i think if we are to look at it as a duet, its like taylor's character is moving on and looking back at a relationship, while harry's character is looking back at the relationship and realizing he's not quite over it yet
Cardigan is actually part of a teenage love story she made up for her album folklore but she has said that she still takes personal ideas and experiences and puts it in her work - but I still really doubt it's about Harry specifically...maybe loosely inspired by feelings she recalls from a while ago. They dated like 6-7 years ago and were on and off for like a year but both have moved on since. If you want songs about Harry you should listen to 1989 (it's basically dedicated to him haha)
@@taniamarcella I agree though it was not confirmed but idk, it's just that the lyrics of their songs screams back then plus the behind messages of T in 1989
@@wildestdreams7721 There is long twitter thread about them, it's like reading an interesting novel. Where all the proofs says about their on-off thing.
Harry wrote falling about his ex Camille Row Taylor made an entire album (Folklore) from fictional characters' perspectives, she created characters and timelines and told an entire story throughout the album. All the songs in the album are different chapters about these characters' lives coming together.
I dont think that Cardigan is a response to Falling..and Falling is about something else ...so they are not telling the same story...Beachwood cafe explains everything i think (my opinion)...btw I enjoyed this reaction!:-)
Cardigan is abt three fictional characters named James, Inez, and Betty. Cardigan is from the perspective of Betty. James cheated on Betty with Inez and inez thought he was serious but it was just a summer fling. So James showed up at Betty’s party to apologize. And they got back together, but Inez was left alone.
1. React to Niall Horan answers the webs most searched questions 2. React to Louis Tomlinson answers the webs most searched questions 3. React to Liam Payne answers the webs most searched questions 4. React to bedroom floor by Liam Payne by BBC Music 5. React to Louis Tomlinson goes undercover on RU-vid, Instagram and Twitter by GQ 6. Harry Styles and James Corden have a singing problem
The songs that are related where I was super impressed with the correlation (not mashup necessarily) was Taylor Swift's "Style" and One Direction's "Perfect". Taylor wrote her song, and I think the song has a clear reference though she refuses to confirm who any of her songs are about. And Harry and Louis wrote Perfect together, and some of the lyrics REALLY match up with the Style situation and lyrics. It's wild.
jeffery: he’s drowning and she’s floating and in a way this could be her response to his song but DONT QUOTE ME is basically what he’s saying... not jeffery being a dark haylor 😭
It's definitely a response mixed with other things. She's been a muse for a LOT of his songs, and he, hers. He's all over Red, 1989, & even Folklore. People refuse to accept it bc they are childish and wanna believe in Larry or just hate on Taylor and Harry's relationship (she got bashed horribly for dating him & the pressure of his management ripped them apart 3xs). But yeah. I call it like I see it. 🤷♀️
I might be mistaking but Red was released in 2012 and it takes time to write and record things so I don't think it has any reference to Harry, unless he inspired her before they met. On the other hand, 1989 reeks of those references imo :)
@@OceanChild7 She actually met him in march 2012, then Harry left for tour, just after that Taylor started recording Red, she has released a bonus track called "comeback, be here" which is written in spring after Harry left.
@@rubyi2677 I think, Illicit affairs- in her 1989 she used "crooked love" which is synonymous to "illicit", both means illegal. And the lines like, "don't call me baby" matches oddly with " don't call me baby again" of Harry's TBSL... also "you showed me colors that you know I can't see with anyone else" matches with "we were screaming colors" from OOTW, then "you taught me a secret language that you know I can't speak with anyone else"- their Music. Also they met secretly so many times after breakup ( maybe just as friends), it never created a big news. "illicit affairs" and, The one, because it mentions young love "roaring 20s" "greatest love" and most of her previous relationships (that she took seriously) were with old jerks who were in 30s. And Joe Jonas is married. Out of all her bf, Harry is the best guess. From evermore, "right where you left me"- "she is still 23 inside her fantasy, (age when they broke up) and lyrics have reference to 1989 songs specially blank space.
Love the video! You should react to Taylor’s music video “blank space” I love the music video. Also you should react to Taylor’s album red it’s my favorite album of hers.
If you are a true Directioner then please go stream drag me down and get it to 1 billion... If we did that then one direction is gonna be the first boyband to have 2 mv to 1 billion.
React please to: -harry styles chains cover -harry styles falling live -harry styles at the graham show sign of the time!!!! And more zayn content pleaseeeeee (Btw i love your reactions)
Cardigan is a part of the ficticious love triangle she created for her new album folklore! At least In my opinion, considering it is an imagery she comes back to in another song (called betty). The piano thing though, I'm pretty sure it's a metaphor for the way she holds on to music to get her through tough times/how music saved her during troubling times. But with taylor, you never know, she's the queen of Easter eggs! (Her album 1989 is basically all about Harry though, if you're looking for a connection; harry has a song called two ghosts which is about her, and in "ready for it" she says "but if I'm a ghost, then he can be a phantom" in response, if you're looking for another connection haha)
Cardigan is actually part of a trilogy, Taylor wrote a short story of a love triangle gone wrong. You should listen to the other parts, Betty and August!!!
They edited Cardigan A LOT for this song, its not just a piano song, its also faster than it is here. You should have a listen to it and you would notice how different Taylor's original is. Its a good mashup, but only because the creator mashed the songs well.
Your thoughts are on point. First of all, Taylor never does something by coincidence. She obviously did it on purpose. HARRY released his album Fine Line on her birthday. And she randomly came with Folklore talking about his affairs of when they were younger and together. If you listen to Folklore album and Fine Line you'll understand a lot. There are clues even in their oldest albums songs. Like 1989 and Harry's first album and the song Perfect from 1D. She made a story line in Folklore that is about a love triangle... affairs and stuff. The one, Cardigan, Exile, Betty, and Illicit Affairs are about Harry. She is like thinking back like... I loved you so much, but you did all the wrong things, thinking that because you were younger you didn't know better. So, yes... the song Cardigan is an answer to his. That's why she used a piano with a waterfall... It will bring you automatically to Falling music video. She always leaves clues for her fans to figure out and understand, so she doesn't do interviews explaining the hints. Although, for this one she told about the teenage love triangle. I do think is about Harry. Because is the person she loved the most before meeting Joe. She was longer with other ex's. But that short time frame with Harry mean a lot. There were rumors that she cheated on Calvin Harris with Harry, and not just with the other guy from Thor. (which was the gateway car) lol.
OMG people in the comments are still pressed about Haylor, we do not care, she's been with Joe for 4 years, we are just saying they were a nice couple, gave us 1989 and are both crazy talented. This song could be about his ex, Taylor or Louis or anyone really. Let people have their own opinions
Idk I don’t want to speculate cause there are like a million people on the internet that do that and know absolutely nothing, we don’t exactly know what’s happening in their personal lives maybe it was a response to Harry by Taylor but again idk.
I feel like with that water coming out of both pianos I feel like he can't control the flow of the water but she can so she can make a waterfall and a he floods his room it's it's like he doesn't have his life together and he is a mess after a break up on the other hand she is getting over him
In my opinion A lot of people in the fandom don’t take Haylor serious because of Larry. Back when one directions management separated Harry and Louis they Were probably very brokenhearted. Harry didn’t like being alone, he and Taylor spotted each other, and some sparks flew. Their management and the media quickly got a hold of it. It became a huge deal and before Harry and Taylor knew it their relationship was being consumed not with each other but by gossip and self serving managements. I’m sure they both had to sign plenty of NDA’s to keep things under wraps but their relationship was never able to blossom the way they first intended. New love is delicate and if things get in the way such as gossip and drama It can leave room for doubt. That makes it easy for relationship to end and the person to go back with their first love. Harry and Taylor have great respect for each other but she was no match for his old feelings he had with Louis. Harry and Taylor are very similar and have lots of things in common. They have complimentary zodiac signs and base their careers on integrity. They even sing lyrics about each other to this day. No one can convince me that Taylor is not talking about Harry and Louis in her song Invisible String when she says “Time Curious time Gave me no compasses Gave me no signs Were there clues I didn't see? And isn't it just so pretty to think All along there was some Invisible string Tying you to me?” She is referencing Louis compass tattoo and Harry’s Sign of the Times. She is saying that her relationship with Harry never gave her what it gave him with Louis. The song is for her boyfriend Joe and it’s about how their past mistakes, jobs and relationships ended up bringing them together perfectly. People don’t notice this but if you want good Larry proofs look at Taylor’s lyrics. Sorry for the long comment. Great reaction.
hannah nur well... actually Invisible astringe is only about Joe, it’s about how they were on the same places without knowing each other, nothing to do with Harry and Louis. The invisible string is like the red thread🤔 although is an interesting point of view
Jabi Rivera Yes this song totally is about Joe it’s about how they didn’t know it but there was this invisible string tying them together through everything in life no matter where they were. They visited the same places and didn’t even know it at the time. it was always something tying them together. She speaks about her past/places she’s been and how it brought her to Joe and how his past/places he’s been also brought him to her. The song is all about Joe but I do believe she’s making a reference to her past In relation to it bringing her to where she needed to be in her future with Joe. Just like puzzle pieces when you put them together it all adds up to a finished picture.
Jabi Rivera Right Taylor’s and Harry’s minds are amazing. Most people think because they dated for media purposes they couldn’t have actually had any real care for each other. Somehow I don’t think it’s that simple. Like why would you go through being someone’s cover, a media circus, all types of harassment just for money when you yourself are already super rich. Taylor probably didn’t need the money. This leads me to believe she and Harry actually did care about each other as at least friends when signing contracts about they’re dating. There had to be a huge level of trust between the two of them. If anyone knows about Larry being real Taylor would be one of them.
hannah nur yes!! I always thought that, I mean we don’t know what happen between them, but it was real, and they fall in love at some point till they weren’t, and yes if Larry is real she would know, I mean I doubt that Harry would lie to her with that. Besides I truly believe that a lot of songs on 1989 are about them, and a fake or short relationship can’t have a story that long 🤔 I would love a collab, I think that they have a lot of things in common, and they would make art
listen to the say so multifemale megamix you’ll then have an appreciation for mashups (the original artist deleted their channel :( ru-vid.com/video/%D0%B2%D0%B8%D0%B4%D0%B5%D0%BE-CJ06jUrWxsw.html )
