Thanks for watching folks! What video do you want next? Leave a comment down below! Also be sure to check out my most recent 3 videos... HP Actors Who Passed Away: ru-vid.com/video/%D0%B2%D0%B8%D0%B4%D0%B5%D0%BE-Nj1aVKSzQeU.html Dark History of the Death Eaters: ru-vid.com/video/%D0%B2%D0%B8%D0%B4%D0%B5%D0%BE-Nt1WIAO4nvo.html What if Cedric Diggory SURVIVED?: ru-vid.com/video/%D0%B2%D0%B8%D0%B4%D0%B5%D0%BE-5mAYWXB8RWI.html
@@davidkennedy8929 I would assume that the train would be classified as an area of hogwarts as from what I have seen is that the only use of the 93/4 train is to take students and people to hogwarts and hogsmead
Might be like doping in the muggle world, not illegal (in many countries, in some it is) according to a countries law, but instead banned by the sports organisation, who can only ban the person, not put then in prison, for example.
Goblins also do not accept the fact when a wizard buys something from goblins ownership goes to wizard. This caused a lot tension between the two species. Goblins need to also do better.
@@nickgennady yes, it is a two way street, the Goblins are not unaware of the customs of other races, they just want to use the system that is to their advantages.
@@drackestalentorgen166 I almost guarantee that is true, they would also likely justify it as such activities are not part of the Wizards tradition. While I may seem to be hard on goblins, they can and have stood their own ground, have their own power, and are not just victims here.
They didn’t know he specifically was doing magic…, only that magic was being done around him… and he was the only wizard in his neighborhood… remember Dobby and the Hover Charm?
@@Foxfire-xq5ij Interestingly enough, Dobby Apparating in and out didn't show up in the letter he was given. Meaning that in book 5 & 7, they could have picked Harry up by telling Dobby to fetch him.
I wonder if it would be illegal for anyone who has proven to be good at divinations to take part in games of chance such as gambling? For example could Trelawney be allowed to bet on quiddich matches if she's able to determine which team will win using the sight?
The fact that divination has credibility issues even in the magical community could keep Seers like Trelawney out of trouble in that regard. On the other hand, the use of Felix Felicis is strictly forbidden in the field of sports and that is something not mentioned in the video. I could probably see a ban of its use in casinos opened and operated by wizards, particularly in the U.S.
@@olesuhr727 considering the muggles in fantastic beasts don’t have much trouble spotting magic if they’re actually looking and the girl that harry was flirting with at the train station in half blood prince (the movie) i’d say yes. i’m trying to think of any canon examples but the only thing i can think of is the muggles who saw the Ron’s dad’s flying car.
@Ole Hason Muggles don’t see all magic because as Stan Shunpike says they “don’t see nothing, don’t look properly” or something along those lines. So they don’t see wizards passing through platform 9 3/4 or the Knight bus, but see disappearing glass at the zoo, exploding trash cans at Mad Eye’s house, Weasleys flying car, Expandjng Aunt Marge, Floating Cake at the Dursley’s, etc.
In OotP both film and book, Fudge was trying to make Harry guilty no matter what just to prevent more talks on Voldemort's return; turning the hearing into a criminal trial. The Anti-Werewolf Legislation was created by Umbridge, thinking of them as "half-breed" which she is prejudice against but their really "*FULL*" on both sides depending their forms (not counting animagus). The Anti-Werewolf Legislation was most likely repealed by Shacklebolt when he became minister.
Winx Club characters in Hogwarts Houses Bloom🔥- obviously gryffindor! she is a very brave girl. Flora🥰: a hufflepuff. ... Stella☀- a slytherin- she is very ambitious and funny. Musa🎶- Gryffindor! ... Tecna💚- ravenclaw!- ... Aisha - (actually idk). Roxy- a hufflepuff. ( ...
If memory serves me than Roxy was the last fairy born on earth and she chose to Allie herself with the trix. So my thinking she would probably be slytherin
@@saintzeroinfinity Nothing past season 4 is canon to most as from there the show gets dumber & dumber until you see that every character is out of character. Even in season 4 you could see they broke Stella's character
Love your video and recently subscribed cause I actually rewatched Harry Potter recently and was confused about some things so then I found your channel and btw can’t wait for legacy hogwarts game and be my own wizard anyways love your videos
Given the Underage magic restriction, I'm curious about Hermione's line to Ron on the Hogwarts Express prior to their 1st year. "I've only tried a few simple spells, but they've all worked for me." Given what we know of Hermione, I imagine she read each of her school books cover to cover right after leaving Diagon Alley. It's reasonable to assume she then might have practiced some of the spells in the "Standard Book of Spells". How does this worK? We know it's not accidental magic as she demonstrates a spell on Harry's glasses. Further, what about students practicing during the summer holiday? Don't McGonagall and Flitwick allude to this somewhere? How about Harry using spells like "lumos" to read? This may have been only in the movie, but it did cause me to wonder if there are certain spells that are more permissible than others, though I would imagine any spell has the potential to reveal the Wizarding World to muggles.
On the point of Hermione practicing before the first school year, I have personally always assumed that the Trace is placed on young witches and wizards when they first arrive at their magical school, whichever it ends up being. If that weren't the case, I don't really know of any other unifying moment that they all go through that would distinguish someone to be "old enough to get the Trace".
@@Molotover if the trace wasn't on them until they arrived at school, how then would the owl find Harry to deliver his admission letter? Better yet, how would Hagrid find Harry after the Dursley's tried to relocate and hide from the owls? Same as for how Dumbledore found Tom Riddle in the orphanage and knew he'd been using magic already.
@@Deezy_Ankh I of course don't have set in stone anwsers, but owls seem to also know how to locate adult witches and wizards just fine, so I don't really think they use the trace to function. For how Hagrid and Dumbledore know of the kids locations, the Hogwarts founders enchanted the Quill of Acceptance and Book of Admittance to keep track of every child showing any signs of magical abilities, and deem them accepted to the school, so I would imagine it also provides the details for where the invitation letter would have to be sent. As to wether this particular magic is based on the trace, no one is permitted in the tower with the book and quill since no one in modern times knows how it works, and besides, the ministry was formed a good bit after the founding of Hogwarts, so I doubt they are directly the same thing, but might be similar.
When Harry was put on trial for it, the big key was that he performed the magic in the presence of a Muggle. So his lumos spells when he was alone, or Hermione's practice presumably in Diagon Alley or even on the train would not have violated the law since there were no Muggles present.
1. I don't think it is illegal to use it before starting at Hogwarts. 2. They migth be talking about the homework that does NOT include spells. 3. The lumos thing was just in the movies, they made it up and you would be prosecuted for that probably.
It's odd that the US has such strict regulations on registration of wands but in the UK it seems like the right of every wizard to keep and bear wands, shall not be infringed.
Wizard guidelines. There is a spell that causes people to forget also a bird that does the same thing also do they have magick sensing eyes or is it a more science approach to magic?
I was already aware of some of these laws, but there were others that were new to me. It’s always interesting to learn more details about the Wizarding World, and how it works.
How does Hogsmeade exist? Like how do they keep a whole city for witches and wizards secret? How does the statue in Godrick’s Hollow work? How does the statue know that there’s a wizard looking at it? Can a squib see it? An underage wizard or witch that lives there as a muggle, but doesn’t know yet that they are a witch or wizard?
7:20 Our view of goblins is too limited to judge the law as unjust. In the little we have seen war with goblins has been long and bloody. Goblins have shown a propensity for cruelty and control of magic that when combined with wands may have been quite adequate reasons to forbid goblin access. From again the limited view it appears that the goblin wars stopped about the same time they were forbidden wands. Remember too, goblins are not men; most of them would consider it an insult to be treated as peers to men. They think and reason in a distinct and alien manner and you can not judge from our current view point the law to be just or unjust.
I would love a video telling us all the magical beast that we know exist and some of their characteristics or what would Snape have become if he hadn't loved lily would he of replaced lord Voldemort or fought him for the title that is the dark lord?
Video idea for you to do: What additional effects do spells have that are not seen in the movies? For instance, what else can the patronus charm do besides ward off dementors?
One important aspect of Wizarding law that wasn’t mentioned was patent, trademark, and copyright law. Without these, there is no real incentive for research and invention.
I first misread this as "All magic in-laws in Harry Potter" and, with seeing Umbridge and Fudge on the thumbnail, was just thinking, "sounds about right! The worst kinds of in-laws!" XD
In the harry potter first time travelers who use apparition from of travel always vomit up their food only if they never travel by way of apparition before hand
I feel that the wand use law should be removed when goblins share their magic tech. I see no reason why house Elfs should not be allowed to carry wands.
Hey HPT, can you please tell me what background music you use in some of your older videos? I really like them and they calm me down and I'd love to listen to them. I'm a huge fan of your content btw, I watch every video 💖💖💖💖💖💖
I wonder what the punishment for using the Imperius curse to get someone who was action paralyzed in a disaster to safety would be. I mean, on one hand it's one of the Unforgivable Curses. On the other, it was used explicitly to save a life.
It can't be used like that as you have to give the commands unless your sitting with them every day you might as well just do the thing and the curse needs a working body if your paralysed your Nevers are damaged the spell wouldn't even work in said body part as it doesn't control you it makes you loose all responsibility and frees your mind making you obey any command from the caster
@@livingglowstick1337 You never heard of fear paralysis before? Some people just... ...stop moving in extreme situation. Those people could be saved through the Imperius curse, by forcing them to get moving.
@@elfmonster1476 you can also curr it from therapy and many other treatments also pulling the memory from there heard or erasing it which wow who knew there's spells for that
Hermione mentioned a law that gave the Ministry of magic a window of 30 days to withhold inheritance in order to investigate its use and origin, ie the deluminator that Dumbledore left Ron Weasley in his will.
I just realised. When Tom returned in goblet and they had the duel. Why was the ministry not informed that Harry was using magic outside of the school 🤔 from there they could have deduced Tom was back
I believe the law on Werewolf conduct and registry is a modern version of the trials that werewolves had to go through in the Puritan period. Which is curious, as the witches and wizards received such treatment at the hands of Muggles. So you'd think they'd have a closer relationship, not a segregated one.
I guess why Rappaport's law is present. (It's pury my theory) There are 11 main schools (smaller ones aren't important), and they're gathering muggle-raised students from the territories where conflicting muggle groups live(judging by that Harry Potter school mapping) Meanwhile, pureblood mages are all pureblood mages, with no inside-group discrimination. If non-purebloods were that united, they would be impossible to control and discriminate. But when "lower castes" aren't united, this way, since school, everyone is "at own place": 1. United pureblood human houses 2. [sunni vs shiite vs israelite] vs halfbloods 3. Beings (even more various and with own psychology and magic systems) 4. Beasts (some of which are sentient, but for various reasons, disregarded) In USA, problematic existence of "Untermensh" was solved the other way, that didn't involve slavery or genocide: by complete isolation. It got especially important when ppl have grown more united there, unlike middle east school Durmstrang have done other way: mudbloods are allowed in schools only as lab rats for darker magic. If I'm right, the indian/chinese 11th school must be either 1. Totalitarian to the non-purebloods, like outright genocide and/or slavery 2. Have no centralized school, being kind of third-world magic community with primitive education and no valuable artifacts 3. Both
I wonder if Hagrid created blast ended screwts by flauting the law of creating new creatures like that (they don't seem to be a creature listed in Newt's Fantastic Beasts book). If so, it seems the Ministry of Magic wasn't too bothered by it, as they used some of them in the Third Task.
The trial was so stupid. "underage magic". It was a patronus charm, not like he was trying crazy potentially harmful magic. He does worse things to his family with his magic when he was much younger and that's no problem.
Personally if I had the ability, I would cancel the law prohibit Elves and Goblins from caring a wand. Because by allowing them to have a wand it would have created a bond of trust which was so important especially with Goblins. Now the dueling law I can understand- They probably don't want it to be unsupervised and witches and wizards will act like it's the wild west and start to kill each other in the streets. Dueling competitions is a thing. Now as for the unforgivable curses, I wonder if a wizard or a witch will be forgiven for using them in a case of life risking situation or a higher goal. For example- Harry had to use the Impirius curse for breaking into Gringots bank for getting the cup horcrux. He had no choice otherwise the mission would have failed, but he did no damage with it only what's necessary. He had Travers under his control a prized DE and he didn't command him to kill himself, he ordered him to hide while he controlled a Goblin to get to the vault and open it. As for the status of secrecy I can understand that because of the time period. Think about the obsession of Salazar Slytherin not to accept Muggle Born students it made sense in a way duo to the period in which he lived. He saw witches and wizards being slaughtered by Muggles so it wasn't for no reason, Salazar Slytherin wasn't a bad person he just saw things in a single way.
Idk If any cannon Harry Potter content exists about this idea, but once the muggles gain advanced technology and weapons that can potentially substitute for magic what are the wizard worlds opinion on this? How do they feel knowing that while they have magic , muggles have nucular weapons and radiation , hypersonic jets , the internet , ability to perform space exploration, fully automatic machine guns, smart phones and other incredible advanced yet compact devices, Bluetooth , virtual reality , and so many others that make magic (or at least most of the common spells ) look like a joke ? Do they feel threatened ? Would they try to advance magics evolution to keep even footing ? Would they think it’s a new dangerous type of magic and try to regulate it with obvious failure ?Or would they simply just not understand what any of it was and brush it of ? I don’t remember the exact movie details perfectly but I do remember a wizard in muggle studies (I think it was Ron’s dad) asking Harry what the purpose of a rubber duck was🤨 I’m certain I’m completely wrong and I apologize if I am but if I am right like seriously … it’s bad enough that wizard or not your still human , your not THAT detached from muggles , but somone specializing in MUGGLE STUDIES!? Makes me think they are in for a while mess with there horrific lack of understanding
I wonder which items are forbidden to be modified with magic. I also wonder how much scientific muggle stuff are included as wizards seem to have a gap in knowledge about muggle things
If the ministry knew where Harry lived why didn't any death eaters or lil voldy ever show up at privet drive like he did at the potters and the bond of blood shouldn't stop him from knocking on the door
Probably reasonable in the point of 'Is this a low-risk QOL spell? If so, it can be used if you can be sure not to expose yourself. Is this spell one with more noticeable effects? If so, no.'
@@shinrapresident7010 I didn’t say it wasn’t believable did I? Just wondering where I said that, the author, just didn’t understand the implications of some of the things she created. Actually that’s probably giving her too much credit, she just didn’t care about the implications, because to include topics and mirrors to real life like that, you must first respect and understand that, then cover that within your series. You don’t create a world like that, just to tell a fun story that involves none of those themes what so ever. You can’t have a universe like that, then just ignore those topics.
@@shinrapresident7010 Is it not stupid to include such topics when you proceed to ignore the implications and impact those things would actually have on the characters and universe you have created? When you could’ve told the exact same story without most of that, and thus made it not less confusing when you do ignore the topics you put in the series? Seems like a pretty stupid idea to me. But hey, you’re right and I’m wrong, who cares about discussing anything, clearly your ego is too big.
@@rubydragon1034 I don’t hate Harry Potter, I enjoy the universe and stories that have been told. I also never said they had be tolkien levels, nowhere near that, way to blow things out of proportion. It’s a pretty simple thing to understand, if you make a universe with complex social issues, you can’t just ignore them. Simple as that. It’s not my fault the author of the series is a horrible person irl, and is stupid when it comes to this element of world building. Bold assumptions you’ve made, all of which were wrong, if you assumed less, you’d be a lot smarter as well.
I was just going to ask that question when I decided I’d better read all the comments to see if somebody else had. Right, what was that from and why was it here?
It's from one of the Bond movies. My guess would be Goldeneye. I was always amused during the HP movies because I always thought of Robbie Coltrane as Valentin Zukovsky, Russian accent and all
I was just thinking watching this, If a witch/wizard married a muggle or had muggle family members that knew they were magical, they could do magic in front of them right?
Quite a useful vid, since I'm making an HPMOR-based civ3 map (will probably finish it in 10 years) and don't have to take inspiration for every detail from fanfics or own delusional mind, when there's canon
What about a video on what was conjured up in the books? Like the glasses of mead in HBP that Dumbledore conjures up during his visits to the Dursleys.
Ngl I really hope the game's story doesn't center around the goblin uprising. I think they should be allowed wands and be treated equally as wizards and witches. Makes me sad they still weren't.
how many wand maker are there ? once you have to leave school and you wand is brocken that does not mean your powerless so then what there are other schoolare? but what stop you from sudying on your own?
So why would you expel an underage Wizard or which from performing Magic or even going to school whenever the trace breaks at 17 when they just go and perform unchecked magic that they they could do because they're no longer bound by those rules and then government didn't teach them correctly so now they're doing bad Magic
They're still bound by the rules. It's just that now if they use magic illegally or violate the statute of secrecy then the Ministry will come down on them. I image they will either be sent to Azkaban or have their memories wiped about the magic and the wizarding world.
Many laws are bad ideas, just like in the real world. Imagine if there was a law that said you're not allowed to do math outside of school, if you're under 17. And of course, the law gets violated all the time without consequence - and not just by accident, such as the vanishing glass, or Aunt Marge. Hermione's "oculus reparo", and Harry's "lumos maxima", etc., and all the various uses of magical items outside of school.
i always wondering does wizard make anycontribute in WW1 or WW2 consider that the result will also heavely effect megical world in general since for ex that hitler win i dont think he will let wizard or magical being free just like voldemord who see to rule magical and wizard and conquer world also enslave muggle, because since 20 century big change happend to muggle we can split atom and make nuke even send people to moon so if war do broke beetween wizard and muggle the result stil unclear unlike maybe in medieval era
Actually the greatest example of the breeding law being broken was effin Hagrid creating those blast ended screwts and on top of that endangering an entire school of students by making them care for them with no idea just how dangerous they were. If you read the books u know how terrifyingly dangerous they were. How is that man still a teacher?
Hi! I would love a video on the wizarding world itself! Has the realm always existed? Or was it created by wizards? I’d love to know about that! Is it a parallel universe? Is it in the same universe as the muggle world but just hidden? Or is it a completely different world? And how big is it? Can you explore all of it or does it have a magical wall? So interesting !
So I wasn’t gonna call bs until 6-7 min in with the goblin and wand theory bro learn the facts first please in this is a old video but common man they can’t use them because they were deemed to powerful with them during the rameock era
So how do muggles an wizards have children an not break the law. Like surly telling them classes as blowing the cover lmao 🤣 same as telling none magic parents like what if they went telling everyone lol x
I have a question if there's a magical trace on underage magic how did Harry not get in trouble for making the glass disappear and Dudley beyond the inside of the cage with the snake and he's snappy comeback now so how's it work you're so smart
This was BEFORE Harry got his Hogwarts letter. It's called 'Accidental Magic'. Whenever Harry was angry or upset, (like most magical children), he turned his teacher's hair blue, got his own hair to grow back after an unsightly haircut, APPARATED to the school roof, disappearing glass to relase a boa, etc. After getting his wand, I'm pretty sure there's a kind of Trace spell that tracks magic use that sends it to the Ministry. However, that so-called Trace feels ambiguous, as Harry received a warning because Dobby the House Elf used magic in said house, NOT Harry.
What if somebody grows up not knowing about magic, is invited to Hogwarts... but turns them down, because they'd rather go to the city comp. with all their friends?
