Exactly, he'd deport all Anglos if he could. He hates us. I don't think he's actually spoken to Anglo Montrealers either. The ones I know don't feel the way he claims they do. French language is not their priority.
Ses québécois qui ne s'intéresse plus a la culture et la langue des état Unis et la culture et la langue de leur propre ! mais que méprise la majorité francophone !
Et moi je connais plein Anglos qui méprisent la langue et al culture de la majorité des québécois et même qui refusent de se faire servir en Français dans une province francophone
We must protect the English language in Ontario. I see most classes in elementary and high schools are french immersion and they should be banned. I left in 88 and still have a shopping centre that I manage on the south shore and I have only gone back once. I manage by phone and internet. I am sent bills, insurance documents and leases in french which I turn down and have to sign forms that both parties agree to use English and that might get banned too.
Alors explique moi pourquoi la seule province officiellement bilingue est le Nouveau-Brunswick ? Toutes les provinces à l'exception du Québec et du Nouveau-Brunswick ont l'anglais comme seule langue officielle. Le Canada a deux langues au niveau fédéral oui mais pas au niveau des provinces.
Non mon cheri .Le Canada est une fédération bilingue ou chaque province a le droit de décider sa langue officielle . Au Quebec c'est le français , la seule province bilingue est le Nouveau Brunswick. Merci de montrer ton ignorance sur la constitution canadienne
@@nicolasg.514 Ontario is bilingual too. Most of the classes in english schools here are French immersion and all signs are in French too as well as government document and signs in an place.
@@paull3179 Ce qui est faux. L'Ontario n'est pas bilingue. Seul certaines régions offrent les services provinciaux ou municipaux en français. Pour ce qui est des immersion en français, c'est 10 a 15% seulement des étudiants anglophones. 11,6% au Canada 36,8% au Nouveau-Brunswick 26,6% Île-du-Prince-Édouard 16,3% T.-N.-L. 15,3% Yukon 14,4% Manitoba 13,5% Nouvelle-Écosse 12,9% T.N.-O. 12,8% Ontario 9,0% C.-B. 8,8% Sask. 7,0% Alberta Donc avant de dire n'importe quoi, valide les informations champion.
Simple solution which is a bit hard to do, all non-French speaking citizens need to leave Quebec. Quebec will slowly die on the vine as its population will get less and less over time. All English speaking provinces should entirely drop the french language. Its a waste of money having everything in English and French.
The reality is that these politicians don’t care about “protecting French” and have nothing against English. The real goal is to have enough people to win a eventual referendum and split Canada, so inmoral politicians can have more power and steal more money. Only brain washed people, easy to adoctrínate, believe their game is “protecting french”. It’s all BS.
It might be a good idea to organize Lesotho like French only enclave in Quebec around Victoriaville with all eager francophones moving there. Montreal has half of Quebec population and French language is not that popular in there. The more effort is put to enforce French language, the less popular it will be. (strangely enough)
I have lived in Quebec for the last 25 years. I have never ever had a problem with languages .I speak English and French and other languages. I speak English and French at work ,never had a problem .when I see my doctor I speak in English and French ,never had a problem.
This aged poorly. Someone send this to Legault now that he's trying to force French on our health care system. Canada has always been about Freedom, being forced to speak a singular language is not being free.
Deserves the resignation of Legault Montreal Port smuggling illegal vehicles, illegal drugs, illegal guns, illegal immigrants organized crime French and the 6 th New Italy mafia and the China Triad mafia Quebec.
I agree with the Premier. My grandparents were French Canadians from Quebec. I was born and raised in California and of course all my schooling was in English. We're thinking of re-locating to Montreal and according to Mr Legault we'd have the choice of sending our kids to either English or French Schools. We would send them to French schools no question about it.
You are naive. As an immigrant to Quebec, you would have no choice but to send your kids to school only in French. Because of the unconstitutional "law" that was passed 101/96/14, only English speakers educated in Canada, in English, are allowed to send to kids to English school in Quebec. Your lack of knowledge about the topic is humourous, and should tell you to stay quiet about it in the future
@@eddie-xi6ls Lol, that is both funny and delusional. Quebec is not a State (with a capital S!) it is just a province. A province subject to the Canadian Charter of Rights & Freedoms. There are a million Anglos, and a million Allophones here too. English has been alive and well in Montreal since 1761. People are free to speak and express themselves in any language they see fit.
yeah, and you'd have to speak French too, within six months and after that you're banned from receiving ANY services in English no, you would have no choice to send your children to English schools
@@eddie-xi6lsAnd you're an anglophone. Man, you're in for a surprise. Just wait until you learn French, and they hate you anyway just because your mother tongue is English.
Would be great if all the anglophones stopped allowing thier tax dollars support the have not province. Strip french from all engligh provinces. Learn Mandarin instead. Or spanish.
I speak, write and teach French (real beautiful Parisien French, not the Pète de Cul, le Quebecois, le "dérivé cancéreux" de cette belle langue). Protecting the language is good. I agree. However, reducing services to non-French speaking people is a bit on the fascist side. Case in point, Protection du Citoyen is OBLIGED to communicate in French only
What you are saying is the real Fascism. You don’t respect accents. The Quebecois is a magnificent accent coming from the old French spoken in Charente and Brittany regions of France. Le vrai cancer, ce sont des gens comme toi qui ont besoin d’humilier leur compatriote pour se prouver des choses aux yeux du monde. Tu es leur larbin. Ils se moquent de gens comme toi.
I wouldn’t call it a "dérivé cancéreux". Languages change over time especially if it’s spoken in two different continents. Of course it’s not gonna sound the same. There’s no “right way to speak French”
@@neofils François Legault veut forcer les gens à parler en français (Nói Tiếng Pháp). En plus, il (François Legault) veut qu'on remplace tout le monde au travail par des robots (sauf dans les écoles) à partir de (en) 2030. Fait que, il devra partir, François Legault yi hao yune (fini), bye-bye.
except what they are speaking IS NOT FRENCH.... this is why i have enourmous respect for congolese ans senegalese immigrants here that are speaking perfect french.. what is degrading further more true quebecuers in my eyes is thatmany of them, especially old people and college only educated people dont know french, dont know english, dont know any language on green earth except this french dialect they are speaking fluently apparently
C’est à 99% la même langue. Imbécile. You understand that a Scottish and an Australian speaks the same language but with different accents and very few different words. Exactly the same thing for the French in Quebec vs French from other part of the world.
Quebec does have to be like this to a big degree or else Quebecers will lose there sense of Culture and also ther french language in the process. They must protect it or else it will fail and be lost. Now unfortunately the English speaking people will suffer so there has to be better ways for them also.
Medical services are supposed to be available in English but the majority of the drs. secretaries do not speak English so you can't even make an appointment, CLSC in Chertsey refuses to speak English & this is a medical organization.
@@snowy7236 Non, pas quand c'est du Québec Bashing... Alors, selon ta logique, pourquoi tu ne m'as pas répondu en français ? 🤔 En passant l'Alberta à encore moins de leçons à nous donner pour ce qui est des services à donner aux minorités (dans votre cas, le français).
Because when I go to Toronto I can get access to healthcare in French? Right? You are liar. You have a superiority complex. You expect that everybody in Canada should speak English. Yes most of people in Quebec are bilingual. And to be honest our grand prends had a inferiority complex because of the many humiliations they faced in Canada. But it’s enough. Au Quebec on parle français que cela vous plaise ou non. Nous ne sommes pas vos larbins.
In other words, the Ancestral English community needs to identify themselves as a minority group and then get services which may or may not be in English. Does this not sound like the behaviour during WWII?
This is horse manure.. worst than racism, I was advised by an agent at SAQ that it's better I speak Chinese or any other language other than English to get serviced in English. He helped me with my transfer and added another strong advice. If I ever get pulled over by police, DONT SPEAK ENGLISH.. speak any other language then you will have a greater chance of getting a break. However if you speak English, they will slamm you with all kinds if tickets. Then I realized why every time I get pulled over in the past I had hefty fines for minor offenses. Like speeding over 10km hr bs. Such hypocrite system, the rest of canada should now put a bann on french and no longer use french as nobody in other provinces even cares. Waste of ink printing a language nobody no longer reads
Years ago, I was told by a nurse that they were not allowed to speak to me in English or she could get fired. So this is going to make it worse. It won't be long until we're pinning A's on our clothing or carrying cards to exercise our rights. I'm getting Nazi vibes and it's unacceptable. Canada is a bilingual country and Quebec is part of Canada. None of these language laws should stand.
Le Canada est un pays bilingue au niveau fédéral seulement. La seule province officiellement bilingue est le Nouveau-Brunswick. Essaie de te faire soigner en français dans les autres provinces. Il y a eu plusieurs cas de Québécois qui ont eu de la difficulté à se faire soigner en français dans la région de Montréal.
Next time I will try to get healthcare in French in Toronto. You are misinformed, the only bilingual part of Canada is the New Brunswick. Quebec has a single official language which is French. Love it or leave it. Nazi? The Quebec is the most open minded society in Canada. Welcoming anyone who accepts to learn French and making enough effort to integrate. There is no racial cleansing on going in Montreal.
5:08 the french speakers love to shrug just like that and lie to us in english then go talk trash about us in french. Had this happen to me 100+ times.
Because there’s no other way. If we talk about foreign migrants, most of them are taught English at school in their countries to some degree. But hardly anyone is taught French. Since most people are lazy, they don’t want to learn a new language from scratch, so they stick to English, of which they know at least the basics. And if you don’t force it on them, they won’t bother learning French, which is disrespectful. It’s so privileged and audacious to come to someone else’s land and expect the environment to adjust to you instead of you adjusting to it. You should learn the language of the place you’re moving to, not the other way around.
This is horse manure.. worst than racism, I was advised by an agent at SAQ that it's better I speak Chinese or any other language other than English to get serviced in English. He helped me with my transfer and added another strong advice. If I ever get pulled over by police, DONT SPEAK ENGLISH.. speak any other language then you will have a greater chance of getting a break. However if you speak English, they will slamm you with all kinds if tickets. Then I realized why every time I get pulled over in the past I had hefty fines for minor offenses. Like speeding over 10km hr bs. Such hypocrite system, the rest of canada should now put a bann on french and no longer use french as nobody in other provinces even cares. Waste of ink printing a language nobody no longer reads
@@jtruong416I agree. It’s one thing to Preserve official status of a language, but it’s another thing to oppress and penalize other languages, especially one that is an official language of the nation. Quebec is the only place in the world where Somebody meeting medical care will face penalties for speaking English. If linguistic and cultural aesthetics are a priority over the most basic of human needs, then something is seriously wrong. This is more than a language issue, it’s a humanitarian crisis.
@@inenfmkHow about incentivize French instead of punishing English? I have nothing against the French language and culture of Quebec, but these attempts to preserve them are creating an aversion and host of disadvantages for all Quebecers. When bridges are burned everybody loses.
@@timothyjackson4653 people are lazy, and if you allow them to get by with just English, they won't bother learning French. Most Canadians only know English (they might be taught French at school but that doesn't count cuz most forget it due to not using it) And most foreigners are taught English in their countries, not French. Most people won't bother learning a new language from scratch, which is what they'd have to do with French. If they have an option of just speaking English, they will. And it kind of makes sense. Why spend hundreds of hours sweating over French if you can get all the services and talk to everyone in English? That soft power that you mention won't work.
He's saying we should all be 'modeling' and 'posing' as French people because he thinks it's impressive to visitors. Seriously, my business has nothing to do with french and the promotion of french, but he wants us to do our jobs and ALSO pose like we're putting on some kind of show in french...Other than that this 'protecting 'the french language' is similar banter as the kkk...Anyone being anything other than French should go just away...Even though my anglo grandfather built major prominent buildings in Montreal, Chateau Champlain for starters, being a proud anglo in the Legault government is only for the privacy of my home to hide away! So much of Montreal was built by the english, yet the french still shun us as a threat...so SAD!
Coming from a Quebecoise, if you want to keep your language alive, don't try to extinguish the languages of others and don't try to force people to learn your language without any incentives or sufficient resources. He can't just tell people to "learn" and then not make learning accessible to them. That's not how things work, that's not how PEOPLE work.
Le gouvernement du Québec devrait payer les gens pour apprendre le français. Le français est facile pour apprendre quand vous pratiquez tous les jours.
I believe montreal should be apart from quebec in terms of bill 96 and have a bilingual status. If a community like cote st- luc ,who as a Bilingual status and are fine with it ,why can montreal as a whole have that same bilingual status ?
I live in the only bilingual province of canada (New-Brunswick). Having a bilingual status makes the assimilation faster; it's definitely not the solution. I live in the Acadian peninsula where I should be able to completely live my daily life in French; however it's not the case anymore. Make Montréal bilingual and this will happen there too.
@@Alternity666 mind your own business. Do you see me pushing for the decline of french in your province? No. Do you want other provinces to reject bilingualism?? No.
He's right, the French language and culture should be protected, encouraged and celebrated, but not at the expense of the English minority population and its institutions. What Quebec needs is a competent government that would promote and encourage the learning of the French language.
i'm gonna start off by saying that if the entire world spoke the same language the world would be infinitely better place. that being said let me try to do a better job of defending the english language then that reporter who spoke. i can't even explain how irritating it is when asked about the french language in quebec how politicians will default to it being good for tourism. which may be true but for that to be the main selling point for keeping people divided? for adding fuel to the fire of an already divided polulation for them to reject english and introduce a seedy situation where the language is being witch hunted all over town. instead of encouraging the learning of two languages (which should be the main selling point) to seemingly fight back against it's incorporation. which it just so happens to be the dominant language worldwide. that seems primitive. its hard to accept a system which openly rejects broadening. one new selling point that i haven't heard of is that its good for the restaurants! as legault said. what? restaurants? yeah like the restaurants that are being threatened due to languages laws for the word pasta? it's completely unacceptable that anywhere in the country of canada that an english speaking person should feel out of place or out of context. that is to say that english is so widely used worldwide that by now it should be totally accepted as an intenational language if it already hasn't been. why is this important? because of the first thing that i mentioned. people should not be running away from the unification of language. in fact they should be running towards it for the simple reason of simplicity. imagine a world where their are no language barriers. were already headed in that direction its just a matter of time. but what if we weren't stalling it. what if we encouraged it instead. you heard it straight from the mouth of legault that it would seemingly happen overnight. so is this a matter of system functionality? or is this seemingly a matter of historcal ego/pride driven systems? sometimes i wonder if our societies were ran by engineers with a conscious how that would be? engineers with a sense of humanity. not robots. they would build systems for efficiency and output. a system for the people by the people. their are plenty of things to fight for in this world. language is not one of them in my opinion. i know you may think that ironic that i am saying that given i am defending english but i only choose english because it seems to make the most economic sense.
Il a raison de leur expliquer en anglais pour ne pas laisser ses propos déformés. Nous connaissons trop bien leur capacité à altérer la pensée avec une traduction foireuse
The question is never answered. The journalist asks about a detail of the Bill, and the politicians have their set response in their back pocket to tell us that French is important to Quebec, which we all know..
If the whole point of language is to communicate with the most people possible then speaking mandarin chinese is the best move. The reason it's better to know english is because if you do you can communicate with over 90% of the continent. Raise your children in french, how are they going to go get a job in Mississippi? Youre ultimately limiting your children's opportunities. If you wanna keep it french, dont force it. If the people wanna do it, they will.
En parlant de communication, le français est très important au Québec car ce la langue de la majorité de la population du Québec. Ne pas apprendre le français au Québec va limiter vos habiletés à trouver un emploi au Québec 🤷♂️
WHY adjust anything? You live in French Quebec. If you don't like it, leave. Government services should all be in French, exclusively, and all English instruction education, regardless of where your parents went to school, should be in French. If you don't like it, leave.
I think it's great that Quebec will stay French. As an American that speaks metropolitan French at a conversational level and loves traveling to Quebec, I like the fact that people speak French and hold to traditional French culture there. I don't agree with Legault on many things politically, but I do think that something must be done to protect French in Quebec, the same way that the USA should be making strong efforts to protect English everywhere outside of Puerto Rico.
Of course is French , anglophone can live in Québec too without problem , 95% of Quebecois dont care about the language you talk , its about being respectful about our culture , you dont go in some Asian place for talking spanish right? So why being mad for the exact same reason in Québec? Its because you live here , because in general other country you honestly dont give a s. But Quebec is your home so is your buisiness and French Quebecois at large either. But never and never this going to be the anglophone the problem, only gouvernment and some simp who follow , right gazette? Peace. But f.o Trevor and Carlo , these guys are next level nuts
Bilingual for me thx you.. French only means putting everyone that is not french as second class citizen and services! They can pass whatever language they want and am talking whatever I want!! Montreal should vote to become sovereign and be part of Canada and makeit officially a bilingual city has it should be! Look at everything that happened ever since the ''french'' are in charge... NOTHNIG!
Tu sembles avoir des préjugés envers les francophones. Et pour ton information, la seule province officiellement bilingue est le Nouveau-Brunswick. Cela veux-tu dire que les francophones hors Québec et Nouveau-Brunswick sont des citoyens de 2e classe ? 🤔
@@nicolasg.514 j'ai pas de prejeguer envers les franco seulement ceux qui pense qui peuvent s'inposer sue moi... On parle pas de province, on parle de la ville de Montreal... Et c'est ce qui devrai arriver!! On vote, status special bilingue! Parler unlingue francais a aucun benifice! et je parle de Montreal et de ce que la loi 96 a fais.. Si tu parle pas francais, t'as pas de service, pas de droit... Donc second class citizen!
Come and practice your English in the woods with me I promise nothing will happen to you you’ll be right at home in the dirt and the mud with the other frogs and toads
Keep like that, our immigrants kids will speak at least 3 languages and them will get the best positions and best businesses. Mean while, French only speakers will stay stranded
Protecting french doesn't mean we have to oppress other language speakers This hurts Indigenous people, not just anglophones Quebec's self victimization used to justify more colonialism :( There are more french speakers living in Quebec right now then at any time in history Je me souviens, de tout... There is room for all language speakers in my community
I live in the only bilingual province. Bilingualism in canada only makes assimilation faster. You want to see the francophone cultures in canada disapear faster? That's the solution.
Did you know poverty allieviation completed in 🇨🇳 now Modernization-BRI-BRICS. CGTN The Point-Hub-Heat, RT International. Farming/Family friendly policies
