Jai Jawan, Jai Kisan Link to KukuFM- kukufm.sng.link/Apksi/1ocn/9n2s Coupon code - DHRUV50 for first 1000 subscribers Coupon code - DHRUV20 for all other times
Dhruv Rathee mujhe lag Raha hai Kisi Kanoon wapas Nahin hua hai yah chunav jitne ke liye Aisa nautanki ki gai hai dekh Nayak picture Amrish Puri se Anil Kapoor ne sawal kiya tha Amrish Puri ne ek din Ka CM banne Ko Kaha tha mujhe bhi lag raha hai Modi koi aisi gandi chal chal raha hai
Well i will say if sikhs were not involved in this protest, it would have been raptured very earlier..i have visited singhu border during this protest in March..and the spirit of sikh people over there cann't be described in words...From Food, medicine, books, clothes, groceries, blankets, shoes, tents and so many other langars were runned there 24/7 for free...i haven't seen all this in my life and i couldn't believe first what all i was seeing...Hatsoff to sikh community..they are truely Courageous and unstoppable🙌...and also all other farmers too no matter what religion they belong to, played important roles too...Congratulations to Farmers for their victory🙌
पंजाब के किसानों और आढ़तियों ने देश के छोटे किसानों के साथ धोखा किया है , कृषि सुधार बिल छोटे किसान के लिए फायदेमंद थे ! अब देश का छोटा किसान गरीबी में ही सड़ेगा
"My grandfather used to say that once in your life you need a doctor, a lawyer, a policeman and a preacher but every day, three times a day, you need a farmer. God bless all 🌹🌸 jai jwan jai kissan
@Time Machine do you think farming is so easy bhai karkey dekho tbh ptha chalega kismat ka khel hai weather pey depended hai aur ek baath Aisa bhi kabhi waqth ayega jab hame ek waqth ka khaney key liye apne gharwalon ko marna padey ya apney purey daulat Dena padey so respect farmers agar tumhey vo asli condition Janna hai tho starve movie dekho
"We are proud vegetarians and yet ran over farmers who grew our vegetables." This lines spoken on foreign soil for Indian soil cultivators was indeed like a spear through the Indian govt's stone heart.
punjabis protested against contract farming (farmers bill) and they go to Canada for earning through contract farming..... What will you say on this??? For your kind information 1. Selling in private mandi is optional 2. Contract farming is optional 3. Selling in intra state mandis is optional If the farmer is not satisfied in any of the three then he can sell his goods to old mandis as usual.... Where he will get msp as usual. And if someone have a farmer background... Then then ask, he must be knowing that private rates are much higher than MSP, I'm from a farmers background and I'm fully aware of the reality. And suppose if rate of potato in Rajasthan in sarkari mandi is ₹2 and in uttarpradesh it is ₹8 .... Then a farmer cannot sell his goods to uttarpradesh and the middleman (aadatiya) will sell the potatoes to a middleman in uttarpradesh.... So the full profit will be gain by the middleman. Suppose if a farmer can sell his produce directly to the state where he is getting more revenue.... This will definitely increase his income. Right or wrong? Please think once 🙏🙏🙏
People say Punjab and Tamil Nadu and two very opposite states.. .. But in reality these are the two states who are so strong in their protest... right from Jallikattu to Farms laws..
Yes the reason is they have independent political parties who like to run their fiefdom at the expense of others. DMK/AIADMK for its water policies with Karnataka and Kerala. SAD for continuing "green revolution". I hope every state gets its own political fiefdom like this. Fantastic for the future of united India.
I am from Tamil Nadu. For god sake Don’t compare Tamil Nadu with Punjab. Tamil protest was right from heart but these punjabis protest for money from other countries. Tamil protest was from public but this is from brokers and middle man. Jallikattu united every religious people but this protest hoisted Khalistan flag in Red Fort. Summa edhana adichu vida vendiyadhu kevalam likes kaga sighhhh
All farmers??? I isn't seen the farmers of estern UP, Bihar, West Bengal,Jharkhand,MP and many other farmers from different states...Why....??? I think they don't want to be rich like Punjab,haryana,and western up's farmer...stupid guys...unko yahi nai pata ki ye Punjab,haryana,aur estern up ke dalal hi in baki ke states ke kisano ka anaj kharid kar apne state me msp par bechte hai...aur apne hi kisan bhaiyeon ka haq chente hai... Yar dhruv kabhi ye bhi batao in logo ko...
@@jassdhaliwal7253 80% of MSP Procurement Comes From Haryana and Punjab Other States not do procurement At that level Haryana PUNJAB Farmers Only Grow those Grains which gives them Better return like Wheat and Rice They consume Large amount of Water for Irrigation Due To which The Water levels ( Underground) in Punjab and Haryana are at record low level Government Tried To Force Farmers To grow different Types of crops Other Farmers in the country are doing that ONLY but not in a systematic way That's why they don't earn that much as the farmers in Punjab and Haryana Farmers ( Punjab and Haryana) thought they will become like Farmers of other states that's why they Started these Protests Government Had Plans To Make Procurement Systematic But Can't Do That That's why they said They were unable To Convince Farmers In long Run Due to MSP Punjab and Haryana will dig their own Graves Because They will don't have enough Water To Cultivate Rice 🙁🙁🙁🙁 Science Loss Propaganda Win
@@_kartik_chauhan MSP ka kanon bn ne se poore desh ko uska labh hoga jis se chote se lekar bade kisano tak ka fayda hoga par nhi ye baat tumhe smj mei nhi ayegi andhbhakti mein jo jindgi gujarni hai 19 September truth wins propaganda loose
@@_kartik_chauhan MSP ka kanon bn ne se poore desh ko uska labh hoga jis se chote se lekar bade kisano tak ka fayda hoga par nhi ye baat tumhe smj mei nhi ayegi andhbhakti mein jo jindgi gujarni hai 19 September truth wins propaganda loose
Farmers were fighting for all not only for them selves They were had to cancelled Only some modi bhagts and others those don't wont democratic n peace in the country are against Only agriculture sector was left from being exploited they wanted to capture it Althought these bills will be cancelled But still u can see the diesel and other daily uses prices from last 5 years
@@RamKishan-hs3ws and more other there are not only sardars all the country farmers are the people like u with less information spread wrong information
@@RamKishan-hs3ws they don't want change.. i think other state won't mind anything wrong in this bill. Government doing everything for good I am not even supporter of any party But i see modi is right person who can make great changes.. Jo nahi badlega phichad jayega Baad mein ye log khud phareshan honge dekh na.
The farm laws which were enacted were 100% correct and BJP knew that..the people livin in punjab those r farmers who r roaming in Porsche n can afford to pay the apmc the Mandi bill but their is not one section in the whole india uk other regions where the people r not that wealthy r unable to pay the bill they can sell it to private companies without paying any tax n when it comes to the thing that if the produce is not that gud somehow then they can sell it to apmc as usual with msp..n the thing that farmers were saying that they were not consulted beforehand..what do u guys think ? Modi ji had a dream last night n decided to implement the law next day..this law has beeen in the process of discussion since decades.. And just throw that mentality outta ur head that only the farmers were killed ig more than farmers..the police and the innocent people were the one who died in majority.. The incident that happened on Republic Day was not a joke either.. The BJP decided to backdown bcoz they didn’t wanted to loose the elections and give the power to the foolish people just bcoz of the law.. so they decided to backdown ..n don’t worry sooner or later this law will be implemented again🙂 I know their will be so many people who can give me hate bcoz of this..but uk if this one comment can at least change the pov of’em then it is the best blessing I can ever get😇
guys in Porbandar ( Gujarat ) fruit yard I have to sell my top quality CUSTARD APPLE at the price of 13rs to 18rs per kg because of having no other choice , & my farm's CUSTARD APPLE are sell in market at 100 to 150 RS per kg 😭😭😭
@@1008apocalypse1008 no minimum price, hence the price can be easily manipulated and the crops can be bought for so less stating low demand and can be sold for a lot higher price stating low supply and high demand and without any limit on storage, food hoarders and big companies will get the huge profits
@@user-rx8tg6yz4t Everybody has a mobile these days. Nobody can fool anybody about prices or demand. Once farmers have freedom they will be able to get the best price. Farmers can come together and start cooperatives like Amul which own the storage, distribution, price etc. Amul is a 5 billion dollar company and is similar in size to Hindustan Unilever.
@@1008apocalypse1008 ya I Agree but companies have cold storage they can easily manipulate the market Eg they will buy Custer apples in season for cheap because supply is high and they will sell them at off season at high rates at the end the loss is of farmers
Basmati rice 1121 is being sold by the farmers at Rs 38 per 1 Kg. My friend works at a trading company. He is making bills of selling that same basmati 1121 at Rs 80 per 1 Kg. And this is without any processing. THe people who auctions in APMC mandies and those who take the crop to the processing mills are the real culprits. Strict rules on how much profit can the sellers make on the crops are necessary.
no punjab famer even come close( those days till modern era). my grandpa had to sell rice bags to bombay presidency as he was in madras presidency area and price per bag was half. he purchased a border land and shipped bags across the river( smuggled you can say) more than 100 years ago( 15 rs to 30 rs per bag or something). this was during british raj. he had 500 acres wet land( it is like punjab farmer having 1500 to 2000 acres of wet land). the land area in western ghat are one of the most fertile in the world! but only one season as there were no boring machines. british wanted rice from india but they did not introduce any modernisation. but today punjab is the bread basket of india but they use massive amount of fertilizers unlike south india. in south india nobody grows 3 seasons, even if they can.
@@king_has_no_clothskul8635 I live in Haryana, no one grows 3 seasons here. Growing more than 2 seasons ruins the soil. Most of us just grow two, Paddy/ Cotton/ Bajra/ Corn/ jowar in summer, and wheat / mustard, jon, jai, chana, etc in winters, vegitables aside.
@@parveshkhatri1027 are you paying bore bill? electricity is free is it not? that too in summer. then who are those folks burning stubs? we dont burn maize or sugar cane stubs, it is illegal in this part of the world. it is left to rot during off season and becomes a manure. if you are getting 38 rs/kg for unhusked paddy you are in heaven. a) take the paddy b) take it to mill c) remove the husk, polish it d) then sell it. that would cost 100 rs/kg in this part of the world and of course nobody would buy that. there is no farmer in southern india who makes money per acre anywhere close to what punjab does. i dont know about haryana unless the land is wet! as i said we grow max 25 quintals per acre and would be lucky to see 20 rs per kg! as I said it is mostly 15 rs per kg and farmer is thankful if he can get that far. 20 quintals*15=30k/acre. they spend around 15 k max!
I'm a student of agriculture.. I need to mention a point here when u told govt can hire trainer to train farmers for practising unconventional agricultural process.. actually the system is already present.. lab to land.. where extension officer and worker apply those techniques in field level bt prblm is lack of officers and infrastructure.. also govt's callousness is responsible..
I am from Himachal Pradesh And i know what it feels like to get exploited by big companies like adani . Everyone knows what the company is doing but still we can't do anything about it.
Ok.. Now you have complete freedom to sell the products and you became lakhpati in farming. My father is a farmer from 25 years. Still his insurance premium of 15k every year is a tough task for him
Arrey badahyi ho, ab t crorepati banane wale hi lagta hai apney apples local mandi main bechkar. U must be a dumbo. Aisa hai to bhai tum online shopping band kar do Amazon,flipkart grocers se... Jio network use karna bhi band kar do.... Private airliance bhi use karna band kardo... Private network channels bhi band kar do...
This is The Victory Of Unity, This is The Victory Of Honesty This is The Victory Of Truth, This is The Victory Of Democracy ❤️❤️❤️❤️ Kisan Mazdoor Ekta Zindabad 🌾
The farming in developed countries is heavily subsidized by the government, the farmers are given huge support, even to the extent that the govt sometimes ask them to stop all farming activities and still pay them.
Farmers in the West pay income taxes as well. Here, farmers don't; 0% income tax for Indian agriculture. Also Western farmers don't have MSP for crops nor do they get any Government Mandi like facility to sell their produce. All the farmers directly to the Pvt FMCG cos like Walmart's etc. Wherein these cos directly visit the farmers, determine the price and the produce is sold. Don't forget that as well. Agriculture is subsidised the world over anyway, nothing new about it, since it is a low margin of profit but high risk of loss profession/business.
@@gaurangkarmakar4046 they are not just farmers in the west, most of them are scientists and researchers with thousands of hectares of land and use it for agriculture . In India farming has always been exploited by rulers including modern India and British India. Hence our *most* farmers are poor, illiterate, and have meager land to cultivate. Hence we must subsidize them heavily
@@VkKing_18 Who is even arguing or debating this point? When did anyone here suggest otherwise. Did you even bother reading my final few statements? Please don't put in red herrings or strawmen arguments here. In fact, the one who started the thread was the one who started comparing the farmers of India and the West by putting in the example of Western farmers and how they are subsidised. My point was that farmers in India cannot be compared to Western farmers because of these basic differences.
Dhruv Sir,,, में असम से हूं। आपका Video देखकर बहुत अच्छा लगता है। आपने SSC के उपर एक Video दिया था। बात ये है कि अभी SSC GD 2018 के All medical fit candidates का joining की मांग पर जो Protest हो रहा है, आप उसके लिए एक Video बना दिजिए.... Please Sir 🙏🙏🙏
Very nice presentation and very informative. Kindly tell us about how to develop storage system of Agriculture products and why farmers cannot hold the storage house in there area. Thanks.
@@jatindersekhxn agriculture farm law ka ka b pata hai 99 percent farmer ko nhi pata hai . Bas bheed banake chal diye aur ese log support kar rhe hai unhe
Dhruv ji Why I look forward to your videos is, you explain things in a simple way. Calm, composed narration helps one to understand the matter better. Thank you.
Hi dhruv Bhai, I am a farmer ,...One of the big problem for farmers In MP and other states too is that the ground water level is decreasing day by day almost every year farmer is forced to invest in boring Tubewells(nearly 1lakh rupees) Small and Medium farmers take loans for boring tubewells ... I think there is need for an awareness program like what Pani foundation did in Maharashtra how to increase ground water level ,bcz in upcoming 2-3 years ground water will drop to very low level .....
dairy industry in india has ben privatised , so far there is no monopoly the law says MSP won't be removed. private players do not mean just huge corporates , it also includes start ups , individual investors , etc , it is a spectrum. these laws were necessary for india's agricultural sector. only 6% farmers in india enjoy MSP. the excess food bought by food corporation of india from farmers gets stored and when food corporation of india runs out of spaces to store it just gets dumped . Pvt players will have more resources to manage , store , these products , even export .One of the three laws will educate the farmers about new and modern techniques and different variety of crops . Where ever open market has been formed , the ones who are willing to provide better services have gained more profits . Even the farmers can join and form cooporatives . Didn't expect this from you. support open market
Advait. Those 6% farmers who get MSP are the farmers from Punjab, Haryana, UP who have the highest standard of living then all farmers of India and these 6% farmers produce most of India's wheat and rice. Look at the farmers of Bihar who don't have MSP they are dirt poor and exploited. Farmers of Punjab, Haryana and UP dont want to end up poor and exploited like Bihari farmers
Government needs to improve the ease of business in India and help set up MNC factories and other units to employ the overflowing population dependent on agriculture....
600+ FARMERS lost their lives in protest So don't think the laws are taken back for us These are taken back because of the fear of votes in UP Where in majority BJP won
@@vishalgupta9068 yaa! It's our government For them country countrymen aren't important buy yaa elections are important otherwise how will they plunder our nation of course winning is important for them
Bjp won bihar , Puducherry and Assam with thumping majority and also the telangana civic polls and >60% of by-elections happened recently......india m harr year election hote h kisi na kisi states ke 🤷
@@aryankumarjha4274 because FARMERS of UP are protesting and they will not won any seat from UP where they won in majority and secondly if they are worried this much about nation then why this action wasn't taken a year ago!? Also why they called FARMERS terrorists?? Any answer??
@@snehjotkaur2107 first of all farm laws have effect in western up only that too with jats .....bjp can win up election that's sure but they would have to compromise with less seats from western up .....and bjp has no presence in Punjab everyone knows that ....!! 3 Reason of repealing these laws are mainly what I think is rising insurgency in Punjab ( as u know punjab has suffered 20 yrs with khalistani terrorists) and 2nd one is unfortunate lalhimpuri incident which kind a put bad mark on bjp ( which I think none of bjp leaders other than the accused have ever dreamt of) 3rd one is next year preseidential election which is very important for bjp ( bjp will win up anyhow but if they get less seats , it might affect president election) Now what u asked was why people called them terrorists so I want to say people like me and bjp supporters never said that they were terrorists or anti-national but point was it became breeding ground for khalistani mindset people who were seen asking to free muzaffarnagar and Bheema Koregaon riots accused and raising bhinderwala flags openly.......I agree some right-wingwrs and few bjp leaders crossed the limits which was unfortunate but we never called all of them as terrorists 🙏
Maam just 1 Question which country (which can be compared to india) guarantee MSP ? And if government guarantee MSP then what will happen to government budget. You have read economics i expect a sensible answer
@@Ak-vo5jn msp law doesn’t mean procurement by government but farmers get paid a minimum price for its produce whoever buys it private trader or government
Sabne milke Sikho ko jam kar gaaliyan di thi, par aaj Punjab ki wajah se hi yeh aandolan safal hua tha.. Punjab hamesha aagey raha hai India ko shield karne main par badle main "aatankwadi" ka thapa hi laga
@@_kartik_chauhan bhai jab tak modi hai to sucide mumkin hai kisaano ko msp nai milta fasal ka sahi rate nai milta kaya karega kisaan uper se gorment ne black bill kisaano ke uper thop diye shukar hai kisaan ekathe huye black bill wapis karwa liye nai to companio ke hath mai kisaani ko de daina tha gorment ne agar sach mai modi kisaano ko bhala chahte hai to sabi faslo pe MSP granty de tabi kisaani bach payegi yeh bill phele se bihar mai lagu the bihar ke kisaano ko fasal ka 1000-1200 rate milta hai jab ke gorment ka rate 1900 rupee hota hai
@@satnamsinghghuman6776 Sahi rate private Sector hi de Sakta hai government msp private Sector se dilwaegi aap aaj likh ke lelo ye laws Wapas Ayenge MSP ki Guarantee ke saath
Good Dhurv ji..you always tried to show reality irrespective of people perspective especially blind followers..i have high Regards for you...at early age you reached the milestone where only other journalists think about it..it could be possible only of your dedication and true picture of what's happening...jai kissan, jai jawan
80% of MSP Procurement Comes From Haryana and Punjab Other States not do procurement At that level Haryana PUNJAB Farmers Only Grow those Grains which gives them Better return like Wheat and Rice They consume Large amount of Water for Irrigation Due To which The Water levels ( Underground) in Punjab and Haryana are at record low level Government Tried To Force Farmers To grow different Types of crops Other Farmers in the country are doing that ONLY but not in a systematic way That's why they don't earn that much as the farmers in Punjab and Haryana Farmers ( Punjab and Haryana) thought they will become like Farmers of other states that's why they Started these Protests Government Had Plans To Make Procurement Systematic But Can't Do That That's why they said They were unable To Convince Farmers In long Run Due to MSP Punjab and Haryana will dig their own Graves Because They will don't have enough Water To Cultivate Rice 🙁🙁🙁🙁 Science Loss Propaganda Win
Consumers who were going to hit severely by Farm Laws along with Farmers failed to understand the consequences of Laws . Consumers were required to support farmers who remained as silent watchers. We need to help farmers in all respect in future so that even such laws should not effect.
Dhruv bhai I'm a Pakistani I'm not against modi government but Pakistani pepole need to learn like Kisan how reach their destination like Kisan even they are many Sikh even in Pakistan Dhruv bhai love you from Pakistan ❤❤❤🇵🇰🇵🇰🇮🇳❤ once again Jai Jawan Jai Kisan🇮🇳🇮🇳❤❤🇵🇰❤🥰
Abraham Lincoln once said, "You can fool all the people some of the time, and some of the people all the time, but you cannot fool all the people all the time" Ek din zaroor aayega jab sabke aakhe khulengi aur pachthayengi apni buri soch ko lekar except for those andh bhakts jinka dum kabhi seedha nahi hota Waiting for that day✌️
A simple solution to solve the problem for grain storage would be that farmers can form their own regional cooperative like amul. It will reduce the financial burden on the government and at the same time empower the farmer. The concept of MSP on all crops is not feasible. It will increase the fiscal burden on the government.
NO concept of MSP should be enabled on cooperatives too, it's true that government can't purchase all, but government should ensure that cooperatives don't exploit the farmers.
It's not for the government to buy all agricultural produce, the main problem is that people who buy from farmers earn rediculas amount of money, the MSP should be same like MRP.
Current msp of grade a rice is less than 20 rs. How much did u pay in ur retail. Msp as the name says is just to prevent farmers from making loss not for their gains.
The method by which this bill was passed in Rajya Sabha was by no means "unconstitutional". Yes, you may say that it was unethical. Furthermore, as far as my understanding goes about the three bills, this reform had more merits than demerits (which could've been improved by a few amendments), therefore I can conclude, although big farmers got an advantage out of it, small farmers have fallen into a big loss.
There were major flaws with the bill such as hoarding and reliance on the good-will of companies that at their heart are built in a way to maximise profits for their shareholders as much as possible. Don't think these issues can be addressed using "minor amendments".
@@celestialbody9807 It's a government system atleast, we can thus push for better legislation and regulation for this system. Privatizing and de-regulating is exactly NOT the thing we would want to do.
@@vinilshah4494 But bill never mentions anything about ending APMC. Yes, APMC would eventually come to an end if the government kept non-APMC areas tax free, but that could be fixed either by adding taxes to those areas or removing taxes from APMC. This type of system had already been implemented in Maharashtra iirc, and APMC still contributes a lot there.
