@@TTA42800 can I get your email, please? I’ve been following you on your audits. You are really good and patient educating Employees and Police. I’ve been there backing you up. You always end up saying what I’m typing to you on your own. You do a great job!! If you are annoyed by me following you, just tell me. I learn more as I follow you. By commenting I reinforce what I know. You are a great and patient teacher. I do wish you would read the comments when you get a chance. I am trying to help you, too. Seriously. You should get 3 or 4 Auditors of your choice to go in and re audit this Library. Those women still consider it “their way or the Highway!!!” They are going to continue stepping on Auditors RIGHTS UNTIL THEY LEARN AND A GANG BANG(so to speak) OF AUDITORS IS GOING TO BE THE WAY TO SHAKE UP THEIR. POLICY AND FIGURE OUT THAT THEIR POLICY IS NOT LAW, but, The U.S. Constitution and The Bill of Rights ARE THE LAW!! THEY NEED TO LEARN THAT OR THEY ARE GOING TO CONTINUE TO VIOLATE EVERY AUDITORS RIGHTS THAT COME INTO THAT LIBRARY TO RECORD!! Please do the group Auditors. It will be a great teaching video for Police Officers and especially these Lady’s who believe they won the day when you left the LIBRARY. I’ve seen it done and NO ONE WENT TO JAIL!! I am Donna Cicero and I am 70 yrs old and still learning our Rights. Thank you!!🌹❤️
Wow was she ever narcissistic. Even after the cops explained it to her, she still insisted that you were in the wrong, refusing all accountability in the act.
How disgusting that they still stand behind their policy and not the Constitution even after they were informed that you have the right to do what you’re doing. REVISIT until they are educated! 🇦🇺🇺🇸
Sir I respect the way you approached this issue. You have all my respect and I thank you for what you are doing to protect our God given rights. As a veteran I swore to serve and protect the the constitution against any enemy's foreign or domestic... Again I thank you for what you are doing.
I follow all the top guys, Seanpaul, Jay, Jeff, Mike etc. James is truly underexposed. Quit wit and knowledge of the law, calm and assertive. Nice job and I appreciate your efforts!
The behavior of certain library supervisors who hold presumptuous and uninformed views on the law can be hazardous. In your case, they harassed you and disregarded your rights. Even when the police arrived and confirmed your right to be there, they did not offer an apology. Taxpayers deserve better public servants who earn six-figure salaries. Your audit was commendable, and it has successfully revealed the incompetence of these individuals. Justice has been served. ⚖️✅
I would like to commend you on that aswell sir. I quickly flip the channel when auditors lash or curse out cops. You can get your point across without it. Again great job!
Lol so race is first thing that popped into your shallow brain ? How about he is the 1000th man you seen as a patriot . Ohh and there are other " black" auditors
@@angelforanimals7809 It was "Written" but it's certainly not "proof" that it's against the law to film in a public library or that any library policy supercedes state or federal laws. Just because someone typed that up, doesn't make it proof that it's a state law. Did you notice that no actual law was quoted? Because there is none. Illinois does not have a law that allows a public library's policy to supercede federal law. In fact, no state has that law.
@@angelforanimals7809 You really don’t know the difference between policies and Law. Have you ever seen a policy officer? They don’t even name security that.
The cameras are pointing downward to actually record private information everywhere we go!. Cell phone companies spy on conversations tracking your every move with gps, the streets, malls, restaurants, people's Ring cameras on their houses, camcorders in private citizen's cars etc...
Did I give you permission to film Me "It's A Yes or No Question If you don't want to be Filmed Working with the general public Get another F****** Job Karen and Darren ARE Getting Upset because this Auditor is Not Obeying their AUTHORAAAYTAY
This man wields the Hammer of Thor and the Sword of Justice with 500% skill, ease and accuracy like it's not even a thing. The horrible lack of knowledge of these public officials on the other hand is truly terrifying and fascinating. You gotta love the verbal asswhoopings and the deserved walks of shame. Am impressed; have subbed and please stay save sir! ; D
"Policy is not law, policy doesn't have the force of law, and if choose to ignore the policy, that is not breaking the law." This is a great statement!
In Kreimer v. Board of Police of Morristown, NJ, an important court opinion addressing a library user’s right to enter and use the library, the court held that because public libraries are a limited public forum, constitutional protection is afforded only to those expressive activities that are consistent with the mission and purpose of the library. A public library is only obligated to permit the public to exercise rights that are consistent with the government’s intent in establishing the library as a limited public forum for the purpose of receiving information and accessing the library’s books, programs, and online resources.
@Dantheman Thank you for making my point. It is a location to acquire information, to expand the knowledge base of an individual or group(s), to disseminate literature and arts, and to promote the learning process. Due to the exercise of these auditors, I, along with hundreds of law-abiding citizens, have obtained a little more information about the desire for government, including our court systems, to limit our constitutional rights. Thank You!
What the librarians fail to understand, cut and dry, is they are not in charge of that PUBLIC building or of public citizens and those said citizens that lawfully enter and act lawfully. They act like Library Police. Yet, are nothing more than public employees there to ASSIST public citizens that enter the public building. Not act like they are the boss and in charge of the public inside of a public building. That simple.
@@feltonrogers906 Hello, I've managed a public library for about 10 years, and one of the policies at that library is 'Out of consideration for other users and to protect library collections and equipment, drinks must be covered and food is prohibited in the reading and computer areas.' I've fairly and consistently enforced that policy dozens of times, on people with and without library cards, and have faced exactly zero legal consequences despite the threats of several exciting civil rights lawsuits. Public facilities can make and enforce reasonable rules for their use, even rules that address actions that are not necessarily against the law. 'Policy only applies to employees and people who opt in' is a widespread, but inaccurate, auditor myth HTH.
@@nder The thing is you haven't been taken to court. And those who went alone were people who just went along. WE all know that The Constitution places Law above policy and rules. People who threatend to sue realized something was wrong. First time I saw the Law properly applied in a Library was when two Auditors were threatened with arress for recording the facilty and "Policy Stated" etc.This was at the main Library in downtown Detroit. Ten officers responded and tried to push their weight around. One Auditor remained calm and explained that he as a citizen had his right to enjoy the inside of that public building and not partake of any service that was offered and if he didn't partake of any service in any way, he was not bound by any Library policy, and the librarian could not say that he had broken any Law. That being the case ment he could not be legally removed or trespassed just because the Librarian wanted him to leave. The cops all looked at the Sgt in charge and he said, let's go, and the were gone in 10 seconds. I have seen that that senerio played out time and time again.
@@nder agreed. And I don't think it's obvious for a lay person to know what limited public forum is and how that would apply to A. Protest B. Standing silently with a sign C. Gathering content for a story via photography or video. For library, C. is fine. I wouldn't want to bet on B. And A is right out the door. Ymmv of course.
I'm a Waukegan resident,I love my rights. Thank you so very much for be our Local First Ammendment Warrior. First time viewing your Audit,you have a new Subscriber
These people just look for anyway to control people and enforce their policies. Lay it down for them! Education time! Keep em in check. Right on point My Friend.
The staff are the ones who are escalating and causing his obstruction of his work. No patrons have complained, but the staff. They just can't be wrong!
Why are people so ARAID OF A CAMERA! The camera doesn't lie, and no one likes to be exposed to themselves and how self righteous they are for everyone to see!
Truer words have never been spoken. If what these people were saying was the truth, you wouldn't be able to record in any building because "sensitive/personal" information is everywhere.
Part of what makes this good is you are articulate, knowledagable and patient, keep it going, I think you should take this to another level and do some deep dirty work exposing corruption everywhere
With these ladies who work for the library, I'm gonna use their logic. I really hate red shirts, they offend me and make me uncomfortable. I'm going into that library and complaining about anyone wearing those horrible red shirts. I know they'll get asked to leave and they should get those red shirts out.
That’s a great audit sir. You’re articulate and calm in expressing your rights. I can’t believe over there some folks still wearing face masks 3 years on 😆. And that security fella, he’s got the best job ever. New subscriber from the UK 👍
Great audit brother! You did an excellent job of attempting to explain our rights to those library workers that just didn’t seem to get what you were puttin down for them, but hey, I guess we can’t all be smart about knowing constitutional law and rights lol. Some people just hate freedom
Good job educating people that know nothing about first amendment is bad they work for the public and they don’t even no the first amendment. I am totally a fan from Canada British Columbia.👍 you are calm and collected. Totally cool.👍
Great video! It amazes me how some employees think that their policy trumps the Constitution. Way to be respectful and calm, because some people just don't know. I get an education almost every time that I watch good audit videos. Keep doing what you do. Knowledge is power! Subscribed!
You are doing such a great job! Please stay exactly like you are. Consistency is everything. Keep learning as much as you can and keep fighting for our rights. Your such a great advocate for the movement! Also, your voice is smooth as silk.
I love this Audit 🇺🇸 I are- watching and even More Entertaining than Before 💪🏼TTA is Sooo Calm and kool and Re-Explained everything over and over. Mr . Ed , Phil , can only Hope they Learned on this Day 😊
Indeed you are. I'm not a First Amendment auditor but have watched numerous videos. You seem to be the most knowledgeable about the Constitution and the law. Just as important you are very respectful and I've never seen you escalate a situation to the point of either party raising their voice or becoming violent. I really think the calm and even tone of your voice keeps the situation from escalating it's too bad in this case the Librarians try to make up their own laws and had no knowledge of the law are Constitution. Too many people think that because their employer has policies that those policies are law. Way to educate the uneducated. It's just too bad that it probably went in one ear and out the other.
I love James. He is so professional. These two KARENS suck!!! Why would they not apologize? She kept flipping it back, like you choose to escalate it. Wow..... Sad little cats they are. You did so well James. 🙂
I appreciate your auditing; this was my first time seeing one of your audits - and you have done a great job! You almost had me where they were doing taxes. They need close off the public area that is not fully open to the general public.
I just wanted to say I like the way you conduct your audits and a nice cool nonconfrontational manor. It makes a big difference how you communicate with people calmly and respectfully you're very good at that
@@TTA42800Auditors don’t know what the term “public” means Three categories of government property Traditional, or quintessential, public forums; Limited, or designated, public for ums; And nonpublic forums
You communicated very well. The Supreme Court recognizes that “free speech” inherently can make people feel uncomfortable. But it is still legal to express your free speech in appropriate places recognized as a public forum. Recording may make people feel “uncomfortable”, but is legal to do in unrestricted public forums.
LOL. A library isn't an unrestricted public forum. It's a "limited public forum." They can restrict free speech inside a library as long as their restrictions are reasonable and viewpoint-neutral. So yeah, they'll do the same on Tuesday, even though this guy thinks he "educated" them.
Hey Man, just stumbled across your channel on 1st amendment audits, love the content & the way you present yourself! Reminds me alot of another auditor I totally respect--- Long Island Auditor *Sean Reyes. I've subscribed to your channel & looking forward to the rest of your videos/content, keep up the good work & I will continue to respect, watch & recommend your Vid's to others. Way to go! 🙂
The officers showed ultimate wisdom in applications!! They tried to diffuse and Deescalate the now moment by tactfully attempting to get you to comply to make the now moment issue go away. They can ask, but they did not try to enforce a policy. Outstanding- and ultimately upheld their Constitutional pledge to adhere to that which is lawful. Great job by all. Take care. Be kind to each other. I did solve that there were no absolute un level actions from anyone here that caused a high level of anguish. Pretty cool As we all learn peacefully together. Thanks y’all.
second cop was all business. straight to the source, handled, retreat. professional all the way without wasting resources. right back to work. amazing.
This was a great audit. Truly. The behavior of these people, so comfortable in their delusional positions kf power over this library came crashing down around them the moment you walked in. Well done sir.
trickle down theory at work right here. the young security man better run for the hills or they’ll pass on their spirit of anger. you become what you hang around.
Very good audit...if you need change with the employees you will need to return to see if there are any changes...especially with those two who let there staff down. Good luck..
What they were saying to you James after the police left is that they “asked” you to stop recording and you would not-that translates to, We told you to stop recording and you did not obey our authority! Thus you offended their entrenched “ego.”
Thank you for your upholding our constitutional and exercising our rights sir. Btw the terminator scene fits the glove when you educate public servants that unfortunately they don’t know their constitutional rights
Small correction if I may. You've got over two thousand subscriber's and after another super fine and flawless teaching, I've subscribed so I may enjoy all future lessons/lectures to come. Cheers dude/Professor.
I started watching auditors because people didn’t believe me how cops act. In the 80s. There was expensive cameras Who would waste a kodiac disposable snap shot on a cops. But in them days Cops wouldn’t shoot Ask questions later.
If you stop and read some of those policies of the library they are beyond ridiculous. Filming without permission. Distributing leaflets. Wearing any 'gang' clothing. Flashing gang signs etc. Come on. Is this China or North Korea? Who determines what is gang related? Like I said, beyond ridiculous.
The way you conducted your audit was exemplary, especially given the fact that you, like myself, are a minority! I commend you on your demeanor and attitude. Although this is my first time watching your video I had to give you a thumbs up 👍🏼! Keep up your great educational process you've started and thank you for doing what you do!
Love finding a bit older video's from you! And once again....I adore the way you stand your ground. Your words just come out so smoothly and another thing, it's UNDERSTANDABLE. There are tons of other auditors, and I adore most of them, but with you, IDK .....lol....words are not my strong suit, took me 3 years to learn how to talk again after my stroke, but I did it! Your words are understandable. Tons of others, speak and nothing comes out. With you though, your words come out and they are understandable and taught. Not like a teacher would teach, but as a wise man educating his family type of thing. Ok, I'm rambling lol You are in my prayers darlin and be safe out there. xoxo Nancy
Keep up the great work. I subscribe to other 1A auditors and as much as I like watching their channels there is something about the way you conduct your 1A Audits that made me hit that subscribe button. Way to keep your composure through it all.
Well I’m from Canada What I remember about this video is that they were trying to enforce policy, not what is constitutional in this instance. So please educate me that policy over rides your constitutional rights? Regards
@@Colgate64 I see. Please correct me if I’m wrong. I also read what you described, understanding it also has to do with, time, manner, and place. Being the auditor was there during opening hours and not going into any restricted areas I felt he was acting lawfully within your constitution, and therefore his rights would have been violated? Thx
This was one of the best audits I've seen....gave them every opportunity to adhere to the law, dropped subtle and direct hints about that law and even after the police corrected them they still were ignorant
@@Colgate64 Bruh you obviously know nothing about First Amendment audits. First Amendment audits are undertaken in areas accessible to the public. How else do you think a First Amendment audit can be effected? For verification look at the tens of thousands of First Amendment audits on RU-vid
You entertained these people for waaaaaay too long. I just found your channel and am not sure how long you've been performing audits but I would guess it hasn't been too long. I appreciate your demeaner and your ability to compose yourself well and articulating yourself. I also suspect if you continue performing these audits, I suspect your patience will dwindle as you continue doing these audits. I have subscribed and really like your style. Good job
Where do you work?? maybe sometime somebody will file a false complaint on you and you'll get fired and humiliated on RU-vid and dozed!! How would you feed yourself or your family and pay bills?? Frauditors and their fake clones on RU-vid will get him arrested very soon. 😂
@@Jellyfish2022 I own my own businesses and would never treat my costumers as such. You should try it sometime and see just how successful your business can be.
I'm so glad you pulled out the holdings of _Miller v. United States_ on this audit. I don't hear that one as much as I think I should. For those unfamiliar with _Miller,_ "The claim and exercise of a constitutional right cannot thus be converted into a crime."
Just came across your channel. Wow you are very well spoken, no BS, straight to the point in a professional manner. People should really learn to stop being sheep in this world. You can clearly see how lost these workers are. Idiotic at best.
You've really become strong as an auditor. You're built for this and I really do enjoy your calm and clarity of information to public employees. The only thing I would suggest is to keep your camera on their faces. In fact, you should look at the employees through the camera until you can build the habit of keeping the camera on the people you're speaking to. You should also remind them it's up to them to create privacy if they want it by "closing the door". I don't know what state you're in but states usually have laws that allow for the recording of public employees. You should research that and quote the statute to law enforcement that may not know themselves. Otherwise, love your videos and great job again TTA!
I just found your channel and subscribed, appreciate you very much. Love you are close to us in Indiana and how you stay so calm and polite. Stay safe my friend
Policy is not law, and definitely doesnt trump the Constitution. I love how James your respectful and your funny too in your own way, i dont understand how anyone can get mad at you. GOD bless you James
I truly can’t believe that the staff wouldn’t swallow their egos and just apologize and say they were wrong good job on keeping your cool and educating them regardless of their stubbornness
These women need to learn the law they are so stuck on policy The smugness when she was reading the policy . They will never get it, they love the power
