Тёмный
No video :(

FINAL RESULTS: Table Saw vs Band Saw - Cutting Board Production Showdown 

Jennie and Davis
Подписаться 117 тыс.
Просмотров 22 тыс.
50% 1

➡️ Community for Makers who run a business: www.studstack.net
➡️ Our Programs: www.jennieandd...
➡️ Our Podcast: www.letsquitpo...
Thanks so much for watching - subscribe and try out our channel for a few days! Will you be our newest friends?
We're Jennie and Davis. We love watching people grow. That includes you! Join us as we learn to build a furniture business. We want to help people dominate their fears and weaknesses. You can learn from our mistakes ;)
Find us on IG:
/ jennieanddavis
Our Blog:
www.jennieandd...
Music by:
Jaylon Ashaun - Stick to the Plan - thmatc.co/?l=6...
AFFILIATE LINKS to things we LOVE
Track Saw:
amzn.to/2ObJ4VT
Fuji Sprayer:
amzn.to/2HEyDZZ
Fastcap Lefty/Righty Tape Measure:
amzn.to/2W7QkEX
Camera Gear:
Main Cam:
amzn.to/2u9Ua4N
Main Lens:
amzn.to/2ualOhU
Microphone:
amzn.to/2O8z005
The appearance of U.S. Department of Defense (DoD) visual information does not imply or constitute DoD endorsement.
#Woodworking #SideHustle #Business #Furniture #Money #Maker #Project #DIY #DIYIdeas

Опубликовано:

 

6 сен 2024

Поделиться:

Ссылка:

Скачать:

Готовим ссылку...

Добавить в:

Мой плейлист
Посмотреть позже
Комментарии : 218   
@denoftools
@denoftools 2 года назад
The band saws by far my favorite piece of shop equipment and it is also the most underused and forgotten piece of shop equipment for most woodworkers
@jennieanddavis
@jennieanddavis 2 года назад
It's really great! I understand now why DiResta collects so many of them! So proficient at many different tasks.
@denoftools
@denoftools 2 года назад
@@jennieanddavis Yeah, Jimmy has a good reason not to trust table saws, lol. Also, you need to stop standing behind the offcut on the table saw. If you get any kickback it's going to do a number on you.
@ProfessorDIY
@ProfessorDIY 2 года назад
Most certainly!
@BradsWorkbench
@BradsWorkbench 2 года назад
Get outta here! Go on now get 😉
@denoftools
@denoftools 2 года назад
@@BradsWorkbench oh well there goes the neighborhood!
@chickenpotpie4045
@chickenpotpie4045 2 года назад
You know, you're totally right, the Bandsaw is the superior tool and we are obsessed with the Table Saw, it's what we all learned on. Put it this way, I'm heavily restricted by the size of the blade if I want to resaw a board and often you have to flip the board, which leaves your cutoff board unsupported, it's a whole lot sketchier to resaw on a table saw than on the bandsaw, and here's an incidental that might not matter to some people, but the bandsaw is a lot quieter than the table saw too.
@DamianInman
@DamianInman 2 года назад
LOL disgustingly obsessed. I love that you gave this as much work here as you did.
@tracdfar
@tracdfar 2 года назад
A 3/16" kerf eats up 2.25 cubic inches of material every 1 ft. rip. That's one bf. every 64 linear ft. of ripping. For Cherry, that $8-9 loss/shrinkage, significant for small pieces, like cutting boards. Average bandsaw blade kerf is .025", 60% less than a thin kerf table saw blade. So, not only does the bandsaw save time, but also money.
@nemo4907
@nemo4907 2 года назад
The table saw eats and spits profit out as dust. Kerf waste adds up QUICK!
@johndavid3114
@johndavid3114 2 года назад
NO BECAUSE ALL OF THOSE BOARDS ALSO NEED PLANNING!
@duvuvuei
@duvuvuei 2 года назад
The bandsaw is a great tool. But I was surprised by the amount of internal stress you were finding in your stock. I had a similar issue until I equalized the humidity in my shop with the incoming stock. It was really a game changer when things were turned around in short timeframe.
@ddutton0
@ddutton0 2 года назад
Well now the tablesaw camp say in your power feeder and a bigger saw! Lol I am camp use what you got and keep making!
@jennieanddavis
@jennieanddavis 2 года назад
That's the best camp to be in! We have THE BEST campfires.
@jonnybooks9337
@jonnybooks9337 2 года назад
@@jennieanddavis & MUCH less drama!
@JackInTheShop
@JackInTheShop 2 года назад
I did not know about the table saw blade myself. I do not have a band saw. I use the table saw to rip 1X1strip from 2X4s to make frames for my 27in flags. I will change the blade today. Thanks..
@jennieanddavis
@jennieanddavis 2 года назад
We're all learning together! That's what makes this so much fun!
@BradsWorkbench
@BradsWorkbench 2 года назад
I cut alot of wood thats been dried too quickly and the stress causes pinching. I either kill the saw, remove the piece and cut again which helps kerf stay open or have a helper insert a wood wedge once past the blade to keep the kerf open
@tonxmodern4436
@tonxmodern4436 2 года назад
For the bend saw ones, don't you need to joint it on the jointer?
@tonxmodern4436
@tonxmodern4436 2 года назад
ohhhh nvm. I guess your bandsaw is very tuned. My silly bench top bandsaw can never produce clean cuts.
@kalepopp2848
@kalepopp2848 2 года назад
TROY AND ABED IN THE MORNING! Unlike them you have cameras rolling. Love all the videos and quality info you both provide!
@tinydane69
@tinydane69 2 года назад
Interesting findings. I think possibly if you had a larger 3hp+ cabinet saw it'd be an interesting comparison. But with what you have now, agree..bandsaw seems the better option and no worries about binding, burning and kickbacks.
@jennieanddavis
@jennieanddavis 2 года назад
A friend in the Stud Stack tried this with a 5hp saw and his bandsaw was still faster!
@tinydane69
@tinydane69 2 года назад
@@jennieanddavis ahh. I'm surprised but good to know. Thanks for passing that along.
@chrisdunford9711
@chrisdunford9711 Год назад
I have the rikon bandsaw ! And I'm having issues making the fence perfectly square to the blade .. it seems when I am happy with it , because it has that adjustment feature , I believe it's also moving little bits at a time . Did you have issues at all like this ? I recently moved and sold my tablesaw . Kept my bandsaw very small workspace now . I now more than ever need my bandsaw to be precise as possible .
@davidrobison4485
@davidrobison4485 2 года назад
I do not know what type of blade you are running in your table saw, but using a good Rip blade is world of difference if you are using a Combo blade. It might not outperform a bandsaw, but it reduces required HP significantly, it can also eliminate burning on heavier stock. It is worth the investment if you are doing a lot of ripping.
@mmckeeha
@mmckeeha 2 года назад
One thing I did now see him talk about: one from a recent upload he admitted that he had a lower quality blade WHILE the band saw has a high quality blade Two, what is the HP/ RPM of the table saw compared to the bandsaw. That can make a huge difference. Third the quality of the tool itself needs to be taken into effect. If the table saw is old and kind of junk and the bandsaw is new and tuned, then of course the bandsaw will win. Ultimately you use what works best. Right now the band saw works best, but if/when they get a professional shop, if they put a 3 HP 220 volt Professional cabinet saw in there with an excellent blade, I am pretty sure that will win out.
@jennieanddavis
@jennieanddavis 2 года назад
Michael, this is a great example of what I meant when I said that sometimes we “talk past each other”. I addressed several of those things in the videos leading up to this one - we can’t repeat ourselves 5,000 times in every video. We’ll try to be more clear in the future, but it’s a tough balance to strike. Also, our friend in the Stud Stack repeated this test with his 5hp table saw and a rip blade - his bandsaw was faster also 🙌🏼.
@mmckeeha
@mmckeeha 2 года назад
@@jennieanddavis I apologize that I did not watch all the videos leading up to this one. Also, did the person from the stud stack put out a RU-vid video on it? I would love to see it.
@elgris22
@elgris22 2 года назад
That's good to know guys as I have been putting off getting a table saw for ages ( due to expense and lack of room in my 8 x 8 workshop. I use only a thickener, router, skill saw and It kind of works for me.
@MichaelBrown-kk6ck
@MichaelBrown-kk6ck 2 года назад
8x8 workshop? And I thought mine was small at 11x8. Gotta make every square foot do double/triple duty & put everything on wheels.
@DirkieB
@DirkieB 2 года назад
Would love to get a bandsaw but I just don't have the floorspace, so making my table saw do everything I can possibly throw at it! Love my table saw, and yes it's my first 4 digit tool purchase
@jamesking2509
@jamesking2509 2 года назад
Thanks for doing this. I haven't been able to justify buying a band saw solely based on less material waste, but seeing how much time you save...
@woodsniffer
@woodsniffer 11 дней назад
Great comparison thanks for posting. Yes I hit the bell. yes im up to speed LOL Bandsaw is defiantly safer and less floor space less noisy ....
@grumpymaker
@grumpymaker 2 года назад
Dustin is an amazing creator. I've got 1/20 of that print.
@KevinCoop1
@KevinCoop1 2 года назад
Very nice video showing advantage of the band saw! BTW, Less sawdust as well! For cutting boards to length, nothing beats a 12” radial arm saw! You can make a stop, set (11) 2x4’s on edge, clamp one end, and cut them to the exact same length with one pull of the saw. Over and over.
@saratogawoodcrafts
@saratogawoodcrafts 2 года назад
I was cutting hard maple on my miter and table saw using 40 tooth blades and it was real slow. I bought a Diablo "Pergo" 12 tooth blade. It cuts really easily and pretty clean cuts on both my miter saw and table saw. Not sure how long the blade will stay sharp.
@jeffpendergrass9481
@jeffpendergrass9481 2 года назад
I do all my small rips on a bandsaw. I use the table saw for cross cuts and larger rips. Band saw is the way to go, especially when cutting a lot of smaller pieces. Great job J&D!
@OkieOrganix
@OkieOrganix 2 года назад
Bandsaws rock. I recently got one and use it more than any other tool in my shop.
@scottsimpey2965
@scottsimpey2965 2 года назад
Great video. While I completely agree with your results and what you had to say I think the efficiency would also depend on how well tuned a persons bandsaw or table saw was. For example I have a semi older bandsaw for which I can’t find anything online about and even though I have it tuned up the best that I can seem to get it I still get some amount of drift so my table saw would be far more efficient because I would most likely have to deal with getting the cut surface from the bandsaw flat before the glue up.
@coreyorourke1542
@coreyorourke1542 2 года назад
I still think you are missing outfeed support... This will increase your output on either machine due to reducing touches on each piece
@jennieanddavis
@jennieanddavis 2 года назад
True, but at some point you have to collect what's on the outfeed table, which means walking around the tool. Maybe you 'break even' on time after 10-20 slats, but that's gonna be a really big outfeed table! Gotta do what we can in our little garage!
@coreyorourke1542
@coreyorourke1542 2 года назад
@@jennieanddavis what if you have them slide off the outfeed into a bin? As long as the fall is not too far then you could do dozens before swapping the bin for another... Maple bin then cherry bin and then move each of the bins to the next stage of processing. By the way I have been following now for qu I'm the a while and enjoy the fact that you are not just a "woodworking" channel. You have a very unique take on the genre and it keeps me (and likely others) interested! Great work!
@Tydyrium
@Tydyrium 2 года назад
Was it the kerf difference that allowed more slats? Or were the boards just wider? I'm assuming the boards were just a little wider.
@jennieanddavis
@jennieanddavis 2 года назад
Yes. I had a whole rant about that before I realized the time difference. The boards were wider on the band saw, but that's not really important to the overall results.
@andrewward9345
@andrewward9345 2 года назад
@@jennieanddavis actually the width of the boards used in the test would matter. Less reaching for another board, as often would effect the results in time. On a side note, longer boards would yield a better time result on a production stand point, because your not wasting time cutting them to length before ripping them down. Not that it matters. Each woodworker can just use what there comfortable with.
@georgewilmore7599
@georgewilmore7599 2 года назад
My suggestion would be move the blade guide an 1/8” above the wood on the bandsaw. It’s safer and you will get a nicer cut.
@jennieanddavis
@jennieanddavis 2 года назад
That's a great suggestion - I wish we could do that, but the fence gets in the way of the guide on these narrow strips.
@shdwhealr
@shdwhealr 2 года назад
Just to speak on the table saw, there has been wood that I have cut where it did the same thing (wood pinching on rival knife). Its the wood not the table saw. Sometimes the wood acts as a spring with cutting it, clamping on the rival knife. you could always remove the rival knife?
@mikeplacko8135
@mikeplacko8135 2 года назад
You clearly are more experienced with a bandsaw so you can go faster than the table saw. I think for a large portion of woodworkers, there will be more table saw experience so it will be faster for them to use the table saw.
@jennieanddavis
@jennieanddavis 2 года назад
I’ve got way more hours logged on a table saw! Other Stud Stack members with different experience levels tested this on their own - same result!
@SethDowns
@SethDowns 2 года назад
You mean like the last video when he was jamming the wood through -- I thought he was going to get it back in the gut. Definitely some things to learn.
@frenchriversprings
@frenchriversprings 2 года назад
Now I’m curious to see how fast I can cut 20 slats on my 4hp sliding table saw using my Fritz and Franz jig with my $700 diamond blade. Will try to make a video tomorrow. Will send you the link after. The hard maple slats, how wide do you cut them and how thick is it. 8/4?
@jennieanddavis
@jennieanddavis 2 года назад
Had a guy in the Stud Stack try a similar setup and his band saw won, too! They're 1.25 inches wide and 8/4
@frenchriversprings
@frenchriversprings 2 года назад
Ok. I’ll try it today.
@erikpaul2550
@erikpaul2550 2 года назад
It's an interesting debate for sure! I went for a CNC and Drum Sander in my garage shop and don't have space for a Band Saw now, but it's on the to do list for when I can upgrade to a commercial space.
@nathanmeyer9676
@nathanmeyer9676 2 года назад
A couple of questions, as a woodworking class we analyzed your first couple of videos on this project and we’re wondering if you have considered a power feeder to optimize the repeatable cuts. Have you all considered or compared the variety of buying 3S or 2 sides planed and 1 side jointed material? Finally I think it would be fun and interesting to see you all make a video on how you would use a work force of people to creat cutting boards at scale while addressing the bottle necks of making so many. Have a good one, Nate
@jennieanddavis
@jennieanddavis 2 года назад
Hi Nate, yes a power feeder would probably help with both tools. Using pre-milled lumber reduces the size of our slats such that we end up using more material per board (7 slats instead of 6 per board). Chopping the rough boards into 18" blocks first drastically reduces the amount of waste in milling. We definitely plan to have a full assembly line with a team of 3 people working on a batch in our commercial space!
@randyclements2852
@randyclements2852 2 года назад
What make & model band saw are u using in table saw vs band saw
@HaciendaHomesteadNC
@HaciendaHomesteadNC 2 года назад
Clearly the band saw is superior for this task....so, with this new info...what band saw so you have or would you suggest for volume production?
@woodworkingDad64
@woodworkingDad64 2 года назад
What bandsaw are you using? Mine would not even compare to my table saw
@jennieanddavis
@jennieanddavis 2 года назад
Rikon 14"
@woodworkingDad64
@woodworkingDad64 2 года назад
Thank you for the quick response! I knew it was a Rikon based on the color scheme, I guess I should have asked for model. I would like to get something nicer (than my bench top) but as a weekend warrior I have to justify beyond the annual pinewood derby car races! Thank you for your content and your enthusiasm! You guys are great!!
@chucksmith9633
@chucksmith9633 2 года назад
I thought that you were gluing the edges that were being cut by the two saws in comparison. I would never glue the edge from the bandsaw, but with a good glue-line rip blade (such as a Frued) I would glue straight off of the blade. But you went with the box stores cheaper blade that vibrates and leaves chatter marks. So ya get what you pay for. Had my tablesaw for 30 years before I even bought a bandsaw. It is the main tool in the shop with many different sleds and jigs. Someday when you get more experienced, you'll realize that, but yes there are many ways to get the same products out the door.
@jennieanddavis
@jennieanddavis 2 года назад
Chuck, thanks for sharing your experience! We mentioned the orientation of the strips in the first video at about 4 minutes in. This is a great example of what I said about sometimes we "talk past each other". We'll try to be more clear in the future, but we can't repeat ourselves 5,000 times either - that's a constant struggle to balance as a video creator! Thanks for your continued support 🙏.
@ProfessorDIY
@ProfessorDIY 2 года назад
Why would you not glue from the band saw? I do and never had a problem.
@travisstiernagle9011
@travisstiernagle9011 2 года назад
They are make edge grain cutting boards not face grain.
@Kicker700
@Kicker700 2 года назад
What TPI are you running on the bandsaw?
@marcoshernandez1901
@marcoshernandez1901 2 года назад
i love how excited you are for the win lol.
@baraksinz
@baraksinz 2 года назад
Band saw is extremely versatile, BUT so is the table saw! They each do different things well, with some overlap in between. Try building a crosscut sled for your bandsaw. Try cutting dados or tenons on a bandsaw. Try cutting larger sheet goods on a bandsaw. On the other hand, try resawing large pieces, or cutting curves on the table saw. One is not necessarily “better” than the other. They are both great tools that excel at certain things and not so much at others.
@JCHCREACIONES
@JCHCREACIONES 2 года назад
You did it!!, you have a winner!! 🏆.
@TheChasingSunsetsFamily
@TheChasingSunsetsFamily 2 года назад
Do you still use the table saw then?
@ChipLinck
@ChipLinck 2 года назад
That's funny. I just got a second band saw for my shop, and it was more expensive than my table saw. Once I set it up, I'll have to compare it to my table saw. Both are 3HP so it should be interesting.
@Meyerwoodworks
@Meyerwoodworks 2 года назад
Really impressed with the cuts on that Rikon. I don't get that clean and consistent of a cut with my Grizzly G0513X 17" with a Woodslicer.
@geneb.7825
@geneb.7825 2 года назад
Are you using a carbide band saw blade?
@owendukes145
@owendukes145 2 года назад
Loving daily videos keep it up Davis
@jennieanddavis
@jennieanddavis 2 года назад
It's a grind - but we're enjoying the experiment!
@AirClown
@AirClown 2 года назад
What size was the starting board on both and what were your cuts sizes?
@junkwagonllcDOTcom
@junkwagonllcDOTcom 6 месяцев назад
Question……is there a perfect size band saw that you recommend?
@BillHartCooks.
@BillHartCooks. 2 года назад
The fact that you do this as a professional in the first place was good enough. But The rest of the series was great. Carry on.... Carry on.....
@seporte231
@seporte231 2 года назад
What band saw blade do you use?
@62schmidt
@62schmidt 2 года назад
the bandsaw is perticular about adjustments. as you found when your blade started getting dull. it wandered terribly. if the blade on the table saw gets dull you can still cut straight. it will just burn the wood mostly.anyhow, yes bandsaws are faster. most modern sawmills run bandsaws to break down the logs
@HeliRy
@HeliRy 2 года назад
Based on that test, the bandsaw saved roughly 2.4 seconds per cut over the table saw. Interesting.
@jennieanddavis
@jennieanddavis 2 года назад
Very! Thanks for watching
@debandmike3380
@debandmike3380 2 года назад
Maybe I missed it but you didn't mention what kind of tablesaw blade you were using was it a thin kerf? You did take the time to find the right bandsaw blade but you just used whatever you had in the tablesaw Which looks like a freud industrial 24 tooth (Hopefully it wasn't the lesser Diablo). Either way what matters is how clean of an edge do they give you because the feed time can only be so fast anyways to be safe. In addition it seems like you always need to justify and prove to everybody that what you've decided to do is best so I am curious about why you feel the need to do that unless that's just part of what you want your videos to be about
@baileywhetsel5578
@baileywhetsel5578 2 года назад
What blade do you use on your bandsaw? Love your videos.
@jennieanddavis
@jennieanddavis 2 года назад
Thanks! Wood Slicer from Highland woodworking
@toddulery
@toddulery 2 года назад
So obsessed hahaha! Seriously though, thanks for entertaining everyone's suggestions. You win!
@roywisdom459
@roywisdom459 2 года назад
Can you join studstack if you have been in business, but don't currently own a business?
@frank3283
@frank3283 2 года назад
I'm curious as to your process, which maybe you address elsewhere. If I were making similar boards to what I think you do, with the strips gradually reducing in width, the cut edges would be glued together as I'd be cutting sequentially thinner strips. That would mean I'd need a glue-ready surface from each cut. My bandsaw is the Rikon 14-326, the very slightly newer version of yours, and even with a new blade it's never going to give glue-ready surfaces off the cut. My table saw does.
@jennieanddavis
@jennieanddavis 2 года назад
They get turned 90 degrees and the bandsaw marks get planed away after glue-up
@frank3283
@frank3283 2 года назад
@@jennieanddavis are each of the strips the same width? I thought they reduced down in size. *disregard, I see now they are all consistent width. I had your design wrong 👍
@johndavid3114
@johndavid3114 2 года назад
Wait! You have to add in the time for planning the bandsaw cuts!
@joelvargas8648
@joelvargas8648 3 месяца назад
That's interesting
@nobdyspecial
@nobdyspecial 2 года назад
I'm looking forward to a future video of your setup in the new shop (once you have the volume) to see a gang rip saw feed into a cut-off saw. 8-16ft boards being sliced into 18 inch strips in the blink of an eye. You'll look back on these videos with a smile to see how far you've come, with production speeds that are exponentially faster. Love your channel btw.
@jennieanddavis
@jennieanddavis 2 года назад
One day!!!
@nobdyspecial
@nobdyspecial 2 года назад
@@jennieanddavis Hope it's part of your 1 year plan, rather than the 10 year plan. And given the cost of the machines, a good amount of planning is needed. (i.e. talking to the machine companies who can recommend the best set-up for your needs).
@scottallen606
@scottallen606 2 года назад
Interesting find. Thanks for doing the test!
@relwoodmusic3630
@relwoodmusic3630 2 года назад
I struggle getting a straight line on my band saw. I've always gotten reliably straight cuts on my table saw. Must be doing something wrong--would love to find a more efficient way to work
@jennieanddavis
@jennieanddavis 2 года назад
We struggled with straight cuts until we got a good, sharp blade. They go dull much quicker than you want them to. Also look up the Snodgrass method of tuning a bandsaw
@danielwilliams4438
@danielwilliams4438 2 года назад
What bandsaw blades are you using for resaw? I managed to snag up a $20 14" bandsaw that only needed the wheel belt/tires replaced and blades. So, now I'm hunting as local options are non-existant.
@curtiswilliams7638
@curtiswilliams7638 2 года назад
The next question is can either one of them make a clean enough cut to eliminate the planner step, maybe if you took a couple seconds longer on each board and on both the tablesaw and bandsaw and see if you can get rid of that step all together, within reason
@jennieanddavis
@jennieanddavis 2 года назад
We could spend an hour trying to get 6 slats perfectly square, and they'd still slip and be uneven during glue-up. Planing or drum sanding is necessary
@InTheLab3d
@InTheLab3d 2 года назад
How about end grain? sure, first cuts on the band saw, but 2nd cut on the table saw? given you cant "plane" down the end grain? Just curious.
@lothariokelly6844
@lothariokelly6844 2 года назад
Your Bandsaw only has a 1/2 hp motor where your table saw should have atlest 3hp, using a small motor to cut hard lumber will force your tool to work harder then intended and will burn your tool up quicker. Unless you have a blade with a low tooth count on a straight tooth cut design with atlest 1 3/4 hp bandsaw it’s best to stick with a table saw that has a 3hp motor with preferably a frued rip blade. Also never ever force a cut. Your riving knife is a safety feature that is designed to help stop your work piece from pinching against your fence and kicking back on you or worse popping your piece and causing your hand to fall into your blade.
@Omega5Weapon
@Omega5Weapon 2 года назад
Assuming 19 cuts on the table saw at 1/8 blade kerf is going to be about 2 3/8th of waste. Bandsaw will always win.
@jennieanddavis
@jennieanddavis 2 года назад
OMG thank you. I'm so glad someone did the math.
@micheelariviereguitaremelo4085
@micheelariviereguitaremelo4085 2 года назад
You prouved your point I prefer the bandsaw too
@ckurtz1013
@ckurtz1013 2 года назад
Been watching with interest. Don’t have a band saw yet, but I think you may have convinced me to get a band saw before I spring for a drum sander which was going to be my next purchase.
@jennieanddavis
@jennieanddavis 2 года назад
Which one will make you more money? Are you spending more time cutting lumber, or getting perfectly flat pieces?
@ckurtz1013
@ckurtz1013 2 года назад
@@jennieanddavis about 6 one, half dozen the other truthfully. I have a good planer, but the drum sander I’m looking at will handle much wider boards. On the other hand a band saw would cost about 2/3 as much as the drum sander.
@javabean252
@javabean252 2 года назад
Good information
@VillageLaneFurniture
@VillageLaneFurniture 2 года назад
How many bandsaw blades do you have to buy to equal the life of a tablesaw blade?
@shedloadsoffun2093
@shedloadsoffun2093 2 года назад
I think bandsaw is sort of Better because it has a smaller kerf which requires less power than the wide kerf on the table saw so you get less waste with the bandsaw however bandsaw blade have to be replaced pretty often. And also the bandsaw is safer.
@BlueAdept596
@BlueAdept596 2 года назад
Love the "Community" coffee cup
@atomictyler
@atomictyler 2 года назад
gripper for your push stick and you'll go way faster on the table saw. you can go forward and keep it against the fence with one hand. bingo-bamo edit: you're not using push sticks on the band saw, but are on the table saw. that would EASILY be the difference. use push sticks on the bandsaw and you'll be taking a lot longer. it's a bit odd you find it to be safe to not use them on the band saw but then need to use them on the table saw.
@briantompkins947
@briantompkins947 2 года назад
Great video's! I just need to understand, you are glueing the faces together and the rough cut ends are your top/bottom that get cleaned up with the planner? The cutting surface is your endgrain?
@jennieanddavis
@jennieanddavis 2 года назад
We covered orientation of the strips in a previous video! We glue the faces together and plane the edge grain
@rod1951
@rod1951 2 года назад
What blade are you using on the Rikon? I have a Rikon and am not impressed with the blade that came with it.
@jennieanddavis
@jennieanddavis 2 года назад
Wood sliver from highland woodworking
@jennieanddavis
@jennieanddavis 2 года назад
*wood slicer
@jonweisel1649
@jonweisel1649 2 года назад
I had the same thought that the band saw would be better. Great job with the testing and seeing it through and showing us the journey. How big a band saw is the one that you have?
@Fixbuildflip-Dustin-Boettcher
@Fixbuildflip-Dustin-Boettcher 2 года назад
Where do you buy your lumber from? Clarks or houston hardwoods?
@gabesmith6475
@gabesmith6475 2 года назад
Interesting. Also, dangit because now I want a bandsaw
@jennieanddavis
@jennieanddavis 2 года назад
It's a slippery slope!
@gabesmith6475
@gabesmith6475 2 года назад
@@jennieanddavis sure is you guys got me to buy a 100th anniversary Powermatic jointer
@jeremyhendrix5873
@jeremyhendrix5873 2 года назад
I’m sure this was discussed but I’ve heard of dropping the boards several times to release the tension in them.
@MrFordjd
@MrFordjd 2 года назад
I’m curious to know how the cost compares between the band saw and the table saw. I enjoyed this and I think the kerf thickness is a huge advantage for rip cuts that need to be efficient. Tables saw waste a lot of wood, meaning more dust, etc. 👍🏻
@jennieanddavis
@jennieanddavis 2 года назад
Cost is negligible. Focus your time on making sales, not saving money!
@billinfarmington5189
@billinfarmington5189 2 года назад
Just curious if you are using hard maple or soft maple. In my life soft maple has way more problems with internal stress and doesn't finish as well. Bill
@Mikey-qd8wo
@Mikey-qd8wo 2 года назад
What model of band saw do you use? Looking to purchase one for my shop.
@carpentersson2884
@carpentersson2884 2 года назад
What kind of band saw do you have?
@pattyofurniture100
@pattyofurniture100 2 года назад
Just FYI, loosen the 2 bolts holding the bandsaw fence to the rail and slide it out and lay it down 90°. You can then lower the blade guides and get even better cuts
@jennieanddavis
@jennieanddavis 2 года назад
Wait... what?! [sprints to garage]
@pattyofurniture100
@pattyofurniture100 2 года назад
@@jennieanddavis lol, yes it's a 3 position fence. You currently have it set up for resawing wide boards. When you turn it you can get closer to the blade for thin strips and the third position is a low clearance position for very thin stock
@M2woodworking
@M2woodworking Год назад
I know this is old but even my husband who is a master woodworker says the band saw is the best way to go.
@mikemahaffey8386
@mikemahaffey8386 2 года назад
Is there a way for you to just keep cutting instead of having to move the board to the stand after every cut? Unnecessary motion is a waste of money also.
@jennieanddavis
@jennieanddavis 2 года назад
Not in our current shop!
@brostir64
@brostir64 2 года назад
Well done love watching your videos
@ericmelancon7834
@ericmelancon7834 2 года назад
Love the enthusiasm and congrats on the win 🏆
@gerrysmith4493
@gerrysmith4493 2 года назад
Wow, hard to believe. You had no blade draft? What type of blades? I enjoy your videos, thank you! gerry Smith.
@jacobswedberg1402
@jacobswedberg1402 2 года назад
What bandsaw are you using
@BadAppleWoodwerx
@BadAppleWoodwerx 2 года назад
I don't know. I guess if I had a fancy table saw and a fancy band saw like yours I could decide for myself. 😉 For now I'm using my grandpa's ShopSmith and while it functionally works, it's not exactly a great piece of equipment like what you have.
@MrDmorgan52
@MrDmorgan52 2 года назад
Actually,YOU were faster on the band saw. Look how you are standing,off to the side. You're using more of your body,i.e.less stress On the table saw, you're standing directly behind it, over a spinning blade. You will naturally be slower. Safety and all
@MrDmorgan52
@MrDmorgan52 2 года назад
That said almost all of the large industrial sawmills are band type blades
@psguardian
@psguardian 2 года назад
Simple physics, thinner blade = less binding (and less kerf), larger tool = more cuts per blade... It will win efficiency every time. Both have their place for sure, but in tasks where they overlap band saw wins.
@guido2071
@guido2071 2 года назад
What blade are you using to get such nice cuts on the bandsaw?
@jennieanddavis
@jennieanddavis 2 года назад
Wood Slicer from Highland Woodworking
@brkoury
@brkoury 2 года назад
great! now I gotta buy a bandsaw??
@nutsandbolts432
@nutsandbolts432 2 года назад
This Old Tony would just karate chop the board and break it into several perfectly size pieces in one motion and there would be no need to plane it afterwards. Gotta get on board with that.
@honeybeecare6393
@honeybeecare6393 2 года назад
after 40 plus years of (steel mfg as opposed to wood) my accident with a band saw and my hand was far less worse than my accident with my table saw and hand. So the band saw is way way way SAFER than a table saw. (loss time 1 day verse 6 months and 2 months of rehab to learn how to operate my hand again, 2 years later the hand is still not like it used to be!
@robertlivingstone3947
@robertlivingstone3947 2 года назад
I told you the band saw well win
@robertlivingstone3947
@robertlivingstone3947 2 года назад
When you sead the band saw or table saw watch one would won
@thearcadian8051
@thearcadian8051 2 года назад
I love cutting on a ban saw........... only problem is mine died two years a go! and cant afford to buy a new one so I have to make my cuts with my handheld saw or my job site table saw (that wants to murder me !) so ....... I'm just sol lol
@mbmurphy777
@mbmurphy777 2 года назад
Only problem with a bandsaw is the dust collection. Anyone that solves that should get a medal
@jennieanddavis
@jennieanddavis 2 года назад
And the miter saw... but maybe that's just a pipe dream 😅.
@larrykenner8095
@larrykenner8095 Год назад
Lately I’ve been thinking just as you said … bandsaw …
Далее
we toured 7 MASSIVE shops! here's what we found...
11:09
Track Saw or Table Saw?
13:43
Просмотров 42 тыс.
Самое неинтересное видео
00:32
Просмотров 401 тыс.
after 4 years it finally happened...
14:10
Просмотров 57 тыс.
Bandsaw Accident
14:14
Просмотров 656 тыс.
you were right, we were wrong! (the WORST lumber ever)
14:08
the end of an era...
12:51
Просмотров 36 тыс.
Every beginner needs to hear this
11:10
Просмотров 1,6 млн