You can't make a diagnosis by reading someone's poems.
@SIGSEGV1337
@SIGSEGV1337 Год назад
She was very clearly not an atheist. What's the deal with people projecting their own ideals and fan-fictions onto Emily to force her into being some kind of frankenstein 21st century girlboss?
@phillipstroll7385
@phillipstroll7385 Год назад
@@SIGSEGV1337 excuse me, she was. It's plain as day in her letters and there is no shame in it. She was absolutely 100% a romantic. She tells us in her letters, writings, etc.
@SIGSEGV1337
@SIGSEGV1337 Год назад
@@phillipstroll7385 I'm genuinely curious what letter could have possibly made you think this. Everything points to her being an unorthodox Christian. Her poems and book both clearly presume the existence of a God and this is referenced repeatedly. Even arguing she was some kind of pagan makes more sense than that she was an atheist. The only reference any of the Brontes made to atheism is Charlotte calling them untrustworthy in her letter to James Taylor. I scarcely see any reason why Emily would feel any different.
@phillipstroll7385
@phillipstroll7385 Год назад
@@SIGSEGV1337 you wouldn't. Especially if you believe one sister believed something therefore every other lesson in the house believed the same thing. Smh
@ichoosejoy2712
@ichoosejoy2712 3 месяца назад
I laughed out loud at how idiotic and ignorant this is. Don't you know anything about introversion? Everything you are saying are signs of being an introvert. Being anti social is often due to someone being hurt by people or disliking the awful things that people say and do. Who could blame her? I cant function around people because they have put me through so much misery and I find human beings so toxic. But i am not mentally ill, just an introverted empath. Like Emily I adore nature and animals. My advice is you study a bit more about introversion before you make an introvert think they are autistic!
@Literaturedoodle_64
@Literaturedoodle_64 25 дней назад
You do have autism, sir.
@Jeanhollywoodold
@Jeanhollywoodold Год назад
She was literally just a Leo. Leave us alone
@professorgraemeyorston
@professorgraemeyorston Год назад
If you're suggesting it was her star sign, I don't agree.
@Jeanhollywoodold
@Jeanhollywoodold 11 месяцев назад
@@professorgraemeyorstonhave you ever met a leo? we’re all like this
@LilaCerullos
@LilaCerullos 11 месяцев назад
Dude, just chill, not everyone believes in astrology, and generalizing is one of the dumbest things anyone can do, astrology is a nonsense without foundation, i am not of the sign of Leo and I feel totally identified with how they describe Emily, on the contrary my close ones who are of this sign are the opposite, the Leo's that i have known personally and with whom I live every day are extremely extroverted, but not for that reason I will put everyone of that sign in a bag, because astrology does not exist. You can have your own beliefs but don't get defensive with someone else simply because they don't pay attention to such trifles.
@ilovenature9077
@ilovenature9077 11 месяцев назад
She was Scorpio Ascendant!
@c.s.70
@c.s.70 10 месяцев назад
She was BOTH. They are not mutually exclusive. She was on the spectrum AND a Leo Sun, but Scorpio Rising/Ascendant which she is, describes her and the nature of her works most accurately.
@Emilyb21-dm3bf
@Emilyb21-dm3bf 5 месяцев назад
Or just liked to be at home not everyone has a disorder
@professorgraemeyorston
@professorgraemeyorston 5 месяцев назад
Sure, but did she like to be at home or was she unable to function in the world?
@Emilyb21-dm3bf
@Emilyb21-dm3bf 5 месяцев назад
@@professorgraemeyorston I think she was in love with nature some people want to be in the countryside she didn't like busy places. I always thought she might be gay which might have added anxiety in public places. I live in a house that she came to visit and the house opposite me is the one she got her idea for wuthering heights . My 1500s farm had a big telescope to look at the stars at the time. I'm not far from Ann Lister estate either I can get there and walk through countryside to get there 2 mile away. So I get why she preferred the countryside
Далее
Who was the real Woman in White?
24:11
Просмотров 4,6 тыс.
БАТЯ И ТЁЩА😂#shorts
00:58
Просмотров 4,4 млн
Wuthering Heights (1939)
1:39:37
Просмотров 192 тыс.
Charles Bukowski - Individuality
3:31
Просмотров 46 тыс.
Book Review | Jane Eyre by Charlotte Brontë
6:10
Просмотров 57 тыс.
The Most Controversial Children's Book in History
40:38
Emily Bronte - full documentary
23:45
Просмотров 73 тыс.