Endless Narrative : Cosmic | Recording 

It's fascinating how their vocal matches with their represent colors. Wendy voice blue like flawless water/river, Seulgi voice yellow like sunlight/summer, Joy voice green like fairytale/spring, Yeri voice purple like galaxy/unique, Irene voice pink like lovely/soft cotton candy

Moonshine being there even just for a bit is so nice to see. They've contributed so much in red velvet's music over the years

Wendy can be a vocal guide. She has the sense and know how to make it great

4:34 Wendy sounds like Irene 5:08 Wendy sounds like Joy 5:35 Wendy sounds like Yeri 5:43 Wendy sounds like Seulgi SHE'S A WITCH CONFIRMED

Wendy's warm up being the whole song 😭😭😭

So Wendy sings the whole song as a guide to the other members like she has been doing for a while now, and the other members do an amazing job bringing their magic to the song. This is why Red Velvet are my favorite female vocal group in kpop! They all absolutely slay 💖💛💎💚💜

I love watching Wendy record. When she sings, she expresses the song through her whole body. It’s amazing to watch. I am endlessly in awe of her limitless skills.

Joy’s “cosmic love” is like one of the best things i’ve ever heard in my whole entire life. Cosmic really suit them so much, i really loveeee this song

Yeri sounds so powerful in her lower register omg 😭😭😭

I expected SM to release this in 2 weeks 😭. We accept the MV being delayed for 44 mins now 😭

Wendy doesn't even need studio effects. Her unprocessed voice is so full and resonant.

We' re not talking enough about the importance of Yeri's low harmonies in Red Velvet sound

wendy who perfect her vocals everytime and paying attention to every single detail in her singing and delivery... like thats a real vocalist!

Dayum, Wendy come first then sing whole song to warm her voice up? That's my girl 😆

wendy is the music genius! she's not just listening to the director, but also gives her opinions. love to see her and the director discussing about what sounds better. 💙💙💙💙💙

The producer has been working with Red Velvet for a long time. They will correct what needs to be corrected and if it is appropriate then they approves it

Wendy said she had a cold, but wait, she nail it when recording, I can't even hear any missing notes or pitch. Yeoksi, uri Main Vocalist, undoubtable 💙👏👏👏🫰

Wendy: the Power of the vocal Joy: the Color of the vocal Yeri: the Harmony of the vocal Seulgi: the Emotion/Energy of vocal Irene: the Red Velvet of the vocal They are THE VOCAL kpop group!!! Wahhhh i love my cake girls so muchhhhhhh 💙💛💗💜💚

I feel like Yeri really shines in middle to lower ranges. I'm glad she's getting to show that here❤

웬디는 진짜 무슨 경지에 오른 사람같다.. 잘한다는 말로도 모자름

레코딩 비하인드가 가장 기대되는 아티스트 1위.. 그 기대를 충족시켜주는 아티스트 레드벨벳,,

3센터 이제 퍼포먼스 비디오도 주세요

It's so fascinating watching Wendy take feedback from the director and instantly transform her technique and tone to suit. Truly the best vocalist in K-pop.

Wendy has a lot of potential. We need her solos more

Damn wendy is layering every foundations needed. She is very detailed and quick to catch on. Thats why her part always sound extraordinary. I've always loved to see wendy's craft in recording studio. Amazing!

Wendy is a monster when it comes to singing.

백보컬을 코러스 싱어 안쓰고 자체 샘플로 하는 아이돌은 드문데 그중에서 레드벨벳은 별의별 파트에 쓰는 세세한 보이스 샘플까지 직접 해서 정말 대단함

스엠는 비하인드 영상에 뭐 처리를 안 하는 것 같아서 좋음...그래 쌩으로 보여줘야 진짜 레코딩 비하인드이지

u know what’s interesting about rv? it’s the fact that this is not even the first recording bts that we have witnessed so far but we always find ourselves shocked by their vocals each dmn time like woah… esp wendy the technique is impeccable!!

웬디 슬기 조이가 일단 틀을 잡아놓으면 아이린과 예리가 사이사이 틈을 메워넣는 느낌. 이렇게 화음 차곡차곡 쌓고 라이브에서도 하나도 놓치는 거 없이 다 해주니까 사랑하지 않을 수 있나?! 이번 노래 너무좋다. 41개국 1위 라더라. 홍보 1도 안해주는데 그정도면 아직 레벨 안 시들었다. 아직 건재하다고.

Never realized that Kenzie is actually this perfectionist lol. I mean RV has known her since probably a decade and even before their debut but her being a perfectionist during recording is really intimidating somehow even for RV themselves..... Now I get why the atmosphere is a bit tense here

Idk why but sometimes i adore their raw vocals more than the audio version🥹

40분짜리 레코딩 비하인드를 내준다? 사실상 과시죠

아니 웬디 보컬은 진심 ‘득음’ 이 단어를 그대로 구현시켜놓은거같아요…진짜 득음했다는말 밖에 안나옴 보는 내내 감탄만 나오네 🥹

빅마마 리더 신교수님은 웬디보컬을 이제 보컬기술의영역을 벗어난 그 너머로 넘어갈 수준이라고했음 유튜브하시는 보컬트레이너 장효진님도 자기 생각에 웬디가 여돌 보컬원탑을 새롭게 차지했을뿐아니라 보컬기술 감정전달 모두 탈아시안급이라고 인터뷰했었고 같이작업했던 모노트리 프로듀서들도 최근의 웬디보컬을 감정전달이나 기술적인면이나 음악해석이나 그에따른 보완까지 모두 완벽해서 만랩보컬 이라 평한적있고 cn블루정용화 다비치이해리 어반자카파조현아 같은 가수분들도 개인적으로 웬디를 현시점 가장뛰어난 여성or여돌 보컬리스트라 생각한다고 말했었고.... 이제 11년차인데 아직도 무섭게 성장중인게 대박이고 심지어 이정도 수준으로 완숙한 보컬리스트중엔 가장젊음 반박은 할거면 위에 저분들한테 직접하세요 제 의견 아니구 그저 저분들이 방송에서 한말이나 인터뷰를 옮겨왔을뿐입니다 ㅎㅎ

just realized Wendy had a cold after seeing the comments?!! how can she sounds soooo perfect

Wendy is truly the backbone of Red Velvet vocal and harmonization

Wendy is now at the level of director. She directs herself 😭💙

everytime red velvet records with kenzie i keep getting flashback to when they were recording power up's chorus(?) and the banana parts all together in one room😭

Man.... Wendy is amazing, she got in and started nailing it from the second she opened her mouth.... main vocal of the century ❤

Wendy’s vocal is always powerful and cheerful at the same time. You can clearly hear her singing while smiling!

I love how Wendy goes into the recording booth half awake and casually nailing the whole song by herself. My Cosmic Love Wendy 🩵

WENDY IS THE BACKBONE OF RV'S VOCALS NO DOUBT

The amount of layering, damn Wendy. And that bridge? Beautiful.

왁 뭐야 왤케 빨리 올려줌..? 레코딩은 레벨이 젤 재밌음 화음 넣는 과정들 다 볼 수 있어서ㅜㅜ

Wendy: I haven't warmed up yet... I have a cold... Also Wendy: sings everything perfectly

Wendy pre chorus, adlibs and ending highnote is the main dish for this song!

Irene’s voice sounding more beautiful each comeback. You can tell she’s been practicing

와 스엠아 레코딩 먼저주는건 처음아니냐...? 화나게했다가 좋게했다가 오락가락하는게 컨셉인가???

Wendy's positive energy is bright enough to enlighten all solar system, I LOVE HER!

웬디가 진짜 레드벨벳에서 중요한 존재구나...

레코딩 영상부터 뜨는 그룹의 기개는 뭔가 다르다.

Tired from work but Son Seungwan’s voice makes it all go away. I love you angel 💙 I hope to see you even just once.

wendy recorded this while she has a cold is really a testament of how great of a singer she is 😭💙 i also love wendy’s layering well actually all of them it’s so beautiful ! the bridge is so angelic and gorgeous that the aliens will take me away

I love Seulgi saying: “Can I listen to Wendy in the Vibrato parts?” It really shows that the members trust Wendy when it comes to vocals and how the song should sound. I love them so much❤

Wendy stays as the artist with the most comfort in the recording studio. She is in her element and I love to see her just vibe whenever she's in that booth.

웬디 코 막혔다면서 영상 처음부터 우리 고막 엄청 시원하게 뚫어주고 시작하네…

웬디 날라다닌다 진짜 ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ 벅차오르는 애드립 들을 때마다 어떻게 사람이 이렇게 노래부르지 감탄함....

if they makes a korean disney princess it has to be wendy's voice

Wendy's raw vocal is amazing!!

It’s always insane to see Wendy stacking her vocals 🤯

확고한 메보가 얼마나 팀에 중요한지..그 메보를 받쳐주는 탄탄한 보컬라인이 중요하다는걸 새삼느낌

yeri’s vocal layering and lower octave is so addictive!!! love how the girls’ voices all complement each other to create that cohesive ‘red velvet’ sound 🫶🏻

Irene and Yeri’s little “Naeng”🥺

16:35 joy giving the staff candies is the cutest thing ever 😭💚💚💚

manifest ✨whole album recording video✨ because i really need to hear Red Velvet's raw vocals in Sunflower, Last Drop and Love Arcade

wendy as always being the first to be the guide for the others

수록곡 레코딩도 주세요!!!!!!!! 선플라워... 라스트드롭..... 러브 아케이드..... 버블...... 나잇 드라이브..... 모두.....🤤

손승완 너무 스윗해… 잘 알고 있는 사실이지만 초반에 대화나누고 잘 가라고 인사해주는 것도 너무 좋다 그냥 웬디만 보면 흐뭇미소짓게돼…

Damn, Wendy is FIRE 🔥 I hope she get the recognition she deserve more, her talent is no joke! 🔥

Wendy ATE!!! She's trully in her element

i enjoy seeing wendy being a friendly bubbly baby like she always does

웬디는 이제 디렉터 수준이네 부르면서 본인이 디렉팅함... 대단

If you listen carefully, there is a difference between the lyrics of the demo version and those sung by the members. wendy's raw voice is incredible

I love that we got to see Wendy interacting with Moonshine!!

3일 만에 레코딩 받은 게 왜 이리 감동ㅠㅠ 진짜 자식 키우는 거 같애

Wendy voice very amazing

스엠아 레벨 잘 챙겨주세요 스엠이 잘 되는 이유는 레벨같은 잔혹동화적 컨셉의 레벨과 쇠맛의 에스파와 네오적 엔시티 등 다양한 컬러가 한 회사에서 잘 있어주는게 있는거여 그러니까 놓지말고요 잘 해주세여~ 팬들은 이렇게 목빠져라 기다리고 기대하고 아직 목말라합니다!!! 이렇게 잼있는 소스를 가진 그룹 없다요~ 그건 본인들이 더 잘 알고있으리라 믿습니다!!!

레벨은 진짜 절대 누구 목소리 하나라도 빠지면 안 돼ㅠㅠ 5명의 조합이 그냥 너무 완벽해

화음 쌓는 과정이 제일 재밌음… 정말 오래 가두고 화음만 10분 쌓고싶음

Wendy's vocals... OMG! I absolutely love hearing her in the studio! I am always amazed by her vocals. Ain't nobody doing it like her. She can sing anything in any way in any voice. Like how does she have 10 voices?!

joy is really crazy with how much control she has of her voice

Wendy is so professional, I love how she takes the lead and isn’t afraid to give her artistic direction of certain parts which makes it sound 10x better 🥹

귀한 그룹...잘 대우해주세요....11년차에 이런 폼 유지하는 그룹 흔치 않아요 에스엠 부탁드려요😢

목소리가 어떻게 저렇냐곸ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ 진짜 에스엠 레벨한테 잘해라 이런 그룹이 어딨어!! ㅠㅠㅠ

그냥 서로 음색이 잘 어울려서 합이 좋게 느껴지는 게 아니라.. 엄청난 고민과 노력 끝에 만들어진 화음이라는 걸 알게 되면.. 레벨의 우주에 갇히는 수밖에 없다

I love how relevant Wendy's main vocal position is, Seulgi literally using her recorded chorus as a melody guide and Wendy giving Joy pointers in singing the song 🩷

I always love how Wendy always giving her input and wanting to try it different ways to get the best out of the song, . They're all truly professionals and care about the work they put out.

승완이는 진짜 뭐지... 왜 점점 잘하지 어떻게 맨날 실력이 발전하지 부를 때 마다 음원이 막 재생되는데

The fact that Wendy try to put so much detail to the singing, no wonder i'm getting emotional everytime listening to that part especialy on the 9:20 💙💙💙

irene’s voice is so chic, her parts suits her so well

Wendy's throat is very clean and relaxing :')

Irene and Wendy sound alike at times! I'm always amazed by that. Irene's definitely grown as a vocalist over the years, and I have no idea how Wendy keeps getting better and better when she is already the best 😂😂😂

Wendy's raw vocal, energy and professionalism always reel me in

40분 내내 옥구슬 굴러가는 소리밖에 안 들리는데 어디가 레코딩 비하인드인거지 진짜 이 분야는 레드벨벳 못 이긴다 너무 좋아ㅜ

Really love how each member has a distinct voice...... you immediately know who's singing just by ear. Then all the vocals come together to make something greater than the sum of their parts.

Love how the Red Velvet members enable directly to adjust their vocal tone/sound technically based on the PD's vision.. showcase how advanced their skills are as talented singer & idols

그래 레벨이들 레코딩 영상은 항상 옳지

Wendy's singing is really another level. Such a talent

WENDY THEY WILL NEVER STOP ME FROM LOVING YOU (as a seulgi stan)