That to me is our big mistake, can't believe they let him go. Selling all our supposed top young talent and buying other young players, makes no sense.
@@thesampsoninstituteYea struggling with financials instead Juve are offering Enzo (I ain't going to try and butcher his surname but it begins with a B) who was on loan at Frosinone last season
Apparently he's demanding that his wages get doubled if he moves to villa!! His current contract that he's on atm with juventus has him earning roughly 50 grand a week, he's saying that he wants his wages doubled to 100k a week if he comes to us!! I'm sure all of us villa fans will be thankful for him trying to be greedy and thinking he can blackmail us!! He's absolutely done our club a huge favour pmsl.. UTV
To this, it feels like us Chelsea and Everton are using each other to essentially cook the books. £10m in for Tim, take that as profit. Spend say the same on Dobbin, but spread that cost over 4 years, books are £7.5m up for the year. Same with Duran and Maatsen. Both players move for £35m, profit gets banked and kicked down the road to next season.
Exactly. It’s been such a blatant opportunity to manufacture “PSR credits”. And when you see how much promising academy players have gone for in the past few years (Archer, Ramsey…) it’s easy to defend 10-20m valuation for swaps between PL clubs and generate 10-20m profit for PSR.
💯 I commented the same elsewhere. This shows why the rules are so stupid. It's young players suffering now. Both these players could have moved somewhere to advance their careers and are instead being used as numbers on phantasmic accounting sheets
What I don't understand right now is one minute I'm constantly hearing about us being extremely close to the PSR limit and we have no choice but to sell our most valuable player/players before a certain date?? And now it's looking like we are going to sign Maatson for over 30 million! Have we already sold someone or do you think we've got a few sales in the pipeline?? I'm definitely not complaining, just a bit confused about our situation? Whatevers going on it's certainly one great signing we're making!! UTV
To be honest, never seen this lad !!! I’m excited about there two signing from Juventus, the CDM looked he’s from Argentina so he’s goin like a tackle we need this badly, he’s tall aswell !!!
The Juve players are still being over valued but im so glad Were not getting McKennie. I was on some videos looking at Barrenechea. All the Juve fan comments were screwing. Not because Barrenechea is going but because McKennie isn't. Had ro translate the comments as the only English word in every comment was McDonald's which is whatbthey call him. This should twll you everything you need to know on him. His mentality is luckily SO bad that he's helped us dodged the bullet before it even hit us. Whatch him be moved on for £5m or even let go on a free and We were going to let Juve value him at £25m - £30m. Best news of the window is not having him.🎉
Transfer news is wild atm, McKennie being swapped out for Barranechea, it's like a game of Top Trumps. I presume this lad Dobbin is just a swap for our lad Tim?
The thing with Unai is he can see players who would do better in a different position. But with Dobbin i think we'll loan him out, raise his value and then make a profit. The only error we point to is letting Philogene-Bidace leave, but he wanted first-team football every week which he wasn't realistically going to get. And even now he wouldn't get in ahead of Rogers or Diaby. Most academies now will get themselves a diamond every few years but the main job is to improve the young players and get fees for them. Currently i can only see Omari Kellyman and Rory Wilson making it into our first-team squad
The biggest struggle last season was depth, looks like we're attacking that problem. Let's be honest, Emery can get anybody playing so the names themselves aren't as important.
My question is how much is barrenchea valued at? Ad mckennie was 20m illing Jr was 10mil an 30mil ? So we might see even more money + 2 players so would be good business! Squad depth! However if Luiz goes I don't think we have his replacement YET! So another big incoming player?
Are any of these players actually improving our squad though ? Especially with a Champions League campaign coming up ? It just feels like we are just swapping bodies with other clubs and not really improving anywhere. Still ,Emery and Monchi know more than me ! UTV .
Great show as always mate and you are definitely in for busy one this summer. Is it just me or am I the only one that’s think Juve are taking this absolute piss here! I really didn’t want to lose Dougie but I get why in the grand scheme of things but just feel Juve are taking the piss now - if you want someone then pay the money! The question I ask is would Villa have gone after these players involved in a swap deal in normal circumstances? I’m not sure. UTV
It's looking like we might be considering signing him to use as a back up striker and Watkins understudy?, with us putting things in place for after Duran's been sold?? Obviously we will definitely need at least one striker if Duran does end up leaving? Not only does it look like we're signing Maatsen at left back, but we've also got the youngster who we signed last season Kosta Nedjelkavic coming in to challenge Cash at right back "if cash doesn't get sold"?? It's looking like Luiz is going and we are getting 2 players in exchange, Illing-Junior and someone else?? We've also got Ross Barkley "which considering his form for Luton last season looks like a good bit of business" all that we need after all these deals are another centre back in place of Carlos? A new backup goalkeeper, a new left winger, maybe another defensive mid due to Kamaras injury and a attacking midfielder or a forward?? Then we will be ready for the big boy champions league!! BRING IT ON!!!! UTV
Not gonna lie, glad McKennie has talked his way out if this deal. Don't need to swap one primadonna for another and we still have Duran btw. I like Junior and the new boy that is being thrown around. We need to build for the future. Lowering the age is smart. Don't know about Dobbin but if Monchi and Unai are all thumbs up then who am I to judge? We can probably flip him in a couple years. We all have to realize at the end of the day this is a global buisness now, not just local teams made up of home grown players. To compete you have to expand, and we all want to win major honors. If players aren't good enough sell them. Make your profit, stay in the green. We are lucky to have Monchi as much as Emery because he has made a career out of finding diamonds for cheap and sold them on
Have to say very happy not to see McKennie's sullen, chubby little face in a Villa shirt! At least Enzo looks like a footballer rather than an angry ten yr old whose lost his favourite toy.
@@timedwards5734He knew he'd make less at Villa and wanted Juve to pay him the difference between the 2 contracts, never considering that the reason they want rid is because he's not worth the money he is on and most likely not even worth what we were to pay. Says it all that he'd rather sit on Juves bench for more money than try to make a go of his career at Villa Park. Bullet dodged.
Random one this is, scouts must see something there hopefully he can be like a Morgan Rogers type signing, do we not have any youth players that are better than him or the same level though?
I don’t think anything monchi and emery do is random …… obvious what we are doing and why we are doing it …… players that are leaving Villa will not get game time and Robbin plays in a position we need to invest in
@@LG26 maybe….. I do like that clubs are working together to get around this obstacle ….. I think it might also help with us wanting Onana …. Tim plays same position ….. onana is a massive upgrade and imo walks into our side
I think us, Everton and Chelsea owners have had a meeting and decided to do some “business” to help the books, I get us signing Maatsen but Tim going to Everton and us signing Dobbin C’mon that’s a cook the books deal, if we didn’t have to balance the books we wouldn’t be signing Dobbin 😂
@@LG26 If it wasn't for FFP then Man City and Man United would just dominate the league's with their superior revenue whilst Newcastle would dominate with their wealthy owners we wouldn't compete regardless but I disagree we would still be looking at these types of players you got to future proof your squad you don't always make signings for the here and now Dobbin and Iling Jr both have potential to be great look at Rogers and what you can do with potential under Emery
Good morning. I doubt Dobbin can find playing time with the players we have already. I imagine its a move to facilitate the Tim transfer to Everton and he will go on loan. He can get time and potentially be an asset to sell in the future. As far as Barrenechea Juventus fans rate him highly. I only watched him once so i cant say much but looks like he could help is in a Kamara role. Luke you butchered Frosinine lol UTV
Both the Juve players are still over valued but I'm so happy not to be having McKennie. I was on some videos looking at Barrenechea. Man the Juve fans are screwing. Not at loosing him but at nit getting rid of McKennie. Had to translate comments because the only English was McDonald's. That's what they call McKennie. That should tell you everything. His mentality was luckily sooo bad that hes forced us to dodge the bullet before it hit us. Best news of the window is not having him.
Van Dijk and Mane were signed from Southampton Maddison went down with Leicester Grealish was at our midtable Villa Hundreds more I cba to name Im not sure what you mean by that comment about Everton
Dobbin does have abit of potential hes very young still and could be a good player in a free flowing villa side. On Tim going i am gutted i had high hopes for the lad, i understand why we sell our youth players but i don't like and i dont see the point in kellyman getting all this hype when we all know he'll get sold. Again i understand the whole idea behind it but it now just takes away that connection to our home grown players Also im loving these deals Were giving our players to teams we want player's off them For example were getting maatsen in a potential swap almost for duran which probably opened up that business its smart Ramos on a free agent sparks my interest No weston mckennie what a shame.... enzo is a unknown quality
Ramos has offers from the US. At 38 and given his wages, it's probably for the best. We certainly can't afford the red cards he did get and often didn't get in La Liga.
This swap with Barrenechea now instead of McKennie doesnt sit well with me. Dont get me wrong i didnt want Mckennie but who is this player whats his true value its a real unknown quantity for a 23 year old and it just feels uncomfortable. Surely there is a better option it feels more like we are now stuck with Luiz going to Juve and therefore settling for anyone because we need this trf to be complete for PSR....hope i'm proved wrong but just doesnt feel right i mean would we be interested in buying him if the other deals werent going ahead i.e. Luiz and Illing Jr??
Not too keen on Lewis Dobbin just because I'd rather Alex Baena as our left winger, no disrespect to him. VERY keen on Enzo though, more Argentines is always great and always down for Bouba backups!!
So we have Bailey, Diaby, Rogers, Buendia and Ramsey to play on the wings or in the number 10 role. Why oh why do we need a winger???????? We have ZERO fit defensive midfielders!!!!!!!! Please buy a fucking defensive midfielder.
