Thank you for sharing your reaction. I’ve been familiar with the original Simon and Garfunkel version for a long time and liked its beauty, but after hearing Disturbed’s version, so powerful and full of meaning, I realized I had never understood it. The words were there, but they were sung in a soft, melodic way that softened their impact. Here you get it all, the powerful, passionate protest and warning that must have moved Paul Simon to write the poem in the first place. The message needed to be heard then and, if anything, it’s even more needed now in the age of isolating social media and institutionalized misinformation. After all the dark images, it was kind of them to end the video with a hopeful scene, the music writers and performers getting together as the ship reached the shore and a bright sunrise broke through the foggy, deadening clouds. They didn’t want despair, which solves nothing, but a new beginning.
He does this the same way live also in concert and on the Conan Show which you need to watch and listen to with a 20-piece orchestra behind him. This video was done in 2015 and the Conan Show was done in 2016. Find some of the live concerts to listen to, in the Athens, Greece concert the audience sang along, amazing. I am 76 and have listened to Simon & Garfunkel all the way till now. I never understood the song until hearing Disturbed's version.
I grew up with this song and it just floated over my head. I don't like folk music style and was too young to understand what the words meant. I never changed my mind about the original S&G version. Why would I? I still don't like folksy music and always switched away if it came on. However ... I heard this version one day in the car and I actually listened to the words. Internally (because only psychos talk to themselves out loud in the car, right? Lol. Ok. I muttered it out loud.) "WTF was that?!" I was inexplicably choked up by a song that played around me my whole life, but I never actually, truly heard. So I punched replay at least 9 times in a row, (because that's what any reasonable person would do, right?) and wound up having to pull over and cry. I was traveling to a hotel for work and when I got there, I fired up my laptop and went looking for a video. And holy 💩, I found this ... masterpiece. So a big thank you to S&G for the lyrics (sorry I'm not into your style, Guys), but also a big thank you to Disturbed for actually making me hear it and make it mean something to me. This is a special version. I think it brought this song to more people like me in a very meaningful way. And David Draiman's vocals ... 🔥 He was trained as a cantor, as was his brother, who went the opera route. Why am I telling you this? Idk. Because I randomly know it and if I do, you should, too. Lol. 🤷🏻♀️ I'm going to their concert in a month or so and cannot wait to hear this live.
You put into words what i couldnt,i have heard this so many times and i cant listen without crying.hope u enjoy the concert.much love from manchester ,uk
It's very rare to find a cover that compares to the original but even rarer to find one that's better and to me...Disturbed's version is better. They absolutely nailed the interpretation of the lyrics and were able to convey them masterfully!!
You need to listen to the original by Paul Simon and Art Garfunkel……I cried the first time I heard David sing this…..this song spoke to the 60’s and even more powerful today.
Original artist said this was the best cover ever! Disturbed os awesome, Davids voice is off the chart. He also was classically trained. David and Chester were friends, cant imagine what they would have come up with, if they wrote a song together and then sung it.
David was NOT classically trained. He was trained as a Cantor in his Jewish school and that is NOT classical. Cantor is singing a prayer. Classical is a genre written in Europe around 1750 to 1830 whereas cantors officially started in the 7th century. (although singing prayers was something very ancient for jews
Loved your reaction ❤ it excites me more each time I hear this song by Disturbed ❤️🙏🥰😘 no one can top Disturbed wth The Sound Of Silence in my book ❤️😘
Paul Simon described it as a "wonderful rendition" and did reach out to David with the compliment. PS would never give his work to anyone and would never think that anyone could do it better...
So glad to see you are back!!! I absolutely love this song, and also have watched several different covers.....I think all versions play a crucial role, in getting the message out, that we need to go back to basics, and communicate & care about each other, and our planet.....
This is the best version I've heard of Sound of Silence, I never understood the upbeat happy sound it has in the original and why everyone kept doing the same in their covers. So, when I heard this and the intensity/gravitas that David puts into it, ugh... I was sold! I get chills EVERY time I listen to it, and sometimes tears depending on my mood while listening to it - especially at the 'god they made' part, wow! If you want to check out someone else who does some awesome covers, check out Chase Holfelder, he does all sorts of covers changing songs that were in a major key to a minor key, or cinematic versions or even using different instruments, like children's toys or kitchen gadgets... yeah, he does a really great job with covers. Also, if you choose to check out more Disturbed, yes, they are a metal band, so enjoy that as well!!
the Sound of silence.....TEXTING. "words without speaking". We have lost the ability to communicate verbally, even tho we carry phones, how many answer them? That's how you get the sound of silence. #incredibleysad
I remember this song, as a kid, I didn't like it. Until this cover. This cover, gives Paul Simon's lyrics the intensity that covey the true meaning of the song. If you have ever lived or worked in Manhattan (NYC), it is a NOISY place. After a while you drown it out to the point that you don't care for others. That is why many say that New Yorkers are "rude", we really aren't we are rushed and overwhelmed. Thanks for your reaction.
I enjoyed your reaction and looking forward to hearing more from you. Just something I noticed in the video was at the end the sun was coming up when the boat reached the shore. This seems like a sign of hope that there's still time to hear each other.
I'm not a fan of this band in general, but this is my favorite rendition of this song. Another that's worthy of a listen though would be the cover by Peter Hollens and Tim Foust (of Home Free). It's a very different take, closer to the original, and all a capella.
I had heard this before and I so agree with Everything you said! The video made me listen to the words in a different way than I ever had! His voice with the gravely sound took me a little bit to decide if I liked but the more I listened the better I liked it and yes the strength of it was awesome!!!
one of their newest song is hey you. very metal and very appropriate for what is going on these days. Davids voice and heart comes through all of his music whether it be his more ballad or his heaviest metal. his range of vocals and just plain style is why he has been so wide spread.
The lead singer's name is David Draiman. They are a heavy metal group. The one song You may be familiar with is down with the sickness particularly the first 15-20 seconds. David studied to be a cantor That is a person who sings what the rabbi has just read the Jewish religion. Obviously he did not become a Cantor. So some of his vocal ability c 9:17 omes from his training to be a cantor om how a Cantor sings. Most people view with like this the original Simon & Garfunkel is a warning. Pentatonix cover is a warning but with hope, and this version is the anger that we have yet to learn this lesson. I'm so glad you did this version rather than the live version on Conan. To me the video is as important as any member in the group. It starts off with the instruments being buried and there's not any music just silence and then as it builds your getting the people who are on the other side of the river slowly getting involved and by the end the boat with all the musical instruments is sailing towards the people bringing them music so that there is no silence. There are other people who comment that explain it better I think. three other songs that are out of character so to speak for them is hold onto memories and a reason to fight. That song is very special to me. It's about fighting the Demons of mental health and addiction. I am bipolar and in recovery and I just got my 5-year chip.. these two diseases token. unlike any other disease a person may have. Both of them live in your brain and change how you think and see the world. Other diseases they manifest in whichever system in the body that that disease affects.. and then it just does what that disease does. Mental-health and substance-abuse they latched onto the brain and the brain is the center of everything we do. So it's going to manifest in our thoughts are behaviors are actions. The official video is very good and he has an official lyrical video where he talks about the diseases of mental health and substance abuse. These topics are very very close to things that have happened in his life so it's rather personal. He has another song called Inside the Fire which is about survivor's guilt after an incident that happened in his life. It's a very personal video as the subject matter happened in his life. I do hope that you do hold onto memories a reason to fight and If I Ever Lose My Faith In You. Thank you for the reaction and I'm sorry the comments so long but it's the very personal topic also.😅
Cuando se toca y araña el alma humana modificandola se está ante una OBRA MAESTRA. SU VOZZZZ TAN INCREIBLEMENTE ÚNICA MARAVILLOSA QUE NACE DE LO MÁS PROFUNDO DE LOS SENTIMIENTOS, DEBERÍA SER ESCUCHADA EN TODO EL MUNDO ❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤
Crossing the river was bringing musical instruments to sheet music!!!!! People will be talking and listening again!!!!!At least that is my take on the symbolism of the scene!!!! So says Austin TX
Also be sure to watch their live performance on Conan. I forgot to mention that David Draiman was really sick for the Conan live performance and I heard he was not pleased with his performance, being the perfectionist that he is I can understand why he felt that way. However, the production as a whole was amazing and his performance was EXCEPTIONAL! I loved it. So POWERFUL and EMOTIONAL! Thanks, Diane Disturbed "The Sound Of Silence" 03/28/16 | CONAN on TBS Team Coco
OMG, the tissues I've 🤧 gone through since I discovered David Draiman and Disturbed performing their rendition of "The Sound of Silence" on April 29, 2024. That day I have to believe my spirit 🙏 guides (out of the blue) first led me to a cover video by Dan Vasc singing "Amazing Grace" 👏 and then to the cover video of Disturbed and David Draiman singing this most POWERFUL, EMOTIONAL 😂rendition of Simon and Garfunkels "The Sound of Silence". I'm 75 and was 15 when they released one of the most popular classic songs of our time during the 60's. It is amazing how relevant it is today, actually I feel it is even more relevant than ever in so many different ways. I've spent days since listening and seeing the many channels and each of hosts reactions and have 😢 almost every time. It's funny that more males have gotten teary-eyed than females, just an observation. Diane Davis
To me, there's a darkness to this. An emotional warning that took the origonal warning multiple steps beyond the times that it was made. A repeat that grew in emphasis from being ignored. The desparation portrayed in this version is a direct result of todays decline.
Oh man, you just have to react to this super underrated musician Guilhem Desq called Omen and maybe also Le château magique. Both are phenomenal! He uses an ancient and very obscure instrument that has amazing untapped potential. You will not be disappointed, though maybe it won't do all that well if you're more interested in popularity and the algorithm. I can't say it will get a lot of views, but it's amazing all the same. At the very least they're worth a watch for yourself.
Just saying wow right how tight! And then some! I grew up with S& G ! And for my fav metals bring to life another Artist message to light/life …. Off the chain! Chain!! There is no other in history a Remake|rendition of another Artist that has been done with such justice! Amen and then some
I once heard the original was a warning about what could happen and Disturbed’s version is anger at what has happened. Also, strap-on spelled backwards is no-parts
As a different comment already stated Paul Simon wrote an Email to David after listening to the live version at the Cohen show. Paul Simon was impressed that he even linked the Live version on his social media accounts which he never did before. Paul and David met each other later and they had a chat about it.
This was not the first time listening to this. You were mentioning that there was grit right from the beginning of the song. He was not applying grit until the end of the song when you said there's the grit. As I said this was not the first time you heard this. No biggie but I get it you were trying to prepare your comments. I hope you enjoy David's incredible voice.
“Tech” world today~ in~person, eye to eye stimulation is gone I guess as well “our” music/musicians have been taken over if you will by computers, machines ect I grew up in the 60’s Simon and Garfunkel predicted the future who would have known. I have followed disturbed since they hit “98” I think. been to 9 of their concerts and counting AWESOME JUST AWESOME FISTS IN THE AIR!! Thank you for acknowledging the talent here, the original was basically a “folk song” if I may,
Paul Simon wrote this as anti Vietnam war. The silence was the people not being able to voice this and how it divided the country. Very apt to our lives today.
This is a very negative, intense , passionate version. Whereas, Pentatonix and Simon and Garfunkel give a more hopeful, teaching, warning version. Although they are all different, they are all amazing
Just LISTEN to it first. Then talk. Everyone would enjoy it a lot more. Else youre taking away from the entire "effect" of the song. It just gets lost. Now if you heard it, in its entirety first, then talked, you'd grow your subscribers. Trust that
I read he was classically trained as a cantor, which is one who sings liturgical songs in synagogue. But he was thrown out of the seminary because he blew up the rabbi’s van along with other atrocities lol. He found his calling singing metal and he can do crazy things with his voice!
No, you are tragically misinformed. David was NOT classically trained. He was trained as a Cantor in his Jewish high school (who agreed with him that they should part ways), NOT a seminary, and singing cantor is NOT classical. Cantor is singing a prayer. Classical is a genre written in Europe around 1750 to 1830 whereas cantors officially started in the 7th century. (although singing prayers was something very ancient for jews)
@@hilaryc3203 - That’s how it was worded in the article I read about his life. “Tragically misinformed” is so dramatic I spit out my coffee laughing. I did read a quote from him saying “ I was about two years away from being ordained as a rabbi before I had a, I don’t know what you want to call it, a crisis of conscience, or just awareness.” I’ll have to look up the definition of what being classically trained means. Assuming it doesn’t apply to David, I have a feeling there’s still probably a number of different answers.
@@carolynnewcomb2153 LOL it was a bit tongue and cheek, but apparently you didn't appreciate the nuance. Too many people parrot the error without actually looking it up. Classical voice training is different from being a Cantor. Whilst one might have the position that they both lead to powerful singing voices, they are indeed worlds apart. The training of a cantor goes beyond singing, but speaking as well. Even their spoken words must be precise. Articulating every sound and letter must be precise for a cantor, whereas for an opera singer for instance, they can sing without going into that precise training as much.
@@hilaryc3203 - you might enjoy this interview. He has a lot to say about his vocal techniques. It seems he considers himself classically trained, but regardless, listening to him is a joy. ru-vid.com/video/%D0%B2%D0%B8%D0%B4%D0%B5%D0%BE-osBbQLhOp8A.html
