ETSY Mystery Boxes | 2 Different Sellers | Not Impressed 

This is going to be a harsh comment but it seems to be the consensus in the comments; that first box was a total rip off and that seller should be ashamed of themselves!! That is absolutely disgusting to charge someone that amount for what they sent. 🤮 I’m upset for you! Thank you for providing us with honest reviews and great content regardless of the slimy sellers. My condolences on Paco’s passing. 💐 🐾 💕

Some people have no shame in ripping people off. I would be sure to leave a review. These kinds of sellers should not be allowed to have a shop. Charging that much for Dollar Tree products would never be worth the scoop, even if it was done with a shovel!

That's disappointing. Etsy isn't what it use to be for sure. Years ago it was mostly handmade and vintage, but now there are a lot of sellers that re-sell things from Alibaba and Wish type sites. Definitely still good things on there, but a lot of low quality too. Hope you're doing okay. ❤

That first box had dollar store items and was certainly not worth the money! Definitely one to avoid

Omg Melissa… that first bag… 😬😬😬 maybe equaled $10 max… i would be embarrassed to send something like that for almost $50! Yikes… that second 2 boxes wasn’t great either. You usually have awesome luck getting valuable mystery boxes. Guess we can’t have it great all the time huh 😂

That is such a shame about the Etsy mystery boxes Melissa. I really cannot understand why you received cheap mass produced tat from China, instead of some lovely handmade goodies which is what Etsy should be about. They give the rest of us genuine crafters and artists a bad name. There are so many really good sellers who create beautiful handmade items that are definitely worth every penny and NOT mass produced. I am an Etsy seller myself and I create all sorts of handmade goodies, from bunting to junk journaling supplies. I repurpose, up-cycle old vintage books, ephemera, fabrics, lace, ribbons and costume jewellery into journals or things to go into journals. I also create digital journal kits so people can download the images, print them out and make them into their own journals or journal inserts. One of my best sellers is a small mystery bundle made up of lots of vintage journalling goodies. I make them up in such a way that within the parcel there are more little parcels or envelopes or little boxes all made by me using old book pages, vintage ephemera etc. They are so popular many people come back to buy more. Sadly, yes there are people who just sell mass produced plastic rubbish, but with a little research they are very easy to spot a mile off. I buy all my birthday & Christmas gifts from Etsy and have never been disappointed. It is also nice knowing that I am supporting a small private business like my own. Please don't let these awful mystery boxes put you off Etsy as with a little checking you will find the real craft artistic sellers are still here (0; xxx

All of it looked like Dollar Tree/store to me, even 5 Below or Temu. I was on Etsy site 1 time, closed it right out. 😢 I don't blame you for being disappointed

I think poshmark is better, thanks for showing us the difference. You are in my thoughts and prayers during this difficult time you are going through❤

I love how they put a fragile sticker and then put it in a bag instead of a box😂

Glad that the other site, the one in the bag, is not up anymore! Thank you for showing us.

I don't shop at stay because they have high prices on their stuff. I heard that they are closing up and trying to get their inventory down. I miss Paco,I still look for him on his own little bed. He was so sweet. Love you💖

Your enthusiasm when pulling out the items from the first bag lol was waiting for the ugh ugh sound. For what u paid for that compared to the last two boxes, the last two was well better. . Hope you’re all coping ok n sending love your way. No need to reply Lovely. You’ve enough going on. 💓🙏❣

Hi Melissa you have made it hun I've seen 2 videos reviewing your mystery boxes it was positive 🎉 yay your famous now lol 🎉

Your Poshmark mystery boxes are great. The one my daughter ordered for me I got about a week ago,it was packed full,loved it. Happy Memorial Day. Have a great weekend.👍

Hi Melissa, these are my favorite unboxings I really like watching you open mystery boxes. Honestly the $45 box wasn’t worth it at all! The other two were meh. But I enjoy just seeing you and your great fun personality. 💖

OMG I miss Paco. I literally cried this whole video

Your have such an amazing outlook. I've seem most of those items at the Dollar Store. It's sad how people seem to think it's ok to charge this much for Dollar Store items. Hugs

So so sorry for your massive loss.. sending you a massive hug..xxx

Those seller's should be ashamed of themselves.....love you Melissa i appreciate all the things you do for your viewers ❤

I love how you always have a positive attitude in your videos even when the items are not the greatest. I honestly think they could have done better when they created those mystery boxes.

Wow The sense of disappointment is palatable.

The purple arm sleeves are really nice 👍

As we say in Scotland, that first bag was full of guff LOL Sending prayers of healing 🙏🏻🫶🏻

I am so sorry about Paco. I lost a lot of dogs. Hope you have a sweet day. 6ou make my day watching your videos of you and Paco. Love watch you and your mom and dad. I lost my parents 2020

Yay new video to watch while I’m battling a stomach glue thank you Melissa!!

I think that there’s funny sleeve things that you’ve got in one of the boxes might be driving sleeves. Some people cover their arms when they’re driving to protect from sun. I’m not in that camp but I know some people are

Both were disappointing. Love you reaction! Some of the stuff came from dollar tree and temu. I enjoy your videos.

Oh nooo! I rush home nightly to see Paco❤. Tell me I misunderstood a comment I just read from a may 19th post.

Love your channel Melissa

I have an idea🤔 how's about you get some of that old school freeze dried candy!!!!! I Have been wanting to try it so bad just haven't pulled that lever yet! Lol ❤❤❤

The first package was not worth it. The boxes were a little better but it is what it is 🤣🤣🤣 You have such a positive attitude. I love watching your videos. You keep me laughing. Thank you for sharing.❤❤

Good afternoon Melissa!!! The first box is cute, but not worth what you paid for. I do like the purple theme though too. Out of the boxes, they are better then the very first box. I still don't think they are worth $18 though. Thank you so much for sharing with us, and I hope you have a Blessed day!!!!

I am sorry that you got ripped off. Those sellers should be ashamed of themselves, but bet they aren't

My heart honestly. 🥺🥺🥺🥺 Hugs honey bun great video as per ❤❤❤

I enjoy your realism and realist reactions. In my opinion, none of those boxes were worth what you paid. It's was all stuff from the dollar store, but at least now you know. Thank you for showing us because now we know to stay clear of those shops. I enjoy your content.....thank you! 😀

That's such a bummer, but you're happy no matter what Hope you doing good 👍🏻😊

I have to say, when it comes to Etsy mystery boxes, I've only had luck with Halloween / Horror themed ones! Definitely a hit or miss! 😄

I will always give you a thumbs up because your delivery is so cheering even when, like today, when,as we say this side of the pond, " you woz dun." If they gave you a new website on that first one, I think I would have to leave a review. 😅😊❤❤

I agree. Not impressed but I enjoyed resting a bit and watching the unboxing. Have a good holiday weekend!

What a bummer man!! I guess that’s why we love the mystery, sometimes there’s a dud.🤷‍♀️ Hope you’re all doing ok! ❤

I am so glad that Bunny talked about you in her videos. You are one of my new favorites.

I cancelled my previous beauty boxes so always on the look out for alternatve options. Something not too beauty heavy as have enough highlighters to open a shop 😅😅. Hugs from Scotland 🏴󠁧󠁢󠁳󠁣󠁴󠁿

Hello Melissa blessings to u and my condolences 🙏🏿🙏🏿💜so good seeing Paco,💜good items but not for that price

Happy Friday Melissa

With Etsy it depends on what you regularly search for and click on. I see a few mass produced things, but mostly it's handmade items that I get recommended.

That package of butterfly stickers looked like it came straight from Temu!

Can’t bring myself to watch your videos since learning of pacos passing feels like I lost him too as I’m sure everyone on here feels that way as well.

You win some, you lose some. 🤷🏼‍♀️ I really enjoy your videos! You’re so sweet and I relate to you so much. I have a serious shopping addiction sometimes and if I watch your videos it saves me from buying from some places. Lol. I have to say it IS your fault I was addicted to TEMU for a bit. 😂. Have a great weekend!

I noticed that the 1st website is not up. I wonder why! I am so sad that people are becoming so ugly and mean. What ever happened to the Golden Rule? I was taught to be kind to others not to rip them off. Sorry for that happening. Thanks for the video!😁✌💓

Those sleeve things I think are used for protecting your clothes. Say you have long sleeves on and are doing things like baking, gardening or something that can dirty your clothes, you put the sleeves on and they help keeping your clothes clean.

The things you were getting from the Tik Tok scoops for $35 were AMAZING 🤩! These, not so much.

Those boxes are something else

Hope your all doing OK hun love to you all xxxx🎉

The first one was really sad! $5 max. Your right. It’s so disappointing when people ruin the surprise boxes by cheapening out on the boxes and literally ripping the customer off.

Oh my! I saw both pair's of those purple earrings on Temu.😏 I wouldn't be buying anything from either of those seller's. To bad everyone isn't is generous as you Melissa. Sending love, light & blessings.❤

wow I am staying on poshmark.....thanks Melissa.

It's considered "Home/Hand Made" if you stuff the box yourself or fill a plastic bag hahaha 😂 the first bag was like a lucky bag for a kid 🤦‍♀Huge thanks for the warning 💖

That's a shame I hope you gave the feedback about the scam some people are just too greedy xx

yay more videos 😁

The 2 boxes on the end had some Dollar Tree items in it.

That second one was worth it just I recon.

What’s sad is that Etsy used to be for crafters and home made items .. now people sell dollar store items on there .. what happened to the original purpose of that site !

That was sad. Seller has no integrity. Thanks for the warning. Nice to see little Paco in the background...🥺

Sorry you got some bad boxes😵‍💫 but the next one will make up for it 😊❤

i hope your doing ok Melissa, i feel your pain, I will be in your shoes soon enough, my fur boy has 3- 6 months to live he has lymphoma cancer in his neck. he is 17 yrs old. I'm devastated. my prayers are with you and rob.😭🐶🐕🦮

You can get almost all that first box for like 10 at Christmas in a makeup case

I used to list some awesome mystery boxes but no one bought them.. Mine were worth it too.. it's sad that those who don't make them worth it sold them.. lol aww well..

I’m pretty sure the purple bag was all Temu stuff!

I’m from England and would love to get one of your Posh Mart Mystery boxes, where do I sign up?😂 I don’t know how people can afford to rip people off with such tat, I wouldn’t dare do that! X

I bought a mystery box from etsy once it was my first and last time .

That first box was loaded with Temu items because I have seen them. I have once of the pairs of earrings with cost me 1.40. I think you got took on the first box.

Oh man!! What a shame hey? I hope the people you bought the boxes from see this video and read all of the comments here. I hope they feel horrible!! Shame on you sellers!! Love you Melissa ❤✨

I get so sad seeing paco... But i do love your vids still ❤😢❤😢

Oof I have to agree that these boxes were not worth it, especially the first box (bag). Sorry you spent your hard earned money on these but thanks for showing us what you really get. 💕

shocking! 😱 Hope you're doing okay 💜

Yeah unfortunately not to great :/ but it’s a mystery and some people really don’t care what they put in. Still fun 🤩 your boxes are way better!!

Etsy hs become a drop shipment seller site. It’s not like it used to be. How are you doing Melissa, hoping you are hanging I there.

Nope!! Dang!! That wasn’t even fun for you😢❤

That second box except for the crystal all came from my local dollar tree

Tfs🌼

all of that can be bought at the dollar store-I agree with you-nope not worth it! Now you know! lol

I guess people do this as a business and want to make a profit on the boxes they do, as this is their main income. Some face masks are about $8-$20 plus each. Depends how much it all cost and what their shipping cost them and then their profit. The cost of living is huge right now and items that used to be cheap aren't anymore. So maybe that also factors into it. Also, I've seen masses of videos that say these crystal scoops are a massive scam. My comment mainly refers to the last 2 boxes 😊😊

Don't think that was money well spent but thank you for sharing!

I have seen others open mystery boxes from you, and they are full of fun, useful and always so cheap. I guess when you get big you lose quality or quanity. I will never learn to spell, sorry. I loved this video though sad ....🇺🇸✌ Have a great weekend and God bless always

Lots of dollars tree stuff what a rip off .😢Thanks for sharing.

Shipping is a large factor. When shipping anything over 16 ounces via USPS $8.80 is the least it would cost. When I ship all the way across the country it’s closer to $12. Also, that seller is probably not on there anymore because those look like made in China items which are not allowed on Etsy.

Not a big fan of the first box. My fav color is purple as well. All I would use is the wrist things to wash my face. Love your videos! ❤ Edit: the second box just from the first 4 things looks soooo much better. Edit: wouldn’t pay $18 for the boxes but they are waaay better than the bag “box”.

First box was worth maybe $19! Sorry it was a loss. 😕 Guess you can resell some of it at the flea market.

Do you sell mystery clothing boxes? If so how do you label them?

While neither of them were particularly exciting, the second seller was better, especially if your someone that does a home spa day or is into skincare. I don’t think I would do anymore from Etsy though

not worth it on all 3. luv your vids!!

The purple sleeves made me laugh. Talk about random.

The first one looks like dollar items from Claire's clearance

Not great value but it’s always good to see different sellers stuff.

I think 🤔 I know what kinda scoop they used 🤨 it had to of been a pooper 💩 scooper ⁉️ Oh my 😵‼️

❤❤🐣🐤🐥🌻🌻#TeamCheapChick#Roadtol00k 😊

It's like you bought a crystal pendant and got free personal items 😂

wow that sad. I've seen most of that at my dollar tree. I will never understand how ppl can live with themselves after ripping ppl off daily.

Those people should be ashamed of themselves, neither of the packages were worth more than $10 at most. You'll get better boxes soon.,🙌🙏

Guarantee that first box is either from Shein or Temu.