Тёмный

Finger Pointing Checks 

timtak1
Подписаться 5 тыс.
Просмотров 20 тыс.
50% 1

The Japanese have a specular self, that is to say that their self consciousness centeres on the awareness
or imagination of themselves, reflecting (quite litterally) upon themselves, rather than in talking to themselves.
For this reason, when a Japanese person, like Suzuki Ichiro, wants to reinforce conscious decisions and
actions he does so by pointing his bat. Railway workers and bus drivers regularly point at signals and other
things when they check them, to reinforce the awareness of having performed the act. These finger pointing
checks are only carried out in Japan, Korea and Taiwan (as a result of Japanese influence). In the UK on
the other hand, train drivers "call the road" that is to say they call out the colour of signals or other signs along the way. They do not point at them.
The western self, as many many psychologists and philosophers will tell you, is centered upon self speech,
it is the monologue that we have with ourselves. The Japanese self centers upon however, the awareness of ones self as an image. You could say that the Japanese are permanently in "the mirror stage."
However, while Lacan and other white men claim that it is only through indentification with the symbolic (language) that one can optain a third person, objective perspective on self, it seems to me that the Japanese are quite able to internalise a mirror, to simulate a mirror in their minds eye and take a third persons perspective of themselves.
While men westerners think that appearance is superficial and external, in Japan voice and speech be viewed as that which one does for others. Speech is external, communicative, transfers information from one person to another, and does not get reflected back to Japanese speakers. While Lacan and James Mead seem to think that speach is always heard, understood and cognised by the speaker, in Japan I believe speech, rolls out of mouths like water off a ducks back; it is said and gone. On the other hand again, Japanese would be surprised to hear that we Westerners can not imagine ourselves unless we have a mirror. They do it all the time. How else could they "refect upon their behaviour" (hansei)? There is not even a word in English for hansei although hansei involves more than simply imagining yourself.
Video taken with the kind permission of the talent.
This and my othe Japanese culture related videos are on
burogu.com

Опубликовано:

 

2 мар 2010

Поделиться:

Ссылка:

Скачать:

Готовим ссылку...

Добавить в:

Мой плейлист
Посмотреть позже
Комментарии : 28   
@nihonbunka
@nihonbunka 14 лет назад
@AmaranthPink Thank you! Voiced documentary is on its way. I made a couple today buy found I had broken my microphone lead.
@crazywoodlouse
@crazywoodlouse 14 лет назад
plus it gives them the chance to show off those super clean gloves ^_^ but seriously that was very interesting, kind of graceful in a way
@nihonbunka
@nihonbunka 14 лет назад
@Koroodetto And you can try it too, like when you turn off your kitchen appliances and lock your door as you leave home.
@nihonbunka
@nihonbunka 14 лет назад
@gggu Horses for courses. Pointing works in Japan. Calling the Road, works for English railway workers. But you are right, the Japanese railway is far more efficient. I like to think that this is because it is essentially a visual industry. On the other hand, linguistic industries such as insurance, finance, software, and even perhaps office work is often performed surprisingly efficiently by UK folk, as compared to Japan.
@nihonbunka
@nihonbunka 14 лет назад
Thank you!
@Koroodetto
@Koroodetto 14 лет назад
Thanks for the info. I have lived here for 3 years and I've always meant to ask my Japanese friend what all the 'finger pointing' was about. Now I know.
@nihonbunka
@nihonbunka 14 лет назад
@chimera15 Umm... His finger comes nowhere near the train. His finger is extended far enough for him to see it. He is pointing because he wants to remind himself, and be fully aware of the fact that he has performed the actions of checking. He is wearing a mask probably because he has a common cold and does not want to pass the virus onto his colleagues (a courtesy strangely lacking among Britons). He can see where he is looking.
@nihonbunka
@nihonbunka 14 лет назад
@gggu Someone did try to introduce it to Australia, but the railway workers laughed it off and refused to comply. But then, while I believe the regulations state that the Japanese should Say and Point, the Japanese feel silly saying, or that saying is useless, so they just point.
@nihonbunka
@nihonbunka 10 лет назад
In the UK, or at least Australia, according to my sources, there is a practice called "calling the road" where drivers say the names of the lights that they come to. Can you confirm? Someone from the Australian railway came to Japan and heard of the pointing and tried to introduce pointing to Australia but the staff laughed off the suggestion. Too embarrassed? I think that the self is different. We (Westerners) care about our spoken self, the Japanese about their visual self.
@nihonbunka
@nihonbunka 11 лет назад
Thank you. I am not whether or not I said thank you at the time you wrote your comment but thank you now.
@nihonbunka
@nihonbunka 14 лет назад
@chimera15 People forget, and as a result, sometimes folks die. So people do things to remind themselves. British train drivers "call the road" saying "red" "green" "40mph." They would probably look, or rather sound, pretty studid to Japanese. But that does not make it a bad idea.
@allgoo19
@allgoo19 14 лет назад
@timtak1 "I hear that they tried to introduce it to Australia .." I didn't miss that part in the video, so I was talking about that specifically. I think they'll learn only after something seriously bad happen. IMO, it also gives the customers an impression of how serious they are toward their job which makes them more confident in taking it. Anyway, thanks for the good report.
@AmaranthPink
@AmaranthPink 14 лет назад
That's a pretty neat trick for the mind :O I'd like to agree that I love the gloves, but I love the whole uniform overall. (Especially the hat and the gloves :D)
@nihonbunka
@nihonbunka 14 лет назад
@kamiurage Thank you. Yes. It is a shame that the name involves the "呼称" (calling) since that gives the impression that it is like the Western equvalent which is only "呼称" (calling, as in "Calling the Road") but in fact, in Japan, there is hardly any calling. This guy was completely silent. I think that he is *meant* to be saying at least "yoshi" (okay) but I think that he demonstrates that the important part in Japan is the finger pointing.
@Ynysmydwr
@Ynysmydwr 6 лет назад
tim, Japanese train drivers point AND call, as shown in this video: ru-vid.com/video/%D0%B2%D0%B8%D0%B4%D0%B5%D0%BE-9W6tHOmWyLQ.html The efficiency and safety record of Japanese railways are of an astoundingly high standard, as anyone who used the trains in Japan will gratefully acknowledge, so the system does work. This coupled, of course, with the whole Japanese attitude to duty, service, and taking pride in one's work which must, in itself, make pointing-and-calling routines so much more acceptable to workers than is the case in the "western" culture which often seems to foster a feeling that conspicuously conforming to regulations is undignified.
@Kzuuto
@Kzuuto 14 лет назад
I greatly appriciated for your introduction for Japanese way of Industrial safety method on the clip "Finger Pointing Checks". I found very interesting report about this "Shisa-Kanko" . West Japan Railway Company's Safety Institution has provided the report - whether the way of "Shisa-Kanko" keeps operator's concentration of awareness during one's duty(w ww.westjr.co.jp/security/labs/pdf/report02/05.pdf). The Institution has been settled after the terrible accident of Amagasaki Train Crash.
@wstnli725
@wstnli725 13 лет назад
Like in planes. I also like to see signals. They help a lot when you are lost, but in our Modern culture they are blaming on body language and, of course, it used to be very Latin to indicate this way with your hand, arm, head, etc. I appreciate this video very much, timtak1, as I love to do that, too, while speaking (like children do.) :) Arigato!
@nihonbunka
@nihonbunka 11 лет назад
Thank you:-)
@aewowww
@aewowww 14 лет назад
amazing!
@nihonbunka
@nihonbunka 14 лет назад
@crazywoodlouse I love the gloves ^_^
@nihonbunka
@nihonbunka 14 лет назад
@chimera15 Do you take sick leave when you have a cold?
@nihonbunka
@nihonbunka 14 лет назад
@allgoo19 I hear that they tried to introduce it to Australia but the Australians laughed it off.
@nihonbunka
@nihonbunka 10 лет назад
Thank you. Perhaps you could introduce finger pointing in your own work.
@brandonconnelly6798
@brandonconnelly6798 6 лет назад
Check your spelling
@nihonbunka
@nihonbunka 6 лет назад
where as > whereas I did not notice any others but the captions are now burned into the video so I think it would be difficult to correct them.
@chimera15
@chimera15 14 лет назад
I'm going to laugh when I see a video of this guy's finger getting ripped off cause he pointed at the wrong place and a train went by and hit it. roflol He's probably pointing because he has that stupid mask and glasses on, so noone can see where he's looking for one thing.
Далее
Best father #shorts by Secret Vlog
00:18
Просмотров 20 млн
МНЕ ИСПОРТИЛИ МАШИНУ #shorts
00:30
Просмотров 1,1 млн
Why Tokyo Has Musical Train Stations
13:03
Просмотров 144 тыс.
Lion and White Tiger
1:13
Просмотров 40 тыс.
Pointing and Calling (English)
17:00
Просмотров 15 тыс.
Inside the Conductor's cab on the L train
0:47
Просмотров 117 тыс.
'Pointing and Calling'
2:19
Просмотров 427
Why are Japanese trains so punctual?
2:49
Просмотров 46 тыс.
Change of Drivers Shinkansen Japanese Bullet Train
5:32