The dog had an internal experience and awareness before learning to communicate with humans. We are just beginning to hear a fraction of it thanks to these buttons. The dog has a deep journey all their own.
Part of the reason we believe religion is biological. Our brains adapted it as a way to cope with consciousness until we could fill it with something later.
Yep. That’s what I’ve been thinking about lately. Everyone is on automatic mode. Won’t stop to breathe. We are self aware about our eventual death, yet, almost all population isn’t self aware of their own existence.
Reminds me of the story of Adam and Eve and the whole knowledge of good and evil. Your only hope would be to enlighten other dogs and ruin their life, or go through life as a sad self aware dog.
Like koko the gorilla. She learned sign language and learned more than a thousand words. She was monitered and supervised by a female biologist. They became best friend. One day she told the biologist that she wanted to be a mom. All of her previous baby where captured or dead. So she gave her a small kitten. Her mother instinct was phenomenal. RIP KOKO Koko was self-aware to !!!!!
@@1stWellMate Koko the gorilla died in her sleep from natural causes on June 18, 2018 at the age of 46 at the Gorilla Foundation's preserve in Woodside, California. The Gorilla Foundation said that Koko was showing signs of aging, such as slowing down and losing her appetite. One possibility was that she had cardiomyopathy, a heart condition that many gorillas have, but her case was apparently mild and she was being treated for it.
@@1stWellMate Koko was 13 years old when she learned her beloved kitten, All Ball, died after being hit by a car. Visibly upset, the western lowland gorilla kept signing the words “sad, frown, cry, bad” and cried out with a hooting sound she made as a baby while left alone in her cage at night.
@@kinglokimrvegas8687 that’s not the truth. Bunny isn’t even on antidepressants. That was a joke and people ran with it. Bunny is just anxious and takes anxiety meds
Your comment has 666 likes at the time of me watching this... Screenshoting this one for sure lol. Also that's like almost more sad to think about other than losing a dog
Those buttons got started by a lady who was an expert in child language development who realized dogs were at the phase right before actually speaking. She knew it was because their mouth doesn’t let them make those sounds, so she did the buttons and found the dogs could learn to speak that way.
@@setme4ree dogs don't have the language comprehension ability to string thoughts together. they press buttons with a vague idea of what they're even doing and then we do all of the work interpreting it.
@@benjaminqmorrisreally? I have 11 words for my chihuahua, and she uses them very proficiently. It’s never random, and it always makes sense. Some of the things she says are “want play outside mommy” “Ena want play love you “ “want play outside later” “want treat daddy” “Ena want play outside yes mommy” just to name a few. Or, if she asks for a treat, I will say “no” and she challenges me, “yes”, and when I finally say no, she sometimes says “mommy no” or “later”, and yes, she knows the concept of later. You can never in a million years tell me dogs don’t understand language and can’t put thoughts together. And for the record, I didn’t teach my dog these buttons, once she learned how to press them, I programmed them, put them down, and she figured it out. At first she pressed them to see what word it was, then she knew that button was this word. She figured all that out herself. I mix up the order on her to make her look for the buttons and she gets it right every time.
@@Blablabla44475it's the same concept of how dogs understand commands but they do not know how to actively think to process words into sentences and to communicate verbally they just understand some words do some things when they react to them, it's been proven over and over that those buttons are NOT allowing dogs to actually communicate their thoughts and feelings to us.
Becomes self aware, immediately becomes depressed, same Edit: I made a joke why tf are y'all freaking out about Satan in my replies, I'm actually pretty happy with my life
In the book of Jubilees which was omitted from the Bible but still remains in some sects, the serpent spoke to Eve. It's also said that before Adam and Eve ate of the tree of knowledge that all the beast and animals including Adam and Eve all spoke with one tongue and only after they ate from the tree did God shut up the beasts and sent Adam Eve and the animals out into the world into their respective habitats outside of the Garden. The dogs very well are fully self aware!
@@egierhethjer How do you know for sure?!! Need more buttons for them to explain! How about "Want" "Snow" "Run" "Work" ???!!! Gawd, it could all go so wrong...and we find out that ALL of our animal friends are depressed and feel trapped 😱
@staingwapo Is that your first explanation for this phenomena? We tend to humanize pets because we want then to be more human, and teaching a dog a human language is humanizing them a lot, so for their brain they think being human is good and being an animal is bad. This is unfortunate because we are also animals, not superior in any means (with the exception of intelligence and abstract thinking) to any other vertebrate.
Animals understand languages, whichever one u speak to them in, how do u think they kno "go sit" "go lie down" "no" "stop" etc....@franciscoborrashidalgo7776
My dog learned those buttons very quickly, by 4months she knew; outside, potty, walk, mom(attention), train, and playtime. The first time I didn't let her outside immediately, I said no outside. She stared me down and hit it 3 more times.
Tbh at first I thought this was cool but now it’s starting to seem annoying., now another being that you have to try to reason with and explain yourself to ….
It is said that language unlocks the mind. Even Helen Keller said so. For the longest time she couldn’t comprehend reality until she learned a language
There is a case of a young feral girl from soviet Russia that shows this extremely well. It is fascinating, she lived with livestock for the formative years of her life.
Dogs are so much more intelligent than people think. They analyze us and learn to understand functionalities of a human system and society without anyone needing to tell them. I had a shepherd from puppy to she died of age, in those 12 years I barely ever trained her, she was loyal and well behaved to the bone. I told her things a few times and she would get it. It was so effortless to do anything with her, that I would almost forget she was my dog and not the other way around. I could stroll around in peak traffic hours in a city and watch a video with headphones, completely emerged in it. She would stopped me if it was a red light and she would always seek eye contact with the drivers before crossing to make sure the drivers saw us. And she wasn´t trained to do any of that. She just understood traffic safety and that humans control the vehicle without anyone teaching her that. She understood humans so well, she would follow me everywhere and she learned how to interact in with humans in our way. Considering how difficult that is even for humans, dogs are damn good at adapting and learning! She would also teach other dogs to do the same so. Later I walked around with 12 shepherds, and people would think I am some type of dog genie. While it was really just my one loyal dog who was the pack leader and the rest just naturally followed. Dog training on easy mode.
She needs a button for that dog that says “best friend” or “important” or “family” or “special” or “unique” or “loved” and then she can tell the dog that he’s those things. That dog needs to know it’s loved.
Bunny has those buttons and they really love on her and tell her they love her with the buttons all the time and she's very well taken care of. Bunny is insanely smart to the point of self realization, it seems.
@@DiscoChixify yeah you should really check a little bit of her channel out she’s very popular and has had most of her progress with the button communication documented.. there is no doubt she is in a good home. Those guys are talking about one video and broke it down in way that made it seem like bunny was an unhappy dog with a unhappy life. But theres more to it.
Did you not see how many buttons there were. If there is who am o and sad then there is love family friend but probably not “unique” 😅that might worsen the case of depression. Seeing other dogs as beats and sometimes ravenous
My favorite Bunny moment was when there was a person interviewing them for a local tv show or something. After a while, Bunny pressed "Stranger" "All done". Interview was over...
@@adamnasir2 You are correct and incorrect kinda. Yeah it has to know what the word means to use it in correct situations, it doesn't have to know the definition tho. We all as children didnt learn all of the words from our parents telling us "*That* means that and that", we learned also by observing them use the words and trying to understand what their meaning. Also i heard somewhere that the smartest doggos have a mental capacity of a 3-4 years old (not confirmed info, but it would check out) so learning the meaning of words would not be an impossible task.
Bunny is actually a very happy dog Thanks to the buttons. She does not say “help I’m stuck in a dog body” she says “mom play with me” and then wags her tail.
Honestly that makes sense, hears my thought, (it might not make sense lol) people have been breeding dogs for hundreds of years to be workers, pets, caretakers etc. so it makes sense that dogs could be a lot smarter then we think, we never give them a chance or teach them we just keep them dumbed down and maybe it’s so we can stay superior or we just never thought to maybe treat them like a toddler and kinda teach them to how to do things, we never give them a chance, hmmm maybe I’m going too far lol anyways that’s my thought
My cat has the buttons. Her understanding floors me. She understands the word outside and the concept of go. She will press "outside, go" and then wait for me to take her for a walk. She loves it. She also understands "love you".
😂😂😂😂 because those buttons are associated with going outside so she presses it, she doesn’t really know or understand the words, and a cat can’t understand “I love you” from a button 😂😂
There is a video of cat that runs to button in the middle of the night and press "stranger, stranger, stranger". Her lady owner came downstairs terrified😱
It learned like a baby would I'm pretty sure of it change words the accent of the voice or the agencement of the buttons and he will be as lost as the first day being introduced to it it's not for nothing that dogs respond better to short orders and are more sensible on how you say things maybe this dog is more intelligent than other dogs but ''intelligent dog'' is not how I would put it maybe by pressing the sad button the owner give him more treats or more cuddles idk what you do with a dog but yeah I call bs
@@RainBwateur I guess there might be some selection bias. but animals are smarter than we give them credit for. granted that maybe difficult when they have the zoomies or do something stupid. then again humans aren't always smart either.
@@MookieDookie9000 nah dude u are entirely wrong. The majority of animals in general are entirely self aware. Dogs, cats, dolphins, larger mammals are usually self aware.
All dogs have the minds of a small child. This dog is sad because they are creating it. The amount of time inside any dog would need to learn this shows the lack of outdoors it has in its life. Of course it’s sad. The owners are shit
It’s actually super helpful for dogs to learn things like this, dogs are super smart and even exercising their brain for 30 minutes is the equivalent to a couple hour walk.
Why would you listen to Dylan Mulvaney over someone who's much more interesting and stable and says he's Napoleon, a leprechaun, Elvis, an Area 51 alien, the missing link, or the Lindbergh baby?
Yea , I’ve only seen the Dog as doing very minimal communication with those buttons Which is still impressive But not to the point of being on antidepressants This park maybe exaggerated and now it’s being spread Go to the ladies Ch and ask She has an ig or YT
It’s not real dogs genuinely don’t have the capacity to have an existential crisis in fact if the very few animals who’ve actually been able to communicate not one has ever asked a single question the dogs are fake there’s a reason no scientist has taken it seriously
@@dotjs0n There's literally videos of it, the dog was continuously asking who and what it was, and kept looking at itself in a mirror and saying it was sad
we are trapped, but i wouldn’t say irreversibly trapped because one truth we all know to be true is we do die. but what is irreversible is how we spend the one life time of this experience, while tangled in the resistance of flow i.e beyond self awareness. sitting in the origin of stillness, is to return to your roots which we don’t do or practice often.
I love Bili the cat with all the buttons. Her dad was out of the country and she kept pushing "where" "dad" or "dad" "home" "soon" and her mom said "he's not here. he's in Africa" And Bili just looked so stunned, walked over and pushed "What" Like, you made all these buttons, now have fun explain the concept of different continents to your cat!
Bunny was stressed and quite reactive. The buttons are a way for her to blow steam and communicate I guess. She understands that otter (the other dog) is an animal and that type of animal is a dog, but she doesn’t understand that she’s a dog. It’s been a few months since I’ve consistently kept up with them though. But she understands time, asks about tides and different storms are coming. She’s always broadening her understanding of the world around her.
@@kanedashoutaroit’s clear the dog was already having these thoughts she just had no way to communicate them, like a fussy baby. No one says “ your baby’s stressed enough, teaching them to communicate will just increase r their stress further”
@@kanedashoutaro you realise that you are assuming the dog is able to understand the buttons, and you are failing to also realise that if the dog understands the speech, but cannot replicate it, that would cause infinite stress. Giving them the ability to communicate its thoughts allows the dog to tell their owners they don't feel happy. Do you think the buttons caused this? I have no mouth yet I must scream vibes
@@thepenguin9 For their humans to know it is helpful to have buttons, but if she just want to express her emotions she could bark in ways that would translate roughly to happy, sad, angry, excited.
@@jiffy3263 sometimes I think about bunny putting words together and asking why her and her human mom were different and I think of those memes using the monologue from sugar. When you are limited in communication, it's a recipe for anxiety and major depression. Bunny the dog might have not been able to express her self awareness had it not been for these buttons, but that doesn't mean that she would not have reached this point without being able to express these concepts anyways. I'm certainly not mute, but sometimes I go nonverbal and need to be left alone. If I were limited to expressing plain emotion and a family or friend kept trying to talk to me, my options would be pretty much limited to shoving them out of the room and locking myself in, and there's no way to reassure them that it's going to be okay or express my needs, and that causes them and me extra stress. This has happened before lmao and it is hell since the normal response is concern and trying to get me to return to normal behavior when I'm already stressed out by socialization and trying to avoid having a meltdown
I've been saying this for years. Animals are far more intelligent than we give them credit for. If you live with another more cognitive sentient being for as long as dogs have, you're bound to learn how to emulate that level of cognition. At least, that's my stoner theory.
Just because a creature is sentient doesn’t mean the creature is a human trapped in another form. It just means the creature is sentient in its own unique way. The dog probably hates not being able to live in a world that has been shaped exclusively for humans by humans
Fun fact about Bunny is that she was depressed and anxious before they got her the buttons. They felt that the buttons may help her communicate her feelings better, so it’s not surprising that she’s having an existential crisis imo. Billi speaks is an account that shows a cat with buttons. I highly recommend it!!
Many dogs are on anti anxiety medication. Many humans as well. Talking or not. I know this is a content booster for you but it's irresponsible to act like anxiety is abnormal. Dogs and humans have anxiety responses naturally. It's how species survive. At times the responses get a little out of hand and we have medications and behavioral therapy to help. I don't think your intent is malicious, but others might not seek help for their furry family members if they get the impression that anxiety is abnormal. That would be tragic. Food for thought.
If that were true, then they would have made languages hundreds of thousands of years ago. Maybe our own dogs and cats can comprehend those factors but dont asusme all animals can
Giving a dog the means to learn further about itself because of clear communication. I think it increases their intelligence too and allows them to reflect. Some questions are human in nature.
I've always wondered if my pets thought there was something wrong with them cause they don't look like us, like they are human but deformed or some shit
But he cant communicate with other dogs that way. Imagine being the only human amongst aliens. You know who you are and you can speak. But theres no one like you.
@@rickdavis32 you’re describing being bilingual bro he’s just taken English lessons and is bummed he’s still got a dog’s reward system probably just sick of the additional work / tests
Hear me out people. These are videos on the internet. TikTok none the less. It is more plausible that people are faking this, rather than a dog being depressed he isn't a bunny. Because a dog knows what a bunny is. Sure, it might know the animal when it sees it. But it wouldn't know that it was a bunny.
Oh man, that's so sad. That's my constant worry that my dog may not be that happy, because they can get depression, anxiety, mood disorders etc. A way you can tell though is for looking out for the signs of a depressed dog etc.
Imagine the dog's soul was a human in their last life and didn't realize they were a dog until his owner made him start critically thinking with the buttons.
I know your speaking of this and not being serious but I swear my dog was once my grandfather because I one day was talking to my cousin and we got to talking about my grandfather cause we both was close to him and when I said my grandfather's name my dog jumps up runs to me wagging its tail super fast jumps up in my face and starts licking my face frantically to the point my cousin is in shock but says my grandfather's name and my dog came running to him and does the same thing. So I had to show one of my brothers I whispered in my brothers ear to say our grandfather's name out loud and watch the reaction of my dog. So he does and my dog jumps up happy wagging his tail runs to my brother kisses him frantically like he did me and my cousin which freaked my brother out he literally had to pick up my dog and stares him in his eyes while my dog stares at him back and my brother looks at me and says SIS I DON'T WANT TO BELIEVE THIS BUT THE ONLY EXPLANATION I CAN GIVE IS THAT THIS IS OUR GRANDFATHER NOW INSIDE A DOG! The strangest part is that my dog picked me to be his puppy parent and he has always loved me and was very protective of me even though he is a little guy. And every once in a while I'll say my grandfather's name to see if he reacts and he does everytime. 😳
@@Madamefyness ....or he thinks his name means playtime, snack time something like that my dog gets excited and started jumping frantically when i mention twiggy sticks after seeing them a single time he probably thinks its for a certain food
Bunny was on antidepressants before the buttons and they use the buttons as a way for her to cope with her anxiety/depression. I’m pretty sure bunny’s mom has addressed the concerns
Just like humans, they have emotions, and as they don't have a voice, they get a bigger body language than us. There's professionals trained to watch for these marks of an animal suffering from anxiety or depression, and just like a human, they know and get them the needed help! You can research about this online, it's pretty interesting
Dog realised what dogs are to humans ,pets , weppans ,entertainmet ,and in some places food and the dog realise that its a incell for life and pethetic they are in comparison to humans its not even spooky its strait sad and funny to be honist just like BRUH imagen all dogs gained awarnes they most likly wwould sucide😂
Read a interesting book a serial killer showed me it's called " The conspiracy against the human race" I didn't get to deep into it but while in jail but it's talks about how consciousness is kind of a mistake It gives us The idea that we have free will when really we don't
A dog has the intellect of a small child…therefore it’s not surprising that they can be taught to speak at that level of intellect. Dogs are not stupid. If you spend enough time with them you’ll quickly learn that those eyes speak thousands of words at a time.
The most mind blowing part is when Bunny talked about her dreams. She used limited words available to her and the owner was confused at first but commenters pointed it out. 🤯🤯🤯
Well, the dog is not being forced to press it it’s something that she does on her own when she wants to. At first, I believe she was trained, and every time she pressed it she got a treat but eventually she learned that that was just a way to communicate.
Imagine understanding what language is. And even understanding one. But not being able to speak it. Imagine being a god that can think about the future..... What does life become at that point, being so limited.
Y’all should see the cat. Pretty sure his name is Russel. He’s got all of the buttons.. and hates it when his person leaves clean laundry in the dryer. He’s a unique one.
Billy the cat is also good at using buttons! She especially has a good grasp on time. One video amazed me because she pushed "play" and "later", then some time passed, and again she goes to the buttons but this time she presses"play NOW". I'm still flabbergasted that a cat could make plans for later
@@regeenabutton2805 Yeah but it's still a nice trick though. If it's truly language and the understanding of planning ahead, then the cat should use "now" and "later" with every other word it has learned. When a cat is full it should press "eat, later" and go to sleep for this theory to have any credibility.
I wanted to confirm this for myself. So I looked up the video. The dog just kept pressing random buttons. If they put their dog on drugs, they need to stop doing those drugs. Some people are so stupid.
I saw another one where the owner asked what animal she was and bunny replied "human" and then the owner asked about the other dog and bunny said "dog" ans then she asked about herself and bunny said "human" again
For SURE I've had both dogs and cats who were certain that they were furry people. And others who were perfectly happy being dogs and cats. Interesting that they think the other dog is a dog.
@@joel.ha. Lacking self-awareness/information does not equal bliss in your reality. Acceptance/forgiveness of your reality equals bliss. The dog is waking up to reality and lacking acceptance, and the owner is definitely not helping by giving it ignorance inducing antidepressants.
Thank you. I have never understood why people think animals don't think like they are a blender or something. I speak in complete sentences with my cat and dog and they understand me.
Maybe consciousness is learned… I mean, maybe a baby can remember flashes of memories or show signs of self awareness, but notice that if the baby isn’t associated with physical contact with another human and communicate, (different varieties of communication) they can actually fail to thrive and eventually die. Humans may just be smart enough (through many generations of our past ancestors figuring the world out FOR us) to establish a system of communication and beneficial physical interactions, unlike any other animal, and might be the reason we have to ABILITY to gain consciousness, just like this dog may have.
But notice it wasn’t able to be self-aware on its own, the human’s knowledge allowed it to physically re-wire its brain, and it’s simply too much for the small dog brain, explaining the major depression
Maybe that’s why she’s able to catch on cuz she straight up is a human in a dog body lol and that’s why she was already trippin before the communication I MEAN YOU NEVER KNOW
The dogs got anxiety because there giving it pills that alter it’s mental state and can’t just be a dog. In other word the owners are failing the dog by not training it and ignoring it will pills.
@@janelledavault1870 Or we could go with the more logical conclusion in that dog's are intelligent and emotional animals and Humans are not special or unique in that regard. Animals feel emotions as well. It shows a large degree of Hubris to think that a dog can only feel like that cus a human "soul" is trapped in a dog body.
@@ibe6524 so I see you haven't hit the part of history class where you critically assess how the western world's education system still has deep roots in Christian theology and that "man was created to have dominion over the beasts" nonsense has affected the ridiculous need people have to be special as a species instead of just sort of normal in self awareness for a species on this floating rock.
@@greyguy.960 🤣🤣🤣🤣 no buddy, animals have more complex thought than that. But hey, if you need to be some sort of Zaphod Beeblebrox type character that believes that no other living being is as important and self aware as you, go for it just know you radiate that level of cringey self importance.
@@afreaknamedallie1707 calm down hey, shown by your emojis and insults, opinions upset you. Try to have a rational civil dialogue. It will document that dogs follow patterns and can't read. Plus they are self-aware anyway and have basic communication skills. I expect more insults and belittling from you as you don't like to be challenged shown by your behavior here. I will not insult you or belittle you as you did me. Calm down hey .
Bunny was already on antidepressants before having the buttons. The owners gave her buttons in order to allow her to communicate directly, and allow her a direct means of expression. The buttons were to help the dog's depression, it's not what caused it. This is just proof there are animals capable of complex thought, and reason to treat them well.
THAT’S a lie & it takes less than 10 mins to do the proper research to figure this out.. y’all REALLY need to STOP being so comfortable speaking on things y’all clearly don’t know abt.. it’s honestly pathetic how often y’all do this shit.. 😐🙄🚮🚩🚩🚩
I think it’s because it hinders the dog’s innocence in a way. It’s feeling the pressure of absolute silence and having to feel emotions that weren’t ever required before. He’s feeling the teetering possibility of failure like a human
Dogs aren’t really supposed to be able to understand their own reflection tho which is why that’s very odd, they can recognize their owners and other animals in mirrors but not themselves so this is a different level of self aware
“You can’t endow a creature with sentience and then rip it away”. However dogs are already sentient. This particular story seems to be of a dog with… some how an identity crisis. Doesn’t make a lot of sense but now I wanna look into it!
@@aaronnaser3928 A dog can have complex emotions, but not ones as complicared as self hatred. Dogs can feel love, worry, anger, sadness, happiness, and depression. Animals get depressed all of the time! I had a hamster with depression, and I have a cat with seperation anxiety. So please do not spread the thought process that animals cannot feel emotion.
Animals can be smarter like some people think, but they also dumber than some other people think. But at least both groups are obvious dumb. Sorry for my bad English.
@@randomhiphop5055 Idk how it works tbh. It seems like just normal priming by positive reinforcement training; ergo, I don’t think the dog is really self aware, just that it associates certain sounds with actions that have rewards.
Can confirm, the dog they are talking about is named Bunny and she is extremely intelligent. She even uses the buttons to describe her nightmares when she wakes up. The dog 100% understands English and she will invent ways to use the word buttons she has available to describe what she means with the buttons she has available to her. Like when she was describing why her dream made her upset and said she saw a monster but used the button “stranger” and “animal” because she didn’t have the word for monster or anything similar. Bunny is a very interesting case.
Crazy! I saw bunny on tiktoks, and yeah she does describe stuff. Another tiktok dog told its owner it wanted her to play the guitar, but it didnt have a button for the word 'guitar' so it would press, 'bird' and 'stick', so guitar is bird stick. 😢 We dont deserve dogs.😢
Nope. It's been scientifically proven dogs can't understand sound the way that we do. And they are incapable of being self aware. No, this is not me saying dogs are dumb. I love dogs so much. But I also understand them, and know the difference between science and some stupid tik toks. Dogs don't understand language, and are neurologically incapable of knowing wtf the buttons mean. All they know is button = attention
@@TALKINGtac0 You have absolutely no clue what you’re talking about. The amount of genetic variation within the dog species is vastly greater than in humans obviously, that’s why we have teacup Yorkies and Saint Bernards but they’re both dogs. The brains in each breed are different as well and intelligence of each breed varies quite a bit, so no you’re absolutely wrong, there is no absolute proof that no dog on the planet is capable of understanding language. Bunny is already 100% proof that they can(as are other dogs out there) and if you’re in denial about that you need to watch all of Bunny’s videos from beginning to end and you will understand how ignorant your statement actually is. And also who tf cares if their process of thinking is different than humans? That proves nothing in the realm of being able to comprehend language. And you have no clue whether the dog is self aware. I’d like to see you define what parameters must be met in order to be considered self aware. If I didn’t know any better I’d say you might be looking at this thru the lens of religion or some sort of dogma but I could be wrong. Do you subscribe to the idea that only humans can understand language and are self aware? If so I’d also like to introduce you to koko the gorilla.
@Krzysztof Łaguna I did. She doesn't describe anything. The button presses are totally random, except for "who this." Even then, "who" and "this" were extremely close to each other, and right next to the mirror. The dog was just trying to reach the closest buttons. Aside from that one, all the other button presses could be interpreted a million ways. That's the problem with these money-grabbing buttons, they're supposed to be intentionally vague so people can apply their own meaning to the random button presses their pets make. Again, dogs are scientifically incapable of conversation and self-awareness. You can live in this little fantasy world, that's fine. But before you do, do me a favor. I've gone and watch the videos, now you go and read the studies showing that there has never in the history of the world been a dog capable of language or self-awareness.
