Auto and numbered card aren't bad. I ordered three of these myself. Never had good luck with Optic but at least the chance is there to pull something nice.
Bought five from Target three came in good condition, the last two came in a box that had been stepped on. One box is absolutely destroyed. Of course Target claims they don’t accept returns…even for completely damaged product!
Ugh that a bummer! I’ve had good luck with their online chat feature with customer service, so I’d recommend giving that a try to see if that helps at all.